John Chapter 2 Read as one passage
John 2:18–22
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
18On account of this, the Jews demanded, “What sign can You show us to prove Your authority to do these things?” 19Jesus answered, “Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up again.” 20“This temple took forty-six years to build,” the Jews replied, “and You are going to raise it up in three days?” 21But Jesus was speaking about the temple of His body. 22After He was raised from the dead, His disciples remembered that He had said this. Then they believed the Scripture and the word that Jesus had spoken.
What the first hearers heard
To the first readers of John, many of them Jewish believers in Jesus or communities with close ties to the synagogue, this verse set out the question at the centre of the Gospel: by what authority does Jesus act, and what proves it?
- The challenge was legitimate in form. Testing a would-be prophet was what Torah required (Deut 13; 18). John does not present the question as foolish. Jesus does not rebuke them for asking; he answers. What the questioners cannot see is that the sign is Jesus himself.
- Irony. Readers had just heard about the first "sign" at Cana (2:11). The Gospel is built around such signs, "written so that you may believe" (20:30–31). Here the people in charge of God's house ask the one who calls it "my Father's house" for a sign, and fail to recognise him.
- The temple question. Many readers lived after the temple's destruction in AD 70. For them the challenge led into the next verses, where Jesus' body is the true temple (2:19–21). The temple's authorities ask for proof, and the proof will be the death and raising of a new "temple."
- Group identity. For a community in conflict with synagogue leaders (cf. 9:22; 16:2), "the Ioudaioi" who question Jesus mirrored the authorities they themselves faced. This was a dispute inside the Jewish world about Jesus. It was not an outsiders' verdict on Jews as a people.
From the study of John 2:18.
Verse by verse
-
18On account of this, the Jews demanded, “What sign can You show us to prove Your authority to do these things?”
Full study →So the Judean temple authorities, responding to what he had just done, said to him: "What sign are you going to show us, to back up the fact that you are doing these things?"
The scene is the temple courts at Passover. Jesus has just made a whip, driven out the sheep and cattle, poured out the money-changers' coins, overturned their tables and called the temple "my Father's house." The men who now speak are the people answerable for the temple. They are not "the Jewish people" in general, since Jesus and his disciples are Jews standing in the same courts. They are "answering" his action, not a question: his act was itself a claim, and they reply to it.
Their question is not idle. Scripture told Israel to test anyone claiming to act for God. Moses was given signs so the people would believe him, and a prophet's word had to be confirmed. So they ask for a sign: a visible credential showing that God authorised this. The tense is immediate ("are you showing us?"): they want proof now, in front of them. "These things" are the overturned tables and the claim of authority behind them.
John's readers hear an irony that the questioners miss. "Sign" is this Gospel's own word for Jesus' revealing acts; the first was at Cana a few verses earlier (2:11). Jesus does give them a sign in the next verse, but one that can only be checked later: the "temple" of his body destroyed and raised in three days.
-
19Jesus answered, “Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up again.”
Full study →The temple authorities have just demanded a sign, a credential to prove that Jesus has the right to clear out the temple courts. Jesus answers with a riddle that works as a dare: "Go on, tear down this sanctuary, and within three days I myself will raise it up."
Every part of it has two edges:
- "Tear down" is a command aimed at them. It works like an "if": if you take this dwelling apart, I will raise it. It does not say Jesus will destroy anything. The destroying is theirs.
- "This sanctuary" is not the word John has been using for the temple courts where the money-changers sat. It is the word for the inner house of God, the place where God's presence lived. That is why John can explain afterward that "he was speaking about the temple of his body" (v.21).
- "Raise up" is a builder's word for putting up a structure, and also the ordinary word for raising the dead. His listeners hear a man boasting he can rebuild in three days what took 46 years (v.20). John's readers hear the resurrection, as the disciples did after Easter (v.22).
- "Within three days" is a ridiculously short time for a building project. In Israel's Scriptures it is also the short interval after which God acts to turn things around.
So the sign Jesus offers is this: they will take apart the true dwelling-place of God, his own body, and he will raise it again. That act will prove his authority over the temple.
-
20“This temple took forty-six years to build,” the Jews replied, “and You are going to raise it up in three days?”
Full study →So the Judeans who had challenged him, the people tied to the temple's running who had just demanded his credentials (v.18), threw his words back at him with scorn: "Forty-six years this sanctuary has been in the building, and you, in three days, are going to raise it up?"
They take Jesus' saying literally. "This sanctuary" is the holy house towering over them, the centrepiece of Herod the Great's rebuilding. It had been under way since about 20/19 BC, was still unfinished, and was famous across the Roman world. "Forty and six" comes first in their sentence for emphasis: a whole generation of labour, wealth and skilled priest-masons. Against it they set "three days" and an emphatic, contemptuous "you". To them the claim is absurd.
John's readers hear a second layer the speakers miss. The verb "raise up" was used for putting up a building, but it was also the standard word for raising the dead. The word for "sanctuary" means God's dwelling-place, and John says next that Jesus "was speaking about the sanctuary of his body" (v.21). Even the pronoun "it" is masculine in Greek and can be heard as "him". The building they are proud of took nearly fifty years and would be destroyed in AD 70, only a few years after it was finally completed. The "sanctuary" Jesus meant would be raised in three days.
-
21But Jesus was speaking about the temple of His body.
Full study →But he, unlike the people questioning him, meant something else. The "sanctuary" he spoke of, the house where God himself dwells, was his own body.
In verse 19 Jesus had said, "Destroy this sanctuary, and in three days I will raise it." His hearers heard a claim about Herod's huge building, still not finished after forty-six years of work. John stops the story to tell the reader what Jesus was actually talking about. He uses the word for the inner sanctuary (naos), the dwelling of God's presence, not the word for the courts where the money-changers sat. So the claim is bold. The place where God lives among his people is now the living body of Jesus.
The body is a real, physical one. John uses the same word only for the body taken down from the cross and laid in the tomb. "Destroy" points to his killing, carried out by the same authorities who were asking him for a sign. "Raise" works on two levels: you raise a building, and God raises the dead. The sign Jesus offers is his own death and resurrection. The past tense ("he was speaking") makes clear that this was his meaning all along, though, as the next verse admits, the disciples only understood it after Easter.
-
22After He was raised from the dead, His disciples remembered that He had said this. Then they believed the Scripture and the word that Jesus had spoken.
Full study →So, once he had been raised out from among the dead (the same "raising" he had promised when he said, "Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it"), his disciples called back to mind that this was exactly what he had been saying. A saying they had heard and kept without grasping it suddenly made sense. And they trusted as true both the Scripture, Israel's sacred writing that had already come to mind at the temple ("Zeal for your house will consume me"), and the particular saying Jesus had spoken. These were now two agreeing witnesses, one from Israel's sacred writings and one from Jesus himself.
The verse is the narrator stepping out of the story to say that the disciples did not understand this at the time. The building-and-body wordplay (one Greek verb for "rebuild" and "raise from the dead") was opaque until Easter. Understanding came through remembering his words, reading Scripture and seeing the resurrection together.
Where the English drifted
-
in v18, v20
the Jews
hoi Ioudaioi
- What we hear
- The Jewish people as a whole, as an ethnic and religious group, set against Jesus.
- What they heard
- In this setting it means the Judean authorities answerable for the temple, a specific group within Judaism. Jesus, his disciples and the surrounding pilgrims are all Jews.
-
in v18
sign
sēmeion
- What we hear
- A miracle on demand, or a vague hint or omen.
- What they heard
- An authenticating token: visible proof that a messenger acts with God's backing, as Moses' signs were. It may be miraculous but need not be, and it can be a future event that confirms the claim afterwards.
-
in v19
this temple
ton naon touton
- What we hear
- The whole temple building or complex, the same 'temple' Jesus has just cleared of traders.
- What they heard
- The sanctuary, God's dwelling-house itself. It is a different word from the 'temple' (hieron, the courts and grounds) of vv.14–15. That sets up v.21's 'temple of his body'.
-
in v19
Destroy
lysate
- What we hear
- Jesus is telling them to destroy it, or announcing that he will destroy the temple.
- What they heard
- A command that works as an 'if': 'If you tear it down, I will raise it.' The destroyers are his opponents. Jesus claims only the rebuilding.
-
in v20, v21
temple
naos
- What we hear
- The whole temple complex, the same place where Jesus overturned the tables.
- What they heard
- The sanctuary proper, the holy house where God's presence dwelt, as distinct from the hieron (whole precinct) of vv.14-15. That narrower sense is what makes the 'sanctuary of his body' in v.21 work.
-
in v21
his body
sōma
- What we hear
- Read through church language as "the Body of Christ", meaning the church as God's new temple.
-
in v22
the Scripture
hē graphē
- What we hear
- The Bible as a whole, Old and New Testaments.
- What they heard
- Israel's sacred writings (the Law, the Prophets and the other writings such as the Psalms), and in John's singular usage probably one specific passage, most likely Psalm 69:9 quoted in v.17. No New Testament writings existed when this happened.
-
in v22
they believed
episteusan (with dative)
- What we hear
- They came to faith or were converted at this point.
- What they heard
- They took Scripture and Jesus' saying as true and reliable. These disciples had already "believed in him" (2:11). This marks a deeper, post-resurrection trust with understanding, not a first conversion.
Every word
-
ἀπεκρίθησαν
apekrithēsan · G611
to answer, respond · v18, v19
Nobody has asked them a question. They are "answering" what Jesus has just done, overturning the traders' tables. In biblical Greek this verb is used for reacting to a situation, not only for replying to words.
-
οὖν
oun · G3767
so, then, therefore · v18, v20, v22
John's usual word for moving the story on ("so," "then"). It also hints that their challenge is a direct result of the temple action. BSB's "On account of this" makes the cause stronger than the Greek does.
-
οἱ
hoi · G3588
the · v18, v19, v20, v21, v22
The article points to a known group, "the" Ioudaioi. In John that is a recognisable party in the story, not an unidentified crowd.
-
Ἰουδαῖοι
Ioudaioi · G2453
Jews, Judeans · v18, v20
Here it means the people who speak for the Jerusalem temple and have the standing to question someone who disrupts it, most likely the temple authorities. It cannot mean the Jewish people as a whole, because Jesus and his disciples, standing in the same courts, are Jews too.
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v18, v19, v20, v22
Joins the two verbs in the Semitic-style formula "answered and said."
-
εἶπαν
eipan · G2036
said · v18, v19, v20, v22
A plain verb of speaking. The Greek has no "demanded" (that is BSB's interpretation), though the context does make their words a challenge.
-
αὐτῷ
autō · G846
to him · v18, v19, v20, v21, v22
They address Jesus directly. This is a face-to-face challenge in public, in the temple courts.
-
τί
ti · G5101
what? which? · v18
"What sign?" The question is about what kind of credential, not only whether he has one. The word asks him to name the proof.
-
σημεῖον
sēmeion · G4592
sign, token, authenticating mark · v18
A visible proof that would show God stands behind his action, the kind of credential expected of a prophet. In John the same word names Jesus' own revealing acts (2:11), so their demand uses the Gospel's key word.
-
δεικνύεις
deiknueis · G1166
to show, point out, display · v18
Present tense, "are you showing us?", with the sense "what will you show us?" They want something put in front of their eyes, here and now.
-
ἡμῖν
hēmin · G2254
to us · v18
"To us": they cast themselves as the ones entitled to test his credentials. This is the posture of the people responsible for the temple.
-
ὅτι
hoti · G3754
that, because, since · v18, v22
This word joins the sign to the action in a compressed way: "seeing that," "since," "to back up the fact that" you do these things. The English versions differ in how they spell out the link the Greek leaves unstated.
-
ταῦτα
tauta · G3778
these things · v18, v19, v20, v22
Refers back to 2:14–16: the whip of cords, driving out the cattle and sheep, scattering the money-changers' coins, and the words "Stop making my Father's house a house of trade."
-
ποιεῖς
poieis · G4160
to do, make · v18
Present tense, "you are doing." They are asking about an act still fresh in front of them, which is also a continuing claim of authority over the temple.
-
Ἰησοῦς
Iēsous · G2424
Jesus (Hebrew Yeshua/Joshua) · v19, v22
The subject. Some editions put the article in front of it ('the Jesus'), which is normal Greek and makes no difference to the meaning.
-
λύσατε
lysate · G3089
loose, undo, break up, tear down · v19
A plural command aimed at his opponents: 'you tear down'. It works like an 'if': 'Go ahead and destroy it, and I will…'. It does not mean he wants them to, and it does not say he will do the destroying himself.
-
ναὸν
naon · G3485
sanctuary, shrine, dwelling of a deity · v19, v20, v21
Not the word John has been using for the temple grounds (hieron, vv.14–15). Naos means the inner house where God dwells. The switch prepares for v.21: 'he was speaking about the temple of his body.'
-
ἐν
en · G1722
in, within · v19, v20
'Within' the space of three days: an astonishingly short time compared with 46 years of building (v.20).
-
τρισὶν
trisin · G5140
three · v19, v20
'Three days' carries Hebrew Bible echoes of a short, decisive interval before God acts (Hosea 6:2; Jonah 1:17). John's readers knew it as the time of the resurrection.
-
ἡμέραις
hēmerais · G2250
days · v19, v20
Days on the calendar. Read with 'three', it is an extremely short time for any building project.
-
ἐγερῶ
egerō · G1453
I will raise, erect, wake · v19, v20, v22
A future tense: 'I myself will raise.' The verb can mean putting up a building or raising someone from the dead. John uses this second sense in v.22 ('when he was raised from the dead'). The ordinary word for building was oikodomeō (used in v.20), so this choice is deliberate.
-
τεσσεράκοντα
tesserakonta · G5062
forty · v20
First part of the number 'forty-six'. It comes first in the sentence for emphasis: the long span of years is the point of their objection.
-
ἓξ
hex · G1803
six · v20
Completes the figure. Forty-six years after Herod began rebuilding the temple (20/19 BC) gives a date around AD 27/28 for this scene.
-
ἔτεσιν
etesin · G2094
years · v20
In the dative case, used here for a span of time: 'over forty-six years' or 'in forty-six years'. It sets up the contrast with 'in three days'.
-
οἰκοδομήθη
oikodomēthē · G3618
was built · v20
A passive verb in the simple past ('was built'). The Greek past tense used here sums up an action as a whole, so it can mean 'has been under construction for forty-six years', which fits the fact that the complex was still unfinished. A minority reads it as 'was built (completed) forty-six years ago', referring only to the sanctuary building.
-
σὺ
sy · G4771
you · v20
Greek does not need this pronoun, because the verb already shows 'you'. Adding it makes it emphatic and scornful: 'you, of all people'.
-
ἐκεῖνος
ekeinos · G1565
-
δὲ
de · G1161
but, and, however · v21
Marks a contrast. The hearers meant one temple, but Jesus meant another.
-
ἔλεγεν
elegen · G3004
to say, speak, mean · v21, v22
The imperfect tense (an ongoing past action): "he was speaking," or in effect "what he meant was." It describes what his words referred to all along, not a new statement.
-
περὶ
peri · G4012
about, concerning · v21
Names the subject of his saying: what "this temple" in verse 19 actually pointed to.
-
σώματος
sōmatos · G4983
-
ὅτε
hote · G3753
when · v22
Points to a specific moment, the resurrection, as the time when understanding came. It sets up a clear before and after.
-
ἐκ
ek · G1537
out of, from · v22
"Out from among." The picture is of being brought out of the company of the dead.
-
νεκρῶν
nekrōn · G3498
dead · v22
Plural, with no article: "dead ones." This was the fixed early Christian phrase for resurrection. One person comes out from the realm and company of the dead. It does not describe a soul surviving apart from the body.
-
ἐμνήσθησαν
emnēsthēsan · G3403
to remember, call to mind · v22
"They remembered." The same word John uses in v.17, when the disciples remembered Psalm 69:9. Here it means more than pulling up a fact. A saying they had kept without understanding now made sense in light of what had happened.
-
μαθηταὶ
mathētai · G3101
disciple, learner, pupil · v22
The close followers who had been with Jesus since chapter 1 and were present at the temple incident. A disciple was a pupil attached to a teacher, and pupils were expected to remember and pass on the teacher's sayings.
-
ἐπίστευσαν
episteusan · G4100
to believe, trust, give credence to · v22
"They believed." Followed by a plain dative object ("believed the Scripture"), it means they took the Scripture and the saying as true and reliable. They had already "believed in him" in 2:11. What is new here is that they now credit the words, with understanding.
-
γραφῇ
graphē · G1124
writing, Scripture · v22
Singular: "the Scripture." It means Israel's sacred writings, and in John the singular usually points to a particular passage. Here that is most likely Psalm 69:9, quoted in v.17, or some text about the righteous one being vindicated. It does not mean the New Testament, which did not yet exist.
-
λόγῳ
logō · G3056
word, saying, statement · v22
The particular saying Jesus spoke, the temple riddle of v.19. It is not the title "the Word" of John 1:1, though John's readers may hear that the Word's words carry Scripture's weight.
-
ὃν
hon · G3739
which, that · v22
"Which": ties the saying to its speaker.
The world behind it
The act being challenged. At Passover, Jerusalem filled with pilgrims who had to buy animals for sacrifice that were free of defects. They also had to pay the annual temple tax in an accepted coinage, the Tyrian shekel, prized for its silver purity. Selling animals and changing money in the outer court made this possible. To most worshippers it was a service, not an obvious scandal. By driving the trade out, Jesus disrupted the machinery of sacrifice at the busiest feast of the year. He also called the temple "my Father's house" (2:16), an implied claim of special standing.
Who could challenge him. The temple was run by the high-priestly families and their officers, including a temple police force. Interfering there was a public affront to their authority. Their natural response was to demand credentials rather than simply arrest him, perhaps because the act echoed known prophetic hopes. Zechariah 14:21 says that on the day of the LORD there will be "no trader in the house of the LORD," and Malachi 3:1–3 has the Lord suddenly coming to his temple to purify it.
Prophets and signs. Israel's scriptures tied a prophet's legitimacy to signs (Exod 4; Deut 13; 18; 1 Kgs 13). In the first century, Josephus reports several popular figures who promised crowds that God would show "signs of freedom" (Antiquities 20.168). So someone acting with prophetic boldness in the temple would very naturally be asked, "What sign?"
When it happened. John places this incident at the start of Jesus' ministry. Mark, Matthew and Luke place a temple action in the last week, where it leads to his arrest. In 2:20 the questioners mention that the temple has been under construction for 46 years. Herod began rebuilding it around 20/19 BC, which puts this Passover around AD 27/28.
From the study of John 2:18.
Where scholars differ
in v18
Who are "the Ioudaioi" here, and how should the word be translated?
-
Jewish (temple) authorities
Context: the people with standing to challenge a disruption of the temple. John 1:19 has "the Ioudaioi" sending priests and Levites from Jerusalem. In 9:22 Jewish parents fear "the Ioudaioi," which only makes sense if the word means leaders. Argued by U. C. von Wahlde and reflected in NLT.
-
"Judeans": a regional or ethnic sense
In ancient usage Ioudaios was primarily an ethnic and geographic term, like other names of peoples (Steve Mason, JSJ 2007). In John, opposition is centred in Judea and Jerusalem, while Galileans are treated differently.
-
Keep "the Jews" and name the problem openly
Adele Reinhartz and others argue that softening the translation hides the Gospel's own rhetoric, which at times does set "the Jews" against the believing community. Honest translation should keep the word and explain it rather than tidy it away.
in v18
Did Jesus act in the temple once (placed differently by John and the Synoptics) or twice?
-
One event, which John moves to the start for theological reasons
The core is closely similar: trade driven out and a challenge to his authority. The Synoptics place it in the final week as the trigger for his arrest. John places it first to frame the whole ministry as being about the temple and Jesus' body (Raymond Brown and many others).
-
Two events, at the start and the end of the ministry
The details differ: John has the whip, the animals, "my Father's house" and the 46-year remark, while the Synoptics have "den of robbers" and a different form of the authority question. Defended by some conservative commentators (e.g. Leon Morris, D. A. Carson).
in v19
Did Jesus originally mean the Jerusalem temple, with the 'body' meaning added later, or did he mean his body from the start?
-
The saying first concerned the temple itself: a prophetic announcement of its end or replacement by a renewed temple. John (or the early church) later saw it as pointing to the body.
In Mark and Matthew the saying is about the temple, not a body. 'Made with hands / not made with hands' (Mark 14:58) points to a new kind of temple. John 2:22 itself says the disciples understood the meaning only after the resurrection.
-
Jesus deliberately spoke a riddle with two layers, and the body meaning was intended all along.
The switch to naos, the choice of egeirō over oikodomeō, and the masculine 'it/him' (auton) all prepare for v.21. John's Gospel often has Jesus use deliberately ambiguous words that hearers take the wrong way (3:3–4; 4:10–11; 6:51–52).
-
Both layers: Jesus' death and the fate of the temple are bound together, and the community of the risen Jesus becomes the new temple.
John 4:21–24 (worship no longer tied to Jerusalem). Paul's use of naos for the church (1 Cor 3:16; Eph 2:21). Many readings hold the body meaning and the replacement-of-the-temple meaning together.
in v19
What is the force of the command 'Destroy'?
-
It works as an 'if': 'If you destroy… I will raise.'
A common pattern in Greek and Hebrew: a command followed by 'and' plus a future verb (compare John 1:46 'Come and see'; Eph 5:14). Most grammarians (e.g. Wallace) read it this way.
-
An ironic or prophetic dare, close to 'Go ahead, do it.' The command half-predicts what they will in fact do.
Compare the prophetic irony of Amos 4:4 ('Go to Bethel and sin') and Matthew 23:32 ('Fill up the measure of your fathers'). In John the authorities do go on to bring about Jesus' death.
in v19
Is 'three days' a precise time or an idiom?
-
A specific prediction of the resurrection 'on the third day'.
John 2:22 makes the link explicitly. The early creed in 1 Cor 15:4 says 'raised on the third day'.
-
In its first setting, a Hebrew idiom for a short, set time before God acts. It was later read precisely.
Hosea 6:2; Exodus 19:11; Gen 22:4. 'Within three days' versus 'after three days' (Mark 8:31) shows the phrase could be used loosely.
in v20
What exactly do the 'forty-six years' measure?
-
The temple complex had been under construction for forty-six years and was still unfinished.
Josephus dates the start to about 20/19 BC and says work continued until about AD 62-64 (Ant. 15.380; 20.219). The simple past verb with a span of time can sum up an ongoing process. This is the majority view (e.g., Brown, Carson, Keener) and fits the 'has taken' translations.
-
The sanctuary building (naos) itself had been completed and standing for forty-six years: 'this sanctuary was built forty-six years ago'.
Josephus says the naos proper was finished in a year and a half (Ant. 15.421), and the speakers specifically say naos, not hieron. Advocated by H. Hoehner (Chronological Aspects of the Life of Christ), giving about AD 29/30. Critics reply that the Greek case used for time more naturally gives the length of the work than 'years ago'.
in v20
Who are 'the Jews' (hoi Ioudaioi) in this scene?
-
The Jerusalem religious authorities, or people acting for the temple establishment.
They demand Jesus' authority for disrupting the temple (v.18), which is the kind of challenge temple officials would make. Elsewhere John separates 'the Ioudaioi' from ordinary Jews who fear them (7:13; 9:22).
-
Judeans in general, meaning the people of Judea and Jerusalem as opposed to Galileans, or the Jewish crowd present.
Ioudaios has a regional sense in period sources (Josephus). John 7:1 contrasts Judea with Galilee. The text does not name priests or officials here.
-
A literary character for unbelief in John's story, shaped by later conflicts between synagogue and church.
John's use of the term is uneven, sometimes neutral, sometimes hostile, and many scholars see the experience of the evangelist's community reflected in it (e.g., J. L. Martyn).
in v20
Does John's placement of the temple clearing (with this dating) reflect a separate early event or a rearrangement of the one the other Gospels place in Passion Week?
-
There were two clearings, one early (John) and one late (the other Gospels).
The details differ, and John's '46 years' fixes an early date that fits a ministry of two to three years with several Passovers.
-
There was one clearing, which John moved to the start for theological reasons.
In the other Gospels the event triggers Jesus' arrest. John uses the raising of Lazarus for that role instead and puts the temple theme up front as a programme for the Gospel. The dating figure could belong to the tradition of the saying rather than to the sequence of events.
in v21
Does "the temple of his body" refer only to Jesus' physical body, or also to the church as his body?
-
Only (or primarily) Jesus' own physical body, killed and raised.
Verse 22 explicitly ties the saying to his being "raised from the dead". John uses σῶμα only for Jesus' body around death and burial (19:31–40; 20:12). John's Gospel never uses the Pauline "body = church" image. This is the majority view in modern commentary (e.g. Brown, Carson, Keener).
-
A secondary reference to the community of believers as God's new temple.
Some early interpreters (notably Origen in his Commentary on John) extended the image to the church. Some modern scholars point to John's themes of believers indwelt by Father and Son (14:2, 23; 17:21–23) and to Pauline temple imagery. Critics reply that this rests on other texts, not on the wording of 2:21.
in v21
What does "forty-six years" (v. 20) measure, and does it tell us when this happened?
-
Forty-six years of ongoing construction since Herod began work in 20/19 BC, putting the event around AD 27/28.
Josephus, Antiquities 15.380 (Herod's 18th year). The precinct was not finished until about AD 63 (Antiquities 20.219). Naos is then used loosely for the whole project.
-
The sanctuary building, completed around 18/17 BC, had been standing for forty-six years, putting the event around AD 29/30.
The aorist oikodomēthē can mean "was built" as a completed act. Naos strictly means the sanctuary, which Josephus says took about eighteen months (Antiquities 15.421).
in v22
Which "Scripture" did the disciples come to believe?
-
Psalm 69:9, quoted in v.17 ("Zeal for your house will consume me").
John's singular γραφή usually refers to a particular text. Psalm 69 was read early as a psalm of the suffering righteous one and is quoted again in John 15:25 and 19:28-29. Verse 17 uses the same "remembered" formula. On this view, "consume" points to Jesus' death.
-
A text predicting the resurrection or third-day vindication, such as Psalm 16:10 or Hosea 6:2.
John 20:9 speaks of "the Scripture that he must rise from the dead," and early preaching used Psalm 16 this way (Acts 2:27-31; 13:35). 1 Corinthians 15:4 says "raised on the third day according to the Scriptures."
-
Scripture as a whole, its general witness to the Messiah.
20:9 names no text, and the singular can sometimes be used generally. Commentators such as Brown leave the question open.
in v22
Did Jesus raise himself, or was he raised by God?
-
A divine passive: God raised him.
ἠγέρθη is passive in form, and the common early Christian confession is that God raised Jesus (Acts 2:24; Rom 4:24; 1 Cor 15:4).
-
Intransitive "he rose," consistent with Jesus' own agency.
The aorist passive of ἐγείρω often just means "got up" or "rose" in Koine. In 2:19 Jesus says "I will raise it," and in 10:17-18 he has authority to lay down his life and take it up again. John holds both together, since the Son acts in union with the Father (5:19-21).
Sources
- BDAG s.v. σημεῖον, Ἰουδαῖος, ἀποκρίνομαι, ὅτι
- Louw–Nida, Greek-English Lexicon (semantic domains for σημεῖον)
- K. H. Rengstorf, TDNT s.v. σημεῖον
- Blass–Debrunner–Funk, Greek Grammar of the NT (on the compressed use of ὅτι)
- Raymond E. Brown, The Gospel according to John I–XII (Anchor Bible)
- Craig S. Keener, The Gospel of John: A Commentary
- D. A. Carson, The Gospel according to John (Pillar)
- Steve Mason, "Jews, Judaeans, Judaizing, Judaism," Journal for the Study of Judaism 38 (2007)
- Urban C. von Wahlde, "The Johannine 'Jews': A Critical Survey," NTS 28 (1982)
- Adele Reinhartz, Cast Out of the Covenant: Jews and Anti-Judaism in the Gospel of John (2018)
- Josephus, Antiquities 20.167–172; Jewish War 2.258–263
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on John 2:13–22
- BDAG s.v. ναός, λύω, ἐγείρω
- Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. ναός (distinction from ἱερόν)
- Josephus, Antiquities 15.380–425; 20.219
- Josephus, Jewish War 6.300–309 (Jesus son of Ananias)
- LXX 1 Esdras 5:43; 1 Kings 6; Hosea 6:2
- 4Q174 (Florilegium)
- D. B. Wallace, Greek Grammar Beyond the Basics (conditional imperative)
- R. E. Brown, The Gospel according to John I–XII (Anchor Bible)
- C. S. Keener, The Gospel of John: A Commentary
- Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 15.380-425; 20.219
- Josephus, Jewish War 1.401
- BDAG s.v. ναός
- BDAG s.v. ἐγείρω
- BDAG s.v. Ἰουδαῖος
- BDAG s.v. οἰκοδομέω
- Babylonian Talmud, Bava Batra 4a
- R. E. Brown, The Gospel according to John I-XII (Anchor Bible)
- D. A. Carson, The Gospel according to John (Pillar NT Commentary)
- H. W. Hoehner, Chronological Aspects of the Life of Christ (1977)
- D. B. Wallace, Greek Grammar Beyond the Basics (dative of time; constative aorist)
- Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John 10.12
- J. L. Martyn, History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel
- BDAG s.v. σῶμα
- BDAG s.v. ἐκεῖνος
- Josephus, Jewish War 5.184–227
- R. E. Brown, The Gospel According to John I–XII (Anchor Bible)
- D. A. Carson, The Gospel According to John (Pillar NTC)
- M. L. Coloe, God Dwells with Us: Temple Symbolism in the Fourth Gospel
- A. R. Kerr, The Temple of Jesus' Body (JSNTSup 220)
- Origen, Commentary on John, Book 10
- Nestle-Aland 28th edition
- BDAG s.v. ἐγείρω, μιμνῄσκομαι, πιστεύω, γραφή, λόγος
- Nestle-Aland 28th ed., apparatus at John 2:22
- R. E. Brown, The Gospel According to John I-XII (Anchor Bible)
- D. A. Carson, The Gospel According to John (Pillar)
- Josephus, Jewish War 6.300-309; Antiquities 15.380 (Herod's temple rebuilding)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on John 2:13-22
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).