John Chapter 9 Read as one passage

John 9:15–17

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

15So the Pharisees also asked him how he had received his sight. The man answered, “He put mud on my eyes, and I washed, and now I can see.” 16Because of this, some of the Pharisees said, “This man is not from God, for He does not keep the Sabbath.” But others said, “How can a sinful man perform such signs?” And there was division among them. 17So once again they asked the man who had been blind, “What do you say about Him, since it was your eyes He opened?” “He is a prophet,” the man replied.

What the first hearers heard

For John's first readers this verse is a turning point. Until now the man has talked with curious neighbours. From here on he faces authorities who are investigating him. His answer is honest, brief and consistent, a model of witness under questioning: he says only what happened to him and what he now knows. He neither embellishes the story nor backs away from it. He will repeat it (v. 25: "one thing I know: I was blind, now I see") until his questioners tire of hearing it (v. 27).

Hearers who knew the Sabbath rules would feel the tension at once. The man's plain words ("mud", "put on") are the very details on which the charge of Sabbath-breaking rests. At the same time "and I see" sets out the dilemma that splits the Pharisees in verse 16: can someone who breaks the Sabbath do what no one has ever done? John's Gospel calls such deeds "signs". For readers who knew the potter imagery of their Scriptures ("we are the clay, you are our potter", Isa 64:8), mud on the eyes of a man born blind may also have suggested a new act of creation. And the chapter is moving toward its ironic ending, where the one who began blind sees, and those who claim to see are shown to be blind (9:39–41).

From the study of John 9:15.

Verse by verse

  1. 15So the Pharisees also asked him how he had received his sight. The man answered, “He put mud on my eyes, and I washed, and now I can see.”

    So, once again (this time it was the Pharisees as well), they set about questioning him: how had he, a man born blind, come to see? He gave them the bare facts: "Mud. He put it on my eyes. I washed. And I see."

    The Greek is short and plain. Jesus is just "he", not named as he was a few lines earlier (v. 11). The making of the mud and the walk to the pool of Siloam are left out. Three quick past-tense steps (put on, washed) end in one present-tense fact: I see. That fact needs no argument. The word "mud" comes first for emphasis, and it is the very detail that matters to his questioners, because the narrator has just told us (v. 14) that Jesus made this mud on a Sabbath. The verb for "came to see" can mean "see again", but here it describes something with no precedent: a man who had never seen now sees. The imperfect "were questioning" makes this the start of a continuing inquiry, which will draw in the man's parents and end with the man being thrown out (vv. 18–34).

    Full study →
  2. 16Because of this, some of the Pharisees said, “This man is not from God, for He does not keep the Sabbath.” But others said, “How can a sinful man perform such signs?” And there was division among them.

    The man's plain testimony in v.15 sets off an argument among the Pharisees: he put mud on my eyes, I washed, and I see. Some of them kept insisting, "This fellow is not sent from God, because he does not keep guard over the Sabbath." Their reasoning runs from his conduct to his origin. In their reading of the law, kneading clay and treating a condition that was not life-threatening on the seventh day broke the holy rest, and anyone who did that as a habit could not be God's envoy. That is the logic of Deuteronomy 13, where a wonder-worker who leads people away from God's commands is false whatever signs he performs.

    Others kept pushing back: "How could a man who flouts God's law, the kind of man God does not answer, perform signs like these?" For them the sign itself is God's endorsement. Opening the eyes of a man born blind had never been heard of (v.32), and such a thing does not come from someone God has abandoned.

    Both groups accept the same premise: a man who is really a lawbreaker cannot be from God. They disagree about which piece of evidence decides the question. So the panel was torn down the middle, the way cloth rips, and the rift stayed open. The story pointedly leaves the question of where Jesus comes from with the man who had been blind. In the next verse they ask him, and he answers, "He is a prophet."

    Full study →
  3. 17So once again they asked the man who had been blind, “What do you say about Him, since it was your eyes He opened?” “He is a prophet,” the man replied.

    So, unable to agree among themselves, the Pharisees turn once more to the man everyone still thinks of as "the blind man," and put the question to him: "You — what's your verdict on him? After all, it was your eyes he opened." The phrase "opened your eyes" carries the weight of Israel's Scriptures, where it is the LORD who "opens the eyes of the blind." Their question is really the one that has just split them: is this man from God or not? The beggar answers in three Greek words, putting the key word first: "A prophet — that's what he is." He does not mean someone who predicts the future. He means a man sent by God who acts with God's power, in the line of Elijah and Elisha. His verdict sides firmly with the Pharisees who said a sinner could not do such signs. It is his best word so far for Jesus, and the chapter will take him further, to "from God" (v. 33) and finally to faith in and worship of the Son of Man (vv. 35–38).

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v15

    the Pharisees

    Pharisaioi

    What we hear
    Hypocrites, petty legalists, people who were against Jesus as a group.
    What they heard
    A respected movement of Torah experts, popular with ordinary people, whom neighbours would naturally ask about the Sabbath. In the very next verse they are divided over Jesus.
  • in v15

    received his sight

    aneblepsen

    What we hear
    He got his sight back (the 'again' of the Greek prefix ana-).
    What they heard
    He came to see for the first time. He was blind from birth (9:1), and verse 32 stresses that this had never happened before.
  • in v15

    clay

    pēlos

    What we hear
    Modelling or potter's clay, a prepared craft material.
    What they heard
    Wet earth, mud, here made from soil and saliva on the ground (9:6). It could also mean the potter's material, which is part of why it may suggest the making of a person.
  • in v16

    a sinner / a sinful man

    hamartōlos

    What we hear
    Anyone at all, since everybody sins, or a generally immoral person.
    What they heard
    A known, open violator of God's law, the social opposite of the righteous. God was not expected to answer such a person's prayers or work through him (v.31).
  • in v16

    miracles (KJV)

    sēmeia

    What we hear
    Supernatural events that break natural laws, valued as wonders in themselves.
    What they heard
    Signs: acts that point to and show who stands behind them, like a prophet's credentials.
  • in v16

    not of God (KJV)

    para theou

    What we hear
    Ungodly, without God's character.
    What they heard
    Not sent by God, without God's commission: a question about origin and authority.
  • in v17

    a prophet

    prophētēs

    What we hear
    Someone who predicts the future or has special foresight.
    What they heard
    A messenger and agent sent by God who speaks and acts with his authority, often confirmed by mighty deeds such as healing (Elijah, Elisha). Here it is shorthand for "he is from God."
Every word
  1. πάλιν

    palin · G3825

    again · v15, v17

    Points back to verse 10, where the neighbours had already asked him how his eyes were opened. He now has to tell the story a second time, to a new and more official audience.

  2. οὖν

    oun · G3767

    therefore, so · v15, v16, v17

    John's usual word for moving the story on. Here it links back to verse 14: because the healing happened on a Sabbath, the questioning goes up a level.

  3. ἠρώτων

    ērōtōn · G2065

    to ask, question · v15

    The imperfect tense pictures an action going on: 'they were questioning him', or 'they set about questioning him'. It reads like an ongoing inquiry, not one polite question.

  4. αὐτὸν

    auton · G0846

    him · v15, v16, v17

    The formerly blind man. The questioning is aimed at him, not yet at Jesus, who is absent from the whole scene from verse 8 to verse 34.

  5. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    also, and · v15, v16

    'Also': the Pharisees now ask too, after the neighbours. The word marks a second round of questioning by a second group.

  6. οἱ

    hoi · G3588

    the · v15, v16, v17

    The definite article marks 'the Pharisees' as a known group, the ones the neighbours took him to in verse 13.

  7. Φαρισαῖοι

    Pharisaioi · G5330

    Pharisee · v15, v16

    Members of a respected Jewish movement known for careful Torah observance and the traditions for applying it. The neighbours bring the case to them as recognised experts on what is allowed on the Sabbath.

  8. πῶς

    pōs · G4459

    how? · v15, v16

    An indirect question: 'how' he came to see. It asks about method, and the method matters because it decides whether the Sabbath was broken (verse 14).

  9. ἀνέβλεψεν.

    aneblepsen · G0308

    to look up; to (re)gain sight · v15

    'He came to see.' The verb can mean 'see again', but this man was born blind (9:1), so here it means gaining sight he never had. The aorist tense presents it as a single event.

  10. δὲ

    de · G1161

    and, but · v15, v16, v17

    A light connective that moves from the question to the answer.

  11. εἶπεν

    eipen · G2036

    said · v15, v17

    A plain verb of speaking. Nothing marks his answer as reluctant or defiant. It is simply a report.

  12. πηλὸν

    pēlon · G4081

    mud, clay · v15

    Wet earth. In verse 6 it is made from Jesus' saliva mixed with soil. It comes first in the Greek sentence for emphasis: 'Mud, that's what he put on my eyes.' It is also the detail that raises the Sabbath question.

  13. ἐπέθηκέν

    epethēken · G2007

    to put on, lay upon · v15

    'He put (it) on.' Plainer than the 'smeared, anointed' of verses 6 and 11. The subject is just 'he'. The man does not name Jesus here, though he did in verse 11.

  14. μου

    mou · G3165

    my · v15

    'My (eyes).' The Greek places it early, before the phrase 'upon the eyes', which keeps the focus on what happened to him personally.

  15. ἐπὶ

    epi · G1909

    upon · v15

    'Upon.' It repeats the prefix of the verb ἐπέθηκεν, which is ordinary Greek style.

  16. ὀφθαλμοὺς

    ophthalmous · G3788

    eye · v15, v17

    His physical eyes, blind from birth. In John's chapter as a whole, eyes and seeing also carry the larger theme of spiritual sight and blindness (9:39–41).

  17. ἐνιψάμην

    enipsamēn · G3538

    to wash · v15

    'I washed (myself).' The middle voice means washing a part of one's own body. His part was simple obedience. He leaves out Siloam, which he mentioned in verse 11.

  18. βλέπω.

    blepō · G0991

    to see · v15

    'I see.' The present tense is a sudden switch from the past-tense steps to his present condition. Whatever they decide about how it happened, the fact stands in front of them.

  19. ἔλεγον

    elegon · G3004

    were saying · v16, v17

    The tense pictures an ongoing action, not a single statement. The Pharisees were arguing back and forth while the hearing went on.

  20. ἐκ

    ek · G1537

    out of, from among · v16

    Marks a part of a group: "some from among" the Pharisees. From the start, not all of them hold the same view.

  21. τινές

    tines · G5100

    some, certain ones · v16

    Only "some". The word sets up the split reported at the end of the verse.

  22. οὐκ

    ouk · G3756

    not · v16

    Comes first in the quoted sentence, so it carries emphasis: "NOT from God is this man."

  23. ἔστιν

    estin · G1510

    is · v16, v17

    A plain present-tense judgment about who Jesus is and where he comes from.

  24. οὗτος

    houtos · G3778

    this (one) · v16

    Combined with "the man" it makes "this man here". The phrasing can sound distancing, even dismissive ("this fellow"), as it does in v.24 and v.29.

  25. παρὰ

    para · G3844

    from (the side of) · v16

    Used with the genitive case, it means coming from someone's presence or authority. The question is whether God sent Jesus. In John this is the language of being sent, as in 1:6 and 9:33.

  26. θεοῦ

    theou · G2316

    God · v16

    The God of Israel, who gave the Sabbath command. The irony is that people are invoking the Lawgiver's name to rule out the one who healed.

  27. ἄνθρωπος

    anthrōpos · G444

    human being, man · v16

    "Man" here is pointed: he is just a man, and the question is whether a mere man is from God. Readers of John know the deeper irony (1:1, 14).

  28. ὅτι

    hoti · G3754

    because · v16, v17

    Gives the evidence for their verdict. The argument runs from his conduct to his origin.

  29. σάββατον

    sabbaton · G4521

    Sabbath · v16

    The seventh-day rest commanded in the Torah, a covenant sign marking Israel's identity (Exod 31:13–17). The Greek word order puts "the Sabbath" before the verb for emphasis.

  30. τηρεῖ

    tērei · G5083

    keeps, observes, guards · v16

    The present tense presents his Sabbath-breaking as typical of him, not a one-off slip. That fits John 5, where he also healed on a Sabbath. To "keep" the Sabbath meant to guard it carefully against forbidden work.

  31. ἄλλοι

    alloi · G243

    others · v16

    A second group of Pharisees with the opposite view.

  32. δύναται

    dynatai · G1410

    is able, can · v16

    The question is what is possible: such power must come from God. The same verb returns at v.33: "if this man were not from God, he could do nothing."

  33. ἁμαρτωλὸς

    hamartōlos · G268

    sinful, a sinner · v16

    Picks up the first group's charge. "Sinner" here means a person who openly disregards God's law, the kind of person God does not answer (v.31). It does not mean a person who sometimes does wrong.

  34. τοιαῦτα

    toiauta · G5108

    such, of this kind · v16

    "Signs like these": the healing of a man born blind, which was unheard of (v.32), and probably the earlier signs too.

  35. σημεῖα

    sēmeia · G4592

    signs · v16

    John's word for Jesus' miracles as acts that point to something and show who he is. The Pharisees use it the way people spoke of a prophet's credentials.

  36. ποιεῖν

    poiein · G4160

    to do, make, perform · v16

    The same verb is used of Jesus "making" the clay (vv.6, 11, 14), which was the Sabbath offense. So the "doing" lies behind both the charge and the defense.

  37. σχίσμα

    schisma · G4978

    split, tear, division · v16

    A tear, like a rip in cloth. The panel splits down the middle. The same thing happens around Jesus at 7:43 and 10:19.

  38. ἐν

    en · G1722

    among, in · v16

    The division ran inside the group itself, not between the Pharisees and outsiders.

  39. τυφλῷ

    tuphlō · G5185

    blind · v17

    He can now see, but the narrator still calls him "the blind man." The old label sticks to him, as it does in the minds of those questioning him. It also sets up the closing irony of the chapter (9:39–41), where the sighted turn out to be the blind ones.

  40. τί

    ti · G5101

    what? · v17

    "What": they ask what he says about the man, his assessment, not just facts.

  41. σὺ

    su · G4771

    you · v17

    Greek does not need this pronoun, because the verb already shows "you." Adding it puts weight on the word: "you, what do *you* say?" The religious authorities are asking a beggar to settle the question that has divided them.

  42. περὶ

    peri · G4012

    about, concerning · v17

    "Concerning him": the topic of the testimony.

  43. ἠνέῳξέν

    ēneōxen · G0455

    he opened · v17

    A single, completed act: "he opened." In Israel's Scriptures, opening the eyes of the blind is something God does (Psalm 146:8; Isaiah 35:5; 42:7). The phrase is repeated through the chapter (9:10, 14, 21, 26, 30, 32).

  44. προφήτης

    prophētēs · G4396

    prophet · v17

    Someone sent by God who speaks and acts for him, often confirmed by mighty deeds, like Elijah and Elisha. The word comes first in the Greek for emphasis: "A prophet, that's what he is." It answers verse 16's question of whether this man is "from God."

The world behind it

Why the method matters. The question "how?" is not idle curiosity. Verse 14 has just said that the healing took place on a Sabbath, and that Jesus made mud. In the Jewish legal tradition that was later written down in the Mishnah (c. AD 200), "kneading" is one of the thirty-nine kinds of work forbidden on the Sabbath (m. Shabbat 7:2). Mixing earth with saliva could fall under it. Later rabbinic texts also discuss whether saliva may be put on the eyes as treatment on the Sabbath, and some forbade it (Jerusalem Talmud, Shabbat 14:4). Healing that was not needed to save a life could generally wait until after the Sabbath. These texts are later than John, but they show the kind of reasoning the questioners would have used. So "Clay he put on my eyes" is, without his meaning it to be, evidence that Sabbath work was done.

Who is asking. The neighbours bring the man to the Pharisees (v. 13). The Pharisees were not a court in themselves, but they were the recognised experts on how to keep the Torah in daily life, and people looked to them on Sabbath questions. In the next verses John moves between "the Pharisees" and "the Jews", meaning the religious authorities (v. 18, 22). The expulsion from the synagogue mentioned in verse 22 has led many scholars to think John's first readers saw their own experience reflected in the scene (see Debates).

Mud and spittle as treatment. Saliva was widely thought to have healing power in the ancient world. Pliny's Natural History 28.7 mentions saliva for eye complaints, and Tacitus (Histories 4.81) tells of the emperor Vespasian healing a blind man with spittle in Alexandria. So the method would not have looked bizarre to first-century hearers. What was unheard of was the result: sight for someone born blind (v. 32).

From the study of John 9:15.

Where scholars differ

in v15

Does the mud echo God forming humanity from earth (Genesis 2)?

  • Yes. John presents Jesus as finishing or renewing creation in a man 'born' blind.

    John's prologue opens with creation (1:1–3). πηλός is the potter's clay in the Greek Old Testament (Isa 64:8; Job 10:9). Irenaeus (Against Heresies 5.15.2) read the passage this way in the 2nd century, and the man is blind 'from birth'.

  • Possible, but not certain. The mud reflects ordinary healing practice and sets up the Sabbath issue.

    Gen 2:7 in the Greek Old Testament uses χοῦς ('dust'), not πηλός. Saliva was a well-known remedy (Pliny, Natural History 28.7; Tacitus, Histories 4.81). John himself draws attention to the Sabbath meaning of 'made the mud' (v. 14), not to creation.

in v15

Why is the man's account here shorter than in verse 11?

  • Caution. He leaves out Jesus' name and the 'making' of mud in front of hostile authorities.

    In verse 11 he names 'the man called Jesus', but here he says only 'he'. Verse 22 shows that people feared being expelled from the synagogue.

  • Narrative economy and weariness. He is repeating a story he has already told.

    'Again' (πάλιν) and later 'I told you already' (v. 27) suggest a man tired of repeating himself. He becomes bolder, not more careful, as the questioning goes on (vv. 17, 30–33).

in v15

Does the interrogation reflect conflict in John's own day as well as Jesus' day?

  • Yes. The scene works on two levels and mirrors the late-first-century expulsion of Jesus-followers from synagogues.

    J. Louis Martyn's influential reading rests on the word ἀποσυνάγωγος ('put out of the synagogue', 9:22; 12:42; 16:2), a term found only in John.

  • The link is overstated, or a formal decree of expulsion cannot be shown.

    Some critics argue the 'Blessing against heretics' (Birkat ha-Minim) cannot be shown to be a decree aimed at Christians by c. AD 85–90. Local disputes over synagogue membership also happened in Jesus' and Paul's day (e.g. Acts 18:6–7).

in v16

Did Jesus actually break the Sabbath law, or only the Pharisees' interpretation of it?

  • Jesus broke only a disputed interpretation. Nothing in the written Torah forbids making a little clay or healing.

    Exod 20 and Deut 5 forbid "work" without listing kneading or healing. The detailed categories come from later rabbinic tradition (m. Shabbat 7:2). In the Synoptic Gospels Jesus defends Sabbath healing by appeal to Scripture and to mercy (Mark 3:4).

  • In John, Jesus deliberately acts as one with authority over the Sabbath, so the charge is more than a quibble about interpretation.

    In John 5:17–18 Jesus claims that he works as his Father works, and the narrator says the opponents saw this as "breaking" the Sabbath and making himself equal with God. The deliberate making of clay here, repeated three times in the story, suggests the act was meant to provoke.

in v16

Is the split among the Pharisees historical or a literary device?

  • It is historically plausible.

    The Pharisees were known for internal debate (the schools of Hillel and Shammai). Gamaliel urges caution in Acts 5:34–39. Nicodemus defends Jesus in John 7:50–51, and 12:42 says many leaders believed.

  • It mainly serves John's theme of division and judgment.

    The same "split" appears at 7:43 and 10:19 at key points in the story. After v.18 the narrator shifts to "the Jews", and the sympathetic side drops out of view.

in v17

Does "a prophet" here allude to the Prophet like Moses (Deuteronomy 18), or mean a prophet in general?

  • A prophet in general, in the Elijah/Elisha mould: an agent of God shown by mighty deeds.

    There is no article ("a prophet," not "the Prophet"), whereas John uses the article when he means the expected figure (1:21, 25; 6:14; 7:40). Elijah and Elisha are the Old Testament healing and miracle prophets, and Elisha's opening of eyes (2 Kings 6:17–20) fits closely. The man is giving the best category a layperson had.

  • It carries overtones of John's broader picture of Jesus as the Mosaic Prophet.

    John repeatedly frames Jesus against Moses (1:17; 5:46; 6:14, 32). Deuteronomy 13 and 18 (testing prophets by signs and obedience) sit behind the Sabbath dispute of 9:16. Readers would hear the larger theme even in an article-less use.

in v17

Is the first ὅτι causal ("since he opened") or does it give the content of the question ("that he opened")?

  • Causal: "since/because he opened your eyes."

    This is the most natural flow: the Pharisees explain why they are asking him. It is followed by ESV, NASB, WEB and BSB ("since it was your eyes").

  • Content: "what do you say about him, [about the fact] that he opened your eyes?"

    ὅτι after verbs of saying or thinking with περί often introduces content. KJV's "that he hath opened" and the Vulgate's relative clause reflect this. On this reading the Pharisees are asking how he explains the act itself, which fits their later suspicion of the miracle (9:18).

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. ἀναβλέπω, πηλός, ἐρωτάω, Φαρισαῖος
  • Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. πηλός
  • Mishnah Shabbat 7:2 (thirty-nine categories of forbidden work, including kneading)
  • Jerusalem Talmud Shabbat 14:4 (saliva on the eyes on the Sabbath)
  • Josephus, Antiquities 13.297–298; 18.12–15; Jewish War 2.162–166
  • Pliny the Elder, Natural History 28.7; Tacitus, Histories 4.81
  • Irenaeus, Against Heresies 5.15.2
  • J. Louis Martyn, History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel
  • C. K. Barrett, The Gospel According to St John
  • Raymond E. Brown, The Gospel According to John I–XII (Anchor Bible)
  • Craig S. Keener, The Gospel of John: A Commentary
  • NA28 critical apparatus at John 9:6
  • BDAG s.v. ἁμαρτωλός
  • BDAG s.v. σημεῖον
  • BDAG s.v. σχίσμα
  • BDAG s.v. παρά (A.3, with genitive of person)
  • BDAG s.v. τηρέω
  • Mishnah Shabbat 7:2 (39 categories of labor, including kneading)
  • Mishnah Yoma 8:6 (danger to life overrides the Sabbath)
  • Jerusalem Talmud Shabbat 14:4 (applying saliva to the eyes on the Sabbath)
  • Deuteronomy 13:1–5; 18:21–22 (tests of a prophet)
  • 1 Maccabees 1:34; 2:44; Psalms of Solomon ("sinners" as lawless)
  • R. E. Brown, The Gospel according to John I–XII (Anchor Bible)
  • C. S. Keener, The Gospel of John: A Commentary
  • J. D. G. Dunn, "Pharisees, Sinners, and Jesus"
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on John 9
  • BDAG s.v. προφήτης
  • BDAG s.v. ὅτι
  • Septuagint: 2 Kings (4 Kingdoms) 6:17–20; Psalm 145:8 LXX; Isaiah 35:5; 42:7
  • 1 Maccabees 4:46; 9:27; 14:41
  • Josephus, Against Apion 1.41; Antiquities 20.97–98, 169–170
  • Mishnah Shabbat 7:2
  • Raymond E. Brown, The Gospel according to John I–XII (Anchor Bible)
  • C. K. Barrett, The Gospel according to St John

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).