Mark Chapter 5 Read as one passage

Mark 5:12–13

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

12So the demons begged Jesus, “Send us to the pigs, so that we may enter them.” 13He gave them permission, and the unclean spirits came out and went into the pigs, and the herd of about two thousand rushed down the steep bank into the sea and drowned in the water.

What the first hearers heard

Mark's first hearers would have taken several things from this short plea:

  • Jesus is in command. A horde large enough to name itself after a Roman army unit cannot act without his permission. They ask to be sent, and in v. 13 he permits. For a community that may itself have been living under Roman power and pressure, this showed that the power behind the oppression answers to Jesus.
  • Unclean meets unclean. Unclean spirits, unclean animals, tombs and Gentile land all belong together in Jewish thinking. By sending the spirits into the pigs and the pigs into the sea, the story clears the impurity out of the man and out of the land. The sea was the place of chaos that Jesus had already silenced in 4:39.
  • A request that defeats itself. The spirits want to stay in the area by living in the herd. What they get is a herd plunging into the sea. Hearers who knew the Exodus story might think of Pharaoh's army drowned in the sea (Exod 14–15).
  • The first of several pleas. This is the first plea Jesus grants in a chapter full of pleading (vv. 10, 12, 17, 18, 23). The contrast is pointed: the spirits and the frightened townspeople get what they ask for, but the healed man is told to stay and tell his own people (v. 19).

From the study of Mark 5:12.

Verse by verse

  1. 12So the demons begged Jesus, “Send us to the pigs, so that we may enter them.”

    And they pleaded with him: the horde that had just spoken with one voice and called itself "Legion, for we are many" now pleads as the many. Beings strong enough to break chains and shackles (vv. 3–4) can do nothing but ask. They already know they must leave the man. What they argue over is where they will go, and they recognise that Jesus decides. "Send us into the pigs," they say. This is the urgent command form people used for requests to a superior, much as prayers say "give us". They mean the pigs, the great herd feeding on the hillside in plain view. "So that it is into them we may enter": the Greek says "into" twice, pressing the point. Thrown out of one body, they want new living bodies to live in, here in this region (v. 10).

    To a Jewish hearer the request fits almost too well. Spirits Mark calls unclean ask to go into the animal the Law treated as most unclean, in Gentile country among the tombs. It is the same picture as Isaiah 65:3–4, where people offer to demons, sleep in tombs and eat pork. What they ask for will also be their undoing: in the next verse Jesus permits it, and the whole herd, about two thousand, rushes into the sea.

    Full study →
  2. 13He gave them permission, and the unclean spirits came out and went into the pigs, and the herd of about two thousand rushed down the steep bank into the sea and drowned in the water.

    Jesus granted their request: the spirits had to ask, and they could act only with his leave. The impure spirits ("Legion," many of them under one name) came out of the man and went into the pigs, exactly as they had asked. In Jewish ears these are the most unclean animals there are, herded in Gentile country beside the tombs. At once the whole herd charged as one body down the steep slope into the sea, the same waters Jesus had just silenced in the storm, the deep that in Israel's stories swallows hostile powers. There were about two thousand of them, a herd big enough to be a serious livelihood. Then the scene slows: one by one they were choking in the water, drowning before the eyes of the herdsmen. The man is free, the unclean host is gone into the deep, and the cost is plain for everyone to see.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v12

    devils (KJV: "all the devils besought him")

    daimones

    What we hear
    Many small versions of the Devil, Satan himself multiplied, or pitchfork-and-horns figures.
    What they heard
    Evil spirits. Mark calls them 'unclean spirits' (v. 13), lesser hostile powers that are distinct from 'the devil' (diabolos, Satan), who is a different word and a single figure.
  • in v13

    unclean spirits

    pneumata akatharta

    What we hear
    Dirty, filthy or morally disgusting spirits, perhaps with a sexual tinge. NLT's "evil spirits" makes it purely moral.
    What they heard
    Spirits defined by impurity in the Torah's sense: opposed to and incompatible with God's holiness, the kind of thing that defiles. In this chapter they belong with tombs, pigs and Gentile land.
  • in v13

    the sea

    thalassa

    What we hear
    A salt ocean or open sea.
    What they heard
    The Sea of Galilee, a freshwater lake, called "sea" after Hebrew *yam*. The word carries the biblical sense of the deep as a realm of chaos that God masters.
Every word
  1. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v12, v13

    Mark's usual storytelling link. It keeps the scene moving straight on from the herd mentioned in v. 11.

  2. παρεκάλεσαν

    parekalesan · G3870

    to beg, plead, entreat; to urge; to comfort · v12

    They pleaded urgently. The verb is plural, while v. 10 used the singular for the same begging: the one voice that spoke as 'Legion' now breaks into the many it said it was ('we are many', v. 9). The begging is a petition from those who are weaker, not a bargain between equals.

  3. αὐτὸν

    auton · G0846

    him · v12, v13

    Jesus. The spirits direct their plea to him alone. They know their future depends on what he allows.

  4. πάντες

    pantes · G3956

    all · v12

    Found only in the later Byzantine text (KJV, WEB). It stresses that the whole horde joined the plea.

  5. οἱ

    hoi · G3588

    the · v12, v13

    The article with 'demons'. Found only in the later Byzantine text.

  6. δαίμονες

    daimones · G1142

    demons, spirits · v12

    An added subject in the later text. Mark himself calls these beings 'unclean spirits' (vv. 2, 8, 13), and elsewhere uses the related word daimonion. This rarer form matches Matthew 8:31.

  7. λέγοντες

    legontes · G3004

    saying · v12

    Introduces the words of the plea. Greek often uses this where English would just open quotation marks.

  8. πέμψον

    pempson · G3992

    send · v12

    A one-time command form ('send us!'). In Greek this is the normal way to make an urgent request even to a superior, just as prayers say 'give us'. It is not rude. The spirits cannot simply move on their own: they ask to be sent.

  9. ἡμᾶς

    hēmas · G3165

    us · v12

    The plural group again: the 'many' of v. 9.

  10. εἰς

    eis · G1519

    into · v12, v13

    Movement into. BSB's 'to the pigs' softens it. The Greek asks to be sent into the animals themselves, not just toward them.

  11. χοίρους

    choirous · G5519

    pigs, swine · v12, v13

    Pigs, the clearest unclean animal in Jewish law (Lev 11:7; Deut 14:8). Raising them in large numbers marks this as Gentile country. Unclean spirits ask for unclean animals.

  12. ἵνα

    hina · G2443

    so that, in order that · v12

    Gives the purpose of being sent. The point of the plea is to have bodies to occupy.

  13. εἰσέλθωμεν

    eiselthōmen · G1525

    we may enter, go in · v12, v13

    'Enter' is the usual language for spirit possession, the opposite of the 'come out' (exerchomai) Jesus ordered in v. 8. Having been forced out of one body, the spirits ask for other bodies to live in.

  14. ἐπέτρεψεν

    epetrepsen · G2010

    to permit, allow · v13

    "He permitted." The verb is in the aorist, the Greek tense for a single completed act. Jesus does not send the spirits. He grants their request (5:12). That puts him in the position of a superior granting leave to subordinates who cannot move without it.

  15. εὐθέως

    eutheōs · G2112

    immediately · v13

    Found only in the Byzantine/Textus Receptus text (KJV "forthwith"). It is absent from the oldest manuscripts. Mark himself normally writes the related form εὐθύς.

  16. Ἰησοῦς

    Iēsous · G2424

    Jesus · v13

    Byzantine/TR only. It names the subject outright. In the critical text the subject is simply understood from 5:12.

  17. ἐξελθόντα

    exelthonta · G1831

    to go out, come out · v13

    "Having come out" of the man. This is Mark's standard verb for a spirit leaving a person (1:25–26; 9:25). It confirms that the exorcism has actually happened.

  18. πνεύματα

    pneumata · G4151

    spirit, breath, wind · v13

    "Spirits," plural. The single voice that called itself "Legion" (5:9) turns out to be many. The word is neuter, but its verb is plural, so they are treated as many personal agents.

  19. ἀκάθαρτα

    akatharta · G0169

    unclean, impure · v13

    Impurity in the Torah's sense: incompatible with God's holiness. Here impure spirits pass into impure animals, in a land of tombs and Gentiles.

  20. ὥρμησεν

    hōrmēsen · G3729

    to rush, charge, stampede · v13

    "Rushed, charged." The verb is singular: the herd moves as one mass in a sudden violent surge. The same verb is used of a mob rushing (Acts 7:57; 19:29) and in wider Greek of troops charging.

  21. ἀγέλη

    agelē · G0034

    herd · v13

    The ordinary word for a herd of animals moving together. A singular collective noun, it takes the singular verb "rushed."

  22. κατὰ

    kata · G2596

    down, down from · v13

    With the genitive case it means "down from, down along." The herd pours down the slope.

  23. κρημνοῦ

    krēmnou · G2911

    steep slope, cliff, overhang · v13

    A steep bank or precipice. It need not be a sheer cliff, but it is steep enough that a panicked herd cannot stop.

  24. θάλασσαν

    thalassan · G2281

    sea · v13

    The Sea of Galilee, a freshwater lake. Mark calls it "sea" in the Hebrew manner, and in Jewish imagery the sea is the deep, the realm of chaos.

  25. ἦσαν

    ēsan · G1510

    they were · v13

    Byzantine/TR only. It turns "about two thousand" into a separate remark: "now they were about two thousand."

  26. δὲ

    de · G1161

    now, and · v13

    Byzantine/TR only. It marks the aside.

  27. ὡς

    hōs · G5613

    about, approximately · v13

    With a number it means "about." The figure is a round estimate, not a count.

  28. δισχίλιοι

    dischilioi · G1367

    two thousand · v13

    A huge herd, implying a large commercial operation and so a heavy economic loss (compare the townspeople's reaction in 5:14–17). The word is masculine, agreeing in sense with "the pigs" (masculine) rather than "herd" (feminine). The camera shifts from the mass back to the individual animals.

  29. ἐπνίγοντο

    epnigonto · G4155

    to choke, strangle, drown · v13

    "They were choking / drowning." It is in the imperfect tense, which presents an action in progress. After the single surge of "rushed," the picture is drawn out: animal after animal suffocating in the water.

  30. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in · v13

    Location: in the water where they ended.

The world behind it
  • Gentile territory. The scene is the far (east) side of the Sea of Galilee, in the "region of the Gerasenes" (v. 1), part of the Decapolis, a league of Greek-style cities. Pigs were ordinary livestock there, used for food and in sacrifices to Greek and Roman gods. A herd of two thousand (v. 13) points to a commercial operation, which explains why the townspeople are so upset (vv. 14–17).
  • Pigs and Jewish identity. Since the Maccabean crisis (2nd century BC), when Jews were forced under threat of death to eat pork, refusing pork had been one of the clearest badges of loyalty to Israel's God (1 Macc 1:47; 2 Macc 6–7). For Jewish hearers, pigs, tombs (v. 3) and unclean spirits made up one picture of complete impurity, much like Isaiah 65:3–4.
  • How people thought spirits behaved. Jewish literature of the period pictured evil spirits as restless, needing a body or a place, and wanting to stay in their territory (1 Enoch 15; Jubilees 10:7–9; cf. Matt 12:43–45). The plea not to be sent "out of the region" (v. 10) and the request for the pigs fit that picture.
  • Visible proof of an exorcism. Josephus tells of a Jewish exorcist, Eleazar, who in front of the future emperor Vespasian ordered a departing demon to overturn a bowl of water so onlookers could see it had gone (Ant. 8.46–48). Exorcism stories in that world often included a visible sign that the spirit had left. Here the herd's stampede is that sign.
  • "Legion." The name given in v. 9 is the Latin word for a Roman army unit of several thousand soldiers. It was a word everyone in the occupied East knew.

From the study of Mark 5:12.

Where scholars differ

in v12

Why do the spirits ask for the pigs, and why does Jesus allow it?

  • They want to stay in the region. Living in a body, even an animal's, is better for them than being sent away or into 'the abyss'.

    V. 10 (they beg not to be sent out of the region); Luke 8:31 (the abyss); Jewish ideas of restless spirits seeking bodies or places (Matt 12:43–45; 1 Enoch 15; Jubilees 10:7–9).

  • The stampede is the visible proof that the spirits have left, the kind of sign exorcism stories often included.

    Josephus, Ant. 8.46–48 (a demon made to overturn a bowl of water as proof); the effect on the onlookers and townspeople (vv. 14–17).

  • It is symbolic cleansing: unclean spirits go into unclean animals and then into the sea, clearing impurity from the man and the Gentile land.

    Mark calls them 'unclean spirits' (v. 13); Lev 11:7; Isa 65:3–4 LXX (demons, tombs, pork); the sea as a hostile power subdued in Mark 4:39.

  • The spirits overreach and destroy themselves. What they ask for turns out to be their defeat, not a clever escape.

    The herd drowns immediately (v. 13). Mark does not say what happens to the spirits, but the story treats the outcome as their removal.

in v12

Do 'Legion' and the pigs carry an anti-Roman meaning?

  • Yes. 'Legion' is a Roman military word, the pigs evoke Rome (the boar was an emblem of the Tenth Legion, Fretensis, which was stationed in the region), and the drowning in the sea recalls Pharaoh's army. Mark's hearers would have heard a hint about the occupier being driven into the sea.

    The Latin loanword legiōn (v. 9); military-sounding language (agelē, 'herd', and hōrmēsen, 'charged'); boar emblems on Legio X objects; Exod 14–15.

  • At most this is a background echo. The story's main concern is impurity and Jesus' power over spirits, not politics.

    The clearest evidence for the boar emblem dates from later than Mark; 'legion' was also used loosely to mean 'a huge number'; Mark never draws a political lesson from the story.

in v13

Is the drowning of 'Legion' in the sea meant as a coded picture of Roman occupation?

  • Yes. The story deliberately uses military imagery against Rome.

    "Legion" is a Latin military term (5:9). J. D. M. Derrett (JSNT 1979) argued that ἐπιτρέπω can be a command word, that ἀγέλη was used of bands of young recruits, and that ὁρμάω is a word for a military charge. The Tenth Legion, active in Palestine during the Jewish War, used a boar as an emblem. Drowning in the sea recalls Pharaoh's army (Exod 15). Ched Myers and Richard Horsley develop this reading.

  • Only partly, or not at all. The undertone is possible, but the story is about spiritual power and impurity.

    ἀγέλη and ὁρμάω are the ordinary words for a herd stampeding. Two thousand does not match the size of a legion. The boar emblem is securely attested only after 70. "Legion" may simply mean "a huge number" (Mark 5:9 itself explains: "for we are many"). Commentators such as R. T. France and Joel Marcus accept at most a secondary echo.

in v13

Why did Jesus allow the spirits into the pigs, with the loss of the herd?

  • As visible proof that the exorcism succeeded.

    Ancient exorcism stories include visible signs of departure (Josephus, *Ant.* 8.46–49; Philostratus, *Life of Apollonius* 4.20). The herdsmen and town see the result (5:14–16).

  • To reveal what the spirits are like: they destroy whatever they inhabit.

    In the story, possession leads to self-harm in the man (5:5) and to death in the pigs. The narrative sets the worth of one restored person against the herd (compare 5:15–17).

  • The demons were outwitted, ending up in the deep they wanted to avoid.

    In Luke they beg not to be sent to "the abyss" (8:31), yet end in the sea, a biblical image of the deep. Mark does not say what happened to the spirits themselves, so this remains an inference.

in v13

Were the pig owners Jews breaking the Law, so that the loss was a judgment on them?

  • Possibly. Some Jews lived in the region, and later rabbinic law forbade raising pigs.

    The Mishnah (Bava Qamma 7:7) prohibits Jews from raising pigs. Some older commentators read the loss as punishment.

  • Unlikely. The text gives no sign of it.

    The setting is the Decapolis, a Gentile region (5:20). Mark never mentions the owners' identity or any wrongdoing, and Jesus rebukes no one. The Mishnah is also later than Mark.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).