Acts Chapter 1 Read as one passage
Acts 1:21–22
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
21Therefore it is necessary to choose one of the men who have accompanied us the whole time the Lord Jesus went in and out among us, 22beginning from John’s baptism until the day Jesus was taken up from us. For one of these must become a witness with us of His resurrection.”
What the first hearers heard
For Luke's first readers, this verse sets out what made the Twelve's testimony reliable. The men who founded the community were not people with private visions. They had walked the roads with Jesus through his whole public life, and they could say that the one raised from the dead was the same man they had known from the Jordan to the Mount of Olives.
It also told them that the community started out obeying Scripture and keeping its structure intact. The Twelve, the sign of a restored Israel, were made whole again before the Spirit came, and the choice followed scriptural necessity ("must"), clear eyewitness criteria, prayer, and finally the casting of lots, which left the decision with God (1:24–26).
Jewish hearers would also have caught the old leadership language in "went in and went out", the language of Moses, Joshua and David. It quietly presents Jesus as the shepherd-leader who had gone before his people. Whether Luke meant the specific echo of Joshua (the same name as Jesus) in Num 27:17 is uncertain.
From the study of Acts 1:21.
Verse by verse
-
21Therefore it is necessary to choose one of the men who have accompanied us the whole time the Lord Jesus went in and out among us,
Full study →"So then, since Scripture must be fulfilled and another must take Judas's place, it has to be one of the men who travelled with us as part of our company the whole time, through the entire public life the Lord Jesus lived among us and at our head, all his comings and goings…" (the sentence goes on in v. 22: "…from John's baptism to the day he was taken up from us. One of these must become, with us, a witness to his resurrection.")
Three things are packed in here:
- "Must" is not just practical. In Luke's writing this word marks what God's plan requires, and it repeats the "had to be fulfilled" of v. 16. Choosing a replacement is presented as obeying Scripture, not as reorganising.
- "Accompanied us" means men who were literally on the road with the group, sharing its life, not occasional listeners. The pool is narrow on purpose.
- "Went in and went out" is an old Hebrew way of describing a person's whole active public life, used of leaders like Moses, Joshua and David who "went out and came in before the people". Peter means: he must have seen all of Jesus' ministry, start to finish, with no gaps. The point of the rule is that the new man can testify from his own eyes that the risen Lord is the same Jesus they knew.
-
22beginning from John’s baptism until the day Jesus was taken up from us. For one of these must become a witness with us of His resurrection.”
Full study →Peter's sentence runs from verse 21 into verse 22: "So it is necessary that, out of the men who travelled with us the whole time the Lord Jesus came and went among us, starting from the time John was baptizing, right up to the day he was taken up from us, one of these men become, together with us, a witness to his rising from the dead."
Each part carries weight:
- "It is necessary" (v.21) is Luke's word for what God's plan requires. Verse 16 uses the same word for Scripture having to be fulfilled. Filling the gap is not office management. Something in God's purpose requires twelve.
- "Starting from John's baptism… until the day he was taken up" marks out the whole public story of Jesus, from the Jordan to the ascension. The candidate must have been there for all of it, so that he can testify that the risen one is the same Jesus they followed.
- "Taken up" uses the language of Elijah being taken into heaven. Those who saw it happen are the ones who stand in line to carry on the work.
- "A witness" means a qualified eyewitness, someone able to say in a court of public opinion, "I saw this." It is not yet "martyr", and it is not general evangelism.
- "His resurrection" means Jesus literally standing up alive, in the body, after death. It is a public, physical event that can be testified to, not a spiritual idea.
- "With us… one of these": exactly one man joins the eleven so that a complete body of twelve can testify together.
Where the English drifted
-
in v21
went in and out among us
eisēlthen kai exēlthen eph' hēmas
- What we hear
- Jesus came and went, dropping in and out of the disciples' lives, or literally entering and leaving places.
- What they heard
- A Hebrew-style idiom for a person's whole active public life, often a leader's life lived before and at the head of his people (Num 27:17; 1 Sam 18:16). Here it means Jesus' entire ministry as he led his followers.
-
in v21
it is necessary
dei
- What we hear
- A practical need: the group has a vacancy and should fill it.
-
in v22
a witness
martys
- What we hear
- In church use, "witnessing" often means evangelism: sharing your faith or your personal story of conversion. Some readers also hear "martyr" behind the Greek word.
- What they heard
- A legal-style eyewitness: someone who personally saw the events and can testify to them as fact. Here the qualification is having been physically present from John's baptism to the ascension.
-
in v22
resurrection
anastasis
- What we hear
- Many people hear life after death in general, or the soul surviving and going to heaven.
- What they heard
- A dead body standing up alive again. In Jewish belief this was a physical event, and it was argued over between Pharisees and Sadducees.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v21
Matthias wasn't a mistake that Paul fixed
- What's often taught
- Peter acted hastily before Pentecost: the Eleven chose Matthias by their own method, Matthias disappears from the story, and God's real twelfth apostle was Paul.
- What the text supports
Luke frames the choice as divine necessity, not haste. The same word, dei ('must'), marks Judas's fall as fulfilling Scripture (1:16) and the replacement as required (1:21–22), following Ps 109:8 ('let another take his office', 1:20). The group prays to the Lord 'who knows the hearts' and leaves the outcome to the lot (1:24–26), a recognised way of letting God decide (Prov 16:33). Afterwards Matthias is 'numbered with the eleven', and 'the Twelve' act together (6:2).
The criteria in this verse also rule Paul out: the twelfth man must have travelled with the group the whole time Jesus 'went in and out' among them, from John's baptism to the ascension (1:22). Paul never did. Luke keeps Paul's role distinct, calling him a 'witness' chosen separately (22:15; 26:16) and almost never an 'apostle' (only 14:4, 14, with Barnabas).
What the popular reading gets right: Matthias is not mentioned again, and Paul does call himself an apostle in his letters. But silence about Matthias proves little, since most of the Twelve are never mentioned again either. Paul's apostleship is real in its own way, but it is not the twelfth place among the Twelve.
- Where the English feeds it
- Translations that render *dei* as plain 'it is necessary', or that add 'to choose', can make the scene sound like an administrative decision rather than the scriptural 'must' Luke intends. Translations that blur 'went in and out' also obscure how specific the eyewitness requirement was.
δεῖ dei εἰσέρχομαι eiserchomai ἐξέρχομαι exerchomai συνέρχομαι synerchomai
in v22
Was Matthias a mistake? This verse says no
- What's often taught
- The apostles acted too soon in choosing Matthias by lot, before the Spirit came. God's real choice for the twelfth apostle was Paul, which is why Matthias is never mentioned again.
- What the text supports
The verse sets a qualification that Paul could not meet: being with Jesus' followers from John's baptism to the ascension (v.21–22). Paul accepts this distinction himself. In Acts 13:31 he points to "those who came up with him from Galilee to Jerusalem" as "his witnesses" and does not include himself. In 1 Cor 15:5–8 he lists "the Twelve" separately from his own later sight of the risen Jesus. He describes his calling as apostle to the Gentiles (Gal 2:7–9; Rom 11:13), not as a seat among the Twelve.
Luke gives no sign of disapproval. The group prays to the Lord who "knows all hearts" to show his choice (1:24). Casting lots was an accepted way of leaving a decision to God (Lev 16:8; Prov 16:33). Straight afterwards Luke counts the group as full: Matthias "was added to the eleven apostles" (1:26), and Peter stands "with the eleven" at Pentecost (2:14), which makes twelve, as does "the Twelve" in 6:2. Most of the original Twelve are never mentioned again after Acts 1:13 either, so Matthias's silence proves nothing.
The popular view does get one thing right: Paul's role in Acts is enormous and his apostleship is real. The text simply presents it as a different calling from membership in the Twelve.
- Where the English feeds it
- Not much. The KJV's supplied "must one be ordained" can make the scene sound like a human church procedure, which may encourage the idea that it was a merely human decision. But the misreading mostly comes from preaching, not from translation.
μάρτυς martys ἀναλαμβάνω analambanō ἀνάστασις anastasis ἄρχω archō
Every word
-
δεῖ
dei · G1163
it is necessary, must · v21
Opens the sentence with the weight of necessity. In Luke and Acts this word regularly marks what has to happen because God has planned it or Scripture has said it, and it picks up 'the Scripture had to be fulfilled' (same verb) in 1:16. The thing that 'must' happen is only stated in v. 22: one of these men must become a witness.
-
οὖν
oun · G3767
therefore, so · v21
Draws the conclusion from the Psalm texts just quoted in v. 20 ('let another take his office'): since Scripture says another must take Judas's place, here is who qualifies.
-
τῶν
tōn · G3588
the · v21, v22
Article tying the following participle to 'men': 'the men who came along with us'. The whole phrase is in the genitive case meaning 'out of / from among', and it is picked up in v. 22 by 'one of these'.
-
συνελθόντων
synelthontōn · G4905
to come together; to go along with, accompany · v21
Here not 'assemble' but 'travel along with, be part of the company'. It describes men who walked the roads with Jesus' band, as Luke uses the same verb of the women 'who had come with him from Galilee' (Luke 23:55). The past-tense participle looks at their accompanying as a completed fact.
-
ἡμῖν
hēmin · G3165
us (to/with us) · v21, v22
'With us', meaning Peter and the remaining Eleven. The qualifying men must have been with the core group, not merely followers at a distance.
-
ἀνδρῶν
andrōn · G0435
man, male; husband · v21
Specifically adult males, not the general word for 'people' (that would be anthrōpos). Peter has just addressed the gathering as 'men, brothers' (1:16), even though women were present (1:14). The replacement is for a place among the Twelve, whose number matches the twelve sons of Israel.
-
ἐν
en · G1722
in, during · v21
'During': it marks the stretch of time the candidate must have spent with the group.
-
παντὶ
panti · G3956
all, every, whole · v21
'The whole' time. This is the heart of the requirement: being with the group without a gap, from start to finish. Verse 22 spells out the start and end points.
-
χρόνῳ
chronō · G5550
time, period · v21
A span of time, here Jesus' public ministry. It is the ordinary word for duration, with no special religious meaning.
-
ᾧ
hō · G3739
which, that · v21, v22
'In which'. The relative pronoun stands alone with 'in' understood, a normal Greek shortcut that some editions fill out with a second ἐν.
-
εἰσῆλθεν
eisēlthen · G1525
to go in, enter · v21
First half of the pair 'went in and went out'. Taken together the two verbs are a Hebrew-style idiom for a person's whole active life and public work, often a leader's (see the studies), not literally entering and leaving rooms.
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v21
Links the two verbs into one fixed expression.
-
ἐξῆλθεν
exēlthen · G1831
to go out, depart · v21
Second half of the idiom. 'In and out' together cover the whole of Jesus' daily public life and activity with his followers.
-
ἐφ᾽
eph' · G1909
upon, over, among, toward · v21
An unusual preposition for this idiom. Most translations take it as 'among us'. Some scholars hear 'over us', that is, Jesus coming and going at their head as leader, which fits the leadership use of the idiom in the Old Testament.
-
κύριος
kyrios · G2962
lord, master, owner; in the Greek Old Testament, the stand-in for God's name · v21
Peter speaks of Jesus, now risen and taken up, as 'the Lord'. In Acts this is the main title for the exalted Jesus (2:36, 'God has made him both Lord and Christ'). The same word stood for God's own name in the Greek Scriptures, though in this phrase it is chiefly a title of honour and authority.
-
Ἰησοῦς
Iēsous · G2424
Jesus (Greek form of Yeshua/Joshua) · v21
The personal name of the one whose earthly ministry the candidate must have witnessed. The phrase 'the Lord Jesus' joins the exalted title to the man the disciples walked with on the road.
-
ἀρξάμενος
arxamenos · G0757
begin; be first · v22
"Beginning". It is singular and masculine, so it grammatically fits "the Lord Jesus" at the end of v.21 (Jesus, starting from John's baptism). Luke also uses it as an almost fixed phrase, "starting from…", to mark where an account begins (compare Luke 24:47; Acts 10:37).
-
ἀπὸ
apo · G0575
from · v22
Marks where the span of time begins: the start of the period the candidate must have been present for.
-
βαπτίσματος
baptismatos · G0908
baptism, immersion · v22
John's ritual of immersion in the Jordan, and by extension the whole movement and period of John's preaching, the setting in which Jesus first appeared in public.
-
Ἰωάννου
Iōannou · G2491
John · v22
John the Baptizer, not the apostle John. "John's baptism" was a recognised label for his movement (Luke 7:29; 20:4; Acts 18:25).
-
ἕως
heōs · G2193
until, as far as · v22
Marks the end of the span. The candidate must have been there for the whole story, from start to finish.
-
ἡμέρας
hēmeras · G2250
day · v22
A real calendar day, the day of the ascension. It ties the qualification to an event that could be dated.
-
ἀνελήμφθη
anelēmphthē · G0353
take up, receive up · v22
"He was taken up". The passive suggests God is the one who takes him, and the verb repeats the language used for Elijah being taken into heaven (2 Kings 2:9–11 in the Greek Old Testament). Luke uses it again in Acts 1:2 and 1:11.
-
μάρτυρα
martyra · G3144
witness · v22
An eyewitness who can testify, someone able to say "I was there and I saw". This is the job being filled. It is not yet the later sense "martyr".
-
ἀναστάσεως
anastaseōs · G0386
resurrection, rising up · v22
Literally a "standing up again". It means Jesus' bodily return from death, which is the core of what the witness will testify to.
-
αὐτοῦ
autou · G0846
his · v22
Refers back to "the Lord Jesus" in v.21.
-
σὺν
syn · G4862
with, together with · v22
"Together with" the eleven. The new man joins a group that testifies together, rather than becoming a lone voice.
-
γενέσθαι
genesthai · G1096
become, come to be · v22
"To become". It depends on "it is necessary" (dei) in v.21: one of these men must come to hold this role. It describes a change of status, not something already true of him.
-
ἕνα
hena · G1520
one · v22
Exactly one. The aim is to bring the number back to twelve, not to add an open-ended number of witnesses.
-
τούτων
toutōn · G3778
of these · v22
"Of these" men, picking up "the men who accompanied us" at the start of v.21. The word for men there (andrōn) means males specifically.
The world behind it
Why replace Judas at all? Jesus had chosen twelve, matching the twelve sons of Jacob and the twelve tribes of Israel, and promised that they would "sit on thrones judging the twelve tribes of Israel" (Luke 22:30). For a Jewish group expecting God to restore Israel (Acts 1:6, "will you at this time restore the kingdom to Israel?"), a broken Twelve was a broken sign. The number is restored just before Pentecost, when the message goes out first to Jews "from every nation" (2:5). Later, when the apostle James is killed (12:2), no one replaces him: the issue with Judas was his defection, not his death.
What the requirements mean. The candidate had to have been with the group from John's baptism to the ascension (v. 22). That is the same outline as the early preaching about Jesus (Acts 10:37–41) and matches Luke's own claim to rely on "those who from the beginning were eyewitnesses" (Luke 1:2). In a world where testimony carried weight only from people who had seen for themselves (compare Deut 19:15 on witnesses), the Twelve's role was to vouch for the whole story: the ministry, the death, and the resurrection of the same person.
Disciples as travelling companions. Teachers in that world, Jewish and Greek alike, often had pupils who lived and travelled with them, learning from their conduct as well as their words. Jesus' group was wider than the Twelve (Luke 8:1–3; 10:1, the seventy-two), so there were other men who had been there throughout. Two are named in v. 23.
From the study of Acts 1:21.
Where scholars differ
in v21
Does ἐφ᾽ ἡμᾶς mean 'among us' or 'over us'?
-
'Among us': Jesus lived his public life in the disciples' company.
Most translations and the Vulgate (inter nos). ἐπί with the accusative can loosely mean 'among, with' in Koine Greek, and the context is about companionship.
-
'Over us / at our head': Jesus came and went as their leader.
The Old Testament idiom 'go out and come in' is mostly about leaders before their people (Num 27:17; 1 Sam 18:13, 16), and ἐπί often has the sense 'over' for authority. Commentators such as Barrett note the oddness of the preposition and allow this nuance.
in v21
Did Peter and the Eleven act rightly in choosing Matthias?
-
Luke presents the choice as approved by God.
The 'must' of divine necessity (1:16, 21), the appeal to Scripture (1:20), prayer to the Lord who knows hearts (1:24), the lot (1:26; compare Prov 16:33), and Matthias 'numbered with the eleven apostles' (1:26). 'The Twelve' then act as a body (6:2). This is the view of most modern commentators (e.g. Fitzmyer, Johnson, Barrett).
-
The choice was premature; God's intended replacement was Paul.
Matthias is never mentioned again; the action came before the Spirit was given; Paul calls himself an apostle. Critics of this view answer that most of the Twelve are never mentioned again either, that Paul could not meet the criteria in 1:21–22, and that Luke almost never calls Paul an 'apostle' (only 14:4, 14, jointly with Barnabas).
in v22
Does "the baptism of John" mean the moment Jesus was baptized, or the whole period of John's ministry?
-
It means Jesus' own baptism by John, the event that launched his public ministry.
Luke 3:21–23 places Jesus' baptism at the start of his ministry "when he was about thirty". Acts 10:37–38 links the beginning to God anointing Jesus with the Spirit, which Luke places at the baptism.
-
It means the era of John's baptizing movement, the time and setting in which Jesus began.
"John's baptism" usually names John's movement as a whole (Luke 7:29; 20:4; Acts 18:25; 19:3). Acts 10:37 says "after the baptism *that John preached*". John 1:35–42 has some of Jesus' first followers coming from John's circle.
in v22
Do these criteria define all apostles, or only the Twelve?
-
Only the Twelve. Luke separates this founding eyewitness group from other "apostles" or witnesses such as Paul.
In Acts 13:31 Paul himself names "those who came up with him from Galilee" as "his witnesses to the people" and does not count himself among them. 1 Cor 15:5–8 lists "the Twelve" separately from Paul, who saw the risen Jesus "last of all". Paul is called a witness in Acts 22:15 and 26:16, but of what he saw on the Damascus road, not of the whole ministry.
-
Luke's criteria show how he understands "apostle" in general, which is why he rarely uses the title for Paul.
Luke calls Paul and Barnabas "apostles" only in Acts 14:4, 14, probably in the sense of envoys sent by the Antioch church (13:1–3). Elsewhere in Acts "the apostles" consistently means the Jerusalem group. Paul's letters, by contrast, insist strongly that he is an apostle (Gal 1:1; 1 Cor 9:1).
Sources
- BDAG s.v. δεῖ
- BDAG s.v. συνέρχομαι
- BDAG s.v. ἐπί
- BDAG s.v. εἰσέρχομαι / ἐξέρχομαι
- Septuagint: Num 27:17; Deut 31:2; 1 Sam 18:13, 16; 1 Kgs 3:7; Ps 121(120):8
- C. K. Barrett, Acts (ICC), vol. 1
- J. A. Fitzmyer, The Acts of the Apostles (Anchor Bible)
- L. T. Johnson, The Acts of the Apostles (Sacra Pagina)
- F. F. Bruce, The Acts of the Apostles: Greek Text
- C. H. Cosgrove, 'The Divine ΔΕΙ in Luke-Acts', Novum Testamentum 26 (1984)
- Vulgate, Acts 1:21
- BDAG s.v. μάρτυς, ἀνάστασις, ἀναλαμβάνω, ἄρχω, βάπτισμα
- Blass–Debrunner–Funk, A Greek Grammar of the New Testament (on stereotyped ἀρξάμενος)
- H. Strathmann, "μάρτυς", TDNT vol. 4
- A. A. Trites, The New Testament Concept of Witness (Cambridge, 1977)
- J. A. Fitzmyer, The Acts of the Apostles (Anchor Yale Bible)
- D. L. Bock, Acts (Baker Exegetical Commentary on the NT)
- C. S. Keener, Acts: An Exegetical Commentary, vol. 1
- Septuagint 4 Kingdoms (2 Kings) 2:9–11; Sirach 48:9
- Josephus, Antiquities 18.116–119; Jewish War 2.163
- Martyrdom of Polycarp (development of 'martyr' sense)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).