Daniel Chapter 5 Read as one passage
Daniel 5:15–16
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
15Now the wise men and enchanters were brought before me to read this inscription and interpret it for me, but they could not give its interpretation. 16But I have heard about you, that you are able to give interpretations and solve difficult problems. Therefore, if you can read this inscription and give me its interpretation, you will be clothed in purple and have a gold chain placed around your neck, and you will be made the third highest ruler in the kingdom.”
What the first hearers heard
For the Jewish readers of Daniel, living under foreign empires, this line confirms a theme the book keeps returning to: the most prestigious knowledge system of the world's greatest empire cannot read a message from Israel's God. The Babylonian scholars were famous; their omen literature and incantation lore made up a huge and respected tradition. Here the king himself, in his own words, admits that all of it came to nothing.
The verse also gets the scene ready. By saying "they could not," the king opens the space for Daniel, a deportee from Judah, to do what the empire's experts could not. The point is not that Daniel is cleverer. The book insists that interpretation comes from "the spirit of the gods" in him (v.14) and, more exactly, from the God who "reveals mysteries" (2:28). For a people in exile, the story taught that real knowledge of history's direction, including the fall of their oppressors, belonged to their God and was given to his faithful servants, not to the court that held them captive.
From the study of Daniel 5:15.
Verse by verse
-
15Now the wise men and enchanters were brought before me to read this inscription and interpret it for me, but they could not give its interpretation.
Full study →The king turns from praising Daniel to the crisis itself: "So here is where things stand. My court experts, the official scholars and the incantation priests whose trade is handling omens, were summoned into my presence to read this writing aloud and to unlock its meaning for me. They could not. They were unable to produce the solution of the matter."
A few things are packed into the wording. "Were brought in" is passive: they were ordered in, and the whole professional establishment came. The two titles stand side by side with no "and" between them ("the wise men, the enchanters"), as if to say the entire guild. There are two tasks: say the words aloud, then give their pəšar, the decoding of a hidden sign into its fixed, real meaning, normally a message about what is about to happen. The word for "interpretation" comes twice, because the decoding is the whole point. "They were not able" uses a participle that describes a condition, not a refusal: they lacked the ability. The same verb comes back in the next verse, "you are able," so the king's report of failure sets up Daniel's opening. "The matter" (millah) means both "the words" and "the affair": both the message on the wall and what its appearance means for the king and his kingdom stayed closed to Babylon's best minds.
-
16But I have heard about you, that you are able to give interpretations and solve difficult problems. Therefore, if you can read this inscription and give me its interpretation, you will be clothed in purple and have a gold chain placed around your neck, and you will be made the third highest ruler in the kingdom.”
Full study →"And I, the king, have heard about you. They say you can crack the hidden meaning of signs and dreams and untie knots: riddles tied too tight for anyone else to loosen, perhaps even the bindings of spells. So now: if you can read this writing aloud and make its hidden meaning known to me, you will be robed in royal purple, the costly dyed garment of a high officer of state. The gold torque of honor will be placed on your neck. And you will hold real power as 'the third' in the kingdom."
Behind the words:
- The emphatic "I." Belshazzar sets himself against his failed experts (5:15). He knows Daniel only by reputation.
- The interpreting language ("interpret interpretations… untie knots") comes from a root that means "loosen." Daniel is presented as the one who unbinds sealed meanings.
- The offer is an investiture, not a tip. Robe, collar and rank are the recognized signs of promotion at a Near Eastern court, the same pattern as Pharaoh raising Joseph (Genesis 41:42).
- "Third" probably reflects that Belshazzar was himself second, acting king under his absent father Nabonidus. It may also be a formal title, "one of the three."
- The king is offering power in a kingdom that will fall that same night. Daniel will turn the gifts down (5:17), receive them anyway (5:29), and outlive the king who gave them (5:30).
Where the English drifted
-
in v15
astrologers (KJV)
ʾāšəp̄ayyāʾ
- What we hear
- Horoscope-casters who read the stars to tell fortunes.
- What they heard
- Incantation priests or exorcists (Akkadian āšipu), ritual specialists who recited spells to ward off demons and the evil predicted by omens.
-
in v15
wise men
ḥakkîmayyāʾ
- What we hear
- Thoughtful, sensible people known for good judgment.
- What they heard
- A job title: the king's official body of scholars and diviners, the professional experts in signs and texts.
-
in v15
interpretation
pəšar
- What we hear
- One person's reading or opinion of what something means.
- What they heard
- The single, real solution of a hidden sign, normally revealing what is about to happen. It is unlocked, not proposed.
-
in v16
dissolve doubts (KJV, WEB)
qiṭrîn lemishrē'
- What we hear
- Removing someone's mental or spiritual uncertainty, like a counsellor or apologist.
- What they heard
- 'Untying knots': solving intractable riddles and hard cases, possibly with an overtone of undoing magical bindings.
-
in v16
purple / scarlet
'argewān
- What we hear
- A color of clothing, a nice gift.
- What they heard
- A garment dyed with very expensive murex dye, worn by royalty and officers of state. Putting it on meant being installed in high office.
-
in v16
a chain of gold
hamnîkhā'
- What we hear
- A piece of jewelry, a valuable reward.
- What they heard
- A gold torque or collar, a Persian-style insignia of royal favor and rank, worn so that everyone could see it.
-
in v16
third highest ruler
taltā'
- What we hear
- Number three in a ranking, like third in line to the throne.
- What they heard
- Either the highest available post under a king who was himself second, or a formal office title ('one of the three' or 'third officer').
Every word
-
וּכְעַ֞ן
ukhəʿan · H3705
and now · v15, v16
A speech marker that moves from flattering Daniel (v.14) to the business at hand: 'So, here is the situation.'
-
הֻעַ֣לּוּ
huʿallu · H5954
were brought in · v15
A passive causative form, 'they were made to come in.' The experts did not drop by; they were summoned into the royal presence (compare v.8, 'all the king's wise men came in').
-
קָֽדָמַ֗י
qodamay · H6925
before me · v15
'In front of me,' the normal court phrase for standing in audience before a king. The king puts himself at the centre of the failed consultation.
-
חַכִּֽימַיָּא֙
ḥakkîmayyāʾ · H2445
the wise men · v15
Not 'wise people' in general but the professional class of royal scholars and diviners, the court's official experts in signs, texts and omens.
-
אָֽשְׁפַיָּ֔א
ʾāšəp̄ayyāʾ · H0826
the enchanters · v15
Set beside 'the wise men' with no 'and,' as a further label for the same group: incantation specialists, a loanword from Akkadian āšipu, the ritual expert who recited spells against evil and ill omens.
-
דִּֽי־
di- · H1768
that, so that · v15, v16
Introduces the purpose of summoning them: so that they would read.
-
כְתָבָ֤ה
kətāḇāh · H3792
the writing · v15, v16
The writing the hand had traced on the plaster wall (v.5). The word means anything written: inscription, document, script.
-
דְנָה֙
dənāh · H1836
this · v15
'This writing.' The king may be pointing at it; it is still on the wall in front of everyone.
-
יִקְר֔וֹן
yiqrôn · H7123
they should read (aloud) · v15, v16
To read out, to say aloud what is written. Reading in the ancient world was normally voiced, so the first task was simply to say the words.
-
וּפִשְׁרֵ֖הּ
ûp̄išrēh · H6591
and its interpretation · v15, v16
The 'solution' or decoding of the writing: what the sign means and what it says will happen.
-
לְהוֹדָעֻתַ֑נִי
ləhôdāʿutanî · H3046
to make known to me · v15, v16
Causative 'to cause me to know.' The king wants to receive knowledge he cannot reach himself; the stress falls on 'me.'
-
וְלָֽא־
wəlāʾ- · H3809
and not · v15
Flat negation, the turn of the verse: 'but not.'
-
כָהֲלִ֥ין
kāhălîn · H3546
able · v15
A participle, 'were not able / are not able.' It describes a state of incapacity, not unwillingness. The same verb comes back in v.16, 'you are able,' setting up the contrast with Daniel.
-
מִלְּתָ֖א
millətāʾ · H4406
the word, the matter · v15
Both 'the word' (the words on the wall) and 'the affair' (the whole event). Either way, its meaning stayed closed to them.
-
לְהַחֲוָיָֽה׃
ləhaḥăwāyāh · H2324
-
וַאֲנָה֙
wa'ănāh · H0576
and I · v16
An emphatic 'I' that the verb doesn't need. The king sets himself apart: 'my experts failed, but I have heard about you.' YLT's 'and I — I' keeps the emphasis.
-
שִׁמְעֵ֣ת
shim'ēt · H8086
to hear · v16
'I have heard.' Belshazzar knows Daniel only by report, from the queen's speech in 5:11–12. Daniel is a stranger to this king, though he was well known to Nebuchadnezzar.
-
עֲלָ֔ךְ
'ălākh · H5922
upon, about · v16
'About you' or 'concerning you,' the subject of the report.
-
תִיכּ֥וּל
tukhal (written tikkul) · H3202
to be able · v16
'You are able, you have the power to.' It describes an ability Daniel is known to have.
-
לְמִפְשַׁ֖ר
lemifshar · H6590
to interpret · v16
The verb from the same root, so the phrase reads 'to interpret interpretations.' The root's basic sense of 'loosening, solving' sets up the next phrase.
-
וְקִטְרִ֣ין
weqiṭrîn · H7001
knot, joint · v16
'And knots.' The word means things tied or bound, here used as a picture of tangled riddles and puzzles. It may also hint at magical 'bindings'.
-
לְמִשְׁרֵ֑א
lemishrē' · H8271
to loose, untie · v16
'To untie.' Together with 'knots' it is the stock phrase from 5:12 for someone who can undo any bound-up, baffling problem.
-
הֵן֩
hēn · H2006
if (Aramaic); lo (Hebrew) · v16
In Aramaic this word means 'if' and introduces a condition. YLT's 'lo' takes it in the Hebrew sense of 'look!', which misses the condition.
-
אַרְגְּוָנָ֣א
'argewānā' · H0711
purple (cloth) · v16
'The purple,' meaning a garment dyed with costly red-purple dye from sea snails. It marked royal or high official rank and was a uniform of honor, not a fashion choice.
-
תִלְבַּ֗שׁ
tilbash · H3848
to put on, wear · v16
'You will wear.' The verb is active, but the act is an investiture: being dressed in the robe of office.
-
וְהַֽמְנִיכָ֤א
wehamnîkhā' · H2002
necklace, collar · v16
'And the necklace,' a Persian loanword for a torque or collar. This was a recognized court decoration rather than ordinary jewelry.
-
דַהֲבָא֙
dahăvā' · H1722
-
צַוְּארָ֔ךְ
ṣawwə'rākh · H6676
neck · v16
'Your neck,' where the badge of rank would be seen by everyone.
-
וְתַלְתָּ֥א
wetaltā' · H8531
third; possibly 'triumvir' · v16
'And as third.' It names a rank. It could mean third in the realm (after Nabonidus and Belshazzar) or an official title, 'one of the three,' 'triumvir.' Scholars debate which.
-
בְמַלְכוּתָ֖א
bemalkhûtā' · H4437
kingdom, kingship, realm · v16
'In the kingdom,' meaning the Babylonian realm and its royal authority. The irony is that this kingdom will end that same night (5:30).
-
תִּשְׁלַֽט׃
tishlaṭ · H7981
to rule, have power · v16
'You will rule' or 'hold authority.' It comes from the root behind the later word 'sultan,' and it means real power to govern, not just an honorary title.
The world behind it
The court scholars. Neo-Babylonian kings kept a staff of specialists: omen-readers, astrologers, scribes and āšipu incantation priests. Their work was to notice signs from the gods, decode them, and carry out rituals to turn aside the evil those signs predicted. An unexplained sign appearing at a royal banquet was exactly their job. Total failure was a professional disgrace, and in the logic of the court it left the king without protection.
The night of the feast. Belshazzar (Bēl-šarra-uṣur) was the son of Nabonidus, the last Neo-Babylonian king, and ruled in Babylon while his father spent years at the oasis of Tayma in Arabia. That is why the reward offered in v.16 is the "third" rank in the kingdom: after Nabonidus and Belshazzar. Babylon fell to Cyrus of Persia in 539 BC. Daniel 5 places the writing on the wall on that last night (5:30).
A repeated pattern. Verse 15 is the king retelling to Daniel what the narrator already told us in v.8. Ancient storytelling uses such repetition on purpose. It is the third time in Daniel that Babylon's experts fail before a sign from Israel's God (2:10–11; 4:7; 5:8, 15) and the exiled Judean succeeds.
From the study of Daniel 5:15.
Where scholars differ
in v15
Why could the Babylonian experts not even read the writing?
-
The words were readable, but their meaning was hidden.
The words (mene, tekel, peres) are ordinary Aramaic terms for weights or money (mina, shekel, half-mina) and could be read as nouns. What made the message opaque was what a string of weights meant. Verse 15's stress on the failure to interpret fits this view.
-
The script or arrangement was unusual.
The Babylonian Talmud (Sanhedrin 22a) records rabbinic views that the letters were written in a cipher (such as atbash, which swaps letters from opposite ends of the alphabet) or in columns, so they could not be read in the normal direction. Others suggest a script unfamiliar to Babylonian scribes.
-
God kept them from reading, as a sign.
The narrative frame of Daniel (2:27–28; 5:11–14) presents understanding as a divine gift. Their inability belongs to the story's theology rather than to any technical problem, and the text gives no mechanism.
in v16
What does 'third' (taltā') in the kingdom mean?
-
Third in rank after Nabonidus and Belshazzar: the highest place the acting king could offer.
Cuneiform sources (Nabonidus Chronicle, Verse Account of Nabonidus) show that Nabonidus was the official king and Belshazzar governed Babylon in his place. A co-regent could not offer 'second.'
-
An official title: 'triumvir,' one of a board of three high officials, or 'third officer.'
The form varies (*talti*/*taltā'*) across 5:7, 5:16 and 5:29. Daniel 6:2–3 describes exactly three chief officials over the satraps. Hebrew *shalish* ('third man') became a general officer's title. Commentators such as Montgomery and Collins discuss this option.
-
A general expression for very high rank, not to be pressed precisely.
Court stories often use stylized honors. The robe, collar and rank pattern echoes Joseph without needing exact administrative detail.
in v16
Does 'untying knots' refer only to solving riddles, or also to undoing magic?
-
An idiom for solving hard problems and riddles.
The parallel with 'interpreting interpretations' and the queen's list in 5:12 (dreams, riddles, knots) point to intellectual and mantic skill, that is, skill in reading signs and omens.
-
It also carries the sense of undoing magical bindings or spells.
Mesopotamian anti-witchcraft texts (e.g. *Maqlû*) describe sorcery as tying knots and its cure as untying them. The same Semitic 'bind/loose' vocabulary is used of spells in later Aramaic incantation bowls and Arabic tradition. A king terrified by a supernatural sign would value both senses.
Sources
- HALOT (Aramaic section) s.v. פְּשַׁר, אָשַׁף, חַכִּים, כְּהַל
- BDB (Aramaic) s.v. עֲלַל, קְרָא, מִלָּה, חֲוָה
- CAD s.v. āšipu; pašāru
- John J. Collins, Daniel (Hermeneia), on Dan 5
- Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 22a
- Qumran Pesher Habakkuk (1QpHab)
- Paul-Alain Beaulieu, The Reign of Nabonidus, King of Babylon 556–539 B.C.
- HALOT (Aramaic section) s.v. פְּשַׁר, קְטַר, שְׁרָא, אַרְגְּוָן, הַמְנִיךְ, תַּלְתִּי, שְׁלֵט
- BDB (Biblical Aramaic) s.v. הֵן, קְטַר, הַמְנִיךְ
- J. J. Collins, Daniel (Hermeneia, 1993), on Dan 5:7, 12, 16, 29
- J. A. Montgomery, Daniel (ICC, 1927), on 'third ruler' and hamnikha
- J. Goldingay, Daniel (WBC 30)
- Nabonidus Chronicle (ABC 7) and the Verse Account of Nabonidus, on Belshazzar's regency
- Xenophon, Anabasis 1.2.27 (gold torque and Persian robe as royal gifts)
- Maqlû incantation series (knot-tying and loosing in Mesopotamian anti-witchcraft ritual)
- 1QpHab (Habakkuk Pesher), for 'pesher' as interpretation of mysteries
- Theodotion's Greek Daniel and the Vulgate, Dan 5:16
- Genesis 41:42; Esther 8:15; 1 Maccabees 10:20, 62; 14:43–44 (parallel investiture honors)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).