John Chapter 4 Read as one passage
John 4:20–24
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
20Our fathers worshiped on this mountain, but you Jews say that the place where one must worship is in Jerusalem.” 21“Believe Me, woman,” Jesus replied, “a time is coming when you will worship the Father neither on this mountain nor in Jerusalem. 22You worship what you do not know; we worship what we do know, for salvation is from the Jews. 23But a time is coming and has now come when the true worshipers will worship the Father in spirit and in truth, for the Father is seeking such as these to worship Him. 24God is Spirit, and His worshipers must worship Him in spirit and in truth.”
What the first hearers heard
For John's first readers, this verse put the Jewish–Samaritan rift in a single sentence that anyone in the region would recognise. Both peoples worshiped the God of Israel and both claimed the Torah, but they disagreed about where God had placed his name. That disagreement had produced rival temples, rival texts of scripture, a temple destroyed by a Jewish ruler, and generations of contempt.
The woman's words set up the contrast that runs through 4:20–24: this mountain against Jerusalem, our fathers against your claim, one sacred site against another. Readers would hear in her question the deep assumption both sides shared: God is properly met at one holy place he has chosen. That shared assumption is what Jesus' reply goes on to overturn ("neither on this mountain nor in Jerusalem," 4:21). He does still say that "salvation is from the Jews" (4:22).
For John's audience, writing in all likelihood after the Romans destroyed the Jerusalem Temple in AD 70, Jerusalem's Temple, like Gerizim's, now lay in ruins. The question "which place?" would have carried special weight. John has already presented Jesus himself as the true temple (2:19–21), and that background shapes how readers would hear this verse. The verse also shows the gospel moving across an old ethnic and religious boundary: the dispute is aired openly, between a Jewish man and a Samaritan woman, at Jacob's well.
From the study of John 4:20.
Verse by verse
-
20Our fathers worshiped on this mountain, but you Jews say that the place where one must worship is in Jerusalem.”
Full study →"Our ancestors, Abraham and Jacob and the generations after them, bowed down before God here, on this very mountain above us, Gerizim. But you Jews, as a people, insist that the one legitimate sanctuary, the Place God chose for his name, is in Jerusalem, and that worship has to be offered there and nowhere else, because God requires it."
The woman has just called Jesus a prophet (4:19). Now she puts to him the oldest and most bitter religious dispute between their two peoples. "Worship" here does not mean singing or private devotion. It means bowing before God at his chosen sanctuary, with the sacrifices and pilgrimage feasts that went with it. "The place" is not just a location. It echoes Deuteronomy's "the place the LORD will choose," the text both communities argued over. "Must" turns the question from preference into commandment. On one side stands the ancestors' practice on a mountain they can both see. On the other stands the Jewish claim, backed by books the Samaritans did not accept. A prophet, she implies, should be able to say which is right.
-
21“Believe Me, woman,” Jesus replied, “a time is coming when you will worship the Father neither on this mountain nor in Jerusalem.
Full study →Jesus answers her: "Trust me, ma'am. Take my word for it. The appointed hour is already on its way, the decisive moment God has set, when it will not be on this mountain (Gerizim, rising above the well, where your ancestors bowed down) and it will not be in Jerusalem (where the Jews insist the one true temple stands) that you people will bow down in worship before the Father."
A few things in the Greek do not come through easily in English:
- "Woman" is a courteous address, closer to "ma'am" than to the sharp "Woman!" of modern English. It is the same word Jesus uses for his own mother.
- "Believe me" is a real request to accept his word, and an unusual one. Jesus says it in the place where he normally says "Truly, truly." She has just called him a prophet, and he speaks as one.
- "The hour" is John's word for the time God has appointed, centred on Jesus' death and glorification. It means a decisive moment, not a vague "someday".
- "You will worship" is plural and future. It speaks about the Samaritans as a people, not just this one woman, and it assumes they will worship the Father.
- "Worship" means bowing low in homage, especially at a sanctuary. The question was where the true holy place is. Jesus' answer is that neither rival site will be the answer.
- "The Father" answers her "our fathers" (v. 20). The issue moves from which ancestors' mountain to the Father that worship is meant for.
Jesus does not declare a winner. He says that the time is coming when the question itself stops deciding anything. Verse 22 then goes on to affirm that "salvation is from the Jews", so this is not indifference to Israel's history. It is an announcement that something new is arriving.
-
22You worship what you do not know; we worship what we do know, for salvation is from the Jews.
Full study →"You Samaritans bow down before God in a worship you don't really understand. Your knowledge of him stops at the five books of Moses, and you have cut yourselves off from everything God revealed after them through the prophets and the psalms about Zion, David's line and his chosen house. We Jews bow down before a God we know, because he has made himself known among us. That is no accident: God's promised rescue, the deliverance and restoration he pledged to Israel and through Israel to the nations, comes out of the Jewish people. The Messiah you are waiting for comes from Judah."
Jesus says this as a Jew ("we"), sitting at a Samaritan well, after he has just told the woman that the dispute over Gerizim and Jerusalem is about to stop mattering (v.21). So the verse does two things. It honestly affirms that Israel's revelation, temple and Scriptures are where God's salvation comes from. It also clears the way for what follows (v.23): true worshipers, Jewish and Samaritan alike, will worship the Father "in spirit and truth." The "salvation" that comes from the Jews is standing in front of her (v.26: "I am he"), and a few days later her townspeople call him "the Savior of the world" (v.42).
-
23But a time is coming and has now come when the true worshipers will worship the Father in spirit and in truth, for the Father is seeking such as these to worship Him.
Full study →"But God's appointed hour is on its way, and in fact it is already here. In that hour the genuine worshipers, the real thing that all earlier worship pointed toward, will bow down in homage to the Father. They will do it not on this mountain or in that city but in spirit and truth: in the realm opened by God's own life-giving Spirit and in line with the reality of who God is, now made known in Jesus. For the Father himself is out looking for exactly this kind of people to be his worshipers."
Several things are packed into the wording:
- "An hour is coming and now is" is deliberately paradoxical. The new age of worship depends on Jesus' coming death and the gift of the Spirit, yet it is already present because Jesus is standing at the well.
- "Worship" means bowing low before a superior. In this conversation it means sanctuary worship with pilgrimage, sacrifice and a holy mountain. Jesus keeps the bowing and removes the dependence on a place.
- "True" means genuine, real, as in "true light", "true bread", "true vine". It is not mainly a charge of insincerity against either Jews or Samaritans.
- "In spirit and truth" sits under one "in". It is a single answer to the woman's question of where to worship. It is not two ingredients, emotion and doctrine, to be balanced.
- "The Father is seeking" is in the present tense and active. The verse ends with God as the one searching for worshipers, not people searching for the right place to find God.
-
24God is Spirit, and His worshipers must worship Him in spirit and in truth.”
Full study →"What God is, is Spirit. So for those who bow before him in homage, it cannot be otherwise: their worship must happen in the realm of Spirit and truth."
Jesus starts with God's nature and puts the word Spirit first for emphasis. God is not a local deity attached to a holy mountain. He is living, life-giving Spirit: unseen breath and power that no sanctuary can contain. This is not a philosophy lecture about God having no body (though he does not). It answers the woman's question, Which mountain is the right place?
The word translated worship means bowing down, lowering oneself in homage before a greater one. It covered everything Jews and Samaritans did at their sanctuaries. Jesus keeps the homage but changes its setting. The worshipper's "place" is now in spirit and truth. One small word "in" covers both nouns, so they describe one combined sphere rather than two separate ingredients:
- Spirit: the same word used for God himself. Worship matches the God being worshipped. In John's Gospel this is God's own Spirit, who gives new birth and life and is given through Jesus.
- Truth: the reality of God as he has now actually made himself known, which John identifies with Jesus ("grace and truth came through Jesus Christ"; "I am the truth"). It contrasts with worshipping "what you do not know" (v. 22). It still carries the Old Testament sense of wholehearted faithfulness.
Must describes a necessity built into the way things are, not an extra rule. Given who God is, this is the only worship that fits him. It is the same divine "must" that sent Jesus "through Samaria" (4:4) to this conversation. The woman's reply hears this correctly as end-of-the-age talk: "I know Messiah is coming."
Where the English drifted
-
in v20
worshiped / to worship
proskyneō
- What we hear
- Taking part in a church service, singing praise songs, or feeling devotion inwardly, anywhere.
- What they heard
- Bowing low in homage before God at his sanctuary. This included the religious life of a holy site: pilgrimage, sacrifice and festival worship. That is why the question can be about which mountain is the right one.
-
in v20
the place
ho topos
- What we hear
- Any location, a suitable spot for religious activity.
- What they heard
- 'The Place': the one sanctuary God chose for his name to dwell (Deut 12:5). It was a technical term for the Temple, as in John 11:48 ('our place').
-
in v21
Woman
gynai
- What we hear
- A curt or dismissive address, as if Jesus were putting her in her place.
-
in v21, v22, v23, v24
worship
proskyneō
- What we hear
- Singing praise songs, the music part of a church service, or a general inner attitude of devotion.
- What they heard
- Bowing low in homage. In this context it means going to a sanctuary to bow before God, which is why the question is 'where'.
-
in v22
salvation
sōtēria
- What we hear
- An individual's personal ticket to heaven.
-
in v22
the Jews
Ioudaioi
- What we hear
- Followers of a religion distinct from Christianity, or, from other passages in John, Jesus' enemies.
- What they heard
- The Judean people of Jerusalem's temple and the full Scriptures, here set against the Samaritans. Jesus includes himself ("we"). No separate "Christianity" yet existed to contrast them with.
-
in v23, v24
in spirit
en pneumati
- What we hear
- Inwardly, sincerely, emotionally, with passion, as opposed to outward forms.
- What they heard
- Most likely the sphere created by God's own Spirit, the new 'where' of worship that replaces the holy mountain, in line with v. 24 'God is spirit' and John's teaching on the Spirit. Inner sincerity is included but is not the main contrast.
-
in v23
truth
alētheia
- What we hear
- Correct doctrine, accurate theology, or personal honesty.
-
in v23
true worshipers
alēthinoi proskynētai
- What we hear
- Sincere worshipers, the ones who really mean it, not hypocrites.
- What they heard
- Genuine, real worshipers: the final form that earlier worship anticipated, as in 'the true bread' versus the manna (6:32).
-
in v24
God is a Spirit (KJV)
pneuma ho theos
- What we hear
- God is one spirit among many, a ghost-like being; or a statement only about God having no body.
- What they heard
- Spirit is the kind of being God is: living, life-giving, not bound to any place. It describes his nature and is used here to show why no holy mountain can confine worship of him.
-
in v24
in truth
en alētheia
- What we hear
- With correct doctrine, or simply with honesty.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v23
'Spirit and truth' isn't heart plus head
- What's often taught
- Real worship needs a balance of two things: 'spirit', meaning heartfelt emotion and passion, and 'truth', meaning sound doctrine. Too much emotion without doctrine, or doctrine without passion, falls short of what Jesus requires.
- What the text supports
The reading is partly right: the passage cares about knowing whom you worship (v. 22) and about worship that is real rather than formal. But the wording points elsewhere.
- The question being answered is where to worship: Gerizim or Jerusalem (vv. 20–21). Jesus answers with a new 'where': one preposition, en, governs both nouns, 'in spirit-and-truth'. He is not giving two ingredients to be mixed.
- 'Spirit' is explained by v. 24, 'God is spirit'. The point is about God's nature and the Spirit he gives (John 3:5–8; 7:39; 14:17), not about human emotional intensity.
- 'Truth' in John is God's reality revealed in Jesus ('I am the truth', 14:6). That is much more than doctrinal accuracy, though it includes knowing God rightly.
- 'The hour is coming and now is' marks this as a new era God is bringing in, not a technique for better services.
So the verse is about worship made possible by God's Spirit and shaped by God's self-revelation in Jesus, now freed from any holy mountain.
- Where the English feeds it
- Lowercase 'spirit' invites readers to hear 'my inner feelings'. Many versions (KJV, BSB, NIV, NLT) add a second 'in' ('in spirit and in truth'), which makes the phrase sound like two separate requirements.
in v24
'In spirit and truth' isn't emotion plus doctrine
- What's often taught
- Worshipping 'in spirit' means worshipping with heartfelt passion and emotion, and 'in truth' means worshipping with sound doctrine. Healthy worship keeps the two in balance, because too much of either makes it lopsided.
- What the text supports
Part of this is right. True worship is not empty ritual, and v. 22 does stress knowing whom you worship. But the wording does not support a two-ingredient balance between feeling and theology.
- One 'in', one sphere. Greek has a single preposition governing both nouns (en pneumati kai alētheia). They describe one combined realm, not two dials to keep level.
- 'Spirit' is God's word, not a mood. The verse opens with 'God is pneuma' and then requires worship en pneumati: the worship matches the God. In John, pneuma is God's life-giving Spirit, the one who brings new birth (3:5–8) and gives life (6:63). Elsewhere John calls it 'the Spirit of truth' (14:17). It is never used for emotional intensity.
- 'Truth' is reality revealed in Jesus. In John, truth 'came through Jesus Christ' (1:17), and Jesus is the truth (14:6). Here it contrasts with worshipping 'what you do not know' (4:22), and the scene ends with Jesus saying 'I am he' (4:26).
- The actual contrast is place. The question was 'this mountain or Jerusalem?' Jesus' answer moves worship from a sacred location to the realm of God's Spirit and the reality revealed in his Son. The contrast is not between head and heart.
- Where the English feeds it
- Lowercase 'spirit' in the second half (KJV, BSB, ESV, NASB, NLT) makes it look like a different word from 'God is Spirit'. The repeated 'in spirit and in truth' (KJV, BSB, NLT) makes two separate items out of one phrase. The modern sense of 'worship' as church music then invites readers to map 'spirit' onto the band and 'truth' onto the sermon.
Every word
-
οἱ
hoi · G3588
the · v20, v21, v22, v23, v24
The definite article with 'fathers': not fathers in general but the known, named ancestors of her people.
-
πατέρες
pateres · G3962
fathers, ancestors · v20, v21, v23
Ancestors, especially the patriarchs. She has just called Jacob 'our father' (4:12), and Abraham and Jacob built altars at Shechem, right at the foot of this mountain (Gen 12:6–7; 33:18–20).
-
ἡμῶν
hēmōn · G3165
of us, our · v20, v21, v22
'Our', meaning we Samaritans. It sets up the contrast with the emphatic 'you' later in the sentence: our ancestors against your claim.
-
ἐν
en · G1722
in, on · v20, v21, v23, v24
'On' the mountain. It marks where the worship happened, and location is the whole point of her question.
-
ὄρει
orei · G3735
mountain · v20, v21
Mount Gerizim, which rose above Sychar and Jacob's well. For Samaritans it was the holy mountain chosen by God.
-
τούτῳ
toutō · G3778
this · v20, v21
A pointing word. She can practically gesture at the slope above them. Jesus repeats the same words, 'this mountain', in 4:21.
-
προσεκύνησαν
prosekynēsan · G4352
they worshiped, bowed down · v20, v21, v22, v23, v24
A past-tense verb summing up a long practice: our ancestors performed their worship here. The word means bowing low or lying face-down before a god at his sanctuary. It covers temple worship with its sacrifices and pilgrimage feasts, not just an inner attitude.
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v20, v23, v24
Literally 'and', but here it carries a contrast ('and yet', 'but'), setting the two claims side by side.
-
ὑμεῖς
hymeis · G4771
you (plural) · v20, v22
An emphatic plural 'you'. Greek can leave the pronoun out, so including it adds stress. She means 'you Jews' as a people, not Jesus alone. That is why BSB and WEB add 'Jews', a word that is implied but not written.
-
λέγετε
legete · G3004
you say · v20, v21
'You say' or 'you claim'. The present tense presents it as the ongoing official Jewish position, set against what 'our fathers' actually did.
-
ὅτι
hoti · G3754
that · v20, v21, v22
Introduces what the Jews claim.
-
Ἱεροσολύμοις
Hierosolymois · G2414
Jerusalem · v20, v21
The Greek form of the name, which John always uses. It means the city of the Temple on Mount Zion.
-
ἐστὶν
estin · G1510
is · v20, v22, v23
A flat statement of fact in the present tense: Jerusalem *is* the place. That is how she presents the Jewish claim.
-
τόπος
topos · G5117
place · v20
In Jewish usage 'the place' was shorthand for the sanctuary God had chosen (Deut 12:5; John 11:48). The word carries the whole question of which sanctuary is the legitimate one.
-
ὅπου
hopou · G3699
where · v20
'Where'. It connects the place to the worship that must happen there.
-
δεῖ
dei · G1163
it is necessary, must · v20, v24
'It is necessary' or 'one must'. This is not a matter of preference. It is a requirement grounded in God's command (Deut 12). Worshiping anywhere else would be illegitimate.
-
αὐτῇ
autē · G0846
to her · v21, v23, v24
The Samaritan woman of 4:7. In this conversation Jesus treats her as someone fit to discuss a disputed theological question.
-
Ἰησοῦς·
Iēsous · G2424
Jesus · v21
The Greek form of Yehoshua/Joshua. The speaker.
-
πίστευέ
pisteue · G4100
believe, trust · v21
A command in the present tense: 'trust me', 'take my word for this'. Here it means believing that a statement is true, but it also asks for confidence in the speaker. Nowhere else in the Gospels does Jesus say 'believe me' like this. His usual formula is 'Truly, truly, I say to you'.
-
γύναι,
gynai · G1135
-
ἔρχεται
erchetai · G2064
is coming · v21, v23
Present tense: the hour is already on its way. Two verses later Jesus sharpens this to 'is coming, and now is' (4:23).
-
ὥρα
hōra · G5610
-
ὅτε
hote · G3753
when · v21, v23
'When'. It introduces what will be true in that hour.
-
οὔτε
oute · G3777
neither · v21
First half of 'neither… nor'. Both sites in the dispute are set aside equally.
-
ὃ
ho · G3739
which, what · v22
Neuter, "what" rather than "whom." It puts the stress on the content of their worship — what they understand about the God they serve — more than on the person of God.
-
οὐκ
ouk · G3756
not · v22
Plain, factual negation: they do not know.
-
οἴδατε,
oidate · G6063
to know · v22
"You know." The form is perfect but works as a present: settled knowledge. The point is not that Samaritans know nothing of God; they lack the fuller revelation that came through Israel's prophets and Jerusalem.
-
σωτηρία
sōtēria · G4991
salvation, deliverance, rescue · v22
God's promised deliverance and restoration of his people, which in John means the life the Messiah brings. This is the only place the noun appears in John's Gospel.
-
ἐκ
ek · G1537
out of, from · v22
Source or origin: salvation comes out of the Jews. It does not say salvation belongs only to them. Four verses later the Samaritans call Jesus "Savior of the world" (4:42).
-
Ἰουδαίων
Ioudaiōn · G2453
Jew, Judean · v22
The people of Judah: the Israelites centred on Jerusalem and its temple, as opposed to the Samaritans, who also claimed to be Israel. Here it is a neutral, even positive, term for a people, not a label for Jesus' opponents.
-
ἀλλ᾽
all' · G0235
but · v23
A strong 'but, rather' that turns away from what Jesus has just said about Samaritan and Jewish worship (vv. 21–22) to something new that outranks both.
-
νῦν
nyn · G3568
now · v23
'Now': the future hope is already breaking in, because the one who brings it is standing at the well talking to her.
-
ἀληθινοὶ
alēthinoi · G0228
true, genuine, real · v23
'Genuine, real': the worshipers who match what worship was always meant to be, set against earlier forms that pointed toward it. It does not simply mean 'sincere'.
-
προσκυνηταὶ
proskynētai · G4353
worshiper · v23
Literally 'those who bow down / pay homage'. This noun occurs only here in the New Testament.
-
πνεύματι
pneumati · G4151G
spirit, breath, wind · v23, v24
No article, so 'in spirit'. In John's usage, and given 'God is spirit' in v. 24, it most naturally points to God's own life-giving Spirit as the new place of worship, not mainly to human feelings. Whether it means the Holy Spirit or the human spirit is debated.
-
ἀληθείᾳ·
alētheia · G0225
-
γὰρ
gar · G1063
for · v23
Gives the reason: true worship of this kind will happen because the Father himself is after it.
-
τοιούτους
toioutous · G5108
such, of this kind · v23
'Such people, of this kind': it describes what kind of worshipers the Father wants, namely those who worship in spirit and truth.
-
ζητεῖ
zētei · G2212
to seek, look for · v23
Present tense, 'is seeking, keeps looking for'. God is pictured as actively searching, and the scene itself shows it: Jesus has gone out of his way into Samaria to find this woman.
-
θεός
theos · G2316
God · v24
The God of Israel, whom Jesus has just called 'the Father' (vv. 21, 23). Greek needs no verb 'is' here; it is understood.
The world behind it
Where they were standing. Jesus and the woman are at Jacob's well near Sychar, close to ancient Shechem (4:5–6). Shechem sat in the pass between Mount Ebal to the north and Mount Gerizim to the south. "This mountain" was in plain view above them.
Why Gerizim. In the Torah, Gerizim is the mountain of blessing (Deut 11:29; 27:12). Shechem is where Abraham built his first altar in the land (Gen 12:6–7) and where Jacob built an altar and bought land (Gen 33:18–20). The Samaritan Pentateuch, the Samaritans' own text of the five books of Moses, goes further:
- It reads "Gerizim" in Deut 27:4, where the Jewish text has "Ebal", as the place for the altar. Some scholars think the Samaritan reading may preserve the older text.
- It adds a commandment after the Ten Commandments to build an altar on Gerizim.
- It reads "the place the LORD has chosen" throughout Deuteronomy, where the Jewish text has "will choose".
Why Jerusalem. The Torah never names Jerusalem. Its claim rests on later books: David's choice of the city, Solomon's Temple, and Psalms such as 78:68 and 132:13 ("the LORD has chosen Zion"). Samaritans accepted only the five books of Moses, so to them Jerusalem's claim rested on writings they did not recognise as scripture.
A history of hostility.
- A Samaritan temple stood on Gerizim from the Persian period (5th–4th century BC), according to excavations and Josephus.
- Josephus (Ant. 13.74–79) tells of Jews and Samaritans in Alexandria arguing this exact question, which temple Moses' law authorised, before King Ptolemy VI.
- The Jewish ruler John Hyrcanus destroyed the Gerizim temple around 112–111 BC (Ant. 13.254–256). By Jesus' day it had been rubble for more than a century, though Samaritans still worshiped on the mountain.
- Under the Roman governor Coponius (AD 6–9), Samaritans were said to have scattered human bones in the Jerusalem Temple to defile it (Ant. 18.29–30).
- Jewish texts call the Samaritans "the foolish people that live in Shechem" (Sirach 50:26). Jewish texts traced Samaritan origins to the foreign settlers of 2 Kings 17. Samaritans saw themselves as faithful descendants of the northern tribes and "keepers" of the Torah.
So when the woman says "our fathers… you say," she is speaking from inside centuries of competing scriptures, a destroyed temple and mutual contempt (compare 4:9, "Jews do not associate with Samaritans").
Prophet and question. Samaritans expected a coming figure, the Taheb ("one who returns" or "restorer"), modeled on the "prophet like Moses" of Deut 18:18. He would settle questions of true worship. That expectation helps explain why recognising Jesus as a prophet leads straight to this question, and then to the Messiah (4:25).
From the study of John 4:20.
Where scholars differ
in v20
Is the woman changing the subject to avoid Jesus' exposure of her marital history (4:16–18), or asking a sincere question?
-
Deflection: she moves from an uncomfortable personal topic to a safe, abstract religious controversy.
The topic changes abruptly right after Jesus reveals her five husbands. Many commentators, ancient and modern, read it as an evasive move.
-
A real theological question prompted by recognising a prophet.
In 4:19 she has just concluded that Jesus is a prophet. Samaritans expected a Moses-like prophet (the Taheb, Deut 18:18) to settle questions of true worship. The conversation then moves logically to the Messiah (4:25). Jesus does not rebuke her for dodging but answers her at length. Some scholars also question whether 4:16–18 is about her immorality at all. Widowhood, divorce initiated by husbands, or levirate marriage are possible.
-
Both: an awkward moment and a sincere question at the same time.
John often writes dialogue that works on several levels at once. The text does not say what she was thinking.
in v20
Who are 'our fathers' who worshiped on this mountain?
-
The patriarchs (Abraham, Jacob).
She has just called Jacob 'our father' (4:12). Abraham and Jacob built altars at Shechem (Gen 12:6–7; 33:20), and Samaritan tradition associated Gerizim with patriarchal events, including the binding of Isaac.
-
The Samaritan ancestors who worshiped at the Gerizim temple and continued to worship there.
'Fathers' can mean ancestors in general, and the temple stood on Gerizim from the Persian period until about 112 BC. The past tense may sum up that whole history.
-
Both together.
Samaritan self-understanding ran an unbroken line from the patriarchs to their own community. The two readings support each other more than they compete.
in v21
Is the woman's question about the mountain (4:20) a way of dodging the conversation about her husbands, or a sincere question?
-
She is changing the subject to escape an uncomfortable personal exposure.
The question comes right after Jesus reveals her marital history (4:16–18). Many preachers and some commentators read the abrupt turn to a debate topic as deflection.
-
She is asking exactly the question a recognised prophet ought to answer.
She has just concluded 'you are a prophet' (4:19). Samaritans expected a prophet like Moses who would settle the true place of worship (compare 4:25). Jesus does not rebuke her for evasion. He gives one of his most important answers in the Gospel, beginning with 'believe me'. Commentators such as Keener and Cohick favour this reading. The text never says she was evading.
in v21
What exactly does the 'neither… nor' announce?
-
Jesus replaces the temple: worship now centres on him and the Spirit rather than a sacred site.
John has already presented Jesus' body as the true temple (2:19–21). The next verses speak of worship 'in spirit and truth' (4:23–24) and connect it to Jesus' 'hour'. This is the majority reading in modern commentaries (Brown, Carson, Keener).
-
It foretells the loss of both sanctuaries.
Gerizim's temple was already in ruins, and Jerusalem's would fall in AD 70. The future tense 'will worship' can be read as a prophecy, and John's first readers would have known it had come true. This view is usually combined with the first rather than set against it.
-
It sets aside sacred place in general in favour of inward devotion.
This is drawn from 4:24 ('God is spirit'). Critics answer that 'spirit' in John refers to God's Spirit given through Jesus, not to an inward attitude as opposed to outward action. They also point out that v. 22 still affirms Israel's place, so the point is not that place never mattered.
in v21
Is the 'hour' still future here, or already present?
-
Future, tied to Jesus' death and glorification.
John repeatedly places 'the hour' at the cross (12:23; 13:1; 17:1). Here the verb is 'is coming' and the worship verb is future.
-
Already breaking in with Jesus' presence.
Verse 23 adds 'and now is'. John often holds future and present together, as in 5:25 ('an hour is coming and now is').
in v22
Why the neuter "what" rather than "whom"?
-
It refers to the object of worship in a general, impersonal way: the God they worship, considered as something understood or not understood.
Greek can use the neuter for a thing or reality being considered in general (compare 1 John 1:1, "what was from the beginning"). The parallel "what we know" refers to the same God.
-
It stresses the content or character of the worship (the whole system of revelation and practice) rather than the person of God.
The debate in 4:20 is about where and how worship is offered. Samaritans did worship the God of Israel, so the issue is the truncated knowledge behind their worship, not a different deity.
in v22
What does "salvation is from the Jews" refer to?
-
The Messiah himself, Jesus, a Jew of Judah's line, through whom the promised deliverance comes.
Gen 49:10; John 7:42; v.26 ("I am he"); 4:42 ("Savior of the world"); Rom 9:5.
-
Israel's whole heritage of revelation (Scriptures, covenants, promises) through which God prepared his rescue.
The contrast with Samaritan knowledge limited to the Pentateuch. Ps 76:1; Rom 3:2 ("entrusted with the oracles of God").
-
Both together: the full revelation given to Israel culminates in the Messiah who comes from Israel.
The flow of vv.22–26 moves from knowledge ("we know") to the person ("I am he").
in v22
Should Ioudaioi in John be translated "Jews" or "Judeans"?
-
"Judeans": a geographic and ethnic term tied to Judea and Jerusalem, which avoids reading later religious categories back into the text.
Ancient usage linked ethnic names to homelands (S. Mason, "Jews, Judaeans, Judaizing, Judaism," 2007). John also sometimes contrasts Judeans with Galileans.
-
"Jews": the term already covered religious identity (including diaspora Jews and converts), and "Judeans" can obscure the continuity with later Jewish people.
The usage includes proselytes and diaspora communities. Here the contrast is with Samaritans, who also lived in the land, so religious identity is in view.
in v23
Does 'in spirit' (en pneumati) mean the Holy Spirit or the human spirit?
-
God's Spirit: worship in the sphere created by the Spirit given through Jesus.
Verse 24 'God is spirit' grounds the statement in God's nature, not human psychology. In John the Spirit gives new birth (3:5–8) and life (6:63) and comes after Jesus' glorification (7:39), which fits 'an hour is coming'. 'Spirit of truth' pairs the two words elsewhere in John (14:17; 15:26). Qumran's 'spirit of truth' (1QS IV) is a close parallel. Held by many recent commentators (e.g., Carson, Keener, Köstenberger).
-
The human spirit: inward, heartfelt worship as opposed to worship tied to place and ritual.
The direct contrast in vv. 20–21 is with physical locations, which suggests inward versus outward. 'Pneuma' has no article. The reading is long-standing in patristic and Reformation interpretation, and most English versions print lowercase.
-
Both: the human spirit renewed and enabled by God's Spirit.
John 3:6 ('what is born of the Spirit is spirit') links divine Spirit and renewed human spirit. Many commentators (e.g., R. E. Brown) see the phrase as describing worship made possible by the Spirit and expressed from within.
in v23
Are 'spirit' and 'truth' two separate requirements or one combined idea?
-
One combined idea: the new reality of worship that God gives through Jesus.
A single preposition governs both nouns. The phrase answers one question (where to worship). John links Spirit and truth closely ('Spirit of truth'). Jesus, who is 'the truth', and the Spirit are the new 'place'.
-
Two distinguishable qualities, such as inner reality and conformity to God's revelation.
The two nouns are not synonyms, and each carries its own Johannine weight. Verse 22 stresses knowing what one worships (truth), while v. 24 stresses God's nature (spirit), so each word has its own role in the argument.
in v24
Does 'in spirit' mean the worshipper's own spirit or God's Holy Spirit?
-
The human spirit: worship that is inward and sincere, as opposed to merely outward or tied to a place.
Lowercase reading in most translations; the contrast with physical sanctuaries; Old Testament calls for heart-worship (Ps 51:17). Older commentators such as Westcott leaned this way.
-
God's Spirit: worship enabled by, and happening in the realm of, the Spirit given through Jesus.
John's consistent use of pneuma for God's life-giving Spirit (3:5–8; 6:63; 7:39); the repeated word in 'God is spirit … in spirit'; 'Spirit of truth' (14:17); the end-times promises of the Spirit (Ezek 36; Joel 2). Taken by many recent commentators (e.g., Carson, Keener, Köstenberger) and reflected in the NIV.
-
Both together: the human spirit renewed and moved by God's Spirit.
John 3:6 ('what is born of the Spirit is spirit') joins the two. A single preposition governs a combined sphere rather than one narrow referent.
in v24
Is 'God is spirit' a definition of God's being or a description of how he relates to the world?
-
It is a statement about what God is in himself: not physical, not limited by place.
The grammar describes God's nature. Patristic use (Origen) and classical theology drew on it for the doctrine that God has no body.
-
It mainly characterises God as the life-giving one who acts from 'above', and it is not offered as a philosophical definition.
In John pneuma is about life and power (6:63) rather than substance. The context is the place-of-worship dispute. The parallels 'God is light' and 'God is love' describe God in relation to his people. Commentators such as Brown and Carson stress this point.
in v24
What does 'truth' chiefly mean here?
-
Sincerity and faithfulness: worship that is genuine, not hypocritical.
Old Testament usage of 'emet ('serve him in sincerity and in truth', Josh 24:14; Ps 145:18).
-
The reality of God revealed in Jesus, as opposed to ignorance and to preparatory forms.
John's theme of truth (1:14, 17; 8:32; 14:6); the contrast with 'you worship what you do not know' (4:22); the climax 'I am he' (4:26).
Sources
- BDAG s.v. προσκυνέω
- BDAG s.v. τόπος
- BDAG s.v. δεῖ
- Josephus, Antiquities 11.302–347 (Gerizim temple founding)
- Josephus, Antiquities 13.74–79 (Jewish–Samaritan dispute before Ptolemy VI)
- Josephus, Antiquities 13.254–256 (destruction by John Hyrcanus)
- Josephus, Antiquities 18.29–30 (bones in the Temple)
- Sirach 50:25–26
- Samaritan Pentateuch at Deut 12:5; 27:4; Exod 20:17 (expansion)
- Y. Magen, Mount Gerizim Excavations (Israel Antiquities Authority)
- R. Pummer, The Samaritans: A Profile
- R. E. Brown, The Gospel According to John I–XII (Anchor Bible)
- C. S. Keener, The Gospel of John: A Commentary
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on John 4
- BDAG s.v. γυνή, ὥρα, προσκυνέω, πιστεύω
- Josephus, Antiquities 11.302–347; 13.254–256; 18.29–30; 18.85–87; Jewish War 1.62–63
- Samaritan Pentateuch, Deut 27:4 and the expanded Decalogue (Exod 20 / Deut 5)
- Nestle-Aland, Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at John 4:21
- R. E. Brown, The Gospel according to John I–XII (Anchor Bible)
- D. A. Carson, The Gospel according to John (Pillar)
- L. H. Cohick, Women in the World of the Earliest Christians
- Y. Magen, Mount Gerizim Excavations (reports on the Samaritan sanctuary)
- Vulgate, John 4:21
- BDAG s.v. σωτηρία
- BDAG s.v. Ἰουδαῖος
- BDAG s.v. οἶδα
- Septuagint: Ps 75:2 (MT 76:1); Isa 49:6; Ps 97:2–3
- 2 Kings 17:24–41
- Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 9.288–291; 11.302–347; 13.254–256
- C. K. Barrett, The Gospel According to St John
- C. S. Keener, The Gospel of John: A Commentary; IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament
- R. Bultmann, The Gospel of John: A Commentary
- S. Mason, "Jews, Judaeans, Judaizing, Judaism: Problems of Categorization in Ancient History," JSJ 38 (2007)
- BDAG s.v. προσκυνέω, προσκυνητής, ἀληθινός, ἀλήθεια, πνεῦμα, ὥρα, ζητέω
- Louw–Nida, Greek-English Lexicon of the NT Based on Semantic Domains (53.56 προσκυνέω)
- H. Greeven, TDNT s.v. προσκυνέω
- Josephus, Antiquities 13.254–256 (destruction of the Gerizim temple)
- Dead Sea Scrolls, 1QS (Community Rule) III–IV, IX 3–5
- D. A. Carson, The Gospel According to John (PNTC)
- A. J. Köstenberger, John (BECNT)
- Vulgate, John 4:23
- BDAG s.v. πνεῦμα, προσκυνέω, ἀλήθεια, δεῖ
- D. A. Carson, The Gospel According to John (Pillar NTC)
- B. F. Westcott, The Gospel According to St. John
- Josephus, Antiquities 11.310–311; 13.254–256
- Dead Sea Scrolls, Community Rule (1QS) 3:18–4:22; 9:3–5
- Origen, On First Principles 1.1.1–4
- Herodotus, Histories 1.134
- Vulgate, John 4:24
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).