Matthew Chapter 16 Read as one passage
Matthew 16:17–19
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
17Jesus replied, “Blessed are you, Simon son of Jonah! For this was not revealed to you by flesh and blood, but by My Father in heaven. 18And I tell you that you are Peter, and on this rock I will build My church, and the gates of Hades will not prevail against it. 19I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven. Whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven.”
What the first hearers heard
For Matthew's first readers, mostly Jewish followers of Jesus in the late first century and probably in debate with other Jewish teachers, this verse did several things:
- It grounded the confession in God, not in human argument. That Jesus is the Messiah and Son of God was not something one could prove from “flesh and blood” sources. The Father had to disclose it. This explained why many, including learned teachers, did not recognize him (compare 11:25–27), and it gave a community under pressure a reason for confidence.
- It honored Peter while redirecting the credit. Peter is publicly declared “fortunate”, but only because he received something. This matters for reading vv.18–19: Peter's role as “Rock” rests on a gift from God, not on his own insight. A few verses later he speaks again from purely human thinking and is called “Satan” and a stumbling stone (16:22–23). The contrast is deliberate: what comes from the Father versus “the things of men”.
- It placed the event in the line of Daniel and the prophets. Hearers who knew Daniel's “God in heaven who reveals mysteries” would recognize that the hidden plan of God was now being disclosed, and that what prophets and kings longed to see (13:16–17) was being shown to Galilean fishermen.
- It affirmed Jesus' unique sonship. By saying “my Father” in reply to “Son of the living God”, Jesus confirms the title in his own words.
From the study of Matthew 16:17.
Verse by verse
-
17Jesus replied, “Blessed are you, Simon son of Jonah! For this was not revealed to you by flesh and blood, but by My Father in heaven.
Full study →Jesus answers Peter's confession, “You are the Messiah, the Son of the living God”, with a solemn declaration addressed to him by his full name:
“How fortunate you are, Simon son of Jonah! Because no mortal human being uncovered this for you. My own Father, the one in the heavens, lifted the veil.”
The opening is a beatitude, the old Jewish form “How fortunate is the one who…”, used in the Psalms for someone God has favored. In Matthew it is spoken to a single named man only here. Simon is not praised for being clever. He is declared fortunate because he has been shown something. “Flesh and blood” is a Hebrew idiom for a mortal, limited human being in contrast to God. Jesus rules out every human source: not the crowd's guesses about him (John the Baptist, Elijah, Jeremiah, vv.13–14), not a teacher, not Simon's own reasoning. The verb “revealed” means “took the cover off”. In the Jewish tradition of Daniel it describes God disclosing hidden things that people could never find out for themselves. And the one who disclosed it is “my Father”: the Father has revealed his own Son, which confirms the title Peter has just spoken.
Using Simon's formal Aramaic name, “Simon Bar-Jonah”, sets up the next moment. The man known by his father's name is about to be given a new name by Jesus: “you are Peter” (v.18). Peter said “You are…”; Jesus replies “You are…”.
-
18And I tell you that you are Peter, and on this rock I will build My church, and the gates of Hades will not prevail against it.
Full study →"And I, in my turn, say this to you: you are Rock, and on this very rock I will build my assembly, the gathered people of God, and the gates of the realm of the dead will not overpower it."
Peter has just declared who Jesus is: "You are the Christ, the Son of the living God" (v16). Jesus now answers by declaring who Peter is, matching "You are…" with "You are…". Simon receives a new name that means what it says, Aramaic Kēphā, Greek Petros, "Rock". It was hardly in use as a personal name, so everyone would have heard the meaning. The name sets up a pun: "You are Rock, and on this rock…" The picture is a builder setting a house on bedrock, the same picture as the wise man in Matthew 7:24.
The thing built is not a building. It is an ekklēsia, a gathered assembly. That is the word the Greek Old Testament used for Israel assembled before God at Sinai, "the assembly of the LORD". Jesus calls it my assembly, and he himself will build it, as the promised Son of David was to "build a house" for God. The future tense looks ahead: this community does not yet exist in the form he means.
Last comes a guarantee. "The gates of Hades" was a standard Jewish phrase for death, the walled realm of the dead that shuts people in. It is not the place of fiery punishment that "hell" now suggests. The realm of death, with all its strength, will not get the upper hand over the people Jesus gathers. Matthew places this promise just before Jesus first announces his own death and resurrection (v21), which gives it extra force.
-
19I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven. Whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven.”
Full study →Jesus has just said that he will build his own community, his ekklēsia ('assembly'), on Peter, the 'rock'. Now he gives the builder's trusted man the household's keys:
"I will give you, Peter, the keys of the reign of the heavens, the steward's keys of God's royal house. Whatever you declare binding, whatever you forbid or hold someone to, here on earth will stand bound in heaven. Whatever you release, whatever you permit or set free, here on earth will stand released in heaven."
To a Jewish hearer the keys called up the royal steward of Isaiah 22:22. He was 'over the house', carried the key of David's house on his shoulder, and 'opened and no one shut'. He was not the king. He ran the king's house with the king's authority. 'Binding' and 'loosing' were the familiar words for what authoritative teachers and rulers did: decide what God's people were obliged to do or free to do, and hold someone under discipline or release them. The 'you' is singular and the promise is in the future, so this office is promised to Peter personally. Two chapters later (18:18) the same power is spoken over the disciples as a group. The perfect forms 'will stand bound / will stand loosed' present the rulings as settled and valid before God, whose realm Matthew reverently calls 'the heavens'. This is a promise about authority in the community Jesus is founding on earth. It is not about who gets through heaven's gate after death.
Where the English drifted
-
in v17
Blessed
makarios
- What we hear
- Either “God gave you a blessing” (as though Jesus were bestowing something), a compliment like “good for you”, or the popular sense of “lucky, materially favored”.
- What they heard
- A beatitude: a solemn declaration that someone is in an enviable, God-favored position (“How fortunate you are!”). Here the reason is that God has disclosed something to him.
-
in v17
flesh and blood
sarx kai haima
- What we hear
- Relatives (“my own flesh and blood”), or the physical body and senses, or the “sinful flesh” of later theology.
- What they heard
- A mortal human being, in contrast to God. No human source, whether another person or Peter himself, produced this insight.
-
in v17
in heaven
en tois ouranois
- What we hear
- The place where the saved go after death; God's address in the afterlife.
- What they heard
- God's own realm above the earth, “the heavens” (plural, as in Hebrew). It is used here in contrast to earthly “flesh and blood”: the knowledge came from above, from God himself.
-
in v18
church
ekklēsia
- What we hear
- A building where Christians meet, a Sunday service, a denomination, or an organisation with clergy and property.
- What they heard
- An assembly, a gathered body of people. In Jewish Greek it means Israel assembled before God (the *qahal*). Here it is the people the Messiah gathers around himself.
-
in v18
hell (KJV, ESV: 'the gates of hell')
hadēs
- What we hear
- The place of eternal fiery punishment, the devil's kingdom, so that the verse pictures demons attacking or the church storming Satan's fortress.
- What they heard
- The realm of the dead (Hebrew Sheol), where all the dead go. 'Gates of Hades' was a set phrase for death and its power to hold people.
-
in v19
keys of the kingdom of heaven
kleidas tēs basileias tōn ouranōn
- What we hear
- Peter as the gatekeeper at the pearly gates, deciding who enters heaven after death.
- What they heard
- The keys of a royal steward. They stand for delegated authority to manage the King's house and its access, in the community where God's reign is now being lived out on earth.
-
in v19
kingdom of heaven
basileia tōn ouranōn
- What we hear
- Heaven, the place believers go when they die.
-
in v19
bind … loose
deō … luō
- What we hear
- A spiritual-warfare formula: commanding demons ('I bind you, Satan') or 'loosing' blessings.
- What they heard
- A paired legal expression: to declare forbidden or permitted, to impose or release an obligation, and to place someone under discipline or lift it.
Every word
-
Ἀποκριθεὶς
Apokritheis · G611
answering, replying · v17
Jesus responds directly to Peter's confession in v.16. Paired with “said”, it echoes the Hebrew storytelling habit “he answered and said”, so this is a formal reply, not a passing remark.
-
ὁ
ho · G3588
the · v17, v18, v19
Greek puts the article before personal names; it is not translated in English.
-
Ἰησοῦς
Iēsous · G2424
Jesus (Yeshua/Joshua) · v17
The speaker. In Greek the name is the same as Joshua, “YHWH saves” (compare Matt 1:21).
-
εἶπεν
eipen · G2036
said · v17
Simple past “said”, introducing a solemn pronouncement.
-
αὐτῷ
autō · G846
to him · v17, v18
Addressed to Simon personally. What follows is said to one man, not to the group as a whole.
-
μακάριος
makarios · G3107
blessed, fortunate, happy · v17
The opening word of a beatitude, a fixed Jewish form (“How fortunate is…”) that declares someone to be in an enviable, God-favored position. Here it is said to one named individual, which is rare in the Gospels.
-
εἶ
ei · G1510
you are · v17, v18, v19
“You are”. It mirrors Peter's own “You are the Christ” (v.16) and anticipates “you are Peter” (v.18): you are…, you are…, you are….
-
Σίμων
Simōn · G4613
Simon · v17
His ordinary given name, probably the Greek form of Hebrew Shim'on (Simeon). It is the name he has before Jesus gives him the new one in v.18.
-
Βαριωνᾶ
Bariōna · G920
son of Jona(h) · v17
An Aramaic patronymic left untranslated: bar = “son of”, Yonah = Jonah (or possibly a short form of Yohanan/John; see debates). The full formal name sets up the solemn renaming in the next verse.
-
ὅτι
hoti · G3754
because, for · v17, v18
Gives the reason Simon is “blessed”. His good fortune is not his cleverness but what has been given to him.
-
σὰρξ
sarx · G4561
flesh · v17
First half of the idiom “flesh and blood”, meaning a mortal human being. It is not about the body as a source of sin.
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v17, v18, v19
Joins the two halves of the fixed pair “flesh and blood”.
-
αἷμα
haima · G129
blood · v17
Completes the idiom. Together, “flesh and blood” means human beings in their frailty and limits, as opposed to God.
-
οὐκ
ouk · G3756
not · v17, v18
A flat denial that any human source produced Peter's insight.
-
ἀπεκάλυψέν
apekalypsen · G601
uncovered, revealed · v17
“Took the cover off.” In Jewish usage this is what God does when he discloses his hidden purposes. The simple past tense points to a definite act of disclosure. The object (“it”, “this”) is left unstated: it is the content of Peter's confession.
-
σοι
soi · G4771
to you · v17, v18, v19
Singular. The disclosure was given to Simon himself.
-
ἀλλ᾽
all' · G235
but, rather · v17
Strong contrast: not human beings, but God.
-
πατήρ
patēr · G3962
father · v17
God named as Father, the counterpart to Peter's “Son of the living God”. The Father has revealed the Son.
-
μου
mou · G3450
my, of me · v17
“My” Father, not “our” or “your” Father. Jesus speaks of a sonship that is uniquely his own, which confirms the title Peter has just used.
-
ἐν
en · G1722
in · v17, v19
Locates the Father “in” the heavens.
-
οὐρανοῖς
ouranois · G3772
heaven, sky · v17, v19
Plural, “the heavens”, following Hebrew shamayim, which is always plural. It names God's realm above, the source of the disclosure, in contrast to the earthly “flesh and blood”.
-
κἀγὼ
kagō · G1473
and I · v18
A contraction of 'and' + 'I', with the 'I' stressed: 'And I, in my turn…'. Peter has just told Jesus who he is (v16); now Jesus answers by telling Peter who he is.
-
δέ
de · G1161
and, now · v18
A light linking word marking the turn in the conversation, from Peter's declaration to Jesus' reply.
-
λέγω
legō · G3004
I say · v18
Present tense, 'I am telling you'. Coming from Jesus in Matthew it has the weight of a formal pronouncement, like his repeated 'I say to you'.
-
Πέτρος
Petros · G4074
Peter, 'Rock' · v18
The Greek form of the Aramaic nickname Kēphā, 'Rock' (John 1:42). To the first hearers it was not yet a familiar name. It sounded like what it was: 'you are Rock'.
-
ἐπὶ
epi · G1909
upon · v18, v19
'Upon' in the sense of resting on a foundation, as in Matthew 7:24, where the wise man builds his house 'upon the rock'.
-
ταύτῃ
tautē · G3778
this · v18
'This' points back to something just mentioned. The most natural thing it points to is the 'Rock' just named. What exactly it refers to is the most debated question in the verse (see debates).
-
πέτρᾳ
petra · G4073
rock, bedrock · v18
The ordinary Greek word for solid rock, a ledge or bedrock, the kind of thing you build a house on. It is feminine because the common noun is feminine. Peter's name takes the masculine form because it belongs to a man.
-
οἰκοδομήσω
oikodomēsō · G3618
I will build · v18
Future tense: something Jesus will do, not something that already exists. 'Build' brings in the language of building a house or a temple, and Jesus himself is the builder.
-
μου
mou · G3165
my · v18
'My' is placed early, before the noun, which gives it some stress. In Israel's Scriptures the assembly was 'the assembly of the LORD'. Here Jesus calls it his own.
-
ἐκκλησίαν
ekklēsian · G1577
assembly, congregation · v18
A gathered body of people. In the Greek Old Testament it is the standard word for Israel assembled before God (Hebrew qahal). Here it means the people Jesus will gather round himself. It does not mean a building or an organisation.
-
πύλαι
pulai · G4439
gates · v18
City gates. In the ancient world gates stood for a city's strength, its defences and the authority of its rulers, because rulers held court at the gate. The phrase 'gates of Hades' is used as a figure of speech.
-
ᾅδου
hadou · G86
Hades, the realm of the dead · v18
The underworld where all the dead go. It is the Greek equivalent of the Hebrew Sheol. 'Gates of Hades' was a stock phrase for death and its hold on people. It does not mean the place of fiery punishment, which Matthew calls Gehenna.
-
κατισχύσουσιν
katischusousin · G2729
will overpower, prevail over · v18
Future tense: 'will not get the upper hand over' or 'will not overpower'. It is the language of a contest of strength where one side wins.
-
δώσω
dōsō · G1325
I will give · v19
A future promise. Jesus does not hand the keys over at Caesarea Philippi. He promises them for later, after the coming 'building' of his community (v. 18).
-
κλεῖδας
kleidas · G2807
keys · v19
Keys were the mark of the steward who ran a household or palace. They meant the authority to open and shut, to grant or refuse access, and to manage the master's affairs. The image echoes Isaiah 22:22.
-
βασιλείας
basileias · G0932
kingdom, reign · v19
God's royal rule breaking into the world, which Jesus announces. It is not first of all a territory or the afterlife. The keys give authority within the realm where God's reign is acknowledged.
-
ὃ
ho · G3739
what, whatever · v19
Neuter ('whatever', not 'whoever'). The most natural reading is matters, rulings and things, although Greek can use the neuter for people in a general sense.
-
ἐὰν
ean · G1437
if, -ever · v19
With the relative pronoun it makes the expression open-ended: 'whatever you happen to bind'. It covers any case that comes up.
-
δήσῃς
dēsēs · G1210
you bind · v19
Literally 'tie up'. In Jewish legal usage of the time, 'bind' meant to declare something forbidden or binding. It could also mean to hold someone under a ban (see studies). The verb is singular, so Peter is the one acting.
-
γῆς
gēs · G1093
earth · v19
Paired with 'heavens' in the familiar Jewish contrast between earth and heaven, the human realm and God's realm (compare 6:10, 'on earth as in heaven').
-
λύσῃς
lusēs · G3089
you loose, untie · v19
Literally 'untie, release'. In legal usage it meant to declare permitted or not binding, or to release someone from an obligation or ban.
The world behind it
Where and when. The scene takes place near Caesarea Philippi (16:13), a city at the foot of Mount Hermon, at the far northern edge of Jewish territory. It was largely pagan: a cave-shrine to the god Pan stood there, and Herod the Great had built a temple to Augustus nearby. The city's current name honored Caesar and Herod's son Philip. In this setting of rival claims to divinity and power, Jesus asks who people say he is, and Peter calls him the Messiah and “Son of the living God”.
The beatitude form. Jewish hearers knew “Fortunate is…” (Hebrew ’ashrê) from the Psalms and wisdom books. It is a public verdict on someone's standing before God. In an honor-conscious society, being publicly declared “fortunate” by a teacher in front of the other disciples raised Peter's status.
Revelation in Jewish expectation. Many Jews of the period believed that God's plans for the end of the age were hidden and could only be known if God disclosed them. Daniel is the model: “there is a God in heaven who reveals mysteries” (Dan 2:28). Jesus places Peter's recognition of him in this category. It is a divine disclosure, not a conclusion from evidence. Matthew has already prepared for this in 11:25–27: the Father hides these things from the wise and reveals them to “infants”, and only the Father truly knows the Son.
Names. A Jewish man was formally identified by his father's name (“son of…”, Aramaic bar). Being renamed by a superior marked a new role, as with Abram to Abraham or Jacob to Israel. Calling Simon by his full patronymic in v.17 sets up the renaming in v.18.
A striking parallel. Paul, describing his own call, uses the same cluster of ideas. God “was pleased to reveal [apokalypsai] his Son in me”, and “I did not consult with flesh and blood” (Gal 1:15–16). This shows the pairing of “revealing the Son” with “not from flesh and blood” was established early Christian language for how people came to know who Jesus was.
From the study of Matthew 16:17.
Where scholars differ
in v17
Was Peter's father named Jonah or John?
-
“Bar-Jona” is a shortened or alternative form of Bar-Yohanan (son of John), so Matthew and John agree.
John 1:42 and 21:15–17 call him “son of John”. Some argue Ἰωνᾶς could render a short form of Yohanan. NLT adopts this. Direct evidence for that contraction is weak, however.
-
Jonah and John are different names. Either the father had two names (common for Jews at the time, who often had a Hebrew and a Greek name) or one tradition is mistaken.
Yonah and Yohanan are distinct Hebrew names. The Septuagint renders Jonah as Ἰωνᾶς, the same form Matthew uses elsewhere for the prophet (12:39–41; 16:4).
-
Matthew intends an echo of the prophet Jonah.
Jesus has just mentioned “the sign of Jonah” (16:4), so some see wordplay. This is speculative; the text does not develop it.
in v17
Does this saying go back to Jesus, or did Matthew compose it?
-
It preserves early Aramaic tradition, likely from Jesus or the earliest Palestinian community.
Dense Semitic idiom: the untranslated Bar-Jona, “flesh and blood”, the beatitude form, “Father in heaven”, and the Aramaic wordplay on Kepha/rock in v.18 (Jeremias; Davies & Allison; Meyer).
-
It is Matthew's expansion of Mark's shorter account.
Mark 8:29 and Luke 9:20 lack vv.17–19. The vocabulary (“Father in heaven”, “church”) is characteristically Matthean, and the passage fits Matthew's interest in Peter and in community authority (Bultmann; Luz, with qualifications).
in v17
What exactly did the Father reveal?
-
The whole confession: that Jesus is the Messiah and the Son of the living God.
The unstated object of “revealed” most naturally points back to all of v.16.
-
Especially the Son-of-God element, the deeper identity beyond messiahship.
Jesus answers with “*my* Father”. Matt 11:27 says only the Father knows the Son. Peter's misunderstanding of what kind of Messiah Jesus is (16:21–23) suggests the disclosure was real but partial.
in v17
Is makarios best rendered “blessed”, “happy”, or “honored”?
-
“Blessed/fortunate”: a declaration of God-given good standing.
Septuagint use for Hebrew ’ashrê; standard lexicons (BDAG: “fortunate, happy, privileged”).
-
“How honorable!”: a public grant of honor in an honor-shame culture.
K. C. Hanson (Semeia 68, 1994) argued that beatitudes ascribe honor. Critics reply that this captures the social effect but narrows the lexical meaning.
in v18
What is 'this rock'?
-
Peter himself, as the confessing apostle
The pun, 'You are Rock, and on this rock', points most naturally to the person just named, and in Aramaic the same word *kēphā* would stand in both places. Verse 19 continues in the second person singular ('I will give *you* the keys'). Ephesians 2:20 and Revelation 21:14 call the apostles foundations. Held by Catholic interpreters and by many Protestant scholars (Cullmann, Carson, France, Keener). Most of the Protestants who hold it add that the verse says nothing about successors to Peter.
-
Peter's confession or faith, that Jesus is the Messiah
The demonstrative 'this', the switch from *Petros* to *petra*, and the emphasis in v17 on what was revealed suggest the foundation is the truth Peter confessed. Found in Chrysostom and other church fathers, in many Eastern Orthodox interpreters, and widely among the Reformers. Weakness: the gender switch is better explained by grammar than by contrast.
-
Christ himself
Elsewhere Christ is the only foundation or the cornerstone (1 Cor 3:11; 1 Pet 2:4–8; Matt 21:42), and 'rock' is a title of God in the Old Testament. Augustine sometimes read it this way, while noting in his *Retractations* that he had also taken it as Peter and leaving the choice to the reader. Weakness: the wordplay with Peter's name becomes hard to explain.
-
Jesus' teaching or revelation
Matthew 7:24 builds 'upon the rock' the one who hears and does Jesus' words. The foundation would then be the revealed truth about Jesus. This overlaps with the confession view.
in v18
What does 'the gates of Hades will not prevail' picture?
-
Death will not hold or swallow the assembly
'Gates of Hades/Sheol' is a stock phrase for death in Isaiah 38:10, Wisdom 16:13, 3 Maccabees 5:51 and Psalms of Solomon 16:2. Fits the announcement of Jesus' death and resurrection in 16:21. The majority reading.
-
Hostile powers of the underworld will attack the assembly and fail
The Dead Sea Thanksgiving Hymns (1QH xi) picture the gates of the Pit opening and destructive powers pouring out. In Jewish expectation the last days would bring a final assault of evil. Argued by Joel Marcus (CBQ 1988), who links it with the 'keys' of v19.
-
The assembly will storm the gates of Hades
Popular in preaching ('gates are defensive'). But it reverses the grammar: the gates are the subject that fails to overpower; the assembly is the object. A related, older idea is that the assembly, with Christ, will rescue the dead from Hades, but this is not stated in the text.
in v18
Do these words go back to Jesus or to the later community?
-
An early saying with Aramaic roots
The concentration of Semitic idioms, the Aramaic pun on *Kēphā*, the strongly Jewish ideas (qahal, building God's house, Isa 22:22 keys), and Paul's early use of 'Cephas' and 'pillar' language (Gal 2:9) point to an early source, perhaps originally set at another moment in Jesus' ministry.
-
A post-Easter community formulation
It appears only in Matthew. Mark and Luke tell the same scene without it. 'Church' appears in the Gospels only here and in 18:17. Some scholars (e.g. Bultmann) linked it to resurrection appearances to Peter (1 Cor 15:5).
in v19
What exactly does 'binding and loosing' refer to?
-
Legal rulings: declaring what is forbidden or permitted for the community (teaching authority).
The Hebrew/Aramaic forbid/permit pair is standard in the Mishnah. The neuter 'whatever' fits matters better than persons. It sits next to the 'keys' of teaching (Matt 23:13; Luke 11:52). The Peshitta uses the forbid/permit verbs. Matthew is concerned throughout with interpreting the Law (5:17–48).
-
Discipline and forgiveness: admitting people, excluding them, and restoring them, including declaring sins forgiven or retained.
Matthew 18:15–18 places the same saying in a discipline procedure. John 20:23 is a parallel about forgiving and retaining sins. Rabbinic use of 'bind' covers the synagogue ban. Josephus's 'loose and bind' covers decisions about people. Early church interpretation took this line widely.
-
Binding spiritual powers (exorcism, defeating Satan).
'Bind' is used of demons in Matt 12:29, Tobit 8:3 and 1 Enoch 10:4, and the 'gates of Hades' appear in v. 18. Most commentators judge this a minor or secondary note at most here, because of the neuter 'whatever' and the forbid/permit pairing.
-
A combination of the first two.
Many major commentators (for example Davies & Allison, Keener, France) hold that teaching authority and community discipline overlapped in Jewish practice and cannot be cleanly separated.
in v19
Does heaven ratify Peter's decisions, or do his decisions carry out what heaven has already settled?
-
Earth follows heaven: 'will have been bound'. Peter declares what God has already determined.
Takes the future perfect form seriously (Mantey, 1939; NASB, WEB). It fits Matthew's emphasis that human authority is answerable to God's will (6:10; 7:21).
-
Heaven ratifies earth: 'will be bound'. God backs Peter's authorised decisions.
Cadbury and many grammarians hold that in Koine this construction stresses a resulting state, not the order of events. Most translations take this line. Rabbinic texts also speak of the heavenly court agreeing with the decisions of the earthly court.
-
The grammar cannot decide it; the point is that earthly and heavenly decisions correspond.
The perfect participles stress permanence and validity. The question of priority is a later theological question that the construction does not clearly settle.
in v19
Is this authority unique to Peter, shared, or passed on?
-
Peter personally receives a unique office that continues in his successors (Roman Catholic teaching on the papacy).
Singular 'you' (contrast 18:18). Isaiah 22's steward was an office that passed from one holder to another, with robe and sash handed on. The keys are given only to Peter. The verse is read together with John 21:15–17 and Peter's leadership in Acts.
-
Peter receives a unique foundational role, historically fulfilled by Peter himself, with no succession implied (common in modern Protestant and some critical scholarship, e.g. Cullmann, France, Carson).
Peter opens the way into the community to Jews (Acts 2), Samaritans (Acts 8) and Gentiles (Acts 10), and speaks decisively at the Jerusalem council (Acts 15). The text itself says nothing about successors.
-
Peter stands for the apostles, or for every believer who makes his confession (a view going back to Origen, common in Eastern Orthodox and Reformation readings).
The same authority is given to all the disciples in 18:18 and John 20:23. Peter often speaks for the Twelve in Matthew. The authority is closely tied to his confession of Jesus as Messiah in v. 16.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. μακάριος, ἀποκαλύπτω, σάρξ, οὐρανός
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. Βαριωνᾶς
- HALOT s.v. אַשְׁרֵי; s.v. גלה (Aramaic)
- Septuagint: Psalm 1:1; Daniel 2:19–47; Sirach 14:18; 17:31
- W. D. Davies & D. C. Allison, Matthew (ICC), vol. 2, on 16:17–19
- U. Luz, Matthew 8–20 (Hermeneia)
- R. T. France, The Gospel of Matthew (NICNT)
- C. S. Keener, The IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Matt 16:13–20
- J. Jeremias, New Testament Theology: The Proclamation of Jesus
- K. C. Hanson, “How Honorable! How Shameful! A Cultural Analysis of Matthew's Makarisms and Reproaches,” Semeia 68 (1994)
- Galatians 1:12–16; Matthew 11:25–27; 13:16–17; John 1:42; 21:15–17
- Mishnah Sotah 9:15; Yoma 8:9 (“Father in heaven”)
- Vulgate, Matthew 16:17
- BDAG s.v. ἐκκλησία, πέτρα, Πέτρος, ᾅδης, κατισχύω, οἰκοδομέω
- LSJ s.v. πέτρα, πέτρος
- J. A. Fitzmyer, "Aramaic Kepha' and Peter's Name in the New Testament" (1979)
- P. Lampe, "Das Spiel mit dem Petrusnamen – Matt. xvi.18", NTS 25 (1979)
- O. Cullmann, Peter: Disciple, Apostle, Martyr (1953)
- W. D. Davies & D. C. Allison, Matthew (ICC), vol. 2
- R. T. France, The Gospel of Matthew (NICNT, 2007)
- D. A. Carson, Matthew (Expositor's Bible Commentary)
- C. S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Matt 16:13–20
- J. Marcus, "The Gates of Hades and the Keys of the Kingdom (Matt 16:18–19)", CBQ 50 (1988)
- LXX: Isa 38:10; Wis 16:13; 3 Macc 5:51; Pss. Song of Songs 16:2; Deut 9:10; 23:2–4; Job 38:17
- Dead Sea Scrolls: 4Q171 (4QpPs37) iii 16; 1QS viii 5–10; 1QH xi
- Augustine, Retractationes 1.21
- BDAG s.v. κλείς, δέω, λύω, βασιλεία
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. δέω, λύω
- Isaiah 22:15–25 (Hebrew text and LXX); Revelation 3:7
- Josephus, Jewish War 1.111 (1.5.2)
- Mishnah, passim: Beit Shammai osrin / Beit Hillel mattirin formula
- 2 Baruch 10:18; 3 Baruch 11:2; Tobit 8:3; 1 Enoch 10:4
- R. T. France, The Gospel of Matthew (NICNT), on 16:19
- C. S. Keener, A Commentary on the Gospel of Matthew / IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on 16:19
- J. R. Mantey, 'The Mistranslation of the Perfect Tense in John 20:23, Mt 16:19, and Mt 18:18', JBL 58 (1939); H. J. Cadbury, reply in JBL 58 (1939)
- O. Cullmann, Peter: Disciple, Apostle, Martyr
- Strack–Billerbeck, Kommentar zum Neuen Testament aus Talmud und Midrasch, vol. 1, on Matt 16:19
- Syriac Peshitta, Matthew 16:19; Latin Vulgate, Matthew 16:19
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).