Mark Chapter 16 Read as one passage

Mark 16:11–14

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

11And when they heard that Jesus was alive and she had seen Him, they did not believe it. 12After this, Jesus appeared in a different form to two of them as they walked along in the country. 13And they went back and reported it to the rest, but they did not believe them either. 14Later, as they were eating, Jesus appeared to the Eleven and rebuked them for their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they did not believe those who had seen Him after He had risen.

What the first hearers heard

For the early Christians who read Mark with this ending, the verse did several things:

  • It admitted something embarrassing. The founding leaders of the movement did not believe at first. A story invented to impress would hardly show the apostles stubbornly rejecting the news. Keeping this memory told readers that Easter faith did not come from wishful thinking among grieving followers. They resisted it.
  • It honoured the first witness. Mary Magdalene, a woman out of whom seven demons had been cast (v. 9), is the first to see the risen Lord and the first to announce him. In a world that discounted women's testimony, she is the one in the right and the apostles are in the wrong.
  • It modelled the reader's own position. Later believers, like the disciples in this scene, only hear that he is alive. They depend on the word of those who saw. The scene, followed by Jesus' rebuke in v. 14 for not believing "those who had seen him," tells readers that the right response to trustworthy testimony is belief, and that refusing it is hardness of heart, not caution.
  • It prepared for the commission. The words for believing and disbelieving in vv. 11–16 build toward the great sending (v. 15) and the line between those who believe and those who do not (v. 16).

From the study of Mark 16:11.

Verse by verse

  1. 11And when they heard that Jesus was alive and she had seen Him, they did not believe it.

    Mary Magdalene, the first person to see the risen Jesus, comes to his followers while they are still mourning and weeping. They hear her report: "He is alive" (alive now, in the present tense of her own words), and she has looked at him with her own eyes. But they, the ones who knew him best, refused to credit it. They had only her word, and her word was not enough.

    The verse turns on a contrast between hearing and seeing. She is an eyewitness. They are hearers who will not accept what she saw. The verb for their response, "disbelieved," is not a neutral "we'll wait and see." In the following verses the same reaction repeats when two more disciples report (v. 13), and Jesus then rebukes the Eleven for "unbelief and hardness of heart, because they did not believe those who had seen him" (v. 14). Then comes the warning that whoever disbelieves will be condemned (v. 16). So this short sentence is the first step in a deliberate sequence: grief gives way to disbelief, disbelief is rebuked, and then the message goes to the whole world.

    Full study →
  2. 12After this, Jesus appeared in a different form to two of them as they walked along in the country.

    "After these events, he was made visible to two of them, but in a different outward appearance, while they were walking along, travelling out of the city into the countryside."

    The verse is one link in a quick chain of resurrection appearances. First Mary Magdalene sees him (16:9); then two of Jesus' wider band of followers do. They are not among the Eleven. They are on foot, on the road, leaving Jerusalem for the farmland and villages around it.

    The verb is passive ("he was revealed, was made visible"). This presents the encounter as a disclosure, something given to them, not a chance sighting. "In another form" means that he did not look the way they knew him. That is why they did not recognise him at once. The verse does not explain how or why; it simply records it.

    Most readers familiar with the Gospels will recognise this as a compressed summary of the Emmaus road story told in full in Luke 24:13–35. The number two matters too. Two witnesses was the legal minimum for valid testimony, and the next verse says that even their report was not believed. That sets up the rebuke of the Eleven's unbelief in v.14.

    Full study →
  3. 13And they went back and reported it to the rest, but they did not believe them either.

    The two followers who had just met the risen Jesus out in the countryside (v. 12) left at once and brought the news back to the rest of the group, as Mary Magdalene had done a little earlier (v. 10). The verb casts them as messengers carrying a report. They got the same reception she did: not even these two were believed. "Believe" here means to accept what a person tells you as true. The others did not trust the eyewitness word of their own companions that Jesus was alive and had shown himself to them.

    The Greek frames the sentence with the same word, "those": those two reported, and those two were not believed. The small word "not even / neither" links this refusal to the earlier one. First a woman's testimony was rejected, now that of two men, and two witnesses together were normally enough to settle a matter. The scene builds up the disciples' stubborn disbelief, which Jesus confronts in the next verse when he rebukes "their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they did not believe those who had seen Him after He had risen" (v. 14).

    Full study →
  4. 14Later, as they were eating, Jesus appeared to the Eleven and rebuked them for their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they did not believe those who had seen Him after He had risen.

    Last of all, while the Eleven (the Twelve, now without Judas) were reclining at a meal, Jesus was made visible to them. He was revealed, not just glimpsed. And he reproached them sharply, a shaming rebuke and not a gentle word. He reproached them for their refusal to trust and their closed, stubborn minds ("hardness of heart" in the biblical sense: a mind that will not take in what it has been shown, not a lack of feeling). The reason was specific. People had looked on him with their own eyes as the one who had been raised, first Mary Magdalene and then the two disciples on the road, and the Eleven would not believe them. Their failure was refusing credible testimony about something God had revealed. That is why the next words send these same men out to proclaim the news to the whole world (16:15) and say that everything turns on believing (16:16).

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v12

    in a different form / in another form

    en heterā morphē

    What we hear
    A change in what kind of being Jesus was: a spirit-form or a different body. Or a deliberate disguise or shape-shift.
    What they heard
    A different outward appearance, how he looked to the eye. The phrase explains why he was not recognised at first and does not say how this happened. Luke's fuller account puts the cause in the travellers' eyes being 'held' (Luke 24:16).
  • in v14

    hardness of heart

    sklērokardia

    What we hear
    Being cold, unfeeling or unkind toward others.
    What they heard
    A stubborn, closed mind and will that refuses to take in and respond to what God has shown. The heart was where people thought and chose.
Every word
  1. κἀκεῖνοι

    kakeinoi · G2548

    and those; and they · v11, v13

    Two words ('and' + 'those') run together. It points back to 'those who had been with him' in verse 10: the mourning followers. Using 'those' (ekeinos) as a plain 'they' over and over is a habit of the Longer Ending (vv. 10, 11, 13, 20) and is rare in the rest of Mark.

  2. ἀκούσαντες

    akousantes · G0191

    to hear · v11

    'Having heard': they got the report secondhand, from Mary. The whole contrast of the verse is between hearing a report and seeing for yourself, which she had done and they had not.

  3. ὅτι

    hoti · G3754

    that · v11, v14

    Introduces what they heard, the content of Mary's report, given as indirect speech.

  4. ζῇ

    zē · G2198

    to live, be alive · v11

    Present tense: 'he lives / he is alive.' Greek keeps the tense of the original statement in reported speech, so we hear Mary's own claim: he is alive now. Not a ghost and not a memory, but a living person.

  5. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v11, v14

    Joins the two parts of her report: he is alive, and she saw him.

  6. ἐθεάθη

    etheathē · G2300

    to look at, behold, see · v11, v14

    'He was seen.' This verb means seeing with your own eyes, actually looking at someone. It is the language of an eyewitness, and it backs up 'he is alive' with a personal sighting.

  7. ὑπ᾽

    hyp' · G5259

    by · v11

    Names who did the seeing with the passive verb: 'seen by.'

  8. αὐτῆς

    autēs · G0846

    her · v11, v12, v14

    Mary Magdalene (v. 9), the only witness so far. The text makes her the first person to see the risen Jesus.

  9. ἠπίστησαν

    ēpistēsan · G0569

    to disbelieve, refuse to believe · v11

    'They disbelieved.' They would not accept her report as true. The same verb comes back in v. 16 ('whoever does not believe will be condemned'), and v. 14 calls this reaction 'unbelief and hardness of heart.' So it carries more weight than ordinary scepticism.

  10. Μετὰ

    meta · G3326

    after, with · v12

    With an accusative it marks time: 'after'. It opens a new step in a list of appearances.

  11. δὲ

    de · G1161

    and, now, but · v12, v14

    A light connective that moves the story on to the next episode. It is not a strong 'but'.

  12. ταῦτα

    tauta · G3778

    these things · v12

    'These things' looks back to Mary Magdalene's encounter and the disciples' unbelief (16:9–11). 'After these things' is a common Greek formula for a new section. It appears nowhere else in Mark, but often in John and Luke.

  13. δυσὶν

    dusin · G1417

    two · v12

    In the dative case it marks who received the appearance: 'to two'. Two is also the minimum number of witnesses Jewish law required for valid testimony (Deut 19:15), which matters when their report is rejected in v.13.

  14. ἐξ

    ex · G1537

    out of, from · v12, v14

    Picks out part of a group: 'two out of them'.

  15. περιπατοῦσιν

    peripatousin · G4043

    to walk, walk about · v12

    A present participle, describing action in progress: 'while they were walking'. The appearance interrupts an ordinary journey on foot.

  16. ἐφανερώθη

    ephanerōthē · G5319

    to make visible, reveal · v12, v14

    Passive: 'he was made visible / was revealed'. The wording frames the event as a disclosure: Jesus is brought into view, not someone glimpsed by chance. John uses the same verb for resurrection appearances (John 21:1, 14), and so does the Longer Ending in v.14.

  17. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in · v12

    Marks the manner of the appearance: 'in' another form.

  18. ἑτέρᾳ

    hetera · G2087

    other, different · v12

    'Another, a different' form. The point is that he did not look the way they expected, or the way he had appeared to Mary. Heteros appears nowhere else in Mark.

  19. μορφῇ

    morphē · G3444

    form, outward shape · v12

    The visible shape or appearance by which someone is seen and recognised. The phrase explains why the two did not recognise him at first, without saying how this came about.

  20. πορευομένοις

    poreuomenois · G4198

    to go, journey · v12

    A second present participle, also referring to the two: they were travelling, on their way somewhere. It goes with 'walking' and adds the idea of a destination.

  21. εἰς

    eis · G1519

    into, toward · v12

    Direction of travel: 'into' or 'toward'.

  22. ἀγρόν

    agron · G0068

    field, countryside · v12

    Without the article it means 'into the country', the farmland and villages outside the city (here Jerusalem). It does not mean one particular field.

  23. ἀπελθόντες

    apelthontes · G565

    to go away, depart · v13

    'Having gone away': they left where they were (the countryside of v. 12) and went off to find the others. The form shows the going happened before the reporting. The BSB's 'went back' fits the sense, since they returned to the group.

  24. ἀπήγγειλαν

    apēngeilan · G518

    to report, announce · v13

    'They reported': they passed on news of what they had seen. It is the same verb used of Mary Magdalene in v. 10, so their report repeats hers, and it meets the same response.

  25. τοῖς

    tois · G3588

    the · v13, v14

    The definite article: 'to the…', marking a known group.

  26. λοιποῖς·

    loipois · G3062

    remaining, the rest · v13

    'The rest': the other followers of Jesus who had not seen him, including those who mourned in v. 10 and the Eleven named in v. 14.

  27. οὐδὲ

    oude · G3761

    and not, not even, neither · v13

    'Not even' or 'neither'. It ties this refusal to the earlier one in v. 11: as they had not believed Mary, so they did not believe these two either. 'Not even' may add that two male eyewitnesses together still made no difference.

  28. ἐκείνοις

    ekeinois · G1565

    that one, those · v13

    'Those (two)', here as the ones not believed. The same pronoun stands at the start and end of the sentence: those two spoke, and those two were not believed.

  29. ἐπίστευσαν.

    episteusan · G4100

    to believe, trust · v13, v14

    'They believed', denied by 'not even'. Followed by a person in the dative ('them'), it means to accept what someone says as true. The rest did not accept the two men's report that Jesus was alive and had appeared to them.

  30. Ὕστερον

    hysteron · G5306

    later, afterward · v14

    An adverb meaning 'later' or 'finally'. It marks this as the next and last of the appearances in the series that runs from 16:9 to 16:13, and it may hint that this one came last of all.

  31. ἀνακειμένοις

    anakeimenois · G0345

    to recline (at table) · v14

    Literally 'lying back'. It refers to the formal way people ate, lying on cushions or couches around a low table. The present tense means Jesus appears while the meal is going on.

  32. ἕνδεκα

    hendeka · G1733

    eleven · v14

    The Twelve without Judas. By this point 'the Eleven' is almost a title for the inner circle that is left (compare Luke 24:9, 33; Acts 1:26).

  33. ὠνείδισεν

    ōneidisen · G3679

    to reproach, reprove, revile · v14

    He 'reproached' them. This is a strong word for public reproach that shames. It is harsher than a correction.

  34. ἀπιστίαν

    apistian · G0570

    unbelief, lack of trust · v14

    Their refusal to accept and trust the testimony they had been given. Here it is a failure to trust reliable witnesses, not a vague mood of uncertainty.

  35. σκληροκαρδίαν

    sklērokardian · G4641

    hardness of heart · v14

    In biblical idiom the heart is where a person thinks and decides. A 'hard heart' is a stubborn mind that will not take in what it is shown. It does not mean coldness of feeling.

  36. ἐγηγερμένον

    egēgermenon · G1453

    to raise, rise · v14

    A participle meaning 'having been raised' and still in that state: they saw him as one who is risen. The passive form is often read as 'raised by God', though with this verb it can also simply mean 'risen'.

  37. νεκρῶν

    nekrōn · G3498

    dead (ones) · v14

    'From the dead', literally 'out from among the dead ones'. A standard early Christian phrase that some copyists added to fill out the sense. Not in most editions.

  38. οὐκ

    ouk · G3756

    not · v14

    A flat negation of the verb that follows.

The world behind it

Where this verse sits. Mark 16:9–20 is the "Longer Ending" of Mark. It is not in the two oldest complete manuscripts and is written in a noticeably different style (see textual notes). It reads like a compact summary of resurrection appearances found in the other Gospels. Verses 9–11 closely match John 20:11–18 (Jesus appears to Mary Magdalene, and she reports to the disciples) and Luke 24:10–11 (the women's report seems to the apostles like nonsense, "and they disbelieved them").

Mourning. Verse 10 finds the disciples "mourning and weeping." Jewish mourning for the dead was intense and public, and the first days were the most acute. The report reaches people who are deep in grief for someone they saw executed and buried. They have no frame of mind for welcoming news that he is alive.

A woman's word. Ancient Jewish legal tradition limited women's testimony. Josephus (Antiquities 4.219) says women's evidence should not be admitted, and the Mishnah also restricts women as witnesses in many cases. In the 2nd century the pagan critic Celsus mocked the resurrection as resting on "a hysterical woman" (Origen, Against Celsus 2.55). This background probably made Mary's report easier to dismiss. But the Longer Ending does not say her sex was the reason. In v. 13 the disciples also disbelieve two (apparently male) travellers. The text treats this as unbelief toward any witness, not just a woman.

From the study of Mark 16:11.

Where scholars differ

in v11

Is Mark 16:9–20 (and so this verse) part of what Mark originally wrote?

  • No. It is an early addition, probably early 2nd century, written to supply resurrection appearances after Mark's abrupt ending at 16:8. This is the majority view among textual critics.

    It is missing from א and B. Eusebius and Jerome report that the best copies lacked it. Its style and vocabulary differ from Mark 1:1–16:8 (e.g. the repeated ekeinos). It reintroduces Mary Magdalene in v. 9 as if she had not just been named in 16:1. It seems to depend on Luke and John.

  • Yes, or at least it is very early and belongs in the text. A minority holds that it is original or part of Mark as the church first received it.

    It is attested by the overwhelming majority of manuscripts and versions. Irenaeus quotes it c. AD 180. Supporters argue that the gaps in Vaticanus and Sinaiticus suggest their scribes knew of an ending, and that a Gospel ending at 'for they were afraid' is unlikely.

in v11

Why did the disciples disbelieve Mary?

  • Mainly because she was a woman, and women's testimony carried little weight.

    Josephus, Ant. 4.219, and Mishnaic limits on women as witnesses. Luke 24:11 describes the women's words as seeming like 'nonsense' (lēros).

  • Mainly because of grief-stricken unbelief toward any secondhand report. The Longer Ending presents it as hardness of heart, not as a legal judgment about women.

    In v. 13 the disciples equally disbelieve two travellers, who are not identified as women. In v. 14 Jesus rebukes them for not believing 'those who had seen him,' a group that includes everyone. Verse 10 shows them overwhelmed by mourning.

  • Both. Cultural discounting of women's word made disbelief easier, but the text's own explanation is unbelief.

    The background is real, but the Longer Ending's repeated pattern (vv. 11, 13, 14) points to a general resistance to resurrection testimony.

in v12

Is Mark 16:9–20 (and so this verse) part of Mark's original Gospel?

  • It is a later addition (majority of textual scholars).

    It is missing from א and B and from early translations. Eusebius and Jerome both report its absence from many copies. It does not join smoothly to 16:8, and its vocabulary and style differ from Mark's, including features in this very verse. It appears to depend on Luke, John and Acts (e.g. Kelhoffer, *Miracle and Mission*; Metzger, *Textual Commentary*).

  • It is original, or at least an early, authentic part of the Gospel as received (minority).

    It is present in the vast majority of manuscripts and in early versions. Irenaeus cites it as Mark around 180. Supporters argue that the omission in א and B reflects a local Alexandrian tradition, and that a Gospel ending at 'they were afraid' (16:8) is unlikely (e.g. Burgon; more recently Lunn).

in v12

What does 'in another form' mean?

  • A summary of the non-recognition in Luke's Emmaus story: he looked different to them, without any claim that his body changed.

    The phrase closely matches Luke 24:13–35 (two travellers, the countryside, the report to the others). Luke gives the reason as 'their eyes were kept from recognizing him' (24:16).

  • A real change in his visible appearance, reflecting the changed nature of the resurrection body.

    Morphē normally refers to actual outward shape. Compare the transfiguration (Mark 9:2) and Paul's contrast between the natural and spiritual body (1 Cor 15:42–44). Other recognition failures (John 20:14; 21:4) suggest something about him was genuinely different.

  • 'Another' simply contrasts with the appearance to Mary in 16:9 (where, in John, she took him for the gardener).

    Heteros naturally compares with what came just before. The writer is cataloguing a series of appearances, each one different.

in v13

Is Mark 16:9–20, including this verse, part of what Mark originally wrote?

  • An early addition by another hand, probably early 2nd century.

    It is absent from Sinaiticus and Vaticanus. Eusebius and Jerome say the best copies lacked it. A rival Shorter Ending exists. Its vocabulary and style are not Mark's (e.g., the repeated absolute ekeinos; words not found elsewhere in Mark). The jump from v. 8 to v. 9 is awkward: Mary Magdalene is introduced afresh as if not already mentioned.

  • Original to Mark, or at least an authentic early part of the Gospel as received.

    It is in the vast majority of manuscripts and early versions. Irenaeus and Tatian knew it in the 2nd century, possibly Justin Martyr too (*1 Apology* 45). Some argue an ending at 16:8 ('for they were afraid') is too abrupt to be intended.

in v13

How does 'they did not believe them' fit Luke 24:33–35, where the Eleven already confess that Jesus has risen?

  • Harmonisation: the group was divided, and some believed while others doubted.

    Augustine, *Harmony of the Gospels* 3.25. Luke 24:41 and Matthew 28:17 ('some doubted') show doubt lingering even after belief was expressed.

  • Independent or thematic shaping: the Longer Ending summarises the tradition freely and turns disbelief into its organising theme.

    The pattern of disbelief repeats in vv. 11, 13 and 14 and leads to the rebuke and the faith-or-condemnation saying of v. 16. The author compresses Luke's account rather than reproducing it.

in v14

Is Mark 16:9–20, including this verse, part of what the Gospel's author originally wrote?

  • No. It is an early second-century addition that summarises resurrection traditions (the majority scholarly view).

    It is absent from Sinaiticus and Vaticanus. Eusebius and Jerome say the best copies lacked it. Other endings circulated (the 'Shorter Ending', the Freer Logion). Its vocabulary and style are not Mark's. The joins are awkward: Mary is introduced again in 16:9, and the other women from 16:1–8 vanish. Its contents look like a digest of Luke, John and Acts.

  • Yes, or at least very early and accepted as Mark's ending, so it should keep its place.

    It is in the great majority of Greek manuscripts and early versions. It is attested by the second century (Irenaeus, Tatian). Some scholars (e.g. Maurice Robinson; Nicholas Lunn, *The Original Ending of Mark*, 2014) argue that the stylistic differences are overstated and that a Gospel ending at 16:8 ('for they were afraid') is unlikely.

  • Mark's real ending was lost (or never finished), and 16:9–20 was written to fill the gap.

    The abrupt ending at 16:8 on the Greek word *gar* ('for'). Promises such as 14:28 and 16:7 point toward a meeting in Galilee that is never narrated.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. ἀπιστέω
  • BDAG s.v. θεάομαι
  • BDAG s.v. ζάω
  • BDAG s.v. ἐκεῖνος (unemphatic use in Mark 16:10–20)
  • Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, 2nd ed., on Mark 16:9–20
  • Josephus, Antiquities 4.219
  • Origen, Contra Celsum 2.55
  • Irenaeus, Adversus Haereses 3.10.5
  • Eusebius, Ad Marinum (Quaestiones ad Marinum) 1
  • Vulgate, Mark 16:11
  • BDAG s.v. φανερόω
  • BDAG s.v. μορφή
  • BDAG s.v. ἀγρός
  • BDAG s.v. ἕτερος
  • J. Behm, TDNT s.v. μορφή
  • James A. Kelhoffer, Miracle and Mission: The Authentication of Missionaries and Their Message in the Longer Ending of Mark (2000)
  • Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3.10.5
  • Eusebius, Ad Marinum; Jerome, Epistle 120
  • Luke 24:13–35 (parallel narrative)
  • BDAG s.v. πιστεύω (1.b, 'believe someone', with dative)
  • BDAG s.v. ἀπαγγέλλω
  • BDAG s.v. ἐκεῖνος, κἀκεῖνος
  • Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Mark 16:8–20
  • William L. Lane, The Gospel of Mark (NICNT), on 16:9–20
  • Augustine, De consensu evangelistarum 3.25
  • Irenaeus, Adversus haereses 3.10.5
  • Eusebius, Ad Marinum (Quaestiones evangelicae)
  • Septuagint, Genesis 45:26
  • BDAG s.v. ὀνειδίζω, ἀπιστία, σκληροκαρδία, φανερόω, θεάομαι, ἀνάκειμαι
  • Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. σκληροκαρδία
  • Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (2nd ed.), on Mark 16:9–20 and the Freer Logion
  • Nestle-Aland 28th ed. apparatus, Mark 16
  • Jerome, Against the Pelagians 2.15
  • Eusebius, Ad Marinum (Gospel Questions and Solutions)
  • Nicholas P. Lunn, The Original Ending of Mark (2014)
  • Septuagint: Deut 10:16; Jer 4:4; Sirach 16:10

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).