Mark Chapter 9 Read as one passage

Mark 9:28–29

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

28After Jesus had gone into the house, His disciples asked Him privately, “Why couldn’t we drive it out?” 29Jesus answered, “This kind cannot come out, except by prayer.”

What the first hearers heard

To Mark's first readers, this verse put into words a question their own communities faced. The early churches prayed for the sick and confronted what they understood as demonic oppression, as Acts and Paul's letters show. Sometimes they succeeded and sometimes they did not. Here they saw that even Jesus' hand-picked Twelve, who had already been commissioned and had already succeeded (6:7, 13), failed in public and had to ask why.

The scene teaches through contrast. The disciples frame their failure as a problem of their own ability ("we were not able"). The surrounding story frames it as a problem of faith (v. 19, "unbelieving generation"; v. 23–24, "I believe; help my unbelief!") and prayer (v. 29). Authority given by Jesus was not a possession they could use on their own. It worked through ongoing dependence on God. The setting of private teaching in a house also told Mark's readers that what follows is insider instruction for the community of followers, not a public pronouncement.

From the study of Mark 9:28.

Verse by verse

  1. 28After Jesus had gone into the house, His disciples asked Him privately, “Why couldn’t we drive it out?”

    Once Jesus had gone indoors, away from the crowd, the arguing scribes and the newly healed boy, his students came to him by themselves and kept pressing him with the question that had been burning since the failure: "Why were we, of all people, not able to throw it out?"

    The "we" is emphatic. These were the men Jesus had appointed "to have authority to drive out demons" (3:15), who had gone out in pairs and "drove out many demons" (6:13). This time, in public, in front of a desperate father and critical scribes, they had failed (9:18). They are not asking for a general lesson about spiritual things. They are apprentices asking the master why the tool did not work. "It" is the spirit (the Greek pronoun matches the neuter word for "spirit"), not the boy. The question picks up a word that runs through the whole scene, able / can. The father asked "if you can" (v. 22), Jesus answered that "all things are possible to the one who believes" (v. 23), and now the disciples confess "we were not able." Jesus' reply in the next verse ("this kind cannot come out except by prayer") moves the answer away from the disciples' own power and onto dependence on God.

    Full study →
  2. 29Jesus answered, “This kind cannot come out, except by prayer.”

    The disciples have just asked privately, "Why couldn't we throw it out?" Jesus answers: "This sort of spirit cannot be made to leave by any means at all, except by prayer."

    The wording rules out every alternative. By nothing (no command formula, no borrowed authority, no technique) except by prayer. "Kind" means a type of spirit, here the one that made the boy mute and deaf and tried to kill him. It does not mean a rank on a ladder of demonic strength. The verb "come out" is the same one Jesus used in his command ("Come out of him!") and the narrator used for the result ("it came out"). So Jesus is answering their "why couldn't we?" with what actually makes a spirit go.

    "Can" is the last of a series of words about ability that runs through the scene. The father said "if you can". Jesus answered that "all things are possible for one who believes". The disciples asked why they could not. Now Jesus says what can: prayer, meaning reliance on God rather than confidence in a power they thought they now held. Jesus himself did not stop to pray before commanding the spirit. That suggests the "prayer" he means is the dependence on God that his own authority rests on, rather than a phrase to add to the exorcism.

    Many later manuscripts read "by prayer and fasting". The earliest and best witnesses lack those words, and they were most likely added by scribes as the church came to value fasting more.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v28

    cast him out (KJV)

    ekbalein auto

    What we hear
    A modern reader of the KJV can take 'him' as the boy, as though the disciples were trying to throw the boy out, or can read 'him' as a statement about the spirit's personhood.
    What they heard
    'Throw it out': the neuter pronoun refers back to 'the spirit' (to pneuma, a neuter noun). The boy is the one being freed, not the one being expelled.
  • in v28

    disciples

    mathētai

    What we hear
    Christians in general, or any committed believer.
    What they heard
    Jesus' student-apprentices, a specific group. Here it means mainly the nine who stayed behind while Peter, James and John went up the mountain.
Every word
  1. Καὶ

    Kai · G2532

    and · v28, v29

    Mark's usual way of linking one scene to the next. It moves the story from the crowd in the open (vv. 14–27) to an indoor scene.

  2. εἰσελθόντος

    eiselthontos · G1525

    to go in, enter · v28

    'When he had gone in.' The participle describes an action already finished, and its construction makes the clause background: once Jesus is indoors, the real scene starts.

  3. αὐτοῦ

    autou · G0846

    he, him · v28, v29

    Jesus, the subject of 'having gone in.'

  4. εἰς

    eis · G1519

    into · v28

    Movement into a place: from the public road into a private space.

  5. οἶκον

    oikon · G3624

    house, home, household · v28

    There is no 'the' in Greek, so the phrase can mean 'into a house' or idiomatically 'indoors' or 'home.' Mark doesn't say whose house it is. In his Gospel the house is where Jesus explains things to his inner circle.

  6. οἱ

    hoi · G3588

    the · v28, v29

    The definite article, marking a known group: 'the disciples.'

  7. μαθηταὶ

    mathētai · G3101

    learner, pupil, apprentice · v28

    Jesus' student-followers. In context these are mainly the nine who stayed below while Peter, James and John were on the mountain (9:2), and they are the ones who failed (9:18).

  8. κατ᾽

    kat' · G2596

    according to, by · v28

    Combines with the next word in a fixed phrase meaning 'privately.'

  9. ἰδίαν

    idian · G2398

    one's own, private · v28

    With κατ᾽ it means 'by themselves, away from others.' This is one of Mark's recurring markers for teaching given only to the inner circle (4:34; 9:2; 13:3).

  10. ἐπηρώτων

    epērōtōn · G1905

    to ask, question · v28

    The Greek tense shows an action in progress: 'they began asking' or 'kept asking.' It suggests a pressing, puzzled inquiry rather than one passing question.

  11. ὅτι

    hoti · G3754

    that, because; (here) why? · v28

    Usually 'that' or 'because,' but Mark sometimes uses it to introduce a direct question with the sense 'why?' (compare 2:16 and 9:11).

  12. ἡμεῖς

    hēmeis · G2249

    we · v28

    Greek verbs already show who acts, so adding the pronoun is emphatic: 'we, of all people.' The stress points back to their earlier success (6:7, 13) and contrasts their failure with Jesus' success.

  13. οὐκ

    ouk · G3756

    not · v28

    A flat negation of fact: they simply did not manage it.

  14. ἠδυνήθημεν

    ēdunēthēmen · G1410

    to be able, have power to · v28, v29

    'We were not able.' The past tense views the failed attempt as one completed event. The word picks up the theme of ability that runs through the whole scene: 'if you can' (v. 22), 'all things are possible' (v. 23), 'this kind cannot' (v. 29).

  15. ἐκβαλεῖν

    ekbalein · G1544

    to throw out, drive out, expel · v28

    A forceful, ordinary verb for throwing or driving something out. It is the standard Gospel word for expelling an unclean spirit, the very task Jesus had sent them to do (3:15; 6:13).

  16. εἶπεν

    eipen · G2036

    he said · v29

    A simple past-tense "he said". This is Jesus' reply to the private question asked inside the house.

  17. τοῦτο

    touto · G3778

    this · v29

    Points back to the spirit that had just been expelled, the one that made the boy mute and deaf and threw him into fire and water (9:17–18, 22, 25).

  18. γένος

    genos · G1085

    kind, class, family, race · v29

    "Kind" in the sense of type or category, here a category of spirit. It describes what sort of spirit this is, not how strong it is.

  19. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in, by · v29

    Here it means "by means of", a use of "in" common in Greek shaped by Hebrew idiom.

  20. οὐδενὶ

    oudeni · G3762

    nothing, no one · v29

    "By nothing". It is emphatic and sweeping: no method, formula or technique will do it.

  21. ἐξελθεῖν

    exelthein · G1831

    to go out, come out · v29

    The standard word in exorcism stories for a spirit leaving its victim. It repeats Jesus' command "come out of him" and the report "it came out" (vv. 25–26). The grammar is active, so the spirit is the one doing the leaving.

  22. εἰ

    ei · G1487

    if · v29

    Combines with the next word to form "if not", meaning "except".

  23. μὴ

    mē · G3361

    not · v29

    Completes "except". The sentence works as "by nothing … except by", which shuts off every other means.

  24. προσευχῇ

    proseuchē · G4335

    prayer · v29

    Prayer addressed to God: asking and depending on him, as opposed to commanding by one's own authority or technique. The word has no article, so it names prayer as a kind of activity rather than a particular prayer.

  25. νηστείᾳ

    nēsteia · G3521

    fasting · v29

    Found only in later manuscripts. Probably a scribal addition, made at a time when the church increasingly paired prayer with fasting.

The world behind it

Exorcism in Jesus' world. First-century Jews took possession by unclean spirits for granted. Exorcists were known figures, and many worked by technique: incantations, names of power, objects. Josephus (Antiquities 8.45–49) describes a Jewish exorcist, Eleazar, who drew a demon out through a man's nose using a ring and a root and spells credited to Solomon. Acts 19:13–16 shows itinerant Jewish exorcists trying to use Jesus' name as a formula. Against that background, the disciples' question "why couldn't we?" naturally assumes something went wrong with method or power. Jesus' answer (v. 29) does not supply a better method.

Honour and shame. The failure happened in public, with scribes already arguing with the disciples (9:14). In an honour-based society a teacher was judged by his students, so their failure was a public embarrassment for Jesus' circle. Asking the question indoors and in private kept a sensitive matter among teacher and students.

Mark's pattern. Mark often follows a public event or saying with private explanation in a house or apart from the crowd (4:10, 34; 7:17; 10:10; 13:3). This verse is one of those moments. It also belongs to the section where Jesus is on the way to Jerusalem (8:27–10:52) and the disciples repeatedly misunderstand him. In the very next paragraph (9:38) they try to stop a stranger who was successfully driving out demons in Jesus' name, which is pointed irony after their own failure.

From the study of Mark 9:28.

Where scholars differ

in v28

What does the disciples' failure, which this question exposes, come down to?

  • A lack of faith or trust: the failure was spiritual, not technical.

    Jesus' outburst at the 'unbelieving generation' (9:19), the theme of belief in vv. 23–24, and Matthew's version of Jesus' answer, 'because of your little faith' (Matt 17:20).

  • A failure to depend on God in prayer: they treated their earlier commissioning as an ability they owned.

    Mark's own answer in v. 29 ('except by prayer'), and the fact that they had succeeded before (6:13). Nothing in Mark suggests that Jesus himself prayed a special prayer at this exorcism, so 'prayer' points to an ongoing posture of dependence rather than a formula.

  • A particularly resistant kind of spirit needed a special response.

    'This kind' (τοῦτο τὸ γένος, v. 29) suggests that spirits differ, and the boy's long-standing, severe condition (vv. 18, 21–22) is emphasised. Critics note that Mark's answer still points to prayer, not to a stronger technique.

in v29

Did Mark write "and fasting"?

  • No: it is an early scribal addition.

    It is absent from the two oldest complete manuscripts (Sinaiticus first hand, Vaticanus), from Old Latin k and from Clement of Alexandria. Scribes added fasting next to prayer in other passages (Acts 10:30; 1 Cor 7:5). The shorter reading explains how the longer one arose, but not the reverse. It also fits Mark 2:18–20, where Jesus' disciples do not fast. This is the view of NA28/UBS5 and Metzger, and of most modern commentators.

  • Yes: the longer reading is original or at least deserves serious consideration.

    It is attested very early (apparently Papyrus 45, 3rd century) and very widely across regions, versions and the great majority of manuscripts. Majority-text advocates argue that a few Alexandrian manuscripts may have shortened it, perhaps because of the tension with Mark 2:18–20.

in v29

What does "by prayer" mean, since Jesus does not pray during the exorcism?

  • An ongoing life of prayer and dependence on God, not a prayer at the moment.

    Jesus simply commands the spirit (v. 25). Mark shows him withdrawing to pray (1:35; 6:46). The disciples' question "why could *we* not?" suggests they relied on authority they thought they owned (6:7, 13).

  • Prayer offered during the exorcism itself, which the disciples left out.

    Jewish tradition included exorcism by prayer (1QapGen XX 28–29). Read this way, the disciples tried to command where they should have asked.

  • Prayer here stands for faith expressed toward God; the two are inseparable.

    The scene stresses believing (vv. 19, 23–24). Matthew's parallel gives "little faith" as the reason (Matt 17:20). Mark later joins faith and prayer explicitly (11:22–24).

in v29

How wide is "this kind"?

  • A particular class of especially destructive spirits, like this mute and deaf one.

    The demonstrative "this" points back to the specific spirit. Mark stresses how severe the case was (vv. 18, 20–22, 26). Ancient thought sorted spirits into types.

  • Spirits of this whole type, meaning hostile spiritual powers in general, so the principle applies to all exorcism.

    The sweeping "by nothing … except" states a general principle. The disciples' earlier successes also count as God's work, not technique.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. ἐκβάλλω, δύναμαι, ἴδιος, ἐπερωτάω, ὅτι
  • Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. κατ' ἰδίαν
  • Josephus, Antiquities 8.45–49 (Eleazar the exorcist)
  • Tobit 8:1–3; Acts 19:13–16
  • Matthew 17:19–20; Luke 9:37–43 (parallels)
  • Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Mark 9:29
  • R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark (NIGTC)
  • Craig S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Mark 9:14–29
  • Nestle–Aland, Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Mark 9:29
  • Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, 2nd ed., on Mark 9:29 and Matt 17:21
  • BDAG s.v. γένος
  • BDAG s.v. προσευχή
  • BDAG s.v. νηστεία
  • BDAG s.v. δύναμαι
  • BDAG s.v. ἐξέρχομαι
  • Josephus, Antiquities 8.45–49 (Eleazar the exorcist); Life 277
  • Philo, Against Flaccus 41, 45
  • Genesis Apocryphon (1QapGen) XX 28–29
  • Tobit 6–8; 12:8
  • Didache 8:1
  • Greek Magical Papyri, PGM IV.1227–1264
  • Joel Marcus, Mark 8–16 (Anchor Yale Bible)
  • Adela Yarbro Collins, Mark (Hermeneia)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).