Matthew Chapter 18 Read as one passage

Matthew 18:15–20

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

15If your brother sins against you, go and confront him privately. If he listens to you, you have won your brother over. 16But if he will not listen, take one or two others along, so that ‘every matter may be established by the testimony of two or three witnesses.’ 17If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church. And if he refuses to listen even to the church, regard him as you would a pagan or a tax collector. 18Truly I tell you, whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven. 19Again, I tell you truly that if two of you on the earth agree about anything you ask for, it will be done for you by My Father in heaven. 20For where two or three gather together in My name, there am I with them.”

What the first hearers heard

To Jesus' disciples, and later to the Jewish-Christian congregations Matthew wrote for, this verse did several things:

  • It made the wronged person responsible for taking the first step. They do not wait for the offender to apologize. They go to him. This matches Matthew 5:23–24, where the person who knows he is in the wrong must go and be reconciled before offering a gift. Whichever side you are on, you go.
  • It ruled out two easy alternatives: quiet resentment, which Leviticus 19:17 calls hating your brother in your heart, and gossip or public accusation. The private setting keeps the matter small and the offender's honor intact.
  • It defined success as the brother regained. Success is not an apology received or a point proven. After the lost-sheep parable, hearers would picture the shepherd carrying the sheep home. 'You have gained your brother' is the same joy at the scale of one conversation.
  • It began a community process (vv.16–17) that Jewish hearers knew from synagogue and sectarian practice. Its first and best outcome is that nothing more is needed.
  • It belonged to a community of mutual responsibility. In Israel's tradition, failing to reprove made you share the guilt ('you shall not bear sin because of him', Lev 19:17). Caring whether your brother stays in the way was everyone's duty.

From the study of Matthew 18:15.

Verse by verse

  1. 15If your brother sins against you, go and confront him privately. If he listens to you, you have won your brother over.

    "And if your brother, one of your own family of disciples, actually does wrong (and some early copies say 'does wrong against you'), don't wait for him and don't talk about him. Go to him yourself. Bring the wrong into the open in a way that helps him see it for what it is, with just the two of you there and nobody else, so his honor is protected and his way back is as easy as it can be. If he takes your words to heart, you have made a real gain: your brother, who was in danger of being lost, is yours again."

    The verse follows straight on from the shepherd who leaves ninety-nine sheep to find one, and from the Father who does not want a single 'little one' to be lost (vv.12–14). So the private conversation is the first step of a rescue, not of a prosecution. Behind it is Leviticus 19:17–18: do not hate your brother in your heart; reprove him, so that you do not share his guilt; love your neighbor as yourself. In Jesus' hands, speaking honestly to the person himself and in private is a form of that love. The opposites are silent resentment and public exposure.

    Full study →
  2. 16But if he will not listen, take one or two others along, so that ‘every matter may be established by the testimony of two or three witnesses.’

    "But if he will not listen to you — will not take your correction to heart — then go back, and take one or two more people with you. That way, as the Law of Moses says, every matter will stand or fall on the spoken testimony of two or three witnesses."

    Jesus is describing the second of three steps (vv. 15–17) for dealing with a fellow member of the community who has sinned. Step one was a private conversation aimed at "winning back" your brother. If that fails, the circle grows only slightly: one or two more people, so that, counting you, there are two or three. The reason he gives is a quotation of Deuteronomy 19:15. That was Israel's basic rule of evidence: no one could be found guilty on the word of a single accuser. "On the mouth of" is a Hebrew way of saying "on the testimony of." "Every matter" translates a word (rhēma, standing for Hebrew dabar) that here means the case or charge in dispute, not a single spoken word. To "stand" is the courtroom sense of a charge holding up as valid.

    The companions serve two purposes at once. They protect the community from acting on one person's grievance. They also protect the accused from being condemned on one person's version of events. And if the matter has to go before the whole assembly (v. 17), they can confirm what happened: what was said and how he responded. The aim from start to finish is still the one stated in v. 15: to regain the brother. The witnesses are a safeguard on the way to that, not a prosecution team.

    Full study →
  3. 17If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church. And if he refuses to listen even to the church, regard him as you would a pagan or a tax collector.

    "But if he hears them and still brushes them aside, refusing to take the correction to heart, then lay the whole matter before the gathered community of disciples. And if he brushes aside even the assembly itself, then let him stand, in your eyes, exactly where the Gentile and the tax-farmer stand: outside the family table, no longer treated as a brother within the fellowship."

    The verse is the last step of a carefully graded process (vv.15–17). It starts privately to protect his honour. Then come one or two witnesses, as Deuteronomy 19:15 requires. Only then does the whole community hear the case. At every stage the hope is that he will listen; the verb for his failure means hearing and refusing to heed. "Church" here means the people gathered in Jesus' name, not a building or a body of officials. "Gentile and tax collector" was a familiar pair for outsiders. One was a non-Jew outside the covenant people. The other was a Jewish toll contractor, seen as a collaborator and a cheat, whom respectable people shunned. The pronoun "you" is singular, so the verdict lands on the wronged person's own relationship with the offender. Yet the hearers of Matthew's Gospel knew that Jesus ate with tax collectors, that the apostle Matthew had been one, and that the nations were to be made disciples. The passage is framed by the shepherd searching for one lost sheep (vv.12–14) and by forgiveness "seventy-seven times" (vv.21–35). So the line marks a real break in fellowship, and it leaves the door open for his return.

    Full study →
  4. 18Truly I tell you, whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven.

    "I tell you this solemnly, and I stand behind it: whatever matters you, as my gathered community, declare binding on earth, forbidding them or holding a person to account for them, will stand as bound before God. And whatever you release on earth, permitting it or freeing a person from the charge and its consequences, will stand as released before God."

    The disciples would have recognised "bind" and "loose" as the everyday vocabulary of Jewish legal authority. Teachers "bound" (forbade, made obligatory) and "loosed" (permitted, released). Courts "bound" an offender under a ban of exclusion and "loosed" him when he was restored. Jesus gives this authority not to one rabbi or council but to "you" plural, the community he has just described in verse 17, which must deal with a member who sins and refuses correction.

    The verbs on the heavenly side are in an unusual form, "will be in the state of having been bound/loosed". The verdict, when rightly given, is a settled matter that God himself recognises. "Heaven" is a reverent way of saying "God". The surrounding verses keep this from becoming a blank cheque. It comes after a patient, private, step-by-step attempt to win the brother back (vv. 15–17). It is tied to agreement in prayer to "my Father" and to Jesus' own presence among those gathered in his name (vv. 19–20). And the chapter immediately turns to forgiving "seventy-seven times" (vv. 21–35).

    Full study →
  5. 19Again, I tell you truly that if two of you on the earth agree about anything you ask for, it will be done for you by My Father in heaven.

    "And again, I solemnly assure you, by my own word: if two of you here on earth come into real agreement, reaching one mind about any matter you are dealing with, then whatever you ask about it will become reality for you. It will come from my Father, the one in the heavens."

    Jesus says this immediately after telling the disciples how to deal with a brother who has wronged them: first privately, then with one or two witnesses, then before the assembly (18:15–17). He then says that what they bind and loose on earth will be bound and loosed in heaven (18:18). Verse 19 says the same thing again in the language of prayer. "Two" recalls the two witnesses the Law required. "Agree" (symphōneō, "sound together") means reaching a real accord, the way parties settle terms. "Matter" (pragma) is the word for an affair or a case. The promise is that when disciples, even a group as small as two, come to one mind over a matter before God and ask him about it, the Father himself will stand behind it. Verse 20 gives the reason: Jesus himself is present where they gather in his name. The wording is broad ("any matter"), so the promise is not limited to legal cases. But its first home is a community trying to settle a wrong and win back an erring member, and the Father it names is the one who "is not willing that one of these little ones should perish" (18:14).

    Full study →
  6. 20For where two or three gather together in My name, there am I with them.”

    "Because wherever even two or three of you have come together and stand assembled as people who belong to me, gathered under my name and authority, I am right there at the centre of you."

    The verse gives the reason for the promise just before it (v. 19). The Father will act on what two disciples agree about because Jesus himself is present among them. "Two or three" is not a random small number. It is the phrase from the law of witnesses that Jesus has just quoted (v. 16, from Deuteronomy 19:15): the smallest group whose word counts. "Gathered" translates the verb behind "synagogue", and its tense describes a group that has assembled and remains so. "Into my name" means gathered as his and on his authority, not simply saying his name. "I am in the midst" is in the present tense, a statement of fact rather than a promise to arrive. It uses the language the Old Testament used for God dwelling "in the midst" of Israel's camp and tabernacle. Jewish teachers said God's presence rests on two who study Torah together. Jesus says he is that presence, among a group gathered in his name.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v15

    brother

    adelphos

    What we hear
    A male sibling, or only male church members.
    What they heard
    Any fellow disciple in Jesus' family (Matt 12:50), men and women alike. A family word that puts the offender inside the circle, not against it.
  • in v15

    confront (BSB); tell him his fault (KJV)

    elenchō

    What we hear
    A showdown: stating your grievance or getting something off your chest.
    What they heard
    To bring the wrong into the light so the other person sees it and is convinced. It is the Torah's loving reproof of Lev 19:17, measured by whether he 'listens'.
  • in v16

    every word (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    pan rhēma

    What we hear
    Each spoken word, or a 'word' from God: a message, prophecy or teaching that needs confirming.
    What they heard
    Every matter, case or charge in a dispute, the way Hebrew dabar is used in Deut 19:15 ('any iniquity or any sin').
  • in v17

    church

    ekklēsia

    What we hear
    A building, a denomination, or the leadership: "take it to the church" heard as "take it to the pastor or elders".
    What they heard
    The gathered assembly of Jesus' disciples, acting together as a community.
  • in v17

    pagan / heathen

    ethnikos

    What we hear
    A person of non-Christian or nature religion, an irreligious person, or (with "heathen") someone uncivilised.
    What they heard
    A Gentile: a non-Israelite, outside the covenant community, with whom close table fellowship was not normally shared.
  • in v17

    publican

    telōnēs

    What we hear
    (British English) the landlord of a pub.
    What they heard
    A toll or tax contractor, despised as a collaborator and extortioner.
  • in v17

    tax collector

    telōnēs

    What we hear
    A salaried civil servant in a government revenue office, unpopular perhaps but respectable.
    What they heard
    A local contractor who bought collection rights and profited by collecting more. He was assumed to be dishonest, socially shunned and ritually suspect.
  • in v18

    bind / loose

    deō / luō

    What we hear
    To restrain demons or Satan by spoken command, and to 'release' blessings, angels or provision.
    What they heard
    To declare forbidden or permitted, to hold someone under discipline, or to release them from it. It is the ordinary language of Jewish legal and community authority.
  • in v18

    you

    humin / dēsēte (2nd person plural)

    What we hear
    Any individual believer acting on their own.
    What they heard
    'You all', the gathered community just named in v. 17 ('tell it to the church'), acting together under Jesus' name (vv. 19–20).
  • in v18

    in heaven

    en ouranō

    What we hear
    A place: things are tied up or released 'up there' in the afterlife realm.
    What they heard
    Before God. 'Heaven' was a reverent stand-in for God's name. The decision is valid with God.
  • in v19

    agree

    symphōneō

    What we hear
    Two people mentally line up behind the same prayer request (the 'prayer of agreement').
    What they heard
    To be in harmony, to come to a settled accord between parties, as when workers and employer 'agree' on a wage (20:2). Here it is unity reached among disciples, in a passage about settling a wrong.
  • in v19

    anything

    pan pragma

    What we hear
    Any item at all that two people might want.
    What they heard
    'Any matter / affair', with pragma also the normal word for a case or dispute. It is broad, but rooted in the matters the community is handling.
  • in v20

    where two or three are gathered

    duo ē treis synēgmenoi

    What we hear
    A general comment on small meetings, often used to reassure a church with low attendance, or as a minimum for Jesus to be present at a prayer meeting.
    What they heard
    The witness formula from Deuteronomy 19:15, just quoted in v. 16. It describes the smallest valid group of disciples acting together, here in the setting of dealing with a sinning member and reaching agreement (vv. 15–19).
  • in v20

    in my name

    eis to emon onoma

    What we hear
    Saying 'in Jesus' name', for example as the closing words of a prayer.
    What they heard
    'Into my name': gathered as belonging to Jesus and under his authority. The name stands for the person.
Every word
  1. Ἐὰν

    Ean · G1437

    if · v15, v16, v17, v18, v19

    Introduces a condition that may well happen: 'if, as can occur'. Jesus treats sin between disciples as something to expect, not something unthinkable.

  2. δὲ

    de · G1161

    but, and, now · v15, v16, v17

    A light link to what came before. It moves from the Father not wanting one of the 'little ones' to be lost (v.14) to what a disciple must do when a fellow disciple goes astray.

  3. ἁμαρτήσῃ

    hamartēsē · G0264

    to sin, do wrong · v15

    Aorist subjunctive: a particular act of wrongdoing, not a general sinful condition. It means a real wrong, not a slight or a difference of opinion.

  4. εἰς

    eis · G1519

    into, toward, against · v15, v20

    With a verb of sinning it marks the injured party: 'against'. The phrase it begins is textually uncertain (see variants).

  5. σὲ

    se · G4771

    you · v15, v16, v17, v18, v19

    Singular. Jesus speaks to each disciple personally, even though the chapter is about the community.

  6. ὁ

    ho · G3588

    the · v15, v17, v18, v19, v20

    Definite article with 'brother'. In Greek it naturally goes with the possessive: 'your brother'.

  7. ἀδελφός

    adelphos · G0080

    brother · v15

    A fellow member of Jesus' family of disciples (cf. Matt 12:49–50; 23:8). It is not limited to blood relatives or to men. The word sets the tone: this is family business.

  8. ὕπαγε

    hupage · G5217

    go, go away · v15

    Present imperative: 'go'. You take the first step and go to him. You do not wait for him to come to you or talk about him to others. Used without 'and' before the next command, as often in Matthew ('go, show yourself', 8:4).

  9. ἔλεγξον

    elegxon · G1651

    to expose, convict, reprove · v15

    Aorist imperative: bring the wrong into the light so that he sees it for what it is. The goal is that he recognizes it, not that you vent or win a debate. It echoes Leviticus 19:17 in the Greek Old Testament.

  10. αὐτὸν

    auton · G0846

    him · v15, v17, v19, v20

    The brother himself is spoken to directly, not spoken about.

  11. μεταξὺ

    metaxu · G3342

    between · v15

    'Between you and him' sounds like the Hebrew idiom 'between me and between you'. It marks a private space shared by two people.

  12. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v15, v17, v18

    Joins the two parties.

  13. μόνου.

    monou · G3441

    alone, only · v15

    'Alone' makes it emphatic: no audience at all. This protects the offender's honor and gives him the easiest possible way back.

  14. ἀκούσῃ,

    akousē · G0191

    to hear, listen, heed · v15, v16

    Here it means to take it to heart and accept the correction, like the Hebrew shama' ('hear and obey'). Hearing the sound of the words is not enough. The opposite in v.16–17 is refusing to listen.

  15. ἐκέρδησας

    ekerdēsas · G2770

    to gain, profit, win · v15

    A word from trade: 'you have made a gain'. The past tense after an 'if' clause speaks of the result as already done. The moment he listens, the brother is won back. It is the reverse of 'perish/be lost' in v.14.

  16. μὴ

    mē · G3361

    not · v16

    The negative used in conditions: 'if he does not…'.

  17. παράλαβε

    paralabe · G3880

    to take along · v16

    A command to one person: 'take along with you', bring companions on the next visit. The same verb is used of Jesus taking Peter, James and John with him (Matt 17:1; 26:37).

  18. μετὰ

    meta · G3326

    with · v16

    'In company with': the companions go together with the person who was wronged.

  19. ἔτι

    eti · G2089

    still, yet, in addition · v16

    'Besides yourself' or 'more'. One or two are added to you, so the total is two or three, the number the quotation needs.

  20. ἕνα

    hena · G1520

    one · v16

    One person, the smallest addition. With you, that makes two.

  21. ἢ

    ē · G2228

    or · v16, v20

    Leaves the number open: one or two, as needed.

  22. δύο,

    duo · G1417

    two · v16, v19, v20

    Two people. With you, that makes three. The circle grows only a little, and it stays small.

  23. ἵνα

    hina · G2443

    so that, in order that · v16

    Gives the reason for bringing companions. What follows is a quotation of the Law (Deut 19:15).

  24. ἐπὶ

    epi · G1909

    upon, on the basis of · v16, v18, v19

    'On the basis of'. The matter rests on the testimony. This is Hebrew 'al-pi, 'on the mouth of', carried over word for word.

  25. στόματος

    stomatos · G4750

    mouth · v16

    'Mouth' stands for what a mouth says: spoken testimony. 'On the mouth of two witnesses' means 'on the spoken testimony of two witnesses'.

  26. μαρτύρων

    martyrōn · G3144

    witness · v16

    A legal witness: someone whose testimony can confirm or disprove a claim before a community or court. It has nothing yet of the later sense 'martyr'.

  27. τριῶν

    triōn · G5140

    three · v16, v20

    The fuller count. Three witnesses make the case stronger still.

  28. σταθῇ

    stathē · G2476

    to stand; be established · v16

    'May stand': hold up, be confirmed as valid. This translates Hebrew yaqum ('it shall stand'), used of a charge that holds up in court. The idea is valid confirmation, not making something stronger.

  29. πᾶν

    pan · G3956

    every, all · v16, v19

    'Every'. No matter is exempt from needing corroboration.

  30. ῥῆμα.

    rhēma · G4487

    word, saying; matter, thing · v16

    Here ῥῆμα stands for Hebrew dabar in its legal sense: the matter, case or charge under dispute. It does not mean a single 'word' that was spoken.

  31. παρακούσῃ

    parakousē · G3878

    to ignore, refuse to heed · v17

    Literally "to hear past" someone. It means refusing to take the warning to heart. In vv.15–16 the hope was that he would "listen" (akousē). Now he hears the words and brushes them aside.

  32. εἰπὲ

    eipe · G2036

    say, tell · v17

    A direct command to the wronged person ("you", singular): tell it. The Greek has no object, but "the matter" is understood: the whole case set out so far.

  33. ἐκκλησίᾳ

    ekklēsia · G1577

    assembly, congregation · v17

    The gathered community of Jesus' disciples, acting as a body. It is not a building and not a separate class of leaders. The case goes before the whole fellowship.

  34. ἔστω

    estō · G1510

    let him be · v17, v18, v20

    A third-person command ("let him be"). It describes how he is now to be regarded. It does not tell anyone to act violently against him or to punish him.

  35. ὥσπερ

    hōsper · G5618

    just as, exactly like · v17

    A strengthened "as": regard him the way people regard such figures. It compares his standing in the community; it is not a statement about his final fate.

  36. ἐθνικὸς

    ethnikos · G1482

    Gentile, belonging to the nations · v17

    A non-Jew, someone outside Israel's covenant community. For Jewish hearers this meant someone you would not normally share a table with in close fellowship. It was a label for an outsider, not a description of what he worshipped.

  37. τελώνης

    telōnēs · G5057

    toll collector, tax farmer · v17

    A local contractor who collected tolls and duties for the ruling power. People saw him as a collaborator and an extortioner, and kept him out of respectable Jewish social life. The Gentile was the outsider from beyond Israel; the tax collector was the Jew who had put himself outside it.

  38. Ἀμὴν

    Amēn · G0281

    amen, truly · v18, v19

    A Hebrew word meaning 'firm, reliable'. Jesus puts it at the start of a saying, not the end, which was unusual. It marks what follows as a solemn statement he personally guarantees.

  39. λέγω

    legō · G3004G

    I say · v18, v19

    Present tense, first person. Together with 'Amen' it forms Jesus' formula of authority: 'I tell you solemnly.'

  40. ὅσα

    hosa · G3745

    as many things as, whatever · v18

    Neuter plural: 'whatever things'. The grammar points to matters, cases or rulings rather than directly to persons, although in this context the 'thing' being decided is how to deal with a sinning brother.

  41. δήσητε

    dēsēte · G1210

    you bind · v18

    Aorist subjunctive, second person plural: 'you (all) bind'. In Jewish legal speech of the time, 'bind' meant to declare something forbidden or binding, or to place someone under discipline.

  42. γῆς,

    gēs · G1093G

    earth · v18, v19

    The earthly realm, set against 'heaven'. The pair echoes the Lord's Prayer: 'on earth as in heaven' (6:10).

  43. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in · v18, v19, v20

    'In' heaven, meaning in God's realm and before his court.

  44. οὐρανῷ·

    ouranō · G3772

    heaven · v18, v19

    God's realm. Jews often said 'heaven' as a respectful way of referring to God himself, so 'bound in heaven' means 'recognised as bound by God'.

  45. λύσητε

    lusēte · G3089

    you loose, release · v18

    Aorist subjunctive, second person plural. It is the opposite of 'bind': to declare something permitted, to release someone from an obligation or a ban, or (as the context suggests) to release someone from the guilt of sin.

  46. Πάλιν

    Palin · G3825

    again · v19

    Marks a further saying added to the one just given (v. 18). It shows that v. 19 builds on the binding-and-loosing promise instead of starting a new subject.

  47. ὅτι

    hoti · G3754

    that · v19

    Introduces what Jesus says.

  48. συμφωνήσωσιν

    sumphōnēsōsin · G4856

    agree, be in harmony, come to terms · v19

    Literally 'sound together'. It means reaching real accord, often a settled agreement on terms (as in 20:2, 13), not just both saying yes to the same prayer request. The aorist tense views it as an agreement actually reached.

  49. περὶ

    peri · G4012

    concerning, about · v19

    Names the subject of their agreement.

  50. πράγματος

    pragmatos · G4229

    matter, affair, thing; case · v19

    A deed, affair or business. It is also a normal word for a legal case or dispute (1 Cor 6:1). In a passage about settling a wrong between members, 'matter' or 'case' fits better than 'any item'.

  51. οὗ

    hou · G3739

    which · v19

    'Which', put in the genitive to match 'matter'. It ties the request to the matter they have agreed about.

  52. αἰτήσωνται

    aitēsōntai · G0154

    ask, request · v19

    The ordinary word for asking, used of prayer in 7:7–11 and 21:22. The middle form ('ask for oneself') is common and should not be pressed for special meaning. The subject switches to 'they', the two who agree.

  53. γενήσεται

    genēsetai · G1096

    it will come to be, happen · v19

    Future: 'it will come about'. The request will become reality, and the Father is its source.

  54. παρὰ

    para · G3844

    from (beside) · v19

    Marks the source: it comes from the Father's side.

  55. πατρός

    patros · G3962

    father · v19

    God as Father. In Matthew this is relational language, often used for the Father's care for his household of disciples (18:10, 14).

  56. μου

    mou · G3165

    my · v19

    'My Father'. Jesus speaks as the Son with a unique relationship, and his word guarantees the promise.

  57. οὗ

    hou · G3757

    where · v20

    A relative adverb of place: 'where', or 'in whatever place'. It makes the promise apply to any place the condition is met, not to one sacred site.

  58. γάρ

    gar · G1063

    for, because · v20

    Ties this verse to v. 19 as its reason. The Father will act on what two disciples agree on *because* Jesus himself is present among them.

  59. συνηγμένοι

    synēgmenoi · G4863

    gathered, assembled · v20

    A perfect passive participle: 'having been gathered', so 'assembled'. It describes a group that has come together and stays together. The verb is the root of 'synagogue', so it hints at a small congregation.

  60. ἐμὸν

    emon · G1699

    my, mine · v20

    The possessive adjective 'my'. It is a little more emphatic than the usual Greek 'of me' (mou) and puts weight on *Jesus'* name in particular.

  61. ὄνομα

    onoma · G3686

    name · v20

    In biblical usage a name stands for the person: his identity, authority and presence. To be gathered 'into his name' means gathering as his, under his authority. It is not a matter of saying a formula.

  62. ἐκεῖ

    ekei · G1563

    there · v20

    'There', answering 'where' at the start of the verse. Wherever the condition is met, that is where the presence is.

  63. μέσῳ

    mesō · G3319

    middle, midst · v20

    'In the middle'. Jesus places himself at the centre of the group. This is the language the Greek Old Testament uses for God dwelling 'in the midst' of Israel and its camp.

The world behind it

Reproof was a Torah duty. Leviticus 19:17 commands Israelites to reprove a fellow Israelite rather than nurse hatred. Jewish groups of Jesus' day turned this into procedure. The Qumran community required members to reprove one another 'in truth, humility and loving-kindness', on the same day, without anger, and before witnesses before any charge could go to the full assembly (1QS 5:24–6:1; CD 9:2–8). Sirach 19:13–17 tells the reader to question a friend before believing the worst. Later rabbis debated how far reproof must go without shaming the person (Sifra on Lev 19:17; b. Arakhin 16b). First-century hearers would have recognized Jesus' steps (private, then with witnesses, then the assembly) as a familiar Jewish pattern, made gentler and aimed at restoration.

Honor and shame. In a Mediterranean village or a close-knit synagogue, public accusation could destroy a person's standing for good. 'Between you and him alone' lets the offender admit the wrong without losing face before others. The person who was wronged gives up the satisfaction of a public hearing to keep the brother.

Witnesses. The next verse quotes Deuteronomy 19:15 ('two or three witnesses'), the Torah's rule for establishing a charge. So verse 15 is the stage before any formal process, where it can still be settled quietly.

Placement in Matthew 18. The chapter is Jesus' teaching on life together among his followers: become like children (vv.1–5), do not cause little ones to stumble (vv.6–9), seek the strayed sheep (vv.10–14), win back the sinning brother (vv.15–17), the community's authority to bind and loose (vv.18–20), and forgiveness without limit (vv.21–35). Verse 15 sits between the lost sheep and Peter's question about forgiving 'seventy-seven times'.

From the study of Matthew 18:15.

Where scholars differ

in v15

Did Matthew write 'sins against you' or simply 'sins'?

  • 'Against you' is original.

    Broad and early spread across Greek, Latin and Syriac witnesses (D, W, Old Latin, Vulgate, Syriac). Accidental omission is plausible because the endings sounded alike. Fits v.21 'sin against me'.

  • 'Against you' is a later addition.

    Missing from א and B, the two oldest complete manuscripts, and from Origen. Scribes tended to harmonize with v.21. The shorter reading fits the context of seeking the straying one (vv.12–14) and the parallel in Luke 17:3.

in v15

Is the verse about personal offenses or about a disciple's sin in general?

  • Personal offenses between two disciples.

    'Against you', the private setting ('between you and him'), and Peter's follow-up about forgiving one who sins 'against me' (v.21).

  • Any sin by a fellow member, which every disciple shares responsibility to address.

    The shorter text. The lost-sheep context. Lev 19:17 and Qumran parallels, which concern a neighbor's sin generally. The community procedure in vv.16–18.

in v15

Do vv.15–17 come from Jesus or reflect the rules of Matthew's church?

  • Substantially Jesus' teaching, which Matthew arranged.

    Luke 17:3 independently attests the core command to reprove a sinning brother. The Jewish background (Lev 19:17, Qumran) shows such teaching fits Jesus' setting.

  • Matthew's congregation developed it into a church-discipline procedure.

    Only Matthew has the three steps. 'Church' (ἐκκλησία, v.17) assumes a settled community. The 'Gentile and tax collector' language assumes a Jewish-Christian group. Some critical scholars (e.g., Luz) see community rules shaped by Jewish models.

in v16

What exactly are the 'one or two' witnesses there to witness?

  • They witness the conversation and the brother's response. If he refuses to listen, they can confirm to the assembly (v.17) that he was rightly approached and refused.

    The companions are recruited only after the private talk. They may not have seen the original offence, which often happens between two people. v.17 ('if he refuses to listen to *them*') shows that they take part in the reproof itself. This is the most common view in major commentaries (e.g., France, Davies & Allison).

  • They are witnesses to the original offence, in the strict sense of Deut 19:15, so the charge can stand.

    In Deut 19:15 the witnesses are witnesses of the crime ('for any iniquity or any sin'). Qumran's Damascus Document (CD 9) also counts witnesses to the offence. The weakness: Jesus tells the wronged person to 'take along' companions, which is hard to square with people who already saw the sin.

  • They act mainly as mediators or added persuasion, to help the brother see sense and to check the accuser as well.

    The aim of the whole passage is to 'gain' the brother (v.15), and the context stresses restoring the stray (vv.12–14). Their presence may persuade the brother, or show the accuser that he is mistaken. This view is often combined with the first.

in v17

What does "let him be to you as the Gentile and the tax collector" require?

  • Exclusion from the community's fellowship: he is no longer treated as a brother at the shared table or in worship.

    Matthew elsewhere uses Gentiles and tax collectors as a negative contrast (5:46–47; 6:7). The close Qumran parallel (1QS 5:24–6:1) leads to exclusion measures. Paul gives parallel instructions: "not even to eat with such a one" (1 Cor 5:11–13), "have nothing to do with him" (2 Thess 3:14), "have nothing more to do with him" (Titus 3:10). Major commentaries (Davies & Allison, Luz, France, Keener) read the primary sense as separation.

  • A deliberately ironic or missional sense: treat him as Jesus treated Gentiles and tax collectors, as people to be sought and won.

    Jesus ate with tax collectors (9:10–13), was called their friend (11:19), and called Matthew, a tax collector (9:9; 10:3). Tax collectors enter the kingdom (21:31). The Gospel ends with the mission to all nations (28:19). The surrounding passage is about seeking the one lost sheep (18:12–14) and limitless forgiveness (18:21–35).

  • Both together: a real break in fellowship whose aim is restoration.

    Paul pairs exclusion with the goal of salvation (1 Cor 5:5) and adds "do not regard him as an enemy but warn him as a brother" (2 Thess 3:15). The parable just before (18:12–14) and the forgiveness teaching just after frame the verdict as remedial. Most commentators who stress exclusion also note this context.

in v17

Did Jesus speak of an "ekklēsia", and what body is meant?

  • The wording reflects the post-Easter community of Matthew's Gospel, which adapted Jesus' teaching on rebuke and forgiveness into a church rule.

    Luke 17:3–4 has the simpler saying with no assembly step. "Ekklēsia" appears in no other Gospel. The procedure fits an organised, settled community.

  • The saying can go back to Jesus, using a familiar Jewish idea of a congregation (qāhāl/ʿēdâ/kenishtā) for his band of disciples.

    Jewish groups already had such procedures (Qumran, synagogue discipline), based on Lev 19:17 and Deut 19:15. A teacher forming a renewed Israel around twelve disciples could naturally speak of "the congregation".

in v17

Who carries out the verdict: the individual or the community?

  • The individual: the singular "to you" describes the wronged person's own relationship with the offender.

    "Let him be to you" (soi) is singular, continuing the singular "you" of vv.15–17.

  • The community: the assembly's decision stands, and v.18's plural binding and loosing makes it a communal act.

    The verdict follows the assembly's hearing. Verse 18 switches to the plural "you", and v.20 places Jesus among those gathered.

in v18

What exactly is being 'bound' and 'loosed'?

  • Legal rulings: declaring conduct forbidden or permitted.

    This is the standard meaning of *asar / hittir* in the Mishnah and Talmud. Josephus *War* 1.111 also fits it. It suits the neuter 'whatever things'. Matthew uses λύω for 'relaxing' a commandment in 5:19, and his community needed authority to interpret Torah (compare 23:2–4).

  • Discipline: binding a person under exclusion or releasing them, which amounts to retaining or forgiving sins.

    The immediate context (vv. 15–17) is about a sinning member. Rabbinic texts speak of binding with the ban (*nidduy*). John 20:23 makes a close parallel about forgiving and retaining sins. The chapter ends with a long treatment of forgiveness (vv. 21–35). Many commentators (e.g., Davies & Allison, Carson) hold that in 18:18 the discipline sense is primary, while the ruling sense may be more prominent in 16:19.

  • Binding and loosing of demonic powers (an exorcistic sense).

    Matthew 12:29 speaks of 'binding the strong man'. Ancient Greek magical texts and Jewish demonology use 'binding' for restraining spirits, and Luke 13:16 speaks of a woman 'bound' by Satan. R. H. Hiers (JBL 1985) argued for this background. Most scholars find it a poor fit for 18:18, where the context is community discipline and the object is neuter 'things'.

in v18

Does the future perfect mean heaven decides first and the church follows, or the church decides and heaven ratifies?

  • Heaven's prior decision: 'will have already been bound'.

    Taken strictly, the perfect participle with ἔσται describes a state already in place by the time of the future. J. R. Mantey and others argued that the disciples can only declare what God has already determined, and NASB and WEB translate accordingly.

  • Heaven ratifies the community's decision, with the stress on its permanence rather than on which comes first.

    H. J. Cadbury (JBL 1939) and later studies of Greek verbal aspect argue that this construction stresses a settled, lasting state ('will stand bound') rather than timing. Several Greek grammarians question whether Koine future perfects carry a strong 'already' sense. Verses 19–20 tie the outcome to prayer and Christ's presence rather than to discovering decisions already recorded.

in v18

How does this relate to Peter's 'keys' in 16:19?

  • Peter holds a unique or foundational authority that 18:18 then extends to the community.

    16:19 is singular and comes with 'the keys of the kingdom' (echoing Isa 22:22, the steward's keys). Peter's prominence elsewhere in Matthew (10:2 'first').

  • Peter in 16:19 represents the disciples, and 18:18 shows the same authority belongs to them all.

    The wording of 18:18 is identical but plural. The same form is given here to the whole gathered community (v. 17), and Matthew often presents Peter as spokesman for the Twelve.

in v19

What is the scope of 'any matter … whatever they ask'?

  • A general promise about united prayer, placed here by Matthew but applying to any request.

    'Again' can introduce an added saying; aiteō is ordinary prayer language (7:7–11; 21:22); 'every matter' is broad. Many commentators (e.g., Davies & Allison) think vv. 19–20 may once have circulated as a separate saying.

  • Mainly about the community's decisions in discipline cases, restating v. 18 as prayer.

    Immediate context (vv. 15–18); 'two' echoes the two witnesses (v. 16; Deut 19:15); pragma can mean 'case'; the earth/heaven pairing repeats v. 18; 'for' in v. 20 grounds both verses. Commentators such as France and Keener stress this contextual reading while allowing wider application.

  • A legal settlement between the two disputing parties, ratified by God.

    J. D. M. Derrett ('Where two or three are convened in my name…: a sad misunderstanding', Expository Times 91, 1979) argued that symphōneō = 'come to terms', pragma = 'claim', aiteō = 'pursue a claim'. Most scholars find this too narrow, since aiteō with 'my Father' reads naturally as prayer.

in v19

Who are the 'two'?

  • Any two disciples praying together.

    'Two of you' is unrestricted in the grammar.

  • The parties involved in the case: the offended member and witness, or the offender and offended once reconciled.

    The numbers in vv. 15–16 (one, then one or two more) and the reconciling aim of the passage.

in v20

Is the promise limited to church discipline (vv. 15–18), or is it a general promise about prayer and gathering?

  • It is primarily judicial. The 'two or three' are the witnesses or the deciding group in a discipline case, and the 'matter' (pragma) of v. 19 is a dispute the community is settling.

    v. 16 explicitly quotes the witness law with 'two or three'. *Pragma* can mean a legal case (1 Cor 6:1). The verse closes a unit about binding and loosing. Scholars such as J. D. M. Derrett have argued for this reading.

  • It starts from the discipline context but states a broader principle: Jesus is present wherever disciples gather in his name, including for prayer.

    v. 19 says 'about *any* matter (*peri pantos pragmatos*) they ask', which is the language of prayer. The verse is a general relative clause ('wherever…'). It fits Matthew's wider theme of presence (1:23; 28:20). Rabbinic parallels apply God's presence to any group devoted to Torah. Most commentators (e.g. Davies & Allison, France, Luz) hold some form of this view, while insisting the context gives it its shape.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. ἐλέγχω, κερδαίνω, ἀδελφός, ἀκούω
  • Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. ἐλέγχω
  • Büchsel, TDNT s.v. ἐλέγχω
  • Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, 2nd ed., on Matt 18:15
  • Nestle-Aland, Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed. (apparatus at Matt 18:15)
  • Septuagint, Leviticus 19:17; Sirach 19:13–17; Proverbs 3:12
  • Dead Sea Scrolls: Rule of the Community (1QS) 5:24–6:1; Damascus Document (CD) 9:2–8
  • Testament of Gad 6:3–7
  • W. D. Davies & D. C. Allison, Matthew (ICC), vol. 2
  • R. T. France, The Gospel of Matthew (NICNT)
  • Ulrich Luz, Matthew 8–20 (Hermeneia)
  • Craig S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Matt 18:15–17
  • David Daube, 'κερδαίνω as a Missionary Term', Harvard Theological Review 40 (1947)
  • BDAG s.v. ῥῆμα, ἵστημι, μάρτυς, στόμα, παραλαμβάνω
  • HALOT s.v. דָּבָר, קוּם, עֵד
  • Rahlfs, Septuaginta, Deut 17:6; 19:15
  • Nestle-Aland, Novum Testamentum Graece 28th ed., Matt 18:15–16
  • Vulgate, Matt 18:16
  • Josephus, Antiquities 4.219
  • Mishnah Makkot 1
  • Dead Sea Scrolls: 1QS (Community Rule) 5:24–6:1; CD (Damascus Document) 9:2–8, 16–23
  • W. D. Davies & D. C. Allison, Matthew (ICC), vol. 2, on 18:15–17
  • R. T. France, The Gospel of Matthew (NICNT), on 18:16
  • C. S. Keener, A Commentary on the Gospel of Matthew, on 18:15–17
  • U. Luz, Matthew 8–20 (Hermeneia), on 18:15–17
  • BDAG s.v. ἐκκλησία, παρακούω, ἐθνικός, τελώνης
  • LSJ s.v. παρακούω, τελώνης
  • K. L. Schmidt, TDNT s.v. ἐκκλησία
  • W. D. Davies & D. C. Allison, Matthew (ICC), vol. 2, on 18:15–20
  • U. Luz, Matthew 8–20 (Hermeneia), on 18:15–20
  • R. T. France, The Gospel of Matthew (NICNT), on 18:15–17
  • J. R. Donahue, "Tax Collectors and Sinners," CBQ 33 (1971)
  • Dead Sea Scrolls: Community Rule 1QS 5:24–6:1; Damascus Document CD 9:2–8; War Scroll 1QM 4:10
  • Mishnah Nedarim 3:4; Tohorot 7:6
  • Septuagint: Deut 4:10; 23:1–3; Esther 3:3, 8; Tobit 3:4; Isaiah 65:12
  • Latin Vulgate and Syriac Peshitta, Matt 18:17
  • BDAG s.v. δέω; s.v. λύω; s.v. οὐρανός
  • Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. δέω, λύω
  • Josephus, Jewish War 1.111 (λύειν τε καὶ δεσμεῖν)
  • Mishnah, recurring formula 'the House of Shammai forbid (oserin) and the House of Hillel permit (mattirin)'
  • Strack–Billerbeck, Kommentar zum Neuen Testament aus Talmud und Midrasch I, on Matt 16:19
  • Dead Sea Scrolls: Community Rule 1QS 5:24–6:1; Damascus Document CD 9:2–8
  • W. D. Davies & D. C. Allison, Matthew (ICC), vol. 2, on 16:19 and 18:18
  • D. A. Carson, Matthew (Expositor's Bible Commentary), on 16:19 and 18:18
  • H. J. Cadbury, 'The Meaning of John 20:23, Matthew 16:19, and Matthew 18:18', JBL 58 (1939)
  • J. R. Mantey, 'Evidence that the Perfect Tense in John 20:23 and Matthew 16:19 Is Mistranslated', JETS 16 (1973)
  • R. H. Hiers, ''Binding' and 'Loosing': The Matthean Authorizations', JBL 104 (1985)
  • S. E. Porter, Verbal Aspect in the Greek of the New Testament (1989)
  • BDAG s.v. συμφωνέω
  • BDAG s.v. πρᾶγμα
  • BDAG s.v. αἰτέω
  • Septuagint Isa 7:2; 4 Kgdms 12:9
  • Mishnah Avot 3:2, 3:6
  • Dead Sea Scrolls 1QS 5:24–6:1; CD 9:2–8
  • R. T. France, The Gospel of Matthew (NICNT), on 18:19–20
  • C. S. Keener, A Commentary on the Gospel of Matthew, on 18:15–20
  • U. Luz, Matthew 8–20 (Hermeneia)
  • J. D. M. Derrett, 'Where two or three are convened in my name…: a sad misunderstanding', Expository Times 91 (1979)
  • BDAG s.v. συνάγω, ὄνομα, μέσος
  • Moulton & Milligan, Vocabulary of the Greek Testament, s.v. ὄνομα (εἰς τὸ ὄνομα in papyri)
  • Mishnah Avot 3:2; 3:6
  • Deuteronomy 19:15; 17:6 (LXX)
  • Exodus 25:8; 29:45–46; Deuteronomy 23:14; Zechariah 2:10–11 (LXX)
  • J. D. M. Derrett, '"Where two or three are convened in my name…": a sad misunderstanding', ExpTim 91 (1979)
  • B. M. Metzger / NA28 apparatus on Matt 18:20 (Codex Bezae reading)
  • Gospel of Thomas 30 / P.Oxy. 1

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).