Mark Chapter 7 Read as one passage
Mark 7:9–13
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
9He went on to say, “You neatly set aside the command of God to maintain your own tradition. 10For Moses said, ‘Honor your father and your mother’ and ‘Anyone who curses his father or mother must be put to death.’ 11But you say that if a man says to his father or mother, ‘Whatever you would have received from me is Corban’ (that is, a gift devoted to God), 12he is no longer permitted to do anything for his father or mother. 13Thus you nullify the word of God by the tradition you have handed down. And you do so in many such matters.”
What the first hearers heard
To Mark's first readers, many of them Gentile believers who needed Jewish customs explained (7:3–4), this verse was a sharp sentence in a larger argument about what really makes a person clean or unclean (7:14–23). It carried several messages:
- The Torah's commandment stands above human rulings. Jesus defends one of the Ten Commandments against a legal device. He does not attack the Law of Moses. He accuses his critics of undermining it.
- Interpretation can turn into replacement. The problem is not that a tradition exists. The problem is a tradition that, in a real case, cancels what God plainly commanded, and that does so cleverly. The irony of "splendidly" exposes how sophisticated the evasion is.
- The honor of parents is not negotiable. In a society where elderly parents depended on their children, a rule that let a son use a religious vow to withhold support was a serious injustice wearing religious clothing.
- It fulfils Isaiah's charge quoted just before (Isa 29:13 in vv. 6–7): worship taught as "commandments of men," lips that honor God while the heart is far from him.
For a mixed Jewish and Gentile community working out which Jewish practices applied to them, the verse helped draw a line between God's commandment and the traditions that had grown up around it.
From the study of Mark 7:9.
Verse by verse
-
9He went on to say, “You neatly set aside the command of God to maintain your own tradition.
Full study →And he went on, pressing the point: "What a splendid job you do of cancelling God's commandment, so that you can set up your own tradition in its place!"
The first word is sarcastic praise. Only moments before, Jesus said Isaiah described these critics rightly (the same Greek word, v. 6). Now he says they cancel God's command beautifully, with real skill and legal ingenuity. The verb does not mean simply ignoring or disliking the command. It means declaring it void, the way a contract or a will is cancelled. It is in the present tense: this is what they regularly do. The commandment in view is single and specific, "Honor your father and your mother," as the next verse shows. The contrast is between whose rule each one is: the commandment of God against tradition that is yours (v. 8 calls it "of men"). The final verb, in the reading most modern editors prefer, means "to make stand" or "establish." So the picture is of taking God's command off its foundation and standing their own ruling on it instead. ("Keep your tradition," found in many manuscripts and in the KJV, makes the same charge less vividly.) The "so that" carries the irony: Jesus talks as if overturning God's word were the very goal of their system.
-
10For Moses said, ‘Honor your father and your mother’ and ‘Anyone who curses his father or mother must be put to death.’
Full study →"For Moses (and in him God himself, v. 13) gave you a command that is on record: Keep on giving your father and your mother their full weight. That means respect, and also the practical care that respect owes: food, a roof and support in their old age. He also said: Whoever treats father or mother as light and worthless, whoever runs them down, is to be put to death without fail."
Jesus quotes two passages from the Law side by side. In the Hebrew behind them they are deliberate opposites. To "honor" is literally to make heavy, to give weight. To "curse" is literally to make light, to treat as trivial. The Law counted the second as a capital offence. Jesus brings up both passages because of what comes next (vv. 11–12). Some teachers allowed a son to declare his property Corban, "dedicated to God", so that his parents could not benefit from it. Jesus is pointing out that this does not honor God. It breaks God's command, because it leaves parents without support, and the Law treated that kind of contempt as one of the gravest sins there is. "Moses said" (v. 10) is set against "but you say" (v. 11). It is the written command of God against a human ruling that cancels it.
-
11But you say that if a man says to his father or mother, ‘Whatever you would have received from me is Corban’ (that is, a gift devoted to God),
Full study →"Moses said, 'Honor your father and your mother.' But you — you scribes and Pharisees — rule like this: suppose a man says to his father or mother, 'Korban! Whatever support you might have had from me is a sacred offering' …"
Here Korban is a Hebrew word for an offering brought to God. Mark explains it to his readers as "gift", meaning a sacrificial gift. In Jesus' day it was also the opening word of a vow. By saying it over his goods, a son could declare that anything his parent might get from him (food, money, shelter, any help at all) was now treated as belonging to God, and so was forbidden to that parent. The property did not have to go to the Temple. The vow simply put it out of the parent's reach.
The sentence breaks off without finishing. Jesus completes the thought in the next verse: once the words had been spoken, "you no longer let him do anything for his father or mother." The force of the verse lies in that broken-off "if": a single sacred word, spoken perhaps in anger, was treated as more binding than God's own command to provide for one's parents.
-
12he is no longer permitted to do anything for his father or mother.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
13Thus you nullify the word of God by the tradition you have handed down. And you do so in many such matters.”
Full study →Jesus has just given an example (vv. 10–12). Moses, speaking for God, commanded, "Honor your father and your mother," and laid down death for anyone who curses them. Yet these teachers rule that once a son has declared his resources korban, "an offering dedicated to God", toward his parents, he may no longer do anything for them. Verse 13 gives the verdict:
"You are annulling God's own command, cancelling its legal force, by means of your handed-down teaching, the tradition that you yourselves keep passing on. And this is not a one-off. You do many things just like it."
The verb is courtroom language. It does not mean "neglect" or "bend". It means declaring a law void. "The word of God" here is not a general phrase for religion or for a whole Bible. It is the specific commandment just quoted from the Law of Moses, which was a binding duty that included supporting aging parents. "Tradition" and "handed down" come from the same Greek root ("the handing-down you handed down"). Jesus takes the Pharisees' proud claim that their teaching came down to them from the elders and turns it into a charge: you are the ones handing it on, and it is yours, not God's. The last line widens the accusation from one vow case to a habit: they forbid the son to do anything for his parents, while they do many other things of the same kind.
Where the English drifted
-
in v9
Full well (KJV, WEB)
kalōs
- What we hear
- "You know full well" means deliberately, with full knowledge. So the line can sound like "you knowingly reject God's command."
- What they heard
- Ironic praise: "How splendidly / what a fine job you do of…" It mocks how skilfully they do it, echoing the straight use of the same word in v. 6 ("Isaiah prophesied rightly").
-
in v9
reject (KJV, WEB, ESV)
atheteō
- What we hear
- To refuse, turn down, or disapprove of something, an attitude of not accepting it.
- What they heard
- To declare void, annul, or nullify, a legal and practical cancellation. The commandment is still officially honored, but in practice it has been made ineffective.
-
in v9, v13
tradition
paradosis
- What we hear
- A harmless inherited custom or ceremony ("family traditions"). Or, in church debate, "tradition" as a whole category set against Scripture.
- What they heard
- A specific body of authoritative rulings handed down by teachers, here the Pharisaic "tradition of the elders" on purity and vows, which its followers treated as binding.
-
in v10
Honor
timaō (Hebrew kabbēd)
- What we hear
- Respect your parents, speak politely and, if you are a child, obey them.
- What they heard
- Give your parents their full weight. That includes respect, and for adult children it also means material support: food, housing, care in old age and burial. Mark 7:11–12 shows that money is the issue here.
-
in v10
curses
kakologeō (Hebrew qillel)
- What we hear
- Swears at a parent, or calls down a magical curse on them.
- What they heard
- Speaks evil of, reviles, treats as light or worthless. It is the opposite of 'honor', which means giving weight. It covers any expression of contempt, including leaving parents without support.
-
in v11
a gift (KJV) / given to God, devoted to God
korban … dōron
- What we hear
- A present, or an actual donation of money to the Temple, like giving to a church instead of to one's parents.
- What they heard
- A sacred offering. In this setting it is the formula of a vow that made property off-limits to a named person (here the parents) as though it belonged to God. The goods did not have to change hands at all.
-
in v13
the word of God
ho logos tou theou
- What we hear
- The Bible as a complete book (Old and New Testaments), or Christ as 'the Word'.
- What they heard
- What God had spoken as a command, here specifically the fifth commandment and its penalty clause given through Moses (vv. 8–10). The New Testament did not yet exist. Israel's Scriptures were the Law, Prophets and other writings.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v9
This verse isn't a verdict against all tradition
- What's often taught
- This verse is often used to teach that Jesus opposed religious tradition and ritual as such, and that any handed-down practice or teaching competes with God's word and should be dropped.
- What the text supports
The charge is narrow and concrete. A specific human ruling (the korban vow, vv. 11–13) is used to annul (atheteō) a specific commandment of God, honoring parents (v. 10). Jesus is defending the written Law of Moses, not doing away with religious practice. The same word, paradosis, is used positively elsewhere in the New Testament: Paul praises the Corinthians for holding to "the traditions" he handed on (1 Cor 11:2) and tells the Thessalonians to "stand firm and hold to the traditions" (2 Thess 2:15). So what makes a tradition right or wrong is not that it was handed down. It is its source ("of God" or "of men," v. 8) and whether it in fact cancels what God commanded. The common reading is partly right: Jesus does insist that God's commandment outranks any human interpretation. But the verse does not condemn tradition in general.
- Where the English feeds it
- Modern English "tradition" sounds like a whole category (customs, rituals, heritage), so "your tradition" can sound like "tradition as such." The Greek "your" and the parallel "tradition of men" (v. 8) point to one particular body of rulings. "Reject" also hides the precise charge of nullifying a command in practice.
in v10
'Honor your parents' was never only for children
- What's often taught
- The fifth commandment is mainly a rule for children: respect your parents, speak politely to them and obey them while you are growing up.
- What the text supports
What the common reading gets right: honor does include respect, and Ephesians 6:1–2 does apply the commandment to children's obedience. But in Mark 7:10–12 Jesus applies it to grown sons and their money. A man who declares his resources Corban so that his parents cannot benefit has broken this commandment.
- The verb τιμάω (timaō) belongs with τιμή, 'honor' and also 'price or payment'. In 1 Timothy 5:3, 17 'honor' means financial support.
- The Hebrew behind it, kabbēd, means 'give weight to'. Sirach 3 and later rabbinic teaching spell it out as feeding, clothing and caring for aging parents.
- The Ten Commandments were addressed to adult members of the covenant people.
So the commandment's main concern is that adults care for their aging parents, and Jesus enforces it as that.
- Where the English feeds it
- English 'honor' now suggests an attitude or manners and no longer suggests providing for someone. 'Curses' in the second quotation also hides the fact that its opposite, treating parents as worthless, includes neglecting them.
in v11
Corban wasn't really about giving to the Temple instead of your parents
- What's often taught
- The man in Mark 7:11 gave his money to the Temple, and the religious leaders praised this generosity even though it left his parents in need. The lesson is that religious giving can become an excuse for neglecting family.
- What the text supports
Korban was the opening word of a vow formula: "qorban be whatever you would benefit from me." Jewish sources of the period (the Jebel Hallet et-Turi ossuary inscription and Mishnah Nedarim) show it working as a ban. It declared property off-limits to a named person as if it were consecrated. Nothing had to be given to the priests, and the vower may have gone on using the goods himself.
Jesus' complaint (v.12) is not that the scribes preferred Temple gifts. It is that they treated the spoken vow as unbreakable: "you no longer let him do anything for his father or mother." Religious words were turned into a legal wall around the son's resources.
The popular reading gets one thing right: a religious practice was being used to dodge the duty to parents. But the mechanism was the binding vow, not a donation.
- Where the English feeds it
- Glosses such as 'given to God' (WEB, ESV, NASB) and 'devoted to God' (BSB, NIV), and paraphrases about vowing to give to God (NLT), suggest a real transfer of money. The Greek says only *dōron*, 'offering', explaining the word *korban*.
Every word
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v9, v10, v13
Mark's usual linking word. It marks a new step in Jesus' reply to the Pharisees and scribes.
-
ἔλεγεν
elegen · G3004
-
αὐτοῖς
autois · G846
-
καλῶς
kalōs · G2573
well, finely, rightly · v9
Ironic praise: "How splendidly you…" or "You do a fine job of…" Only three verses earlier (7:6) the same word was meant straight: "Rightly (kalōs) did Isaiah prophesy about you." Here it bites. Isaiah described them well, and they cancel God's command just as well.
-
ἀθετεῖτε
atheteite · G114
to set aside, annul, nullify, reject · v9
The word means to treat something as void, the way a legal document is cancelled. The present tense describes something they habitually do. It is stronger than the "leaving behind" (aphentes) of v. 8: they don't just neglect the command, they in effect cancel it.
-
τὴν
tēn · G3588
the · v9, v10, v11, v13
Points to a specific commandment, which v. 10 names as honoring father and mother.
-
ἐντολὴν
entolēn · G1785
commandment, order · v9
A specific instruction from God in the Torah (the Law of Moses). The singular looks ahead to the fifth commandment, which Jesus quotes in the next verse.
-
θεοῦ
theou · G2316
God · v9, v13
"Of God" stands in deliberate contrast with "your" tradition (and with "tradition of men" in v. 8). Whose authority is behind each rule is the whole point.
-
ἵνα
hina · G2443
in order that, so that · v9
Normally gives a purpose. It is part of the irony: Jesus talks as if cancelling God's command were the very aim of the exercise, so that their own rule could stand.
-
παράδοσιν
paradosin · G3862
-
ὑμῶν
hymōn · G4771
-
στήσητε
stēsēte · G2476
to make stand, set up, establish, uphold · v9
"That you may set up, establish, or uphold" your tradition. It pairs with atheteite: they take God's command off its footing so they can put their own rule in its place. (Many manuscripts have "keep" here; see variants.)
-
Μωϋσῆς
Mōusēs · G3475
Moses · v10
Moses as the one through whom the Law was given. He stands for the written commandment, set against 'but you say' in the next verse. In verse 13 Jesus calls the same words 'the word of God', so naming Moses does not make the command any less God's.
-
γὰρ
gar · G1063
for · v10
Introduces the proof for verse 9's charge that they 'neatly set aside the command of God'. Here is the command they set aside.
-
εἶπεν
eipen · G2036
said · v10, v11
A simple past tense: Moses said it once, and it stands on record. It is set against the present 'you say' (λέγετε) of verse 11, the scribes' ongoing teaching.
-
τίμα
tima · G5091
honor, value · v10
A present-tense command, so a lasting duty rather than a single act. It means to give someone their proper worth. In this passage that clearly includes material support, because the next verses are about money withheld from parents.
-
πατέρα
patera · G3962
father · v10, v11
One's own father, the head of the household. In this context he is an aging father who may depend on his grown son.
-
μητέρα
mētera · G3384
mother · v10, v11
One's own mother. A widowed mother was especially dependent on her sons, so she mattered greatly in the Corban case that follows.
-
κακολογῶν
kakologōn · G2551
speak evil of, revile · v10
Literally 'bad-speaking': insulting, reviling, running down. In Greek it translates the Hebrew qillel, which means treating someone as light or worthless. The present participle describes a person who keeps doing it, not a single slip.
-
ἢ
ē · G2228
or · v10, v11
'Or'. Contempt toward either parent alone is enough.
-
θανάτῳ
thanatō · G2288
death · v10
'By death'. Together with the verb it copies a Hebrew way of adding emphasis ('dying he shall die'), meaning 'he must surely be put to death'.
-
τελευτάτω
teleutatō · G5053
come to an end, die · v10
'Let him come to his end'. It is a third-person command. The Greek Old Testament has a future here ('he shall die'). Mark's command form makes it a sentence that must be carried out.
-
δὲ
de · G1161
but, and · v11
Contrasts this with v.10: 'Moses said … but you say.' It sets God's command next to the scribes' ruling.
-
ἐὰν
ean · G1437
if · v11
Introduces a test case, the way a legal ruling does: 'if a man should say …'. The 'then' half of the sentence never arrives in this verse. It comes, reworded, in v.12.
-
ἄνθρωπος
anthrōpos · G444
a human being, a man · v11
'Anyone' or 'a person': the generic subject of a legal case. Here it means a grown son who is able to support his parents.
-
κορβᾶν
korban · G2878
Korban, an offering · v11
A Hebrew/Aramaic word, qorban ('offering, something brought near to God'), kept untranslated. In Jesus' day it was also a vow formula. Saying it over property marked that property off-limits to someone, as if it belonged to God.
-
ὅ
ho · G3739
which · v11, v13
Opens Mark's aside to his readers, explaining the foreign word.
-
ἐστιν
estin · G1510
is · v11
'Which is' in the sense of 'which means'. Mark uses the same phrase to translate Aramaic elsewhere (e.g. 'Ephphatha, that is, Be opened', 7:34).
-
δῶρον
dōron · G1435
gift, offering · v11
The standard Greek translation of qorban in the Greek Old Testament. It means a sacred offering to God, not a present for a person.
-
ἐξ
ex · G1537
out of, from · v11
The help would come 'from me', from the son's own resources.
-
ἐμοῦ
emou · G1473
me · v11
The son speaks in the first person. This is the actual wording of the vow.
-
ὠφεληθῇς
ōphelēthēs · G5623
you might be helped, benefited · v11
'You might benefit.' The verb form presents this as a possibility. It echoes the Hebrew vow wording 'that you benefit from me', which barred a named person from any use or support from the speaker's property.
-
ἀκυροῦντες
akyrountes · G0208
to annul, invalidate · v13
A legal word: to strip a law, will or contract of its binding force. The present participle presents the annulling as ongoing, and it explains the result of verse 12. Their ruling does not just bend God's command. In practice it cancels it.
-
λόγον
logon · G3056
word, statement, message · v13
What God has said, here the command 'Honor your father and your mother' with its sanction (v. 10). Mark uses it as a synonym for 'the commandment of God' in verses 8–9.
-
παρεδώκατε
paredōkate · G3860
to hand over, hand down · v13
The verb from the same root as 'tradition': 'the handing-down which you handed down'. The repetition stresses that they are its source and transmitters, and that God is not. The past tense looks at their act of passing it on.
-
παρόμοια
paromoia · G3946
closely similar · v13
'Much like this', meaning other cases built the same way, where a human ruling overrides a divine command.
-
τοιαῦτα
toiauta · G5108
such things · v13
Doubles the 'of this kind' idea. 'Similar such things' is emphatic and colloquial, and it tells the reader that the vow case is one example among many, not a rare exception.
-
πολλὰ
polla · G4183
many · v13
Widens the charge. The problem is a pattern, not one bad ruling.
-
ποιεῖτε
poieite · G4160
you do · v13
Present tense: habitual practice. It echoes verse 12. They will not let the son 'do' (poiēsai) anything for his parents, yet they 'do' many things of this kind themselves.
The world behind it
The dispute. Pharisees and scribes from Jerusalem had seen some of Jesus' disciples eating without the ritual handwashing that "the tradition of the elders" required (7:1–5). Mark explains these customs for readers outside Judea (7:3–4). The Pharisees were a lay movement known for exact interpretation of the Torah. They handed down an unwritten body of rulings meant to apply the Law to daily life. Josephus says the Sadducees rejected these "regulations from the fathers" because they were not written in Moses (Ant. 13.297). Later rabbinic Judaism called this the Oral Torah and recorded it in the Mishnah around 200 CE.
The example Jesus gives (vv. 10–13). In Jewish and wider ancient society, "honoring" parents included supporting them materially in old age (compare Sirach 3:1–16; 1 Tim 5:4, 8). The Torah also treated vows to God as binding (Num 30:2; Deut 23:21–23). A person could declare property korban, "an offering," meaning dedicated to God. Then it could not be used for other purposes, and that included supporting a parent, even if the owner kept using it himself. A 1st-century ossuary (bone box) found near Jerusalem has an inscription using the word qorban in just this kind of dedication formula: whatever someone might gain from this box is "an offering to God." So the vow formula was in real use. Jesus' charge is that a ruling which holds such a vow binding cancels the fifth commandment in practice.
Fairness to the Pharisees. Rabbinic sources show the question was debated. The Mishnah (m. Nedarim 9:1) records Rabbi Eliezer allowing a vow to be released when it would harm the honor owed to parents, and later rabbinic law moved in that direction. Jesus' complaint fits an argument that was going on inside Judaism. It is not a blanket picture of all Pharisees for all time.
From the study of Mark 7:9.
Where scholars differ
in v9
Which verb did Mark write: στήσητε ("establish") or τηρήσητε ("keep")?
-
στήσητε is original.
It is the harder and less expected reading. Scribes tended to bring wording into line with nearby words (v. 8 "hold") and with the familiar "keep the tradition." It has early and widespread support from Western and other witnesses (D, W, Θ, f1, Old Latin, Syriac). NA28/UBS5 and Metzger's committee print it.
-
τηρήσητε is original.
It has strong early Alexandrian support (including Sinaiticus) and the majority of later manuscripts. Some argue στήσητε could have come in through assimilation to Septuagint phrases like "establish the covenant" or to Rom 3:31.
in v9
Is καλῶς ironic, or does it mean something like "thoroughly / effectively"?
-
Ironic: "How splendidly you…"
BDAG and most commentators take it this way. It is a deliberate echo of the straight use of kalōs in v. 6 and fits the rhetoric of the dispute.
-
Plainly descriptive: "You thoroughly / effectively set aside…"
Kalōs can mean "well, effectively" without irony. Some older interpreters read it as a sober statement of how complete the annulling is. The sense is close either way, but the echo of v. 6 favors irony.
in v9
Does Jesus' korban example reflect what Pharisees actually taught?
-
It reflects a real ruling or practice in some 1st-century circles.
The ossuary inscription with *qorban* shows the vow formula was in use. Vows to God were considered binding (Num 30). The later rabbinic debate in *m. Nedarim* 9:1 suggests stricter positions once existed.
-
Mark's account sharpens a debate that was still going on.
The Mishnah records Rabbi Eliezer allowing such vows to be released for the sake of parents, and later halakha (Jewish law) took that route. So not all Pharisees would have held the view Jesus attacks, and the argument may reflect one strand or an early stage of the discussion.
in v10
Did the Pharisees and scribes of Jesus' day really hold that a Corban vow could override duty to parents?
-
Yes. At least some teachers held such vows binding even when they hurt parents, and Mark reports a real ruling.
m. Nedarim 9:1 records that Rabbi Eliezer allowed vows to be undone 'for the honor of father and mother', while the other sages at first disagreed. This suggests an earlier stricter position that bound people to their vows. Philo (Special Laws 2.9–17) also stresses that vows are binding. The ossuary inscription shows the Corban formula was used in Jesus' day.
-
The later rabbinic consensus favored the parents, so Jesus is targeting a particular stricter ruling or abuse rather than all Jewish practice.
The same Mishnah passage ends with the sages agreeing with Eliezer. Rabbinic literature generally places honor of parents very high (b. Qiddushin 31a–b). The Mishnah, though, was written down around 200 AD and may reflect a debate that was settled after Jesus' time.
in v11
Did a korban vow actually transfer the property to the Temple?
-
Mainly a vow of prohibition: the goods became 'as if' sacred in relation to the named person, with no transfer required.
The Mishnah's *Nedarim* formulas ('qorban/qonam be whatever you benefit from me') bar a person from benefit without sending anything to the Temple. The Greek phrase 'whatever you might benefit from me' matches that formula. Many commentators (e.g. Lane, France, Marcus) read Mark this way, and some note that the vower might go on using the goods himself.
-
A real dedication to the Temple, at least sometimes or in principle.
*Qorban* literally means an offering. Josephus (*Ant.* 4.73) describes self-dedication that had to be redeemed with payment to the Temple. Some scholars think the line between 'formula' and 'actual gift' was blurry in practice, or that the property was pledged to the Temple at the vower's death.
in v11
Does Jesus' charge reflect actual Pharisaic law?
-
Yes, it reflects a stricter early stage, before the later rabbinic softening.
m. Ned. 9:1 shows that releasing a vow for the sake of parents' honor was disputed. Rabbi Eliezer argued for it, and the sages' agreement looks like a later development. m. Ned. 5:6 shows that vows against a father really were made.
-
It is a polemical case that sharpens the scribes' position.
The later rabbinic consensus allowed release in exactly this situation. Some scholars think Mark presents the strictest possible reading to make the point of 7:9–13. Others answer that the Mishnah's own debate shows the strict view was held by some.
in v11
Is the korban vow linked to 'speaking evil' of parents in v.10?
-
Yes. The vow, often spoken in anger, is itself a form of cursing a parent, so the tradition protects a curse.
Mark places 'whoever speaks evil of father or mother' (κακολογῶν) directly before this case. Vows of prohibition were often uttered in quarrels, as the Mishnah's cases suggest.
-
The link is looser: v.10 just gives the full force of the commandment.
Jesus' stated charge (vv.12–13) is about failing to *do* anything for the parents. That is neglect of support, not a curse as such.
in v13
Did declaring property 'korban' actually give it to the Temple, or was it just a vow formula that barred the parents?
-
It was mainly a vow of prohibition: the son declared his goods 'as an offering' with respect to his parents, which barred them from benefiting while he could still use the goods himself.
Mishnah tractate Nedarim discusses many vows of this kind ('konam/korban, that you shall have no benefit from me') with no Temple transfer involved. The Jebel Hallet et-Turi ossuary uses qrbn as a protective ban formula. Most modern commentators (e.g. Marcus, France) take this view.
-
It could involve an actual dedication to the Temple, which teachers then upheld over the parents' claim, perhaps to the Temple's financial benefit.
Korban is the ordinary word for a Temple offering (Lev 1:2 etc.), and Josephus (Ant. 4.73) mentions people paying priests to be released from korban vows, which shows money and the Temple could be involved. The text of Mark does not say where the property went.
in v13
Did Jesus' opponents really hold that such a vow overrode duty to parents?
-
Yes. Some teachers in Jesus' day held vows to be binding even against parents, and Jesus is attacking that stricter position.
The Mishnah (Nedarim 9:1) records a real debate on the question, which means the strict view existed. It also implies that the lenient view (release for the honor of parents) won out only after discussion.
-
Mark's presentation sharpens or generalizes a debated position, since the lenient view that later became standard already existed.
Rabbi Eliezer's lenient position (late 1st century) and the sages' eventual agreement suggest many Pharisees would have shared Jesus' concern. Scholars such as A. I. Baumgarten have examined how far the korban practice in Mark reflects Pharisaic tradition.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. καλῶς (ironic use, citing Mark 7:9)
- BDAG s.v. ἀθετέω
- BDAG s.v. παράδοσις
- BDAG s.v. ἵστημι
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. ἀθετέω
- B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Mark 7:9
- Nestle-Aland 28th ed. / UBS5 apparatus; SBL Greek New Testament
- Josephus, Antiquities 13.297
- Mishnah, Nedarim 9:1; Avot 1:1
- J. A. Fitzmyer, 'The Aramaic Qorban Inscription from Jebel Ḥallet eṭ-Ṭûri and Mark 7:11/Matt 15:5', JBL 78 (1959)
- J. Marcus, Mark 1–8 (Anchor Yale Bible)
- R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark (NIGTC)
- Vulgate, Mark 7:9
- BDAG s.v. τιμάω, κακολογέω, τελευτάω
- HALOT s.v. כבד (piel), קלל (piel)
- Septuagint: Exodus 20:12; 21:16 [MT 21:17]; Leviticus 20:9; Deuteronomy 5:16
- Sirach 3:1–16; Tobit 4:3
- Philo, On the Decalogue 106–120; Special Laws 2.9–17
- Josephus, Against Apion 2.206
- Mishnah Nedarim 9:1; Mishnah Sanhedrin 7:8; Babylonian Talmud Qiddushin 31a–b
- J. A. Fitzmyer, 'The Aramaic Qorban Inscription from Jebel Hallet et-Turi and Mark 7:11/Matt 15:5', JBL 78 (1959)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Mark 7:9–13
- BDAG s.v. κορβᾶν, δῶρον, ὠφελέω
- Thayer s.v. κορβᾶν
- HALOT/BDB s.v. קָרְבָּן
- Josephus, Against Apion 1.167; Antiquities 4.73
- Mishnah Nedarim 1:2–4; 5:6; 9:1
- Sirach 3:12–16; b. Qiddushin 31b
- W. L. Lane, The Gospel of Mark (NICNT)
- A. Y. Collins, Mark (Hermeneia)
- BDAG s.v. ἀκυρόω
- BDAG s.v. λόγος
- Moulton–Milligan, Vocabulary of the Greek Testament, s.v. ἀκυρόω
- Josephus, Antiquities 13.297; 4.73
- Josephus, Against Apion 1.167
- Mishnah, Nedarim 9:1
- Mishnah, Avot 1:1
- Sirach 3:1–16
- A. I. Baumgarten, 'Korban and the Pharisaic Paradosis', JANES 16–17 (1984–85)
- Latin Vulgate, Mark 7:13
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.