Mark Chapter 9 Read as one passage
Mark 9:43–47
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
43If your hand causes you to sin, cut it off. It is better for you to enter life crippled than to have two hands and go into hell, into the unquenchable fire. 44 45If your foot causes you to sin, cut it off. It is better for you to enter life lame than to have two feet and be thrown into hell. 46 47And if your eye causes you to sin, pluck it out. It is better for you to enter the kingdom of God with one eye than to have two eyes and be thrown into hell,
What the first hearers heard
Jesus' disciples had been arguing about rank and policing outsiders. They heard a warning that turned their attention back on themselves. The danger to the community was not only that someone might trip up the "little ones" (v. 42). Each disciple could be trapped by his own hands, feet and eyes, the parts of himself that he used and valued most.
To Jewish ears, the command to cut off the hand was obviously not an instruction to mutilate yourself, which the Torah forbade. It was a vivid way of saying that loyalty to God's coming kingdom outweighs anything, even something as dear and as much a part of you as your own hand. The picture of a maimed person entering life would have stood out, because some groups expected people with damaged bodies to be excluded from the final holy assembly. In God's kingdom, being physically whole is not the entry requirement. Faithfulness is.
Gehenna called up a concrete and horrifying picture for them: the cursed valley below Jerusalem, a place of child sacrifice in the past and, in Isaiah's last vision, of burning corpses. "Life" and "Gehenna" were the two outcomes of the coming judgment that most Jews of the time already believed in, and Jesus put the choice between them in the plainest terms. In Mark's setting, the saying also prepared readers for times of pressure (13:9–13) in which "falling away" would be a real temptation.
From the study of Mark 9:43.
Verse by verse
-
43If your hand causes you to sin, cut it off. It is better for you to enter life crippled than to have two hands and go into hell, into the unquenchable fire.
Full study →"And if your own hand keeps tripping you up, setting a trap that will make you fall away from God, chop it off. You are far better off going in through the gate into the life of God's coming age with a stump where your hand was than keeping both hands and being sent away into Gehenna, into the fire that no one can put out."
The verse starts with "and". It follows directly from Jesus' warning in verse 42 that anyone who trips up one of the "little ones" who trust him would be better off drowned with a millstone. Here Jesus uses the same verb and the same "it is better" pattern, but now he points them at the disciple. The trap may not be another person. It may be your own hand, a part of yourself that you value.
The verb (skandalizō) pictures the trigger-stick of a snare. It means more than "prompts a wrong act". It means "brings you down", and in Mark it is the word for people who fall away from faith. The command "cut it off" is one decisive, shocking act. Jesus' hearers knew that Jewish law forbade self-mutilation, so they would have heard a deliberate exaggeration meant to show how serious this is: no part of your life is too precious to give up if it is dragging you away from God.
The reversal is pointed. Some Jewish groups expected maimed people to be barred from the holy assembly of the last days. Jesus says it is the maimed person who enters, and the whole-bodied person who goes away. "Life" here is not ordinary living but the resurrection life of the age to come, the same thing verse 47 calls "the kingdom of God." "Gehenna" is not a vague underworld. It is the Valley of Hinnom outside Jerusalem, remembered for child sacrifice, cursed by the prophets, and pictured in Isaiah 66:24 as full of rebels' corpses burning in a fire that is never quenched. Jesus quotes that line in verse 48. The choice is stark: lose something dear now, or lose everything at the end.
-
44
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
45If your foot causes you to sin, cut it off. It is better for you to enter life lame than to have two feet and be thrown into hell.
Full study →"And if your foot keeps tripping you up, the thing that carries you to the place where you fall and turn away from God, chop it off. Better to limp into the life of God's coming kingdom with one foot than to keep both feet and be thrown, by a judgment not your own, into Gehenna."
Several things are packed in:
- "Causes you to stumble" is the picture of a snare or obstacle that brings you down, so that you fall out of faithfulness. It is not about mild offense, and not only about a single sinful act.
- "Cut it off" is a single, shocking command. It is deliberate exaggeration: make a total break, whatever it costs, with whatever keeps bringing you down, even something as close and useful as your own foot.
- "Better … than" follows a Hebrew way of comparing. It weighs a painful loss now against total loss at the end.
- "Enter the life" means walking into the life of the age to come, which v. 47 calls the kingdom of God.
- "Lame" stings, because the lame were barred from the priesthood and, in some circles, from the holy gathering. Here the lame person gets in, while the whole, unblemished body is thrown out.
- "Gehenna" is not a vague underworld. It is the cursed valley outside Jerusalem, remembered for child sacrifice, which Jeremiah turned into a valley of corpses and Isaiah's closing vision left burning and full of worms. By Jesus' day it was the image of God's final judgment.
-
46
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
47And if your eye causes you to sin, pluck it out. It is better for you to enter the kingdom of God with one eye than to have two eyes and be thrown into hell,
Full study →"And if your own eye keeps tripping you up, setting a trap that would bring you down and away from God, throw it out, the way you would drive out a demon. Better for you to walk into God's kingdom, the life of the coming age under his rule, maimed and one-eyed, than to keep both eyes and be thrown, by God, into Gehenna, the valley of judgment and fire."
This is the third and last of three sayings. Hand, foot, eye: each part is more precious than the one before, and each time the stakes are spelled out. Jesus is not prescribing surgery. He uses deliberately shocking exaggeration, a common way Jewish teachers drove a point home, to say that no part of yourself, however precious, is worth keeping if it costs you God's kingdom. The verb "trip up" pictures a trap that makes you fall, and in Mark the fall in view is falling away from God, not a minor lapse. The command "throw it out" uses Mark's word for expelling demons. The words "you'll be thrown" echo it: throw it out, or you yourself will be thrown. The picture of a disfigured person entering the kingdom would have jarred hearers who linked holiness with a whole, unblemished body. "Gehenna" is not a vague underworld. It is a real valley outside Jerusalem, remembered for child sacrifice and corpses, which by Jesus' day stood for God's final fiery judgment. The next verse describes it in the words of Isaiah 66:24.
Where the English drifted
-
in v43
offend (KJV: "if thy hand offend thee")
skandalizō
- What we hear
- If your hand upsets or insults you.
- What they heard
- If your hand trips you up like a sprung trap and brings you down, possibly so far that you fall away from God.
-
in v43
causes you to sin
skandalizō
- What we hear
- Leads you to commit a particular wrong act, a single moral slip.
-
in v43, v45, v47
hell
geenna
- What we hear
- An underworld where souls go when they die, often pictured as ruled by Satan and his demons.
- What they heard
- Gehenna, named after the Valley of Hinnom outside Jerusalem: the place where God judges and destroys the wicked after the resurrection, drawing on Jeremiah and Isaiah 66:24. It is not the general realm of the dead (that is Hades or Sheol), and Satan does not rule it.
-
in v43, v45
enter life
eiselthein eis tēn zōēn
- What we hear
- Go on living, or have a better life now.
- What they heard
- Enter the resurrection life of God's coming age. Verse 47 calls the same thing entering 'the kingdom of God'.
-
in v45
offend (KJV: "if thy foot offend thee")
skandalizō
- What we hear
- If your foot annoys you, insults you or hurts your feelings.
- What they heard
- If your foot trips you up, like a snare or stumbling-block, and brings you down so that you fall away from God.
-
in v47
offend (KJV: 'if thine eye offend thee')
skandalizō
- What we hear
- To upset someone, hurt their feelings or cause them displeasure.
- What they heard
- To trap someone or trip them so that they fall, and here specifically to bring them down into sin and falling away from God.
-
in v47
kingdom of God
basileia tou theou
- What we hear
- Heaven, where souls go when they die.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v43
Gehenna's 'burning garbage dump' is a medieval guess
- What's often taught
- A common explanation says Gehenna was Jerusalem's town rubbish dump, where fires burned constantly to destroy refuse and the bodies of criminals, and that this is why Jesus spoke of unquenchable fire.
- What the text supports
The explanation is right that Gehenna was a real valley outside Jerusalem associated with death and defilement. But the earliest known source for the idea that it was a constantly burning rubbish dump is the Jewish commentator David Kimhi, writing around 1200, more than a thousand years after Jesus. Archaeologists have found no evidence of such a dump in the Hinnom Valley, and no Jewish, Roman or early Christian writer of Jesus' time mentions one (see Lloyd Bailey, Biblical Archaeologist 1986).
The background in the text itself is Scripture, not municipal waste. The valley was the site of child sacrifice to foreign gods (2 Kgs 23:10; Jer 7:31). Jeremiah declared it a 'Valley of Slaughter' full of corpses (Jer 7:32; 19:6). Isaiah's final verse, which Jesus quotes in Mark 9:48, describes the bodies of rebels against God, whose 'worm shall not die' and whose 'fire shall not be quenched' (Isa 66:24). By Jesus' time Jewish writings such as 1 Enoch 27 and 4 Ezra 7:36 already used the valley's name for the place of God's final judgment. The unquenchable fire is the fire of Isaiah's prophecy, not a fire that was kept burning to dispose of rubbish.
- Where the English feeds it
- The English words do not create this idea, which comes from study notes and sermons. But because most translations say 'hell' instead of the place name 'Gehenna', readers depend on such notes to explain the background, and the dump story has filled that gap.
in v45
Gehenna was not Jerusalem's burning garbage dump
- What's often taught
- When Jesus said 'Gehenna', he was pointing to Jerusalem's municipal rubbish dump in the Valley of Hinnom, where fires burned all the time and worms fed on refuse. His hearers would have pictured smouldering trash.
- What the text supports
No ancient source or archaeological evidence shows that the Valley of Hinnom was a burning rubbish dump in Jesus' day. The idea first appears around AD 1200, in a comment by the Jewish scholar David Kimhi on Psalm 27. Archaeologists such as L. R. Bailey (Biblical Archaeologist, 1986) have found no support for it in the period.
What first-century hearers did associate with the valley is clear from texts they knew:
- Child sacrifice and idolatry (2 Kgs 23:10; Jer 7:31).
- Jeremiah's curse, turning it into 'the Valley of Slaughter', full of corpses (Jer 7:32; 19:6).
- Isaiah's final vision of rebels' corpses with undying worm and unquenchable fire (Isa 66:24). Mark 9:48 quotes this verse directly.
- Jewish writings of the period that already use 'Gehenna' as the name for the place of God's final judgment (1 Enoch 27; 4 Ezra 7:36).
The illustration gets one thing right: the worm and fire are vivid pictures. But they come from Scripture and from cursed sacred history, not from municipal waste disposal. Hearing 'dump' turns a picture of God's judgment on idolatry and rebellion into a picture of garbage.
- Where the English feeds it
- Most English versions translate Gehenna as 'hell', so readers never see that it is a place-name. Preachers then fill the gap with an explanation, and the 'garbage dump' story is the one that spread. Versions that keep 'Gehenna' (WEB, YLT) at least show that a real valley is meant.
in v47
Gehenna wasn't Jerusalem's burning garbage dump
- What's often taught
- When Jesus said 'Gehenna', he meant the Valley of Hinnom, Jerusalem's rubbish dump, where fires burned constantly and worms ate the refuse. His hearers would have pictured a stinking, smouldering trash heap.
- What the text supports
No ancient source (the Bible, Josephus, the Dead Sea Scrolls, the Mishnah, the Talmud) and no archaeological find describes the Hinnom Valley as a garbage dump with constant fires. The idea first appears in the commentary of Rabbi David Kimhi on Psalm 27:13, around AD 1200, more than a thousand years after Jesus (see Lloyd Bailey, Biblical Archaeologist 1986).
The popular reading is right that Gehenna was a real place and that its associations were grim. The actual background is different, and it is in the verse itself. Verse 48 quotes Isaiah 66:24: the worm that does not die and the fire that is not quenched consume the corpses of those who rebelled against God, lying outside Jerusalem. The valley's history is child sacrifice to foreign gods (2 Kgs 23:10; Jer 7:31) and Jeremiah's prophecy that it would become the 'Valley of Slaughter', full of the unburied dead (Jer 7:32–33; 19:6). By Jesus' day, books like 1 Enoch (27:1–3; 90:26–27) had already turned it into the place of God's final fiery judgment. Jesus' hearers would have pictured God's judgment on rebellion as described by the prophets, not a municipal trash fire.
- Where the English feeds it
- Most English versions translate *geenna* as 'hell', which erases the place-name. Popular teachers then try to recover the lost local colour, and the garbage-dump story fills the gap. Versions that keep 'Gehenna' (WEB, YLT) let readers trace the name back to Joshua, Jeremiah and Isaiah.
Every word
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v43, v45, v47
Ties this saying to verse 42. Jesus has just warned about tripping up 'one of these little ones'; now he turns the same warning on the disciple himself.
-
ἐὰν
ean · G1437
if · v43, v45, v47
Sets up a possible situation, 'if it should happen that…'. It does not say that it will happen.
-
σκανδαλίζῃ
skandalizē · G4624
to cause to stumble, to trip up · v43, v45, v47
The present tense suggests something that keeps happening: if your hand keeps tripping you up. The picture is a snare or an obstacle that makes you fall, and in Mark that fall is often a falling away from God. It is the same verb as in verse 42.
-
σε
se · G4771
you · v43, v45, v47
Singular. The warning is aimed at each disciple personally.
-
ἡ
hē · G3588
the · v43, v45, v47
The article that goes with 'hand'.
-
χείρ
cheir · G5495
hand · v43
In Hebrew thought the hand stands for what a person does. Here it is your own hand, so the cause of the fall is a part of yourself.
-
ἀπόκοψον
apokopson · G609
cut off, amputate · v43, v45
A command in a form that signals one decisive act: chop it off. It is a deliberately shocking image, since Jewish law did not allow people to mutilate themselves.
-
αὐτήν
autēn · G846
it · v43, v45, v47
Points back to the hand.
-
καλόν
kalon · G2570
good, fine · v43, v45, v47
Literally 'good'. Followed by 'than' (ē), it works as a comparison, 'better… than', in the way Hebrew and Aramaic compare things. It repeats the 'better' of verse 42.
-
ἐστίν
estin · G1510
is · v43, v45, v47
'It is': a plain statement of how things are.
-
κυλλὸν
kyllon · G2948
maimed, crippled · v43
A person whose limb is bent, deformed or missing. Some Jewish groups shut people like this out of holy places. Here such a person is the one who gets in.
-
εἰσελθεῖν
eiselthein · G1525
to enter, go in · v43, v45, v47
'To go in', as through a gate into a city or a feast. It is set against 'go away' later in the verse.
-
εἰς
eis · G1519
into · v43, v45, v47
Into, as a destination.
-
ζωὴν
zōēn · G2222
life · v43, v45
The life of the coming age, which God gives at the resurrection. In verse 47 Jesus calls the same thing 'the kingdom of God'.
-
ἢ
ē · G2228
or, than · v43, v45, v47
'Than'. It finishes the 'better… than' comparison.
-
δύο
duo · G1417
two · v43, v45, v47
'Two', which stresses being physically whole.
-
ἔχοντα
echonta · G2192
having · v43, v45, v47
'While still having'. The ironic picture is a person who kept his body whole and lost everything.
-
ἀπελθεῖν
apelthein · G565
to go away, depart · v43
'To go off, go away'. Set against 'enter', it pictures being sent away from God's presence instead of being welcomed in.
-
γέενναν
geennan · G1067
Gehenna · v43, v45, v47
The Valley of Hinnom beside Jerusalem. It was remembered as a place of child sacrifice and of God's judgment, and by Jesus' day its name stood for the place of final punishment.
-
πῦρ
pyr · G4442
fire · v43
Fire is the common biblical picture of God's judgment, which destroys and purges.
-
ἄσβεστον
asbeston · G762
unquenchable, inextinguishable · v43
'Un-quenchable': no one can put it out. It echoes Isaiah 66:24, 'their fire shall not be quenched'.
-
πούς
pous · G4228
foot · v45
The foot is what carries you somewhere: where you go and what you walk into. Some scholars also see a possible sexual euphemism here (see debates).
-
χωλὸν
chōlon · G5560
lame, crippled · v45
Lame, limping, with a disabled leg. In Israel a lame man was barred from serving as a priest, and some groups shut such people out of the holy gathering. Here the lame person gets in.
-
βληθῆναι
blēthēnai · G906
to be thrown, cast · v45, v47
'To be thrown'. It is violent and passive: this is done to you, not chosen by you. The person throwing is not named, but Jewish speech often left God unnamed in this way.
-
ὀφθαλμός
ophthalmos · G3788
eye · v47
The physical eye. In Jewish thought it was also where desire, envy and greed start (see Mark 7:22, 'an evil eye', and Numbers 15:39). It is the most precious of the three body parts named, so it is the hardest to give up.
-
ἔκβαλε
ekbale · G1544
-
μονόφθαλμον
monophthalmon · G3442
one-eyed · v47
A blunt, everyday word, 'one-eyed', describing someone visibly disfigured. The picture is shocking on purpose: a maimed person walking into God's kingdom.
-
βασιλείαν
basileian · G0932
kingdom, reign, royal rule · v47
God's royal rule, which Jews expected to arrive in full at the end of the age. Here it stands in place of 'life' in verses 43 and 45. Entering the kingdom and entering life are the same destination.
-
θεοῦ
theou · G2316
God · v47
'Of God'. The kingdom is the one God rules.
The world behind it
Where this is said. Jesus is in a house in Capernaum (9:33). His disciples have just argued about which of them is the greatest (9:34) and tried to stop an outsider who was driving out demons in Jesus' name (9:38). Jesus answers by putting a child in the middle of them (9:36–37) and warning against tripping up "little ones" who believe (9:42). Verses 43–48 then apply that warning to the disciple's own hand, foot and eye.
Exaggeration as a teaching style. Jewish teachers and prophets often used extreme images to make a point. The Torah forbade cutting your own body (Deut 14:1; Lev 19:28). The only amputation it prescribes is a single judicial case (Deut 25:11–12). Later rabbis spoke the same way: Mishnah Niddah 2:1 says that a man's hand that keeps touching his private parts "should be cut off". No one in that culture took such sayings as surgical instructions. They were a way of saying "be ruthless about this".
Bodies and holiness. Leviticus 21:17–23 kept priests with physical defects from serving at the altar. The Dead Sea Scrolls community went further. Its Rule of the Congregation (1QSa 2:3–9) excluded anyone "crippled in feet or hands, lame or blind" from the gathering of the last days. Against this background it is striking that Jesus has a maimed person entering life.
Gehenna. The Valley of Hinnom (Gê Hinnōm) lies along the south and southwest side of Jerusalem. Under kings Ahaz and Manasseh, children were burned there as offerings (2 Kgs 16:3; 21:6). King Josiah defiled the site to stop the practice (2 Kgs 23:10). Jeremiah announced that it would become a "Valley of Slaughter" filled with the bodies of the dead (Jer 7:31–34; 19:6). Isaiah's final verse (66:24) pictures the corpses of rebels against God outside the city, "their worm shall not die, their fire shall not be quenched". By the time of Jesus, Jewish writings such as 1 Enoch 27 and 4 Ezra 7:36 used this valley as the name for the place where God finally punishes the wicked. Jesus' hearers would have recognised the place and the prophecy he quotes in verse 48.
From the study of Mark 9:43.
Where scholars differ
in v43
Is 'cut it off' meant literally?
-
It is deliberate exaggeration in the Jewish teaching style (this is the view of nearly all interpreters).
The Torah forbids people to cut their own bodies (Deut 14:1; Lev 19:28). Rabbinic sayings use the same kind of image (m. Niddah 2:1). Cutting off a hand would not remove the desire or intention behind the act. The early church generally rejected literal self-mutilation, and Origen's reported self-castration (based on a different text, Matt 19:12) was criticised.
-
It is an exaggeration, but it points to a real cost that should not be explained away.
The 'it is better' structure deliberately matches the very real fate in verse 42. Mark elsewhere asks disciples to lose their life (8:35) and leave family and property (10:29). On this view the image is not literal, but the renunciation it calls for is.
in v43
What do the hand, foot and eye stand for?
-
Any part of one's own life (actions, places one goes, desires) that leads to sin or falling away.
The most natural reading of 'your hand… your foot… your eye', which follows directly from verse 42.
-
Sexual sins specifically.
Matthew places the saying in a teaching on lust (5:27–30). Rabbinic discussion in b. Niddah 13a–b connects hand, foot and eye with sexual offences. Will Deming (JBL 1990) argues that Mark 9:42–10:12 follows this pattern, since Mark goes on to the topic of divorce in chapter 10.
-
Members of the community who lead others astray (a reading about the body of believers).
The context is about the community: the argument over greatness, the outside exorcist, and the 'little ones'. Matthew 18 sets the saying among instructions on community discipline. Some early interpreters read the 'members' as members of the church. Critics answer that 'your hand' is plainly personal and individual.
in v43
What does the 'unquenchable fire' of Gehenna imply about final punishment?
-
Punishment that never ends, experienced consciously.
Matthew 18:8 calls the fire 'eternal'. Matthew 25:46 speaks of 'eternal punishment'. Judith 16:17 says the nations will 'weep in pain forever', and some Second Temple texts describe ongoing torment.
-
Final, irreversible destruction (annihilation).
Isaiah 66:24, which verse 48 quotes, describes corpses being consumed. 'Unquenchable' fire in Matthew 3:12 burns up chaff completely. A fire 'not quenched' (Jer 7:20; 17:27; Ezek 20:47–48) means that no one can stop it until it has done its work, not that it burns forever.
-
Fire that purifies (a minority view, held by some in the early church).
Verse 49 follows immediately with 'everyone will be salted with fire'. Some interpreters (for example, in the tradition influenced by Origen) read the fire of judgment as purging. Most commentators think verse 49 is about disciples being tested, not about Gehenna.
in v45
What does the 'foot' (with hand and eye) stand for?
-
Exaggeration for anything in your own life that leads to falling away. Make a total break, whatever it costs.
The general wording. Mark's use of 'stumble' for falling away under pressure (4:17; 14:27). The run of three body parts (hand: what you do; foot: where you go; eye: what you desire) covers the whole person. This is the majority reading (e.g. France, NIGTC; Marcus, Anchor Yale).
-
A specifically sexual reference: hand and foot as euphemisms tied to sexual sin.
'Feet' is sometimes a euphemism for the genitals in the Hebrew Bible (e.g. Isa 7:20; possibly Ruth 3). The Talmud's 'let the hand be cut off' in a sexual context (b. Niddah 13b). Matthew's version sits in a passage about lust (Matt 5:29–30). The next passage in Mark is about divorce (10:1–12). Argued by W. Deming (NTS 36, 1990).
-
A community reading: the 'body' is the community of disciples, and members who cause 'little ones' to stumble must be put out.
The surrounding focus on the community (9:33–42, 50). The use of body imagery for the community elsewhere (1 Cor 12). Matthew sets the parallel in a chapter about community discipline (Matt 18:6–9, 15–17). Held by some interpreters ancient and modern, though it is a minority view for Mark.
in v45
What fate does 'Gehenna' imply: endless conscious punishment or final destruction?
-
Ongoing, conscious punishment.
'Unquenchable fire' (v. 43) and the worm that 'does not die' (v. 48). Judith 16:17 ('they shall weep in pain forever'). 1 Enoch's pictures of continuing torment. Matt 25:46, 'eternal punishment'.
-
Final destruction: the wicked are consumed.
Isaiah 66:24, the source of the imagery, describes *corpses*: dead bodies, not living sufferers. Jeremiah's 'Valley of Slaughter'. Matt 10:28 says God can 'destroy both soul and body in Gehenna'. On this view, 'unquenchable' fire is one that cannot be put out until it has finished its work.
-
The verse itself does not settle the question.
Mark 9:45 stresses the contrast: being thrown into Gehenna against entering the life. It describes neither how long nor in what way. Commentators often note that the imagery is drawn from Isaiah and Jeremiah and that the verse aims at urgency, not at a full description of the afterlife.
in v47
Did Jesus mean a specific kind of sin, especially sexual sin, by hand, foot and eye?
-
Yes: the sayings are about sexual sin.
Will Deming (NTS 1990) points to b. Niddah 13b and m. Niddah 2:1, where 'cutting off the hand' is about sexual sins. In Hebrew 'foot' is sometimes a euphemism for the genitals, and Matthew 5:28–30 ties the eye saying to lust. The sayings in Mark 10:1–12 on divorce come soon after.
-
No: they cover anything that leads to falling away.
In Mark the context is rivalry over greatness (9:33–37), controlling outsiders (9:38–41) and tripping up 'little ones who believe' (9:42). Mark never mentions sex here, and his use of *skandalizō* elsewhere is about apostasy under pressure (4:17; 14:27). Most commentators (e.g. Marcus, France) take the referent as broad.
in v47
Do the body parts stand for individual temptations, or for members of the community?
-
Individual: they are parts of each disciple's own life and desires.
The singular 'your eye … you', and the clear echo of Matthew 5:29–30, which is about one person's looking. This is the majority reading.
-
Community: they stand for members who lead others astray and must be removed, the community being pictured as a body.
Verse 42 is about harm to other believers, and Paul pictures the community as a body with members (1 Cor 12). Some early and some modern interpreters read 9:43–47 as being about church discipline. Critics answer that 'your eye causes *you* to stumble' points inward.
in v47
What happens in Gehenna: lasting punishment or final destruction?
-
Ongoing, conscious punishment.
Verse 48 says 'their worm does not die and the fire is not quenched'. Judith 16:17 already reads Isaiah 66:24 as people feeling pain forever ('fire and worms … they shall weep in pain forever'), as do 1 Enoch 27 and 4 Ezra 7:36–38.
-
Final destruction (annihilation).
Isaiah 66:24 describes corpses being consumed, not living people. The images of worm and fire suggest decay and destruction. Matthew 10:28 speaks of God 'destroying' body and soul in Gehenna. The fire is 'not quenched' in the sense that nothing can put it out until it has done its work.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. σκανδαλίζω, σκάνδαλον, κυλλός, γέεννα, ἄσβεστος, ἀποκόπτω
- G. Stählin, 'σκάνδαλον, σκανδαλίζω', TDNT 7
- J. Jeremias, 'γέεννα', TDNT 1
- Mishnah Niddah 2:1; Babylonian Talmud Niddah 13a–b
- 1QSa (Rule of the Congregation) 2:3–9
- 1 Enoch 27:1–2; 4 Ezra 7:36
- B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Mark 9:44, 46
- J. Marcus, Mark 8–16 (Anchor Yale Bible)
- R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark (NIGTC)
- W. Deming, 'Mark 9.42–10.12, Matthew 5.27–32, and B. Nid. 13b', JBL 109 (1990)
- L. R. Bailey, 'Gehenna: The Topography of Hell', Biblical Archaeologist 49 (1986)
- David Kimhi, commentary on Psalm 27:13
- NA28 (Nestle-Aland, Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed.)
- BDAG s.v. σκανδαλίζω, γέεννα, ζωή, χωλός, ἀποκόπτω
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. σκανδαλίζω, γέεννα
- G. Stählin, TDNT s.v. σκάνδαλον, σκανδαλίζω
- J. Jeremias, TDNT s.v. γέεννα
- A. Y. Collins, Mark (Hermeneia)
- W. Deming, 'Mark 9:42–10:12, Matthew 5:27–32, and b. Nid. 13b', New Testament Studies 36 (1990)
- Dead Sea Scrolls: 1QSa 2:3–9; 1QM 7:4–5; CD 3:20
- Josephus, Life 171–173
- 1 Enoch 27; 4 Ezra 7:36; Mishnah Avot 1:5; 5:19–20; b. Niddah 13b
- BDAG s.v. σκανδαλίζω, ἐκβάλλω, μονόφθαλμος, γέεννα, βασιλεία
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. σκανδαλίζω
- Moulton & Milligan, Vocabulary of the Greek Testament s.v. μονόφθαλμος (citing Phrynichus)
- B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Mark 9:44, 46, 47
- NA28 / SBLGNT apparatus on Mark 9:47
- Lloyd R. Bailey, 'Gehenna: The Topography of Hell', Biblical Archaeologist 49 (1986)
- Will Deming, 'Mark 9:42–10:12, Matthew 5:27–32, and b. Nid. 13b', New Testament Studies 36 (1990)
- Joel Marcus, Mark 8–16 (Anchor Yale Bible)
- Adela Yarbro Collins, Mark (Hermeneia)
- Dead Sea Scrolls: 1QSa 2.3–9; 1QM 7.4–5
- 1 Enoch 27; 90:26–27; 4 Ezra 7:36; Judith 16:17
- Mishnah Niddah 2:1; Avot 1:5; 5:19–20; b. Niddah 13b
- Herodotus, Histories 3.116; 4.27
- Vulgate, Mark 9:46 (Vulgate numbering)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
2 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.