Joshua Chapter 21 Read as one passage
Joshua 21:27–33
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
27This is what the Levite clans of the Gershonites were given: From the half-tribe of Manasseh they were given Golan in Bashan, a city of refuge for the manslayer, and Beeshterah—two cities, together with their pasturelands. 28From the tribe of Issachar they were given Kishion, Daberath, 29Jarmuth, and En-gannim—four cities, together with their pasturelands. 30From the tribe of Asher they were given Mishal, Abdon, 31Helkath, and Rehob—four cities, together with their pasturelands. 32And from the tribe of Naphtali they were given Kedesh in Galilee (a city of refuge for the manslayer), Hammoth-dor, and Kartan—three cities, together with their pasturelands. 33In all, thirteen cities, together with their pasturelands, were given to the Gershonite clans.
What the first hearers heard
For Israelites hearing or reading Joshua 21, this verse did three things.
- It recorded a promise kept. The chapter as a whole shows that Moses' command to give the Levites towns (Num 35) was carried out precisely, by lot and in full, down to the tally "two cities". The chapter ends: "Not one of all the good promises... failed" (21:45). Each small entry like this one is part of that proof.
- It set the Gershonites on the northern frontier. The clan that once carried the tabernacle's curtains (Num 3:25–26) was now spread through Bashan and Galilee. Levites in these towns kept Israel's worship and teaching present far from the central sanctuary (compare Deut 33:10).
- It put justice within reach of the far north-east. Because Golan was a refuge city, a herdsman in Bashan who killed someone by accident did not have to cross the Jordan to find protection. Shed blood was taken seriously, but it was handled through a hearing rather than through unchecked revenge.
The handover of Beeshterah/Ashtaroth, a town named for Astarte and once Og's seat, would also have reinforced the story's claim that YHWH had overthrown the old powers of the land and given their towns to his people.
From the study of Joshua 21:27.
Verse by verse
-
27This is what the Levite clans of the Gershonites were given: From the half-tribe of Manasseh they were given Golan in Bashan, a city of refuge for the manslayer, and Beeshterah—two cities, together with their pasturelands.
Full study →And to the Gershonite line, one of the clan-groups of Levi, the eastern half of the tribe of Manasseh gave two towns. The first was Golan, in the rich cattle-country of Bashan. It was the designated asylum town where anyone who had taken a human life could flee for protection until the case was tried. The second was Be-Eshterah, the old "House of Astarte", better known as Ashtaroth, once the royal seat of King Og. Each came with the open grazing land around it. Total: two towns.
The verse is an entry in a land register, and it reads like one: who receives, from whom, which towns, and a running count. Three details give it weight for its first hearers:
- "City of refuge for the killer." Golan was one of the six towns of Joshua 20 where someone who had killed a person could find legal protection from the dead person's avenging kinsman until the community judged the case. The Hebrew word for "killer" does not decide whether the killing was murder. The trial decided that, and only the person who had killed unintentionally kept the protection.
- "Its pasture-land." The Levites had no tribal territory. They received towns plus the common grazing belt around them, so they could keep livestock. This is not "suburbs" in the modern sense.
- Beeshterah. The name very likely means "House of Astarte". A former Canaanite cult and royal centre in Og's conquered kingdom is now handed to the tribe set apart for Israel's God.
-
28From the tribe of Issachar they were given Kishion, Daberath,
Full study →The verse continues the list from verse 27 of towns given to the Gershonites, one of the three Levite clans:
"And out of the land held by the tribe of Issachar, the Israelites handed over Kishion, together with its common grazing land, and Daberath, together with its common grazing land."
Every phrase has a purpose. The tribe (literally its "staff", the symbol of the leader who headed it) gives up part of its own allotted inheritance. The Levites had no territory of their own, so each town comes with its migrash. This is the belt of open land outside the walls where the Levites' sheep and goats grazed, and Leviticus 25:34 says it could never be sold.
Both towns lay in lower Galilee near Mount Tabor. Daberath is today's Daburiyya, at the foot of the mountain on the border with Zebulun. Kishion's exact site is unknown. Verse 29 adds Jarmuth and En-gannim, bringing Issachar's share to four. That fits the rule in Numbers 35:8 that each tribe gives in proportion to what it holds.
-
29Jarmuth, and En-gannim—four cities, together with their pasturelands.
Full study →From the tribe of Issachar, the Levites of the Gershon clan were also given the hilltop town of Jarmuth (called Remeth or Ramoth elsewhere) and En-gannim, the 'Spring of Gardens', a well-watered town at the southern edge of the Jezreel Valley. Each came with its own ring of open grazing land around it, where the Levites' sheep, goats and cattle could feed. With Kishion and Daberath from the previous verse, that makes four towns from Issachar. The repeated phrase 'and its pastureland' is not filler. It is the legal point of the list: each town came with land to make a living from, because the tribe of Levi had no territory of its own.
-
30From the tribe of Asher they were given Mishal, Abdon,
Full study →"And from the tribe of Asher they handed over Mishal, along with the open grazing land around it, and Abdon, along with the open grazing land around it."
This verse continues a sentence that began in verse 27: to the Gershonite clans of the Levites they gave…. Asher, the tribe settled in the coastal plain and hills of western Galilee, gives up two of its towns, Mishal and Abdon, to Levite families as places to live. Each town comes with its migrash, the strip of common land just outside the walls where livestock were driven out to graze. That phrase matters. The Levites got homes and pasture for their animals, but not the fields and vineyards beyond, which stayed with Asher. They were spread out across Israel as residents, not landowners. In the Hebrew, every town is followed by the same refrain, "and its pasture land", so the grant reads like a legal record: town and grazing rights, town and grazing rights, item by item.
-
31Helkath, and Rehob—four cities, together with their pasturelands.
Full study →This verse finishes the list of what the tribe of Asher handed over to the Gershonite clan of Levites (begun in verse 30). "Helkath and its grazing land, and Rehob and its grazing land: four towns in all."
Each town comes with its migrash. This was the open belt of land around the town where the Levites' sheep, goats and cattle could be driven out to graze. It was not cropland, which the Levites were never given, and not a residential "suburb". Numbers 35 had laid down this grant and Leviticus 25:34 made it permanent and unsellable. Repeating "and its pasture land" after every name is the record's way of saying that the command was carried out to the letter.
The two names carry their own small pictures. Helkath probably means "smooth field" or "portion" and Rehob means "broad place". Both lay in Asher's north-western lowlands next to the Phoenician coast. With Mishal and Abdon they make four, Asher's share of the forty-eight towns that put Levite families inside every tribe of Israel.
-
32And from the tribe of Naphtali they were given Kedesh in Galilee (a city of refuge for the manslayer), Hammoth-dor, and Kartan—three cities, together with their pasturelands.
Full study →From the land allotted to the tribe of Naphtali, the Levites of the Gershon clan were given three towns, each with the open grazing land around it.
The first was Kedesh, whose name means "holy place", up in the northern hill district called the Galil ("the circle/district", the origin of the name Galilee). Kedesh was already one of Israel's legally designated asylum towns for "the killer". In Israelite law that meant anyone who had caused a death and fled there to escape the dead person's avenging kinsman. They stayed there until the town elders and the assembly could rule whether the killing was deliberate murder (no protection) or an accidental killing (protection for as long as the high priest lived).
The second was Hammoth-dor, probably "the hot springs", the hot-water site on the west shore of the Sea of Galilee. The third was Kartan, an old name meaning "town", probably the same place the Chronicler calls Kiriathaim.
What the Levites received in each case was the town to live in and its common pasture, not the surrounding farmland. That makes three towns, completing the Gershonites' total of thirteen.
-
33In all, thirteen cities, together with their pasturelands, were given to the Gershonite clans.
Full study →Here the narrator adds up the list: every town given to the descendants of Gershon, shared out through their clans, came to thirteen, each with the open grazing land around it.
The verse closes the second of four sections in Joshua 21, which distributes the 48 Levitical towns. Gershon's clans received 2 towns from half-Manasseh in Bashan, 4 from Issachar, 4 from Asher and 3 from Naphtali (vv. 27–32). The phrase "by their clans" means the towns went to large kin groups, the Libnites and Shimeites, not to single households. The last word, migrash, is easy to skip past, but it carries the point. It was the common land just outside the town wall where the herds were driven out to graze. The Levites owned no farmland, so this strip of pasture was what fed them, and the law said it could never be sold (Lev 25:34). The verse means: thirteen places to live, and the land to live on.
Where the English drifted
-
in v27
suburbs (KJV)
migrash
- What we hear
- Residential neighbourhoods or housing developments on the edge of a city.
- What they heard
- The open common land around a town where livestock grazed. Num 35:4–5 measures it at 1,000–2,000 cubits from the wall, and it could not be sold (Lev 25:34).
-
in v27
killer / slayer (supplied gloss 'to murder')
rotseach
- What we hear
- A murderer, someone who killed on purpose. Read that way, the refuge city looks like it shelters murderers.
- What they heard
- Anyone who has taken a human life and so carries blood-guilt that must be dealt with. Whether the killing was intentional is settled by a hearing. The refuge protected only the person who killed unintentionally.
-
in v28
suburbs (KJV, YLT)
migrash
- What we hear
- Residential districts on the edge of a city: housing, streets, commuters.
- What they heard
- Open common land just outside a town, used to graze livestock. It was fields, not buildings, and for Levites it could not be sold.
-
in v29, v31, v33
suburbs (KJV, YLT)
migrāš
- What we hear
- Residential neighbourhoods or commuter housing on the outskirts of a city.
- What they heard
- Open grazing and common land around a small town, kept free of buildings.
-
in v29
cities
ʿārîm
- What we hear
- Large urban centres.
- What they heard
- Small permanent settlements, often only a few acres, sometimes walled.
-
in v30, v32
suburbs (KJV, YLT)
migrāsh
- What we hear
- Residential neighbourhoods on the edge of a city, full of houses.
- What they heard
- Open common land outside the town wall, used to graze livestock. Nobody lived on it, and it was not farmed.
-
in v32
murder (lexical gloss of rāṣaḥ)
rōṣēaḥ
- What we hear
- Someone who killed on purpose: a murderer.
- What they heard
- Anyone who had caused a person's death. In the refuge laws it means especially someone who killed accidentally and was waiting for judgment. Deliberate murderers were excluded from protection.
-
in v33
families (KJV, WEB, YLT)
mišpāḥōt
- What we hear
- Individual households of parents and children.
- What they heard
- Clans: large lineages below the tribe, made up of many extended households.
Every word
-
וְלִבְנֵ֣י
ve-livnei · H1121
and to the sons of · v27
'Sons of' is the normal Hebrew way to name a descent group, so 'sons of Gershon' means the whole Gershonite lineage, men, women and households. It opens a new section of the list: the Gershonites' share.
-
גֵרְשׁוֹן֮
Gereshon · H1648
Gershon · v27
Gershon was Levi's eldest son (Exod 6:16). His descendants made up one of the three main Levite divisions, and in the wilderness they were responsible for carrying the tabernacle's curtains and coverings (Num 3:25–26).
-
מִמִּשְׁפְּחֹ֣ת
mi-mishpechot · H4940
from the clans of · v27, v33
A mishpachah is a clan, the kinship level between the tribe and the extended household. It does not mean 'family' in the modern sense of a nuclear family. It marks the Gershonites as one clan-group within Levi.
-
הַלְוִיִּם֒
ha-Leviyyim · H3881
the Levites · v27
The tribe set apart for sanctuary service. It received no block of tribal territory and instead got towns scattered among the other tribes (Josh 13:14; 21:1–3).
-
מֵחֲצִ֞י
me-chatsi · H2677
from half of · v27
Manasseh's land was split. Half lay east of the Jordan in Bashan and half lay west of it. Verse 25 has already used the western half, so this must be the eastern half, which is why KJV adds '[other]'.
-
מַטֵּ֣ה
matteh · H4294
tribe (lit. staff) · v27, v28, v30, v32
Matteh literally means a staff or rod, the symbol of a tribal leader's authority (compare Num 17:2). Here it means the tribe as a political unit. This is the word Joshua's allotment lists usually prefer.
-
מְנַשֶּׁ֗ה
Menasheh · H4519
Manasseh · v27
The Joseph tribe whose eastern branch (the Machirites) held Gilead and Bashan (Josh 13:29–31).
-
אֶת־
et- · H0853
-
עִיר֙
ʿir · H5892
city, town · v27, v29, v31, v32, v33
A permanent settlement, usually walled. Most of these 'cities' would have been modest towns by modern standards.
-
מִקְלַ֣ט
miqlat · H4733
refuge, asylum · v27, v32
This is a legal term for a place of asylum where someone who has killed a person can be safe from the avenger until the case is judged. It appears almost only in the refuge-city laws and lists.
-
הָרֹצֵ֔חַ
ha-rotseach · H7523
the killer, the manslayer · v27, v32
A participle meaning 'the one who has killed'. In the refuge law it covers anyone who has taken a life. The city protects such a person until a hearing decides whether the killing was accidental (Josh 20:3–6). Only the person who killed unintentionally keeps that protection.
-
גּוֹלָ֤ן
Golan · H1474
-
בַּבָּשָׁן֙
ba-Bashan · H1316
in the Bashan · v27
The fertile basalt plateau east and northeast of the Sea of Galilee, once Og's kingdom. It was famous for fat cattle and oaks. Hebrew writes it with 'the', as 'the Bashan', which treats it as a known region.
-
מִגְרָשֶׁ֔הָ
migrashah · H4054
its pasture-land · v27, v28, v29, v30, v31, v32, v33
The open belt of common land around a town, used for grazing the Levites' livestock (Num 35:2–5). It was not housing. The town came with this land attached.
-
בְּעֶשְׁתְּרָ֖ה
Beʿeshterah · H1203
Beeshterah · v27
The name is probably a shortened form of Beth-Ashtarah, 'house (temple) of Ashtart [Astarte]'. It is usually identified with Ashtaroth, Og's old royal city, which the parallel list in 1 Chr 6:71 names here.
-
שְׁתָּֽיִם׃
shetayim · H8147
two · v27
A feminine number agreeing with 'cities'. It closes the entry with an accountant's tally, the way the whole chapter is written.
-
יִשָּׂשכָ֔ר
yissakhar · H3485
Issachar · v28
The tribe named for Jacob and Leah's fifth son. Its land was the fertile Jezreel Valley and the hills around Mount Tabor in lower Galilee. It gives up four towns to the Gershonite Levites (vv. 28–29).
-
קִשְׁי֖וֹן
qishyon · H7191
Kishion · v28
A town in Issachar, also listed in Issachar's allotment at Joshua 19:20. Nobody is sure where it was. It is not the River Kishon, despite the KJV spelling.
-
דָּֽבְרַ֖ת
daverat · H1705
Daberath · v28
A town at the western foot of Mount Tabor, usually identified with modern Daburiyya. Joshua 19:12 puts it on Zebulun's border, so it sat where the two tribes met.
-
יַרְמוּת֙
yarmût · H3412
Jarmuth (place name) · v29
A town in Issachar's land. It is not the better-known Jarmuth in the lowlands of Judah (Joshua 10:3; 15:35). It is the same place called Remeth in Joshua 19:21 and Ramoth in 1 Chronicles 6:73. The name probably comes from a root meaning 'height'.
-
עֵ֥ין
ʿên · H5873
spring of (first half of the name En-gannim) · v29
ʿayin means 'eye' or 'spring'. As the first word of a place name it nearly always means a water source, and here it names the town after its spring.
-
אַרְבַּֽע׃ ס
ʾarbaʿ · H0702
four · v29, v31
The total from Issachar: Kishion, Daberath (v. 28), Jarmuth and En-gannim. The ס after it is a scribal mark for a paragraph break in the Hebrew manuscripts.
-
אָשֵׁ֔ר
ʾāshēr · H836
Asher · v30
The tribe named after Jacob's son Asher, whose name Leah explained as 'happy' or 'counted blessed' (Genesis 30:13). The tribe held the coastal plain and hills of western Galilee, inland from Acco and Tyre.
-
מִשְׁאָ֖ל
mishʾāl · H4861
Mishal · v30
A town in Asher's territory, also listed in 19:26. The name may come from the root meaning 'to ask', but that is uncertain. Its exact location is unknown. It is somewhere in the plain of Acco or the hills nearby.
-
עַבְדּ֖וֹן
ʿabdôn · H5658
Abdon · v30
A town in Asher, probably Tel Abdon (Khirbet ʿAbdeh), inland from Achzib on the north coast of Galilee. The name may come from the root ʿbd, 'serve', but the town has nothing to do with the judge called Abdon in Judges 12:13.
-
חֶלְקָת֙
Ḥelqāt · H2520
Helkath (place name) · v31
A town on Asher's border (Joshua 19:25). The name probably comes from the root for 'smooth' or 'allotted portion', so roughly 'Smooth Field' or 'Portion'. Where exactly it was is uncertain; a site on the edge of the Acco plain is likely.
-
רְחֹ֖ב
Rəḥōv · H7340
Rehob (place name) · v31
A town of Asher (Joshua 19:28, 30). The ordinary noun means 'broad place' or 'open square'. Several places in Israel had this name. This one was in the north-west, near Phoenician territory.
-
נַפְתָּלִ֜י
naftālî · H5321
Naphtali · v32
The northernmost tribe west of the Jordan. Its land lay in the hills of upper Galilee and along the west side of the Sea of Galilee (Josh 19:32–39).
-
קֶ֨דֶשׁ
qedesh · H6943
Kedesh · v32
The name means 'holy place' or 'sanctuary', which may point to an old shrine there. This is Kedesh of Naphtali, usually identified with Tel Qedesh in upper Galilee, north-west of Hazor.
-
בַּגָּלִ֤יל
baggālîl · H1551
in the Galil / Galilee · v32
Literally 'in the circle' or 'in the district'. With the article it is a regional name: 'the Galil', the northern hill country. Here it tells this Kedesh apart from other places called Kedesh.
-
חַמֹּ֥ת
ḥammōt · H2576
Hammoth (first part of Hammoth-dor) · v32
From the root ḥmm, 'to be hot'. It probably means 'hot springs'. The town is usually identified with Hammath (Josh 19:35), at the hot springs just south of later Tiberias.
-
קַרְתָּ֖ן
qartān · H7178
Kartan · v32
Probably based on qart, an old word for 'town' (as in Phoenician). It is likely the same place as 'Kiriathaim' ('double town') in 1 Chr 6:76. Its location is not known for certain.
-
שָׁלֹֽשׁ׃
shālōsh · H7969
three · v32, v33
Naphtali's share. Added to the totals for Manasseh (2), Issachar (4) and Asher (4), it gives the Gershonites' total of thirteen (v. 33).
-
כָּל־
kol- · H3605
all, the whole of · v33
Opens a summary total. The narrator stops listing names and adds them up: the full number of towns, with none left out.
-
הַגֵּרְשֻׁנִּ֖י
haggēršunnî · H1649
Gershonite · v33
Literally 'the Gershonite,' a singular word standing for the whole group: everyone descended from Gershon, Levi's firstborn son (Exod 6:16–17; Num 3:17–18).
-
עֶשְׂרֵ֥ה
ʿeśrēh · H6240
-teen (ten, in compound numbers) · v33
Completes 'thirteen.' The total matches the cities named in vv. 27–32: 2 from half-Manasseh, 4 from Issachar, 4 from Asher, 3 from Naphtali.
The world behind it
The Levites' unusual inheritance. Every other tribe received a block of land. Levi received none, because "the LORD God of Israel is their inheritance" (Josh 13:33). Instead Levi received 48 towns with their grazing land, scattered through all the tribes (Num 35:1–8; Josh 21:41). That meant Levites lived among all Israel, in line with Jacob's words that Levi would be "scattered in Israel" (Gen 49:7). The towns were assigned by lot, clan by clan: Kohathite priests (the sons of Aaron), other Kohathites, Gershonites and Merarites (21:4–7). The Gershonites received 13 towns in the north: from eastern Manasseh, Issachar, Asher and Naphtali (21:6, 27–33).
Bashan and Og. Bashan is the high, well-watered basalt plateau east and northeast of the Sea of Galilee. Biblical poets used it as a byword for strength and plenty: "strong bulls of Bashan" (Ps 22:12), "cows of Bashan" (Amos 4:1), "oaks of Bashan" (Isa 2:13). Israel's tradition remembered its king Og, who ruled from Ashtaroth and Edrei, as the last of the giant Rephaim (Deut 3:1–11; Josh 12:4). Moses granted the region to the Machirite half of Manasseh (Josh 13:29–31). Golan, Beeshterah and their pasturelands sat in this frontier zone, exposed to the Arameans to the north. The region changed hands repeatedly in later centuries (1 Kgs 22:3; 2 Kgs 10:32–33).
Blood-vengeance and asylum. In a kinship-based society, a killing put the dead person's nearest kinsman, the go'el ha-dam ("redeemer/avenger of blood"), under obligation to answer for the blood. The refuge towns did not abolish this duty. They limited it: the killer had a protected place to reach, a hearing before the town's elders and the congregation, and, if the killing was found to be unintentional, safety as long as he stayed in the town until the high priest's death (Num 35:9–34; Deut 19:1–13; Josh 20). Golan was the northern refuge town east of the Jordan, matching Bezer in the south and Ramoth-gilead in the middle (Deut 4:43; Josh 20:8).
From the study of Joshua 21:27.
Where scholars differ
in v27
When does the Levitical city list (Joshua 21 / 1 Chronicles 6) come from?
-
It reflects an actual administrative arrangement of the early monarchy (David/Solomon).
W. F. Albright and B. Mazar argued that the list fits the borders of the United Monarchy, including towns like Gezer that came under Israelite control only in Solomon's time, and that the Levites served as royal-religious officials in frontier regions.
-
It is a later idealised or reconstructed list (late monarchy, around Josiah, or after the exile).
A. Alt, followed by others, linked it to Josiah's reforms. Some scholars (e.g., A. G. Auld) argue the list developed late, possibly in relation to 1 Chr 6, and point to its schematic total of 48 (4 towns × 12 tribes, with adjustments) and to towns never otherwise known to have been held by Levites.
-
It preserves early tradition reworked over time.
Many recent commentators see both old geographical knowledge and later shaping, given the close but not identical relationship to 1 Chr 6.
in v27
Are Beeshterah and Ashtaroth the same town?
-
Yes: Beeshterah is a contracted form of Beth-Ashtarah = Ashtaroth (Tell ʿAshtarah).
The parallel list in 1 Chr 6:71 reads Ashtaroth in the same slot, and contracting beth- to be- is a known pattern in place names. Ashtaroth was the principal town of Bashan.
-
They are possibly separate but nearby sites, or Beeshterah was a cult place associated with Ashtaroth.
The names are not identical, and Ashtaroth is plural ('Astartes') while Beeshterah is singular. A temple precinct and the town could have been distinguished. The evidence is not decisive.
in v28
When does the list of Levitical towns come from?
-
It records a real administrative arrangement from the early monarchy (David or Solomon).
W. F. Albright and B. Mazar argued that the towns fit the borders and conditions of the 10th century BC, and that many were royal administrative centres.
-
It reflects a later reform, possibly under Josiah, or is a partly ideal scheme.
A. Alt and others pointed to gaps in the list's coverage and to links with later reforms. Some scholars treat the even pattern of 48 towns, 4 per tribe, as a planned ideal rather than a record of settlements.
-
It preserves old traditions about Levite settlement that were put into their present form later.
Archaeological evidence for when the various sites were occupied is mixed, and the Joshua and Chronicles lists differ, which suggests the material was handed down and adjusted over time.
in v28
Kishion or Kedesh, and where was Kishion?
-
Kishion is the original reading, and the 'Kedesh' in Chronicles is a copying error.
Kishion is supported independently by Issachar's own town list in Joshua 19:20.
-
The Chronicles list reflects a real change or a different town.
Kedesh is a common town name, and there was a Kedesh in the Issachar/Jezreel area, possibly Tel Abu Qudeis.
-
Several sites have been proposed for Kishion, and none is certain.
Tel Qishyon (Tell el-Ajjul or Khirbet Qasyun) near Tabor and Tel Rekhesh have both been proposed. Neither has an inscription confirming the name.
in v29
Where was Issachar's Jarmuth (Remeth/Ramoth)?
-
Kokab el-Hawa (later the Crusader castle Belvoir), on the ridge above the Jordan Valley.
Its height matches the root meaning 'high', and it is in the right area of Issachar's eastern territory.
-
Location unknown, with other hill sites in lower Galilee proposed.
No inscription or later source fixes the site. The variation in the name across the lists also makes identification harder.
in v29
Which period does the Levitical-town list describe?
-
It reflects a real administrative arrangement from the early monarchy (the time of David and Solomon), written back into the conquest account.
W. F. Albright and B. Mazar argued that the list's geography fits the borders of the united monarchy and royal administrative centres.
-
It preserves a much older tribal arrangement, as the book presents it.
Numbers 35 and Joshua 21 present it as a single allotment, and some of the towns have Late Bronze or early Iron Age remains.
-
It is a later idealised scheme (48 towns, 4 per tribe) composed by priestly writers.
The neat pattern of numbers, and the differences between the Joshua and Chronicles lists, suggest a scheme was being systematised.
in v30
Where was Mishal?
-
In or near the plain of Acco, possibly Tell Keisan or a nearby mound.
Joshua 19:26 lists Mishal with towns that border Carmel and the Acco plain, and a possible match in Thutmose III's town list fits a site in this area.
-
The site is unknown.
No inscription or continuous place name pins it down. Tell Keisan is also proposed for other towns, such as Achshaph, so cautious atlases leave Mishal unplaced.
in v30
When does the list of Levitical towns in Joshua 21 come from?
-
It reflects real administration in the early monarchy, under David and Solomon.
W. F. Albright and B. Mazar argued that the towns fit the borders and needs of the united kingdom, including frontier areas that were only firmly held then.
-
It comes from a later period (the time of Josiah, or after the exile) or is partly an idealised scheme.
A. Alt and others noted gaps and patterns in the geography, and the neat total of 48 towns, four per tribe. Some argue it describes a planned ideal rather than a record of where Levites actually lived.
-
It preserves early tradition that was edited over time.
The differences from 1 Chronicles 6, and the inclusion of towns that Judges 1 says were not conquered, suggest an old core that was later revised.
in v31
When was the list of Levitical cities drawn up, and does it describe a real arrangement?
-
It reflects a real administrative arrangement from the early monarchy (often dated to David or Solomon).
W. F. Albright and B. Mazar argued that the towns form a coherent network of royal or administrative centres that fits the 10th century BC. Several of them, such as Gezer and Taanach, came under Israelite control only around then.
-
It is a later idealised or schematic list (late monarchy, or after the exile).
The neat total of forty-eight towns (four per tribe in most cases) matches the ideal of Numbers 35. Judges 1:31 shows towns like Rehob were never fully taken. The parallel in 1 Chronicles 6 differs in detail, which suggests the list was reworked over time.
-
It is an old core preserved in a later framework.
Many recent commentators (for example R. Nelson and R. Boling) think the list may preserve real early place-names while its present arrangement reflects the theology of a land given and a promise fulfilled (Joshua 21:43–45).
in v31
Where were Helkath and Rehob?
-
Helkath was at Tell el-Qassis or Tell el-Harbaj (Tel Regev) at the south-east edge of the Acco plain.
This fits its place on Asher's southern border in Joshua 19:25. No inscription confirms either site.
-
Rehob of Asher was at Tell el-Bir el-Gharbi (Tel Bira) east of Acco, or another site in the Acco plain.
It must be near Acco and the Phoenician coast (Joshua 19:28–30; Judges 1:31) and is mentioned in Egyptian lists. The identification remains tentative.
in v32
When does the list of Levitical towns in Joshua 21 come from, and does it describe a real arrangement?
-
It reflects real administration under the early monarchy (David and Solomon).
Proposed by W. F. Albright and developed by B. Mazar. Several of the towns were only in Israelite hands in the 10th century, and the list looks like a royal arrangement for placing Levites in border and newly gained areas.
-
It reflects a later reorganisation, perhaps under Josiah (late 7th century).
A. Alt and others point to the way the list's geography matches later Judahite administrative districts.
-
It is largely an ideal or theological scheme from priestly circles, written during or after the exile.
The neat numbers (48 towns, 4 per tribe, uniform 2,000-cubit pastures in Num 35), and towns such as Hebron and Shechem that were never purely Levitical, suggest a planned design more than a record of actual holdings (J. Wellhausen; more recent critical commentators).
in v32
Did the Levites own these towns outright, or only houses and pasture in them?
-
Only houses and the common pasture; other Israelites also lived in and farmed around the towns.
Josh 21:12 gives Hebron's fields and villages to Caleb but the town and its pasture to the priests. Lev 25:32–34 speaks of 'houses in the cities' and the unsellable migrash.
-
The towns were Levitical settlements as a whole.
The plain wording 'they gave the cities' throughout Joshua 21, and the summary totals.
in v33
When does the Levitical city list (Josh 21; 1 Chr 6) date from, and does it describe a real arrangement?
-
It reflects real administration under the early monarchy, in the time of David or Solomon.
W. F. Albright and B. Mazar noted that several towns (for example Gezer and Gibbethon) were only under Israelite control in the 10th century BCE. They read the list as royal placement of Levites in border or newly taken regions.
-
It comes from the later monarchy, perhaps Josiah's time (7th century BCE).
A. Alt and others linked the list to reforms that centralised worship and to the geography of Judah under Josiah.
-
It is largely an ideal or theological scheme, written down late.
Wellhausen and later critics pointed to the neat pattern (48 towns, 4 per tribe) and to the clash with Deuteronomy's picture of Levites scattered and poor (e.g. Deut 14:29). On this view the list is an ideal plan.
-
It is a composite: real older material shaped into an idealised whole.
N. Na'aman and others argue that the town names reflect real geography, while the 4-per-tribe structure is literary arrangement. The differences between Joshua and Chronicles show the list was handed down and adapted.
Sources
- BDB and HALOT s.v. מִקְלָט, מִגְרָשׁ, רָצַח, מַטֶּה, בְּעֶשְׁתְּרָה
- Numbers 35; Deuteronomy 4:41–43; 19:1–13; Joshua 20–21; 1 Chronicles 6:54–81 (parallel list)
- Amarna letters EA 197, 256 (ʿAshtartu in Bashan)
- Mishnah Makkot 2 (rabbinic development of asylum in Levitical towns)
- W. F. Albright, 'The List of Levitic Cities' (1945); B. Mazar, 'The Cities of the Priests and the Levites' (1960)
- A. G. Auld, Joshua, Moses and the Land (1980)
- R. S. Hess, Joshua (Tyndale OT Commentaries)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Joshua 20–21
- BDB s.v. מִגְרָשׁ
- HALOT s.v. מִגְרָשׁ; s.v. מַטֶּה
- HALOT s.v. קִשְׁיוֹן; s.v. דָּבְרַת
- Anchor Bible Dictionary, 'Levitical Cities'; 'Kishion'; 'Daberath'
- Y. Aharoni, The Land of the Bible: A Historical Geography
- W. F. Albright, 'The List of Levitic Cities' (1945)
- R. G. Boling and G. E. Wright, Joshua (Anchor Bible)
- Vulgate, Josue 21:28
- Josephus, Life 126; Jewish War 2.595
- HALOT s.v. מִגְרָשׁ; s.v. יַרְמוּת; s.v. עֵין גַּנִּים
- Numbers 35:1–8; Leviticus 25:32–34; 1 Chronicles 6:54–81
- B. Mazar, 'The Cities of the Priests and the Levites' (VTSup 7, 1960)
- Josephus, Jewish War 3.48 (Ginaea)
- HALOT s.v. מִגְרָשׁ
- HALOT s.v. מַטֶּה
- BDB s.v. מִשְׁאָל; עַבְדּוֹן
- W. F. Albright, 'The List of Levitic Cities' (Louis Ginzberg Jubilee Volume, 1945)
- R. G. Boling & G. E. Wright, Joshua (Anchor Bible)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Joshua 21
- Numbers 35:1–8; Leviticus 25:34; 1 Chronicles 6:74–75; Joshua 19:24–31; Judges 1:31–32
- HALOT s.v. רְחוֹב
- BDB s.v. עִיר
- Numbers 35:1–8; Leviticus 25:32–34
- 1 Chronicles 6:74–75 (Heb. 6:59–60)
- Joshua 19:24–31; Judges 1:31–32
- R. D. Nelson, Joshua (OTL)
- BDB s.v. מִקְלָט, מִגְרָשׁ, גָּלִיל, רָצַח
- HALOT s.v. מִקְלָט, מִגְרָשׁ, קַרְתָּן, חַמֹּת דֹּאר
- Numbers 35; Deuteronomy 19; Joshua 20; 1 Chronicles 6:54–81 (parallel list)
- STEPBible / TAHOT tagged Hebrew text (supplied data)
- BDB s.v. מִגְרָשׁ, מִשְׁפָּחָה, עִיר
- Numbers 35:1–8; Leviticus 25:32–34; Numbers 3–4 (Gershonite duties)
- 1 Chronicles 6:54–81 (parallel list)
- Mishnah Arakhin 9:8; Sotah 5:3 (on migrash)
- N. Na'aman, Borders and Districts in Biblical Historiography (1986)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Josh 21
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).