Matthew Chapter 27 Read as one passage

Matthew 27:19–24

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

19While Pilate was sitting on the judgment seat, his wife sent him this message: “Have nothing to do with that innocent man, for I have suffered terribly in a dream today because of Him.” 20But the chief priests and elders persuaded the crowds to ask for Barabbas and to have Jesus put to death. 21“Which of the two do you want me to release to you?” asked the governor. “Barabbas,” they replied. 22“What then should I do with Jesus who is called Christ?” Pilate asked. They all answered, “Crucify Him!” 23“Why?” asked Pilate. “What evil has He done?” But they shouted all the louder, “Crucify Him!” 24When Pilate saw that he was accomplishing nothing, but that instead a riot was breaking out, he took water and washed his hands before the crowd. “I am innocent of this man’s blood,” he said. “You bear the responsibility.”

What the first hearers heard

For Matthew’s first hearers, probably Jewish followers of Jesus in a mixed Jewish and Gentile setting in the late first century, this short scene did several things:

  • It added a witness to Jesus’ innocence, and a heavenly one. In a trial narrative an unexpected witness for the accused counts for a lot. Here the witness is a member of the Roman ruling household, and her testimony comes through a dream, which suggests it is from God. Along with Judas’ confession (27:4) and Pilate’s handwashing (27:24), it tells the audience that the one condemned was righteous and that those who condemned him knew or were warned of it.
  • It closed the Gospel’s dream frame. Dreams protected the child Jesus. Joseph was warned, and Gentile magi were warned not to return to Herod (2:12). At the end a Gentile is warned again in a dream, but now the ruler in charge does not listen. The parallel between Herod at the start and Pilate at the end, each a ruler facing the true king, would have been clear.
  • It contrasted Gentile perception with the hostility of the leaders. As with the magi and later the centurion (“Truly this was the Son of God,” 27:54), an outsider sees what Jerusalem’s authorities refuse to see. This matters for a community that was increasingly including Gentiles.
  • It made Pilate more responsible, not less. The governor cannot claim ignorance. He knew the motive was envy (27:18), and he had a divine warning. His later claim of innocence (27:24) rings hollow, because he does what she begged him not to do.
  • It echoed Jesus’ own words about suffering. Her “I have suffered many things because of him” repeats the language of his passion predictions (16:21). The hearer is reminded that the suffering he foretold is now under way.

From the study of Matthew 27:19.

Verse by verse

  1. 19While Pilate was sitting on the judgment seat, his wife sent him this message: “Have nothing to do with that innocent man, for I have suffered terribly in a dream today because of Him.”

    While Pilate was seated on the raised tribunal, officially in session and about to hand down a binding verdict, his wife sent a messenger into the proceedings with an urgent word: “Let there be nothing between you and that righteous man. Don’t get tangled up in his fate. Today, in a dream, I have suffered greatly because of him.”

    Each part of her message carries weight:

    • “Nothing between you and…” is an idiom of separation: have no dealings, take no part, keep yourself clear. She is not mainly pleading for Jesus. She wants her husband to stay out of something dangerous.
    • “That righteous man” means in court terms innocent, in the right. In Jewish ears it also meant a man upright before God. A Gentile, a Roman official’s wife, is the first at the trial to say it.
    • “I have suffered many things” describes real anguish, not a mildly unpleasant night. It uses the same words Jesus used about himself: the Son of Man “must suffer many things.”
    • “Today, in a dream” places the experience in the night just ended. In her world, and in Matthew’s Gospel, a dream like that was a warning from heaven.

    Matthew sets the message between two notes about the crowd. Pilate knows the leaders handed Jesus over out of envy (v. 18), and the chief priests are persuading the crowd to ask for Barabbas (v. 20). The governor has a heavenly warning in hand and still goes on. Shortly afterward he washes his hands and declares himself innocent of this man’s blood (v. 24). That is a ritual attempt to have “nothing to do with” the righteous man after it is already too late.

    Full study →
  2. 20But the chief priests and elders persuaded the crowds to ask for Barabbas and to have Jesus put to death.

    But meanwhile, while Pilate sat on the judgment seat and his wife's message about "that righteous man" reached him, the men who actually ran Jerusalem were at work. The senior priestly families and the lay nobility of the city won the crowds over. They used whatever influence it took, the same word Matthew later uses for their plan to "square" the governor about the guards they had paid off. They talked the people into using their festival privilege, claiming as their own favour the release of Barabbas ("son of the father"). And they talked them into the other half of the bargain: that Jesus (emphasised in the Greek, "but Jesus, him…") should be destroyed. This is the same word Matthew used for Herod's hunt for the infant Jesus and for the Pharisees' early plot against him. The crowds would not hold the hammer or the nails. But their shouted choice would be the means by which a long-running plan to destroy Jesus finally succeeded. The verse sets those who lead against those who are led. The leaders design the outcome; the crowds voice it.

    Full study →
  3. 21“Which of the two do you want me to release to you?” asked the governor. “Barabbas,” they replied.

    Then the governor, the Roman official who held the power of life and death in the province, took up the matter again. He had first put the question in v. 17. Since then his wife's warning had interrupted him, and the chief priests had been at work in the crowd. Now he spoke to the crowd and asked: "Of these two men, which one is it your will that I set free as a favour to you?" The question treats the release as a festival gift handed to the people. It places Jesus and Barabbas side by side as the only two options. Earlier Pilate had set them against each other as "Barabbas, or Jesus who is called Messiah". In some ancient manuscripts that phrase reads "Jesus Barabbas, or Jesus who is called Messiah", which would make this a choice between two men named Jesus. The crowd's answer is a single name: "Barabbas." The name is Aramaic for "son of Abba / son of the father". It belonged to a notorious prisoner, jailed according to the other Gospels for insurrection and murder. The answer is flat and immediate. Matthew does not yet say they shouted. The shouting comes in the next verse, when the same crowd says of Jesus, "Let him be crucified!"

    Full study →
  4. 22“What then should I do with Jesus who is called Christ?” Pilate asked. They all answered, “Crucify Him!”

    The Roman governor, who alone has the power to order an execution, turns the decision over to the crowd. They have just chosen Barabbas, so Pilate asks: "Then what am I to do to Jesus, the one people call the Anointed King?" He does not say "Jesus the Messiah." He says "the one called Messiah," keeping at a distance a title that, to a Roman, meant a rival king in his province. Matthew's readers feel the irony, because Matthew opened his Gospel with the same words in his own voice (1:16), meaning them as true.

    Every voice in the crowd answers the same way: "Let him be crucified!" The form is not quite "You, crucify him." It demands the outcome as if passing sentence: let it be done to him. And the death they name is not just any execution. It is the one Rome kept for slaves and rebels, the most shameful death that existed, and it fits the "would-be king" label Pilate has just pinned on him. The judge asks the crowd for a verdict, and the crowd demands a rebel's death for the man called Messiah.

    Full study →
  5. 23“Why?” asked Pilate. “What evil has He done?” But they shouted all the louder, “Crucify Him!”

    Pilate, the Roman governor sitting as judge, cannot believe what he is hearing. He answers the crowd's first demand with one exasperated question: "Why, what wrong has he actually done?" He is asking for a charge: a specific, completed act that could justify a sentence. The crowd gives no answer. Instead they kept on shouting, louder and louder, beyond all measure: "Let him be crucified!" Their cry does not even address Pilate as "you". It is an impersonal demand that the cross, Rome's most shameful death, used for rebels and slaves, be done to him. The scene is a deliberate contrast. Reason and law ask for a crime. A rising roar answers with no crime, only a punishment. The words "they kept crying out, saying" are exactly the words Matthew used for the Hosanna days earlier (21:9), so the reader hears the two cries of the week side by side.

    Full study →
  6. 24When Pilate saw that he was accomplishing nothing, but that instead a riot was breaking out, he took water and washed his hands before the crowd. “I am innocent of this man’s blood,” he said. “You bear the responsibility.”

    Pilate realised that his attempts to get Jesus released were doing no good at all. Worse, the shouting was turning into the start of a riot, the one thing a Roman governor at Passover could least afford. So he sent for water and, in full view of the crowd, washed his hands clean. Anyone who knew the Scriptures would recognise the gesture: it was how the elders of Israel publicly declared, “Our hands did not shed this blood” (Deuteronomy 21). As he did it he pronounced a verdict on himself: “I am guiltless, not liable, clear of this man's blood”, meaning I am not answerable for his death. Then he pushed the guilt back at them, with emphasis: “You — you see to it. That's your affair.”

    These are the exact words the chief priests had used a few hours earlier to brush off Judas when he cried that he had betrayed “innocent blood” (27:4). The verse is full of irony. A crowd uprising, which the priests had feared, now becomes their tool. A ritual meant for people who really were innocent is performed by the one man with the power to stop the execution, and two verses later he orders it anyway. The word “blood” here means a violent death and the guilt that belongs to whoever caused it. Pilate washes, declares and hands the responsibility on, but Matthew's readers are meant to see that water and words do not undo what he is about to do.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v19

    that just man (KJV)

    tō dikaiō ekeinō

    What we hear
    “That mere man” or “only a man,” reading “just” as the everyday adverb meaning “only.”
    What they heard
    “That righteous / innocent man”: one who is in the right before the law and upright before God.
  • in v19

    in a dream

    kat' onar

    What we hear
    A private mental experience, perhaps stress or the subconscious, with no outside source.
    What they heard
    A dream that brings a message, commonly understood as a warning from God or the gods. In Matthew dreams are always the way God guides people around Jesus (1:20; 2:12–22).
  • in v19

    I have suffered

    epathon

    What we hear
    Possibly physical pain or illness.
    What they heard
    She went through anguish and distress. Not bodily harm, but deep inner torment in the dream.
  • in v20

    elders

    presbyteroi

    What we hear
    Church elders: congregational officers, pastors or a church board.
    What they heard
    The lay aristocracy of Jerusalem, heads of powerful families who sat with the priests on the ruling council and negotiated with Rome.
  • in v20

    chief priests

    archiereis

    What we hear
    Several equal "high priests", or simply clergy in general.
    What they heard
    One serving high priest plus former high priests and senior men of the few high-priestly families: a hereditary Temple aristocracy with political power.
  • in v21

    Whether of the twain (KJV)

    tina … apo tōn duo

    What we hear
    Today 'whether' introduces a yes/no alternative ('whether or not'), and 'twain' sounds poetic or obscure, so the line can read like garbled English.
    What they heard
    'Which one of the two?' In older English, 'whether' was also a pronoun meaning 'which of two' (Old English hwæther), and 'twain' simply meant 'two'. The KJV's wording is an exact rendering of the Greek.
  • in v21

    will ye (KJV)

    thelete

    What we hear
    It can sound like a future tense: 'will you (do something)?'
    What they heard
    'Do you want / is it your will (that I release)?' It is a present-tense verb of wishing and choosing.
  • in v21

    governor

    hēgemōn

    What we hear
    A civilian chief executive of a state or region, often elected and limited by courts and legislatures.
    What they heard
    An emperor-appointed Roman military prefect over a conquered province. He commanded troops and alone held the power to execute.
  • in v22

    Christ

    christos

    What we hear
    Jesus' second name or surname, or a purely religious title for a divine figure.
    What they heard
    "The Anointed One": the royal title of Israel's expected king, which in a Roman court meant a claim to political kingship.
  • in v23

    What evil has he done?

    ti gar kakon epoiēsen

    What we hear
    What monstrous wickedness is in this man? Is he an evil person?
    What they heard
    A judge's question: "What wrong, what crime, did he commit?" Kakon here means a punishable misdeed, not a moral or spiritual verdict on his whole character.
  • in v24

    washed his hands

    apenipsato tas cheiras

    What we hear
    The English idiom “to wash one's hands of something”, which means to stop being involved, walk away, or refuse to take part any further.
    What they heard
    A public ritual claiming freedom from bloodguilt: “my hands did not cause this death” (Deut 21:6–7; Ps 26:6). It was a claim of legal and moral innocence for a killing, made at the moment Pilate was about to authorise that killing. He was not stepping back from the case; he stayed in charge and passed the sentence (27:26).
Every word
  1. Καθημένου

    kathēmenou · G2521

    to sit · v19

    “While [he] was sitting.” This opens a background clause. Sitting is the judge’s formal posture: a Roman magistrate gave binding rulings seated on his tribunal, so Pilate is in official session.

  2. δὲ

    de · G1161

    but/and · v19, v20, v21, v23, v24

    A light connective (“now”) moving the story to a new detail, set into the scene of the crowd choosing between Jesus and Barabbas.

  3. αὐτοῦ

    autou · G0846

    he · v19, v21, v22

    “He,” meaning Pilate, the subject of the sitting.

  4. ἐπὶ

    epi · G1909

    upon · v19

    “On”: seated upon the raised platform.

  5. τοῦ

    tou · G3588

    the · v19, v20, v21, v22, v23, v24

    “The”: the specific tribunal where the governor sat.

  6. βήματος

    bēmatos · G0968

    judgment seat, tribunal · v19

    The raised platform from which a Roman official heard cases and gave verdicts. It stood for Rome’s authority to judge, and here that authority is about to be used to condemn the man his wife calls righteous.

  7. ἀπέστειλεν

    apesteilen · G0649

    to send · v19

    “Sent”: she sends a messenger rather than appearing herself. The urgency is plain, because she interrupts a public court session.

  8. πρὸς

    pros · G4314

    to · v19

    “To”: the message is aimed at him.

  9. γυνὴ

    gynē · G1135H

    woman, wife · v19

    “Wife.” With “his” after it, γυνή means wife. She is not named in Matthew. Later tradition called her Procla or Claudia Procula.

  10. λέγουσα·

    legousa · G3004G

    to say · v19, v22, v23, v24

    “Saying.” It introduces the wording of her message, quoted directly.

  11. μηδὲν

    mēden · G3367

    nothing · v19

    “[Let there be] nothing.” The phrase has no verb. This form of “nothing” carries a command or wish: let there be no dealings, no involvement.

  12. σοὶ

    soi · G4771

    to you · v19, v21, v24

    “To you.” Together with “and to that righteous one” it forms the idiom “nothing between you and him.”

  13. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v19, v20

    “And.” It joins the two parties whom she wants kept apart.

  14. δικαίῳ

    dikaiō · G1342

    righteous, just · v19

    “Righteous [man].” In a courtroom this means innocent, in the right before the law, but it also carries the full Jewish sense of an upright man faithful to God. Matthew lets both senses sound.

  15. ἐκείνῳ·

    ekeinō · G1565

    that · v19

    “That.” It points to the man standing before the tribunal. She seems to know him only as “that one.”

  16. πολλὰ

    polla · G4183

    many things, much · v19

    “Many things / much.” Used as the object of “suffered,” it gives the intensity: “I have suffered greatly.”

  17. γὰρ

    gar · G1063

    for · v19, v23

    “For.” It gives her reason for the warning.

  18. ἔπαθον

    epathon · G3958

    to suffer, experience · v19

    “I suffered.” It means anguish and distress she went through, not physical injury. The phrase “suffer many things” is the one Jesus used of his own coming passion (16:21).

  19. σήμερον

    sēmeron · G4594

    today · v19

    “Today.” The dream came this very day, which by Roman reckoning began at midnight, so the night just past counts. It is fresh and urgent.

  20. κατ᾽

    kat' · G2596

    according to, by way of · v19

    With ὄναρ it forms the set phrase “in a dream,” literally “by way of a dream.”

  21. ὄναρ

    onar · G3677

    dream · v19

    “A dream.” In Matthew a dream is how God guides and warns people (1:20; 2:12, 13, 19, 22). This is the sixth and last time he uses the phrase.

  22. δι᾽

    di' · G1223

    because of · v19

    Followed by a word in the accusative case (the object form), it means “because of, on account of.”

  23. ἀρχιερεῖς

    archiereis · G0749

    high priest; (pl.) chief priests · v20

    The plural means the priestly aristocracy: the serving high priest Caiaphas, former high priests such as Annas, and the leading men of the high-priestly families who ran the Temple.

  24. πρεσβύτεροι

    presbyteroi · G4245

    elder · v20

    The lay nobility of Jerusalem: heads of leading families who sat with the priests on the governing council. Here it is a social and political rank, not a church office.

  25. ἔπεισαν

    epeisan · G3982

    persuade, win over · v20

    A simple past (aorist) that sums up the whole effort. The word covers argument, pressure, influence and even bribery. Matthew uses the same verb in 28:14, where the leaders promise to "persuade" the governor about the guards they have paid off.

  26. ὄχλους

    ochlous · G3793

    crowd, throng, common people · v20, v24

    The word is plural: the "crowds", meaning the mass of ordinary people gathered at the governor's tribunal. They have no office, unlike the leaders who sway them.

  27. ἵνα

    hina · G2443

    in order that; that · v20

    After a verb of persuading, this word gives what the crowds were talked into ("persuaded them that they should…"). It is not a separate purpose clause.

  28. αἰτήσωνται

    aitēsōntai · G0154

    ask, request · v20

    The Greek form here (middle voice) can mean asking on one's own behalf or asking a favour. That fits the crowd claiming its festival right to have a prisoner released (Mark 15:8 uses the same form). YLT renders it "ask for themselves".

  29. Βαραββᾶν

    Barabban · G0912

    Barabbas · v20, v21

    An Aramaic family name, bar Abba, meaning "son of Abba" or "son of the father". He is the alternative the leaders steer the crowds toward.

  30. Ἰησοῦν

    Iēsoun · G2424

    Jesus (Yeshua/Joshua) · v20, v22

    Placed first in its clause for emphasis: "but Jesus, him they should destroy".

  31. ἀπολέσωσιν

    apolesōsin · G0622

    destroy, kill, cause to perish · v20

    The crowd does not carry out the killing. Their shouted demand is what brings Jesus' death about, so the verb means "get him destroyed". This is Matthew's word for the plots against Jesus from the start (2:13; 12:14), and here those plots reach their goal.

  32. Ἀποκριθεὶς

    Apokritheis · G0611

    to answer, respond · v21

    No one has asked Pilate a question. In Biblical Greek, 'answering, he said' often just means 'he responded to the situation' or 'he spoke up again'. Here Pilate picks the matter back up after his wife's message (v. 19) and the priests' lobbying of the crowd (v. 20).

  33. ἡγεμὼν

    hēgemōn · G2232

    governor, leader, ruler · v21, v23

    The Roman official who governed the province, with power over life and death. Matthew calls Pilate by this title rather than by name throughout the trial, which keeps the reader aware that Roman imperial power is making the decision.

  34. εἶπεν

    eipen · G2036

    said · v21

    A simple past-tense 'said', reporting the question as one event.

  35. τίνα

    tina · G5101

    whom? which? · v21, v22, v23

    A question word asking the crowd to pick one person. With 'from among the two' it means 'which one of these two'.

  36. θέλετε

    thelete · G2309

    to want, will, wish · v21

    'Do you want' or 'is it your will'. Pilate puts the decision in terms of what the crowd wants. The same verb appears in v. 15, where the governor released 'whomever they wanted', and the scene leads to Pilate trying to disown the outcome in v. 24.

  37. ἀπὸ

    apo · G0575

    from · v21, v24

    Here it means 'from among': one is taken out of a set of two.

  38. δύο

    duo · G1417

    two · v21

    'The two' places the men side by side as the only options. This sharpens the contrast Matthew set up in v. 17, where Pilate asked 'Barabbas, or Jesus who is called Christ?'

  39. ἀπολύσω

    apolysō · G0630

    to release, set free, let go · v21

    The legal release of a prisoner from custody. The form means 'should I release'. Joined to 'do you want', it asks 'whom do you want me to release?'

  40. Πιλᾶτος

    Pilatos · G4091

    Pilate · v22, v24

    Pontius Pilatus, Roman prefect of Judea (c. AD 26–36), the only person present with legal power to order a crucifixion.

  41. οὖν

    oun · G3767

    then, therefore · v22

    Ties the question to the crowd's previous answer: "Since you have chosen Barabbas, what then...?" Pilate's own offer has boxed him in.

  42. ποιήσω

    poiēsō · G4160

    do, make · v22, v23

    Aorist subjunctive used to deliberate: "What am I to do?" It is a question about a decision still to be made, not a prediction. The judge is asking the crowd to decide.

  43. χριστόν

    christon · G5547

    anointed one, Messiah · v22

    A title, not a surname: "the Anointed," the expected Jewish king. To a Roman governor it meant one thing, a claimant to kingship (compare "King of the Jews," 27:11).

  44. πάντες

    pantes · G3956

    all · v22

    Everyone in the crowd answered with one voice. Matthew stresses that they were unanimous, which builds toward "all the people" in 27:25.

  45. σταυρωθήτω

    staurōthētō · G4717

    let him be crucified · v22, v23

    An aorist passive imperative in the third person: "Let him be crucified!" It demands a verdict without naming who carries it out. Mark has the direct "Crucify him!" (sing. active, addressed to Pilate).

  46. ἔφη

    ephē · G5346

    said · v23

    A plain verb for speaking, often used to introduce a quotation. It reports one reply from Pilate, set against the crowd's ongoing shouting.

  47. κακὸν

    kakon · G2556

    bad, evil, wrong · v23

    As a noun, "a wrong, a misdeed, a crime". In a courtroom it means an offence that deserves punishment. Pilate is asking what crime the charge is.

  48. περισσῶς

    perissōs · G4057

    exceedingly; all the more · v23

    "Beyond measure", here with the comparative sense "even more". The question does not calm the crowd. It makes them louder.

  49. ἔκραζον

    ekrazon · G2896

    cried out, shouted · v23

    A loud, raw cry. The tense (imperfect) shows ongoing action: "they kept shouting". Mark 15:14 uses a one-time form, "they shouted". Matthew makes it a continuing roar.

  50. Ἰδὼν

    Idōn · G1492

    having seen · v24

    Not physical sight but realisation: Pilate takes stock of the situation. The past-tense participle sets up everything that follows as his response to what he grasped.

  51. ὅτι

    hoti · G3754

    that · v24

    Introduces what Pilate realised.

  52. οὐδὲν

    ouden · G3762

    nothing · v24

    “Nothing” is put first for emphasis: his efforts were getting absolutely nowhere.

  53. ὠφελεῖ

    ōphelei · G5623

    to help, benefit, be of use · v24

    Present tense, kept from Pilate's own point of view: “it is doing no good.” It refers to his attempts in verses 17–23 to get Jesus released, through the Barabbas offer and the question “What evil has he done?”

  54. ἀλλὰ

    alla · G235

    but · v24

    Strong contrast: not only no progress, but the reverse.

  55. μᾶλλον

    mallon · G3123

    rather, more · v24

    “Instead”: things are getting worse, not better.

  56. θόρυβος

    thorybos · G2351

    uproar, commotion, riot · v24

    The roar of a crowd turning into public disorder. This was exactly what a Roman governor was meant to prevent, and what the priests themselves had feared in 26:5.

  57. γίνεται

    ginetai · G1096

    to become, happen, arise · v24

    Present tense: the riot is starting as he watches, not yet in full swing.

  58. λαβὼν

    labōn · G2983

    having taken · v24

    A deliberate act. Pilate gets water for the purpose, which makes this a planned gesture and not an accident of the moment.

  59. ὕδωρ

    hydōr · G5204

    water · v24

    Plain water, used here as a symbol: water that cleanses a person from bloodguilt.

  60. ἀπενίψατο

    apenipsato · G633

    to wash off · v24

    The prefix apo- means “off, away”. The middle form means he washed his own hands. This verb appears nowhere else in the New Testament, and the picture is of washing something away from oneself.

  61. χεῖρας

    cheiras · G5495

    hands · v24

    In biblical idiom the hands stand for what a person does, so “clean hands” means “I did not do this deed” (Deut 21:7; Ps 24:4).

  62. ἀπέναντι

    apenanti · G561

    opposite, in front of, before · v24

    Face to face with the crowd: a public act done so that everyone would see it.

  63. ἀθῷός

    athōos · G121

    innocent, guiltless · v24

    Literally “without penalty”: not liable to punishment. It is a legal and moral claim, not a claim to be naive or pure-hearted, and it stands first in the sentence for emphasis.

  64. εἰμι

    eimi · G1510

    I am · v24

    Present tense: a formal declaration of his standing, as if he were pronouncing a verdict on himself.

  65. αἵματος

    haimatos · G129

    blood · v24

    “Blood” stands for a life taken by violence, and so for the guilt of a killing. Pilate means: I am not responsible for this death.

  66. τούτου

    toutou · G3778

    this, this one · v24

    Most naturally “of this man”, pointing at Jesus, though in the shorter text the Greek could grammatically also mean “this blood”. Either way, it is Jesus' death that is meant.

  67. ὄψεσθε

    opsesthe · G3700

    you will see · v24

    A future tense used as an idiom: “you see to it”, “that's your affair”. It shifts responsibility onto them, word for word what the priests told Judas in 27:4 (“you will see [to it]”).

The world behind it

Roman governors and their wives. Officials did not always take their wives to the provinces. The Roman Senate debated the practice in AD 21: Caecina Severus proposed banning it, arguing that wives meddled in provincial affairs, and the proposal was defeated (Tacitus, Annals 3.33–34). The debate shows that wives did accompany governors in this period and were sometimes thought to influence their decisions. Pilate’s wife being in Jerusalem for Passover, and sending word to him, fits that world.

The tribunal. Roman provincial governors gave formal verdicts seated on a tribunal (Greek bēma), usually set up in a public space. When in Jerusalem, Pilate probably stayed at Herod’s former palace on the western hill. Josephus describes a later governor placing his tribunal in front of that palace (Jewish War 2.301). John 19:13 names the place “the Stone Pavement.” Matthew’s note that Pilate “was sitting on the tribunal” means the case has reached the point of decision.

Dreams as warnings. Jews and Romans alike took dreams before major decisions seriously. Romans told how Calpurnia dreamed of disaster the night before Julius Caesar was assassinated and begged him not to go to the Senate (Plutarch, Caesar 63; Suetonius, Julius 81). In Jewish scripture God speaks to Gentile rulers through dreams: Abimelech (Gen 20), Pharaoh (Gen 41), Nebuchadnezzar (Dan 2, 4). A Roman wife’s warning dream about a trial would have been instantly recognizable to Matthew’s audience as a sign not to be ignored.

Bloodguilt. Under Israel’s law, shedding innocent blood brought guilt that clung to those responsible (Deut 19:10; 21:1–9, where elders wash their hands to declare “our hands did not shed this blood”). Matthew 27 is full of this concern. Judas: “I have sinned by betraying innocent blood” (27:4). Pilate washes his hands (27:24). The people: “His blood be on us” (27:25). His wife’s plea to have “nothing to do with” the righteous man belongs to this thread.

From the study of Matthew 27:19.

Where scholars differ

in v19

Where did the dream come from, in Matthew’s view?

  • From God, as a warning that adds a heavenly witness to Jesus’ innocence.

    In Matthew every other dream (κατ᾽ ὄναρ) is a channel of divine guidance (1:20; 2:12, 13, 19, 22). The scene works as testimony to the “righteous” one, in line with 27:4, 24 and 54. Most modern commentators (e.g., Davies & Allison; R. E. Brown) read it this way.

  • From the devil, trying to stop the crucifixion and so the redemption it would bring.

    This view appears in some medieval Western interpreters and in medieval passion plays. It rests on the theological idea that Satan would want to stop the cross, not on anything in Matthew’s wording. The text does not mention an angel, but nothing in Matthew points to a demonic source either.

  • Matthew leaves the source unstated on purpose. The point is that Pilate was warned and went ahead anyway.

    Unlike 1:20 and 2:13, 19, no “angel of the Lord” appears. The narrative stresses the effect, Pilate’s greater responsibility, more than the mechanism.

in v19

Is the episode historical tradition or Matthew’s literary or theological shaping?

  • It preserves a genuine tradition.

    Governors’ wives were present in provinces (Tacitus, *Annals* 3.33–34), and Roman respect for warning dreams is well documented. The detail is short and unadorned, unlike later legendary expansions.

  • It is Matthean shaping, possibly legendary, built to frame the passion with dreams and to stress Jesus’ innocence and Pilate’s guilt.

    It appears only in Matthew. It neatly closes his infancy-narrative dream motif and fits his special emphasis on innocent blood (27:3–10, 24–25). Some compare it to Roman warning-dream stories like Calpurnia’s.

in v20

Was there really a Passover custom of releasing a prisoner chosen by the crowd?

  • The custom is historical, or plausibly so.

    All four Gospels report it independently in some form (John 18:39 calls it "your custom"). Possible parallels: an Egyptian papyrus (P. Flor. 61, c. 85 CE) in which a Roman prefect releases an accused man to the crowds; Mishnah Pesahim 8:6, which provides for the Passover lamb of "one whom they have promised to bring out of prison"; and Roman pardons granted at festivals or under popular pressure.

  • The custom is unattested and probably a narrative device or a one-off event made into a custom.

    Josephus, who describes Pilate in detail, never mentions it. A regular amnesty for rebels at Passover would be strange Roman policy in a volatile province. The parallels cited are not a fixed festival custom. Some (e.g. R. E. Brown, *Death of the Messiah*) suggest a single historical release was later described as habitual.

in v20

How large and representative was the crowd before Pilate?

  • A limited group gathered at the praetorium, open to influence by the leaders and their dependants.

    The scene is early morning at a palace courtyard. The verse stresses that the leaders persuaded them. Mark 15:8 has the crowd coming up specifically to request the release. Earlier, the leaders feared the wider festival crowds (26:5).

  • Matthew presents the crowd as standing for the people as a whole.

    In 27:25 Matthew moves from "the crowds" to "all the people" (pas ho laos), a term often used for Israel as a people, so that the scene carries significance for the people as a whole. Scholars disagree on how far this is theological representation rather than a historical estimate of the crowd's size.

in v21

Did a regular Passover release of a prisoner (the 'Passover amnesty') really exist?

  • Doubtful as a fixed custom. It may be a narrative device or an occasional act that the Gospel tradition generalised.

    No Roman, Jewish or other non-Christian source mentions a yearly Passover release. Josephus says nothing of it, even though he reports a good deal about Pilate. Freeing a convicted rebel would be unusual for a Roman governor.

  • Plausible as a local custom or as governors' discretionary practice.

    Partial parallels exist. In P.Flor. 61 (AD 85), an Egyptian prefect releases an accused man 'to the crowds'. The Mishnah (m. Pesahim 8:6) allows a Passover lamb to be slaughtered for one 'whom they have promised to bring out of prison'. Josephus records the governor Albinus releasing prisoners to win popular favour (Ant. 20.215). Livy describes prisoners released at a Roman religious festival (5.13). All four Gospels, including John, which seems to draw on a separate tradition, attest the custom independently.

in v21

Is there deliberate symbolism in the name Bar-Abba ('son of the father')?

  • Yes, it is an intentional irony. The crowd chooses one 'son of the father' over the true Son of the Father, and possibly one 'Jesus' over another.

    The 'Jesus Barabbas' reading in vv. 16–17 may be original. Matthew elsewhere stresses Jesus as Son of the Father (e.g., 11:27; 26:39). Early readers noticed the name: Origen did, and Jerome reports 'son of their teacher' from the Gospel according to the Hebrews.

  • No, or not demonstrably. It is an ordinary Aramaic family name.

    'Bar Abba' is a normal Jewish name meaning 'son of So-and-so' and is attested elsewhere, for example Rabbi Hiyya bar Abba. Matthew translates other meaningful names (1:23 'Emmanuel'; 27:33 'Golgotha') but never explains this one. Any wordplay must be inferred.

in v21

Is the crowd that said 'Barabbas' the same crowd that hailed Jesus at his entry into Jerusalem?

  • It is essentially the same Jerusalem population, which shows how fickle the people were.

    Matthew uses the same word (ochloi, 'crowds') in 21:9 and 27:20. 'All the city' was stirred at his entry (21:10).

  • Probably a different and smaller group, which the text does not identify with the Palm Sunday crowd.

    The entry crowd is pictured as pilgrims going before and following Jesus (21:9), many of them from Galilee (21:11). The trial crowd gathered early in the morning at the governor's tribunal, and the chief priests and elders actively persuaded it (27:20). Matthew never says they were the same people.

in v22

Was the crowd that shouted "Crucify!" the same crowd that shouted "Hosanna" at Jesus' entry (21:9)?

  • Yes, at least in large part. Jerusalem's festival crowds turned against Jesus within days.

    Both are called ochloi ("crowds") in a city packed for Passover. Matthew's story moves from acclaim to rejection, and fickle crowds are a familiar human pattern.

  • Matthew does not identify them, and the details suggest a different, smaller group.

    The Hosanna crowds came in with Jesus, largely Galilean pilgrims, as distinct from "the whole city" that asked "Who is this?" (21:10–11). The leaders arrested Jesus secretly at night because they feared the people (26:4–5). The trial crowd gathered at dawn at the governor's residence and was "persuaded" by the chief priests and elders (27:20). The text leaves the question open.

in v22

Is the Gospels' portrait of a reluctant Pilate historical?

  • Largely shaped by the story's purposes.

    Philo and Josephus describe Pilate as harsh and ready to use force, not easily swayed by a crowd. Early Christians writing under Roman rule had reason to stress Rome's reluctance and Jesus' innocence in Roman eyes.

  • Plausibly historical in substance.

    A governor might well test popular feeling and avoid unrest at a volatile festival. Pilate's questions can be read as political manoeuvring, or even contempt for the leaders, rather than sympathy for Jesus. All four Gospels independently portray him as hesitating.

in v22

Did a Passover amnesty custom (27:15) actually exist?

  • No independent evidence; possibly a narrative device or a one-off act.

    No Roman or Jewish source outside the Gospels mentions a regular Passover release.

  • Plausible as a local practice.

    Roman officials did sometimes release prisoners to win favour with a crowd (e.g. a papyrus of c. AD 85, P.Flor. 61, where a prefect pardons a prisoner "to the crowds"). Mishnah Pesahim 8:6 mentions preparing the Passover lamb for one "promised release from prison."

in v23

Is Matthew's portrait of a reluctant Pilate historical, or shaped by the Gospel's purposes?

  • Largely historical: Pilate was genuinely unconvinced and was handling a volatile Passover crowd.

    All four Gospels independently show Pilate questioning the charge (Mark 15:14; Luke 23:22; John 18:38; 19:4–6). A governor had good reason to avoid a riot at a festival (27:24 θόρυβος), and Josephus records cases where Pilate backed down before determined crowds (the standards affair, Antiquities 18.55–59).

  • Heightened for apologetic reasons: the Gospels play down Roman responsibility.

    Philo (Legatio 299–305) and Josephus describe Pilate as harsh and stubborn. Christians living under Rome had reason to show that a Roman judge found Jesus innocent. Matthew alone adds the wife's dream and the hand-washing (27:19, 24).

in v23

Did the Passover prisoner-release custom (27:15) exist?

  • A real local practice, perhaps at the governor's discretion.

    All four Gospels attest it (Mark 15:6; John 18:39). Releases at festivals and amnesties are known elsewhere in the ancient world, and some point to Mishnah Pesahim 8:6 on preparing the Passover for someone "promised release from prison".

  • Not attested outside the Gospels; possibly a one-off act or a narrative development.

    Josephus, who describes Roman Judea in detail, never mentions such a custom, and no Roman legal source records a fixed annual amnesty for a provincial governor.

in v24

Did the hand-washing happen as described, and would a Roman governor perform such a gesture?

  • It is plausible. The gesture was understood across cultures, and Pilate could have used it to make a point to a Jewish crowd.

    Washing after bloodshed is attested in Greek and Roman practice (e.g. Virgil, Aeneid 2.717–720) and in Jewish practice (Deut 21; Letter of Aristeas 305–306). A governor making a public show for a festival crowd needed a sign they would recognise, and this was one.

  • It is Matthew's own dramatic composition, built from Deuteronomy 21 and the Psalms to underline Jesus' innocence and Matthew's theme of bloodguilt.

    The scene appears only in Matthew. It uses Old Testament wording (athōos, “guiltless from blood”), it echoes 27:4 word for word, and it fits a set of passages unique to Matthew (Judas's death, the wife's dream, 27:25). Pilate's ruthless reputation in Philo and Josephus does not sit easily with a hesitant governor (see Brown, Death of the Messiah; Luz, Hermeneia).

  • A middle position: the core tradition of Pilate's reluctance is historical, and Matthew has shaped it with Scriptural language.

    All four Gospels show Pilate hesitating (Mark 15:14; Luke 23:4, 14–22; John 18:38; 19:4–12), so Matthew is building on shared tradition. The gesture and its wording are the parts that show Matthew's distinctive hand.

in v24

Does Matthew present Pilate as actually innocent?

  • No. The scene is ironic, and Pilate remains responsible.

    Deuteronomy 21 cleared only those who really had no part in a killing. Pilate goes on to flog Jesus and hand him over (27:26), and his soldiers carry out the crucifixion (27:27–37). “You see to it” puts him on the same level as the priests who said those words to Judas. Early Christian confession kept his name as the official responsible: “suffered under Pontius Pilate.”

  • Partly. Matthew lessens Pilate's guilt compared with the Jewish leaders, which reflects the conflicts of his own time.

    Matthew alone adds the wife's dream, the hand-washing and 27:25, and each of these increases the share of blame placed on the leaders and the crowd. Many scholars see this as reflecting Matthew's community in dispute with the synagogue, and perhaps a wish not to provoke Rome. Later texts (the Gospel of Peter, Tertullian) take this trend much further.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. βῆμα
  • BDAG s.v. δίκαιος
  • BDAG s.v. ὄναρ
  • BDAG s.v. πάσχω
  • Thayer s.v. μηδείς
  • Josephus, Jewish War 2.172; 2.301
  • Tacitus, Annals 3.33–34
  • Plutarch, Caesar 63; Suetonius, Julius 81; Augustus 91
  • Artemidorus, Oneirocritica
  • Acts of Pilate (Gospel of Nicodemus) 2.1
  • W. D. Davies & D. C. Allison, Matthew (ICC), vol. 3
  • R. E. Brown, The Death of the Messiah, vol. 1
  • C. S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Matt 27:19
  • NA28 critical apparatus at Matt 27:24
  • BDAG s.v. πείθω, ὄχλος, αἰτέω, ἀπόλλυμι, ἵνα, πρεσβύτερος, ἀρχιερεύς
  • Thayer s.v. πείθω, αἰτέω
  • Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Matt 27:16–17
  • Nestle-Aland 28th ed., apparatus at Matt 27:16–17
  • R. E. Brown, The Death of the Messiah, vol. 1 (on the Barabbas episode and the release custom)
  • W. D. Davies & D. C. Allison, Matthew (ICC), vol. 3, on 27:15–26
  • C. S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Matt 27:15–23
  • Josephus, Antiquities 18.26–35, 18.55–62, 20.197–203
  • Papyrus Florentinus 61
  • Mishnah Pesahim 8:6
  • Origen, Commentary on Matthew (Commentariorum series 121)
  • BDAG s.v. ἡγεμών, ἀπολύω, ἀποκρίνομαι, θέλω, Βαραββᾶς
  • Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. ἀπολύω
  • Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, 2nd ed., on Matt 27:16–17
  • Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Matt 27:16–17, 21
  • Raymond E. Brown, The Death of the Messiah, vol. 1 (Barabbas; the Passover release)
  • Josephus, Antiquities 18.55–62; 20.215; Jewish War 2.169–177
  • Pilate inscription from Caesarea Maritima (praefectus Iudaeae)
  • Papyrus Florentinus 61 (AD 85)
  • Jerome, Commentary on Matthew 27:16
  • Latin Vulgate, Matt 27:21
  • BDAG s.v. Χριστός
  • BDAG s.v. σταυρόω
  • BDAG s.v. λέγω (passive, "be called, named")
  • Josephus, Antiquities 20.200 ("Jesus who is called Christ")
  • Josephus, Antiquities 17.295; 18.55–62; Jewish War 2.169–177
  • Philo, Embassy to Gaius 299–305
  • Psalms of Solomon 17
  • Cicero, Against Verres 2.5.165
  • Martin Hengel, Crucifixion in the Ancient World and the Folly of the Message of the Cross (1977)
  • Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Matt 27:16–17
  • Nestle-Aland, Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed.
  • Raymond E. Brown, The Death of the Messiah, vol. 1
  • Craig S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Matt 27:15–26
  • NA28 / UBS5 Greek New Testament
  • BDAG s.v. γάρ, κακός, κράζω, περισσῶς, σταυρόω
  • Mark 15:14; Luke 23:22; John 18:30, 38; 19:6, 15 (Synoptic and Johannine parallels)
  • Matthew 21:9; 27:4, 19, 20, 24 (Matthean context)
  • Deuteronomy 21:6–9 (hand-washing rite)
  • Josephus, Antiquities 18.55–62; Jewish War 2.169–177, 306–308
  • Philo, Legatio ad Gaium 299–305
  • Martin Hengel, Crucifixion in the Ancient World and the Folly of the Message of the Cross
  • Raymond E. Brown, The Death of the Messiah
  • Vulgate, Matthew 27:23
  • BDAG (Bauer–Danker–Arndt–Gingrich, Greek-English Lexicon of the NT), s.v. ἀθῷος, ἀπονίπτω, θόρυβος, ὁράω
  • Blass–Debrunner–Funk, A Greek Grammar of the NT, §362 (future used as command)
  • Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Matt 27:24
  • Nestle–Aland 28th ed. apparatus, Matt 27:24
  • Septuagint: Deut 21:6–9; 2 Sam (2 Kgdms) 3:28; Ps 25:6 (MT 26:6); Ps 72:13 (MT 73:13); Daniel (Greek) 13:46 (Theodotion)
  • Letter of Aristeas 305–306
  • Josephus, Antiquities 18.55–62, 18.85–89; Jewish War 2.169–177
  • Virgil, Aeneid 2.717–720
  • Gospel of Peter 1.1; Tertullian, Apology 21.24
  • Davies & Allison, Matthew (ICC), vol. 3
  • U. Luz, Matthew 21–28 (Hermeneia)
  • C. S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Matt 27:24

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).