Romans Chapter 11 Read as one passage

Romans 11:1–6

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

1I ask then, did God reject His people? Certainly not! I am an Israelite myself, a descendant of Abraham, from the tribe of Benjamin. 2God did not reject His people, whom He foreknew. Do you not know what the Scripture says about Elijah, how he appealed to God against Israel: 3“Lord, they have killed Your prophets and torn down Your altars. I am the only one left, and they are seeking my life as well”? 4And what was the divine reply to him? “I have reserved for Myself seven thousand men who have not bowed the knee to Baal.” 5In the same way, at the present time there is a remnant chosen by grace. 6And if it is by grace, then it is no longer by works. Otherwise, grace would no longer be grace.

What the first hearers heard

To Jewish believers in Rome, the verse was reassurance that the gospel did not mean God had broken his oath to Abraham’s descendants. Paul answers in the language of their own Psalms, and the apostle to the gentiles names himself an Israelite, now, by tribe.

To gentile believers, it was a warning in advance. Israel’s widespread unbelief did not mean God had moved on and handed the promises to them. The same God who “will not thrust away his people” is the God they now trust. If he could discard Israel, his promises to them would be worthless too (the logic of 3:3–4 and 11:29: “the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable”).

For everyone, the verse opens Paul’s three-part answer in chapter 11:

  1. God has kept a remnant now, with Paul himself as an example (11:1–10).
  2. Israel’s stumbling is not permanent and serves to bring in the gentiles (11:11–24).
  3. In the end “all Israel will be saved” (11:25–32).

From the study of Romans 11:1.

Verse by verse

  1. 1I ask then, did God reject His people? Certainly not! I am an Israelite myself, a descendant of Abraham, from the tribe of Benjamin.

    “So, given everything I have just said about Israel refusing the message, and God holding out his hands all day to a disobedient people, should I ask whether God has thrust his own people away from himself? He hasn’t, has he? Perish the thought! I am living proof against it. I myself am an Israelite, a true member of the covenant people, a descendant of Abraham to whom the promises were made, from the tribe of Benjamin, the tribe of King Saul and neighbour of Jerusalem.”

    Paul asks the question in the words of Israel’s own scriptures. Samuel and the Psalmist had promised, “The LORD will not thrust away his people” (1 Samuel 12:22; Psalm 94:14). The only open question is whether that promise has now failed. The grammar already expects the answer no, and Paul confirms it with the strongest denial he has. Then he points to himself. The “for” matters: an apostle who preaches to gentiles is still, in the present tense, an Israelite by birth and tribe, and that alone shows that God has not written Israel off.

    Full study →
  2. 2God did not reject His people, whom He foreknew. Do you not know what the Scripture says about Elijah, how he appealed to God against Israel:

    God did not thrust away his own people, the people he set his love on and chose before anything else happened. Paul is quoting a promise his hearers knew from the Psalms and from Samuel ("the Lord will not cast off his people"). He puts it in the past tense, as something already shown true: God did not do it. He adds a reason. These people are his, and his choosing them came first, so disowning them would mean God going back on his own decision.

    "Or do you not know what the passage about Elijah says?" This is a pointed debating question, and it expects the answer "of course we do." Scripture says, in the present tense, because it still speaks. In that passage Elijah goes before God like a man bringing a petition to a king, but his petition is a complaint against Israel. He is not praying for them. He is accusing them: they killed the prophets, they tore down the altars, and he alone is left (v. 3). The prophet has given up on Israel and lays charges against it. As vv. 4–5 go on to show, God answers by pointing to a faithful remnant Elijah knew nothing about. The case against Israel, even from the greatest of the prophets, does not end in God casting his people off.

    Full study →
  3. 3“Lord, they have killed Your prophets and torn down Your altars. I am the only one left, and they are seeking my life as well”?

    "Lord", Elijah says, speaking to the God of Israel himself, "they have murdered your prophets and torn your altars down to their foundations. I, I alone, am all that is left behind, the one survivor, and even now they are hunting me down to kill me."

    Each charge is framed as an offence against God's own property: your prophets, your altars. The killing and the demolition are finished deeds. The hunt for Elijah is still going on. The verse is a complaint brought before God as judge. Paul introduces it as Elijah "appealing to God against Israel" (v. 2).

    The Greek has a link English cannot show. Elijah's "I was left" uses the same root that God picks up in reply: "I have left for myself seven thousand" (v. 4). Paul then draws the conclusion with the same root: "a remnant (leimma), a 'left-over', chosen by grace" (v. 5). Elijah's lament about being the last one left becomes, in God's answer, proof that God has kept a faithful group for himself.

    Full study →
  4. 4And what was the divine reply to him? “I have reserved for Myself seven thousand men who have not bowed the knee to Baal.”

    "But what does God's own answer — His formal reply from heaven, which still speaks — say to him? 'I have left remaining, kept back for Myself, seven thousand men: people of the kind who did not bend the knee in worship to Baal, that Shame.'"

    Elijah had just complained that he alone was left (v. 3). God's reply uses the same word back at him: I have left seven thousand. The prophet thought the faithful in Israel had shrunk to one man. God says there were thousands, and they were there because God had kept them for Himself. Their mark was public and physical: they refused to kneel to the god the royal court supported. Paul adds "for Myself", which is not in the Hebrew or Greek Old Testament wording. With it he makes the survivors God's own act, which prepares for his next sentence: "so too, at the present time, there is a remnant [what is left], chosen by grace." The feminine "the" before Baal is probably a scribal habit of reading "the Shame" in place of the god's name, a small sign of contempt in the grammar.

    Full study →
  5. 5In the same way, at the present time there is a remnant chosen by grace.

    "And so, in just the same way, here and now, in this decisive present age, a remnant has come into being and stands: a remnant that exists because God chose it, and chose it out of pure, unearned favour."

    Paul has just retold the story of Elijah. The prophet believed he was the last faithful man in Israel, and God answered, "I have kept for myself seven thousand who have not bowed the knee to Baal." Paul now applies that pattern to his own day. Most of his fellow Jews have not accepted Jesus as Messiah. But that does not mean God has thrown Israel away (11:1). As in Elijah's time, God has a remnant, and Paul himself is part of it.

    Three things fill out the picture:

    • Remnant is not a word for scraps. In the prophets, the remnant is the surviving core of Israel through which God keeps his promises to the whole nation. It is a sign that the people has a future. Later in the chapter Paul calls it the "firstfruits" that make the whole batch holy (11:16).
    • According to choosing places the cause in God, echoing "I have kept for myself". The remnant did not pick itself out by being more loyal than the rest.
    • Of grace names what kind of choosing this is: favour given freely, not as wages. Verse 6 immediately draws the consequence: if it is by grace, it is no longer from works, or grace would not be grace.

    The verb is in a tense that means "has come to be and remains". The remnant is not a hope or a theory. It is a present reality, brought about by God, that Paul can point to in actual people.

    Full study →
  6. 6And if it is by grace, then it is no longer by works. Otherwise, grace would no longer be grace.

    "And since it is by grace, by God's freely given favour, then it does not come out of anything they did. Otherwise grace would turn into something that isn't grace at all."

    "It" is what verse 5 has just named: the faithful remnant of Israel that exists "by a choosing of grace," like the 7,000 God kept for himself in Elijah's day. Paul says where that remnant came from. It was not a reward for their faithfulness. It was God's charis, the everyday Greek word for a benefactor's favour and the gift it produces. Then he gives a reason in the form of a definition. Gifts and wages are opposite kinds of thing. Once a deed earns the outcome, the outcome is payment owed, not a gift (Paul had already said this in 4:4). So the two cannot be mixed. "No longer" here is logic, not history. Paul does not mean it used to be by works and now is by grace. He means that if it is one, it cannot be the other. The verse ends on the same word it turns on, grace… grace, insisting that grace stay what it is: favour that does not take its cue from what the recipient has done.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v1

    God forbid (KJV)

    mē genoito

    What we hear
    An appeal to God or an oath, as if Paul were calling on God to stop something.
    What they heard
    A fixed expression of horrified denial, “May it not be! Perish the thought!” No divine name appears.
  • in v1

    his people

    ton laon autou

    What we hear
    In church language “God’s people” usually means Christians or believers in general, so readers may take the verse to be about the church.
    What they heard
    Israel as God’s covenant nation, the same disobedient people of 10:21. Paul proves his point with his own ethnic descent, which only works if Israel by descent is meant.
  • in v2

    maketh intercession to God against Israel (KJV)

    entynchanei … kata

    What we hear
    Elijah prayed on Israel's behalf, as in "intercessory prayer".
    What they heard
    Elijah brought a formal complaint or accusation against Israel before God, like petitioning a king against someone.
  • in v2

    foreknew

    proegnō

    What we hear
    God knew in advance facts about Israel, such as how they would behave.
    What they heard
    God set his regard on Israel and chose them beforehand. "Knowing" in the biblical sense includes relationship and commitment (compare Amos 3:2).
  • in v4

    to [the image of] Baal (KJV)

    tē Baal

    What we hear
    A reader of the KJV takes the verse as being specifically about kneeling to a statue or idol image of Baal.
    What they heard
    The Greek says only "to the Baal", using a feminine article. That article most likely reflects the habit of saying "the Shame" in place of the god's name, not a hidden word "image". The refusal was to worship Baal himself in any form.
  • in v5

    remnant

    leimma

    What we hear
    Leftovers or scraps: a small, unimportant remainder, or a beleaguered group holding out at the end.
    What they heard
    The prophets' 'remnant': the surviving core of Israel that carries God's promises forward and points toward the restoration of the whole people.
  • in v5

    election

    eklogē

    What we hear
    Either a vote, where people choose, or a fully formed doctrine of individual predestination to eternal destiny.
    What they heard
    God's act of choosing or selecting. Here it is the choosing that brings the believing remnant of Israel into being, as part of God's ongoing commitment to Israel.
  • in v6

    no longer

    ouketi

    What we hear
    A change over time: once it was by works, now it is by grace. Some read this as two eras, with an old covenant of works replaced by a new one of grace.
    What they heard
    A logical conclusion: if it is by grace, then it is not by works. The two are mutually exclusive as a basis, in any era. Paul's example of the remnant is drawn from Elijah's time.
  • in v6

    grace

    charis

    What we hear
    A religious abstraction: a spiritual force or atmosphere, or just leniency. In general English, also elegance or a mealtime prayer.
    What they heard
    A benefactor's favour and the gift that comes from it. It was a common word from the world of patronage and benefaction that named an act and created a relationship. Here it is the kind of favour that does not depend on the recipient's prior deeds.
Every word
  1. Λέγω

    Legō · G3004

    I say · v1, v2, v4

    “I say,” in the sense “I ask.” Paul uses it to bring up the obvious next question, as if someone listening had just asked it. It works like a teacher saying, “So, you might ask…”

  2. οὖν

    oun · G3767

    then, therefore · v1, v5

    Links the question to what came just before: Isaiah 65:2, quoted in 10:21, where God has held out his hands all day to a “disobedient and obstinate people.” The question is whether that leads somewhere.

  3. μὴ

    mē · G3361

    not · v1

    Opening a question with mē tells the listener to expect the answer “no.” The question is really “God didn’t reject his people, did he?” The grammar already leans toward Paul’s answer.

  4. ἀπώσατο

    apōsato · G683

    push away, reject · v1, v2

    “Thrust away from himself.” The past tense asks whether God has, in one decisive act, shoved Israel away. The wording borrows the Greek of Psalm 94:14 and 1 Samuel 12:22 (“The LORD will not thrust away his people”).

  5. ὁ

    ho · G3588

    the · v1, v2, v3, v4, v5, v6

    Greek puts the article before “God.” English leaves it out.

  6. θεὸς

    theos · G2316

    God · v1, v2

    The God of Israel, the one who made the promises to Abraham. Whether he has rejected his people is a question about whether he keeps his word (see 3:3–4; 9:6).

  7. λαὸν

    laon · G2992

    people · v1, v2

    In the Greek Old Testament this is the standard word for Israel as God’s own covenant people, set against “the nations” (ethnē). Here it means Israel as a people, not believers in general.

  8. αὐτοῦ

    autou · G846

    his · v1, v2, v4

    “His” people. They still belong to God even after the disobedience described in 10:21. The pronoun already hints at the answer.

  9. γένοιτο

    genoito · G1096

    may it be / happen · v1, v5, v6

    A wish form, “may it come to be.” Together with mē it makes Paul’s strongest no: “Perish the thought! Never!” The word “God” does not appear.

  10. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and, also, too · v1, v3, v5

    With gar it means “for I too” or “for I myself.” It puts Paul among the people the question is about.

  11. γὰρ

    gar · G1063

    for · v1

    “For.” It gives the reason for the strong denial. Some English versions drop it, which hides the logic.

  12. ἐγὼ

    egō · G1473

    I · v1, v4

    The pronoun is written out, which Greek does only for emphasis: “I myself.” Paul offers his own person.

  13. Ἰσραηλίτης

    Israēlitēs · G2475

    Israelite · v1

    An honoured covenant name, richer than the outsider’s word “Jew.” In 9:4 Paul lists what belongs to “the Israelites”: adoption, glory, covenants, law, worship, promises.

  14. εἰμί

    eimi · G1510

    I am · v1

    Present tense: Paul is an Israelite now, after his calling as apostle to the gentiles. He has not stopped being one.

  15. ἐκ

    ek · G1537

    out of, from · v1, v6

    Marks where he comes from: physical descent.

  16. σπέρματος

    spermatos · G4690

    seed, offspring · v1

    “Seed,” meaning descendants. It recalls the promises to Abraham’s “seed” that Paul discussed in 4:13–18 and 9:7–8.

  17. Ἀβραάμ

    Abraam · G11

    Abraham · v1

    The father of the people and the one who received the promise. Descent from him is the root of Israel’s identity (see the root image in 11:16–18).

  18. φυλῆς

    phylēs · G5443

    tribe · v1

    One of the twelve tribal lines of Israel. Naming your tribe in the first century was a claim to a known, traceable pedigree.

  19. Βενιαμίν

    Beniamin · G958

    Benjamin · v1

    The tribe of King Saul, Paul’s namesake. Benjamin stayed loyal with Judah, and Jerusalem sat on its border. It was a proud and respected lineage (compare Philippians 3:5).

  20. οὐκ

    ouk · G3756

    not · v2, v4

    A flat negative standing first for emphasis. It answers the question of v. 1 ("God did not reject his people, did he?") with a firm statement: he did not.

  21. ὃν

    hon · G3739

    whom · v2

    Relative pronoun referring back to "his people".

  22. προέγνω

    proegnō · G4267

    to know beforehand, choose beforehand · v2

    "Whom he knew beforehand." In Paul this means God's prior relationship with and choice of someone, not just advance information about them (compare Rom 8:29). Because God committed himself to Israel ahead of time, rejecting them would contradict his own choice.

  23. Ἢ

    ē · G2228

    or · v2

    "Or…?" introduces a pointed question in the style of a classroom debate: if you doubt what I just said, surely you know this passage?

  24. οἴδατε

    oidate · G6063

    to know · v2

    "Do you know." The verb has a perfect (completed) form but present meaning. It appeals to the hearers' familiarity with Israel's scriptures.

  25. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in · v2, v5

    "In". Used here as a way of citing a section of scripture: "in the Elijah passage".

  26. Ἠλίᾳ

    Ēlia · G2243

    Elijah · v2

    Elijah the prophet. "In Elijah" is a Jewish way of naming the part of scripture that tells his story (1 Kings 17–19), much as Mark 12:26 says "at the bush" for the burning-bush passage.

  27. τί

    ti · G5101

    what · v2, v4

    "What": the content of the passage Paul is about to quote.

  28. γραφή

    graphē · G1124

    writing, scripture · v2

    Singular "the writing" refers to a specific passage, here 1 Kings 19:10, 14. The body of writing Paul means is Israel's sacred books (the Law, the Prophets and the other writings), which his Roman readers mostly knew in Greek.

  29. ὡς

    hōs · G5613

    how, that · v2

    "How". It introduces what the passage tells: what Elijah did.

  30. ἐντυγχάνει

    entynchanei · G1793

    to approach, petition, appeal · v2

    "He appeals", "he brings a case". The word means approaching a ruler with a petition. With "against" it means filing a complaint. Elijah is not praying for Israel. He is bringing charges against Israel before God.

  31. κατὰ

    kata · G2596

    against · v2, v5

    With a genitive noun κατά means "against". This is the word that turns Elijah's appeal into an accusation.

  32. Ἰσραήλ

    Israēl · G2474

    Israel · v2

    The nation, specifically the northern kingdom under Ahab and Jezebel. Elijah accused them of killing the prophets and tearing down God's altars.

  33. κύριε,

    kyrie · G2962

    Lord, master · v3

    A direct address to God. In the Greek Old Testament kyrios stands in for God's personal name (YHWH), so here it means Israel's God, not Jesus. Paul adds the address himself: the line in 1 Kings has no opening 'Lord'. The addition makes Elijah's words a formal appeal spoken to God's face.

  34. προφήτας

    prophētas · G4396

    prophet, spokesman · v3

    People who spoke for God. In Elijah's day this included whole bands of prophets ('sons of the prophets'). Obadiah hid a hundred of them in caves to save them from the purge.

  35. σου

    sou · G4771

    your · v3

    'Your prophets'. They belong to God, so killing them is an attack on God himself. Elijah is building a case.

  36. ἀπέκτειναν,

    apekteinan · G615

    to kill · v3

    A plain past tense for a finished deed: they killed them. Paul leaves out 'with the sword' from the Old Testament line. He also moves this charge to the front, so the killing of prophets comes first.

  37. θυσιαστήριά

    thysiastēria · G2379

    altar (for sacrifice) · v3

    The Greek Old Testament's usual word for a proper altar to Israel's God, as opposed to a pagan altar. The plural matters: in the northern kingdom there were several local altars to YHWH, like the one on Carmel that Elijah rebuilt (1 Kings 18:30).

  38. κατέσκαψαν,

    kateskapsan · G2679

    to dig down, raze · v3

    Literally 'to dig down', meaning to tear something down to its foundations. Greek writers used it for flattening cities and walls. The KJV's 'digged down' keeps the picture: total demolition, not mere damage.

  39. κἀγὼ

    kagō · G2504

    and I · v3

    'And' and 'I' run together, with the 'I' stressed: 'and I, I myself'. Elijah puts himself forward as the last one standing against the whole nation.

  40. ὑπελείφθην

    hypeleiphthēn · G5275

    to leave behind; passive: be left over · v3

    'I was left behind': a survivor left after the slaughter. This 'leave' root (leip-) runs through the passage. God answers, 'I have left (kate-lip-on) for myself seven thousand' (v. 4), and Paul concludes that there is a 'remnant' (leimma, same root) now (v. 5).

  41. μόνος,

    monos · G3441

    alone, only · v3

    'Alone, the only one'. The Greek Old Testament has the stronger monōtatos, 'utterly alone'. Paul's plainer word sits closer to the Hebrew levaddi, 'by myself'. This is exactly the claim God's reply corrects.

  42. ζητοῦσιν

    zētousin · G2212

    to seek · v3

    Present tense: 'they are seeking'. The killings and the demolition are finished, but the hunt for Elijah is still going on as he speaks.

  43. ψυχήν

    psychēn · G5590

    life, self, soul · v3

    Here it means physical life. 'To seek someone's psychē' is a Hebrew idiom (biqqesh nephesh) for trying to kill them. It says nothing about an immaterial soul.

  44. μου.

    mou · G3450

    my · v3

    'My life'. Elijah ends on himself: the last prophet, and a hunted man.

  45. ἀλλὰ

    alla · G0235

    but · v4

    Turns sharply from Elijah's complaint in verse 3 ("I alone am left") to God's answer, which contradicts it.

  46. χρηματισμός

    chrēmatismos · G5538

    divine response, oracle · v4

    An official pronouncement from God, the kind of answer given from heaven. This is the only place the noun appears in the New Testament. It casts God's words to Elijah as a formal ruling that settles the matter.

  47. κατέλιπον

    katelipon · G2641

    I left behind, left remaining · v4

    Past tense: "I left (remaining)". It picks up Elijah's own word from verse 3, where he says he was "left" (hypeleiphthēn). Paul's next verse builds on the same root with leimma, "remnant" or "what is left". Elijah thinks he is the only one left. God says He has left seven thousand.

  48. ἑπτακισχιλίους

    heptakischilious · G2035

    seven thousand · v4

    A large, full-sounding number. Seven carried a sense of completeness. Set against Elijah's "I alone", it says the faithful are far more than the prophet could see.

  49. ἄνδρας

    andras · G0435

    men, males · v4

    Follows the Greek Old Testament's "seven thousand of men". This is the usual way of counting a population by its adult men. The Hebrew of 1 Kings 19:18 just says "seven thousand".

  50. οἵτινες

    hoitines · G3748

    who, the kind who · v4

    A pronoun that describes what kind of people they are: "people of the sort who did not bow". It defines the seven thousand by their refusal.

  51. ἔκαμψαν

    ekampsan · G2578

    bent, bowed · v4

    Past tense: "they did not bend". Bending the knee was the body's way of worshipping or swearing loyalty to a god or king.

  52. γόνυ

    gony · G1119

    knee · v4

    Singular, as in the set phrase "bend the knee". Taken with the verb, it means kneeling in worship.

  53. Βάαλ

    Baal · G0896

    Baal · v4

    The Canaanite storm and fertility god whose worship Ahab and Jezebel backed in the northern kingdom. Here he stands for the rival god Israel was pressured to worship.

  54. οὕτως

    houtōs · G3779

    thus, in this way · v5

    Points back to the Elijah story just quoted (vv. 2–4): the present situation follows the same pattern as Elijah's day.

  55. νῦν

    nyn · G3568

    now · v5

    Sits between the article and the noun and works like an adjective: 'the now-time'. Paul uses the same phrase in Romans 3:26 and 8:18 for the period opened up by the Messiah.

  56. καιρῷ

    kairō · G2540

    time, season, appointed time · v5

    A period with a particular character, not just a stretch of clock time. 'The present time' is the age in which God is acting through Jesus the Messiah, and Paul contrasts it with Elijah's age.

  57. λεῖμμα

    leimma · G3005

    remnant, what is left · v5

    This word appears only here in the New Testament. It carries the prophets' idea of the remnant: the part of Israel that survives judgment and carries the people's future. Here it means the Jews, Paul among them (11:1), who have trusted Jesus as Messiah.

  58. ἐκλογὴν

    eklogēn · G1589

    choice, selection, election · v5

    An act of choosing. It echoes 'God's purpose according to election' in 9:11 and points ahead to 'the election obtained it' in 11:7 and 'as regards election they are beloved' in 11:28. The chooser is God, matching 'I have kept for myself' in v. 4.

  59. χάριτος

    charitos · G5485

    grace, favour, gift · v5, v6

    Describes what kind of choosing this is: a choosing that comes from favour freely given. Verse 6 immediately explains that this rules out 'works' as its basis.

  60. εἰ

    ei · G1487

    if · v6

    Opens a condition Paul treats as true. Verse 5 has just said the remnant exists "by a choosing of grace," so the sense is close to "since, as we've established, it is by grace…"

  61. δὲ

    de · G1161

    and, now, but · v6

    A light connecting word that carries the argument on from verse 5. Here it means "and" or "now," with no contrast.

  62. οὐκέτι

    ouketi · G3765

    no longer, not any more · v6

    Here it is a word of logic, not of time: "then it is not." Once grace is the basis, works are ruled out as the basis. It does not mean things used to be by works.

  63. ἔργων

    ergōn · G2041

    works, deeds · v6

    Human deeds or performance considered as a basis for God's choice. In Romans the word is closely tied to "works of the law" (3:20, 28; 9:32), but in 9:11–12 it also covers "anything good or bad."

  64. ἐπεὶ

    epei · G1893

    since, because; otherwise · v6

    A shortened argument: "since [if it were otherwise]…" This is why translations render it "otherwise." It brings in the reason the two cannot be mixed.

The world behind it

Where the question comes from. Romans 9–11 deals with a painful puzzle for the earliest Jesus movement. If Jesus is Israel’s Messiah, why have most of Israel not accepted him, while gentiles are flooding in? Chapter 10 ended with Isaiah 65:2: God has held out his hands all day “to a disobedient and obstinate people.” The obvious conclusion seemed to be that God had given up on Israel.

Paul’s teaching style. “I say then… May it not be!” is the question-and-answer style of ancient moral teachers, known as the diatribe. The speaker raises the objection a listener might make and then knocks it down. Paul does this again at 11:11 (“Did they stumble so as to fall? May it not be!”).

The Roman audience. Romans was written around AD 56–57 to house churches in Rome that included both Jews and gentiles. The emperor Claudius had expelled Jews from Rome around AD 49, and many returned after his death in 54. A gentile-majority church could easily decide that Israel was finished and that they had taken its place. Later in this chapter Paul warns gentile believers directly against boasting over the “natural branches” (11:17–24). Verse 1 starts that correction.

Pedigree. In a culture of honour and family lines, your ancestry was your identity. Few Jews of Paul’s day could still trace their tribe. Being able to name Benjamin, the tribe of Israel’s first king and the one that stayed loyal to Judah and Jerusalem, put Paul at the heart of Israel.

From the study of Romans 11:1.

Where scholars differ

in v1

What does “for I too am an Israelite” prove?

  • Paul is evidence. As a Jew who believes in Jesus, he shows that God has not rejected Israel as a whole. He is part of the remnant he describes in verses 2–5.

    Verses 2–5 go straight on to Elijah and the 7,000 God kept, ending “so too at the present time there is a remnant chosen by grace” (11:5). Paul is one of that remnant. The emphatic “I myself” suits an appeal to himself as a test case.

  • Paul is explaining his horror. As an Israelite himself he could never accept the idea, because it would mean God had disowned Paul’s own people and family.

    One person could hardly prove anything about a whole nation, and Paul’s full answer only comes in 11:25–32. His grief over his “kinsmen according to the flesh” in 9:1–3 and 10:1 shows how personally he is invested. Some major commentators lean this way or combine the two views.

  • Both at once: Paul is both evidence of the remnant and personally invested in Israel’s future.

    The “for” can carry both ideas. Many commentators take the verse as part of a larger answer (remnant now, full restoration later), so the two readings fit together.

in v1

Is “his people” Israel as a whole, or only the believing remnant?

  • Israel as a whole. God has not rejected the nation. The remnant now is a pledge of the restoration of “all Israel” later (11:26).

    The “people” of 10:21 is the disobedient nation as a whole. In 11:28–29 Paul says that even those who are “enemies” for now are “beloved for the sake of the fathers,” because God’s calling is irrevocable.

  • The emphasis falls on the elect within Israel. God never rejected those he “foreknew” (11:2), and the remnant is the true “people.”

    Verse 2 adds “whom he foreknew,” and 9:6 says “not all who are descended from Israel are Israel.” Most interpreters still see 11:11–32 as widening the hope beyond the present remnant.

in v2

Does "his people whom he foreknew" mean Israel as a whole or only the chosen ones within Israel?

  • It describes the nation as a whole: God's people, whom (as a people) he chose beforehand. Most modern commentators hold this view (e.g. Cranfield, Dunn, Moo).

    The clause repeats "his people" from v. 1, where it plainly means ethnic Israel. It echoes promises made to the whole nation (Ps 94:14; 1 Sam 12:22). Romans 11:28–29 says Israel is "beloved for the sake of the fathers" and that God's gifts and calling are irrevocable.

  • It singles out a group: only the chosen within Israel, the remnant, are the "people he foreknew". This view is found in parts of the Augustinian and Reformed tradition, including Calvin.

    Romans 8:29 uses "foreknew" for those who are actually saved. Romans 9:6 says "not all who are from Israel are Israel", and 11:5 goes straight on to speak of the remnant chosen by grace.

in v2

What kind of foreknowledge is meant?

  • God's prior choosing: he set his love on Israel beforehand.

    The Hebrew sense of knowing as choosing (Amos 3:2; Jer 1:5; Hos 13:5); BDAG's "choose beforehand"; the parallel with "called" and "predestined" in Rom 8:29–30.

  • God's knowing in advance, especially knowing how people would respond, on which his choice is based.

    The ordinary Greek meaning of the verb (Acts 26:5; 2 Pet 3:17), and early Greek interpreters who read it as prescience. Critics answer that in 11:2 this would make little sense: God foreknowing Israel's unbelief would hardly prove he had not rejected them.

in v3

Is Paul casting himself as a new Elijah?

  • Yes: Paul identifies with Elijah.

    Both are known for 'zeal' (Elijah, 1 Kings 19:10; Paul, Gal 1:14; Phil 3:6). After his conversion Paul went to 'Arabia' (Gal 1:17), which some link to Elijah's journey to Horeb/Sinai (N. T. Wright, 'Paul, Arabia, and Elijah', JBL 1996). And in 11:1 Paul has just offered himself as evidence of a faithful remnant.

  • Partly, but mainly by contrast.

    Paul frames Elijah's words as pleading 'against Israel' (v. 2) and leaves out Elijah's claim of zeal, while he himself prays for Israel (10:1) and would accept being cursed for their sake (9:3). On this view Elijah is a cautionary example of judging Israel's state too quickly, not a model.

  • The point is the precedent, not Paul's self-image.

    The argument in vv. 4–5 needs only the pattern 'apparent near-total apostasy, yet a remnant kept by God'. Commentators like Moo and Fitzmyer put the weight there.

in v3

Why does Paul put 'killed your prophets' before 'razed your altars'?

  • Deliberate emphasis on persecuting God's messengers.

    Killing the prophets was a stock charge in Jewish and early Christian writing (Neh 9:26; Luke 11:47–51; 1 Thess 2:15). Putting it first brings out the theme of Israel resisting God's messengers.

  • Simple loose quotation or style.

    Paul often quotes freely and shortens. The swap may just give a rising order (people, then places, then 'me'), with no special theological weight.

in v4

Why does Paul put a feminine article before the male god Baal?

  • It stands for reading "the Shame" (aischynē, feminine) in place of the god's name.

    Hebrew scribes sometimes replaced Baal with boshet, "shame" (Ishbosheth/Eshbaal; Jeremiah 3:24; 11:13). Greek Old Testament books where the feminine appears are those where this practice fits. This is the majority view (Dillmann, BDF §53(4), most modern commentaries).

  • A feminine noun such as eikōn ("image") or stēlē ("pillar") is implied.

    This explanation lies behind the KJV's "[the image of] Baal". It has few defenders today, because the feminine appears even where no image is in view.

  • Some Greek-speaking readers thought of Baal as a goddess, or as both male and female.

    Proposed occasionally because the feminine appears consistently in some books. The Hebrew Bible presents Baal as male, and the "shame" explanation accounts for the evidence better.

in v4

Is "seven thousand" a literal count?

  • It is a round or symbolic number meaning a full, complete company.

    Seven carries associations of completeness throughout the Bible. Round thousands are common in ancient reports. The point is the contrast with Elijah's "I alone".

  • It may be meant as an actual tally God knew.

    The narrative gives no sign that the number is figurative. Either way, Paul's argument depends only on the number being large and known to God, not on precision.

in v4

Where does Paul's wording of the quotation come from?

  • Paul adapted the text himself to fit his argument.

    "For myself" and the past tense fit verse 5's "chosen by grace" closely. Paul adapts quotations elsewhere too.

  • Paul was using a Greek text that had already been revised toward the Hebrew.

    Paul's first-person "I" agrees with the Hebrew against the standard Greek. Revised Greek texts (e.g. the Lucianic/Antiochene tradition) sometimes differ from the standard Greek in this kind of way.

in v5

Is the 'election' here God's choosing of particular individuals for salvation, or a corporate choosing that serves God's purpose for Israel as a whole?

  • Individual, unconditional election: God chose specific persons within Israel for salvation, and the remnant consists of those persons.

    The direct echo of Romans 9:6–13 (Jacob chosen over Esau 'before they had done anything good or bad'); 11:7 'the elect obtained it, but the rest were hardened'; the stress that grace excludes works (11:6). Held in the Augustinian and Reformed tradition (e.g. Cranfield, Moo, Schreiner, with varying nuance).

  • Corporate or vocational election: the remnant is the chosen group through which God carries his purposes for Israel and the nations forward, and this chapter is about God's faithfulness to Israel, not a list of individual eternal destinies.

    The remnant's function as 'firstfruits' sanctifying the whole (11:16); the use of 'election' for unbelieving Israel too (11:28, 'beloved for the sake of the fathers'); the expected future inclusion of 'all Israel' (11:26) and the possibility of the 'hardened' being grafted back in (11:23); ἐκλογή as vocation in Acts 9:15. Associated with scholars such as Dunn, Wright and others who emphasise Israel's story.

in v5

Is the remnant the whole of 'true Israel', or a pledge of a wider future restoration of Israel?

  • The remnant is the true Israel: the believing core is what God's promise always meant.

    Romans 9:6 'not all who are descended from Israel are Israel'; 9:27 'only the remnant will be saved'.

  • The remnant is a present sign pointing to a larger future salvation of ethnic Israel.

    11:11–12 ('how much more their fullness'), 11:15 ('what will their acceptance be but life from the dead'), 11:24–29 ('all Israel will be saved… the gifts and calling of God are irrevocable'). Many commentators (e.g. Cranfield, Dunn, Moo, Fitzmyer, Jewett) read 11:26 as referring to a future turning of Israel as a people, though they differ on how and when.

in v6

What does "works" mean here: Torah observance specifically, or human deeds and merit in general?

  • Human performance of any kind as a claim on God (traditional Reformation reading; e.g. Moo, Schreiner).

    In 9:11–12 "not from works" applies to Jacob and Esau before they "had done anything good or bad," with no Torah in view. Rom 4:4–5 sets working for wages against gift in general terms.

  • Chiefly "works of the law," Torah practices that marked Jewish identity, such as circumcision, food laws and Sabbath (the "New Perspective"; e.g. Dunn, Wright).

    Romans' wider argument concerns Jew and gentile together. 9:30–32 links "works" directly to pursuing the law. 4QMMT shows "works of the law" as a term for distinctive Torah practice.

  • Grace disregards every kind of prior worth, whether ethnic, moral or Torah-based (Barclay, *Paul and the Gift*).

    Ancient gift-giving normally looked for worthy recipients. Paul's distinctive emphasis is that God's gift is "incongruous," given without regard to fitness. That covers both Torah status and moral record.

in v6

Is the longer ending ("But if of works… work is no longer work") original?

  • No. It is a later addition (majority of textual critics; Metzger).

    It is missing from early witnesses across different regions, it circulates in variant forms (Vaticanus differs), and a scribe would have had an obvious reason to add a matching clause.

  • Yes. It is original and was lost by a copying slip (some defenders of the Byzantine or Received text).

    The repeated "οὐκέτι… χάρις" endings could have caused a scribe's eye to skip from one to the other. The clause is in the majority of later manuscripts.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. ἀπωθέω
  • BDAG s.v. γίνομαι (μὴ γένοιτο)
  • BDAG s.v. λαός
  • BDAG s.v. Ἰσραηλίτης
  • Septuagint: 1 Kingdoms (1 Samuel) 12:22; Psalm 93:14 LXX; Jeremiah 38:37 LXX
  • B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (Rom 11:1)
  • C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC), on 11:1
  • D. J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT), on 11:1
  • J. D. G. Dunn, Romans 9–16 (WBC), on 11:1
  • S. K. Stowers, The Diatribe and Paul's Letter to the Romans
  • Vulgate, Romans 11:1
  • BDAG s.v. ἀπωθέω, προγινώσκω, ἐντυγχάνω, γραφή
  • Septuagint: Ps 93:14; 1 Kgdms 12:22; 3 Kgdms 19:10, 14, 18; 1 Macc 8:32; 10:61–64
  • C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC), on 11:2
  • J. D. G. Dunn, Romans 9–16 (WBC 38B)
  • D. J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT)
  • R. Jewett, Romans (Hermeneia)
  • NA28 apparatus on Rom 11:2
  • Septuagint (LXX), 3 Kingdoms (1 Kings) 19:10, 14
  • Hebrew Bible (MT), 1 Kings 19:10, 14
  • BDAG s.v. ὑπολείπω, κατασκάπτω, θυσιαστήριον, ψυχή
  • LSJ s.v. κατασκάπτω
  • Christopher D. Stanley, Paul and the Language of Scripture (1992)
  • N. T. Wright, 'Paul, Arabia, and Elijah (Galatians 1:17)', JBL 115 (1996)
  • James D. G. Dunn, Romans 9–16 (WBC)
  • Douglas J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT)
  • Joseph A. Fitzmyer, Romans (Anchor Bible)
  • Robert Jewett, Romans (Hermeneia)
  • BDAG s.v. χρηματισμός
  • BDAG s.v. καταλείπω
  • BDAG s.v. Βάαλ
  • Moulton & Milligan, Vocabulary of the Greek Testament, s.v. χρηματισμός
  • Blass–Debrunner–Funk, Greek Grammar §53(4)
  • Rahlfs LXX, 3 Kingdoms 19:18
  • BHS, 1 Kings 19:18
  • HALOT s.v. שׁאר
  • C. D. Stanley, Paul and the Language of Scripture (1992)
  • J. D. G. Dunn, Romans 9–16 (WBC)
  • C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC)
  • J. A. Fitzmyer, Romans (Anchor Bible)
  • Vulgate, Romans 11:4
  • BDAG s.v. λεῖμμα, ἐκλογή, χάρις, καιρός, γίνομαι
  • Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. λεῖμμα, ἐκλογή
  • LXX 4 Kingdoms (2 Kings) 19:4; 3 Kingdoms (1 Kings) 19:18; Isaiah 10:22
  • Damascus Document (CD) 1:4–5; War Scroll (1QM) 13:8
  • Psalms of Solomon 9:4
  • NA28 apparatus on Romans 11:6
  • John M. G. Barclay, Paul and the Gift (2015)
  • N. T. Wright, Paul and the Faithfulness of God
  • BDAG s.v. χάρις
  • BDAG s.v. ἔργον
  • BDAG s.v. οὐκέτι (logical use)
  • Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, 2nd ed., on Rom 11:6
  • Nestle-Aland 28th ed. apparatus, Rom 11:6
  • James R. Harrison, Paul's Language of Grace in Its Graeco-Roman Context (2003)
  • Seneca, De Beneficiis
  • 4QMMT (Dead Sea Scrolls)
  • 1 Kings 19:18 (MT and LXX)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).