Matthew Chapter 14 Read as one passage
Matthew 14:1–6
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
1At that time Herod the tetrarch heard the reports about Jesus 2and said to his servants, “This is John the Baptist; he has risen from the dead! That is why miraculous powers are at work in him.” 3Now Herod had arrested John and bound him and put him in prison on account of Herodias, his brother Philip’s wife, 4because John had been telling him, “It is not lawful for you to have her.” 5Although Herod wanted to kill John, he was afraid of the people, because they regarded John as a prophet. 6On Herod’s birthday, however, the daughter of Herodias danced before them and pleased Herod
What the first hearers heard
Matthew's first readers were most likely Jewish followers of Jesus in the late first century, perhaps in Syria or Galilee. For them, the verse:
- Turns the story toward political danger. In chapter 2 one Herod tried to kill the infant Messiah. Now his son, who has already killed the prophet John, notices Jesus. Readers would feel the threat at once, and Jesus' withdrawal in 14:13 confirms it.
- Places Jesus within the world of power. The title tetrarch reminds readers that Galilee was ruled by a minor ruler under Rome. Jesus' announcement of God's kingdom was spreading across the territory of a man who badly wanted to be called king.
- Contrasts two ways of hearing. Jesus' own hometown has just failed to believe in him (13:54–58). Now a ruler "hears" about him, but only through rumor, and he reads it through his own guilt. In Matthew, "hearing" is a loaded idea (13:9, 13–17, "he who has ears, let him hear"). Herod hears without understanding.
- Links Jesus' fate to John's. The verse leads into the account of John's death (14:3–12). For Matthew, John's fate foreshadows what lies ahead for Jesus (compare 17:12, "so also the Son of Man will suffer at their hands").
From the study of Matthew 14:1.
Verse by verse
-
1At that time Herod the tetrarch heard the reports about Jesus
Full study →"Around that time, Herod Antipas, the Roman-backed ruler of Galilee, heard the talk going around about Jesus."
"At that time" is Matthew's loose way of opening a new scene, set during the same stretch of Jesus' work in Galilee. It is not a precise timestamp. The "Herod" here is not the king who tried to kill the baby Jesus. He is that king's son, Antipas. His title, tetrarch (literally "ruler of a quarter"), marks him as a lesser ruler under Rome who ranked below a king but still held the power of life and death over the region where Jesus was working. What reached him was not "fame" in the modern sense of celebrity. It was akoē, "what is heard": reports, news and rumor passed from mouth to mouth. Herod had not seen Jesus. He knew only what people were saying about the mighty works. The verse sets up his guilty, fearful guess in the next line (that Jesus is John the Baptist come back from the dead) and the flashback to John's execution that follows. Just after Jesus' hometown has refused to believe in him (13:58), the most powerful man in Galilee starts listening, though for the wrong reasons.
-
2and said to his servants, “This is John the Baptist; he has risen from the dead! That is why miraculous powers are at work in him.”
Full study →Herod hears the reports about Jesus, turns to the courtiers around him, and says: "This man is John, the Baptizer himself. He has been raised, back from among the dead. That's why these powers are working in him."
Each part of the sentence matters. "This man" points at the miracle-worker in the reports. "He himself" is emphatic: not a prophet like John but the same man, the one Herod had beheaded (vv. 3–12). "Has been raised" uses the ordinary word for rising from death, and the tense presents it as a completed fact. "From among the dead" pictures John coming back out of the realm of the dead. The last clause is Herod's reasoning. The supernatural powers are the subject of the sentence, actively at work inside the man, and Herod takes them as proof that this is someone who has come back from death. (John himself never did miracles.)
The sentence comes from a guilty and frightened ruler. He takes the language of resurrection and applies it to his own victim. Matthew's readers know who Jesus really is, and they will hear the same verb, "raised", announced about Jesus at the empty tomb (28:6–7).
-
3Now Herod had arrested John and bound him and put him in prison on account of Herodias, his brother Philip’s wife,
Full study →You see, Herod Antipas had earlier taken John by force, put him in chains, and put him away under guard. He was shut out of sight and held at the ruler's pleasure, with no sentence and no end date. All of this happened because of Herodias. Matthew pointedly calls her "the wife of Philip, his brother": she was a woman who, by the Torah's own wording (Leviticus 18:16; 20:21), still belonged to his half-brother's marriage, and that brother was still alive.
The verse is a flashback that explains Herod's dread in verse 2. He thinks Jesus is John back from the dead because Herod himself had silenced John. The verbs Matthew chooses, seize and bind, are the same ones he will use when Jesus is arrested and bound. The fate of the prophet in chains foreshadows the fate of the one he came before.
-
4because John had been telling him, “It is not lawful for you to have her.”
Full study →The verse gives the reason behind the arrest in verse 3: "For John had been telling him, again and again and to his face, 'You are not permitted under God's law to keep this woman as your wife.'"
- "For" points back. Herod had John seized and chained because John would not stop saying this.
- The tense suggests persistence. "Had been saying" points to a known, repeated public position, not one rash remark.
- "Lawful" means God's law. The word means "permitted," and the authority behind it is the Torah, not the state. Herod Antipas was the state in Galilee, and no Roman rule forbade the match. The Law of Moses did: "You shall not uncover the nakedness of your brother's wife" (Leviticus 18:16; see 20:21). Herodias was the wife of Antipas's half-brother, and that brother was still alive.
- "For you" is singular. The ruler stands under the same law as the people he rules.
- "To have her" means to hold her as a wife. The charge is not about a hidden affair. It concerns a public, official royal marriage that John said God's law did not allow, and by implication one that could not go on.
First hearers would have recognised the old pattern of a prophet confronting a king over a forbidden marriage. They would have thought of Elijah facing Ahab and Jezebel. They would also have sensed where this was heading.
-
5Although Herod wanted to kill John, he was afraid of the people, because they regarded John as a prophet.
Full study →Herod had John locked up for telling him, again and again, that his marriage to his brother's wife broke God's law (vv. 3–4). He wanted John dead, and kept wanting it. But he was afraid of the crowd, the mass of ordinary people, because they went on regarding John as a true prophet, a man God had sent to speak for him.
The sentence is built around Herod's fear. His wish to kill is a lasting desire he holds back, and what holds it back is not conscience or reverence for God. It is the danger of popular anger. To the people, John was the first real messenger from God in living memory, so killing him meant killing God's spokesman, the crime Israel's scriptures held against wicked kings. To a ruler who needed Rome's approval, it also risked unrest he could not afford. The irony would not have been lost on Matthew's readers. The man who should have feared God feared only the crowd, and the protection the crowd gave was enough to keep John alive for a while, though not for long (vv. 6–11).
-
6On Herod’s birthday, however, the daughter of Herodias danced before them and pleased Herod
Full study →"But when Herod's birthday festivities came around, the daughter of Herodias danced out on the open floor in the middle of the banquet, in front of everyone, and she delighted Herod."
Verse 5 left Herod stuck: he wanted John dead but was afraid of the crowds who held John to be a prophet. The small word de, "but", turns the story. The ruler's birthday arrives. This is a state banquet in the style of the Gentile courts, with Herod's officials reclining around the room and wine flowing, the kind of feast that pious Jews linked with pagan kings. The only other birthday in the Bible is Pharaoh's, and he too used it to put a man to death (Gen 40:20–22).
The dancer is not a hired entertainer. She is a girl of the royal household, called only "the daughter of Herodias". That name ties her to the very marriage John had condemned (14:3–4). She dances "in the middle", on the open floor in full view of the guests. Matthew uses the ordinary word for dancing (the same word Jesus uses for children's games in 11:17) and does not describe the dance. What he stresses is its effect: she "pleased" Herod. That phrase echoes the Greek story of Esther, where "the girl pleased" the Persian king at his feasts. In Esther the pattern led to the rescue of God's people. Here Herod's pleasure leads straight into a reckless public oath (v. 7), and the oath leads to the death of the prophet.
Where the English drifted
-
in v1
fame (KJV, YLT, ESV)
akoē
- What we hear
- Celebrity, renown, being widely admired or famous.
- What they heard
- "What is heard": the report, news or rumor circulating about someone. The word says nothing about whether the talk was admiring.
-
in v1, v3, v6
Herod
Hērōdēs
- What we hear
- The same Herod who ordered the killing of the infants in Bethlehem (Matthew 2).
- What they heard
- Herod Antipas, son of Herod the Great. His father had died around 4 BC, so this is a different man ruling a smaller territory with a lesser title.
-
in v2
John the Baptist
Iōannēs ho baptistēs
- What we hear
- Can sound like 'John of the Baptist church', a denominational label.
- What they heard
- 'John the Immerser/Baptizer', a nickname describing his practice of immersing people in the Jordan.
-
in v2
servants
paides
- What we hear
- Household staff: butlers, maids, menial workers.
- What they heard
- The ruler's courtiers and attendants, the officials of his inner circle, as with the 'servants' of Pharaoh or Saul.
-
in v3
put him in prison
en phylakē apetheto
- What we hear
- Prison as a sentence: a set term served as punishment after a trial.
- What they heard
- Put away under guard: detention at the ruler's discretion, without a trial or a set term, which in practice often ended in release or execution.
-
in v4
lawful
exestin
- What we hear
- Allowed by the law of the land: legal under state or civil statute.
-
in v4
to have her
echein autēn
- What we hear
- To sleep with her or carry on with her, as in a sexual affair, or simply to possess her.
- What they heard
- To hold her as one's wife. The phrase is the ordinary Greek idiom for a marriage, so the objection is to the public union itself (Mark 6:18: "to have your brother's wife").
-
in v5
when he would have put him to death (KJV, WEB)
thelōn auton apokteinai
- What we hear
- Herod was about to execute John, or would have done so under some condition.
- What they heard
- Herod wanted to kill John: a continuing wish he did not act on.
-
in v5
prophet
prophētēs
- What we hear
- Someone who predicts the future.
- What they heard
- A messenger who speaks God's word with God's authority. For first-century Jews, after a long sense that prophecy had gone quiet, such a figure signaled that God was acting again. Harming him meant opposing God.
-
in v6
danced
ōrchēsato (orcheomai)
- What we hear
- A sultry, erotic performance, the 'dance of the seven veils' by the seductress Salome.
- What they heard
- The general Greek word for dancing, also used for children's play in Matthew 11:17. Matthew says nothing about the style of the dance. What made the scene scandalous was where it happened and who danced, a royal girl at a drinking feast, and what followed from it.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v6
The 'seductive dance of Salome' isn't in Matthew's text
- What's often taught
- A familiar retelling says Herodias's daughter, Salome, performed a deliberately erotic dance that aroused Herod, and that he made his rash oath out of lust.
- What the text supports
Matthew uses the ordinary verb for dancing (orcheomai). Jesus uses the same verb for children playing in the marketplace (11:17). Matthew does not describe the dance at all. He calls the dancer a korasion, a 'little girl' or 'young girl' (14:11), and never names her. 'Salome' comes from Josephus. The verb 'pleased' (areskō) means won his favour or delighted him, and it echoes the Greek of Esther 2:9, 'the girl pleased him'.
The common reading is partly right. A royal daughter performing at a drinking feast for men would have been improper, since such dancing was normally done by hired entertainers. Many scholars think the scene suggests something unseemly. But the text puts its weight elsewhere: Herod already wanted John dead (14:5), and he used the moment and the public oath to get what he wanted. The 'dance of the seven veils' and the adult seductress come from Oscar Wilde's play and the art and opera that followed, not from the Gospel.
- Where the English feeds it
- Only slightly. English 'danced… and pleased Herod' is accurate. Some paraphrases make it 'greatly pleased' or 'pleased him so much', adding intensity that really belongs to verse 7. Most of the misreading comes from cultural imagery, not from translation.
Every word
-
Ἐν
En · G1722
in, at · v1, v2, v3, v6
Marks a point in time: "at". With the following words it forms a set phrase that opens a new scene.
-
ἐκείνῳ
ekeinō · G1565
that · v1
"That" points back loosely to the period of Jesus' Galilean ministry just described. It is not a precise date.
-
τῷ
tō · G3588
the · v1, v2, v3, v4, v5, v6
The definite article goes with "time". English drops it after "that".
-
καιρῷ
kairō · G2540
time, season, period · v1
Here it simply means "period" or "season". It does not carry the special sense of a God-appointed moment that sermons sometimes give the word.
-
ἤκουσεν
ēkousen · G0191
to hear · v1
The tense presents a single event: news reached Herod. It sets up his anxious reaction in the next verse.
-
Ἡρῴδης
Hērōdēs · G2264
Herod · v1, v3, v6
This is Herod Antipas, son of Herod the Great. He is not the Herod of Matthew 2, who had died more than thirty years earlier.
-
τετραάρχης
tetraarchēs · G5076
tetrarch, petty ruler · v1
Literally "ruler of a fourth". By this period it was the standard title for a minor ruler under Rome who ranked below a king. Antipas governed Galilee and Perea.
-
ἀκοὴν
akoēn · G0189
hearing; report, news, rumor · v1
The word means what is heard: the spoken reports about Jesus' deeds passed from mouth to mouth. Because Herod "heard the hearing", the Greek makes a small play on sound.
-
Ἰησοῦ
Iēsou · G2424
Jesus (Joshua) · v1
The genitive means "about Jesus": he is the subject of the reports, not the one making them.
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v2, v3, v5, v6
Carries straight on from verse 1: Herod heard the reports about Jesus, and this was his reaction.
-
εἶπεν
eipen · G2036
said · v2
A single act of speaking in the past. Matthew has Herod himself say it. In Mark's parallel (6:14) it is less clear whether Herod or the crowd is speaking.
-
παισὶν
paisin · G3816
child; servant · v2
Here not children but the king's court attendants and officials, the people around a ruler. In the Greek Old Testament the 'servants' of Pharaoh or Saul are called by this same word.
-
αὐτοῦ·
autou · G846
his · v2, v3, v4, v5
Herod's own people. He says this inside his court, not as a public announcement.
-
οὗτός
houtos · G3778
this one · v2
Points at Jesus, the man in the reports, with some force: 'This man, the one they're talking about...'
-
ἐστιν
estin · G1510
is · v2
Present tense. Herod is identifying who Jesus is, not making a comparison: in his mind Jesus is John.
-
Ἰωάννης
Iōannēs · G2491
John · v2, v3, v4
John, the prophet Herod had imprisoned and then had beheaded (vv. 3–12).
-
βαπτιστής·
baptistēs · G910
baptizer, immerser · v2
A nickname based on what John did, dipping people in the Jordan. It is a description, not the name of a group.
-
ἠγέρθη
ēgerthē · G1453
was raised; rose · v2
A completed past act: 'he has been raised' or 'he has risen'. The verb is the ordinary word for getting up or waking, and the standard word for rising from death.
-
ἀπὸ
apo · G575
-
νεκρῶν,
nekrōn · G3498
dead (ones) · v2
Plural: 'from among the dead'. John is pictured coming back out of the realm of the dead.
-
διὰ
dia · G1223
because of · v2, v3
With the following word, 'for this reason'. Herod is reasoning from cause to effect.
-
δυνάμεις
dynameis · G1411
power; mighty deed · v2
This word can mean the miracles themselves or the forces that produce them. Here it is the subject of 'are at work', so it reads most naturally as active powers operating through Jesus.
-
ἐνεργοῦσιν
energousin · G1754
to be at work, operate · v2
Present tense, ongoing: the powers are actively operating. Elsewhere the verb is often used of unseen forces at work in a person.
-
γὰρ
gar · G1063
for · v3, v4
'For' or 'you see'. It opens a flashback. Verse 2 has Herod saying John has risen from the dead, and here Matthew stops to explain why Herod is haunted by John. This is why most translations use 'had arrested'.
-
κρατήσας
kratēsas · G2902
-
ἔδησεν
edēsen · G1210
to bind · v3
'He bound', meaning chains or fetters. This is the main verb of the sentence. The same verb is used when Jesus is bound and handed to Pilate (27:2).
-
φυλακῇ
phylakē · G5438
guard, watch, prison · v3
'Prison', literally a place of guarding. It means being held in custody, not serving a sentence. Josephus names the place as the fortress of Machaerus, east of the Dead Sea.
-
ἀπέθετο
apetheto · G0659
to put away, lay aside · v3
'He put [him] away'. The word means stowing something out of the way, and the Greek Old Testament uses it for putting someone into custody. The form is middle voice, which can hint that Herod did this for his own sake, but that hint should not be pushed hard.
-
Ἡρῳδιάδα
Hērōdiada · G2266
Herodias · v3, v6
Herodias, granddaughter of Herod the Great. That made her a niece of Antipas and of her first husband. Her name is the feminine form of 'Herod'.
-
γυναῖκα
gynaika · G1135
woman, wife · v3
'Wife'. Greek uses one word for both 'woman' and 'wife'. Calling her 'the wife of Philip' while she is living with Herod is the point of the charge. In the eyes of the law that John cites in verse 4, she still belongs to the brother's marriage.
-
Φιλίππου
Philippou · G5376
Philip · v3
'Of Philip', her first husband. Josephus calls him simply 'Herod', the son of Herod the Great by Mariamne II. This person is not Philip the tetrarch, who married Herodias' daughter Salome. See debates.
-
ἀδελφοῦ
adelphou · G0080
brother · v3
'Brother'. Here it means a half-brother: Herod the Great had many wives, and Antipas and Herodias' first husband had different mothers. Even so, the law forbidding a man to take his brother's wife (Leviticus 18:16) applied in full.
-
ἔλεγεν
elegen · G3004
to say, speak · v4
Imperfect tense, a past action shown as going on: "was saying" or "had been saying." Coming after verse 3, it gives the background to the arrest. John's rebuke was what he kept saying, not a single remark.
-
οὐκ
ouk · G3756
not · v4
A flat, factual negative. John does not say "you shouldn't" or "it would be better not to." He says the permission does not exist.
-
ἔξεστίν
exestin · G1832
-
σοι
soi · G4771
for you, to you · v4
Singular and personal: "for you." The ruler is not exempt. The same law that binds his subjects binds him.
-
ἔχειν
echein · G2192
to have, hold · v4, v5
In this setting "to have" a woman means to have her as wife, to hold her in a marital union. The objection is to the marriage itself, not just to a secret affair.
-
θέλων
thelōn · G2309
to want, to will · v5
"Wanting." It is a present participle, so it describes a desire that kept going while he did nothing about it. Set beside the main verb "he feared," it reads as "though he wanted." The wish is real but held in check.
-
ἀποκτεῖναι
apokteinai · G0615
to kill · v5
A plain, blunt word for killing. It is not a legal word for execution. Matthew gives no sense of a trial or a lawful sentence, only that Herod wanted John dead.
-
ἐφοβήθη
ephobēthē · G5399
to fear, be afraid · v5
"He feared." This is the main verb of the sentence. The fear is political and practical: what the people might do if he killed a man they honored. It is not reverence.
-
ὄχλον
ochlon · G3793
-
ὅτι
hoti · G3754
because, that · v5
"Because." It gives the reason the crowd was dangerous to Herod.
-
ὡς
hōs · G5613
as, like · v5
Together with "they held" it forms the idiom "hold someone as X," meaning "regard someone as X."
-
προφήτην
prophētēn · G4396
prophet · v5
A spokesman sent by God. To the people, John was a genuine messenger of God, the kind Israel had been without for a long time. That made his word carry divine weight, and it made his killer answerable to God.
-
Γενεσίοις
Genesiois · G1077
birthday celebration · v6
A plural noun, like many festival names ('the festivities'). It means the celebration of Herod's birthday, a royal feast day, not just the date. The dative case marks the time: 'at the birthday festivities'.
-
δὲ
de · G1161
but, now · v6
A light 'but' or 'now' that turns the story. In verse 5 Herod wanted John dead but feared the crowd. Now an occasion comes along.
-
γενομένοις
genomenois · G1096
to happen, come about · v6
An aorist participle agreeing with 'birthday festivities': 'when they came around / took place'. With the noun it forms an unusual time clause, 'when Herod's birthday came'.
-
ὠρχήσατο
ōrchēsato · G3738
to dance · v6
A simple aorist, 'she danced', a single event. The verb is the ordinary word for dancing. The same verb describes children dancing in a game in Matthew 11:17, and by itself it says nothing about what kind of dance this was.
-
θυγάτηρ
thygatēr · G2364
daughter · v6
The dancer is named only by her relationship. Matthew later calls her a 'girl' (korasion, 14:11). Josephus names her Salome, but the Gospels never do.
-
μέσῳ
mesō · G3319
middle, midst · v6
'In the middle', meaning the open floor in the centre of the banquet hall, surrounded by the reclining guests. She performed in full view of everyone present.
-
ἤρεσεν
ēresen · G0700
to please · v6
'She pleased', meaning she delighted or won the favour of Herod. It is a general word for gratifying someone. Its weight comes from the result: in verse 7 Herod swears an open-ended oath because of it.
The world behind it
The Herods. When Herod the Great died in 4 BC, Augustus divided his kingdom among three sons. Antipas received Galilee (Jesus' home region) and Perea (east of the Jordan, where John baptized and where Antipas held the fortress of Machaerus). He ruled as tetrarch from 4 BC to AD 39. He governed with Rome's approval, paid tribute and kept order, and he never received the title "king" that he wanted. His request for it led Caligula to banish him (Josephus, Antiquities 18.240–255).
His court. Antipas rebuilt Sepphoris, a few miles from Nazareth, and founded Tiberias on the lake as his capital, naming it after the emperor. Galilean villagers felt his rule through taxes and through his officials and soldiers, the "servants" (paides, courtiers) he speaks to in verse 2.
John the Baptist. Josephus confirms independently that Antipas imprisoned and executed John at Machaerus. He says Antipas feared John's influence over the crowds might spark an uprising (Antiquities 18.116–119). Matthew stresses another motive, John's public criticism of Antipas' marriage to Herodias, his brother's wife (14:3–4). The two explanations fit together: a prophet's moral rebuke of a ruler was itself politically dangerous.
How news travelled. In a village society, akoē (report, word of mouth) was the main way news spread. Reports of healings and exorcisms would have reached the court through officials, traders and travellers, and grew as they were passed on.
From the study of Matthew 14:1.
Where scholars differ
in v1
Does "at that time" place Herod's hearing directly after the rejection at Nazareth, or is it a loose connector?
-
Loose connector: it means only "during this general period".
Matthew uses the same phrase to open scenes in 11:25 and 12:1 without tight chronology. It echoes the Septuagint's "at that time" formula. Matthew's order of events differs from Mark's (Mark 6:7–14), so the arrangement here is literary.
-
Intended link with what comes before, by theme if not strictly by time.
Placing this scene right after 13:53–58 contrasts the unbelief of Jesus' hometown with the ruler's fearful attention. Matthew's interest in true and false "hearing" in chapter 13 makes the placement look deliberate.
in v2
What exactly did Herod think had happened to John?
-
A literal bodily return: John has come back to life, early and individually.
The verb is the normal one for resurrection (ἐγείρω, 'raised'), and Mark 6:16's 'whom I beheaded, he has been raised' points to the same man come back.
-
Popular superstition about restless spirits, possibly with a suspicion of sorcery: Jesus is drawing on the spirit of the murdered John.
Carl Kraeling ('Was Jesus Accused of Necromancy?', Journal of Biblical Literature 1940) pointed to Greco-Roman magical texts in which the spirits of people killed violently were thought powerful and could be called up. 'The powers are at work in him' suits this idea. The theory is suggestive but speculative, and the Gospel text does not spell it out.
-
A guilty conscience talking more than a worked-out belief.
Luke 9:7–9 presents Herod as perplexed, not certain. Matthew 14:3–12 immediately explains the remark by Herod's crime. Josephus shows people tied Herod's misfortunes to John's death.
in v2
Does dynameis here mean 'miracles' or 'powers' (forces)?
-
Miracles: the mighty deeds in the reports.
Matthew elsewhere uses the plural for Jesus' miracles (11:20–23; 13:54, 58), and KJV renders 'mighty works'.
-
Powers: supernatural forces operating through Jesus.
The word is the subject of ἐνεργοῦσιν, 'are at work in him'. Deeds do not 'work in' someone, but forces do. BDAG takes this verse this way.
in v3
Who was Herodias' first husband, and why do Matthew and Mark call him 'Philip'?
-
He bore both names, 'Herod Philip', so the Gospels and Josephus refer to the same man by different names.
Herod the Great's sons often shared names (there were two sons called Antipas/Antipater-type names, and several Herods). Nothing rules out a second son named Philip besides the tetrarch. The modern label 'Herod Philip' comes from harmonizing the two accounts, not from any ancient source that uses the double name.
-
The Gospel tradition confused him with Philip the tetrarch.
Josephus (Antiquities 18.109, 136–137) calls the first husband only 'Herod' and says Philip the tetrarch married Herodias' daughter Salome. A popular tradition could easily have merged the family links. The omission of the name in Codex Bezae and in Luke 3:19 may show early unease about it.
in v3
Why was John arrested: for his rebuke of the marriage, or for political danger?
-
The two accounts complement each other.
A prophet with a mass following who publicly declared the ruler's marriage unlawful threatened Antipas' legitimacy. This was all the more true because the divorce had already offended Nabatea. Josephus gives the political fear and the Gospels give the trigger.
-
Josephus' political reason is the historical core, and the Gospels' focus on the marriage is shaped by the Elijah–Jezebel pattern.
Josephus says nothing about the marriage rebuke (Antiquities 18.118). Matthew's story clearly echoes Elijah and Ahab, and the Gospels themselves differ over who wanted John dead (Mark 6:19–20 vs Matthew 14:5).
in v4
What exactly was John's legal objection to the marriage?
-
The ban on marrying a brother's wife (Leviticus 18:16; 20:21).
Mark 6:18 states it outright: "your brother's wife." The first husband was alive and Herodias had a child, so the levirate exception (Deut 25:5–10) could not apply. Josephus also frames the offence as marrying "her husband's brother" (Ant. 18.136). Most commentators take this as the main charge.
-
The divorces behind it: Herodias divorcing a living husband, and Antipas sending away his Nabataean wife.
Josephus stresses that Herodias divorced her husband against "the ways of our fathers" (Ant. 18.136), and that a woman initiating divorce was not Jewish practice (Ant. 15.259). Jesus' teaching that divorcing and remarrying is adultery, including a woman divorcing her husband (Mark 10:11–12), may echo the Herodian scandal. The Gospels do not cite this as John's ground, but it may have been part of the picture.
-
The marriage of an uncle and niece.
Some sectarian Jewish texts condemn uncle–niece marriage (Damascus Document 5:7–11; Temple Scroll 66:15–17), and Herodias was Antipas's niece. But many Jews of the period accepted such marriages, and no Gospel mentions this. It is generally considered at most a secondary factor.
in v4
Why was John arrested and killed: for the rebuke, or for political reasons?
-
Mainly for the moral and legal rebuke of the marriage, as Matthew and Mark report.
Matt 14:3–4 and Mark 6:17–19 give the rebuke as the direct cause, with Herodias's grudge driving the execution.
-
Mainly out of political fear of John's popularity, as Josephus reports.
Josephus says Antipas feared John's eloquence might lead the crowds to revolt and struck first (Ant. 18.118). He does not mention the rebuke.
-
Both: the rebuke was itself politically dangerous.
Many historians, such as Hoehner and Meier, note how the two fit together. The marriage had already caused a crisis with Nabataea, and John worked in Perea, Antipas's border region with Nabataea. A popular prophet publicly declaring the ruler's marriage illegitimate under Torah was exactly the kind of agitation Josephus says Antipas feared. Matthew's v. 5 also shows Herod weighing the crowd's view of John.
in v4
Who was Herodias's first husband, called "Philip" in v. 3?
-
The Gospel tradition confused him with Philip the tetrarch.
Josephus calls the first husband simply "Herod" and says Philip the tetrarch married Salome, Herodias's daughter (Ant. 18.136–137).
-
He was known as Herod Philip, bearing both names.
Herod the Great reused names among his many sons (there were two Antipaters, for example), so a second Philip is possible. But the double name "Herod Philip" is a modern way of harmonising the sources and is not found in any ancient source.
in v5
Who wanted John dead: Herod (Matthew) or Herodias (Mark)?
-
Matthew has compressed Mark and reshaped the account, putting the hostility on Herod and making the crowd the restraint.
Matthew's version of this story is much shorter than Mark's. Leftovers of Mark's version remain in Matthew 14:9 ("the king was grieved"). Matthew's wording matches his own pattern in 21:26 and 21:46, where leaders fear the crowd because it holds someone to be a prophet.
-
Both accounts are compatible: Herod was torn, both drawn to John and hostile to him, and each Gospel stresses a different side.
Mark says Herod was "greatly perplexed" by John (6:20), which points to mixed feelings. Herod could fear John as a holy man and the crowd as a political risk, while Herodias pushed for John's death. Matthew 14:9 keeps Herod's distress.
-
Matthew's picture is closer to the historical politics.
Josephus, Antiquities 18.116–119, independently gives Antipas's motive as fear that John's popularity might lead to revolt. Matthew's emphasis on fear of the crowd fits this.
in v5
Was John killed for moral rebuke (the Gospels) or for political danger (Josephus)?
-
The two explanations complement each other.
Denouncing a ruler's marriage in front of a Law-observant population undermined his legitimacy, and that was itself a political threat. Matthew 14:3–5 contains both elements: the rebuke (v. 4) and the fear of the crowd (v. 5). Many historians, e.g. Meier and Hoehner, take this view.
-
The sources are independent accounts with different emphases, and neither should be forced into the other.
Josephus does not mention the marriage rebuke or the dance. The Gospels do not mention Machaerus or the war with Aretas. Each writer shapes the story for his own purpose: Josephus to explain Antipas's defeat, Matthew to point ahead to Jesus' fate.
in v6
What kind of dance was it?
-
An improper, probably sensual performance.
At Greco-Roman banquets, dancers were usually low-status hired performers, sometimes linked with sexual availability. A royal girl dancing for drinking men would itself have been scandalous. Herod's extravagant reaction (v. 7) and Mark's mention of the guests also being pleased (Mark 6:22) suggest an effect beyond innocent charm. Many commentators take this view.
-
A girl's performance whose propriety is not the point; the text does not say.
The verb *orcheomai* is neutral and is used of children in Matthew 11:17. Matthew calls her a *korasion*, 'little girl' (14:11), the word used of a twelve-year-old in Mark 5:42. The Esther echo ('the girl pleased him') is about winning royal favour. The narrative's interest is in Herod's oath and guilt, not the dance. The 'seductive Salome' picture comes from later art and from Wilde.
in v6
Does *genesia* mean Herod's birthday or the anniversary of his accession?
-
His birthday.
Papyri of the Roman period use *genesia* for living people's birthday celebrations (Moulton–Milligan; BDAG). It is the natural sense, and the major lexicons and translations take it this way.
-
The anniversary of his accession to power.
Some older interpreters pointed to the Mishnah's 'genusia of kings' (m. Avodah Zarah 1:3), which the Talmud discusses as possibly the accession day (b. Avodah Zarah 10a). They also noted that rulers celebrated accession days. Few modern scholars hold this view.
in v6
Where did the banquet take place?
-
At Machaerus, east of the Dead Sea.
Josephus (*Ant.* 18.119) says John was imprisoned and killed there. The fortress included a palace with banqueting rooms, and the swift delivery of the head (14:11) suggests John was held on site.
-
In Galilee, perhaps at Tiberias, Antipas's capital.
Mark 6:21 says the 'leading men of Galilee' attended, and a birthday feast at the capital would be natural. On this view, Josephus's location applies only to the imprisonment, or the Gospel tradition simply does not specify. Matthew does not name a place.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. ἀκοή
- BDAG s.v. τετραάρχης
- BDAG s.v. καιρός
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. ἀκοή
- Josephus, Antiquities 17.318; 18.27, 36–38, 109–119, 240–255
- Josephus, Jewish War 2.94–95, 181–183
- Vulgate, Matthew 14:1
- Nestle-Aland 28th ed. / SBLGNT, Matthew 14:1
- Harold W. Hoehner, Herod Antipas (Cambridge University Press, 1972)
- Craig S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Matthew 14:1–12
- Oxford English Dictionary s.v. "fame" (historical senses)
- BDAG s.v. παῖς, βαπτιστής, ἐγείρω, δύναμις, ἐνεργέω
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. δύναμις
- Josephus, Antiquities 18.116–119 (John's execution by Antipas)
- Josephus, Antiquities 18.240–256 (Antipas's later exile)
- NA28 critical apparatus at Matt 14:2 (Codex Bezae addition)
- Carl H. Kraeling, 'Was Jesus Accused of Necromancy?', Journal of Biblical Literature 59 (1940)
- Craig S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Matt 14:1–2
- R. T. France, The Gospel of Matthew (NICNT), on 14:1–2
- Vulgate, Matt 14:2
- BDAG s.v. κρατέω, ἀποτίθημι, φυλακή, διά
- Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 18.109–119, 18.136–137
- LXX Leviticus 18:16; 20:21; 24:12; Numbers 15:34; Deuteronomy 25:5
- Damascus Document (CD) 5.7–11
- NA28 critical apparatus; Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament
- H. W. Hoehner, Herod Antipas (1972)
- W. D. Davies & D. C. Allison, Matthew (ICC), vol. 2
- C. S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament
- BDAG s.v. ἔξεστι
- BDAG s.v. ἔχω
- BDAG s.v. λέγω
- Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 18.109–119; 18.136–137; 15.259
- Leviticus 18:16; 20:21; Deuteronomy 25:5–10
- Mark 6:17–29 (parallel)
- Damascus Document (CD) 5:7–11; Temple Scroll (11QT) 66:15–17
- Harold W. Hoehner, Herod Antipas (Cambridge, 1972)
- John P. Meier, A Marginal Jew, vol. 2 (on John the Baptist and Josephus)
- W. D. Davies & D. C. Allison, Matthew (ICC), on 14:1–12
- R. T. France, The Gospel of Matthew (NICNT)
- Craig S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Matt 14:3–4
- Vulgate, Matthew 14:4
- BDAG s.v. θέλω
- BDAG s.v. φοβέω
- BDAG s.v. ὄχλος
- BDAG s.v. ἔχω (sense: consider, regard, with ὡς)
- BDAG s.v. προφήτης
- Josephus, Antiquities 18.109–119 (Antipas, Herodias, Aretas, death of John at Machaerus)
- Josephus, Antiquities 20.97–98; Jewish War 2.261–263 (popular prophets and crowds)
- Josephus, Against Apion 1.41
- 1 Maccabees 4:46; 9:27; 14:41
- Mark 6:17–29 (parallel account)
- Matthew 10:28; 11:9–14; 17:12–13; 21:26; 21:46
- Leviticus 18:16; 20:21
- W. D. Davies & D. C. Allison, Matthew (ICC), vol. 2, on 14:1–12
- H. W. Hoehner, Herod Antipas
- J. P. Meier, A Marginal Jew, vol. 2 (on John the Baptist and Josephus)
- Vulgate, Matthew 14:5
- BDAG s.v. γενέσια, ὀρχέομαι, ἀρέσκω, μέσος
- Moulton & Milligan, Vocabulary of the Greek Testament, s.v. γενέσια
- Blass–Debrunner–Funk, Greek Grammar of the NT §200 (dative of time)
- Josephus, Antiquities 18.109–119, 18.136–137
- Josephus, Against Apion 2.204
- Herodotus, Histories 4.26
- Septuagint: Genesis 40:20; Esther 2:9; 5:3–6; 7:2; 2 Samuel 6:21; 2 Maccabees 6:7
- Mishnah Avodah Zarah 1:3; Babylonian Talmud Avodah Zarah 10a
- B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (Mark 6:22)
- C. S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Matt 14:6
- Vulgate, Matthew 14:6
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).