Luke Chapter 18 Read as one passage

Luke 18:19–23

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

19“Why do you call Me good?” Jesus replied. “No one is good except God alone. 20You know the commandments: ‘Do not commit adultery, do not murder, do not steal, do not bear false witness, honor your father and mother.’” 21“All these I have kept from my youth,” he said. 22On hearing this, Jesus told him, “You still lack one thing: Sell everything you own and give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven. Then come, follow Me.” 23But when the ruler heard this, he became very sad, because he was extremely wealthy.

What the first hearers heard

For the ruler in the story, the reply was an unexpected turn. He had offered a flattering title and a question about what he could do. Jesus refused the flattery and named the one God as the only one who is truly good. In effect he said: the goodness you are looking for is God's, and you already know what it requires (v. 20). Within a few verses the scene shows that the man's real loyalty lies with his wealth (vv. 22–23). The question of who is "good" becomes a question of who his God really is.

For Luke's readers, many of them Greek-speaking and familiar with the custom of praising patrons as "good benefactors," the scene modelled a teacher who would not take honor that belonged to God. Readers who already called Jesus "Lord" also met a puzzle. Luke's Gospel repeatedly connects Jesus with things that belong to God alone (compare 5:21). This verse does not settle that connection, but it leaves the question open for the reader to think about.

From the study of Luke 18:19.

Verse by verse

  1. 19“Why do you call Me good?” Jesus replied. “No one is good except God alone.

    Jesus answered the ruler with a question of his own: "Why are you calling me good? No one is good, except One: God."

    The man had opened with an unusual compliment, "Good Teacher." Jesus does not accept it as a casual courtesy. He asks the man to think about what he has just said. In Israel's speech, "good" in its full sense was something you said about God ("Give thanks to the LORD, for he is good"). God is the one whose goodness comes from no one else, and every other good is measured against it. Jesus' last words, "except one, God," echo the confession every devout Jew recited morning and evening: "Hear, O Israel, the LORD our God, the LORD is one." So the reply moves the conversation away from praising the teacher and toward the one God, whose goodness the commandments express (v. 20).

    The sentence does not say that people can never be called good; Luke calls several people good elsewhere. It does not directly say whether Jesus himself is good or divine; it puts that question in the man's mouth: "why are you calling me this?" What it does make plain is that the measure of "good," and the way to "eternal life," start with the one God.

    Full study →
  2. 20You know the commandments: ‘Do not commit adultery, do not murder, do not steal, do not bear false witness, honor your father and mother.’”

    A wealthy leading man has asked Jesus, "Good teacher, what must I do to inherit the life of the age to come?" Jesus first turns the compliment back to God ("No one is good except God alone") and then answers the way a Jewish teacher would: you already know the answer; it is in the commandments God gave. He recites the familiar Ten Words, choosing the ones that guard one's neighbor.

    Put back together with its full force, verse 20 says:

    "You already know the commandments, the ones everyone learns: Do not violate a marriage. Do not take a person's life unlawfully. Do not take what is not yours. Do not testify falsely against your neighbor. And keep giving your father and your mother the weight and care they are due."

    The four prohibitions are short, sharp Greek "do nots". The last line changes to a positive, ongoing command, "keep honoring". Its "honor" is the Hebrew idea of giving parents weight. For an adult that meant respect together with practical support in their old age, not only childhood obedience. The order (adultery, then murder, then theft) is the one many Greek-speaking Jews of the day used, the same order found in Romans 13:9 and James 2:11.

    Two things are noticeably missing: the commandments about God (no other gods, no idols, the divine name, the Sabbath) and the last one, "Do not covet." Jesus does not mention coveting, but it is exactly what the next verses bring into the open. When the man says he has kept all these, Jesus tells him to sell everything, give to the poor, and follow him, and the man goes away very sad, "for he was extremely rich" (vv. 22–23).

    Full study →
  3. 21“All these I have kept from my youth,” he said.

    The ruler answers Jesus plainly: “These, every one of the commandments you just named, I have guarded and observed ever since I was young.”

    The verb pictures a person guarding something precious, as a watchman guards a post. It is the language Deuteronomy uses for Israel's loyalty to God's covenant: “keep my commandments.” The simple past tense takes in his whole life at a glance: from boyhood, when a Jewish boy learned the Law and became answerable for keeping it, up to this moment, he has not knowingly broken these commands. He has not committed adultery, murdered, stolen, given false testimony, or dishonoured his parents.

    The words “these, all of them” limit the claim to the list Jesus gave. He is not claiming to be sinless. He is claiming to be faithful in the way Luke describes Zechariah and Elizabeth as “blameless” in the commandments (Luke 1:6). The words themselves carry no tone of arrogance, and Jesus does not contradict him. Instead, the next verse begins, “You still lack one thing.” The man's sincere record of keeping the rules is the starting point for Jesus' far more demanding call.

    Full study →
  4. 22On hearing this, Jesus told him, “You still lack one thing: Sell everything you own and give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven. Then come, follow Me.”

    Jesus has just heard the ruler say he has kept the commandments since boyhood. He does not dispute it. Instead he says: "There is still one thing missing in you." The man who has everything is the man who lacks.

    Then comes the remedy, and Luke makes it total: sell everything, every last thing you own, and share it out among the destitute, the beggar-poor at the bottom of society. The goods are not to vanish. Jesus promises: "and you will have treasure, stored in the heavens," wealth deposited with God himself. Jewish teaching already said that alms given to the poor were stored up with God, safe from loss and counted at the judgment.

    Selling and giving are not the end of it. They clear the way for the final words: "And come, here, now! Keep on following me." The "one thing" he lacks is not one more good deed added to his list. It is giving up the security of his possessions so that he can attach himself to Jesus in person and walk with him, as the fishermen and the tax collector had done, on a road that leads to Jerusalem.

    The verse turns on two uses of the same verb, have: "all that you have", sold and given away, and the treasure "you will have" with God.

    Full study →
  5. 23But when the ruler heard this, he became very sad, because he was extremely wealthy.

    When he heard what Jesus required (sell everything, give it to the poor, and come follow him), grief came over him. It wasn't mild disappointment. It was a heavy, all-surrounding sorrow, the same word used for Jesus' own anguish in Gethsemane. Luke tells us plainly why: the man was rich, extremely rich. He wasn't merely comfortable. He belonged to the small landed elite whose wealth was their land, their household, their standing, and their place in the community. He had come asking what he must do to inherit eternal life, and he received an answer he could hear but could not bear. Wanting what Jesus offered and being unable to let go of what he had, he was torn. Unlike Mark and Matthew, Luke does not say he went away. He is still standing there, grieving, when Jesus turns and says how hard it is for the rich to enter God's kingdom.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v19

    No one is good

    oudeis agathos

    What we hear
    Every human being is bad. The verse is heard as a statement that people can do no good, often quoted to prove universal sinfulness.
    What they heard
    No one but God is good in the full, underived sense, as the source and standard of goodness. Luke calls people 'good' elsewhere (6:45; 8:15; 23:50; Acts 11:24). The point is about God, not a verdict on human nature.
  • in v20

    Do not kill (KJV)

    phoneuō (for Hebrew ratsach)

    What we hear
    A ban on taking any life at all: war, self-defense, execution, sometimes even animals.
    What they heard
    Do not murder, that is, do not unlawfully take a human life. The same Torah regulated war and prescribed capital penalties, so the command could not have meant all killing.
  • in v20

    honor your father and mother

    timaō (for Hebrew kabbed)

    What we hear
    Children should respect and obey their parents; a matter of attitude and behaviour in childhood.
    What they heard
    Addressed mainly to adults: treat your parents as weighty, which concretely includes caring for and financially supporting them in old age and never shaming or abandoning them.
  • in v20

    commit adultery

    moicheuō (for Hebrew na'af)

    What we hear
    Either spouse being sexually unfaithful, judged by the same standard for both.
    What they heard
    In Torah law, sex with a woman married or betrothed to another man. It was defined by the woman's marital status, so a married man's affair with an unmarried woman fell under other laws. Jesus elsewhere sharpens this (Luke 16:18; Mark 10:11).
  • in v21

    I have kept

    ephylaxa (phylassō)

    What we hear
    Readers shaped by later debates about law and grace often hear “I have obeyed perfectly, without a single failure.” That sounds either impossible or self-deceived.
    What they heard
    “I have guarded and observed these commandments” as a way of life: faithful, lifelong loyalty to the covenant, with the Law's own remedies available for lapses. Devout Jews considered this attainable, and Luke uses the same standard approvingly in 1:6.
  • in v22

    treasure in heaven

    thēsauros en ouranois

    What we hear
    A personal reward I will receive or enjoy after I die and go to heaven.
    What they heard
    Wealth deposited with God, 'the heavens' being a respectful way of speaking of God and his realm. It is kept safe by him and counts at the final judgment and in the age to come. It was a standard Jewish image for what giving to the poor achieves.
  • in v22

    follow me

    akolouthei moi

    What we hear
    Become a Christian; commit inwardly to Jesus.
    What they heard
    Literally leave home and join Jesus' traveling band of disciples, walking behind the teacher toward Jerusalem. The present tense means an ongoing way of life, not a single decision.
  • in v23

    very sad

    perilypos

    What we hear
    Feeling down or disappointed, a passing mood.
    What they heard
    Overwhelmed or gripped by grief, a deep anguish. The same word is used for Jesus in Gethsemane (Mark 14:34) and for the soul cast down in Psalm 42.
Every word
  1. εἶπεν

    eipen · G2036

    said · v19, v21, v22

    The ordinary verb for a single act of speaking. It introduces Jesus' answer, which comes back at once as a question of his own.

  2. δὲ

    de · G1161

    and, then, but · v19, v21, v22, v23

    A light linking word that moves the story on to the reply. It is not a strong 'but'.

  3. αὐτῷ

    autō · G0846

    to him · v19, v22

    The ruler of verse 18, the man who has just addressed Jesus as 'Good Teacher'.

  4. ὁ

    ho · G3588

    the · v19, v20, v21, v22, v23

    Greek often puts 'the' before a personal name. English leaves it out.

  5. Ἰησοῦς·

    Iēsous · G2424G

    Jesus (Hebrew Yeshua/Joshua) · v19, v22

    The speaker. His name means 'the LORD saves', which has some irony in a scene about how a person inherits eternal life.

  6. τί

    ti · G5101

    what? why? · v19

    Here it means 'why?' It asks for the reason behind the man's words. It is not a scolding 'how dare you'.

  7. με

    me · G3165

    me · v19, v21, v22

    It comes early in the Greek ('Why me are you calling good?'), which puts some weight on Jesus himself as the one being called good.

  8. λέγεις

    legeis · G3004H

    you say, you call · v19

    With two objects ('me' and 'good') it means 'call, name, address someone as'. The present tense points to what the man is doing right now: 'Why are you calling me good?'

  9. ἀγαθόν;

    agathon · G0018

    good · v19

    This is the title the man gave Jesus. It means good in character and good in what one gives to others. Jesus holds the word up and asks about it.

  10. οὐδεὶς

    oudeis · G3762

    no one · v19

    A sweeping 'no one'. It is the first half of a 'no one … except' pattern that leaves only one being in the category.

  11. εἰ

    ei · G1487H

    if · v19

    Together with the next word it forms a fixed phrase, 'if not', meaning 'except'.

  12. μὴ

    mē · G3361

    not · v19, v20

    Completes 'ei mē' = 'except, but only'.

  13. εἷς

    heis · G1520

    one · v19, v22

    Literally 'one', not 'alone'. Set beside 'God', it echoes the Shema, Israel's daily confession: 'The LORD our God, the LORD is one' (Deuteronomy 6:4).

  14. θεός.

    theos · G2316

    God · v19

    The God of Israel, the Creator. The sentence ends on him: the man's compliment is turned away from the teacher and toward God.

  15. ἐντολὰς

    entolas · G1785

    commandment, order · v20

    The Greek Old Testament's usual word for God's mitsvot (commands) in the Torah. Here it means the Decalogue, which Jesus then quotes in part.

  16. οἶδας·

    oidas · G6063

    to know · v20

    A perfect form with present meaning: 'you already know'. Jesus is not handing out new information. He is pointing the man back to what every observant Jew learned as a child.

  17. μοιχεύσῃς,

    moicheusēs · G3431

    to commit adultery · v20

    To have sex that violates a marriage. In the Torah this meant sex with a woman who was married or betrothed to another man. Luke puts it first in the list, an order also found in Greek-speaking Judaism.

  18. φονεύσῃς,

    phoneusēs · G5407

    to murder · v20

    To kill a person unlawfully. It is the Greek for the Hebrew ratsach of the sixth commandment, and it does not cover every kind of killing.

  19. κλέψῃς,

    klepsēs · G2813

    to steal · v20

    To take what belongs to someone else in secret. This lands hard on a very rich man (v. 23), whose wealth Jesus will tell him to give away.

  20. ψευδομαρτυρήσῃς,

    pseudomarturēsēs · G5576

    to bear false witness · v20

    To give false testimony, especially in court against a neighbor. One compound word: 'false' + 'testify'.

  21. τίμα

    tima · G5091

    to honor, value · v20

    A positive present-tense command, 'keep honoring'. The four short bans are followed by an ongoing duty: to treat parents as weighty and valuable, which in practice included supporting them in old age.

  22. πατέρα

    patera · G3962

    father · v20

    Father: in that world, head of the household and the person whose name and honor his children carried.

  23. σου

    sou · G4771

    your · v20, v22

    Singular 'your'. The command is spoken to each Israelite personally, here to this one man.

  24. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v20, v22

    Joins mother to father. Both parents receive the same honor.

  25. μητέρα

    mētera · G3384

    mother · v20

    Mother. Naming her alongside the father makes clear that the honor owed is not to the male head of the house alone.

  26. ταῦτα

    tauta · G3778

    these · v21, v23

    “These” means the five commandments Jesus has just listed in v. 20: adultery, murder, theft, false witness, honouring parents. It comes first in the sentence for emphasis: these, the very ones you named.

  27. πάντα

    panta · G3956

    all · v21, v22

    “All of them,” none left out. The man claims to have kept the whole list Jesus quoted, and makes no wider claim of sinless perfection.

  28. ἐφύλαξα

    ephylaxa · G5442

    to guard, keep, observe · v21

    The literal picture is guarding, as a sentry guards a post. With commandments it means observing them faithfully as a way of life. The simple past tense sums up his whole life so far in one view: “I have kept them.”

  29. ἐκ

    ek · G1537

    out of, from · v21

    Used of time here: starting from a point and continuing ever since. Together with the next word it means “ever since youth.”

  30. νεότητος

    neotētos · G3503

    youth · v21

    Youth as a stage of life, the early years. In a Jewish setting it suggests the age when a boy was taught the Law and became responsible for keeping it. The man is saying his observance is lifelong and was not taken up recently.

  31. Ἀκούσας

    Akousas · G0191

    to hear · v22, v23

    'Having heard' what the ruler just claimed in v. 21, that he had kept the commandments since boyhood. Jesus' answer is a response to that claim. He does not argue with it. He builds on it.

  32. ἔτι

    eti · G2089

    still, yet · v22

    'Still': even granting everything the ruler has done, something remains. The word takes his record seriously and says it is not finished.

  33. λείπει

    leipei · G3007

    to be lacking, fall short · v22

    'Is lacking': present tense, a gap that exists right now. The word is ironic for a man who lacks nothing materially (v. 23).

  34. ὅσα

    hosa · G3745

    as many as, whatever · v22

    'As many as': with panta it means 'every last thing you own'. It closes off any partial reading.

  35. ἔχεις

    echeis · G2192

    you have · v22

    'You have', meaning his possessions. The same verb comes back below as 'you will have' treasure. What he has now is set against what he will have.

  36. πώλησον

    pōlēson · G4453

    sell · v22

    An aorist imperative: a single, decisive command to sell. The property is turned into money so that it can be given away.

  37. διάδος

    diados · G1239

    distribute, hand out · v22

    'Distribute', literally 'give through' or 'parcel out' among many. Luke's choice; Mark has the plain 'give'. It is the word for the church's distribution to the needy in Acts 4:35.

  38. πτωχοῖς

    ptōchois · G4434

    poor, destitute · v22

    'To poor people': no article, so the poor in general. Ptōchos is the beggar-level poor, people who depend on others to survive.

  39. θησαυρὸν

    thēsauron · G2344

    treasure, treasury · v22

    A store of wealth. It is a well-known Jewish image: giving to the poor stores up wealth with God.

  40. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in · v22

    It gives the location of the treasure.

  41. οὐρανοῖς

    ouranois · G3772

    heavens, sky · v22

    'Heavens' is plural because the Hebrew word shamayim is plural. It means God's own realm, often a respectful way to say 'with God'. The treasure is kept by God, safe from loss.

  42. δεῦρο

    deuro · G1204

    come here! · v22

    An urgent adverb used as a command: 'Come on! Over here!' It is an invitation to step into Jesus' company now.

  43. ἀκολούθει

    akolouthei · G0190

    follow · v22

    A present imperative: 'keep following', an ongoing way of life. The word was used for disciples walking behind a teacher, and here Jesus is on the road to Jerusalem (18:31).

  44. περίλυπος

    perilypos · G4036

    very sorrowful, deeply grieved · v23

    'Grief all around', a heavy distress that surrounds a person. It is not passing disappointment. The same word describes Jesus' own anguish in Gethsemane (Mark 14:34).

  45. ἐγενήθη

    egenēthē · G1096

    to become · v23

    'He became'. The grief came over him at that moment, in response to the words. It describes a change of state, not a settled character trait.

  46. ἦν

    ēn · G1510

    to be · v23

    'He was'. This is an ongoing condition that forms the background to the event. Being rich wasn't something that happened in the scene. It was simply what he was.

  47. γὰρ

    gar · G1063

    for, because · v23

    An explanation from the narrator. It ties his grief directly to his wealth. Luke tells the reader why he was distressed instead of leaving it to guesswork.

  48. πλούσιος

    plousios · G4145

    rich, wealthy · v23

    Rich. In Luke this is a loaded word: the rich are warned (6:24), shown as foolish (12:16–21) and shut out (16:19–31). The word points ahead to Jesus' saying about 'the rich' in v.24.

  49. σφόδρα

    sphodra · G4970

    exceedingly, very · v23

    'Extremely'. It intensifies 'rich'. He was not just comfortable. He belonged to the small elite, which makes the cost of v.22 enormous.

The world behind it

An unusual greeting. Commentators since Gustaf Dalman have noted that there is no clear example in surviving rabbinic literature of a teacher being addressed as "good teacher/rabbi." The greeting was striking, not routine.

Honor and compliments. In the Mediterranean world, praise put both sides under obligation. A compliment expected a compliment back, and public flattery could be a way of setting up a relationship of mutual favor. When Jesus refuses the title, he refuses that exchange. Luke's readers had heard him say that the kings of the nations like to be called "benefactors" (22:25). In Greek cities agathos ("good") and "benefactor" were words of praise for wealthy patrons, and this ruler is about to be revealed as very rich (18:23).

The Shema. Deuteronomy 6:4–9 was recited twice daily by observant Jews. The phrase "one … God" would have sounded to this man like his own creed being said back to him.

"Ruler" and "eternal life." The man is an archōn (v. 18), a person of standing. He might have been a synagogue leader or a member of a local council. "Eternal life" in this setting meant the life of the age to come, God's coming kingdom. It was not a timeless afterlife of the soul. Jesus' reply sends him back to the God of Israel and his commandments as the starting point for that question.

From the study of Luke 18:19.

Where scholars differ

in v19

What is Jesus implying about himself when he questions the title 'good'?

  • Jesus is redirecting, not defining himself: as a devout Jew he deflects praise to God and makes no statement about his own nature.

    The plain sense of the sentence. Its Shema-shaped ending. Jesus' consistent pointing to the Father in Luke (e.g. 18:43, where the healed man glorifies God). Matthew's rewording (19:17) suggests early readers found the Mark/Luke wording awkward if it were read as a self-claim.

  • It is an implied test of the man's understanding: 'If only God is good, do you realize what you are saying by calling me good?' On this view it hints at Jesus' divine identity.

    Widely held from the church fathers (e.g. Ambrose) onward. Supported by Luke's pattern of linking Jesus with things that belong to God alone (5:21–24) and by the rest of Luke–Acts calling Jesus 'Lord'. Critics reply that the verse does not state this and that the conclusion has to be inferred.

  • It is chiefly a refusal of flattery in an honor-based society: Jesus will not enter an exchange of compliments and favors with a powerful, wealthy man.

    Social-scientific commentators on Luke point to the rarity of the address 'Good Teacher', Mediterranean customs of praise and reciprocity, and Luke 22:25 on rulers called 'benefactors'. This view can be combined with either of the others.

  • Jesus admits he is not sinless.

    Held by some skeptical readers. Most commentators of every tradition reject it, because the saying contrasts God's absolute goodness with any other goodness and says nothing about sin. Elsewhere the New Testament presents Jesus as without sin (e.g. 2 Cor 5:21; Heb 4:15).

in v20

Is Jesus offering the commandments as a real path to eternal life, or using them to expose the man's failure?

  • A genuine answer: in Jesus' Jewish setting, keeping God's commands is the way of life, and Jesus affirms it, then adds the further call to discipleship.

    Luke 10:25–28 ('do this and you will live', citing Lev 18:5); Jesus does not question the man's claim in v. 21; in Mark 10:21 Jesus 'loved him'. Many commentators (e.g. Fitzmyer, Bovon) read the list as sincere.

  • A diagnostic answer: the commandments act as a mirror. The man's claim to have kept them is shown to be shallow when the demand of v. 22 reveals what he loves more than God.

    The opening rebuke about 'good' (v. 19), the omission of 'do not covet', and the man's failure in v. 23; in Luke the impossibility saying follows (vv. 24–27: 'what is impossible with man is possible with God'). This is common in Reformation-influenced readings.

  • Both: the commandments are truly God's will and truly lead to life, but Luke shows that keeping them in the outward sense does not settle where one's heart and wealth belong, which following Jesus does.

    Verse 22 begins 'one thing you still lack', which assumes the man has real obedience to build on. Luke's wider theme of wealth (12:13–21; 16:13–31; 19:1–10) shows what that one thing is.

in v20

Why does Jesus list only the 'second table' (commands about neighbors) and leave out 'do not covet'?

  • Duties toward neighbors are the visible test of devotion to God, and the first-table loyalty is tested by the call to follow Jesus.

    In v. 22 the call to 'follow me' tests where his ultimate loyalty lies; the pairing of love of God and love of neighbor in Luke 10:27.

  • 'Do not covet' is left out on purpose, because it is the commandment the rich man is about to be shown he breaks.

    His great wealth (v. 23) and Luke's warnings against greed (12:15, 'be on guard against all covetousness'). This is suggestive, but the text does not say so.

  • The selection is simply a conventional summary. Short lists of the second-table commands were standard in Jewish and early Christian teaching, so no special meaning should be pressed.

    Similar short lists appear in Rom 13:9, Jas 2:11 and Philo, without any implied omission.

in v21

Was the ruler's claim true and sincere, or self-deceived?

  • Sincere and true by the standards of Torah observance.

    Jesus does not dispute the claim and says only “you still lack one thing” (18:22). Mark adds that Jesus loved him (10:21). Luke itself uses “blameless in all the commandments” approvingly (1:6), and Paul makes a similar claim about his own past (Phil 3:6). Second Temple Judaism regarded faithful observance as attainable.

  • Sincere but superficial: his reply exposes a deeper failure.

    Jesus' list leaves out “do not covet” and the commandments directed to God. His demand to sell everything shows the man's wealth has a hold on him that breaks the first commandment. Luke has just told the parable of the Pharisee who trusted in his own righteousness (18:9–14), and Jesus has said “no one is good except God alone” (18:19). Many commentators combine the two views: true on the level of outward observance, inadequate as total devotion.

in v21

Why does Jesus cite only commandments about other people?

  • They are easily checked, publicly visible duties, and they set up the test about wealth and the poor.

    All five concern conduct toward others. Verse 22 then turns to the poor and to following Jesus, which tests love of God and freedom from greed together.

  • The order and selection simply follow a familiar summary of the Ten Commandments.

    The order with adultery first matches some Septuagint manuscripts of Deut 5 and appears in Rom 13:9 and Jas 2:11, which suggests a standard listing rather than a pointed omission.

in v22

Is the command to sell everything specific to this man or meant for all disciples?

  • Specific to this man: Jesus diagnoses the particular thing holding him back.

    It is addressed to one individual ('to you', singular). Zacchaeus gives only half and is still praised (19:8-9). Other followers in Luke keep homes and support Jesus from their means (8:3; 10:38).

  • Representative: Luke presents total renunciation as the pattern of discipleship.

    Luke adds 'all' to Mark's wording. The same command is given to the disciples in general in 12:33, and 14:33 says 'whoever does not renounce all that he has cannot be my disciple'. The disciples 'left everything' (5:11, 28; 18:28). Acts 2 and 4 show a community practice.

  • Mediating: the demand is always total in principle, but the form it takes varies.

    Luke places stories of full renunciation (the Twelve) beside generous partial giving (Zacchaeus) and women who used their property to support Jesus (8:3). The common factor is that wealth is released for the poor and for the kingdom (L. T. Johnson, The Literary Function of Possessions in Luke-Acts).

in v22

Does Jesus accept the ruler's claim to have kept the commandments?

  • Yes, broadly. Jesus takes it at face value and adds what is still missing.

    'Still' (eti) and 'one thing' assume the rest is in place. Mark says Jesus 'loved him'. Being blameless in law-keeping was considered achievable (cf. Luke 1:6; Philippians 3:6).

  • No. The command shows he has not truly kept the law, especially the first commandment or love of neighbor.

    His refusal shows that wealth comes before God, and Jesus' list left out the first tablet. This reading is common in Reformation-era interpretation. The verse itself does not say so explicitly.

in v22

Is 'treasure in heaven' a reward earned by almsgiving?

  • Yes, in the Jewish sense: giving to the poor is a real deposit with God that he repays.

    Tobit 4:8-10, Sirach 29:11-12, Proverbs 19:17, and Luke 12:33 and 16:9 use the language of real exchange (G. A. Anderson, Charity).

  • It is a figure of speech for the value of belonging to God's kingdom, and it is tied to following Jesus.

    The promise is bound up with 'come, follow me', and Jesus says salvation is 'possible with God', not with people (18:27).

in v23

Does Luke present the ruler's grief as a final refusal?

  • Yes. The grief amounts to a refusal, the same outcome as in Mark and Matthew.

    Mark 10:22 and Matt 19:22 both say he went away. Jesus' saying in vv.24–25 treats him as an example of how hard it is for the rich to enter, and the man never agrees to sell.

  • Luke deliberately leaves the outcome open.

    Luke drops 'he went away', so the man is still present in v.24 when Jesus looks at him. Verse 27 ('what is impossible with man is possible with God') and the Zacchaeus story (19:1–10) suggest a rich man's response is not settled ahead of time.

in v23

Was the command to sell everything meant for this man alone, or does it express a general demand?

  • It was specific to this man, aimed at what was holding him back.

    'You still lack one thing' (v.22) is addressed to him personally. Zacchaeus gives half, not all, and is still declared saved (19:8–9).

  • In Luke it reflects a broad demand on disciples and especially on the rich.

    Luke 12:33 ('Sell your possessions and give alms') and 14:33 ('any of you who does not renounce all that he has cannot be my disciple') are addressed to wider audiences. Verse 24 itself turns at once to 'those who have wealth' in general.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. ἀγαθός
  • BDAG s.v. εἷς
  • LSJ s.v. ἀγαθός
  • Louw–Nida, Greek-English Lexicon (domains 65, 88)
  • Septuagint, Deuteronomy 6:4; Psalm 72:1 (Heb. 73:1)
  • Mishnah, Avot 6:3; Berakhot 1–2
  • Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 101; First Apology 16
  • B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Matt 19:17
  • G. Dalman, The Words of Jesus
  • J. A. Fitzmyer, The Gospel According to Luke X–XXIV (Anchor Bible)
  • I. H. Marshall, The Gospel of Luke (NIGTC)
  • D. L. Bock, Luke 9:51–24:53 (BECNT)
  • J. B. Green, The Gospel of Luke (NICNT)
  • B. J. Malina & R. L. Rohrbaugh, Social-Science Commentary on the Synoptic Gospels
  • BDAG s.v. ἐντολή, μοιχεύω, φονεύω, κλέπτω, ψευδομαρτυρέω, τιμάω
  • HALOT s.v. רצח, נאף, כבד
  • LXX Exodus 20:12–16; Deuteronomy 5:16–20 (Codex Vaticanus order)
  • Nash Papyrus (Decalogue and Shema)
  • Philo, De Decalogo 106–131, 168–171
  • Mishnah Tamid 5:1
  • Sirach 3:1–16; Tobit 4:3–4
  • Mark 7:10–12; Mark 10:17–22; Matthew 19:16–22; Romans 13:9; James 2:11
  • F. Bovon, Luke 2 (Hermeneia)
  • B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament
  • BDAG s.v. φυλάσσω
  • BDAG s.v. νεότης
  • Nestle-Aland, Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed. (apparatus at Luke 18:21)
  • Septuagint: Deut 5:29; 6:2; Lev 18:5; 1 Kgdms (1 Kings) 18:12; Ps 70(71):5, 17; Jer 3:25
  • Josephus, Against Apion 2.178
  • Mishnah Avot 5:21
  • Synoptic parallels: Mark 10:17–22; Matthew 19:16–22
  • Vulgate, Luke 18:21
  • BDAG s.v. λείπω, διαδίδωμι, πτωχός, θησαυρός, ἀκολουθέω, δεῦρο
  • Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. πτωχός (vs. πένης)
  • Nestle-Aland, Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., Luke 18:22 apparatus
  • Tobit 4:7-11; Sirach 29:8-13; Psalms of Solomon 9:5; 2 Baruch 14:12; 24:1
  • Babylonian Talmud, Ketubot 50a (Usha ordinance on giving)
  • Mark 10:17-22; Matthew 19:16-22; Luke 12:33-34; 14:33; 19:1-10; Acts 2:44-45; 4:32-35
  • J. A. Fitzmyer, The Gospel According to Luke X-XXIV (Anchor Bible)
  • D. L. Bock, Luke 9:51-24:53 (BECNT)
  • L. T. Johnson, The Literary Function of Possessions in Luke-Acts
  • G. A. Anderson, Charity: The Place of the Poor in the Biblical Tradition
  • BDAG s.v. περίλυπος
  • BDAG s.v. πλούσιος
  • Louw-Nida 25.275 (περίλυπος, 'very sad, deeply distressed')
  • Septuagint: Gen 4:6; Ps 41(42):6, 12
  • Synoptic parallels: Mark 10:22; Matt 19:22
  • Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (Luke 18:24)
  • Joel B. Green, The Gospel of Luke (NICNT)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament (Luke 18:18–30)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).