Matthew Chapter 16 Read as one passage

Matthew 16:1–8

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

1Then the Pharisees and Sadducees came and tested Jesus by asking Him to show them a sign from heaven. 2But He replied, “When evening comes, you say, ‘The weather will be fair, for the sky is red,’ 3and in the morning, ‘Today it will be stormy, for the sky is red and overcast.’ You know how to interpret the appearance of the sky, but not the signs of the times. 4A wicked and adulterous generation demands a sign, but none will be given it except the sign of Jonah.” Then He left them and went away. 5When they crossed to the other side, the disciples forgot to take bread. 6“Watch out!” Jesus told them. “Beware of the leaven of the Pharisees and Sadducees.” 7They discussed this among themselves and concluded, “It is because we did not bring any bread.” 8Aware of their conversation, Jesus said, “You of little faith, why are you debating among yourselves about having no bread?

What the first hearers heard

Matthew's first readers were most likely Jewish followers of Jesus in the decades after AD 70, living in tension with synagogue leaders. They would have heard several things in this verse:

  • The leadership is united against Jesus. Rivals who agreed on little else (Pharisees and Sadducees) join in opposing him. This prepares for Jesus' warning about the 'leaven' of both (16:6–12) and for the alliance of authorities in the passion story.
  • This is the wilderness story repeated. After a miraculous feeding in a desert place, people demand a sign and so 'test' God's messenger. Listeners steeped in the Torah and the Psalms would recall Massah ('testing') and Israel asking, 'Can God spread a table in the wilderness?' (Ps 78:19). That generation was remembered as a warning.
  • This is the devil's test again. The same verb was used of Satan, who urged Jesus to make God act in a visible display (4:5–7). Jesus refused then with Deut 6:16, and he refuses again here. He will not perform proof on demand.
  • God's credentials are not provided on human terms. The only sign offered is 'the sign of Jonah' (16:4), which Matthew elsewhere ties to the Son of Man's three days and nights in the earth (12:40). The decisive sign will be his death and vindication, not a portent staged for his critics.

From the study of Matthew 16:1.

Verse by verse

  1. 1Then the Pharisees and Sadducees came and tested Jesus by asking Him to show them a sign from heaven.

    Then the Pharisees and the Sadducees came up to Jesus. These two parties usually agreed on very little: one was a popular movement of Torah experts, the other the priestly aristocracy of the Jerusalem temple. Now they acted together. They came to put him to the test, not to learn from him. Their aim was to force a public trial they expected him to fail. Matthew uses the same verb for the devil in the wilderness, and it recalls Israel 'testing God' at Massah by demanding proof of his presence. They pressed him to put on display, for them, a sign out of heaven. They did not want another healing, which could be explained away. They wanted an unmistakable public credential: a portent in the sky, coming so plainly from God himself that no one could deny it. It had to be staged on request, for their inspection and approval. The request comes straight after Jesus has fed four thousand people. The word 'heaven' also meant 'sky,' and that sets up his reply: they can read the colours of the sky to forecast the weather, but they cannot read the signs of what God is doing in front of them.

    Full study →
  2. 2But He replied, “When evening comes, you say, ‘The weather will be fair, for the sky is red,’

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  3. 3and in the morning, ‘Today it will be stormy, for the sky is red and overcast.’ You know how to interpret the appearance of the sky, but not the signs of the times.

    The Pharisees and Sadducees have come to test Jesus by demanding a sign from heaven (16:1). Jesus answers with weather lore everyone knew. At dusk you say, “Fair weather, for the sky is fiery red.” And at dawn you say, “Storm today! The sky is fiery red, and scowling.” The same red sky means opposite things depending on when you see it, and they know how to tell which.

    “The face of the sky you know how to read, sorting one sign from another. But the signs of the moment — the decisive season God has brought about, happening right in front of you — can you not read them?”

    The word for “sky” is also the word for “heaven.” They wanted a sign from heaven, and Jesus tells them they are already expert readers of the heavens, at least for weather. The “signs” they cannot read are plural and already present: in Matthew's story, the healings and the feeding of thousands just described (15:29–39). The word for “times” (kairos) does not mean history in general or a distant future. It means the critical, appointed moment, this moment. The rebuke contrasts “you know how” with “you are not able”. They have the skill. They will not apply it to what matters.

    Full study →
  4. 4A wicked and adulterous generation demands a sign, but none will be given it except the sign of Jonah.” Then He left them and went away.

    "This evil, adulterous breed of people, unfaithful to God the way a wife is unfaithful to her husband, keeps on demanding a sign: a heaven-sent proof that I speak for God. No such sign will be given to her by God. There is one exception: the sign of Jonah." Then he turned his back on them and walked away.

    Several things sit inside these few words:

    • "Generation" means more than the people alive at the time. It recalls the wilderness generation who saw God's wonders and still kept testing him (Deuteronomy 1:35; 32:5, 20; Psalm 95:10).
    • "Adulterous" is the prophets' marriage picture of Israel betraying God (Hosea, Jeremiah, Ezekiel). The charge is broken loyalty, not sexual scandal.
    • "Sign" appears three times, building to the point: they want a sign, they will get no sign, except one.
    • "Will be given" is a way of saying God gives signs, and God will not perform on demand.
    • "The sign of Jonah" is not explained here. Matthew's reader already knows from 12:40–41 what it means: like Jonah, Jesus will come back after three days, and like Nineveh, the hearers are called to repent.
    • "Having left them, he went away" turns the refusal into an action. Jesus turns his back on those who came only to test him.
    Full study →
  5. 5When they crossed to the other side, the disciples forgot to take bread.

    And when the disciples had crossed over to the far shore of the lake, it turned out they had forgotten to bring any loaves along.

    The verse is a small scene-setter, but Matthew chose it carefully. Jesus has just turned his back on the Pharisees and Sadducees, who demanded a sign, and left them (16:4). Now his own students are alone with him after a boat crossing on the Sea of Galilee, and they find they have no food. "Bread" here is plural, loaves: the flat round loaves that made up an ordinary meal. Forgetting them meant they had nothing to eat on the trip.

    The irony is the point. In the last two chapters these same men watched Jesus feed five thousand with five loaves and four thousand with seven, and both times they gathered baskets of leftovers. Now they are worried about having no loaves. The verb "forgot" is ordinary, but it prepares for Jesus' question a few lines later: "Do you not remember the five loaves…?" (16:9). Forgetting bread becomes a picture of forgetting what Jesus has done. It also sets up the next line, where Jesus warns about the "leaven" (the yeast) of the Pharisees and Sadducees, and the disciples, with bread on their minds, take him literally.

    Full study →
  6. 6“Watch out!” Jesus told them. “Beware of the leaven of the Pharisees and Sadducees.”

    The disciples have crossed the lake and realised they forgot to bring bread. Jesus says to them: "Keep your eyes open, and keep guarding yourselves against the leaven of the Pharisees and Sadducees."

    The two commands mean almost the same thing and are stacked on purpose. Both are ongoing: stay alert, keep on guard. This is not a single shout of alarm.

    "Leaven" is not packet yeast. It is a lump of old, soured dough kept back from the last baking and kneaded into the new batch. It is small and invisible once mixed in, and it slowly works through and changes the whole loaf. Every Jewish household knew it as the thing that had to be searched out and cleared from the house before Passover.

    Jesus picks this kitchen image just after the disciples' worry about bread. He is warning them about an influence that could get inside them without their noticing. That influence belongs to two rival groups: the popular, tradition-keeping Pharisees and the priestly, temple-centred Sadducees. Matthew groups them under one article as a single front, because they have just jointly tested Jesus by demanding a sign from heaven (16:1–4).

    The disciples miss the point and think he is talking about bread (v. 7). After Jesus rebukes them, Matthew makes the meaning plain: the leaven is "the teaching of the Pharisees and Sadducees" (v. 12).

    Full study →
  7. 7They discussed this among themselves and concluded, “It is because we did not bring any bread.”

    But they — instead of asking Jesus what he meant — kept talking it over among themselves, going back and forth, and what they came up with was: "It's because we didn't bring any loaves."

    Jesus has just warned them to "watch out for the leaven of the Pharisees and Sadducees" (v. 6). Leaven was the bit of old fermented dough that works its way through a whole batch, and it was a familiar picture for an influence that spreads unseen. The disciples hear "leaven", think "bread", and remember that they forgot to pack any (v. 5). So they decide the remark must be about their lapse. Perhaps they think it is a rebuke, or a hint that they should not buy bread from those groups.

    The Greek lets their words be read in two ways: as a guess about Jesus' reason ("He said that because we brought no loaves") or as an anxious exclamation ("We didn't bring any loaves!"). In both cases the irony is the same. Men who had just twice watched Jesus feed thousands from a handful of loaves (14:13–21; 15:32–39) are now huddled together worrying about loaves. The verb for their talk, the one the Gospels often use for people reasoning their way to the wrong conclusion, prepares for Jesus' reply: "You of little faith, why are you debating among yourselves about having no bread?"

    Full study →
  8. 8Aware of their conversation, Jesus said, “You of little faith, why are you debating among yourselves about having no bread?

    The disciples have crossed the lake and realise they forgot to bring bread (v. 5). Jesus warns them, "Watch out for the leaven of the Pharisees and Sadducees," and they start murmuring to one another: he must be saying this because we didn't bring any loaves. Jesus notices, perhaps from overhearing them in the small boat, perhaps by knowing their thoughts; Matthew does not say which. He cuts in:

    "Why are you going round and round about this among yourselves, you who trust so little, about the fact that you have no loaves?"

    The question is a rebuke, not a request for information. The word he calls them, oligopistoi, means "little-trusters". It assumes they do trust him, and says that trust has shrunk to the size of an empty bread basket. These men had just seen five loaves feed five thousand and seven loaves feed four thousand (14:13–21; 15:32–39). Their worry is wrong in two ways at once: they doubt he can provide bread, and they are so taken up with bread that they miss what he meant by "leaven", which was the teaching of the religious leaders (v. 12). The next verses press the point: "Do you still not understand? Do you not remember the five loaves…?"

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v1

    tempting (KJV)

    peirazontes

    What we hear
    Trying to lure Jesus into doing something sinful.
    What they heard
    Putting him to a hostile test: probing him so as to expose him or discredit him publicly.
  • in v1

    heaven

    ouranos

    What we hear
    The afterlife realm where the saved go.
    What they heard
    The sky, and also God's dwelling or God himself. A 'sign from heaven' is a portent in the sky with God unmistakably as its author.
  • in v1, v6

    Pharisees

    Pharisaioi

    What we hear
    Self-righteous hypocrites; legalistic villains by definition.
    What they heard
    A respected, popular movement of careful interpreters of the Torah. They were Jesus' real conversation partners and here also his opponents.
  • in v3

    the signs of the times

    ta sēmeia tōn kairōn

    What we hear
    Current events (wars, disasters, moral decline, politics) read as clues that the end of the world is near, or simply society's general trends.
    What they heard
    The indications of the decisive moment God has brought about, here the present season of Jesus' ministry, already visible to the people he is speaking to.
  • in v4

    adulterous

    moichalis

    What we hear
    Guilty of sexual affairs, or sexually immoral in general.
    What they heard
    The prophets' figure for a people who have broken their covenant loyalty to God, pictured as an unfaithful wife. The charge is religious betrayal, not sexual conduct.
  • in v4

    sign

    sēmeion

    What we hear
    A personal message or nudge from God that guides a decision ("I asked God for a sign").
    What they heard
    A public proof that confirms a messenger's claim to speak for God; here a heaven-sent proof of Jesus' authority, demanded as a test.
  • in v4

    generation

    genea

    What we hear
    An age group or cohort (millennials, Gen Z).
    What they heard
    The whole people of that time, seen as a family line with a shared character, and echoing the rebellious wilderness generation of Israel.
  • in v5

    bread

    artous (plural of artos)

    What we hear
    A side item or a sliced loaf, something one might do without on a trip.
    What they heard
    Loaves, the basic food of a meal. Without them the group had no provisions. The plural also echoes the multiplied loaves of the two feeding miracles just narrated.
  • in v6

    yeast (NIV, NLT, WEB)

    zymē

    What we hear
    Dried commercial yeast from a packet: a neutral ingredient, bought fresh each time.
    What they heard
    Sourdough leaven: a lump of old fermented dough saved from the previous batch and worked into new dough, where it spreads unseen through the whole. It was culturally loaded, because it had to be purged at Passover, and it worked as a familiar picture of something small that quietly takes over.
  • in v7

    reasoned among themselves (KJV)

    dielogizonto en heautois

    What we hear
    They thought it through logically and carefully.
    What they heard
    They kept talking it over among themselves, going round in circles. The Gospels typically use this verb for people puzzling their way to a wrong or suspicious conclusion.
  • in v8

    of little faith

    oligopistoi

    What we hear
    Either not believing the right doctrines firmly enough, or not having enough spiritual "faith power" to make bread (or blessings) appear.
    What they heard
    Trusting Jesus too little: real but shrunken reliance on his care and provision, which gives way under ordinary pressure (no food, a storm). Matthew reserves the word for disciples, never for unbelievers.
  • in v8

    reason (KJV "why reason ye")

    dialogizesthe

    What we hear
    Thinking carefully and logically, which sounds like a good thing.
    What they heard
    Talking it over, debating back and forth. In context, a group discussion going round in circles on the wrong question.
Every word
  1. Καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v1, v3, v4, v5, v6

    A simple linking 'and' that moves the story on from Jesus' arrival at Magadan (15:39). It sets this confrontation right after the feeding of the four thousand.

  2. προσελθόντες

    proselthontes · G4334

    to come up to, approach · v1

    'Having come up to him.' This is one of Matthew's favourite verbs. He uses it for sick people and disciples who come to Jesus in need, and also for opponents who come to challenge him (19:3, 22:23). Here the approach is a formal challenge.

  3. οἱ

    hoi · G3588

    the · v1, v3, v4, v5, v6, v7, v8

    'The.' A single article covers both groups ('the Pharisees-and-Sadducees'), so Matthew presents them as one front against Jesus.

  4. Φαρισαῖοι

    Pharisaioi · G5330

    Pharisee · v1, v6

    Members of a popular lay movement devoted to careful observance of the Torah and the inherited 'traditions of the elders' (15:2). They were Jesus' most frequent conversation partners and critics in Galilee.

  5. Σαδδουκαῖοι

    Saddoukaioi · G4523

    Sadducee · v1, v6

    The priestly and aristocratic party tied to the Jerusalem temple. They rejected the Pharisees' oral traditions and denied the resurrection (22:23; Acts 23:8). Their presence in Galilee alongside the Pharisees signals that the official leadership as a whole is now lined up against Jesus.

  6. πειράζοντες

    peirazontes · G3985

    to test, put to the proof, try · v1

    'Testing' or 'putting him to the test.' The present participle gives the purpose and attitude behind the question. They are not honestly enquiring. They are probing for failure, hoping to expose him or discredit him. It is the same verb Matthew used for the devil in the wilderness (4:1, 3).

  7. ἐπηρώτησαν

    epērōtēsan · G1905

    to ask, question, request · v1

    'They asked' or 'they questioned.' Followed by an infinitive, as here, it works as a request or demand: they asked him to do something. The KJV's 'desired' catches this sense of request.

  8. αὐτὸν

    auton · G0846

    him · v1, v4, v5, v6, v8

    'Him,' that is, Jesus, the one being questioned and tested.

  9. σημεῖον

    sēmeion · G4592

    sign, token, portent · v1, v3, v4

    A visible proof that confirms a claim. In this setting it is a public, God-given credential to authenticate Jesus as a messenger from God. They do not mean simply another healing or exorcism.

  10. ἐκ

    ek · G1537

    out of, from · v1

    'Out of.' It marks the source and origin of the sign: something coming from the sky and from God, not from Jesus' own hands.

  11. οὐρανοῦ

    ouranou · G3772

    sky, heaven · v1, v3

    Both 'sky' and 'heaven' as God's dwelling. Jews often used the word as a respectful way of saying 'God' (compare 21:25, 'from heaven or from men?'). Jesus' reply in vv. 2–3 plays on the 'sky' sense: you can read the sky's weather signs but not the signs of the times.

  12. ἐπιδεῖξαι

    epideixai · G1925

    to show, display, demonstrate · v1

    'To put on display' or 'to exhibit.' The word suggests a public demonstration offered as proof, a staged showing for their inspection.

  13. πρωΐ

    prōi · G4404

    early, in the morning · v3

    Early morning, around sunrise. It answers “when evening comes” in verse 2: people read the sky at both ends of the day.

  14. σήμερον

    sēmeron · G4594

    today · v3

    “Today.” The forecast is about the next few hours. Ordinary people can read what is about to happen to them.

  15. χειμών

    cheimōn · G5494

    winter; stormy weather · v3

    Here it means foul, stormy weather, not the season. The saying is clipped, with no verb: “Today, a storm!” It sounds like something people really said.

  16. πυρράζει

    purrazei · G4449

    to be fiery red · v3

    “Is fiery red,” from the word for fire (pyr). It is the same verb used for the evening sky in verse 2, so the same sign means fair weather at dusk and a storm at dawn. Reading it rightly depends on knowing when you are looking.

  17. γὰρ

    gar · G1063

    for, because · v3

    Gives the reason for the forecast. This is reasoning from evidence, not a guess.

  18. στυγνάζων

    stugnazōn · G4768

    to be gloomy, to look sullen · v3

    “Scowling” or “lowering.” The word is normally used of a gloomy human face (Mark 10:22, of the rich man whose face fell). The sky is pictured with a frowning face, which prepares for “the face of the sky” in the next sentence.

  19. μὲν

    men · G3303

    on the one hand · v3

    Opens a balanced contrast that is finished by “but” (de): on the one hand the sky, on the other the times.

  20. πρόσωπον

    prosōpon · G4383

    face, appearance · v3

    Literally “face.” It continues the picture of the scowling sky. They can read the sky's expression as easily as a neighbour's frown.

  21. γινώσκετε

    ginōskete · G1097

    you know · v3, v8

    “You know how,” meaning you have the practical skill. Jesus grants that they are competent observers, which makes what follows sharper.

  22. διακρίνειν

    diakrinein · G1252

    to distinguish, judge, assess · v3

    To tell one thing from another and weigh evidence. In other forms the verb can mean “to doubt,” but here it is the active sense: sorting out what the signs mean.

  23. δὲ

    de · G1161

    but · v3, v6, v7, v8

    Finishes the contrast begun with men: “but the signs…”

  24. καιρῶν

    kairōn · G2540

    (appointed, decisive) time, season · v3

    “Times” in the sense of decisive moments or God's appointed season, not stretches of history. It points to the moment they are living in, when God is acting.

  25. οὐ

    ou · G3756

    not · v3, v4, v7, v8

    Plain negation of “you are able.”

  26. δύνασθε

    dunasthe · G1410

    you are able · v3

    “Can you not?” It is set against “you know how.” They have the skill but do not use it on what matters. That suggests unwillingness more than lack of ability.

  27. γενεὰ

    genea · G1074

    generation, kind, brood · v4

    The people of Jesus' own day, seen as a single family line with a shared character. Put first in the sentence, it echoes the wilderness generation of Israel that tested God and was condemned.

  28. πονηρὰ

    ponēra · G4190

    evil, wicked, bad · v4

    Morally bad and actively harmful. It is the same adjective Matthew uses for "the evil one", and it recalls Moses' "this evil generation" (Deuteronomy 1:35).

  29. μοιχαλὶς

    moichalis · G3428

    adulteress; adulterous · v4

    Literally "adulteress", used here as an adjective. This is the prophets' picture of Israel as a wife who has betrayed her husband, God. The charge is broken covenant loyalty, not mainly sexual misconduct.

  30. ἐπιζητεῖ·

    epizētei · G1934

    seek after, demand, insist on · v4

    A strengthened "seek": they want it badly and keep on wanting it. The present tense describes an ongoing habit, not one request. "Demands" (BSB) catches the pressure.

  31. δοθήσεται

    dothēsetai · G1325

    will be given · v4

    Future passive with no named giver. Jewish speech often used this form to refer to God without naming him: God is the one who gives or withholds signs, and he will not perform on their terms.

  32. εἰ

    ei · G1487

    if · v4

    First half of the phrase "if not", meaning "except".

  33. μὴ

    mē · G3361

    not · v4

    Together with εἰ it means "except". It brings in the single exception.

  34. Ἰωνᾶ

    Iōna · G2495

    Jonah · v4

    The prophet sent to Nineveh, who came out of the great fish after three days and whose preaching made a pagan city repent. Matthew 12:40–41 has already explained both sides of this sign to the reader.

  35. προφήτου.

    prophētou · G4396

    prophet · v4

    Found only in some editions: "Jonah the prophet", probably borrowed from Matthew 12:39.

  36. καταλιπὼν

    katalipōn · G2641

    leave behind, abandon · v4

    Stronger than just "leaving": he leaves them behind and walks away from them. The same phrase comes back in 21:17, when Jesus walks away from the temple authorities.

  37. ἀπῆλθεν.

    apēlthen · G0565

    went away, departed · v4

    He goes away. The refusal is acted out as well as spoken: there is nothing more to say to them.

  38. ἐλθόντες

    elthontes · G2064

    to come, to go · v5

    "Having come / having gone." The aorist participle (a verb form that presents the action as one whole event) sets the scene: the crossing of the lake. The verb can mean either "arrive" or "set out", so it is debated whether the forgetting is discovered on arrival or as they leave.

  39. μαθηταὶ

    mathētai · G3101

    disciple, learner, apprentice · v5

    Jesus' committed students, who follow him around, live with him and are trained by him. The subject of the sentence, and the people whose slow understanding the next verses expose.

  40. εἰς

    eis · G1519

    into, to, toward · v5

    Marks the direction of travel: to the far shore.

  41. πέραν

    peran · G4008

    beyond, on the other side · v5

    "The far side" of the Sea of Galilee. Matthew does not name the lake, since the boat trip from Magadan (15:39) makes it obvious.

  42. ἐπελάθοντο

    epelathonto · G1950

    to forget, to neglect · v5

    "They forgot." A plain, everyday oversight: nobody remembered to bring provisions. In Greek the aorist can stand for an action already completed earlier, so "they had forgotten" (KJV, WEB) is a fair rendering.

  43. ἄρτους

    artous · G0740

    bread, loaf; food · v5, v7, v8

    Plural: "loaves", the flat round loaves that were the basic food of a meal. Forgetting bread meant forgetting food for the trip, and this sets up Jesus' saying about "leaven" in 16:6.

  44. λαβεῖν

    labein · G2983

    to take, to receive · v5, v7

    "To take (along)." Here it means bringing provisions with them, not receiving something.

  45. Ἰησοῦς

    Iēsous · G2424

    Jesus (Joshua) · v6, v8

    The Greek form of the Hebrew Yeshua/Yehoshua, a common Jewish name. Here he is the subject who speaks.

  46. εἶπεν

    eipen · G2036

    said · v6, v8

    Plain past tense of 'say', reporting a single statement. Nothing special about the verb itself.

  47. ὁρᾶτε

    horate · G3708

    see, look, watch out · v6

    A present-tense command, so it means 'keep looking, stay alert' rather than 'take one look'. Used as a warning, as in English 'Look out!'

  48. προσέχετε

    prosechete · G4337

    pay attention, be on guard · v6

    Another ongoing command. With 'from' (apo) after it, it means 'guard yourselves against', keeping steady watch so that something does not get to you.

  49. ἀπὸ

    apo · G575

    from, away from · v6

    Marks what the disciples are to keep away from. 'Guard yourself from' is a Jewish-Greek idiom that echoes the Septuagint (the Greek Old Testament).

  50. ζύμης

    zymēs · G2219

    leaven, sourdough · v6

    A lump of old fermented dough saved from an earlier batch and kneaded into new dough so that it rises. The picture is a small hidden thing that slowly works through the whole. Matthew 16:12 says it stands for the 'teaching' of these groups.

  51. διελογίζοντο

    dielogizonto · G1260

    to reason, deliberate, discuss · v7, v8

    The imperfect tense pictures a discussion that kept going: "they were talking it over" or "they began debating". In the Gospels this verb usually describes people puzzling over something and getting it wrong, or questioning in a muddled or suspicious way. It is not careful logic.

  52. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in, among · v7, v8

    With a plural reflexive pronoun it means "among". The talk happened inside the group of disciples and Jesus was not part of it.

  53. ἑαυτοῖς

    heautois · G1438

    themselves · v7, v8

    "Among themselves". Mark's parallel (8:16) says "with one another", which confirms that this was a conversation between them and not private thoughts. Jesus still overhears or perceives it in verse 8.

  54. λέγοντες

    legontes · G3004

    saying · v7

    A participle that introduces what they said. It gives the content of their debate.

  55. ὅτι

    hoti · G3754

    that, because · v7, v8

    This word can be read two ways. It may simply open a quotation (like quotation marks: "We brought no bread!"), or it may mean "because" ("He said that because we brought no bread"). Both readings are possible in Greek, and translations divide over it.

  56. Τί

    Ti · G5101

    what? why? · v8

    "Why?" The question is rhetorical. Jesus is not asking for information but exposing how pointless their worry is.

  57. ὀλιγόπιστοι

    oligopistoi · G3640

    of little faith, little-trusting · v8

    A form of address: "you little-trusters". The word grants that they do trust him, but say their trust shrinks the moment a practical worry (bread) comes up. Matthew uses it for disciples who falter, never for outsiders.

  58. ἔχετε

    echete · G2192

    to have · v8

    "You have", in the present tense: their current lack. Later manuscripts read "you took", echoing the disciples' own words in v. 7.

The world behind it

Where and when. Jesus has just fed four thousand people in a mostly non-Jewish area (15:29–38) and crossed by boat to 'Magadan' (15:39). The place is uncertain. It may be connected with Magdala on the western shore of the Sea of Galilee, and Mark 8:10 calls it 'Dalmanutha.' This is the second request for a sign in Matthew. In 12:38 'scribes and Pharisees' asked, and Jesus offered only 'the sign of Jonah.' He gives the same answer here (16:4).

Two rival parties. According to Josephus, Pharisees and Sadducees disagreed sharply about resurrection, fate and free will, and the authority of oral tradition (Ant. 13.297–298; 18.11–17). Sadducees were centred in Jerusalem and the temple, so their appearance in Galilee with Pharisees suggests a coordinated challenge from the whole leadership. Matthew pairs them here and in 3:7 and 16:6–12.

Why ask for a sign? Asking for a sign was not wrong in itself in Israel's tradition. Gideon and Hezekiah asked for signs, and Isaiah offered one to Ahaz 'as high as heaven' (Isa 7:11). Deuteronomy gave Israel tests for telling true prophets from false ones (Deut 13:1–5; 18:21–22). In the first century, popular prophets promised dramatic signs to prove that God was about to act. Josephus mentions Theudas, who promised to part the Jordan, and an Egyptian prophet who promised that Jerusalem's walls would fall (Ant. 20.97–99, 167–172). Most of these movements ended in Roman massacres. So a demand for a 'sign from heaven' was a familiar way to test anyone claiming to speak for God. What makes this request hostile, in Matthew's telling, is the motive he names: testing.

Echo of the wilderness. The order of events matters. A miraculous feeding in a deserted place is followed by a demand for a sign. This follows the pattern of Israel in the wilderness, who were fed with manna yet asked, 'Is the LORD among us or not?' (Exod 17:7) and 'tested God in their heart' (Ps 78:18–20). John 6:30–31 shows the same pattern, where after a feeding the crowd demands a sign and cites the manna 'from heaven.'

From the study of Matthew 16:1.

Where scholars differ

in v1

Did Pharisees and Sadducees really act together here, or is the pairing Matthew's way of grouping Jesus' opponents?

  • A real ad hoc alliance: rival parties cooperated against a shared threat.

    Mark also records unlikely partnerships, such as Pharisees with Herodians (Mark 3:6; 12:13). Both groups sat on the Jerusalem council (Acts 23:6), so joint action against a popular figure is plausible.

  • A literary grouping by Matthew, who presents the whole Jewish leadership as one front.

    Mark 8:11 names only Pharisees, and Matthew adds the Sadducees. Matthew pairs them under one article and even speaks of a single 'teaching of the Pharisees and Sadducees' (16:12), though their teachings differed sharply (Josephus, Ant. 18.11–17). Writing after AD 70, when the Sadducees had largely disappeared, Matthew may be using the two names together to stand for the leadership in general.

in v1

What exactly is a 'sign from heaven'?

  • A cosmic portent in the sky, such as fire, a voice, or a heavenly phenomenon.

    *Ouranos* commonly means 'sky.' Jesus' reply about reading the sky (vv. 2–3, if original) assumes this sense. There are precedents such as Elijah's fire from heaven (1 Kgs 18:38) and manna 'from heaven' (Exod 16:4).

  • A sign whose source is God, with 'heaven' standing for God, whatever form the sign takes.

    Jews commonly used 'heaven' as a respectful substitute for God's name, and Matthew does so himself ('kingdom of heaven'; 'from heaven or from men?' in 21:25). The point would then be undeniable divine authorship rather than location.

  • Both senses together.

    The two senses overlapped naturally in Greek and Hebrew. Many commentators (e.g. Davies & Allison, France) see a deliberate double meaning that Jesus exploits in his weather saying.

in v3

Did Matthew write 16:2b–3, or was it added by later scribes?

  • Added later (interpolation)

    Missing from Sinaiticus, Vaticanus, the Old Syriac, most Coptic copies and Origen. Jerome knew many manuscripts without it. Verse 4 follows naturally after 2a. A similar saying exists in Luke 12:54–56.

  • Original, omitted in some copies

    Supported by early and diverse witnesses (D, W, the Old Latin, the Peshitta). The wording is unlike Luke's, so it was not simply copied from there. Egyptian scribes may have dropped a weather saying that did not fit their climate.

in v3

What are “the signs of the times”?

  • Jesus' own ministry: healings, feedings, his teaching and presence

    The immediate context (15:29–39). Matt 11:4–6 points to Jesus' deeds as the answer to the question “are you the one?” Luke's parallel reads “this present time.”

  • Also the coming crisis and judgment on that generation

    Kairos is often used for times of God's visitation and judgment. Verse 4 condemns “a wicked and adulterous generation.” Compare Luke 19:41–44 and the Temple's destruction foretold in Matt 23–24.

in v4

What is "the sign of Jonah"?

  • Jesus' death and resurrection after three days, like Jonah's return from the fish.

    Matthew's own explanation in 12:40 ("three days and three nights in the heart of the earth"). Matthew's readers would carry that explanation over to 16:4, and Jesus' first open prediction of his death and rising on the third day follows a few verses later (16:21).

  • Jonah himself and his call to repent: the prophet and his message are the only sign.

    Luke 11:30 ("Jonah became a sign to the Ninevites") and Matthew 12:41 (the Ninevites repented at Jonah's preaching), where no miracle is mentioned. On this view the sign is the call to repent and the threat of judgement, not a wonder.

  • Both together: Jesus, vindicated by God and preaching repentance, is himself the sign.

    Many commentators (e.g. Davies & Allison, France) see Matthew combining the resurrection reading (12:40) with the preaching-and-repentance reading (12:41–42), and note that within the scene of 16:4 the saying is left as an unexplained riddle.

in v4

Is "adulterous" literal or figurative here?

  • Figurative: covenant unfaithfulness to God, in the prophets' tradition.

    The Septuagint uses μοιχαλίς for unfaithful Israel/Jerusalem (Hosea 3:1; Ezekiel 16:38; 23:45). The pairing with "generation" echoes Deuteronomy 32, and James 4:4 uses the same word figuratively. Nothing in the context is about sexual conduct. This is the view of almost all commentators.

  • Mainly figurative, but possibly also hinting at real moral laxity, for example over divorce.

    A minority note Jesus' strict teaching on divorce and adultery (Matthew 5:27–32; 19:3–9) and suggest the word may have had a secondary literal edge. There is no direct support for this in 16:1–4.

in v5

Did the disciples discover the missing bread on arrival, or while setting out and crossing?

  • On arrival. Matthew places the discovery and conversation on the far shore.

    ἐλθόντες εἰς τὸ πέραν most naturally means "having arrived at the other side." The aorist participle usually describes an action completed before the main verb. Matthew drops Mark's reference to the boat, possibly on purpose. This is the reading behind ESV, KJV and NLT.

  • While going. ἔρχομαι here means "go/set out," so the scene can still take place in the boat as in Mark.

    ἔρχομαι can mean "go" as well as "come," and the NIV's "went across the lake" reflects this. It fits Mark 8:14-21, where the dialogue happens on board with "one loaf." Some commentators read Matthew's phrase loosely as summarizing the trip as a whole.

in v6

What exactly is the 'leaven' Jesus warns against?

  • Their teaching or doctrine.

    Matthew's own explanation in 16:12, 'the teaching (didachē) of the Pharisees and Sadducees'. Matthew 15:1–14 has just criticised Pharisaic tradition.

  • Their hypocrisy, the gap between outward piety and inner reality.

    Luke 12:1 says so explicitly, and Matthew 23 attacks hypocrisy at length. Matthew's own wording in 16:12 points to teaching, though.

  • The unbelieving attitude behind their demand for a sign: refusing to recognise God at work in Jesus.

    The direct context (16:1–4, the sign demand) and Mark 8:11–21, where the leaven saying also follows a sign demand and is unexplained. Many commentators see teaching and disposition as closely bound together here.

in v6

Why does Matthew pair the rival Pharisees and Sadducees?

  • Historical: both groups really did cooperate against Jesus at points.

    Joint opposition to a common threat was possible. Both groups sat on the Jerusalem council (Acts 23:6).

  • Literary and theological: Matthew combines them as a stock pairing for the religious leadership opposed to Jesus.

    Mark's parallel has 'Herod'. Sadducees were based in Jerusalem and are unlikely to have been active in Galilee. Matthew also pairs them in 3:7 and 16:1, 11, 12. Their real doctrinal differences make a single shared 'teaching' hard to pin down, which suggests Matthew is speaking of the leadership in general.

in v7

Does ὅτι mean "because" or does it simply introduce the quotation?

  • Causal: "(He says this) because we brought no loaves." The disciples are guessing at Jesus' reason for the warning.

    This fits the logic of the scene: they are working out why Jesus mentioned leaven. It is followed by the KJV, BSB, NIV and NASB, and the Vulgate's quia allows it.

  • Introducing the quotation: "We brought no loaves!" It is an anxious exclamation.

    Hoti is very often used this way in the Gospels. Mark's parallel (8:16) reports the same content as "that they had no bread", and Jesus' reply in v. 8 ("debating … that you have no bread") treats the content as the bare fact of having none. Followed by the WEB and ESV.

in v7

What did the disciples think Jesus meant by connecting leaven to their lack of bread?

  • They heard a rebuke for forgetting the bread.

    Verse 5 has just reported the forgetting. Their response turns on their own failure ("we took no loaves").

  • They took it as a practical instruction not to obtain bread from Pharisees or Sadducees.

    The warning is phrased as "leaven of" those groups, and bread had to be acquired somewhere on the far shore. Questions about clean food were live ones in first-century Judaism. This is an inference, since the text does not state it.

  • Matthew leaves it unspecified. The point is only that they took a figure of speech literally.

    Jesus' answer (vv. 8–11) does not correct a particular theory. It rebukes their focus on literal bread at all and reminds them of the two feedings.

in v8

Did Jesus know their discussion supernaturally, or simply overhear it?

  • Supernatural knowledge of their thoughts.

    Matthew elsewhere says Jesus "knew their thoughts" (9:4; 12:25), and the parallel pattern in Mark 2:8 explicitly says "in his spirit".

  • Ordinary perception; he overheard or noticed.

    *Gnous* itself only means "perceiving". Verse 7 says they were "saying" things among themselves in a small boat, and Matthew uses *gnous* in 22:18 and 26:10 where ordinary observation is enough.

in v8

What exactly is the "little faith" being rebuked?

  • Failure to trust Jesus to provide food.

    Verses 9–10 point straight to the two feedings, and Matthew used *oligopistoi* in 6:30 for anxiety about food.

  • Failure to understand his teaching, treating a picture as literal.

    Verse 11 asks "How is it you do not understand that I was not speaking about bread?", and v. 12 ends with them understanding about the teaching.

  • Both together: anxiety about bread is what blocked their understanding.

    The passage moves from v. 8 (worry) to v. 9 (memory) to vv. 11–12 (understanding). Matthew's use of *oligopistos* in 14:31 also links small trust with wavering judgment ("why did you doubt?").

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. πειράζω
  • BDAG s.v. σημεῖον
  • BDAG s.v. οὐρανός
  • BDAG s.v. ἐπιδείκνυμι
  • BDAG s.v. ἐπερωτάω
  • Septuagint: Exod 17:2–7; Deut 6:16; Ps 77(78):18–20, 41, 56; Ps 94(95):9; Isa 7:11
  • Josephus, Antiquities 13.171–173, 297–298; 18.11–17; 20.97–99, 167–172
  • Josephus, Jewish War 2.162–166, 259
  • Babylonian Talmud, Bava Metzia 59b
  • W. D. Davies & D. C. Allison, Matthew (ICC), vol. 2, on 16:1–4
  • R. T. France, The Gospel of Matthew (NICNT), on 16:1–4
  • Ulrich Luz, Matthew 8–20 (Hermeneia), on 16:1–4
  • Craig S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Matt 16:1
  • NA28 critical apparatus on Matt 16:2–3
  • Nestle–Aland, Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed. (apparatus at Matt 16:2–3)
  • Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, 2nd ed., on Matt 16:2b–3
  • BDAG s.v. καιρός
  • BDAG s.v. στυγνάζω
  • BDAG s.v. διακρίνω
  • Theophrastus, De signis (On Weather Signs)
  • Jerome, Commentary on Matthew 16:2–3
  • BDAG s.v. μοιχαλίς, γενεά, σημεῖον, ἐπιζητέω, καταλείπω
  • Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. μοιχαλίς
  • LXX: Hosea 3:1; Ezekiel 16:38; 23:45; Deuteronomy 32:5, 20; Isaiah 7:11; Exodus 4:8–9
  • Josephus, Antiquities 20.97–98, 20.167–168; Jewish War 2.259; Antiquities 9.208–214
  • B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (on Matt 16:2b–3, 4)
  • Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Matt 16:4
  • W. D. Davies & D. C. Allison, Matthew (ICC), on 12:38–42 and 16:1–4
  • R. T. France, The Gospel of Matthew (NICNT)
  • U. Luz, Matthew 8–20 (Hermeneia)
  • C. S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Matt 16:1–4
  • BDAG s.v. ἄρτος, ἐπιλανθάνομαι, μαθητής, πέραν, ἔρχομαι
  • Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. ἐπιλανθάνομαι
  • Nestle-Aland 28th ed. / UBS5 Greek New Testament (apparatus at Matt 16:5)
  • Textus Receptus (Scrivener) at Matt 16:5
  • Vulgate (Stuttgart edition), Matt 16:5
  • Mark 8:14-21 (synoptic parallel)
  • Psalm 78 (LXX 77) on Israel forgetting God's works
  • Craig S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Matt 16:5-12
  • R. T. France, The Gospel of Matthew (NICNT), on 16:5-12
  • Davies & Allison, Matthew (ICC), vol. 2, on 16:5-12
  • BDAG s.v. ζύμη
  • BDAG s.v. προσέχω
  • BDAG s.v. ὁράω
  • Josephus, Antiquities 13.171–173, 297–298; 18.11–17
  • Josephus, Jewish War 2.162–166
  • Philo, Special Laws 1.293
  • Plutarch, Roman Questions 109
  • Babylonian Talmud, Berakhot 17a
  • Davies & Allison, Matthew (ICC), vol. 2, on 16:5–12
  • U. Luz, Matthew 8–20 (Hermeneia), on 16:5–12
  • C. S. Keener, A Commentary on the Gospel of Matthew
  • C. L. Mitton, 'Leaven', Expository Times 84 (1973)
  • BDAG s.v. διαλογίζομαι
  • BDAG s.v. ὅτι
  • Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. διαλογίζομαι
  • Nestle-Aland 28th ed., apparatus at Matt 16:8 and Mark 8:16
  • Plutarch, Roman Questions 109 (leaven as corruption)
  • Exodus 12:15–20; Leviticus 2:11 (leaven in Israelite ritual)
  • W. D. Davies and D. C. Allison, Matthew (ICC), vol. 2
  • Craig S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Matt 16:5–12
  • BDAG s.v. ὀλιγόπιστος
  • BDAG s.v. γινώσκω
  • BDAG s.v. ἄρτος
  • Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. ὀλιγόπιστος
  • Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Matt 16:8
  • Babylonian Talmud, Sotah 48b ("small of faith" saying attributed to R. Eliezer)
  • Mekilta de-Rabbi Ishmael, Vayassa (on Exod 16:4)
  • Davies & Allison, Matthew (ICC), vol. 2, on Matt 16:5–12
  • Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Matt 16:5–12

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.