Daniel Chapter 11 Read as one passage

Daniel 11:31–33

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

31His forces will rise up and desecrate the temple fortress. They will abolish the daily sacrifice and set up the abomination of desolation. 32With flattery he will corrupt those who violate the covenant, but the people who know their God will firmly resist him. 33Those with insight will instruct many, though for a time they will fall by sword or flame, or be captured or plundered.

What the first hearers heard

For Jews in Judea in the 160s BC, this verse named exactly what they were living through or had just seen: foreign troops in Jerusalem, the Temple turned over to another god, the morning and evening lamb no longer offered, and a pagan object standing on the altar.

Within Daniel the verse did several things:

  • It put the horror inside God's knowledge. Daniel 10–12 presents itself as revealed in advance, written in 'the book of truth' (10:21). The desecration is terrible, but it has not taken heaven by surprise. It belongs to a sequence with a set limit (8:14; 12:11–12: 2,300 evenings-and-mornings; 1,290 and 1,335 days).
  • It drew a line through the community. The verses around it split the people into those who 'forsake the holy covenant' and are won over by flattery (vv. 30, 32a) and 'the people who know their God,' who 'stand firm and act' (v. 32b), while the wise teach the many and some die for it (vv. 33–35). Hearing v. 31 meant asking which side one was on.
  • It named the enemy's god with contempt. By calling the cult object shiqquts and, very likely, twisting 'Lord of Heaven' into 'the desolating horror,' the text refused the new god any honour and invited the faithful to share that disgust.
  • It linked the crisis to Israel's earlier history. Detestable things in God's house was the charge Jeremiah and Ezekiel brought before the Babylonian destruction (Jeremiah 7:30; Ezekiel 5:11). Readers would have heard this as the same pattern of sacrilege, now forced on them by a foreign king rather than chosen by Israel.

The verse called for loyalty to the covenant under pressure: do not sacrifice at the new altar, keep faith, and wait for the end God has fixed.

From the study of Daniel 11:31.

Verse by verse

  1. 31His forces will rise up and desecrate the temple fortress. They will abolish the daily sacrifice and set up the abomination of desolation.

    Armed men sent by him will take up their positions. They will strip the holy sanctuary of its holiness, the sanctuary that was the people's stronghold and refuge. They will put a stop to the continual offering, the lamb that was to rise to God every morning and every evening without fail. And in its place they will set up the Detestable Thing: a pagan cult object, a horror that leaves God's house desolate and empty of true worship.

    The king of the north (Antiochus IV in the historical sequence of Daniel 11) does not need to be in Jerusalem himself. His 'arms', meaning his troops, act for him. The attack is on holiness rather than on stones: 'profane' means making the holy common. The 'continual' offering was the never-interrupted heartbeat of Israel's covenant worship, so stopping it is presented as cutting the line between Israel and its God. What replaces it is called by the Bible's sneering word for an idol (shiqquts). The word that follows means both 'appalling' and 'making desolate.' It is probably also a pun on 'Ba'al Shamem,' 'Lord of Heaven,' the Syrian name for the Zeus whose worship was forced into the Temple. In effect the writer turns 'Lord of Heaven' into 'the Horror That Empties.'

    Full study →
  2. 32With flattery he will corrupt those who violate the covenant, but the people who know their God will firmly resist him.

    "Those who have already been doing wrong against the covenant, he will lead the rest of the way into godlessness with smooth words and slippery promises. But a people who know their God, who still acknowledge him as their own and stay loyal to him, will hold firm and act."

    The verse sets two groups within Israel side by side during the persecution under Antiochus IV (167 BC).

    • The first group is put first for emphasis: covenant-wrongdoers, Jews who had already been drifting away from the ancestral law. The king does not need force with them. He uses smoothness: offers of rank as "Friends of the King," gifts, safety, the prestige of Greek culture. The verb is not just "corrupt" in a moral sense. It means make profane, cut off from the holy. Verse 31 described the sanctuary being profaned; here the people are profaned too.
    • The second group is "a people" (no "the" in Hebrew), a group marked out within Israel by one thing: they know their God. In biblical language that is relational and covenantal. It means acknowledging him as your rightful Lord and acting loyally toward him, the way a vassal "knows" his overlord.
    • Their response is two verbs. They will hold strong: keep a firm grip, stand fast, the opposite of the others letting go of the covenant. They will act: no object, no "exploits," just action. In this chapter, "acting" has so far belonged to kings who do whatever they please. Now the faithful act too.

    The next verse shows what their acting looks like. The wise teach the many, and for a time they fall "by sword and flame, captivity and plunder." The verse promises loyalty that will not bend under seduction or violence. It does not promise visible triumph.

    Full study →
  3. 33Those with insight will instruct many, though for a time they will fall by sword or flame, or be captured or plundered.

    "And the people's teachers of insight, the ones God has given understanding, will pass that understanding on to the many. Yet for a period of days they will be made to fall: cut down by the sword, burned in the flames, dragged off as captives, stripped of everything they own."

    The verse holds two things together. The first is a task. A circle of faithful Israelites who understand what God is doing in history (Daniel himself is called one of them in 1:4) will explain it to the wider community, "the many". In the previous verse others are being won over by the tyrant's flattery. These teachers keep the people from being taken in by helping them see what is really happening. The second is a cost. The verb is passive, "they will be made to stumble", and it is the language of warriors falling in battle, not of people losing their faith. The four phrases that follow are a classic list of national disaster: sword, fire, captivity, plunder. Ezra 9:7 uses almost the same words for the punishments of exile. Here those disasters fall on the faithful precisely because they are faithful. The single closing word "days" sets a limit: this lasts for a while. It is not open-ended.

    Behind the wording stands Isaiah's suffering servant, who "acts wisely" and "makes the many righteous" while being struck down (Isa 52:13; 53:11). Daniel 12:3 completes the picture: these same wise ones will "shine like the brightness of the sky… like the stars forever and ever."

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v31

    abomination

    shiqquts

    What we hear
    Any horrifying evil or moral outrage, something monstrous in general.
    What they heard
    A specific detestable cult object: an idol or the paraphernalia of a foreign god, named with contempt. Here, a pagan altar or emblem installed in the Temple.
  • in v31

    of desolation / that maketh desolate

    meshomem

    What we hear
    Large-scale physical destruction, devastation of a city or the world.
    What they heard
    Appalling, horrifying, and leaving the sanctuary deserted or unusable for true worship. Probably also a mocking pun on Ba'al Shamem, 'Lord of Heaven.'
  • in v31

    pollute (KJV)

    chillelu (chalal)

    What we hear
    To dirty or contaminate physically, as with pollution.
    What they heard
    To profane: take something holy and treat it as common, removing its sacred status.
  • in v31

    arms (KJV)

    zero'im

    What we hear
    Weapons.
    What they heard
    'Arms' as in limbs, a picture of power; here, armed forces or troops acting for the king.
  • in v32

    do exploits (KJV)

    ʿasu

    What we hear
    Heroic, even miraculous, achievements; a promise of power and success to those who know God.
    What they heard
    Simply 'they will act / take action.' There is no object. In context it is faithful resistance that the next verse says will cost many their lives.
  • in v32

    flattery / flatteries

    chalaqqot

    What we hear
    Compliments, personal praise.
    What they heard
    'Smoothnesses': smooth, slippery dealing. Promises of rank, wealth and favour, persuasion that makes apostasy feel easy.
  • in v32

    corrupt

    yachanif

    What we hear
    Bribe or make morally decadent.
    What they heard
    Make profane or godless: pull people out of the sphere of the holy into apostasy. A religious term, parallel to the profaning of the sanctuary in 11:31.
  • in v32

    know their God

    yodʿe ʾelohav

    What we hear
    Have correct knowledge or beliefs about God (or, for some, a private inner experience of God).
    What they heard
    Acknowledge him as their own God and stay loyal to him in practice. It is relationship and allegiance, shown in conduct.
  • in v33

    stumble (ESV, YLT)

    nikšəlû (kāšal)

    What we hear
    To slip morally, fall into sin, or lose faith, as in church language about "stumbling".
    What they heard
    To be brought down physically or politically: struck down, defeated, ruined. Here it means falling under persecution, with the means listed: sword, fire, captivity, plunder.
  • in v33

    the wise / those who are wise

    maśkîlê ʿām

    What we hear
    Sensible, mature, experienced people with good judgment.
    What they heard
    A recognizable group of insightful teachers who understand God's hidden purposes in history (as Daniel does through visions and scripture) and who pass that understanding on. The role echoes Isaiah's servant who "acts wisely".
  • in v33

    many days (KJV, WEB, NASB)

    yāmîm

    What we hear
    A long, drawn-out period.
    What they heard
    Plain "days" used as an idiom: "for some time, for a while". The emphasis is on a limited period, not a long one.
Every word
  1. וּזְרֹעִ֖ים

    ūzərōʿîm · H2220

    arm; strength; forces · v31

    Literally 'and arms.' In Hebrew the arm stands for power, and the plural here means armed forces, the troops the king sends. It does not mean weapons.

  2. מִמֶּ֣נּוּ

    mimmennû · H4480

    from him · v31

    'From him': the troops come from the king described in verses 21–30 and act for him. He is behind what they do even when he is not there in person.

  3. יַעֲמֹ֑דוּ

    yaʿămōdû · H5975

    stand; arise; take a position · v31

    'Will stand' or 'will take their stand.' Daniel 11 uses this verb again and again for someone rising to power or taking up a position (11:2–4, 7, 20–21). Here it pictures soldiers stationed in Jerusalem.

  4. וְחִלְּל֞וּ

    wəḥilləlû · H2490

    profane; make common; desecrate · v31

    'And they will profane.' They will strip the sanctuary of its holy status and treat it as ordinary ground. The violation is to its holiness, not dirt on its floors.

  5. הַמִּקְדָּ֤שׁ

    hammiqdāš · H4720

    sanctuary; holy place · v31

    'The sanctuary': the place set apart as holy, here the Jerusalem Temple. The word comes from the same root as 'holy' (q-d-sh), so profaning it attacks its whole reason for existing.

  6. הַמָּעוֹז֙

    hammāʿôz · H4581

    stronghold; fortress; refuge · v31

    'The stronghold' stands beside 'the sanctuary' with no 'and' between them: 'the sanctuary, the fortress.' The walled Temple was a physical stronghold, and in the Psalms God himself is Israel's refuge (ma'oz). The place of refuge is the place violated.

  7. וְהֵסִ֣ירוּ

    wəhēsîrû · H5493

    cause to turn aside; remove; abolish · v31

    'And they will remove': they will take away or put a stop to something, here by decree and by force.

  8. הַתָּמִ֔יד

    hattāmîd · H8548

    continually; the regular (offering) · v31

    'The continual': shorthand for the regular burnt offering of a lamb every morning and every evening (Exodus 29:38–42; Numbers 28:3–8). Ending it breaks the unbroken daily rhythm of Israel's worship.

  9. וְנָתְנ֖וּ

    wənātənû · H5414

    give; put; set up · v31

    'And they will set (up)': they will install something in the place where the regular offering used to stand.

  10. הַשִּׁקּ֥וּץ

    haššiqqûṣ · H8251

    detestable thing; idol · v31

    'The detestable thing.' This is the Bible's regular contemptuous word for a foreign god's image or cult object, as in 'Milcom, the detestable thing of the Ammonites' (1 Kings 11:5). Here it is a pagan object placed in God's Temple.

  11. מְשׁוֹמֵֽם׃

    məšômēm · H8074

    appalling; causing desolation · v31

    'Appalling / making desolate.' The root covers both horror (being appalled) and desolation (a place left empty). The object both shocks the faithful and leaves the sanctuary unusable and deserted by true worshippers. The sound also seems to play on the name of a pagan god (see the studies).

  12. וּמַרְשִׁיעֵ֣י

    u-marshiʿe · H7561

    and those who act wickedly · v32

    A participle (a verb used as a noun) of the causative stem: 'those who do wrong' toward the covenant. In context these are Jews who abandoned the ancestral law and sided with the king's Greek-style reforms. It is placed first for emphasis, setting up the contrast with 'a people' later in the verse.

  13. בְרִ֔ית

    verit · H1285

    covenant · v32

    The covenant between Israel's God and Israel, lived out in the Torah, the temple worship, Sabbath and circumcision. Daniel 11:28 and 11:30 call it 'the holy covenant.' Joined directly to the previous word: 'covenant-wrongdoers.'

  14. יַחֲנִ֖יף

    yachanif · H2610

    he will pollute / make godless · v32

    Causative: 'he will make them profane,' that is, draw them fully into apostasy (abandoning their God). The subject is the king (Antiochus IV). He does not create their disloyalty. He feeds it and finishes it.

  15. בַּחֲלַקּ֑וֹת

    ba-chalaqqot · H2514

    with smooth things, flatteries · v32

    Literally 'with smoothnesses': smooth talk, slippery promises, offers of favour and rank. It echoes 11:21 (he took the kingdom 'by smooth dealings') and 11:34 (insincere joiners).

  16. וְעַ֛ם

    ve-ʿam · H5971A

    and a people · v32, v33

    Without 'the' in Hebrew: 'a people,' a group marked out from within Israel by what follows, set against the covenant-violators.

  17. יֹדְעֵ֥י

    yodʿe · H3045

    knowing · v32

    Participle: those who know, meaning they acknowledge their God and stay loyal to him. It is relational, covenant knowledge, not just information.

  18. אֱלֹהָ֖יו

    ʾelohav · H0430G

    its God · v32

    'Its God' (the people's God), Israel's own God. The possessive matters: they hold on to the God who is theirs while the king demands that they adopt his.

  19. יַחֲזִ֥קוּ

    yachaziqu · H2388K

    they will show strength / hold firm · v32

    Causative-intensive stem: 'they will hold firm, keep a strong grip, stand fast.' Set against those who let go of the covenant, it carries the sense of holding fast to it (compare Isaiah 56:4, 6).

  20. וְעָשֽׂוּ׃

    ve-ʿasu · H6213A

    and they will act · v32

    Simply 'and they will act' or 'take action,' with no object. In Daniel 11 the same verb repeatedly describes kings who 'act' as they please (11:3, 16, 28, 30, 36). Here the faithful also act, but the next verse shows that this includes teaching and dying for the covenant.

  21. וּמַשְׂכִּ֣ילֵי

    ūmaśkîlê · H7919A

    and those who have insight (of) · v33

    A participle of the verb for insight or prudence, used here as a noun: "the insightful ones" or "the wise teachers". In Daniel it names a particular group of faithful people who understand God's purposes and pass that understanding on (compare 12:3, 12:10).

  22. יָבִ֖ינוּ

    yābînû · H0995

    they will make understand · v33

    A causative form: "they will give understanding, cause to discern". The wise ones resist by teaching. They explain to others what is happening and what God is doing. They do not fight with weapons.

  23. לָֽרַבִּ֑ים

    lārabbîm · H7227A

    to the many · v33

    With the article: "the many", meaning the wider body of the people. The phrase echoes Isaiah's servant who "makes the many righteous" (Isa 53:11), and Daniel 12:3 makes that echo explicit.

  24. וְנִכְשְׁל֞וּ

    wənikšəlû · H3782

    and they will stumble / be made to fall · v33

    A passive form, "they will be caused to stumble", in a construction that points to the future. Here it means falling victim to violence: being cut down, burned, taken away. It is not a moral lapse. The four phrases that follow spell out how they fall.

  25. בְּחֶ֧רֶב

    bəḥereb · H2719

    by sword · v33

    Execution and killing by soldiers. "Sword" is the standard first item in biblical lists of disaster.

  26. וּבְלֶהָבָ֛ה

    ûbəlehābâ · H3852

    and by flame · v33

    Death or torture by fire. The related word lahab can mean the gleaming blade of a weapon, so "sword and flame" may carry a faint sound-picture. A reader of Daniel would also recall the furnace in chapter 3.

  27. בִּשְׁבִ֥י

    bišbî · H7628A

    by captivity · v33

    Being taken captive: arrest, deportation, or enslavement of men, women and children.

  28. וּבְבִזָּ֖ה

    ûbəbizzâ · H0961

    and by plunder · v33

    Having one's goods seized as spoil. This is a late-biblical word, paired with "captivity" in Ezra 9:7 and elsewhere as a stock phrase for national catastrophe.

  29. יָמִֽים׃

    yāmîm · H3117G

    days · v33

    Used as a time expression: "for some days, for a time". It stresses that the suffering lasts a while but has an end. It does not say the period is long ("many").

The world behind it

The events behind the verse (168–164 BC). Daniel 11 traces the wars between the Seleucid kings of Syria ('king of the north') and the Ptolemies of Egypt ('king of the south'). Verses 21–45 focus on Antiochus IV Epiphanes (reigned 175–164 BC).

  • The 'ships of Kittim' (v. 30). In 168 BC Antiochus invaded Egypt a second time. A Roman envoy, Gaius Popilius Laenas, arrived by ship near Alexandria, drew a circle in the sand around the king, and demanded his answer before he stepped out of it (Polybius 29.27; Livy 45.12). Antiochus withdrew, humiliated. 'Kittim', originally Cypriots, had become a general term for western sea-powers; the Dead Sea Scrolls use it for Rome.
  • 'Forces from him' (v. 31). In 167 BC Antiochus sent Apollonius, the commander of his Mysian mercenaries, to Jerusalem. He attacked on a sabbath, tore down walls, and built and garrisoned a citadel, the Akra, overlooking the Temple (1 Maccabees 1:29–35; 2 Maccabees 5:24–26).
  • The decree. A royal edict banned burnt offerings in the Temple, sabbath-keeping, circumcision and the food laws, on pain of death (1 Maccabees 1:41–50).
  • The 'abomination'. On 15 Kislev, 167 BC (December), 'they built a desolating sacrilege on the altar of burnt offering' (1 Maccabees 1:54). Ten days later they began offering sacrifice 'on the altar that was on top of the altar of burnt offering' (1:59). The Temple was renamed for Zeus Olympios (2 Maccabees 6:2). The object was most likely a pagan altar, or a cult stone or emblem, set on top of God's altar. Pigs and other animals unclean for Jews were offered (1 Maccabees 1:47).
  • The outcome. Judas Maccabeus retook the Temple and rededicated it on 25 Kislev, 164 BC, about three years later (1 Maccabees 4:52–59). Hanukkah remembers this.

Why the 'continual' offering mattered. The Torah required a lamb as a burnt offering every morning and every evening, 'a continual burnt offering throughout your generations' (Exodus 29:42). It was the fixed point that kept Israel's daily life tied to God's presence in the sanctuary. To Jews of the time, its stopping was the clearest sign that the order of the world had been overturned.

Who would read Daniel this way. Daniel's visions use coded titles instead of names. Readers who lived through 167 BC would have recognised every step of verses 21–35.

From the study of Daniel 11:31.

Where scholars differ

in v31

Whom and what does this verse describe?

  • Antiochus IV's desecration of the Temple in 167 BC.

    This is the majority view among critical and many conservative commentators, and goes back to Porphyry and Jerome. Verses 2–30 follow Persian and Hellenistic history closely; the 'ships of Kittim' (v. 30) fit the Roman ultimatum of 168 BC; the troops, the stopped offering and the altar object match 1 Maccabees 1:29–59 and 2 Maccabees 5–6, and 1 Maccabees uses Daniel's own phrase.

  • Antiochus as a first fulfilment that foreshadows a later, final desecration by an end-time figure (often called the Antichrist).

    Held by many dispensational and some other conservative interpreters. They point to Jesus applying 'the abomination of desolation' to an event still future in his day (Matthew 24:15), and to Daniel 11:35, 40 and 12:1–2, which move toward 'the time of the end' and resurrection. Most such interpreters still accept that verse 31 itself refers to Antiochus; the debate centres on 11:36–45.

  • A pattern that Jesus applied to the Roman destruction of Jerusalem (AD 70).

    Luke 21:20 gives 'Jerusalem surrounded by armies' where Matthew and Mark have the abomination, and Josephus (Jewish War 6.316) reports Roman troops sacrificing to their standards in the Temple court. On this view, Daniel 11:31 is about Antiochus and Jesus treats it as a template for another sacrilege.

in v31

What is the 'desolating abomination,' and is the phrase a pun?

  • A deliberate distortion of 'Ba'al Shamem' ('Lord of Heaven'), the Syrian god identified with Zeus Olympios.

    First proposed by E. Nestle (1884) and widely accepted (e.g. Bickerman, Montgomery, Collins). 2 Maccabees 6:2 says the Temple was renamed for Zeus Olympios; shiqquts often replaces divine names with contempt; shomem sounds like shamem/shamayim; the missing article fits a coined name.

  • A plain description, 'the appalling sacrilege,' with no intended pun.

    The root shamem is common in its own right and appears in parallel phrases (8:13 'the transgression that desolates') where no god's name is in play. Some commentators judge the pun possible but unproven.

  • The physical object was an altar, a statue, or sacred stones.

    1 Maccabees 1:54, 59 speaks of something 'built' on the altar and of sacrifice on an altar placed on top of it, which suggests a pagan altar. Later tradition (e.g. Jerome) spoke of a statue of Zeus. Bickerman suggested sacred stones (in a Syrian style of worship) set on the altar. The sources do not settle it.

in v31

When was this chapter written?

  • During the crisis, around 167–164 BC, using the form of prophecy to describe recent history.

    The majority critical view. It points to the detailed accuracy of 11:2–39 up to the desecration, then the less clearly matching account of the king's end in 11:40–45 (Antiochus died in Persia, not 'between the seas and the holy mountain'). There is no mention of the rededication of 164 BC.

  • By Daniel in the 6th century BC, as genuine prediction.

    The traditional Jewish and Christian view, still held by many conservative scholars. They appeal to the book's own claims (10:1), Jesus' reference to 'Daniel the prophet' (Matthew 24:15), and Daniel fragments among the Dead Sea Scrolls dated not long after the Maccabean period. Some read 11:36–45 as moving to a future figure, which removes the apparent mismatch.

in v32

Does 'hold strong and act' include the Maccabean armed revolt, or only the non-violent endurance of Daniel's 'wise'?

  • Mainly non-violent faithfulness: teaching, refusing to comply, martyrdom.

    11:33–35 describes the action of the maskilim as instructing the many and falling by sword and flame. 11:34 calls outside aid only 'a little help' and says many join it insincerely, often read as a cool view of the Maccabean fighters. Daniel 8:25 and 2:34 expect deliverance 'not by human hand'. (So e.g. Collins, Hartman and Di Lella.)

  • Includes active, even armed, resistance.

    'Act' (ʿasah) answers the king's own actions, and 1 Maccabees 2:42 says the Hasidim joined the Maccabean revolt. 'A little help' can be read as genuine, if limited, aid. Some commentators therefore see Daniel as tolerating or welcoming the revolt, though not trusting in it.

in v32

When was the passage written, and what was its original audience?

  • Composed during the crisis (c. 167–164 BC) as a review of history written as prediction, to strengthen the persecuted faithful.

    Detailed accuracy up to the events of 167 BC, then a shift at 11:40–45 to predictions that do not match how Antiochus actually died. Hebrew style and the Greek loanwords in the Aramaic chapters. Majority view of critical scholarship (Collins, Goldingay with nuance).

  • Genuine prophecy from the 6th-century BC Daniel, foretelling these events centuries ahead.

    Traditional Jewish and Christian view. Daniel is presented as a Babylonian-period figure. Conservative scholars point to Dead Sea Scroll copies close to the 2nd century and to Jesus treating Daniel as prophecy (Matthew 24:15). Either way, interpreters agree that 11:32 describes Jewish responses to Antiochus IV.

in v33

Who are the maśkîlîm ("those with insight")?

  • The scribal and visionary circle that produced or passed on the book of Daniel.

    Daniel himself is a model maśkîl (1:4; 9:22). The book's heroes resist without violence. The maśkîlîm's role is to "give understanding", which is what chapters 10–12 do. Verse 34 seems to treat armed help as only "a little help". (So Collins, Hartman & Di Lella, and many critical commentators.)

  • The Hasidim ("pious ones") of 1 Maccabees 2:42 and 7:13, or a group closely related to them.

    They were a known pious group opposing Hellenization at this time. Objection: 1 Maccabees says the Hasidim joined the armed revolt, which sits uneasily with v.34's apparent coolness toward it.

  • Faithful teachers of God's people in a final end-time persecution, with the Antiochus crisis as a pattern or foreshadowing.

    The chapter moves toward "the time of the end" (11:35, 40; 12:1–4). Ancient and many modern Christian readers saw Antiochus as a type of a later Antichrist (Jerome records both readings). Most interpreters of every school, however, agree that v.33 itself fits the events of 167–164 BC very closely.

in v33

Does "they will stumble" (here and in v.35) mean martyrdom or apostasy?

  • Martyrdom and physical persecution.

    The verb is directly followed by sword, flame, captivity and plunder. *Kāšal* consistently means defeat or ruin elsewhere in Daniel 11. In v.35 the stumbling serves "to refine, purify and make white" those who stumble.

  • Partly moral failure: some teachers lapse under pressure and need purifying.

    The purification language of v.35 could suggest that some needed cleansing. *Kāšal* can be moral in other books (e.g. Hos 14:1). Most commentators still find v.33 itself plainly about violence.

in v33

Is this verse prediction from the 6th century BC or written during the events?

  • Composed in the 160s BC during the persecution, presenting recent history as prophecy (a common form in apocalyptic writing) up to about 11:39.

    The detailed accuracy through the Antiochus period, compared with 11:40–45, which does not match how Antiochus actually died. The Hebrew of the chapter is late. This is the majority view in critical scholarship.

  • Genuine prediction given to Daniel in the Persian period (10:1).

    The book's own framing. Traditional Jewish and Christian reading. Some argue that the later verses refer to a still-future figure rather than to Antiochus, so the "mismatch" is not a failed prediction.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. שִׁקּוּץ, שָׁמֵם, תָּמִיד, חָלַל, מָעוֹז, זְרוֹעַ
  • HALOT s.v. שִׁקּוּץ; שׁמם; תָּמִיד
  • 1 Maccabees 1:29–64; 4:36–59
  • 2 Maccabees 5:24–6:11
  • Polybius, Histories 29.27; Livy 45.12 (Popilius Laenas at Eleusis)
  • Josephus, Antiquities 12.248–256; Jewish War 6.316
  • E. Nestle, 'Zu Daniel,' ZAW 4 (1884) on shiqquts shomem / Ba'al Shamem
  • E. Bickerman, The God of the Maccabees (1937; Eng. 1979)
  • J. J. Collins, Daniel (Hermeneia, 1993)
  • J. E. Goldingay, Daniel (Word Biblical Commentary, 1989)
  • J. A. Montgomery, Daniel (ICC, 1927)
  • Jerome, Commentary on Daniel (citing Porphyry)
  • Exodus 29:38–42; Numbers 28:3–8; Matthew 24:15; Mark 13:14; Luke 21:20
  • BDB s.v. חָנֵף, חֲלַקָּה, חָזַק, יָדַע
  • HALOT s.v. חנף (hif. 'make godless, lead into apostasy'), חֲלַקָּה
  • J. J. Collins, Daniel (Hermeneia, 1993), on 11:29–35
  • J. E. Goldingay, Daniel (Word Biblical Commentary 30)
  • L. F. Hartman & A. A. Di Lella, The Book of Daniel (Anchor Bible 23)
  • 1 Maccabees 1–2; 2 Maccabees 6–7
  • H. B. Huffmon, 'The Treaty Background of Hebrew Yādaʿ', BASOR 181 (1966)
  • Damascus Document (CD) 1:18; Pesher Nahum (4Q169) – 'seekers of smooth things'
  • Theodotion's Greek Daniel; Vulgate Daniel 11:32
  • BDB s.v. שָׂכַל, בִּין, כָּשַׁל, יוֹם
  • HALOT s.v. שׂכל (hiphil), כשׁל (niphal), בִּזָּה, שְׁבִי
  • L. F. Hartman & A. A. Di Lella, The Book of Daniel (Anchor Bible, 1978)
  • H. L. Ginsberg, "The Oldest Interpretation of the Suffering Servant," Vetus Testamentum 3 (1953)
  • Community Rule (1QS) 3:13; 6; 9:12–21
  • Jerome, Commentary on Daniel (on 11:21–45)
  • Vulgate, Daniel 11:33; Theodotion Greek Daniel 11:33

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).