Acts Chapter 1 Read as one passage
Acts 1:23–26
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
23So they proposed two men: Joseph called Barsabbas (also known as Justus) and Matthias. 24And they prayed, “Lord, You know everyone’s heart. Show us which of these two You have chosen 25to take up this ministry and apostleship, which Judas abandoned to go to his rightful place.” 26Then they cast lots, and the lot fell to Matthias. So he was added to the eleven apostles.
What the first hearers heard
For Luke's readers this verse does three things:
- It shows the circle of witnesses was real and named. Two specific, nameable men had been with Jesus throughout, beyond the famous Twelve. The resurrection testimony rests on more people than the inner group. The first readers may even have known Joseph Barsabbas or his family, since a Judas Barsabbas was a known leader in Jerusalem (Acts 15:22).
- It shows proper, humble process. The community does its part by applying Peter's criteria and presenting qualified men. It does not presume to make the final call itself. The phrase "they stood up two" sets up the prayer in the next verse to the Lord "who knows everyone's heart." The leadership of the new Israel is shown as received from God, not grabbed.
- It gets Israel's Twelve ready for Pentecost. By the time the Spirit comes (Acts 2), the Twelve are complete, and they stand before the Jewish crowds as the core of a restored Israel.
That Joseph had more names and a fuller introduction than Matthias, yet the lot fell on Matthias, fits a theme Luke's readers would recognise from Israel's scriptures: God's choice does not follow human standing (compare 1 Sam 16:7, a passage echoed by "heart-knower" in v. 24).
From the study of Acts 1:23.
Verse by verse
-
23So they proposed two men: Joseph called Barsabbas (also known as Justus) and Matthias.
Full study →So the gathered believers stood two men up in front of the assembly as candidates. They were presenting them, not installing them, because the choice still belonged to God. The first was Joseph, an ordinary and very common Jewish name. To tell him apart he was known in Aramaic as Barsabbas, "son of Sabba," which may mean "son of the Sabbath," and he had also taken the Latin name Justus, "the upright one," for dealings in the wider Roman world. The second was Matthias, a short form of the Hebrew Mattathias, "gift of Yahweh." Both had walked with Jesus and the Twelve from John's baptism to the ascension, so both met the condition Peter had just set out. Here the people narrow the choice, and in the next verses they hand it to God in prayer and by casting lots.
-
24And they prayed, “Lord, You know everyone’s heart. Show us which of these two You have chosen
Full study →"And when they had prayed, they said: 'You, Lord, you who know every person's heart from the inside, bring out into the open and install the one of these two men whom you have already chosen for yourself.'"
The prayer opens with an emphatic "You". The group has done what it can: it set an outward test (a man who had been with Jesus from John's baptism to the ascension, vv. 21–22) and narrowed the field to two. It now steps back. The Lord is addressed by a striking one-word title, "Heart-Knower of all". In biblical speech the "heart" means the inner person (mind, intentions, loyalty, character), not mainly the emotions. The title echoes Solomon's prayer, "you alone know the hearts of all" (1 Kings 8:39), and Samuel's lesson that "the LORD looks on the heart" (1 Samuel 16:7). The point is that the Lord can see what the Eleven cannot, so he can tell apart two men who look equally qualified.
The request, "show", means more than "let us know". The verb was used for bringing something into public view and for formally installing someone in office, as when "the Lord appointed" the seventy (Luke 10:1). The verb "you chose" is in the past tense and uses the same word as Acts 1:2, where Jesus "chose" the apostles. So the choice has already been made. The lot that follows (v. 26) is meant to reveal it, not to create it. The sentence ends on "one": one man to bring the Eleven back to Twelve.
-
25to take up this ministry and apostleship, which Judas abandoned to go to his rightful place.”
Full study →The disciples ask the Lord, who knows every heart, to show which of the two men he has chosen to take up the post, literally the place, in this commissioned service. This is Jesus' own service, the task of being sent out as his envoys and witnesses to the resurrection. Judas stepped aside from that post. The verb pictures someone walking away from his station, and it is the same verb Israel's Scriptures use for turning off God's road and breaking covenant. He stepped aside so as to go to his own place.
The verse turns on the word place used twice. There was a place at Jesus' table and in his mission, given to Judas as his share (v.17). He walked out of it, and went where he belonged: to the place that fit what he had chosen. Luke does not name that place. To first-century Jewish and Christian ears, "going to one's own place" was a restrained way of speaking of a person's fate after death, and here, of Judas's judgment. The prayer does not set out to condemn Judas, though. It asks God to fill the seat he emptied, because the commission itself has not lapsed.
-
26Then they cast lots, and the lot fell to Matthias. So he was added to the eleven apostles.
Full study →After praying, "You, Lord, who know every heart, show which of these two you have chosen" (1:24), the believers put forward lots for the two candidates, Joseph called Barsabbas and Matthias. These were probably marked stones put into a vessel or the fold of a garment and shaken. One stone dropped out, and it was Matthias's. This was not luck. It was the old way Israel had used to let God decide: how land was shared out, how priests got their turns, how the goat for the Day of Atonement was chosen. "The lot is cast into the lap, but its every decision is from the LORD" (Proverbs 16:33).
Luke's wording also carries a pun. The same Greek word means both "lot" and "share". Judas had "received his share in this ministry" (1:17). Now the lot passes that forfeited share to another man, whose name means "gift of the LORD".
The group then formally counted him in. The verb comes from the pebbles used for counting and voting. Matthias was enrolled alongside the Eleven, and the Twelve were complete again. That mattered because the Twelve stood for a renewed twelve-tribe Israel (Luke 22:30), and the circle had to be whole before the Spirit came at Pentecost.
Where the English drifted
-
in v23
appointed (KJV)
estēsan
- What we hear
- They installed both men in office, or the group made the appointment.
- What they heard
- They stood the men up or put them forward as candidates. The choice between them is left to God through prayer and the lot (vv. 24–26).
-
in v23
surnamed (KJV, YLT)
epeklēthē
- What we hear
- Justus was his family name, inherited from his father.
- What they heard
- He was "given an additional name." Justus was a personal Latin byname, not a family name.
-
in v24
heart ("You know everyone's heart")
kardia (inside kardiognōstēs)
- What we hear
- Feelings, emotions, sincerity: 'God knows how they feel' or 'God knows they mean well.'
- What they heard
- The whole inner self: thoughts, intentions, will, loyalties and moral character. To know someone's heart is to know what they really are and what they will do, which is what matters when choosing someone for a task.
-
in v25
ministry
diakonia
- What we hear
- The clergy profession, a pastor's career, or a church programme.
- What they heard
- A service or task done on someone else's behalf. Here it is the job Jesus entrusted to the Twelve, defined in vv.21–22 as witnessing to his resurrection.
-
in v25
apostleship
apostolē
- What we hear
- A high church rank or title.
- What they heard
- Being sent: the commission of an authorised envoy carrying someone else's message.
-
in v25
by transgression fell (KJV)
parebē
- What we hear
- A 'fall' from grace or salvation, with the stress on falling.
- What they heard
- He 'stepped aside from' his post. The verb is about walking away from a station or path, with the moral sense of breaking faith. Nothing in the Greek corresponds to 'fell'.
-
in v26
cast lots / drew lots
edōkan klērous
- What we hear
- Leaving it to chance: a coin toss, a gamble, or giving up on discernment.
- What they heard
- A recognised, scriptural way of handing a decision to God, here done straight after prayer asking him to show his choice (1:24). The result was understood as God's verdict (Prov 16:33).
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v24
Was choosing Matthias a mistake? Luke tells it as the Lord's choice
- What's often taught
- A common teaching says the apostles acted too early when they chose Matthias. They supposedly relied on a human method (lots) before the Spirit came, and God's real twelfth apostle was Paul. Matthias is never mentioned again, which is taken as a sign the choice was not blessed.
- What the text supports
Luke's own wording points the other way:
- The prayer hands the choice to the Lord. They ask the Lord to show (or publicly install, anadeixon) the one he has already chosen (exelexō, past tense). It is the same verb used of Jesus choosing the original apostles (1:2). The way Luke tells it, the outcome is the Lord's choice, not a human guess.
- The method was a recognised way of asking God. It came after Scripture (1:20) and prayer, and in Israel the lot's decision was understood to come "from the LORD" (Prov 16:33).
- The result is accepted. Matthias "was added to the eleven apostles" (1:26), and "the Twelve" act as a full body afterwards (2:14; 6:2).
- Paul does not fit the criteria, and does not count himself among the Twelve. He had not been with Jesus "beginning from the baptism of John" (1:21–22). In 1 Cor 15:5–8 he lists "the Twelve" separately and calls himself an apostle "untimely born", the "last of all".
- Silence afterwards proves nothing. Most of the original Twelve are never mentioned individually again in Acts either.
What this reading gets right: lots disappear after Pentecost, and Spirit-led discernment takes their place. That is a real change in how decisions are made. Luke does not present it as a correction of 1:24–26.
- Where the English feeds it
- Only slightly. Renderings such as 'Show us which… you have chosen' can sound as if the group is asking for help with its own decision. The Greek stresses that the Lord has already chosen and is asked to make that choice publicly visible.
ἐκλέγω eklegō καρδιογνώστης kardiognōstēs ἀναδείκνυμι anadeiknymi
in v26
The text doesn't call Matthias a mistake
- What's often taught
- The apostles acted too soon, before the Spirit came, by choosing Matthias with something like a dice throw. God's real choice for the twelfth apostle was Paul, which is why Matthias is never heard of again.
- What the text supports
Luke gives no sign of disapproval. The believers pray first and ask God to show which one you have chosen (1:24). Then the lot, κλῆρος, 'falls' on Matthias in the standard biblical phrase for a decision made by God (Jonah 1:7; Prov 16:33). The group formally enrols him, συγκατεψηφίσθη, and from then on Luke speaks of the full group: 'Peter, standing with the Eleven' (2:14) and 'the Twelve' (6:2).
Paul could not meet the requirement of 1:21–22, which was to have been with Jesus from John's baptism to the ascension. Paul never claims a place among the Twelve. He lists 'the Twelve' separately and calls himself 'last of all' and 'untimely born' (1 Cor 15:5–8). His apostleship was real but of a different kind: sent to the Gentiles.
The reading is right about one thing: Matthias does not appear again. But neither do most of the original Twelve, so his silence says nothing against him.
- Where the English feeds it
- To modern ears, 'cast lots' sounds like gambling or giving up on discernment. That makes the episode look careless, when to Luke's readers it signalled reverent submission to God's choice.
κλῆρος klēros πίπτω piptō συγκαταψηφίζομαι synkatapsēphizomai ἀπόστολος apostolos
Every word
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v23, v24, v25, v26
A simple link that moves the story on. Peter has just set out who qualifies (vv. 21–22), and now the group acts.
-
ἔστησαν
estēsan · G2476
to stand, set, place · v23
Literally "they stood (them) up" or "set (them) forward." The group presented two candidates, perhaps quite literally standing them before everyone. It means nominating, not appointing. The final choice is left to God through the lot (vv. 24–26).
-
δύο
duo · G1417
two · v23, v24
Only two men met every requirement Peter had named, or the group narrowed the field to two. Verse 24 picks the number up again: "of these two, the one."
-
Ἰωσὴφ
Iōsēph · G2501
Joseph · v23
His Hebrew given name, after the patriarch Joseph. It was one of the most common Jewish names of the period, which is why he needed other names to tell him apart.
-
τὸν
ton · G3588
the · v23, v24, v25, v26
The article goes with the participle that follows: "the one called." It introduces a name that marks out this particular Joseph.
-
καλούμενον
kaloumenon · G2564
to call, name · v23
"Being called": the name people normally used for him, as Luke uses it for Simon "called the Zealot" (Luke 6:15).
-
Βαρσαββᾶν
Barsabban · G923
Barsabbas · v23
An Aramaic "son of" name: bar plus Sabba. It may mean "son of the Sabbath" (perhaps born on a Sabbath), "son of Saba" (his father's name), or possibly "son of the elder." It shows he belonged to the Aramaic-speaking Jewish world of Judea.
-
ὃς
hos · G3739
who · v23, v24, v25
A relative pronoun that adds a second identifying detail about this Joseph.
-
ἐπεκλήθη
epeklēthē · G1941
to call upon; to give an added name · v23
In the passive it means "was given an additional name" or "was also called." It does not mean a family surname. It means an extra name he went by, here a Latin one.
-
Ἰοῦστος
Ioustos · G2459
Justus · v23
The Latin name Iustus, "just, upright." Jews often took it as a public name for use in the wider Greco-Roman world (compare Jesus called Justus in Col 4:11 and Justus of Tiberias). It may say something about his reputation, but it was mainly a standard name of the time.
-
Μαθθίαν
Maththian · G3159
Matthias · v23, v26
A short form of Mattathias, from the Hebrew Mattityahu, "gift of Yahweh." The name was popular because of the Maccabean family. Unlike Joseph, he is given no second name, which may mean he needed none to be identified. He is the one chosen in verse 26.
-
προσευξάμενοι
proseuxamenoi · G4336
-
εἶπαν·
eipan · G2036
to say · v24
'They said.' The prayer is presented as spoken by the gathered group together, not by Peter alone. The -an ending is ordinary everyday Greek of the period.
-
σὺ
sy · G4771
you · v24
Greek verbs already show who acts, so putting the pronoun first is emphatic: 'You, Lord.' The weight moves off the group, which has only nominated, and onto the One who actually decides.
-
κύριε
kyrie · G2962
lord, master · v24
A direct address, 'Lord!' In Acts the title is used both for Israel's God and for the risen Jesus ('the Lord Jesus', 1:21). Which one is meant here is debated (see debates).
-
καρδιογνῶστα
kardiognōsta · G2589
heart-knower · v24
A compound title, 'Heart-Knower', addressed straight to the Lord. It says that he sees the inner self (motives, character, loyalties) that the community cannot see. That is exactly what they need for choosing between two men who look equally qualified from outside.
-
πάντων,
pantōn · G3956
all · v24
'Of all [people].' The form is masculine plural, so it means all persons, including the two candidates. It echoes Solomon's prayer, 'you alone know the hearts of all' (1 Kgs 8:39).
-
ἀνάδειξον
anadeixon · G0322
to show forth; to appoint publicly · v24
A command addressed to the Lord: 'Show plainly!' The word means bringing something into public view, and it was also used for formally installing someone in an office. They ask the Lord to make his choice visible, which in practice means through the lot.
-
ἐξελέξω
exelexō · G1586
to choose, select (for oneself) · v24
'You chose (for yourself).' The past tense presents the choice as already made: the lot will reveal it, not create it. The middle form ('for yourself') stresses that the apostle belongs to the one who chooses. It is the same verb used of Jesus choosing the apostles in 1:2.
-
ἐκ
ek · G1537
out of, from · v24
'Out of.' It marks choosing one from a defined group.
-
τούτων
toutōn · G3778
these · v24, v25
'These.' It points to the two men standing before the assembly (v. 23).
-
ἕνα
hena · G1520
one · v24
'One.' Placed last in the critical text, it ends the sentence on the single person needed to make the Eleven twelve again.
-
λαβεῖν
labein · G2983
to take, receive · v25
This finishes the prayer of v.24: 'show which one you have chosen … to take'. The person is to take up, or be given, a post that already exists. The aorist infinitive looks at the whole act of taking it on.
-
τόπον
topon · G5117
place, position, post · v25
Here it means a position or station in a group, the 'place' Judas left empty. The same word comes back at the end of the verse for a very different place.
-
διακονίας
diakonias · G1248
service, ministry, commissioned task · v25
The task of serving as an agent on someone else's behalf. Here it is the job Jesus gave the Twelve. It echoes v.17, where Judas 'received his share of this service'.
-
ἀποστολῆς
apostolēs · G0651
a sending, commission, apostleship · v25
The state of being someone's sent, authorised envoy. This is the first time the word appears in the NT. It names the role of the Twelve as Jesus' commissioned messengers.
-
ἀφ᾽
aph' · G0575
from, away from · v25
'Away from', a picture of movement. Judas stepped away from the post.
-
παρέβη
parebē · G3845
to step aside, deviate, transgress · v25
Literally 'stepped aside from'. It carries a picture of space, leaving one's position or path, and a moral weight: breaking faith. Both senses are at work here.
-
Ἰούδας
Ioudas · G2455
Judas · v25
Judas Iscariot, the betrayer. His name is the Greek form of Judah, the name of the tribe.
-
πορευθῆναι
poreuthēnai · G4198
to go, travel, proceed · v25
'So as to go'. This is the result, and in a grim sense the goal, of his stepping aside. He left one place in order to go to another. The same verb is used of journeys to one's final end (compare 1 Clement 5:4 on Peter).
-
εἰς
eis · G1519
into, to · v25
Marks where he ends up.
-
ἴδιον
idion · G2398
one's own, proper, particular · v25
'His own' place: the one fitting for him and belonging to him, matching what he chose. It is a restrained way of pointing to his destiny.
-
ἔδωκαν
edōkan · G1325
they gave · v26
Literally 'they gave' lots. This is an unusual Greek idiom. It most likely reflects the Hebrew natan goralot, 'to give lots' (Lev 16:8), and not the ordinary Greek 'to throw lots'. The aorist tense presents it as a single completed act.
-
κλήρους
klērous · G2819
lots · v26
The lot-markers themselves, probably marked stones or tablets with the candidates' names, put into a vessel or a fold of a garment and shaken.
-
αὐτοῖς
autois · G0846
for them · v26
Dative case. Best taken as 'for them', meaning on behalf of the two nominees Joseph Barsabbas and Matthias. Some take it as 'to them', meaning the lots were handed to the two men. Byzantine manuscripts read 'their' (αὐτῶν).
-
ἔπεσεν
epesen · G4098
fell · v26
'Fell' pictures one marker dropping or jumping out of the shaken container. 'The lot fell upon X' is a set biblical phrase (Jonah 1:7 LXX).
-
ἐπὶ
epi · G1909
upon · v26
'Upon': the choice came down on him and marked him out.
-
συγκατεψηφίσθη
synkatepsēphisthē · G4785
was reckoned/enrolled together with · v26
Built on psēphos, the pebble used for voting or counting. In the passive it means 'he was counted in alongside', that is, formally enrolled with the others. It appears only here in the New Testament.
-
μετὰ
meta · G3326
with · v26
'With' or 'among' the existing group. He joins it as an equal member.
-
ἕνδεκα
hendeka · G1733
-
ἀποστόλων
apostolōn · G0652
apostles · v26
'Sent ones', meaning authorised envoys. Here it means the specific circle of the Twelve, whose job (1:22) is to be witnesses of Jesus' resurrection.
The world behind it
Why a replacement at all. Judas's death left eleven. Jesus had chosen twelve, a number that stood for the twelve tribes of Israel, and he had promised they would "sit on thrones judging the twelve tribes" (Luke 22:30). Restoring the Twelve before Pentecost tells the first readers that the renewal of Israel is going ahead in full.
The requirements (vv. 21–22). The candidate had to have been with the group for the whole of Jesus' public ministry, "beginning from John's baptism until the day He was taken up," so that he could be an eyewitness of the resurrection. That limited the field to a small circle of long-time disciples beyond the Twelve, the circle Luke hints at in Luke 8:1–3 and 10:1.
People nominate, God decides. The two-step process (presenting candidates, then praying and casting lots) follows Israel's practice. Lots were understood as a way of letting God decide: "The lot is cast into the lap, but its every decision is from the LORD" (Prov 16:33). The land was divided by lot (Num 26:55), and priests' duties in the Temple were assigned by lot in Jesus' day (Luke 1:9; Mishnah Tamid). Standing the candidates before the assembly also echoes Moses setting Joshua before the priest and the whole congregation (Num 27:19–22).
Three names, three languages. Joseph's names (Hebrew Joseph, Aramaic Barsabbas, Latin Justus) were typical of first-century Judea. People spoke Aramaic day to day, Hebrew was the language of scripture and family heritage, and Greek and Latin were needed under Roman rule. Additional names were also practical, because a small number of names (Joseph, Simon, Judas, Mattathias) were shared by a large share of Jewish men.
From the study of Acts 1:23.
Where scholars differ
in v23
Who put the two men forward: the whole group of about 120, the eleven apostles, or Peter?
-
The whole gathered community (about 120, v. 15).
The plural "they" follows straight on from Peter speaking to "the brothers" (vv. 15–16). Acts 6:3–6 shows the community choosing candidates and presenting them to the apostles.
-
The eleven apostles.
Verse 26 says Matthias was "counted with the eleven apostles," and some read the action as the apostles' own. However, the grammar does not specify who "they" are.
-
Peter alone (Western text).
Codex D's singular ἔστησεν. It is usually judged a later reading that gives Peter more prominence.
in v23
What does "Barsabbas" mean?
-
"Son of the Sabbath," a name for someone born on a Sabbath.
Fits the Aramaic bar + šabbāʾ. Names based on the day of birth are found in Jewish usage (compare Shabbetai, Ezra 10:15).
-
"Son of Saba," his father's name.
"Bar + father's name" was the most common pattern, as in Bar-Jonah and Bartimaeus. A Judas Barsabbas (Acts 15:22) may point to a family name shared by brothers.
-
"Son of the elder" (Aramaic sābāʾ).
Possible linguistically, but less often argued for.
in v23
Was choosing Matthias a mistake that got ahead of God, who meant Paul to be the twelfth?
-
The election was premature, and Paul was God's real replacement.
Matthias is never mentioned again, while Paul later becomes the dominant apostle. Some 19th–20th-century preachers argued the disciples should have waited for the Spirit.
-
Luke presents the election as legitimate and approved by God (the majority of scholars).
The process is framed by scripture (v. 20), prayer (v. 24) and the lot, which was understood as God's decision (Prov 16:33). Matthias is "counted with the eleven" (v. 26), and "the Twelve" act as a group in 6:2. Paul does not meet Peter's criteria in vv. 21–22. Paul himself separates his calling from "the Twelve" (1 Cor 15:5–8; Gal 1:17).
in v24
Is the 'Lord' addressed here the risen Jesus or God (the Father)?
-
The risen Jesus.
The same verb 'chose' (eklegomai) is used of Jesus choosing the apostles in 1:2 and Luke 6:13, so it fits for him to choose the replacement. Peter has just spoken of 'the Lord Jesus' (1:21). Acts shows prayer addressed directly to Jesus (7:59–60). On this view a title rooted in Old Testament language about God is given to Jesus.
-
God (Israel's God, the Father).
In Acts 15:8 the same rare title 'heart-knower' is applied explicitly to 'God'. The Old Testament background (1 Kgs 8:39; 1 Sam 16:7; Jer 17:10) makes knowing hearts a property of God. The lot was traditionally a way of asking God's verdict (Prov 16:33). Most early Christian prayer in Acts is addressed to God (e.g. 4:24).
in v24
What does the lot in v. 26 mean for the church's practice?
-
A legitimate transitional practice, endorsed by Luke.
It is preceded by Scripture and prayer and follows a well-established Jewish practice (Prov 16:33; Luke 1:9). The outcome is accepted: Matthias 'was added to the eleven' (1:26) and 'the Twelve' act together afterwards (6:2). Lots are never mentioned again after Pentecost, which suggests a shift to Spirit-led discernment, not a criticism.
-
A method no longer used once the Spirit is given.
From Acts 2 on, decisions are attributed to the Spirit (13:2; 15:28; 16:6–7) and to community discernment. Some therefore treat the lot as belonging only to the period before Pentecost. This view generally does not claim Luke disapproves of it, only that it stopped.
in v25
What is Judas's 'own place'?
-
His fate after death, most likely judgment or punishment.
'Go to one's own place' is a well-attested idiom for destiny after death. Ignatius, To the Magnesians 5:1 has the same wording, and 1 Clement 5:4 says Peter 'went to the place of glory owed to him'. Luke 22:3 and Acts 1:16–20 present Judas's end as judgment. This is the majority view (e.g. Bruce, Barrett, Fitzmyer).
-
A deliberate double meaning that also points to the field Judas acquired (vv.18–19).
The 'field' (chōrion) and its renaming are mentioned just before, and Psalm 69:25 is quoted about his 'homestead' becoming desolate (v.20). Some commentators see irony here, but few think this is the main sense.
-
The subject of 'to go' is the replacement: he goes to his proper place in the apostolate.
A few older interpreters read it this way, because the Greek infinitive does not name its subject. Most reject it, since the infinitive naturally follows Judas's 'stepping aside' and the second 'place' contrasts with the first.
in v25
Is diakonia here 'humble service' or 'commissioned agency'?
-
Humble, self-giving service, with overtones of waiting at table.
In Luke 22:26–27 Jesus describes himself as 'one who serves' at table, and Acts 6:1–2 uses the word for distributing food.
-
A commissioned task carried out as someone's agent or envoy.
John N. Collins (1990) surveyed non-biblical Greek and found the word group often means acting as a go-between under a mandate. Here it is paired with 'apostolē' (being sent) and defined as witnessing (vv.21–22). Both ideas may be present. In this verse the 'commission' sense is especially strong.
in v25
Was the choice of Matthias legitimate, or was Paul meant to be the twelfth?
-
Luke presents Matthias's appointment as God's choice.
The prayer asks the Lord to 'show which one you have chosen' (v.24), and lots were a recognised way of leaving the decision to God (Proverbs 16:33). Matthias is 'numbered with the eleven' (v.26), and 'the Twelve' act together afterwards (Acts 6:2). Paul does not meet the criteria of vv.21–22, and he lists himself separately from the Twelve (1 Corinthians 15:5–8).
-
The apostles acted too soon, and Paul was God's intended replacement.
This is a popular view, not one argued from the text. It notes that Matthias is never mentioned again, and that the Spirit had not yet been given. Luke never criticises the decision, though, and most other apostles are also never mentioned again.
in v26
Was the choice of Matthias a mistake: should the apostles have waited for Paul?
-
It was a hasty, human decision. Paul was God's real twelfth apostle.
Matthias is never mentioned again. The decision came before Pentecost and the coming of the Spirit. Paul later insists strongly that he is an apostle.
-
Luke presents the choice as legitimate and God-directed.
It follows prayer asking God to choose (1:24). It fulfils Scripture Peter has just quoted (1:20, 'let another take his office'). Paul does not meet the criteria of 1:21–22. Luke at once speaks of 'Peter with the Eleven' and 'the Twelve' (2:14; 6:2). Paul himself lists 'the Twelve' separately from himself (1 Cor 15:5, 8). Most of the original Twelve are never mentioned again in Acts either.
in v26
Did the lot decide, or did the community vote?
-
A real lot decided, and the community then enrolled Matthias.
The words 'the lot fell upon' are the standard lot-casting phrase (Jonah 1:7; Prov 16:33). Most commentators take it this way.
-
'Gave lots' may mean 'cast votes', and the verb (built on psēphos, a voting pebble) points to an election.
The unusual verb 'gave' and the voting background of συγκαταψηφίζομαι. A minority view, made weaker by the plain lot idiom and the Hebrew background of 'give lots'.
in v26
Does the end of lot-casting after Pentecost mean the method was set aside?
-
Luke shows a shift: from now on the Spirit directs decisions (e.g. Acts 13:2; 15:28), and lots are never used again in the New Testament.
This is the last use of lots in Scripture. In Acts, later decisions come through prayer, prophecy and the Spirit.
-
Luke makes no such contrast, and the silence later should not be read as a verdict on this event.
Luke treats the lot positively here and never criticises it. An argument from silence is weak.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. ἵστημι, ἐπικαλέω, Βαρσαββᾶς, Ματθίας
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. Βαρσαβᾶς, Ἰοῦστος
- Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (2nd ed.), on Acts 1:23
- Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Acts 1:23
- Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History 1.12.3; 3.39.9 (Papias)
- Clement of Alexandria, Stromata 4.6
- Tal Ilan, Lexicon of Jewish Names in Late Antiquity, Part I
- F. F. Bruce, The Acts of the Apostles: Greek Text with Introduction and Commentary
- Craig S. Keener, Acts: An Exegetical Commentary, vol. 1
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Acts 1:21–26
- Mishnah Tamid (lots for priestly duties)
- NA28 / UBS5 Greek New Testament
- BDAG s.v. καρδιογνώστης
- BDAG s.v. ἀναδείκνυμι
- BDAG s.v. ἐκλέγομαι
- LSJ s.v. ἀναδείκνυμι
- Septuagint: 1 Kingdoms (1 Sam) 14:41; 16:7; 3 Kingdoms (1 Kgs) 8:39; 1 Chr 28:9; Jer 17:10; Prov 16:33; 2 Macc 9:23; 14:12
- Mishnah Yoma 2:2–4 (priestly lots)
- Dead Sea Scrolls, Community Rule (1QS) 5–6
- Shepherd of Hermas, Mandate 4.3.4
- Vulgate, Acts 1:24
- B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (on Acts 1:23–26)
- C. K. Barrett, Acts (ICC)
- F. F. Bruce, The Book of the Acts (NICNT)
- J. A. Fitzmyer, The Acts of the Apostles (Anchor Bible)
- C. S. Keener, Acts: An Exegetical Commentary
- BDAG s.v. τόπος, διακονία, ἀποστολή, παραβαίνω, ἴδιος
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. παραβαίνω
- Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Acts 1:25
- NA28 / UBS5 critical apparatus
- John N. Collins, Diakonia: Re-interpreting the Ancient Sources (1990)
- F. F. Bruce, The Acts of the Apostles (Greek text commentary)
- C. K. Barrett, Acts (ICC), vol. 1
- 1 Clement 5:4–7; 40:5; 44:5
- Ignatius, To the Magnesians 5:1
- Polycarp, To the Philippians 9:2
- LXX Exodus 32:8; Numbers 24:25; Proverbs 16:33
- Vulgate, Acts 1:25
- BDAG s.v. κλῆρος; s.v. συγκαταψηφίζομαι
- Thayer s.v. συγκαταψηφίζω
- LXX Jonah 1:7; Lev 16:8; Prov 16:33; 1 Chr 24–26
- Mishnah Yoma 2; Tamid
- 1QS (Community Rule) 6
- B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Acts 1:23–26
- C. S. Keener, Acts: An Exegetical Commentary, vol. 1
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, Acts 1:21–26
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).