Acts Chapter 2 Read as one passage
Acts 2:44–47
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
44All the believers were together and had everything in common. 45Selling their possessions and goods, they shared with anyone who was in need. 46With one accord they continued to meet daily in the temple courts and to break bread from house to house, sharing their meals with gladness and sincerity of heart, 47praising God and enjoying the favor of all the people. And the Lord added to their number daily those who were being saved.
What the first hearers heard
For Luke's first readers (Theophilus and Greek-speaking communities of Jews and Gentiles, probably late first century), this verse did three things:
- It said the Spirit created a new kind of community. Coming right after Pentecost, the awe and the signs (v. 43), the shared property is presented as one more result of the Spirit's arrival, as real as the miracles.
- It made a claim that both Greeks and Jews could recognise. Greek readers heard the friendship ideal of the philosophers ("all things common", and in 4:32 "one soul") realised among ordinary people. Jewish readers heard the hope of Deuteronomy 15 that there would be no poor among God's people, and a devotion like that of the Essenes, but open to anyone who repented and was baptised.
- It set a pattern and a standard. Luke's Gospel spends a great deal of attention on possessions (Luke 12:33; 14:33; 18:22; 19:8). Here that teaching becomes a community's practice. The verse let later congregations measure their own life together, especially care for members in need, against the first community. Acts 5 (Ananias and Sapphira) and 6:1 (the neglected widows) show Luke did not pretend the ideal ran without strain.
From the study of Acts 2:44.
Verse by verse
-
44All the believers were together and had everything in common.
Full study →Now every one of those who had put their trust in Jesus as Lord and Messiah kept gathering as a single body, and they kept treating everything they owned as shared property, open to the use of all.
The Greek doubles the word for "all": all the believing ones held all things in common. The point is the wholeness of the community, not a statistic. The verbs describe what they kept on doing over time ("were gathering", "were holding"), not a one-time event. The next verse explains how it worked in practice: they kept selling property and possessions and distributing the proceeds as anyone had need.
"Together" here means more than feeling close. It is Luke's phrase for the community assembled as one, a phrase the Greek Old Testament uses for people gathered in one body. "Had all things common" is not about being alike. It echoes a saying every educated Greek knew: "friends' things are common." Philosophers held this up as the mark of true friendship and the ideal city. Jews knew it as the practice of the most devoted groups such as the Essenes. Luke's first hearers would have understood the claim this way: in this new community, gathered around the risen Messiah, the friendship the philosophers dreamed of actually happened, among ordinary people in Jerusalem.
-
45Selling their possessions and goods, they shared with anyone who was in need.
Full study →"And their land and their belongings, they would sell. Again and again they parcelled out the proceeds among all of them, as often and as much as any one of them was in need."
Luke is describing a habit, not a single event. Both main verbs are in a Greek past tense that pictures continuing or repeated action. Fields and estates (the heaviest, most inherited kind of wealth in that world) and other belongings were sold off over time. The money was then actually divided out, person by person. What set the timing and the amount was the need of any individual member: "whenever anyone had need." The verse gives flesh to the sentence just before it, "they had everything in common." In this new community, believers treated one another's lack as their own, the way close family or true friends would. The result, Luke says a few chapters later, was what the Law of Moses had hoped for: "there was no needy person among them" (Acts 4:34; Deuteronomy 15:4).
-
46With one accord they continued to meet daily in the temple courts and to break bread from house to house, sharing their meals with gladness and sincerity of heart,
Full study →Every day, without letting up, they kept coming to the temple courts as one body, united in purpose. And they kept gathering in one home after another, where someone would give thanks and break the loaf, and they would eat real meals together. Those meals were jubilant, festive celebrations, eaten with hearts that were plain and open, with nothing rough, hidden or two-faced in them.
Some details the English can hide:
- Two places, one rhythm. The Greek joins the temple and the homes with a matched "both… and". Public worship in Israel's temple and private meals in ordinary houses were two halves of the same daily life. Neither replaced the other.
- Habit, not a single event. Every verb describes continuing, repeated action: "they kept persisting… kept breaking… kept taking food". Luke is describing a way of life.
- "Breaking bread" was a meal. It began with the Jewish thanksgiving over the loaf, and the next clause says plainly that they "took food". For people who had eaten with the risen Jesus, these meals could not help recalling him (Luke 24:30–35).
- "Gladness" is too quiet a word. The word is closer to jubilation, the festival joy of the Psalms.
- "Sincerity of heart" pictures a heart like a field cleared of stones: smooth, simple, without ulterior motive. Coming straight after verse 45, it also carries the openhanded spirit of people who shared their goods.
-
47praising God and enjoying the favor of all the people. And the Lord added to their number daily those who were being saved.
Full study →They kept on praising God out loud, the God of Israel, whose promised Spirit had just been poured out. They also stood in warm goodwill with the whole people, meaning the ordinary Jewish population of Jerusalem who saw them every day in the temple courts. (Some scholars read the goodwill as running the other way: the believers showing kindness toward everyone.) Meanwhile the Lord was adding, again and again, day after day, the people who were being rescued. These were the ones who answered Peter's call to "be saved from this crooked generation" and found safety in the coming Day of the Lord by calling on his name. He joined them together into one gathered body. The growth is presented as the Lord's doing, not the apostles' achievement. Each new person was added to the group, not just counted. In the oldest manuscripts the verse does not say "church". It ends with "together", the community's own word for being gathered in one place and one company.
Where the English drifted
-
in v44
had everything in common
eichon hapanta koina
- What we hear
- Everyday English "we have a lot in common" means "we are alike". Others hear modern political "common ownership" or communism.
- What they heard
- They held their possessions as shared property, available to anyone in the group who needed them. This was the language of ideal friendship ("friends' things are common"). It was a voluntary practice of a faith community, not a political or economic system.
-
in v44
believers / all who believed
hoi pisteuontes
- What we hear
- People who accept certain religious statements as true. Often a general label for religious identity.
- What they heard
- People who had placed their trust and allegiance in Jesus as Lord and Messiah, shown by repentance and baptism. Here that trust shows up in how they handled their possessions.
-
in v45
possessions
ktēmata
- What we hear
- Personal belongings: stuff, clothes, spare items one can do without.
- What they heard
- Mostly landed property: fields, plots, estates (compare Acts 5:1–3, where the ktēma is a field). This was the main store of family wealth and inheritance.
-
in v45
sold … shared / sold … distributed
epipraskon … diemerizon (imperfect)
- What we hear
- One decisive act: on a single occasion everyone liquidated everything and pooled it.
- What they heard
- An ongoing, repeated practice. They kept selling property and kept distributing the money as individual needs came up ('whenever anyone had need').
-
in v46
breaking bread
klōntes… arton
- What we hear
- Taking Communion: a separate church ritual of a wafer or small piece of bread, apart from a meal.
- What they heard
- Holding a meal that began with the host's thanksgiving and the breaking of the loaf. In this circle such meals carried the memory of Jesus' own bread-breaking. Here it is followed directly by 'they took food', so real meals are in view.
-
in v46
from house to house
kat' oikon
- What we hear
- Moving from door to door, as in door-to-door visiting, or going round the houses one after another.
- What they heard
- 'House by house', 'in homes'. Meals took place in various private homes, in contrast to the public temple courts. It describes where they ate, not a tour of houses.
-
in v46
did eat their meat (KJV)
metelambanon trophēs
- What we hear
- They ate animal flesh.
- What they heard
- They took their food, their nourishment, in general. Bread was the staple of the meal.
-
in v46
singleness of heart (KJV, WEB)
aphelotēti kardias
- What we hear
- Something to do with being single (unmarried), or the phrase is simply unclear.
- What they heard
- A heart that is smooth, plain and undivided, without pretence or hidden motive. It probably also had an openhanded quality.
-
in v46
gladness
agalliasis
- What we hear
- A calm, pleasant contentment.
- What they heard
- Exultation, the jubilant festival joy of worship, used in the Psalms for the noise of a celebrating crowd.
-
in v46
in the temple (KJV, WEB, YLT)
en tō hierō
- What we hear
- Inside the temple building.
- What they heard
- In the open courts and colonnades of the temple complex. Only priests entered the sanctuary building.
-
in v47
added to the church (KJV)
epi to auto (critical text); tē ekklēsia (later manuscripts)
- What we hear
- Joined an institution: a church with membership, leaders, possibly a building or denomination.
- What they heard
- The earliest text says only that the Lord added people 'together', into the one gathered company that met daily in the temple and in homes. Even the later reading ekklēsia meant simply 'assembly' or 'gathering'.
-
in v47
such as should be saved (KJV)
tous sōzomenous
- What we hear
- Those who were destined or appointed to be saved, or those who ought to be saved.
- What they heard
- 'Those being saved': a present participle describing people who were, at that time, being rescued. It says nothing either way about prior appointment.
-
in v47
all the people
holon ton laon
- What we hear
- Everyone in society; universal popularity.
- What they heard
- The Jewish populace of Jerusalem as a whole, as opposed to the temple rulers. Laos is Israel's word for itself as God's people.
-
in v47
saved
sōzō
- What we hear
- Purely personal: an individual's soul secured for heaven at a moment of decision.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v44
'All things in common' wasn't a ban on owning property, or just generosity
- What's often taught
- Acts 2:44 is often read as showing that the first church abolished private property and required every member to hand everything over to a common fund, making it a blueprint for Christian communism or socialism. Others answer by reducing it to ordinary generosity.
- What the text supports
The Greek supports something between these two readings.
- Ongoing, not a one-time pooling. The verbs are imperfect: "they kept holding… kept selling… kept distributing". Verse 45 adds "as anyone had need". Property was sold as needs came up.
- Voluntary, not required. Peter tells Ananias, "while it remained, was it not your own? And after it was sold, was it not at your disposal?" (5:4). Ananias's sin was lying about the gift. Believers still owned homes (2:46; 12:12), and Barnabas's gift is recorded because it stood out (4:36–37).
- But more than generosity. κοινά ("common") is strong language. It picks up the well-known saying "friends' things are common". The parallel in 4:32 says no one called anything "his own". Luke presents this as the defining mark of the Spirit-filled community, and he approves of it. Treating it as minor misses his point.
So the text describes a voluntary, ongoing practice of treating possessions as available to the whole family of believers. It is not a compulsory system of collective ownership, and it is not a passing gesture of charity.
- Where the English feeds it
- "Had everything in common" can sound like a fixed legal arrangement, and it brings modern political associations with "common ownership". The English "had" also hides the ongoing sense of the imperfect tenses.
in v45
The Greek doesn't say they sold everything at once
- What's often taught
- After Pentecost the first believers sold everything they owned in a single act, abolished private property and lived as a commune. Some hold this up as the binding model for Christians. Others call it a failed experiment that left the church poor.
- What the text supports
Both main verbs (epipraskon, 'they kept selling'; diemerizon, 'they kept distributing') are imperfect, the Greek tense for ongoing or repeated past action. The closing clause kathoti an tis chreian eichen means 'whenever / to the extent that anyone had need'. So the text describes a continuing practice in which property was sold and distributed as individual needs came up. It does not describe a one-time liquidation followed by equal shares.
The context confirms it. Believers still met in their own houses (2:46; Mary's house in 12:12). Barnabas's sale of a field is singled out as notable (4:36–37). Peter tells Ananias the land 'remained your own' and the money was 'at your disposal' (5:4). The sharing was voluntary.
The popular reading gets the main point right. The generosity was radical: land, the most precious family asset, was sold for the sake of non-relatives, and Luke presents it as the Spirit's work and the fulfilment of Deuteronomy 15:4 ('no needy person among them'). What the text does not support is the picture of compulsory, all-at-once common ownership.
- Where the English feeds it
- KJV, WEB, NIV and NLT render the imperfects with a simple past ('sold … distributed'), which reads naturally as a single event. Alongside 'had everything in common' in v. 44, this suggests a one-time pooling. Versions that keep the imperfect (YLT 'were selling … were parting'; ESV 'were selling'; NASB 'began selling … were sharing') point to the ongoing practice.
διαμερίζω diamerizō καθότι kathoti κτῆμα ktēma ἄν an πιπράσκω pipraskō χρεία chreia
Every word
-
πάντες
pantes · G3956
all, every · v44, v45
Stands first for emphasis: "all of them", not some of them. It pairs with ἅπαντα ("all things") later in the verse, so the line is framed as all people holding all things.
-
δὲ
de · G1161
and, now, but · v44, v47
A light connecting word that moves the summary along ("now"). There is no contrast here. It carries on from the awe and the signs in v. 43.
-
οἱ
hoi · G3588
the · v44, v45, v46, v47
The article turns the participle that follows into a noun phrase: "the ones believing". This names a recognisable group.
-
πιστεύοντες
pisteuontes · G4100
to believe, trust, entrust oneself · v44
"The believing ones": people who had accepted the apostles' message that the crucified Jesus is Lord and Messiah (2:36) and had committed themselves to him through repentance and baptism (2:38, 41). Luke uses it almost as a name for the group. It means trust and allegiance, not only holding an opinion.
-
ἦσαν
ēsan · G1510
to be · v44
Imperfect tense ("were"). It describes a continuing state over a period of time, which suits Luke's summary of how the community regularly lived.
-
ἐπὶ
epi · G1909
upon, at, to · v44, v47
The first word of the fixed phrase ἐπὶ τὸ αὐτό, literally "at the same [place]", meaning "together" or "gathered as one". On its own the preposition adds nothing here. The meaning belongs to the whole phrase.
-
αὐτὸ
auto · G846
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v44, v45, v46, v47
Joins the two descriptions. Being gathered together and holding everything in common are presented as two sides of one shared life.
-
εἶχον
eichon · G2192
to have, hold · v44, v45, v47
Imperfect tense, "they were holding / used to hold". It describes an ongoing practice, not a single event. The same verb returns in v. 45 ("as anyone had need"), linking what they held to what others needed.
-
ἅπαντα
hapanta · G537
all, everything · v44
A stronger form of πᾶς, "absolutely everything". It answers the opening πάντες: all the people, all the things. The doubled 'all' marks this as an ideal summary of the community at its best.
-
κοινά
koina · G2839
common, shared · v44
"Common", meaning shared property that belongs to all and is open to the use of all. To a Greek-speaking reader the phrase "to have all things common" was a well-known saying about ideal friendship and the ideal community. (Elsewhere κοινός can mean 'ritually unclean', as in Acts 10:14, but that sense does not apply here.)
-
κτήματα
ktēmata · G2933
possession, property, estate · v45
In Koine usage this often means landed property: fields, plots, vineyards. Acts 5:1 uses the same word for the piece of land Ananias sold. It is put first in the sentence for emphasis.
-
ὑπάρξεις
hyparxeis · G5223
property, belongings, means · v45
What someone has to live on: goods, possessions, resources. Paired with ktēmata, it means roughly 'land and other belongings.'
-
ἐπίπρασκον
epipraskon · G4097
to sell · v45
An imperfect verb, which in Greek usually shows ongoing or repeated past action: 'they kept selling' or 'they would sell.' It describes a continuing practice, not a single mass sell-off.
-
διεμέριζον
diemerizon · G1266
to divide, distribute · v45
'They kept dividing out' the proceeds. The prefix dia- gives the sense of parcelling something out among many. This is real distribution, not just a generous attitude. Also imperfect: an ongoing practice.
-
καθότι
kathoti · G2530
according as, to the degree that · v45
Sets how much each person received: in proportion to need.
-
ἄν
an · G302
(particle of indefiniteness) · v45
With a past-tense verb this makes the clause repeated and open-ended: 'whenever anyone had need.' It confirms that sales and distribution happened as needs came up.
-
τις
tis · G5100
anyone, someone · v45
Points to individual cases. Each person's real need was what triggered help.
-
χρείαν
chreian · G5532
need, lack · v45
Real lack of what life requires: food, shelter, support. It is the same word as in the identical phrase in Acts 4:35.
-
καθ᾽
kath' · G2596
according to, by · v46, v47
Used with 'day' to mean 'day by day'. It marks a repeated, distributed action: every single day, not now and then.
-
ἡμέραν
hēmeran · G2250
day · v46, v47
Together with kath', 'daily'. It placed first for emphasis, so 'daily' sets the rhythm for both the temple and the home meals that follow.
-
τε
te · G5037
and, both · v46
The first of a matched pair ('both… and'). It ties the temple attendance and the house meals together as the two sides of a single daily pattern.
-
προσκαρτεροῦντες
proskarterountes · G4342
persist in, be devoted to, attend constantly · v46
A present participle, meaning ongoing action: they kept showing up and stayed at it. It is the same verb as 2:42 ('devoted to the apostles' teaching'), so the temple attendance belongs to that same devotion.
-
ὁμοθυμαδὸν
homothumadon · G3661
with one mind, together · v46
'With one passion or purpose', and also simply 'together, as a group'. It is a favourite word of Luke's for the unity of the first believers.
-
ἐν
en · G1722
in · v46
Gives the place: in the temple.
-
ἱερῷ
hierō · G2411
-
κλῶντές
klōntes · G2806
break · v46
In the Bible this verb is used only for breaking bread. In a Jewish meal the host said the blessing and broke the loaf to start the meal, so 'breaking bread' points to the meal and its opening act.
-
οἶκον
oikon · G3624G
house, household · v46
Both the building and the household living in it. The meals were held in ordinary homes, under a household's hospitality.
-
ἄρτον
arton · G0740
bread, loaf · v46
The flat loaf that was the staple of every meal. It also stands for food in general, the way 'bread' can in English.
-
μετελάμβανον
metelambanon · G3335
partake of, share in, take · v46
The main verb. Its imperfect tense describes a habit ('they kept taking their food'). The prefix meta- carries a note of sharing in something with others.
-
τροφῆς
trophēs · G5160
food, nourishment · v46
Plain food, real nourishment. This word shows that the 'bread-breaking' involved actual meals and not just a token rite (compare 27:33–36).
-
ἀγαλλιάσει
agalliasei · G0020
exultation, jubilant joy · v46
Exuberant, festive joy, the kind used for worship, feasts and God's saving acts. It is not a quiet inner contentment.
-
ἀφελότητι
aphelotēti · G0858
simplicity, plainness, sincerity · v46
Used only here in the New Testament. It suggests 'smoothness': a heart without rough spots, ulterior motives or pretence. Some take it to include open-handed generosity.
-
καρδίας
kardias · G2588
heart · v46
The inner person: mind, will and motive, not only feelings. Their whole inner disposition was free of complication.
-
αἰνοῦντες
ainountes · G0134
praising · v47
Praising God out loud, often in public. This is one of Luke's favorite words for how people react when God acts (Luke 2:13, 20; 19:37; Acts 3:8–9). The participle carries on the list of the believers' daily habits from 2:46: they kept on praising.
-
θεὸν
theon · G2316
God · v47
The God of Israel. These believers were Jews worshipping in the temple courts (2:46), so their praise went to the God their ancestors had worshipped.
-
χάριν
charin · G5485
favor, goodwill, grace · v47
Goodwill or a favorable standing between people. Here it is a social word, not the doctrinal 'grace' of later theology. The most likely sense is that the people of Jerusalem viewed the believers kindly.
-
πρὸς
pros · G4314
toward, with · v47
'Toward' or 'with'. It points the goodwill at 'all the people'. Whether the goodwill runs from the people to the believers or from the believers to the people turns on this little word.
-
ὅλον
holon · G3650
whole, all · v47
'The whole' people: the general population taken as a group. It is an overall impression, not a claim that every single person approved.
-
λαόν.
laon · G2992
people · v47
In Luke and Acts this usually means the Jewish people, here the ordinary population of Jerusalem, as opposed to the priestly rulers. It does not mean humanity in general.
-
κύριος
kyrios · G2962
-
προσετίθει
prosetithei · G4369
was adding · v47
'Was adding.' The imperfect tense shows repeated, ongoing action: new people kept being added. It picks up 2:41, where about three thousand 'were added'.
-
σῳζομένους
sōzomenous · G4982
The world behind it
Jerusalem, shortly after Pentecost. Verses 42–47 are the first of Luke's short "summary" passages, which describe the habitual life of the new community. The second is 4:32–35. They are portraits of the community's typical pattern, not diary entries.
- Economic pressure. The community suddenly included thousands of people (2:41). Some were Galilean followers who had left homes and livelihoods. Others were diaspora Jews who had come for the festival and stayed. First-century Jerusalem had many poor people, widows (see 6:1) and day labourers. Sharing resources was a practical answer to real need.
- The friendship ideal. In the Greek world, "friends hold all things in common" and "one soul" were standard phrases for perfect friendship (Aristotle) and for the ideal community (Plato, the Pythagoreans). Luke picks up this vocabulary here and in 4:32.
- Jewish models. Josephus and Philo praise the Essenes for sharing property, and the Dead Sea Community Rule sets out how members' property was handed over to the community. Some scholars think there was an Essene presence in Jerusalem itself, which could have given the early believers a known model. That remains debated.
- Israel's own law. The parallel summary in 4:34 ("there was not a needy person among them") echoes Deuteronomy 15:4 ("there will be no poor among you"). Luke presents the community as fulfilling Israel's covenant ideal, not only a Greek one.
- Not a rule of the community. Later in Acts, Peter tells Ananias that his land and its price remained under his own control (5:4). Believers still own houses (2:46; 12:12). The sin in Acts 5 is lying about the gift, not keeping property.
From the study of Acts 2:44.
Where scholars differ
in v44
Was this full common ownership or ongoing voluntary sharing?
-
Real pooling of property, possibly modelled on Essene practice.
κοινά and 4:32 ("no one said any of his possessions was his own") are strong statements. Proceeds were laid at the apostles' feet (4:35, 37). The Qumran and Essene parallels show such communities really existed in Judea (Capper).
-
Voluntary sharing in response to need, with ownership still in private hands.
The imperfect verbs ("kept selling, kept distributing") and "as anyone had need" (2:45) point to sales as needs arose. In 5:4 Peter affirms Ananias's control over his property. Believers keep houses (2:46; 12:12). Barnabas's gift is singled out as notable (4:36–37), which would make little sense if everyone did it.
in v44
Is Luke giving an idealised portrait or a straightforward historical report?
-
Mainly a literary ideal, framed in Greek friendship and utopia language.
The doubled 'all', the stock phrases "all things common" and "one soul", and the use of summary passages all suggest deliberate portrayal (L. T. Johnson, *The Literary Function of Possessions in Luke-Acts*).
-
Idealised in wording but rooted in real practice.
Luke records failures that spoil the ideal (Ananias and Sapphira, 5:1–11; the widows' complaint, 6:1). Paul's later collection for the poor in Jerusalem (Rom 15:26; Gal 2:10) suggests the community really was economically strained. Similar Jewish practice is documented (Keener; Capper).
in v44
What does ἐπὶ τὸ αὐτό mean here?
-
Physical gathering in one place.
This is the ordinary sense of the idiom. The believers met regularly in the temple courts (2:46; 5:12).
-
A near-technical phrase for the assembled community, perhaps reflecting Hebrew yaḥad.
Luke repeats the phrase (1:15; 2:1, 47). The Septuagint uses it for yaḥad (Ps 2:2, quoted in Acts 4:26). Qumran used yaḥad as the name for its community. Paul uses the phrase for church assembly (1 Cor 11:20). The yaḥad connection is suggestive but unproven.
in v45
Is this a historical report or Luke's idealised portrait?
-
Substantially historical: the Jerusalem community really practised extensive voluntary sharing.
Named examples (Barnabas, Ananias and Sapphira). The 'daily distribution' and the dispute over widows (Acts 6:1). Contemporary Jewish parallels in the Essenes and Qumran show the practice was plausible in Judea. Paul's later collection 'for the poor among the saints in Jerusalem' (Romans 15:26; Galatians 2:10) fits a community with many poor members and a habit of mutual support.
-
Idealised summary: Luke shapes the picture using biblical and Greek ideals.
The summary sections (2:42–47; 4:32–35) generalise ('all', 'everything'). They echo the Greek friendship proverb 'friends have all things in common' and Deuteronomy 15:4 almost verbally. Luke Timothy Johnson and others argue possessions work in Luke-Acts as a symbol of a person's response to God.
-
Both: a real practice described in idealising language.
Many commentators (e.g. Bruce, Bock, Keener) hold that Luke uses stylised summary language to describe a real practice. The imperfect tenses and the 'as anyone had need' clause point to a real, ongoing, ad hoc system rather than a utopian constitution.
in v45
How does this relate to the Essene/Qumran community of goods?
-
Direct influence or close analogy.
Some scholars (e.g. Brian Capper) argue for Essene-style property-sharing in Jerusalem as a model, noting a possible Essene presence in the city and shared vocabulary of 'common' life.
-
A loose analogy with major differences.
Qumran made surrender of property compulsory after a probation period, under an Overseer (1QS 6). Acts stresses voluntary giving (5:4), case-by-case distribution and retained homes (2:46; 12:12).
in v45
Did the practice contribute to the Jerusalem church's later poverty?
-
Yes: selling capital assets left the community without income when famine came.
The famine relief of Acts 11:28–30 and Paul's repeated collections for Jerusalem's poor. This is an inference, not stated in the text.
-
No clear link: Jerusalem's poverty had other causes.
Famine under Claudius, the city's many dependent poor, possible persecution and economic exclusion. Acts presents the sharing positively and never criticises it.
in v46
Is the 'breaking bread' in 2:46 the Lord's Supper (Eucharist), ordinary shared meals, or both?
-
Ordinary fellowship meals
'Breaking bread' was the normal Jewish way to begin any meal. The next clause, 'they took food', describes actual eating. In Acts 27:35 Luke uses the same wording for a meal on a sinking ship that no one takes as a church rite.
-
The Lord's Supper, celebrated in homes
In 2:42 the article ('*the* breaking of *the* bread') suggests a recognised practice, listed beside teaching, fellowship and prayers. Luke 22:19 and 24:30–35 give the phrase a strong link to Jesus. Acts 20:7 describes gathering 'to break bread' on the first day of the week.
-
Both together: the Lord's Supper held within a real communal meal
1 Corinthians 11:17–34 and Didache 9–10 show the Lord's Supper eaten as part of a full meal in the earliest period. Separating the rite from the meal came later. On this view Luke's language deliberately holds meal and remembrance together (so, broadly, Bruce, Jeremias and many recent commentators).
in v46
Does ὁμοθυμαδόν mean emotional unanimity ('with one mind') or simply 'together'?
-
Unanimity of mind and purpose
The word is built from homo- 'same' + thumos 'spirit, passion'. Luke places it in contexts that stress the community's unity (1:14; 4:24; 4:32 'one heart and soul').
-
Mainly 'together, as a group'
In the Septuagint and papyri it often has only a weak sense of 'together'. Luke also uses it for mobs acting together (7:57; 19:29), where unanimity of heart is hardly the point.
in v46
Does ἀφελότης here mean 'sincerity/simplicity' or 'generosity'?
-
Simplicity, sincerity, lack of pretence
This is the core sense of the root aphelēs, 'smooth, plain, unaffected'. The Vulgate has simplicitas, and KJV, BSB, NIV and YLT follow this sense.
-
Generosity
The closely related haplotēs can mean openhanded liberality (2 Cor 8:2; 9:11), and verse 45 describes the sharing of goods. ESV and NLT adopt this sense.
in v47
Does 'echontes charin pros holon ton laon' mean the people favored the believers, or the believers showed goodwill to the people?
-
The believers enjoyed the favor/goodwill of all the people (majority view; nearly all English versions).
Luke's parallel in Luke 2:52 (Jesus grew 'in favor with God and people'); Old Testament idioms of 'finding favor before' someone; Acts 5:13 ('the people held them in high esteem') and the authorities' fear of the people (4:21; 5:26) fit a picture of popular approval.
-
The believers showed goodwill or graciousness toward all the people (argued e.g. by T. D. Andersen, NTS 34, 1988).
The usual sense of 'having X toward (pros) someone' is the subject's attitude directed at the object. The clause sits in a list of the believers' own actions (praising, having). The generosity in 2:44–45 shows the community acting kindly outward.
-
A minority suggests a gratitude sense ('giving thanks') from the idiom charin echein.
Charin echein means 'be grateful' in Luke 17:9 and 1 Tim 1:12. But the person thanked is normally in the dative case, not pros + the people, so most scholars find this reading strained.
in v47
Who is 'the Lord' who adds people: God or Jesus?
-
Jesus, the newly proclaimed Lord.
Acts 2:36 has just declared God has made Jesus 'Lord and Christ'. In 2:34 Psalm 110 is quoted ('The Lord said to my Lord'). Acts 5:14 and 11:24 speak of believers being added 'to the Lord', most naturally meaning Jesus.
-
God (the Father), the Lord of Israel.
Acts 2:39 speaks of those 'whom the Lord our God will call'. The Joel quotation (2:21) uses 'Lord' for YHWH. Throughout Acts, God is the one who acts behind the scenes.
in v47
What does the present participle 'those being saved' imply?
-
Simply descriptive: those who were being rescued at that time, i.e. each day's new converts.
The present tense matches 'day by day' and the imperfect 'was adding'. On this reading the participle is not making a doctrinal point about salvation as a process.
-
Salvation as an ongoing process begun but not yet complete.
Paul uses the same participle for believers in 1 Cor 1:18 and 2 Cor 2:15, alongside a future salvation hope. Some commentators see this sense here too, though Acts 2:47 alone does not prove it.
-
Those destined to be saved (the Vulgate/KJV-style reading 'such as should be saved').
This rests on the Latin 'qui salvi fierent'. The Greek present participle does not itself express appointment; the idea of being appointed is drawn from other texts such as Acts 13:48.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. κοινός, ἐπί, αὐτός, πιστεύω
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. κοινός
- Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Acts 2:44
- Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics 8.9 (1159b31); 9.8 (1168b7)
- Plato, Republic 424a; Laws 739c
- Iamblichus, On the Pythagorean Life 30, 168
- Josephus, Jewish War 2.122
- Philo, Quod Omnis Probus Liber Sit 85–86; Hypothetica 11
- Dead Sea Scrolls, Community Rule (1QS) 1.11–12; 6.19–22
- Luke Timothy Johnson, The Literary Function of Possessions in Luke-Acts
- Brian J. Capper, 'The Palestinian Cultural Context of Earliest Christian Community of Goods' (in The Book of Acts in Its Palestinian Setting)
- Craig S. Keener, Acts: An Exegetical Commentary, vol. 1
- F. F. Bruce, The Book of the Acts (NICNT)
- Max Wilcox, The Semitisms of Acts
- BDAG s.v. κτῆμα, ὕπαρξις, διαμερίζω, πιπράσκω, καθότι, χρεία
- Moulton & Milligan, Vocabulary of the Greek Testament, s.v. κτῆμα
- Blass, Debrunner & Funk, Greek Grammar of the NT §367 (ἄν with past indicative, iterative)
- Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Acts 2:45
- Nestle-Aland 28th ed.
- Philo, Every Good Man Is Free (Quod omnis probus liber sit) 86
- Community Rule (1QS) 6:19–22
- Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics 8.9; Plato, Republic 424a (koina ta philōn)
- Deuteronomy 15:4–11 (MT and LXX)
- Darrell L. Bock, Acts (BECNT)
- Brian Capper, 'The Palestinian Cultural Context of Earliest Christian Community of Goods', in The Book of Acts in Its Palestinian Setting
- BDAG s.v. ἀφελότης, ἀγαλλίασις, κλάω, ὁμοθυμαδόν, προσκαρτερέω, ἱερόν
- Louw & Nida, Greek-English Lexicon of the NT Based on Semantic Domains
- Moulton & Milligan, Vocabulary of the Greek Testament (s.v. προσκαρτερέω, ὁμοθυμαδόν)
- Joachim Jeremias, The Eucharistic Words of Jesus
- Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (Acts 2:46–47)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament (Acts 2:42–47)
- Josephus, Jewish War 5.184–227; Antiquities 15.380–425 (temple courts and porticoes)
- Didache 9–10; 1 Corinthians 11:17–34
- BDAG s.v. χάρις, λαός, σῴζω, προστίθημι, αὐτός (ἐπὶ τὸ αὐτό)
- Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. σῴζω
- B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Acts 2:47
- NA28 / SBLGNT critical text of Acts 2:47
- T. D. Andersen, 'The Meaning of ΕΧΟΝΤΕΣ ΧΑΡΙΝ ΠΡΟΣ in Acts 2.47', New Testament Studies 34 (1988)
- M. Wilcox, The Semitisms of Acts (on ἐπὶ τὸ αὐτό and yaḥad)
- Community Rule (1QS), use of yaḥad
- C. K. Barrett, Acts (ICC), vol. 1
- F. F. Bruce, The Acts of the Apostles: Greek Text
- J. A. Fitzmyer, The Acts of the Apostles (Anchor Bible)
- Latin Vulgate, Acts 2:47
- Joel 2:28–32 (LXX 3:1–5)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).