John Chapter 15 Read as one passage

John 15:8–12

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

8This is to My Father’s glory, that you bear much fruit, proving yourselves to be My disciples. 9As the Father has loved Me, so have I loved you. Remain in My love. 10If you keep My commandments, you will remain in My love, just as I have kept My Father’s commandments and remain in His love. 11I have told you these things so that My joy may be in you and your joy may be complete. 12This is My commandment, that you love one another as I have loved you.

What the first hearers heard

For the Eleven that night, the verse turned a shock into a calling. Their teacher was about to leave them, and he described their future as fruit-bearing branches whose whole life depended on staying joined to him. The point was not to prove themselves by achievement. A branch cannot produce grapes by trying; it carries the life of the vine.

For Jewish hearers the words carried Israel's own story. God had planted a vine and looked for fruit. The prophets lamented wild grapes, and Isaiah promised a planting through which God would be glorified. Jesus places himself at the centre of that story as the true vine, and his followers as branches in whom Israel's purpose is finally met. The honour of God, the thing Israel existed to display, would now be seen in a community whose lives yield what his life yields.

For John's first readers, probably believers who had been pushed out of the synagogue (compare 9:22; 16:2), the verse answered the question of who truly belongs. Belonging to God's vine no longer rested on descent or institution. It meant remaining in Jesus, and that showed itself in fruit. That is how one becomes, and shows oneself to be, his disciple. The verse is both a comfort (the Father is honoured in them) and a warning (fruitless branches are removed, v.6).

From the study of John 15:8.

Verse by verse

  1. 8This is to My Father’s glory, that you bear much fruit, proving yourselves to be My disciples.

    "This is how my Father has been glorified: you keep bearing much fruit, and so you come to be, and show yourselves to be, my disciples."

    Jesus is still inside the picture he began in verse 1. He is the true vine, his Father is the vinedresser, and the disciples are branches. A vineyard's heavy harvest brings credit to the one who tends it. In the same way, the Father's worth and character (his "glory", which in biblical language means his honour, his weight, who he really is made visible) are put on display when the branches are loaded with fruit. Jesus states this as a settled fact. He uses a past-tense form ("was glorified"), just as verse 6 used past-tense forms for the fruitless branch that "was thrown out and withered". In John's way of speaking, what happens to those who remain in him and those who do not is already decided.

    "Fruit" is the grapes of the vine. Behind it stands Israel's long story as God's vine, the vineyard from which God looked for the fruit of justice and faithfulness (Isaiah 5). Branches that draw their life from Jesus now produce what God always looked for. That fruit includes the love and obedience that the following verses spell out, and the harvest of people that Jesus' own death would bring ("if it dies, it bears much fruit", 12:24). "Much" means abundance, and "bear" is in a continuing tense: a life that keeps yielding, season after season.

    The last phrase does not tell outsiders how to start following Jesus. He is speaking to men who already follow him. To "become" his disciples here is to grow fully into what they are and to show it. A disciple was a learner bound to a teacher, and the proof of being Jesus' learner is a life that carries his life. Fruit-bearing and discipleship are two sides of one thing, and both bring honour to the Father.

    Full study →
  2. 9As the Father has loved Me, so have I loved you. Remain in My love.

    "Just as the Father loved me, in that same way, and from that same source, I have loved you. Now stay in my love. Don't leave it. Make it your home."

    Jesus says this on the night before his death, in the middle of the vine-and-branches teaching. He describes a chain of love that starts with the Father. The Father has loved the Son, a love John elsewhere says existed "before the foundation of the world" (17:24). That same love, not just a copy of it, is what Jesus has given his followers. Both statements use the same verb in the same tense, so the grammar itself mirrors the claim. Each love is presented as a whole, completed fact, and on this night it is about to be shown fully at the cross ("he loved them to the end," 13:1).

    Then comes a command: remain. The word is the plain, everyday Greek verb for staying where you are, lodging in a house, not going away. Jesus does not tell the disciples to reach for his love or to earn it. They are already in it, and they are to stay there, as branches stay attached to the vine. "My love" is stressed in the Greek ("the love that is mine"), and the next verse shows that it means Jesus' love for them. They remain in it the way he remains in his Father's love, by keeping commands (15:10).

    The love in view is warm and fatherly, and it is also loyal. In Israel's scriptures, love and keeping commandments belong together. So "remain in my love" means both resting in being loved and staying faithful within that relationship.

    Full study →
  3. 10If you keep My commandments, you will remain in My love, just as I have kept My Father’s commandments and remain in His love.

    "If you guard and carry out the commands I have given you, you will go on living in my love, the love I have already poured out on you. That is how it has been with me: I have kept my Father's charges, every one of them, all the way through, and I go on living, unbroken, in his love."

    A few things the Greek holds together that English can flatten:

    • "Remain" is about staying, not arriving. Verse 9 has just said, "As the Father has loved me, so have I loved you." The disciples are already inside this love. The verb (menō) is the one used throughout the vine picture. Branches stay in the vine. So the verse explains how one stays where one has been placed, not how one gets in.
    • "My love" means Jesus' love for them. It is not chiefly their love for him. It is pictured as a home to live in.
    • "Keep" means guard and carry out. The commands are not a list of rules. Two verses later Jesus gathers them into one: "love one another as I have loved you" (v. 12).
    • Jesus himself is the pattern. "I have kept" is in a Greek tense that describes a finished act whose result stands. Speaking the night before his death, Jesus describes his faithfulness to the Father as complete, including the Father's charge to lay down his life (10:18; 14:31). "I remain" is present and ongoing. The Son did not earn the Father's love. He had it "before the foundation of the world" (17:24). His obedience is how that love was lived out, and the disciples' life is meant to have the same shape.
    Full study →
  4. 11I have told you these things so that My joy may be in you and your joy may be complete.

    "Everything I have just told you about the vine and its branches, about staying in me and in my love, I have said for one purpose. My own joy, the gladness I have as the Son who is loved by the Father and keeps his commands, is meant to live in you. And your joy, your own and not a borrowed one, is meant to be filled to the brim."

    The joy comes first in the sentence and is then pressed home: the joy, mine. Jesus says this on the night before his death, to men who are about to be "filled with grief" (16:6), and just before he warns them that the world will hate them (15:18). He is not offering a calm that has no feeling in it. He is offering real gladness, the kind that belongs to a wedding and to God's promised feast, and he roots it in his own relationship with the Father. The words "I have spoken" are in a tense that means the speaking is finished and still stands, so his words will stay with them after he goes. Through those words his joy enters them, and their own joy is brought to full measure. The passive "be made full" quietly leaves God as the one who fills it.

    Full study →
  5. 12This is My commandment, that you love one another as I have loved you.

    "Here it is, the charge that is truly mine, the one I am leaving you: that you keep on loving one another, all of you together, in the same way I loved you, and because I loved you."

    Jesus is speaking at his last meal, hours before his arrest. A moment ago he washed their feet (13:1–15), doing a slave's job. In the next sentence (v.13) he names the furthest point of love: laying down one's life for one's friends. So "as I loved you" does not refer to a warm feeling. It refers to things the disciples have just seen him do and to what he is about to do. The past tense ("I loved") speaks of that whole self-giving as if it were already complete.

    "Commandment" is meant seriously. It is a binding charge, the same word John uses for the Father's charge to Jesus himself. But it is singular. All of Jesus' "commandments" (v.10) are summed up in this one, and like "my joy" in the verse before, it is something of his own that he gives them. The love asked for is continuing (present tense), shared (it runs among "one another") and borrowed: they can give it only because they have first received it.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v8

    glorified / to my Father's glory

    edoxasthē (doxazō)

    What we hear
    Praised in words or song, as in worship ("we glorify you").
    What they heard
    Honoured by having his real worth and character made visible. In the image, the vinedresser is credited with a rich harvest. Here God is glorified by what the disciples' lives show, not first by what they say.
  • in v8

    disciples

    mathētai

    What we hear
    Either a special, more committed tier of Christian ("converts" versus "disciples"), or the first step of becoming a Christian.
    What they heard
    Learners attached to a teacher and following him. Jesus is speaking to people who are already his disciples. "Become disciples" means growing into it and showing it, not a second class of believer and not first conversion.
  • in v8

    fruit

    karpos

    What we hear
    Often filled in with the virtue list of Galatians 5, or with measurable ministry results such as number of converts.
    What they heard
    The yield of the vine: the whole outcome of a life drawing on Jesus. In context it includes love and obedience (vv.9–17) and the gathering of others (12:24; 15:16). Israel's vine imagery stands behind it, where the fruit God wanted was justice and faithfulness.
  • in v9

    abide (ESV, NASB) / remain

    menō

    What we hear
    Either an archaic word for 'tolerate', or, in church usage, a passive, quiet inner state of spiritual communion cultivated through devotion.
    What they heard
    The ordinary verb for staying put, remaining, lodging or not leaving, with the idea of lasting over time. It describes a continuing loyalty, which verse 10 defines as keeping Jesus' commands, as well as a place to rest.
  • in v9

    love

    agapaō / agapē

    What we hear
    Mainly a feeling or emotional attachment. Alternatively, in popular teaching, a uniquely divine, 'unconditional' kind of love built into the word agapē.
    What they heard
    Love that includes affection but is defined by loyalty and action: giving, obeying, laying down one's life (John 3:16; 14:15; 15:10, 13). It sits in the covenant setting of Deuteronomy, where love and keeping commands go together.
  • in v10

    abide (KJV, ESV, NASB)

    menō

    What we hear
    A special, quiet, mystical spiritual state, often treated as a devotional technique one learns.
    What they heard
    The ordinary word for staying, remaining, continuing to live somewhere. Here it means staying connected to Jesus' love the way a branch stays in the vine.
  • in v10

    commandments

    entolai

    What we hear
    A rulebook or list of religious regulations, often heard as the opposite of love and grace.
    What they heard
    Covenant instructions from someone who loves you. In John, Jesus' commands centre on one: love one another as he has loved you (13:34; 15:12).
  • in v11

    joy

    chara

    What we hear
    Either a private happy mood, or, in much church teaching, a deep and settled contentment set against 'happiness' and largely free of emotion.
    What they heard
    Gladness and delight, a real and often outward emotion. It was the word for festival, wedding and harvest joy, and for the joy expected when God restores his people. In this verse it is the gladness Jesus has in the Father's love, shared with his disciples.
  • in v11

    may be complete

    plērōthē

    What we hear
    Finished or wrapped up, with nothing left to add.
    What they heard
    Filled up to full measure, like a vessel brimming over. In John it is a set phrase for joy that reaches its full measure (3:29; 16:24; 17:13).
  • in v12

    love

    agapaō

    What we hear
    Mostly a feeling of affection or attraction. Something that happens to you and therefore cannot really be ordered.
    What they heard
    Devoted, loyal care that shows in action. It can be commanded because it is something you do and keep doing (present tense). Its shape here is set by Jesus' acts: washing feet, giving his life.
Every word
  1. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in, by · v8, v9, v10, v11

    Marks the thing in which the Father's glory is found or shown: "in this", "by this". It points to a situation, not a place.

  2. τούτῳ

    toutō · G3778

    this · v8, v11, v12

    "This" points forward to the clause that follows ("that you bear much fruit"), a habit of John's style (compare 1 John 4:17; John 17:3). Some take it as also looking back to the answered prayer of verse 7.

  3. ἐδοξάσθη

    edoxasthē · G1392

    to glorify, honour · v8

    Literally "was glorified". The Father's worth and character are made visible and honoured. The past-tense form states the result as already settled, the same way verse 6 says the fruitless branch "was thrown out and withered".

  4. ὁ

    ho · G3588

    the · v8, v9, v10, v11, v12

    Definite article with "Father". It points to the vinedresser of verse 1 ("my Father is the vinedresser").

  5. πατήρ

    patēr · G3962

    father · v8, v9, v10

    The Father, already introduced in this allegory as the vinegrower who prunes and tends the vine (15:1–2). A vineyard's harvest brings credit to its owner.

  6. μου,

    mou · G3165

    of me, my · v8, v9, v10

    "My Father". Jesus speaks of the Father as his own, which matters in John, where the Son's unique relation to the Father is central.

  7. ἵνα

    hina · G2443

    that, in order that · v8, v11, v12

    Here it mostly explains what "this" is ("namely, that…") rather than stating a goal. A sense of purpose may still be present: this is what the Father is after.

  8. καρπὸν

    karpon · G2590

    fruit, produce · v8

    In the vine picture, the grapes a branch yields. It stands for the visible result of a life drawing on Jesus. In Israel's scriptures God looked to his vine for this fruit, meaning justice and faithfulness (Isa 5:7).

  9. πολὺν

    polyn · G4183

    much, abundant · v8

    "Much" picks up verse 5 ("bears much fruit") and echoes 12:24, where the grain of wheat that dies "bears much fruit". The picture is abundance, a heavy harvest.

  10. φέρητε

    pherēte · G5342

    to bear, carry, produce · v8

    Ordinary farming language for a plant yielding produce. The present-tense form suggests continuing to bear fruit season after season, not a single harvest.

  11. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v8, v10, v11

    Joins the two parts of what glorifies the Father: bearing fruit and becoming disciples. The two are presented as one reality seen from two sides.

  12. γένησθε

    genēsthe · G1096

    to become, come to be, prove to be · v8

    The Eleven are already disciples (13:35), so "become" means coming to be fully and visibly what they are, showing themselves true disciples. Hence BSB's "proving yourselves".

  13. ἐμοὶ

    emoi · G1473

    my, mine · v8, v10

    Most likely the possessive adjective "my" ("my disciples"), a form John favours. The same spelling could also be read "disciples to me". Either way it means disciples belonging to Jesus.

  14. μαθηταί.

    mathētai · G3101

    learner, pupil, disciple · v8

    A learner attached to a teacher, who follows him and takes on his teaching and way of life. In John it is the ordinary word for Jesus' followers, but John also distinguishes those who are "truly" disciples (8:31).

  15. καθὼς

    kathōs · G2531

    just as, even as · v9, v10, v12

    Opens a comparison: the Father's love for Jesus sets the pattern for Jesus' love for the disciples. In John it often also hints at a source, meaning 'in the same way as, and because of'.

  16. ἠγάπησέν

    ēgapēsen · G0025

    to love · v9, v12

    'Loved'. The past tense used here presents the Father's love for the Son as one whole, complete fact rather than a process. In John 17:24 that love goes back 'before the foundation of the world'.

  17. κἀγὼ

    kagō · G2504

    and I, I also · v9

    A merged form of 'and' plus 'I'. It completes the comparison ('so I too') and stresses Jesus as the one who now loves in turn, passing on the love he received.

  18. ὑμᾶς

    humas · G4771

    you (plural) · v9, v11, v12

    The disciples as a group. It is plural, so the love is given to the community and is not only a private matter between Jesus and one person.

  19. μείνατε

    meinate · G3306

    stay, remain, abide · v9, v10

    A plural command: 'remain!', 'stay!' It means to stay where you already are rather than to reach for somewhere new. The disciples are already inside Jesus' love, and they are told not to leave it.

  20. ἀγάπῃ

    agapē · G0026

    love · v9, v10

    The noun matching the verb used twice before it. It is the love already shown, now pictured as a space to stay inside.

  21. ἐμῇ.

    emē · G1699

    my, mine · v9, v11, v12

    A stressed form of 'my', stronger than the ordinary 'of me'. Verse 10 shows that it means Jesus' love for them, the same way Jesus remains in the Father's love for him.

  22. ἐὰν

    ean · G1437

    if · v10

    Introduces an open, general condition: 'if (and whenever) you keep…'. It states a real link between keeping and remaining. It neither doubts the disciples nor treats the outcome as automatic.

  23. ἐντολάς

    entolas · G1785

    commandments · v10, v12

    Instructions given with authority. The word carries the weight of Israel's covenant commands, but here they are Jesus' own, and two verses later he sums them up as one: 'love one another as I have loved you' (15:12).

  24. τηρήσητε

    tērēsēte · G5083

    keep, guard · v10

    To keep in the sense of guarding, holding on to and carrying out. The tense views the keeping as a whole rather than as a moment-by-moment process.

  25. αὐτοῦ

    autou · G846

    his · v10

    'His.' It is placed early, before 'in the love', which puts mild weight on whose love it is: the Father's.

  26. λελάληκα

    lelalēka · G2980

    I have spoken · v11

    A perfect tense: the speaking is finished, and what was said stays with them. Jesus is talking on the night before his death, and his words will remain with them after he is gone. 'These things I have spoken to you' comes back again and again through the farewell speech (14:25; 16:1, 4, 6, 25, 33).

  27. χαρὰ

    chara · G5479

    joy, gladness · v11

    The ordinary Greek word for gladness and delight. Here it is the gladness Jesus himself has in his Father's love, and he means to share it with them.

  28. ᾖ

    ē · G1510

    may be · v11, v12

    A present-tense 'may be' that looks to a lasting state: that my joy may be there, and stay there. (Later manuscripts read 'may remain'; see textual notes.)

  29. πληρωθῇ

    plērōthē · G4137

    may be filled, made full · v11

    An aorist passive 'may be filled'. The picture is a vessel filled to the brim. The passive leaves the filler unnamed (most likely God, through Jesus). John uses this same phrase, 'joy made full', as a fixed expression.

  30. ἀλλήλους

    allēlous · G240

    one another · v12

    Reciprocal: the love is to run back and forth among the disciples themselves. The focus is the inner life of the community Jesus is leaving behind.

The world behind it

The night before the cross. These words belong to Jesus' farewell speech at the last supper (John 13–17), spoken to the Eleven after Judas has left (13:30). He is preparing them to keep going without his physical presence. "Remain in me" (15:4–7) is the heart of that preparation.

The vine as Israel's emblem. To a first-century Jew, a vine meant Israel. The scriptures called Israel God's vine or vineyard (Psalm 80; Isaiah 5; 27:2–6; Jeremiah 2:21; Ezekiel 15; 17; 19; Hosea 10:1), and usually complained that it gave no good fruit. Isaiah described Israel as God's planting "that he may be glorified" (60:21; 61:3). The vine was also a national symbol in stone and metal: according to Josephus, a huge golden vine hung over the entrance to Herod's temple sanctuary (Antiquities 15.395), and Jewish coins of the revolts against Rome bore vine leaves and grape clusters. When Jesus says "I am the true vine", he is claiming that Israel's calling to bear fruit for God's glory is now fulfilled in him and in those who are joined to him. Verse 8 completes that thought: when the branches bear much fruit, the vinedresser is glorified, which is exactly what Isaiah said God's planting was for.

Viticulture. Judean vinedressers cut away dead and unproductive wood and trimmed living branches so that the plant's strength went into grapes. Cut-off branches were dried and burned (v.6). A vineyard was judged by its yield, and a rich harvest brought honour to its owner. In an honour-based society, that is the picture behind "this is to my Father's glory".

Disciples and teachers. In the Jewish and Greek world a disciple was attached to a teacher, followed him, learned his teaching and copied his way of life. A teacher was honoured by the quality and number of his students. John also knew that some who were called disciples turned away (6:66), and Jesus had said "if you remain in my word, you are truly my disciples" (8:31). The same verb, "remain", runs through chapter 15.

From the study of John 15:8.

Where scholars differ

in v8

What is the "fruit"?

  • The character and conduct of disciples, especially love and obedience.

    The following verses (9–17) explain remaining in terms of keeping commands and loving one another. Israel's vine texts define fruit as justice and righteousness (Isa 5:7). Elsewhere in the Gospels fruit means deeds that come from character (Matt 7:16–20).

  • Mission: people brought to faith through the disciples.

    John 12:24 uses the identical phrase "bears much fruit" for the many gathered through Jesus' death. John 4:36 speaks of gathering "fruit for eternal life". 15:16 says "go and bear fruit". 17:20 looks to those who will believe through their word.

  • Both: the whole yield of a life lived in union with Jesus, inner and outward.

    John never defines the word within the allegory. Love among disciples is itself what makes the world recognise them (13:35; 17:21–23), so character and mission belong together. Many major commentators (e.g. Brown, Carson, Keener) take a broad view.

in v8

What does "in this" refer to?

  • Forward, to the "that" clause: the Father is glorified in your bearing much fruit.

    John regularly uses "in this / this is… that" to point forward to a clause that explains it (17:3; 1 John 4:17; 5:3). Most translations and commentators read it this way.

  • Backward, to verse 7: the Father is glorified in answered prayer, with the result that you bear fruit.

    John 14:13 explicitly connects answered prayer with the Father being glorified. Read this way, the "that" clause states purpose rather than content.

in v8

Why the past tense "was glorified"?

  • It anticipates the result: the outcome is so certain it is spoken of as done.

    John 13:31 ("now the Son of Man was glorified") speaks the same way on the same night. Verse 6 uses past-tense verbs for the future fate of fruitless branches.

  • It is a timeless statement of a general principle, like a proverb.

    Greek can use this form for general truths, and some see a Hebrew or Aramaic idiom behind it. The surrounding allegory states general principles of how vines and branches work.

in v9

Does 'just as' (kathōs) only compare the two loves, or does it also give the source of Jesus' love?

  • Comparison: Jesus' love for the disciples is like the Father's love for him, in quality and degree.

    'Just as' is the most common sense of kathōs, and the 'as… so' structure is a natural comparison.

  • Comparison plus source: Jesus' love is the Father's love passed on, so it is the same love and not just a similar one.

    BDAG recognizes a causal sense ('since, inasmuch as'). John repeatedly uses kathōs for things that pass from Father to Son to disciples (13:34; 17:18, 21–23). In 17:26 Jesus prays that 'the love with which you loved me may be in them'.

in v9

Does 'my love' mean Jesus' love for the disciples or their love for Jesus?

  • Jesus' love for them.

    Verse 10 is a parallel: Jesus 'remains in [the Father's] love', meaning the Father's love for him. The verse begins with the love Jesus has shown ('I have loved you').

  • Both, or including the disciples' answering love.

    Verse 10 ties remaining to the disciples' obedience, and elsewhere love for Jesus is shown by keeping his commands (14:15, 21). Some commentators therefore hear the disciples' own loving loyalty included.

in v9

How should the first half be punctuated?

  • Two sentences: 'As the Father loved me, so I have loved you. Remain in my love.'

    The printed punctuation of the standard critical editions and nearly all translations. The 'as… so' pattern matches 15:12 and 17:18.

  • One sentence: 'As the Father loved me and I loved you, remain in my love.'

    Grammatically possible, since κἀγώ can mean 'and I'. It has been noted as an option by some commentators (e.g. discussed in Brown and Barrett), but it is a minority reading.

in v10

Does 'my love' mean Jesus' love for the disciples, or their love for him?

  • Jesus' love for them (the most common reading).

    Verse 9 sets it up: 'so have I loved you; remain in my love.' The parallel in the second half is the Father's love for the Son, not the Son's love for the Father.

  • Both: a shared, mutual love the disciples live within.

    John often describes mutual indwelling ('remain in me, and I in you', 15:4), and 14:15, 21 links the disciples' love for Jesus with keeping his commands.

in v10

Is keeping the commandments the condition for staying loved, or the shape of life within a love already given?

  • A real condition: failing to keep the commands means not remaining.

    The grammar is a genuine 'if' clause. The surrounding passage warns that branches that do not remain are thrown out and burned (15:6).

  • The expression and means of remaining, not the basis of the love.

    The love comes first (v. 9; 13:1; 15:16, 'I chose you'). Jesus' own case is the model, and he did not earn the Father's love, which existed before creation (17:24). The commands are summed up as love itself (v. 12).

  • Both held together, which is how many commentators read John: love that comes first and loyal keeping are inseparable, as in Deuteronomy's covenant.

    Deut 7:9 joins God's prior covenant love with 'those who love him and keep his commandments'. John 14:21–23 has love and keeping flowing in both directions.

in v11

What does 'these things' (tauta) refer to?

  • The vine section just before it (15:1–10), about remaining in Jesus and in his love.

    The verse follows straight on from 15:10 and repeats its 'in you' language. The refrain elsewhere usually looks back at the section just finished (e.g. 16:1, 33).

  • The whole farewell teaching so far (chs. 13–15).

    The refrain works across the whole speech, and themes from earlier, such as Jesus' departure and the coming Spirit, also support joy (14:28: 'you would rejoice that I am going to the Father').

in v11

What is 'my joy'?

  • Jesus' own joy: the gladness he has as the Son who obeys and is loved by the Father, now shared with the disciples.

    The emphatic 'mine' and the direct link to 15:10 ('I have kept my Father's commandments and remain in his love'). Compare 17:13, 'my joy made full in themselves'.

  • The joy Jesus gives or brings about, the joy of salvation or of the new age.

    In 16:20–24 joy comes as a gift after the sorrow of his death and his return. 'My peace' in 14:27 is likewise something given ('I give to you'). The two readings overlap; most commentators combine them.

in v11

When is the joy 'made full'?

  • Already, in the disciples' present life of remaining in Jesus.

    The present 'may be in you' and the vine image describe an ongoing relationship.

  • Chiefly after the resurrection and the Spirit's coming, with a fuller completion at the end.

    16:20–24 places the fullness of joy after the sorrow ('I will see you again, and your hearts will rejoice'). 20:20 records, 'the disciples rejoiced when they saw the Lord.' John often describes the end-time gifts as begun now and completed later.

in v12

Is 'one another' a narrowing of love to insiders only?

  • John's love command has an in-group focus that is noticeably narrower than 'love your enemies' in Matthew and Luke.

    In John and 1 John the command is always 'one another' or 'the brothers'. There is no explicit love-of-enemies teaching. The Qumran community offers a parallel love for insiders.

  • The focus is on the community, but the community's love is meant to reach outward, not to exclude.

    13:35: the world will recognize the disciples by this love. 3:16: God loved 'the world'. 17:21: their unity is meant 'so that the world may believe'. Unlike Qumran, John never commands hatred of outsiders.

in v12

Does kathōs mean only 'like' or also 'because'?

  • Comparison: Jesus' love is the pattern to imitate.

    This is the most common sense, and v.13 immediately describes what that pattern looks like.

  • Comparison and ground: love one another because I first loved you.

    BDAG lists a causal sense. 15:9 sets out a chain of love passed from Father to Son to disciples. 1 John 4:11, 19 ('since God so loved us… we love because he first loved us') makes the grounding explicit.

in v12

What does 'I loved you' (aorist) refer to?

  • Mainly the footwashing and Jesus' whole ministry, which in the story is now complete.

    13:1 ('having loved his own… he loved them to the end') introduces the footwashing. 13:34 ties the new command to it.

  • It anticipates the cross, spoken from the standpoint of the completed work.

    V.13 defines the greatest love as laying down one's life. In the farewell speeches Jesus often speaks as if the 'hour' were already past (e.g. 16:33; 17:4, 11).

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. δοξάζω, καρπός, μαθητής, γίνομαι, ἵνα
  • Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed. (text and apparatus at John 15:8)
  • Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, 2nd ed., on John 15:8
  • Raymond E. Brown, The Gospel according to John XIII–XXI (Anchor Bible)
  • D. A. Carson, The Gospel according to John (Pillar NT Commentary)
  • Craig S. Keener, The Gospel of John: A Commentary
  • Daniel B. Wallace, Greek Grammar Beyond the Basics (on the timeless and anticipatory uses of the past tense; content use of ἵνα)
  • Septuagint: Isaiah 5:1–7; 27:2–6; 60:21; 61:3; Psalm 80; Sirach 24:17
  • Josephus, Antiquities 8.354; 15.395
  • Mishnah Avot 1:1
  • Vulgate, John 15:8
  • BDAG s.v. ἀγαπάω, ἀγάπη, καθώς, μένω, ἐμός
  • Louw–Nida, Greek-English Lexicon (domains 25 'Attitudes and Emotions', 85 'Existence in Space', 68 'Aspect')
  • Septuagint: Deut 6:5; 7:8–9; Hos 11:1; Isa 40:8; 2 Sam (2 Kgdms) 13:15
  • R. E. Brown, The Gospel according to John XIII–XXI (Anchor Bible)
  • C. K. Barrett, The Gospel according to St John
  • D. A. Carson, The Gospel according to John (PNTC); Exegetical Fallacies (on agapaō/phileō)
  • W. L. Moran, 'The Ancient Near Eastern Background of the Love of God in Deuteronomy', CBQ 25 (1963)
  • Nestle–Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed.
  • Vulgate, John 15:9
  • BDAG s.v. μένω, τηρέω, ἐντολή, ἀγάπη, καθώς
  • Louw–Nida, Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament, domains 'remain' and 'obey'
  • D. A. Carson, The Gospel according to John (Pillar)
  • James Barr, 'Words for Love in Biblical Greek'
  • Septuagint, Deuteronomy 6:5–6; 7:9
  • Vulgate, John 15:10
  • Nestle-Aland, Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed. (apparatus at John 15:11)
  • BDAG (Bauer–Danker–Arndt–Gingrich, Greek-English Lexicon) s.v. χαρά
  • BDAG s.v. πληρόω
  • BDAG s.v. ἐμός
  • TDNT s.v. χαίρω, χαρά (Conzelmann)
  • Raymond E. Brown, The Gospel According to John XIII–XXI (Anchor Bible)
  • D. A. Carson, The Gospel According to John (Pillar NT Commentary)
  • Diogenes Laertius, Lives of the Philosophers 7.116 (Stoic 'good emotions', including chara)
  • Septuagint: Deut 16:14–15; Isa 35:10; 51:11; Ps 104:15 (LXX 103:15)
  • BDAG s.v. ἀγαπάω, ἐντολή, καθώς, ἵνα, ἐμός
  • Louw–Nida, semantic domain 25 (love, affection)
  • Septuagint (LXX): Lev 19:18; Deut 6:5; 2 Sam 13:1, 15
  • D. A. Carson, Exegetical Fallacies (on agapaō/phileō)
  • D. A. Carson, The Gospel According to John (Pillar)
  • Daniel B. Wallace, Greek Grammar Beyond the Basics (ἵνα giving the content of a command)
  • Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs (Testament of Gad 6)
  • Qumran Community Rule, 1QS 1:9–10

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).