Mark Chapter 8 Read as one passage

Mark 8:1–9

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

1In those days the crowd once again became very large, and they had nothing to eat. Jesus called the disciples to Him and said, 2“I have compassion for this crowd, because they have already been with Me three days and have nothing to eat. 3If I send them home hungry, they will faint along the way. For some of them have come a great distance.” 4His disciples replied, “Where in this desolate place could anyone find enough bread to feed all these people?” 5“How many loaves do you have?” Jesus asked. “Seven,” they replied. 6And He instructed the crowd to sit down on the ground. Then He took the seven loaves, gave thanks and broke them, and gave them to His disciples to set before the people. And they distributed them to the crowd. 7They also had a few small fish, and Jesus blessed them and ordered that these be set before them as well. 8The people ate and were satisfied, and the disciples picked up seven basketfuls of broken pieces that were left over. 9And about four thousand men were present. And when Jesus had dismissed the crowd,

What the first hearers heard

For Mark's first readers, this verse was the cue that a story they had already heard was about to be told again, with differences. The opening "in those days… again a large crowd… nothing to eat" deliberately recalls 6:30–44, and the differences that follow carry the meaning:

  • Jesus is the one who sees the need and acts. He summons the disciples. They do not come to him.
  • The setting, by most readings, is outside Jewish Galilee. If so, the crowd is likely mostly non-Jewish. This comes right after the Syrophoenician woman's plea for "crumbs" from the children's table (7:24–30). A feeding of Gentiles would show the "bread" now reaching them too.
  • The disciples are being tested. Having seen five thousand fed, will they trust that Jesus can do it again? Their reply in 8:4 shows they do not yet understand. Mark brings this to a head in 8:14–21, where Jesus asks them to recall the baskets left over from both feedings: "Do you not yet understand?"

Mark's audience, probably a mixed community of Jewish and Gentile believers, would hear in this double feeding that Jesus' provision was not confined to one people. They would also hear a warning, echoed through the Gospel, against being as slow to understand as the original disciples.

From the study of Mark 8:1.

Verse by verse

  1. 1In those days the crowd once again became very large, and they had nothing to eat. Jesus called the disciples to Him and said,

    "During that time, once more there was a large crowd, and the people had nothing at all to eat. Jesus called his students over to him and says to them:"

    The verse is set-up for a scene, and almost every element of it does a job:

    • "In those days" loosely links this story to the journeys just described (7:24–37). On the most natural reading of 7:31, Jesus is still in the Decapolis, the ten-city region east of the Sea of Galilee where most people were not Jews.
    • "Once more" a large crowd gathers. Anyone who has just heard the feeding of the five thousand (6:30–44) recognises the situation: a remote place, a huge crowd, no food. Mark is deliberately setting up a second, parallel feeding.
    • The crowd is one mass ("a large crowd being there"), but Mark switches to the plural ("they had nothing they could eat"). The focus moves from the crowd as a whole to many hungry individuals. Verse 2 adds that they have been there three days, and verse 3 that some have come "from far away".
    • This time Jesus starts the action. He summons the disciples to himself. In the first feeding the disciples came to him wanting to send the people away.
    • "He says" is in the present tense. Mark often tells past events this way, which makes the scene feel as if it is happening in front of the listener. It leads straight into Jesus' words: "I have compassion on this crowd…"
    Full study →
  2. 2“I have compassion for this crowd, because they have already been with Me three days and have nothing to eat.

    “I am moved to the depths of my being for this crowd. It’s been three days now that they have stayed on here with me, and they have nothing left to eat.”

    Jesus is speaking privately to his disciples (8:1). The first word he uses, splagchnizomai, comes from the Greek word for the inner organs, the gut and heart, where people of the time located deep feeling. He is not describing polite sympathy. He is telling them that what he sees affects him physically. He gives two concrete reasons, joined by “and.” First, the people have stayed on with him: the verb suggests sticking close and persevering, not just hanging around. Second, after three days in the open country, whatever food they brought is gone. The time phrase comes out in a loose, spoken way (“it’s three days already”), which makes the words sound like real speech. The verse ends on the most basic need there is: what they might eat.

    So his compassion has a specific object: hungry bodies, and the loyalty that brought them there. The next verse makes the danger explicit (some may collapse on the long walk home), and the verse as a whole prepares for Jesus to act as host and feed them.

    Full study →
  3. 3If I send them home hungry, they will faint along the way. For some of them have come a great distance.”

    Jesus has just said that his gut is wrenched for this crowd (v.2). Now he spells out why: "If I dismiss them to go home with empty stomachs, they will give out on the road. Their strength will go slack and their legs will fold under them. And some of them have travelled a long way to be here."

    The people have not been fasting for religious reasons. They have simply run out of food after three days in open country. "Faint" here does not mean a brief dizzy spell. It means a body that stops being able to walk, the kind of collapse the Old Testament describes among hungry people in the wilderness. Mark's Greek has a small wordplay: the verb for sending them off (apolyō, "loosen, release") and the verb for collapsing (eklyō, "be loosened, go slack") share a root. To "loosen" them from Jesus' presence would be to leave them to "come loose" on the road.

    The final clause looks at the people as they are now: they have come from far off and are still here, stranded a long way from food. In this largely Gentile region east of the Sea of Galilee, "from far away" may also have reminded early hearers of the biblical "far-off ones", the outsiders and the nations gathered in. On the surface, though, it is the practical reason the danger is real.

    This time Jesus raises the problem himself, before anyone asks. In the earlier feeding the disciples were the ones who wanted the crowd sent away.

    Full study →
  4. 4His disciples replied, “Where in this desolate place could anyone find enough bread to feed all these people?”

    And his disciples answered him: "From where is anyone going to get enough to fill these people up — loaves, here, out in an empty wilderness?"

    Several things in the Greek are easy to miss in English:

    • "From where" (pothen) asks about a source, not just a method. Where could bread possibly come from in a place that has none? The question expects the answer "nowhere."
    • "Will anyone be able" is a future-tense rhetorical question that amounts to no one can. The disciples speak about human ability in general and leave Jesus out of the calculation, even though he fed five thousand only a short time before (6:35–44).
    • "Fill up" (chortazō, a word first used for fattening animals on fodder) means a full meal for a crowd of about four thousand, not a token handout. Mark uses the same verb in 8:8 when the impossible happens: "they ate and were filled."
    • "Wilderness" (erēmia) is open, empty country with no villages and no markets, not necessarily sand. To Jewish ears it also called up Israel in the wilderness. Moses once asked, "From where am I to get meat for all this people?" (Numbers 11:13), and the wilderness generation scoffed, "Will God be able to spread a table in the wilderness?" (Psalm 78:19).

    So the disciples' realistic objection also repeats an old wilderness doubt. Jesus does not reply with a rebuke. He asks about what they already have: "How many loaves do you have?" (8:5).

    Full study →
  5. 5“How many loaves do you have?” Jesus asked. “Seven,” they replied.

    The disciples have just said there is no way anyone could find enough bread in this empty country to feed so many people. Jesus does not argue with them. He keeps asking them a simple, practical question: "How many loaves do you have?" He is not asking for information. He is making them look at what they actually have in hand instead of at what they lack, the way Elisha once asked a desperate widow, "What do you have in the house?" Their answer is one word: "Seven." These would have been seven small, flat, round breads, about a meal each, so the honest answer amounts to "almost nothing" for a crowd of about four thousand. The number matters. In the earlier feeding there were five loaves, and here there are seven. Mark tells the two stories as a matched pair, and a few verses later Jesus makes the disciples recite these exact numbers to test whether they have understood what happened (8:19–21).

    Full study →
  6. 6And He instructed the crowd to sit down on the ground. Then He took the seven loaves, gave thanks and broke them, and gave them to His disciples to set before the people. And they distributed them to the crowd.

    Jesus takes charge as the host. He tells the huge, hungry crowd to lie back on the bare ground the way guests recline at a feast, so a dinner is arranged in a deserted place before there is anything to serve. Then he does what the head of any Jewish table did. He takes the seven small flat loaves (the whole supply, just counted), gives thanks to God for them in the customary grace that praised God as the one who brings bread from the earth, and breaks them once to begin the meal. After that he keeps on handing pieces to his disciples. Mark switches from the single act of breaking to a continuing act of giving, and never says how seven loaves stretch to four thousand people; the bread simply keeps coming from Jesus' hands. The disciples are told to serve it to the guests, setting it in front of each group as servants do at a meal, and they did serve it to the crowd. The verse begins and ends with "the crowd": the people seated as guests are the people who get fed. Mark's first readers would also have heard in "took… gave thanks… broke… gave" the same sequence used at the Last Supper (14:22) and in their own shared meals.

    Full study →
  7. 7They also had a few small fish, and Jesus blessed them and ordered that these be set before them as well.

    The disciples also had a few little fish, probably the small salted or dried fish that went with bread as ordinary travel food in Galilee. They were almost not worth mentioning beside the seven loaves, and absurdly few for four thousand people. Jesus did what a Jewish host did at a meal: he spoke the blessing over the fish, praising God as the one who gives food. Then he told the disciples to serve these too, setting the fish in front of the people just as they were already doing with the bread. They kept serving like table servants at a meal Jesus was hosting.

    Full study →
  8. 8The people ate and were satisfied, and the disciples picked up seven basketfuls of broken pieces that were left over.

    They ate, and they were fed until they were full. Then the leftovers, pieces of the bread Jesus had broken, were gathered up: seven woven baskets of surplus.

    Mark tells it plainly and briefly, but every word counts. The verb for being satisfied once meant animals fed on fodder until they want no more. These people, three days in the wilderness with nothing to eat (8:2), go home with full stomachs. What is left over is not crumbs but surplus, more than was needed. The pieces are the very pieces Jesus broke when he gave thanks (8:6). Seven loaves went in, and seven baskets came back out. These are not the kophinos baskets of the first feeding (6:43) but spyrides, a word Jesus will repeat on purpose when he asks his slow-to-understand disciples, “How many baskets…? Do you still not understand?” (8:19–21).

    A first-century Jewish listener would hear the prophet Elisha in this ("they ate and had some left over," 2 Kings 4:44), and God filling the hungry in the Psalms. Mark also places the meal in largely non-Jewish territory (7:31), just after Jesus told a non-Jewish woman, "Let the children first be fed full." That may hint that the same fullness now reaches others too.

    Full study →
  9. 9And about four thousand men were present. And when Jesus had dismissed the crowd,

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v2

    I have compassion

    splagchnizomai

    What we hear
    A kindly attitude or sympathetic feeling toward people who are suffering, possibly from a distance and possibly without doing anything.
    What they heard
    A deep, physical stirring of the inner parts that, in the Gospels, always leads straight to action on behalf of the person in need.
  • in v3

    fasting (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    nēsteis

    What we hear
    Deliberately going without food for spiritual or dietary reasons.
    What they heard
    Simply 'not having eaten', with an empty stomach. Here it is forced on them by circumstance after three days in a remote place.
  • in v3

    faint

    eklythēsontai

    What we hear
    Briefly pass out or black out.
    What they heard
    Give out, grow slack and weak, collapse from exhaustion and hunger, so that one cannot go on walking.
  • in v4

    desert / wilderness

    erēmia

    What we hear
    A sandy, barren, waterless desert.
    What they heard
    Uninhabited, uncultivated country with no towns or markets. It could be grassy hill country. The point is isolation and no supplies. It also called up Israel's wilderness years, when God fed the people.
  • in v4

    satisfy (KJV, WEB)

    chortazō

    What we hear
    To please someone or meet their expectations.
    What they heard
    To feed until full: a complete meal that ends hunger.
  • in v5

    loaves

    artoi

    What we hear
    Large, risen, sliced loaves, each enough for a family for days.
    What they heard
    Small, flat, round breads, each about one person's meal. Seven of them was a pitifully small amount.
  • in v6

    sit down

    anapesein (anapiptō)

    What we hear
    Take a seat, get off your feet, rest.
    What they heard
    Recline on one elbow as a guest at a proper or festive meal. Jesus seats the crowd as banquet guests.
  • in v6

    loaves

    artous (artos)

    What we hear
    Large raised loaves of the kind sold in shops, each enough for many people.
    What they heard
    Small round flatbreads, each roughly a single portion, so seven of them is a pitifully small supply.
  • in v7

    blessed them

    eulogēsas (auta)

    What we hear
    Jesus did something to the fish: made them holy, gave them power, or asked God to 'bless this food'.
    What they heard
    He said the Jewish table blessing over the fish. That blessing praised God as the giver of food, so it was spoken to God about the food, not a spell on the food.
  • in v8

    broken [meat] (KJV)

    klasmatōn

    What we hear
    Leftover pieces of meat or flesh.
    What they heard
    Broken pieces of bread. In 1611 English 'meat' meant food in general. The KJV translators added the word (printed in italics/brackets to show it is not in the Greek); the Greek has only 'broken pieces.'
Every word
  1. Ἐν

    En · G1722

    in · v1, v3

    Marks the time: 'in' or 'during' those days.

  2. ἐκείναις

    ekeinais · G1565

    that, those · v1

    'Those' points loosely back to the period of Jesus' travels just described (7:24–37), in the region of Tyre, Sidon and the Decapolis.

  3. ταῖς

    tais · G3588

    the · v1, v2, v3, v4, v5, v6

    The definite article. In English it is absorbed into 'those days'.

  4. ἡμέραις

    hēmerais · G2250

    day · v1, v2

    'Days' in the plural, a vague time-frame. Mark uses this kind of phrase to link stories, not to give a precise date.

  5. πάλιν

    palin · G3825

    again, once more · v1

    Grammatically it goes with the crowd: once more a large crowd was there. It also prepares the reader for a second feeding that echoes 6:34–44.

  6. πολλοῦ

    pollou · G4183

    much, many, large · v1

    Modifies 'crowd': a large crowd. Verse 9 puts it at about four thousand.

  7. ὄχλου

    ochlou · G3793

    crowd, throng · v1, v2, v6

    A mass of ordinary people. It is singular, and that matters for the next words.

  8. ὄντος

    ontos · G1510

    to be · v1

    'Being (there)'. With 'crowd' it forms a background clause: 'there being a large crowd'.

  9. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v1, v2, v3, v4, v5, v6, v7, v8

    Joins the two background facts: crowd present, food absent.

  10. μὴ

    mē · G3361

    not · v1

    The usual negative with a participle: 'not having'.

  11. ἐχόντων

    echontōn · G2192

    to have · v1, v2, v5, v7

    'Having' in the plural, although 'crowd' was singular. Mark moves from the crowd as one mass to the people in it, each of whom has nothing.

  12. τί

    ti · G5101

    what? · v1, v2

    'What'. Used here as in an indirect question: they had nothing they could eat.

  13. φάγωσιν

    phagōsin · G5315

    to eat · v1, v2, v8

    'They might eat'. The mood points to possibility: there is nothing available to eat at all. Jesus repeats the phrase word for word in 8:2.

  14. προσκαλεσάμενος

    proskalesamenos · G4341

    to summon, call to oneself · v1

    'Having called them to himself'. The verb form stresses that Jesus summons them toward himself. Here Jesus starts the action, unlike 6:35, where the disciples raise the problem.

  15. μαθητὰς

    mathētas · G3101

    disciple, pupil, apprentice · v1, v4, v6

    Jesus' students and followers, the inner group who travel with him. Here they are the ones he will involve in feeding the crowd.

  16. λέγει

    legei · G3004

    to say, speak · v1

    'He says'. Mark tells a past event in the present tense, which makes the scene vivid, as if happening now.

  17. αὐτοῖς

    autois · G0846

    him, them · v1, v3, v4, v5, v6, v7

    'To them', the disciples. The colon leads into Jesus' words of compassion in 8:2.

  18. σπλαγχνίζομαι

    splagchnizomai · G4697

    to be moved with compassion · v2

    “I am moved to the core.” The verb comes from the word for the inner organs, which were thought to be where strong feeling lived. It is in the present tense, so Jesus is describing what he feels as he looks at the crowd. This is the only place in Mark where Jesus says the word about himself.

  19. ἐπὶ

    epi · G1909

    upon, toward, over · v2, v4, v6

    Marks who the feeling is aimed at. The compassion settles “upon” the crowd. This is the usual way Greek says what someone has pity for.

  20. ὅτι

    hoti · G3754

    because, that · v2

    Gives the reason for the compassion. What moves him is something concrete that he names straight away.

  21. ἤδη

    ēdē · G2235

    already, by now · v2

    Stresses how long it has gone on: “by now it’s been three days.” It carries a sense that the situation has reached its limit.

  22. τρεῖς

    treis · G5140

    three · v2

    Three days in the open countryside. That is long enough for any food people brought to be gone.

  23. προσμένουσίν

    prosmenousin · G4357

    to remain with, stay on, persist · v2

    “They have been staying on with me.” The prefix pros- means “toward” or “beside,” so the word suggests sticking close to a person and holding on. The present tense, with “already” and a length of time, describes something that began in the past and is still going on.

  24. μοι

    moi · G3165

    to me, with me · v2

    “With me.” The crowd has stayed attached to Jesus himself, and this personal bond is part of why he feels responsible for them.

  25. οὐκ

    ouk · G3756

    not · v2

    A flat statement of fact: they do not have.

  26. ἐὰν

    ean · G1437

    if · v3

    Introduces a real, foreseeable possibility: 'if I do this, here is what will follow.' Jesus is weighing a course of action, not making a guess.

  27. ἀπολύσω

    apolysō · G0630G

    to release, dismiss · v3

    'I send away / dismiss.' The ordinary word for dismissing a gathering (Mark 6:36, 45; 8:9). Its root is 'loosen', which sets up the play on the next verb.

  28. νήστεις

    nēsteis · G3523

    without food, hungry · v3

    'Not having eaten.' The plain, physical state of having had no food, here forced on them by three days in a remote place. It is not a religious fast.

  29. εἰς

    eis · G1519

    into, to · v3

    Marks where they are headed: home.

  30. οἶκον

    oikon · G3624G

    house, home · v3

    Singular, but it applies to each person ('each to his own home'). Home is where food is, and it lies at the end of a long walk.

  31. ἐκλυθήσονται

    eklythēsontai · G1590

    to give out, become exhausted, faint · v3

    'They will give out.' Literally 'be loosened': their strength goes slack and their legs give way from lack of food. It means collapsing from exhaustion, not just a brief blackout. Future tense: Jesus states it as what will happen.

  32. ὁδῷ·

    hodō · G3598

    road, way, journey · v3

    The journey home on foot through open country. 'The way' is a theme Mark builds on later (8:27; 10:52), but here it is simply the road home.

  33. τινες

    tines · G5100

    some, certain ones · v3, v4

    'Some.' Not all of them: a part of the crowd lives far away. Jesus has noticed who is in front of him.

  34. μακρόθεν

    makrothen · G3113

    from far away · v3

    'From a distance.' Literally they are a long way from home. Some readers also hear an echo of 'those who are far off', a biblical way of speaking about Gentiles (see debates).

  35. ἥκασιν.

    hēkasin · G2240

    to have come, be here · v3

    'Have come and are now here.' The verb already means 'to have arrived', and this perfect form stresses their present situation: far from home, with nothing to eat.

  36. ἀπεκρίθησαν

    apekrithēsan · G0611

    to answer · v4

    'They answered.' Jesus has not asked anything. He has only voiced his compassion and concern, so their 'answer' replies to the problem he raised, and it replies with an objection.

  37. πόθεν

    pothen · G4159

    from where? how? · v4

    Literally 'from where?', asking where something could come from. It can also mean 'how?' Both senses are active here: where would the bread come from, and how could it be done? The same word opens Moses' complaint in the Greek of Numbers 11:13.

  38. τούτους

    toutous · G3778

    these · v4, v7

    'These people.' It is placed early in the Greek for emphasis, perhaps with a gesture at the huge crowd: about four thousand (8:9), some of them from far away (8:3).

  39. δυνήσεταί

    dynēsetai · G1410

    to be able · v4

    'Will (anyone) be able?' The future tense makes this a rhetorical question that expects the answer 'no one.' It echoes the Greek of Psalm 78:19 (LXX 77:19), 'Will God be able to spread a table in the wilderness?'

  40. ὧδε

    hōde · G5602

    here · v4

    'Here,' meaning this very spot, far from villages and markets. Together with 'in a wilderness' at the end, it underlines how impossible the place is.

  41. χορτάσαι

    chortasai · G5526

    to feed to the full, satisfy · v4, v8

    'To fill (them) up.' The word was first used for fattening animals on fodder. Here it means feeding people until they are full, not handing out a snack. The same verb returns in 8:8: 'they ate and were filled.'

  42. ἄρτων

    artōn · G0740

    bread, loaf · v4, v5, v6

    'With loaves.' The genitive case here names what they would be filled with. These are round flat loaves, the staple food, and 'bread' stood for food in general. Jesus' next question picks the word up: 'How many loaves do you have?' (8:5).

  43. ἐρημίας

    erēmias · G2047

    uninhabited region, wilderness · v4

    An empty, unsettled place: no towns, no farms, nothing to buy. It need not be sandy desert. The word recalls Israel in the wilderness, where God supplied bread (manna).

  44. ἠρώτα

    ērōta · G2065

    to ask, question · v5

    'He was asking.' The tense describes the action as ongoing, which makes the scene vivid. In Koine Greek ('Koine' is the everyday Greek of the time) this verb means simply 'to ask a question'. Jesus is not short of information. He is pointing the disciples to what they already have.

  45. πόσους

    posous · G4214

    how many · v5

    A request for a number. Mark cares about the figures in these stories, and Jesus later quizzes the disciples on them (8:19–20).

  46. δὲ

    de · G1161

    and, but · v5, v8

    A light connective that signals the reply. It carries no sense of contrast here.

  47. εἶπαν

    eipan · G2036

    to say · v5, v7

    'They said.' The ending -an is a normal everyday-Greek form of eipon. The answer is short and to the point.

  48. ἑπτά

    hepta · G2033

    seven · v5, v6, v8

    Seven. The number differs from the five loaves of the first feeding (6:38). Mark keeps the two sets of numbers apart and later makes the disciples repeat them (8:20). Whether seven carries a symbolic meaning is debated.

  49. παραγγέλλει

    parangellei · G3853

    to order, direct, instruct · v6

    Present tense used to tell a past event, a habit of Mark's that makes the scene feel immediate: 'he directs.' The word is used for an instruction given with authority, here the authority of a host arranging his guests.

  50. ἀναπεσεῖν

    anapesein · G0377

    to recline, lie back (for a meal) · v6

    Literally 'to fall back.' In meal settings it means leaning back on one elbow, the posture of a proper or festive dinner. Jesus is telling people to take their places as guests at a meal, not just to sit down and rest.

  51. γῆς

    gēs · G1093

    earth, ground, land · v6

    The bare ground of a remote place (8:4, 'a desolate place'). The banquet posture on open ground makes a pointed contrast: a feast with no couches and no hall.

  52. λαβὼν

    labōn · G2983

    to take, receive · v6

    'Having taken.' The first of the host's set actions at a Jewish meal: he takes the bread in his hands before he says the blessing.

  53. εὐχαριστήσας

    eucharistēsas · G2168

    to give thanks · v6

    'Having given thanks': the grace said over bread, in which a Jewish host thanked and blessed God as the giver of bread. It is thanks directed to God, not a blessing that changes the bread.

  54. ἔκλασεν

    eklasen · G2806

    to break (bread) · v6

    'He broke [them].' A single, completed act. Breaking the bread after the blessing was how the host opened the meal and began sharing it out.

  55. ἐδίδου

    edidou · G1325

    to give · v6

    Imperfect tense, which pictures ongoing action: 'he kept giving.' After the one breaking comes a steady handing-out. Many readers have seen here a hint that the bread kept coming as Jesus gave it.

  56. ἵνα

    hina · G2443

    so that, in order that · v6

    Gives the purpose of the giving: the bread goes to the disciples so that they can serve it.

  57. παρατιθῶσιν

    paratithōsin · G3908

    to set before, serve (food) · v6, v7

    The normal word for putting food in front of a guest. The present tense suggests serving that goes on, one group of guests after another.

  58. ἰχθύδια

    ichthydia · G2485

    little fish · v7

    A diminutive of ἰχθύς, 'fish'. It means small fish, very likely the dried or salted fish that people carried with bread as ordinary travel food around the Sea of Galilee. The small form stresses how little there was.

  59. ὀλίγα

    oliga · G3641

    few, little · v7

    'A few'. Unlike the five thousand story, which says 'two fish' (6:38), Mark gives no number, only that the amount was tiny next to four thousand people.

  60. εὐλογήσας

    eulogēsas · G2127

    to bless, praise · v7

    'Having blessed'. This is the Jewish blessing said over food, praising God as the giver of the meal. In verse 6 over the bread Mark uses 'having given thanks' (εὐχαριστήσας), and the two words point to the same mealtime act.

  61. ἦραν

    ēran · G0142

    to lift, take up, carry away · v8

    'They took up / gathered up.' The Greek does not name who did it. BSB, NIV and NLT add 'the disciples', which is a reasonable inference from Mark 8:19–20, but the verse itself does not say it.

  62. περισσεύματα

    perisseumata · G4051

    overflow, surplus, what is left over · v8

    'Surpluses, overflowings.' The word suggests more than enough, not scraps scraped together. The plural strengthens the sense of excess.

  63. κλασμάτων

    klasmatōn · G2801

    broken piece, fragment · v8

    'Of broken pieces.' These are pieces from the loaves Jesus broke (ἔκλασεν, verse 6), not crumbs off the ground. They are the unused portions of what he broke and handed out.

  64. σπυρίδας

    spyridas · G4711

    basket (woven, sometimes large) · v8

    A woven or plaited basket, the kind used for carrying provisions or fish. It can be big: in Acts 9:25 Paul is let down a wall in one. Mark uses a different word here from the κόφινοι ('baskets') of the first feeding (6:43), and Jesus keeps the two words distinct in 8:19–20.

The world behind it

Where this happens. Mark 7:31 brings Jesus "through Sidon to the Sea of Galilee, into the region of the Decapolis". The Decapolis was a league of Greek-style cities with mostly non-Jewish populations, east and south-east of the lake. Mark 8:1 does not name a place, but nothing between 7:31 and 8:10 moves Jesus elsewhere. Most readers therefore picture this crowd in largely Gentile territory, and Mark may intend it that way, though he never says so outright (see debates).

Why a crowd could run out of food. People in the countryside travelled on foot and carried a few days' bread at most. Once away from villages there were no markets. After three days in "a desolate place" (8:4), food carried from home would be gone, and a long walk back on an empty stomach was a real danger (8:3). The need described here is physical and urgent.

Echoes a first-century listener might catch. A hungry crowd fed in the wilderness would recall Israel fed with manna (Exodus 16). It might also recall Elisha feeding a hundred men with a few loaves (2 Kings 4:42–44). Mark leaves these echoes unspoken; they come from the shape of the scene, not from the wording of this verse.

From the study of Mark 8:1.

Where scholars differ

in v1

Are the feedings of the 5,000 (Mark 6) and the 4,000 (Mark 8) two separate events, or two versions of one tradition?

  • Two separate events, as the Gospels present them.

    Mark and Matthew both tell both stories. Jesus refers to the two feedings as separate events, with different numbers of people, loaves and baskets (Mark 8:19–20; Matt 16:9–10). The details differ in setting, numbers and the words for 'basket'. Repeating a sign is not implausible.

  • One tradition handed down in two forms, which Mark included as a pair.

    The plots are strikingly similar. The disciples' question in 8:4 is hard to explain if they had just seen the first feeding. Luke and John each have only one feeding. Many historical-critical scholars hold this view, though they agree Mark presents them as two.

in v1

Is the crowd of Mark 8:1 meant to be Gentile?

  • Yes: Mark sets this feeding among non-Jews as a counterpart to the Jewish feeding of chapter 6.

    7:31 places Jesus in the Decapolis, and nothing in 7:31–8:10 moves him elsewhere. The story follows the Syrophoenician woman's 'crumbs' (7:27–28). Some 'have come from far away' (8:3), language used elsewhere of Gentiles (e.g. Josh 9:6; Isa 60:4). The numbers (seven baskets, four thousand) are often read as symbolic of the nations.

  • Not clearly: Mark does not say so, and the symbolism may be overread.

    8:1 gives no location. The Decapolis had Jewish residents too. 'From far away' can simply mean a long walk. The number symbolism is speculative. Matthew's version places the crowd glorifying 'the God of Israel' (Matt 15:31), which some read as Gentile and others as Jewish.

in v2

Was this crowd mainly non-Jewish, and is Mark presenting the second feeding as Jesus feeding Gentiles?

  • Yes. Mark deliberately pairs a feeding of Jews (6:30–44) with a feeding of Gentiles.

    The setting follows a journey through the Decapolis (7:31) and comes straight after the Syrophoenician woman’s “crumbs” saying (7:28). “Some have come from far away” (8:3) may echo biblical language for Gentiles as “those far off” (e.g. Joshua 9:6; Isaiah 60:4; compare Ephesians 2:13, 17). Some also link the seven baskets (8:8) with the nations, against the twelve baskets for Israel’s twelve tribes in 6:43.

  • Possible, but Mark never says so. The symbolic readings are uncertain.

    8:1 begins only with “in those days” and does not repeat the location. The Decapolis had Jewish residents too. “From far away” is ordinary travel language. The number symbolism of the baskets is never explained in the text, and Mark 8:19–21 stresses that two feedings happened without decoding the numbers.

in v2

Is the feeding of the four thousand a separate event or a second telling of the feeding of the five thousand?

  • Two versions of one tradition (a ‘doublet’).

    The structure and wording are very similar (remote place, loaves and fish, blessing, distribution, leftover baskets). Also, the disciples’ question in 8:4 is hard to explain if they had just seen the earlier feeding.

  • Two distinct events, as Mark presents them.

    Mark (and Matthew) explicitly count two feedings with different numbers (8:19–20). The details differ: three days, seven loaves, a different Greek word for basket (*spyris* vs *kophinos*), different numbers of people, and Jesus’ first-person statement of compassion here. Repeated misunderstanding by the disciples is a recurring theme in Mark.

in v2

Is “three days” symbolic?

  • Mainly a realistic detail.

    It explains why food has run out and sets up the danger in 8:3. Matthew keeps it in the same plain way.

  • It may also carry overtones.

    Some interpreters link it to the “after three days” of the passion predictions (8:31) or to three-day periods in Israel’s scriptures (e.g. Exodus 19:11; Hosea 6:2). The text makes no explicit connection, so this remains speculative.

in v3

Does 'some of them have come from afar' hint that Gentiles are in the crowd?

  • Yes. Mark is signalling that this feeding includes non-Jews, the 'far-off ones'.

    The setting is the largely Gentile Decapolis (7:31), straight after the Syrophoenician woman's request for 'crumbs' (7:24–30). Septuagint passages pair hēkō with makrothen for outsiders or for those gathered in from a distance (Joshua 9:6; Isaiah 60:4), and 'those far off' became early Christian language for Gentiles (Acts 2:39; Ephesians 2:13, 17). Some also see symbolism in the numbers (seven loaves and seven baskets here; twelve baskets in the first feeding). Commentators such as Joel Marcus are open to this reading.

  • No, or not clearly. The clause is a realistic detail explaining why the crowd cannot simply walk home.

    The words make complete sense literally: three days in a remote area and a long walk home. Matthew drops the clause entirely, which would be odd if it were a key signal. Mark does not say the crowd is Gentile, and 'far' language is common in plain description (Mark 5:6; 15:40). Commentators such as R. T. France are cautious about building symbolism on it.

in v4

Why would the disciples ask this after already seeing five thousand fed (Mark 6)?

  • Two tellings of one event: early tradition kept two versions of a single feeding, and Mark included both.

    The two stories are closely parallel (wilderness, compassion, loaves, fish, blessing, distribution, baskets). The disciples' complete forgetfulness reads oddly if the events really were separate.

  • Two separate events, recorded as such.

    In Mark 8:19–20 Jesus himself lists both feedings, with different numbers of loaves, people and baskets. The details differ: the basket words are kophinos in chapter 6 and spyris in chapter 8, the crowd sizes and settings differ, and so do the time periods (one day versus three days).

  • Whatever the history behind it, Mark tells it this way on purpose to show the disciples' lack of understanding.

    Mark builds to 8:17–21: 'Do you not yet perceive or understand? Are your hearts hardened?' Their question in 8:4 sets that rebuke up. This view can sit alongside either of the first two.

in v4

Was this crowd mainly Gentile?

  • Yes. The second feeding extends Jesus' provision to non-Jews.

    The setting is the Decapolis (7:31). It follows the Syrophoenician woman's 'crumbs' (7:28). 'Some have come from far' (8:3) may echo biblical language for Gentiles. Some also see symbolism in the numbers, though this is more speculative: seven baskets against twelve (the twelve tribes).

  • Not clearly. The location and the crowd are left vague.

    8:1 gives no fresh location. 'From far' can simply describe a long journey. The number symbolism is speculative.

in v5

Does 'seven' (seven loaves, seven baskets) carry symbolic meaning?

  • It points to the Gentiles. The twelve baskets of the first feeding represent Israel, and the sevens of this feeding represent the nations.

    The Gentile setting in the Decapolis (7:31). Jewish traditions that link seven with the nations: the seven nations of Canaan (Deut 7:1) and the seven Hellenist deacons of Acts 6. Mark's insistence on the numbers in 8:19–21.

  • It signals completeness or fullness, without any Jew/Gentile pattern.

    Seven is widely used in Scripture as the number of completeness, while the specific link of seven with Gentiles is less securely attested.

  • It is simply the remembered count, and the comparison in 8:19–21 is about the size of the miracle and the disciples' dullness, not number symbolism.

    Jesus' rebuke focuses on their failure to understand and their worry about bread (8:16–17), not on what the numbers represent.

in v5

Is this a separate event or a second version of the feeding of the five thousand?

  • A doublet: one event that came down in two forms and that Mark included twice.

    The structure is very similar. The disciples' incomprehension in v. 4 is hard to explain if they had just seen the first feeding.

  • Two distinct events, as Mark presents them.

    The numbers, place and audience differ, and the basket words differ (kophinos in 6:43, spyris in 8:8). Mark 8:19–20 explicitly treats them as two events.

in v6

Is the feeding of the four thousand meant as a feeding of Gentiles, balancing the Jewish feeding of the five thousand?

  • Yes. Mark arranges the two feedings so that Jesus' bread goes first to Israel and then to the nations.

    The setting follows the Decapolis note (7:31). Some 'have come from far away' (8:3), and 'far off' is language used elsewhere for Gentiles (Josh 9:6; Isa 60:4; Acts 2:39; Eph 2:13). The scene comes right after the Syrophoenician woman's 'crumbs' (7:28). The twelve baskets of 6:43 may suggest Israel's tribes and the seven baskets here the nations, and the vocabulary shifts (εὐχαριστέω, a Greek-flavoured word; σπυρίς for the basket instead of the Jewish κόφινος).

  • Not clearly. Mark does not mark the crowd as Gentile, and the evidence is suggestive rather than decisive.

    Mark never calls this crowd Gentile. Jews lived in and around the Decapolis too. 'From far away' may just mean a long walk. The different numbers and vocabulary may come from two separate tellings of the tradition, not from a symbolic plan. Several commentators (e.g., France, Guelich) are cautious, while others (e.g., Marcus) favour the Gentile reading.

in v6

Is the language of this verse meant to evoke the Lord's Supper?

  • Yes. Mark tells the story using his community's meal words.

    The same four verbs (took, gave thanks/blessed, broke, gave) appear in Mark 14:22 and 1 Cor 11:23–24. Paul uses εὐχαριστήσας for the bread exactly as here. Mark 8:14–21 returns to the 'one loaf' in a way that suggests a deeper meaning.

  • Only partly. These are simply the normal actions of any Jewish host, and the echo should not be overstated.

    Every Jewish meal opened with taking, blessing, breaking and distributing bread. There is no cup and no word about body or covenant. Fish are served as well (v. 7). In Acts 27:35 Paul does the same four things before pagan sailors at an ordinary meal. The shared language comes from a common meal custom, and the specifically Eucharistic name for the rite comes later.

in v6

Did Mark record two separate feedings, or one event told twice?

  • Two events.

    Mark and Matthew both narrate two feedings with different numbers, settings and basket words, and Jesus explicitly refers back to both (Mark 8:19–20; Matt 16:9–10).

  • One tradition in two versions, which Mark has used as two episodes.

    The two stories have very similar structure. The disciples' question in 8:4 is hard to explain if they had just seen 6:30–44. Luke and John each have only one feeding. Supporters argue that Mark arranged the doublet deliberately to build his bread theme.

in v7

Why does Mark mention the fish separately, with a separate blessing?

  • It reflects Jewish meal practice or an eyewitness-style detail: the disciples remembered the fish only afterward, and a blessing was said over each food.

    Mishnah Berakhot 6 gives different blessings for bread and for foods 'not grown from the earth', though it also says a blessing over the main food can cover a side dish (m. Ber. 6:5–7). The Mishnah was written down later than Mark, so this is suggestive, not proof.

  • Mark or his tradition kept the bread action (take–give thanks–break–give) apart so that it matches the Last Supper, and treated the fish as an add-on.

    Verse 6 matches 14:22–23 closely, including 'give thanks'. The fish play no part in the later Christian community meal. Interpreters such as J. Marcus and R. T. France discuss this.

in v7

Was the crowd in the second feeding mainly non-Jewish?

  • Yes. The second feeding presents Jesus feeding Gentiles, after he fed Jews in chapter 6.

    The setting follows 7:31 (the Decapolis). Some came 'from far away' (8:3), language used elsewhere for Gentiles. The story comes right after the Syrophoenician woman (7:24–30). The two numbers of baskets (twelve, seven) are often read as symbols.

  • Not clearly. Mark does not say the crowd was Gentile, and the symbolic readings are speculative.

    The Decapolis had Jewish residents too. The text gives no explicit ethnic marker. Seven and twelve may just record what happened, or may be read in more than one way.

in v8

Does the seven-basket feeding deliberately portray Jesus feeding non-Jews, in contrast with the twelve-basket feeding of Jews?

  • Yes. Mark arranges the two feedings as bread for Israel (twelve baskets, recalling the twelve tribes) and then bread for the nations (seven baskets).

    The setting is the Decapolis (7:31). The scene follows the Syrophoenician woman and the words 'let the children first be fed full' (7:27). Some in the crowd come 'from far away' (8:3), a phrase used of nations. The basket word changes from κόφινος, associated with Jews in Juvenal, to σπυρίς. Some link seven to the non-Jewish nations (Genesis 10; the seven nations of Canaan, Deuteronomy 7:1) or to completeness.

  • Uncertain or overread. The numbers and baskets may be details from tradition rather than coded symbols.

    Mark never explains the numbers. The 'seven loaves' are given by the disciples as what they happen to have (8:5). The symbolic meaning of seven is disputed. The Decapolis had Jewish residents too. Matthew's parallel (15:29–39) places the scene by the Sea of Galilee and ends with the crowd glorifying 'the God of Israel', which some read as pointing to Gentiles and others do not.

in v8

Are the two feeding stories two separate events or two versions of one event?

  • Two distinct events, as Mark and Matthew present them.

    Jesus refers to both separately, with different numbers and basket types (Mark 8:19–20; Matthew 16:9–10). The details differ in crowd size, number of loaves, basket type and how long the people had been there.

  • A doublet (two forms of one tradition) that Mark kept and arranged on purpose.

    The disciples' question in 8:4 seems odd if they had just seen the 5,000 fed. The structure and wording of the two stories are closely parallel. Luke and John each tell only one feeding.

in v8

Does the vocabulary of breaking and broken pieces carry Lord's Supper overtones?

  • Yes, at least for Mark's readers.

    Verse 6 uses 'took… gave thanks (εὐχαριστήσας)… broke… gave', the same sequence as Mark 14:22. κλάσμα is used for the bread of the early Christian meal in *Didache* 9:3–4.

  • Only partly. These are the ordinary actions of a Jewish host at a meal.

    Taking, blessing or giving thanks, breaking and distributing were what any Jewish head of household did at a meal. The story is about filling hungry people in a wilderness, not about a ritual meal.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. πάλιν, ὄχλος, προσκαλέομαι, μαθητής
  • Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Mark 8:1
  • Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (2nd ed.), on Mark 8:1
  • R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark (NIGTC)
  • Joel Marcus, Mark 1–8 (Anchor Yale Bible)
  • Robert H. Gundry, Mark: A Commentary on His Apology for the Cross
  • Craig S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Mark 8:1–10
  • BDAG s.v. σπλαγχνίζομαι
  • BDAG s.v. προσμένω
  • BDAG s.v. ὄχλος
  • TDNT s.v. σπλάγχνον, σπλαγχνίζομαι (H. Köster)
  • Blass–Debrunner–Funk, A Greek Grammar of the New Testament §144 (parenthetic nominative of time)
  • R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark (NICNT)
  • Adela Yarbro Collins, Mark (Hermeneia)
  • Robert Guelich, Mark 1–8:26 (WBC)
  • Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs, Testament of Zebulun
  • 2 Maccabees 6:8 (LXX)
  • BDAG s.v. νῆστις, ἐκλύω, ἀπολύω, μακρόθεν, ἥκω
  • LSJ s.v. νῆστις
  • Septuagint: 2 Samuel 16:2; 1 Samuel 14:28; Judges 8:15; 1 Maccabees 3:17 (ἐκλύω); Joshua 9:6; Isaiah 60:4 (ἥκω + μακρόθεν)
  • NA28 / SBLGNT apparatus; Westcott–Hort text at Mark 8:3
  • Vulgate, Mark 8:3
  • BDAG s.v. πόθεν, χορτάζω, ἐρημία, δύναμαι
  • LSJ s.v. χορτάζω (fodder/fattening sense)
  • Septuagint: Numbers 11:13; Psalm 77:19–20 LXX; Psalm 106:9 LXX; Exodus 16
  • Vulgate, Mark 8:4
  • BDAG s.v. ἄρτος, ἐρωτάω, ἑπτά
  • Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Mark 8:5
  • Septuagint, 4 Kingdoms (2 Kings) 4:2, 42–44
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Mark 8:1–10
  • Joel Marcus, Mark 8–16 (Anchor Yale Bible)
  • BDAG s.v. ἀναπίπτω, ἄρτος, εὐχαριστέω, κλάω, παρατίθημι, ὄχλος
  • Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Mark 8:6
  • Mishnah Berakhot 6:1 (blessing over bread); Mishnah Pesahim 10:1 (reclining)
  • Didache 9–10; Ignatius, To the Smyrnaeans 7:1; Justin Martyr, 1 Apology 66 (later use of eucharistia)
  • Septuagint: Gen 18:8; 49:9; 2 Kgs 4:42–44; Isa 25:6; 58:7; Tobit 2:1
  • Robert A. Guelich, Mark 1–8:26 (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • William L. Lane, The Gospel of Mark (NICNT)
  • Vulgate, Mark 8:6
  • BDAG s.v. εὐλογέω
  • BDAG s.v. ἰχθύδιον
  • BDAG s.v. παρατίθημι
  • Nestle-Aland, Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Mark 8:7
  • Mishnah Berakhot 6:1–7
  • Septuagint 1 Samuel 9:13; Numbers 11:22; 2 Kings 4:42–44
  • Strabo, Geography 16.2.45 (Taricheae)
  • J. Marcus, Mark 1–8 (Anchor Yale Bible)
  • K. C. Hanson, 'The Galilean Fishing Economy and the Jesus Tradition', Biblical Theology Bulletin 27 (1997)
  • BDAG s.v. χορτάζω, περίσσευμα, κλάσμα, σπυρίς, κόφινος
  • Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. σπυρίς
  • LSJ s.v. χορτάζω
  • Septuagint: Ruth 2:14; 4 Kingdoms (2 Kings) 4:42–44; Psalms 106:9; 131:15 LXX
  • Juvenal, Satires 3.14; 6.542 (cophinus)
  • Didache 9:3–4
  • Plato, Republic 586a
  • Nestle-Aland 28th ed. apparatus at Mark 8:8

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.