Ezra Chapter 4 Read as one passage
Ezra 4:6–24
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
6At the beginning of the reign of Xerxes, an accusation was lodged against the people of Judah and Jerusalem. 7And in the days of Artaxerxes king of Persia, Bishlam, Mithredath, Tabeel, and the rest of his associates wrote a letter to Artaxerxes. It was written in Aramaic and then translated. 8Rehum the commander and Shimshai the scribe wrote the letter against Jerusalem to King Artaxerxes as follows: 9From Rehum the commander, Shimshai the scribe, and the rest of their associates—the judges and officials over Tripolis, Persia, Erech and Babylon, the Elamites of Susa, 10and the rest of the peoples whom the great and honorable Ashurbanipal deported and settled in the cities of Samaria and elsewhere west of the Euphrates. 11(This is the text of the letter they sent to him.) To King Artaxerxes, From your servants, the men west of the Euphrates: 12Let it be known to the king that the Jews who came from you to us have returned to Jerusalem and are rebuilding that rebellious and wicked city. They are restoring its walls and repairing its foundations. 13Let it now be known to the king that if that city is rebuilt and its walls are restored, they will not pay tribute, duty, or toll, and the royal treasury will suffer. 14Now because we are in the service of the palace and it is not fitting for us to allow the king to be dishonored, we have sent to inform the king 15that a search should be made of the record books of your fathers. In these books you will discover and verify that the city is a rebellious city, harmful to kings and provinces, inciting sedition from ancient times. That is why this city was destroyed. 16We advise the king that if this city is rebuilt and its walls are restored, you will have no dominion west of the Euphrates. 17Then the king sent this reply: To Rehum the commander, Shimshai the scribe, and the rest of your associates living in Samaria and elsewhere in the region west of the Euphrates: Greetings. 18The letter you sent us has been translated and read in my presence. 19I issued a decree, and a search was conducted. It was discovered that this city has revolted against kings from ancient times, engaging in rebellion and sedition. 20And mighty kings have ruled over Jerusalem and exercised authority over the whole region west of the Euphrates; and tribute, duty, and toll were paid to them. 21Now, therefore, issue an order for these men to stop, so that this city will not be rebuilt until I so order. 22See that you do not neglect this matter. Why allow this threat to increase and the royal interests to suffer? 23When the text of the letter from King Artaxerxes was read to Rehum, Shimshai the scribe, and their associates, they went immediately to the Jews in Jerusalem and forcibly stopped them. 24Thus the construction of the house of God in Jerusalem ceased, and it remained at a standstill until the second year of the reign of Darius king of Persia.
What the first hearers heard
For the community in Persian-period Yehud, and for later readers of Ezra–Nehemiah, the verse did three things:
- It showed that the opposition never stopped. The trouble that began with the "people of the land" refusing to let the returned exiles build alone (4:1–5) carried on into the next king's reign and beyond. By listing it king by king, the narrator explains the long delays and the community's weakness. The story of restoration is told honestly, as a struggle.
- It showed the threat as political and legal. The danger came through paperwork: written denunciations to the throne. Readers who lived under the empire knew that a letter could decide a province's fate. That is why later in the book the community's protection is also written: the Cyrus decree found in the archive (6:1–12) and Artaxerxes' letter to Ezra (7:11–26).
- It set up the contrast that runs through the book. Accusations are written against God's people, but the book keeps showing that "the eye of their God was on the elders of the Jews" (5:5). Here no response from Xerxes is recorded. Within the narrative's pattern, this accusation simply came to nothing.
From the study of Ezra 4:6.
Verse by verse
-
6At the beginning of the reign of Xerxes, an accusation was lodged against the people of Judah and Jerusalem.
Full study →"Next, under Ahasuerus (Xerxes), right at the start of his reign, before he was settled on the throne, the same opponents put in writing a hostile charge against everyone living in Judah and Jerusalem. It was a formal denunciation sent to the royal court to turn the new king against them."
The verse is one link in a chain. Verses 1–5 tell how the neighbouring "people of the land" frustrated the temple builders "from Cyrus to Darius". The narrator then jumps ahead, past the temple's completion in 515 BC, to show that the hostility kept going under the next kings: Xerxes here, then Artaxerxes (v. 7). The word for the charge, śiṭnah, comes from the same root as śāṭān, "adversary, accuser". So this was not a neutral report but an attack in writing, a prosecutor's brief against a whole community. "They wrote" points to the Persian empire's world of official letters, where a document reaching the king at the right moment could ruin a province. The narrator gives no reply and no result. He records only that the accusation was made, and moves on to a later and more serious one.
-
7And in the days of Artaxerxes king of Persia, Bishlam, Mithredath, Tabeel, and the rest of his associates wrote a letter to Artaxerxes. It was written in Aramaic and then translated.
Full study →"Later still, in the time of Artaxerxes king of Persia, a formal written complaint went to the king himself. Its senders were Bishlam (or, as the old Greek translation understood it, it was sent 'with the agreement' of the others), the Persian official Mithredath, Tabeel, and the rest of their fellow officials. The document was drawn up in Aramaic, the empire's official language of government, and passed through the royal scribes' process of translation. [Reader's note: what follows is in Aramaic.]"
Several things lie beneath the English. The verse opens a new entry in a list, not the next scene in a story: after opposition under Cyrus and Darius (vv. 1–5) and a complaint under Xerxes (v. 6), the writer jumps ahead to Artaxerxes I (465–424 BC), decades after the temple was finished in 515 BC. The writers are colleagues in office (the Persian bureaucratic term kənāwōt), and the document is a ništtəwān, the Persian word for an official state document. The petition is formal and legal, filed through proper channels, and that is exactly what makes it dangerous. The doubled "Aramaic" at the end is odd in Hebrew too. Most likely the first means the letter was written in Aramaic, and the second works like a heading telling the reader that the text now switches into Aramaic, as it does from verse 8 to 6:18.
-
8Rehum the commander and Shimshai the scribe wrote the letter against Jerusalem to King Artaxerxes as follows:
Full study →Rehum, the official in charge of reports and orders for the province, and Shimshai, the government secretary, together drafted a formal letter about Jerusalem, a letter against it, and sent it straight to Artaxerxes, the Great King of Persia. What follows is a copy of it:
The verse is a file heading. Two named officials, one holding authority and one doing the professional drafting, put their names to an official dispatch. The word for "letter" is the Persian empire's word for official correspondence. The preposition says only that the letter was about Jerusalem, but what it says (4:11–16: a "rebellious and wicked city" that will stop paying tribute if its walls go up) makes it an indictment. The closing word, "thus", works like a colon before an attached document.
Something else happens here that English readers cannot see: from this verse the book of Ezra stops writing in Hebrew and continues in Aramaic, the administrative language of the Persian empire. It stays in Aramaic until 6:18. A Jewish reader would hear the switch at once. The story is now quoting the empire's own paperwork, in the empire's own language.
-
9From Rehum the commander, Shimshai the scribe, and the rest of their associates—the judges and officials over Tripolis, Persia, Erech and Babylon, the Elamites of Susa,
Full study →Then, at the head of the letter, stood its senders: Rehum, the official in charge of reports and orders for the province, and Shimshai the secretary who drafted it, and all their fellow officials: the judges, the envoys, the other officers (or "the men of Tripolis"), the Persians (or one more class of Persian official), together with the people of Uruk, the people of Babylon, and the people of Susa, that is, the Elamites…
The sentence carries on into verse 10: "…and the rest of the peoples whom the great and noble Osnappar deported and settled in the cities of Samaria and the rest of the province Beyond the River." The verse has no verb of its own. It reads like the heading of a formal state letter, listing everyone who claims to speak.
The original hearers would have taken in two things. The first is weight: an official with authority to report, a professional secretary, a body of colleagues, judges and commissioners. All of the region's bureaucracy has lined up behind this complaint to the king. The second is origin: the communities named come from Uruk, Babylon and Susa in Mesopotamia and Elam, far to the east. They are descendants of people the Assyrians transplanted into the hill country of Samaria. The opponents name themselves by where their ancestors came from, and for the book of Ezra that is the point: they are not Israel. Several words that older English versions print as strange tribal names ("Dinaites," "Apharsathchites," "Dehavites") are really job titles or the small phrase "that is." The verse lists officials and resettled communities. It is not a list of mysterious lost tribes.
-
10and the rest of the peoples whom the great and honorable Ashurbanipal deported and settled in the cities of Samaria and elsewhere west of the Euphrates.
Full study →"…and all the other peoples whom Osnappar, the great and illustrious king of Assyria (Ashurbanipal), uprooted from their homelands and forcibly resettled in the city of Samaria and throughout the rest of the imperial province called 'Beyond-the-River' (everything west of the Euphrates). And now: [here begins the letter's business]."
The verse ends the list of people sending a hostile letter to the Persian king Artaxerxes. The writers make three claims. First, numbers: it is not just a few officials writing but "the rest" of the peoples and "the rest" of the whole province. Second, pedigree: they were planted here by a "great and honored" king, so they are long-settled subjects placed by royal decree. Third, loyalty: they speak the empire's own administrative language. The two verbs describe forced relocation, uprooting and replanting, which is how Assyria ruled conquered lands. The closing "and now" is the stock phrase of an Aramaic letter as it moves from greeting to business, a sign that the book is quoting real correspondence.
-
11(This is the text of the letter they sent to him.) To King Artaxerxes, From your servants, the men west of the Euphrates:
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
12Let it be known to the king that the Jews who came from you to us have returned to Jerusalem and are rebuilding that rebellious and wicked city. They are restoring its walls and repairing its foundations.
Full study →"Be it formally known to the king: the Judeans who travelled up from your side of the empire into our territory have arrived at Jerusalem. That city, the one with a record of revolt, the troublesome one, is the city they are building. They have all but finished its walls, and they are mending its foundations."
This is the first sentence of the main body of an official report from provincial officials of Samaria and the lands west of the Euphrates to the Persian king Artaxerxes. It opens with the standard formula of Persian administrative letters ("be it known to the king"), so it reads as a formal entry on the royal record. The officials point out that these settlers came from the king's own side of the empire. The implication is that the king let this happen and now has to deal with it. They name Jerusalem and then place "the city" first in its clause, labelled "rebellious and bad". Both words are political, not religious. They mean a city with a history of breaking away from its overlords and a danger to royal interests. The verbs build momentum: building now, walls practically finished, foundations being repaired. The aim is to make the king fear that a fortified, tribute-refusing Jerusalem is only days away. The next verse states the real point: a walled Jerusalem will stop paying taxes.
-
13Let it now be known to the king that if that city is rebuilt and its walls are restored, they will not pay tribute, duty, or toll, and the royal treasury will suffer.
Full study →"And now, let the king be informed: if that city is rebuilt and its walls are brought to completion, then tribute, produce-tax and land-service dues (every kind of royal tax) are exactly what they will stop paying. And in the end the crown itself, the treasury of the kings, will take the loss."
The verse is the turning point of a hostile memo sent to the Persian king. Verse 12 called Jerusalem a "rebellious and wicked city". Here the writers turn that into the one argument a Persian king could not ignore: money. Each word is the office language of the empire. "Let it be known to the king" is the set formula of a report to the throne. The three tax words come from the Babylonian and Persian tax system (mindah, regular tribute; belo, a levy probably paid in goods; halakh, the duty owed for crown land, paid in silver by this time). Together they mean "every kind of tax you collect". The writers put them first for emphasis: these they will not pay.
The logic rests on the walls. In that world, finished walls meant a city that could shut its gates on the governor's tax collectors. So "build the walls" becomes "stop paying", and "stop paying" means revolt. The last clause is the threat. Whether the rare Persian word means "the revenue of kings" or "in the end", the damage falls on the crown, "kings" in the plural, the royal house that lasts from reign to reign. The verb (nzq, "cause loss") is the same one the king uses in his reply (v. 22), which shows the argument landed.
-
14Now because we are in the service of the palace and it is not fitting for us to allow the king to be dishonored, we have sent to inform the king
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
15that a search should be made of the record books of your fathers. In these books you will discover and verify that the city is a rebellious city, harmful to kings and provinces, inciting sedition from ancient times. That is why this city was destroyed.
Full study →The officials of Samaria are urging the Persian king to order an investigation:
"…so that a search may be made in the official chronicles of the kings who held your throne before you. In those very records (it is all written down) you will find, and know for certain, that this city here is a rebel city: a vassal that breaks faith with its overlords, a city that has cost kings and their provinces dearly in lost revenue and lost control. Its people have been brewing revolt inside its walls for ages, generation after generation. That is exactly why this city was reduced to ruins."
Several things are packed into the wording:
- "Your fathers" means the king's royal predecessors, the Babylonian and Assyrian kings whose archives the Persians inherited, not Artaxerxes' family tree.
- "The book of the records" is said twice. The writers insist that the charge is on file and can be checked.
- "Find" and "know" belong together: discovering the record will give the king settled certainty.
- "Rebellious" is the formal political term for a subject state that breaks its treaty with its overlord. The Bible itself uses the same root for Hezekiah's, Jehoiakim's and Zedekiah's revolts.
- "Damaging" includes financial loss. The previous verse warns that tribute, tax and toll will stop.
- "They have been making sedition" describes an ongoing, habitual activity.
- "Was laid waste" is passive: kings did this to the city. The writers leave the conclusion unspoken but obvious. Your predecessors had good reason to destroy it, so do not let it rise again.
-
16We advise the king that if this city is rebuilt and its walls are restored, you will have no dominion west of the Euphrates.
Full study →"We hereby report to the king: if that city gets rebuilt and its fortification walls are completed, then as a direct result you will no longer have any share at all in the province of Beyond-the-River."
This is the closing punchline of a formal complaint sent by provincial officials in Samaria to the Persian king Artaxerxes. They speak in the stiff, deferential style of an imperial report ("we are making known to the king"). Then they switch to a blunt, personal "you" for the threat. They never name Jerusalem here. It is just "that city," which they have already described as rebellious from ancient times (v. 15). The danger they stress is the walls: a finished wall circuit would turn a minor town into a fortress able to refuse tax and resist the crown.
The consequence is deliberately inflated. The king will not only lose Judah. He will lose his share, meaning his revenue, tribute and hold, in Beyond-the-River, the official name for the whole western province between the Euphrates and Egypt. The word for "share" puts money at the front. It goes back to their earlier warning that tribute, poll tax and land tax would stop (v. 13). So the verse appeals to the king's treasury and his strategic fears at once, using one hill town's walls as the lever.
-
17Then the king sent this reply: To Rehum the commander, Shimshai the scribe, and the rest of your associates living in Samaria and elsewhere in the region west of the Euphrates: Greetings.
Full study →The king wrote back. Artaxerxes' official reply was sent to Rehum, the senior imperial official in charge of orders and reports, to Shimshai, the secretary of the provincial office, and to the whole group of fellow officials stationed in Samaria and across the province officially called "Beyond the River," the Persian name for everything west of the Euphrates. The letter opens with the standard courtesy of an Aramaic official letter: "Greetings" (literally "Peace," a wish for their well-being). Then comes the fixed phrase that moves a letter from greeting to business: "And now…"
The verse is the heading of a state document, not a narrative of feelings. Every part of it is chancery language. "Reply" is a Persian term for an official answer. Rehum's title is a set Babylonian-Persian office. "Colleagues" is the word officials used for one another. "Beyond the River" is a provincial name. "Peace… and now" is the letter formula found in Aramaic papyri of the same century. The effect for the first hearers is that the complaint against Jerusalem (vv. 11–16) was heard and answered at the highest level, and the answer is about to come down, with all the weight of the empire, through the local officials who opposed the rebuilding.
-
18The letter you sent us has been translated and read in my presence.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
19I issued a decree, and a search was conducted. It was discovered that this city has revolted against kings from ancient times, engaging in rebellion and sedition.
Full study →"An order went out from me, and they searched the records and found it: this city, from time immemorial, has been one that keeps raising itself up against kings, a place where rebellion and insurrection are carried out."
King Artaxerxes is replying in formal court language to a complaint from Persian officials in the province "Beyond the River" (the lands west of the Euphrates). He first puts himself forward ("from me") and uses the standard office phrase for issuing an order. Then come two short verbs with no named subject, "they searched, they found": the court archivists did their job. What they found is presented as a fact about the city's character. The verb for "rising up" is a participle, so Jerusalem is pictured as the kind of city that is always lifting its head against its overlords, and that habit goes back "to the days of old," further than living memory. The last words, "rebellion and insurrection are done in it," treat the city as the place where revolt breeds. The two nouns are near-synonyms, one meaning a vassal's breakaway and the other stirred-up struggle, and together they make one heavy charge: open, repeated revolt, not just dangerous talk.
The charge was historically grounded. The Assyrian and Babylonian records that Persian kings had inherited would have shown Hezekiah's revolt against Sennacherib and the revolts of Jehoiakim and Zedekiah against Nebuchadnezzar.
-
20And mighty kings have ruled over Jerusalem and exercised authority over the whole region west of the Euphrates; and tribute, duty, and toll were paid to them.
Full study →Artaxerxes is writing back to the officials who accused the Jews of rebuilding Jerusalem. He has had the royal archives searched (v. 19), and this is his conclusion:
"Formidable kings have reigned over Jerusalem. They held real authority over the whole of my province Beyond-the-River, everything west of the Euphrates. Every kind of royal revenue (the tribute, the levy, the land-duty) used to flow, year after year, to them."
The word for "mighty" means raw political force. It is the same word Daniel uses for the iron kingdom and the terrifying fourth beast. "Beyond-the-River" is not loose geography. It is the official name of a Persian province, the king's own administrative territory. The three financial terms are technical tax vocabulary borrowed from Assyrian and Babylonian administration: general tribute, a levy probably paid in goods, and a duty tied to land held from the crown. Together they mean "all the income the crown draws from a province." The closing verb ("being given") describes a regular, ongoing flow of payments.
The king's logic is about money and security. A walled Jerusalem is not just a local building project. It is a city whose past shows it can become a rival centre of power, drawing to itself the revenue that should come to Persia (compare v. 13: "the royal revenue will suffer").
For the Jewish readers of Ezra the sentence has a second edge. The words "over all Beyond-the-River" echo the description of Solomon's empire in 1 Kings 5:4. The emperor's own archives, quoted by Judah's opponents, end up confirming that Jerusalem's kings were once great.
-
21Now, therefore, issue an order for these men to stop, so that this city will not be rebuilt until I so order.
Full study →"So now: you are to issue an official order to halt those men, and this city is not to be rebuilt until an order comes from me personally."
The king is answering a formal complaint from Rehum, a senior Persian official, and Shimshai, the scribe, who claimed that the Jews rebuilding Jerusalem's walls were restoring a rebellious city that would stop paying tribute. Artaxerxes has had his archives searched, found that Jerusalem had a history of independent kings and revolts (vv. 19–20), and now gives his ruling.
The verse is framed by one word, ṭĕʿēm, meaning "decree" or "official order". The king authorizes the local officials to "set an order" to stop the builders. He then reserves to himself the only "order" that could undo it. The ruling has two parts:
- Immediate: halt the builders. The verb means "make them cease", and the same verb comes back in vv. 23–24 when the work is forcibly stopped.
- Provisional: the city stays unbuilt only until the king himself decides otherwise. "From me" is placed first for emphasis: no governor or local official may lift the ban.
To its first readers the order sounds both final and open-ended. It stops the work with full imperial authority, yet it leaves room for the throne to change its mind, and in Nehemiah 2 the same king does exactly that.
-
22See that you do not neglect this matter. Why allow this threat to increase and the royal interests to suffer?
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
23When the text of the letter from King Artaxerxes was read to Rehum, Shimshai the scribe, and their associates, they went immediately to the Jews in Jerusalem and forcibly stopped them.
Full study →As soon as the copy of King Artaxerxes' official written order had been read aloud in front of Rehum, Shimshai the royal secretary, and the rest of their fellow officials, they hurried to Jerusalem, to the Judeans, and made them stop, with arm and army. In other words, by armed force.
What the English cannot easily carry:
- The speed. "From the moment that" and "in haste" frame the verse. The accusers had been waiting for this letter and moved the instant it was read.
- The paperwork. "Copy" and "written order" are both Persian government terms. This is a legal operation backed by the Great King's own document, read out in front of the regional officials. It is not mob violence.
- The echo. "Made them stop" uses exactly the verb of the king's command in 4:21 ("order these men to stop"), and the narrator repeats it twice in the next verse ("the work ceased… and remained stopped"). The decree said stop; they stopped them; and so the work stood still. The same verb comes back reversed in 5:5, where under a later king the officials "did not stop them" because "the eye of their God was on the elders of the Jews."
- The force. "With arm and force" is a vivid pair. The arm is the classic image of military might, and the second word often means an army. The Judeans were halted by armed men, not argued out of building.
- What was being stopped. In this letter the issue is the city's walls (4:12–16), which the court saw as a sign of coming rebellion. The temple had already been finished in 515 BC (6:15).
-
24Thus the construction of the house of God in Jerusalem ceased, and it remained at a standstill until the second year of the reign of Darius king of Persia.
Full study →So, back in that period, the building work on God's house in Jerusalem came to a halt, and it stayed halted, a site frozen in place, right up to the second year of Darius, king of Persia.
The verse closes a loop. The narrator has stepped aside (4:6–23) to show that the community's opponents kept up their pressure for generations, later under Xerxes and Artaxerxes and mainly over the city walls. Now he returns to where he left off in 4:5: from the days of Cyrus 'until the reign of Darius king of Persia', locals had worked to block the temple. The opening 'then' means 'at that time' in the story being told, not 'as a result of Artaxerxes' letter'.
The verb 'stop' sounds twice. First it stopped, then it was standing stopped, a long idleness rather than a brief pause. The same word was used just before for the officials who 'made them stop' (4:21, 23). It will come back when the Persians fail to stop the builders (5:5) and when Darius orders that no one stop them (6:8). What lay idle was the construction. The altar and sacrifices had been running since 3:3–6. The temple itself, 'the house of the God', the dwelling of Israel's God among his people, remained a bare foundation.
The date 'year two of Darius' (520 BC) is a deliberate signpost. It is the exact year in which Haggai and Zechariah began to prophesy (Haggai 1:1; Zechariah 1:1). The next verse (5:1) opens with them, and the restart follows at once.
Where the English drifted
-
in v7
the Syrian tongue / Syrian (KJV, WEB)
ʾărāmîṯ
- What we hear
- The language of the modern country of Syria, which most readers would assume is Arabic, or else 'Syriac', the later Christian liturgical dialect.
- What they heard
- Aramaic, the international language of administration and diplomacy in the Assyrian, Babylonian and especially Persian empires. A Persian king's officials in Samaria wrote to him in it.
-
in v7
companions (KJV, WEB)
kənāwōṯ
- What we hear
- Friends or travelling companions, an informal group of allies.
- What they heard
- Official colleagues: fellow office-holders acting together in a formal capacity, a standard term in Persian-period administrative letters.
-
in v8
chancellor (KJV, WEB)
bəʿēl ṭəʿēm
- What we hear
- A head of government (as in Germany or Austria) or the ceremonial head of a university.
- What they heard
- A provincial official responsible for official reports and orders, someone whose formal 'report' carried weight with the court. A senior regional bureaucrat, not a head of state.
-
in v8
commander (BSB, ESV, NASB)
bəʿēl ṭəʿēm
- What we hear
- A military officer leading troops.
- What they heard
- An administrative title connected with reports and decrees. Nothing in the term itself is military. Rehum's power is the power of the official report.
-
in v8
scribe
sāprāʾ
- What we hear
- A copyist who writes out texts by hand, or the religious 'scribes' of the Gospels.
- What they heard
- A government secretary who drafts, translates and files official documents, a professional administrator.
-
in v9
Dinaites, Apharsathchites, Tarpelites, Apharsites (KJV, WEB)
dînāyēʾ, ʾăpharsatkāyēʾ, ṭarpĕlāyēʾ, ʾăphārsāyēʾ
- What we hear
- Four obscure ancient tribes or nations living in Samaria.
- What they heard
- Probably mostly official titles: judges, envoys or commissioners, other officers, and Persians or a further class of Persian official. Several are loanwords from Persian administrative language.
-
in v9
the Dehavites (KJV) / the Dehaites (WEB)
dĕhûʾ (Qere) / dhyʾ (written)
- What we hear
- Yet another people group, separate from the Elamites.
- What they heard
- 'That is', an explanatory note: 'the men of Susa, that is, the Elamites.'
-
in v9
chancellor (KJV, WEB)
bĕʿēl ṭĕʿēm
- What we hear
- A head of government (as in Germany) or the head of a university.
- What they heard
- A provincial official, 'master of report/order', responsible for official orders and reports to higher authority.
-
in v9
companions (KJV, WEB, YLT)
kĕnāwāt
- What we hear
- Friends or personal companions.
- What they heard
- Colleagues in office: fellow officials co-signing an administrative document.
-
in v10
on this side the river (KJV)
avar naharah
- What we hear
- The near side of a river, from the speaker's own point of view, perhaps the Jordan.
- What they heard
- The official name of the Persian province west of the Euphrates, i.e. 'across the River' as seen from Mesopotamia and Persia.
-
in v10
at such a time (KJV, YLT)
u-khe'enet
- What we hear
- A date, or a note that the letter was sent 'at a certain time'.
- What they heard
- 'And now', the fixed phrase in Aramaic letters that moves from greeting to business.
-
in v10
brought over (KJV, WEB)
hagli
- What we hear
- Brought over or transported, possibly as willing migrants.
- What they heard
- Deported: forcibly sent into exile by a conquering king.
-
in v12
wicked (BSB, ESV, NIV); evil (NASB)
bəʾîštāʾ
- What we hear
- Morally depraved or sinful in the sight of God: a city judged for its religious evil.
- What they heard
- Bad, harmful, troublesome. In this report it means a city that is a danger to the crown's interests, paired with 'rebellious'. It is a political and security judgment from Persian officials.
-
in v12
rebellious
māradtāʾ
- What we hear
- Defiant or nonconformist in attitude.
- What they heard
- Guilty of political revolt: a subject city that has thrown off its overlord and refused tribute, as Jerusalem did against Assyria and Babylon.
-
in v12, v23
the Jews
yəhûdāyēʾ
- What we hear
- Members of a religion, or the Jewish people as later history shaped them.
- What they heard
- The Judeans: people belonging to Judah and the Persian province of Yehud, here specifically the returned exiles. It was used by imperial officials as an administrative people-name.
-
in v13
toll / custom
hălāk (also bĕlô)
- What we hear
- A fee for using a road or bridge, or a customs duty charged on goods crossing a border.
- What they heard
- Probably the ilku: the duty owed by people holding land from the crown, by this period usually paid in silver as a land tax. 'Custom' in the KJV meant a customary due or tax, not border customs. Together with mindah and belo it means 'every category of royal tax'.
-
in v15
hurtful (unto kings and provinces)
məhanzəqat (nəzaq)
- What we hear
- Emotionally wounding or offensive, as in "a hurtful comment".
- What they heard
- Causing damage or loss to the rulers and their administrative districts, especially lost tribute and revenue (compare v. 13) and lost control.
-
in v15
your fathers
ʾavāhātākh
- What we hear
- The king's own biological ancestors: his father, grandfather and so on.
- What they heard
- The kings who held the throne before him, including the Babylonian and Assyrian rulers whose records the Persians inherited. Artaxerxes' own family never fought Jerusalem.
-
in v15
book (of the records)
sefar
- What we hear
- A bound volume with pages.
- What they heard
- A written document or scroll; here the court's archive of official records, kept on scrolls and, in the Babylonian archives, on clay tablets.
-
in v16
on this side the river (KJV)
baʿăbar nahărāʾ
- What we hear
- "This side" sounds like the writer's own side of the river, or near side. Readers may picture the east bank, or even the Jordan.
- What they heard
- An official province name, "Beyond-the-River," meaning everything west of the Euphrates, named from the Mesopotamian heartland of the empire.
-
in v16
We certify the king (KJV)
məhôdəʿîn
- What we hear
- A formal, legal-sounding attestation, like certifying a document as true.
- What they heard
- "We are making known / informing," the ordinary reporting formula of an Aramaic official letter.
-
in v16
dominion (BSB)
ḥălāq
- What we hear
- Sovereign rule or authority in the abstract.
- What they heard
- A "share, portion": the king's allotted part of the province, especially its revenue (see v. 13's tribute, poll tax and land tax).
-
in v17
Peace (KJV, WEB, YLT)
shelam
- What we hear
- A wish for an end to conflict, or a spiritual blessing like 'peace be with you' in a religious sense.
- What they heard
- The routine greeting of an official letter, wishing the recipients well. It works like 'Greetings' or 'Dear sirs.'
-
in v17
and at such a time (KJV, YLT)
ukheʿet
- What we hear
- A placeholder for a date, or the start of a time reference ('at such a time as this').
- What they heard
- 'And now.' The fixed phrase that ends the greeting and introduces the body of the letter.
-
in v17
chancellor (KJV, WEB) / commander (BSB, ESV, NASB)
beʿel-teʿem
- What we hear
- 'Chancellor' sounds like a head of government or a university head. 'Commander' sounds like a military officer.
- What they heard
- 'Master of report/decree,' a set official title, probably a senior imperial official responsible for orders and reports to the court. Its exact duties are uncertain.
-
in v19
sedition (KJV, BSB, ESV)
ʾeštaddûr
- What we hear
- Speech, writing or organising that stirs people up against the government: a crime of words and conspiracy.
- What they heard
- Active insurrection or revolt, from a root meaning "to strive or struggle": open uprising carried out "in" the city, paired with mərad, "rebellion."
-
in v20
toll / custom
hălāk, bəlō
- What we hear
- "Toll" sounds like a fee for using a road or bridge, and "custom(s)" like import duty paid at a border.
- What they heard
- Imperial tax categories borrowed from Akkadian. Hălāk most likely meant the duty owed on land held from the king (originally service, often paid in silver by this period), and bəlō a levy often paid in goods. The pair do not refer to road tolls or border customs.
-
in v21
commandment (KJV)
ṭĕʿēm
- What we hear
- Readers today often hear 'commandment' as a religious or moral law, like the Ten Commandments.
- What they heard
- A secular administrative order issued by Persian officials under royal authority.
-
in v23
by force and power (KJV, ESV)
bəʾedrāʿ wəḥāyil
- What we hear
- With great determination or authority; 'power' heard as abstract might or official clout.
- What they heard
- 'With arm and army', meaning armed force. The arm is a picture of military strength, and ḥayil frequently means troops.
-
in v24
Then / Thus / So (opening word)
bē'dayin
- What we hear
- The temple work stopped as a direct result of King Artaxerxes' order in verse 23, and immediately after it.
- What they heard
- 'At that time': a marker that picks the story up again from 4:5 after a side-section. The stoppage meant here ran from the reign of Cyrus to Darius I's second year (520 BC), decades before Artaxerxes I.
-
in v24
service (YLT)
ʿăbîdâ
- What we hear
- Worship services or temple rituals stopped.
- What they heard
- The labor of building the temple. The altar and its daily offerings had been running since Ezra 3:3–6.
Every word
-
וּבְמַלְכוּת֙
u-vemalkhut · H4438
and in the reign of · v6
Opens a new step in the narrator's list of hostile episodes: 'and (next) in the reign of…'. The noun malkhut, 'kingship, reign', is typical of later Hebrew (Chronicles, Esther, Daniel, Ezra) and here marks a period of rule.
-
אֲחַשְׁוֵר֔וֹשׁ
ʾAḥashwerosh · H0325
Ahasuerus · v6
The Hebrew form of the Persian royal name Xšayāršā, known in Greek as Xerxes. Almost certainly Xerxes I (486–465 BC), the same king as in the book of Esther.
-
בִּתְחִלַּ֖ת
bitḥillat · H8462
at the beginning of · v6
'At the start of'. It pins the letter to the first months of the new king's rule, when a new monarch was hearing petitions and settling his empire.
-
כָּתְב֣וּ
katvu · H3789
they wrote · v6, v7
'They wrote' (a completed act). No subject is named; 'they' are the opponents of verses 1–5, the 'people of the land'. Persian government ran on written letters, so 'writing' means filing a formal document with the court.
-
שִׂטְנָ֔ה
śiṭnah · H7855
accusation, hostile charge · v6
A written denunciation meant to turn the king against the Judeans. It comes from the same root as śāṭān, 'adversary, accuser', so it carries the sense of hostile opposition, not a neutral report.
-
עַל־
ʿal · H5921A
upon, against · v6, v7
Coming after a word for accusation, 'al means 'against': the charge is aimed at the community.
-
יֹשְׁבֵ֥י
yoshvei · H3427
dwellers of, inhabitants of · v6
'Those living in'. The target is the whole settled population, the returned exiles and their community now living in the land, not just its leaders or the temple project.
-
יְהוּדָ֖ה
Yehudah · H3063G
Judah · v6
Here this is the small Persian province of Yehud around Jerusalem, not the old kingdom of Judah. It was a district of the province 'Beyond the River' (the lands west of the Euphrates).
-
וִירוּשָׁלִָֽם׃
virushalaim · H3389
and Jerusalem · v6
'And Jerusalem', the provincial centre and site of the rebuilt temple. The pairing 'Judah and Jerusalem' sums up the whole restored community. The ס that follows is a scribal paragraph marker.
-
וּבִימֵ֣י
ūḇîmê · H3117G
and in the days of · v7
A standard dating formula, 'in the time of'. The 'and' links this report to the one before (v. 6, under Xerxes) as the next item in a list of hostile letters, not as the next event in a story.
-
אַרְתַּחְשַׁ֗שְׂתָּא
ʾartaḥšaśtāʾ · H0783A
Artaxerxes · v7, v8, v23
Hebrew form of the Persian throne name Artaxšaçā, roughly 'whose rule is through Truth/right order (arta)'. Most likely Artaxerxes I (465–424 BC), the king of Ezra 7 and Nehemiah.
-
בִּשְׁלָ֜ם
bišlām · H1312
Bishlam · v7
Either a personal name (so the supplied data, 1 Esdras and most English versions) or the phrase bi-šəlām, 'in peace / with the agreement of' (so the Septuagint). Which one is meant is disputed; see debates.
-
מִתְרְדָ֤ת
miṯrəḏāṯ · H4990H
Mithredath · v7
A Persian name, 'given by Mithra' (Greek Mithridates). The same name belongs to Cyrus's treasurer in Ezra 1:8, but this is almost certainly a different man; the name was common.
-
טָֽבְאֵל֙
ṭāḇəʾēl · H2870A
Tabeel · v7
An Aramaic name, 'God is good' (compare 'son of Tabeel' in Isaiah 7:6). Next to the Persian Mithredath it shows the mixed group of officials typical of a Persian province.
-
וּשְׁאָ֣ר
ūšəʾār · H7605
and the rest of · v7
'The remainder', i.e. everyone else in the group. Here it simply means 'the others'; it has nothing to do with the 'remnant' theme used elsewhere for surviving Israel.
-
כְּנָוֹתָ֔יו
kənāwōṯāw · H3674
his colleagues · v7
A technical Aramaic word from Persian administration: fellow officials of the same office or rank. 'His' points back to one leading man, probably Mithredath or Tabeel. Found only here in Hebrew; common in the Aramaic part of Ezra and the Elephantine papyri.
-
מֶ֣לֶךְ
meleḵ · H4428G
king of · v7
The ordinary word for king, here part of the official title 'king of Persia'.
-
פָּרָ֑ס
pārās · H6539
Persia · v7
Persia, the homeland of the ruling Achaemenid dynasty, used here for the whole empire, which ran from the Aegean to India.
-
וּכְתָב֙
ūḵəṯāḇ · H3791
and the writing of · v7
This can mean the text or wording of a document, or the script it is written in (as in Esther 1:22, 'each province in its own script'). Which sense applies decides how the end of the verse is read.
-
הַֽנִּשְׁתְּוָ֔ן
hanništtəwān · H5406
the letter / official document · v7
A Persian loanword for an official written document. Here it is a formal petition sent through the imperial chancery (the government's writing office), not a private letter.
-
אֲרָמִ֖ית
ʾărāmîṯ · H0762
Aramaic / in Aramaic · v7
'In Aramaic', the official written language of the Persian Empire. With 'writing' read as script, this could mean 'in Aramaic script'.
-
וּמְתֻרְגָּ֥ם
ūməṯurgām · H8638
and translated / interpreted · v7
Passive form, 'translated' or 'rendered'. It occurs only here in the Hebrew Bible, and it is the root of the later word Targum (an Aramaic translation of scripture). It may mean the letter was put into Aramaic, or read out and interpreted for the king.
-
רְח֣וּם
reḥûm · H7348B
-
בְּעֵל־
bəʿēl- · H1169
owner, master, holder of · v8, v9, v17
Aramaic equivalent of Hebrew baʿal, 'owner/lord'. Joined to the next word it forms an official title: 'holder of the ṭəʿēm', the man in charge of reports and orders.
-
טְעֵ֗ם
ṭəʿēm · H2942
report, judgment, decree · v8, v9, v17, v19, v21
Originally 'taste', then 'judgment/discretion', then in administrative Aramaic 'official report' or 'order'. In the title it marks Rehum as the official responsible for official reports and correspondence: the man whose word carried official weight.
-
וְשִׁמְשַׁי֙
wəšimšay · H8124
and Shimshai · v8, v9, v17, v23
A personal name probably connected with šemeš, 'sun' (something like 'sunny' or 'my sun'). He is the second named author of the letter.
-
סָֽפְרָ֔א
sāprāʾ · H5613
the scribe, secretary · v8, v9, v17, v23
Not a mere copyist. In Persian administration the sāprāʾ was the secretary who composed, drafted and handled official correspondence, a trained bureaucrat of real standing.
-
כְּתַ֛בוּ
kətabû · H3790
they wrote · v8
Simple past: the letter was composed and sent. The plural makes both officials joint authors and jointly responsible for it.
-
אִגְּרָ֥ה
ʾiggərāh · H0104
letter · v8
A loanword ultimately from Akkadian egirtu, used for official letters in the Persian empire. It signals an official dispatch to the court, not a private note.
-
חֲדָ֖ה
ḥădāh · H2298
one · v8
The numeral 'one'. Aramaic often uses it where English uses 'a': 'a letter'. It may also hint at a single joint letter from the whole group named in 4:9.
-
עַל־
ʿal- · H5922
upon, concerning, against · v8, v12, v15, v17, v19, v20, v23
The preposition can mean 'about' or 'against'. The letter that follows (4:11–16) is plainly an accusation, so 'against' fits the content, though the word itself only says 'concerning'.
-
יְרוּשְׁלֶ֑ם
yərûšəlem · H3390
Jerusalem · v8, v12, v20, v23, v24
The city whose walls the returned exiles were rebuilding (4:12). The letter targets the city as a political unit, not only the temple.
-
מַלְכָּ֖א
malkāʾ · H4430
the king · v8, v12, v13, v15, v16, v17, v19, v20, v23, v24
The Great King of Persia, the top of the imperial chain. The letter skips any intermediate level and goes straight to the court.
-
כְּנֵֽמָא׃
kənēmāʾ · H3660
thus, as follows · v8
An Aramaic adverb, 'thus'. It points forward to the document about to be quoted, like a colon introducing a copy of the file.
-
אֱדַ֜יִן
ʾĕdayin · H0116
then · v9, v23, v24
A connecting word ('then, at that time') common in Ezra's Aramaic narrative. There is no main verb, so it most likely opens the formal heading of the letter that v. 8 just mentioned. KJV supplies '[wrote]' to make a sentence.
-
וּשְׁאָ֖ר
ûšĕʾār · H7606
remainder, rest · v9, v10, v17
'And the rest of': it brings in the whole body of co-signers behind the two named men.
-
כְּנָוָתְה֑וֹן
kĕnāwātĕhôn · H3675
colleague, associate · v9, v17, v23
'Their colleagues': a technical word in Persian-era Aramaic for fellow officials of the same rank or office. It is not 'friends' or 'companions' in a social sense.
-
דִּ֠ינָיֵא
dînāyēʾ · H1784
judges (traditionally 'Dinaites') · v9
Most likely 'the judges', from dîn, 'judgment'. The traditional vowel marks treat it as the name of a people ('Dinaites'), but no such people is known, and an official title fits the list better.
-
וַאֲפַרְסַתְכָיֵ֞א
waʾăpharsatkāyēʾ · H0671B
envoys, officials (traditionally 'Apharsathchites') · v9
'And the envoys/officials': probably an Old Persian title for a kind of commissioned official, perhaps an envoy or investigator. KJV turned it into a people, the 'Apharsathchites'.
-
טַרְפְּלָיֵ֣א
ṭarpĕlāyēʾ · H2967
officials (?) / men of Tripolis (?) · v9
Meaning uncertain. It is either another official title (so the supplied gloss 'officials') or people of a place, sometimes identified as Tripolis on the Phoenician coast (so BSB).
-
אֲפָֽרְסָיֵ֗א
ʾăphārsāyēʾ · H0670
Persians (?) · v9
Read either as 'the Persians' or as one more Persian official title. Some scholars emend it to 'Sipparites', men of the Babylonian city of Sippar. The supplied in-context gloss gives that reading, although its lemma gloss says 'Persian'.
-
אַרְכְּוָיֵ֤א
ʾarkĕwāyēʾ · H0756
men of Erech (Uruk) · v9
'The men of Erech', the ancient city of Uruk in southern Babylonia (Genesis 10:10). These are descendants of people deported from there.
-
בָבְלָיֵא֙
bāblāyēʾ · H0896
Babylonians · v9
'The Babylonians': descendants of deportees from the city of Babylon who had been resettled in the west.
-
שֽׁוּשַׁנְכָיֵ֔א
šûšankāyēʾ · H7801
men of Susa · v9
'The men of Susa', the old Elamite capital and later a Persian royal city. The -k- in the word is a Persian-style ending for 'people of a place'.
-
דֶּהָיֵ֖א
dĕhāyēʾ (read dĕhûʾ) · H1723
that is (traditionally 'Dehavites') · v9
The scribes' reading (Qere) is dĕhûʾ, 'that is'. It works as an explanatory note: 'the men of Susa, that is, the Elamites'. The written consonants were taken in KJV as yet another people, the 'Dehavites'.
-
עֵלְמָיֵֽא׃
ʿēlĕmāyēʾ · H5962
Elamites · v9
'The Elamites': people from Elam, the land east of Babylonia whose capital was Susa. With the word before it, this explains who the 'men of Susa' are.
-
אֻמַּיָּא
ummayya · H0524
the peoples, nations · v10
Ethnic groups, meaning communities of shared descent and origin. Here these are the transplanted population groups listed in v. 9 (Babylonians, people of Susa, Elamites and others). They are not states.
-
דִּי
di · H1768
which, whom · v10, v12, v13, v15, v16, v17, v19, v23, v24
Relative particle introducing what was done to these peoples.
-
הַגְלִי
hagli · H1541
deported, carried into exile · v10
A causative form of a root whose basic sense is 'uncover, lay bare'. In this causative form it means 'to make go into exile, deport'. It is the vocabulary of Assyrian mass relocation of conquered peoples.
-
אָסְנַפַּר
Osnappar · H0620
Osnappar (= Ashurbanipal) · v10
A shortened Aramaic form of an Assyrian royal name. It is almost universally identified with Ashurbanipal (Aššur-bāni-apli), king of Assyria 668–c. 631 BC.
-
רַבָּא
rabba · H7229
the great · v10
A royal honorific. It echoes the Assyrian kings' standard title 'great king' (šarru rabû).
-
וְיַקִּירָא
we-yaqqira · H3358
and the honored, noble · v10
Literally 'weighty, precious'. Here it is an honorific, 'the illustrious'. The writers speak of the Assyrian conqueror with respect because their own standing in the land rests on his decree.
-
וְהוֹתֵב
we-hotev · H3488
and he settled · v10, v17
Causative of 'sit, dwell': 'he made them dwell'. This is the second half of Assyrian deportation policy: remove a population, then plant it somewhere else.
-
הִמּוֹ
himmo · H1994
them · v10, v23
Object pronoun referring back to the deported peoples.
-
בְּקִרְיָה
be-qiryah · H7149
in the city, town · v10, v12, v13, v15, v16, v19, v21
Singular in the Aramaic text: 'in the city of Samaria'. Ancient translations read 'cities' (see variants).
-
שָׁמְרָיִן
Shamrayin · H8115
Samaria · v10, v17
The Aramaic name of the old northern Israelite capital. In the Persian period it was also the name of the province governed from it, and it is attested in contemporary Aramaic papyri as šmryn.
-
עֲבַר־
Avar- · H5675
the region beyond, across · v10, v16, v17, v20
First half of a fixed administrative name: 'Beyond-the-River'.
-
נַהֲרָה
Naharah · H5103G
the River (Euphrates) · v10, v16, v17, v20
'The River' with no further name is the Euphrates. Avar-Naharah is the official Persian name of the province west of the Euphrates (Syria-Palestine), named from the point of view of the imperial centre in Mesopotamia and Persia.
-
וּכְעֶנֶת
u-khe'enet · H3706
and now · v10, v17
The standard phrase in Aramaic letters that closes the address and greeting and moves into the business of the letter. It shows that the narrator is quoting, or splicing together, an actual letter heading.
-
יְדִ֙יעַ֙
yədîaʿ · H3046
known · v12, v13, v15, v16
A passive participle, 'known', that opens a set formula from Persian-period official letters. It marks the start of the letter's main business: information the king is formally asked to take note of.
-
לֶהֱוֵ֣א
lehĕwēʾ · H1934
let it be · v12, v13, v20, v24
'Let it be', a wish form of 'to be'. In Biblical Aramaic this verb oddly takes an l- prefix instead of the usual y-. Together with the first word it makes the polite official phrase 'be it known'.
-
יְהוּדָיֵ֗א
yəhûdāyēʾ · H3062
the Jews / Judeans · v12, v23
'The Judeans': people belonging to Judah, which was then the Persian province of Yehud. Here it means specifically the returned exiles now living in and around Jerusalem.
-
סְלִ֙קוּ֙
səliqû · H5559
-
מִן־
min · H4481
from · v12, v15, v19, v21, v23
'From': marks where the movement began.
-
לְוָתָ֔ךְ
ləwātāḵ · H3890
beside you, near you · v12
'From beside you', meaning from the king's presence or his home territory in the east. The phrase quietly reminds the king that these people came west under his authority, so whatever they do now reflects on him.
-
אֲת֖וֹ
ʾătô · H0858
they have come · v12
'They have come': a completed arrival. Paired with 'went up', it traces the route from the king's side, into 'our' territory, and on to Jerusalem.
-
מָֽרָדְתָּ֤א
māradtāʾ · H4779
rebellious · v12, v15
'The rebellious one': a political charge. The word means a place that revolts against its overlord. It points back to Jerusalem's revolts against Assyria and Babylon, which the writers invite the king to check in his archives (v. 15).
-
וּבִֽישְׁתָּא֙
ûḇîštāʾ · H0873
and bad, evil · v12
'And the bad one': harmful, troublesome, dangerous to the crown. Next to 'rebellious' it means a bad risk politically, not a city charged with religious sin.
-
בָּנַ֔יִן
bānayin · H1124
building · v12, v13, v16, v21
'They are building'. A participle, so the work is pictured as going on right now. This makes the report sound urgent.
-
וְשׁוּרַיָּ֣א
wəšûrayyāʾ · H7792
and the walls · v12, v13, v16
'And the walls': the city's defensive ring. To an imperial official, rebuilt walls meant a city able to shut its gates against the empire.
-
שַׁכְלִ֔ילוּ
šaḵlîlû · H3635A
they have completed · v12, v13, v16
'They have completed (or finished off)'. The verb comes from Akkadian, the Babylonian administrative language. Its completed form clashes with v. 13 ('if… the walls are completed'), so it is either rhetorical exaggeration or means 'they are bringing to completion'.
-
וְאֻשַּׁיָּ֖א
wəʾuššayyāʾ · H0787
and the foundations · v12
'And the foundations', another Babylonian loanword (Akkadian uššu). Here it probably means the base courses of the city walls.
-
יַחִֽיטוּ׃
yaḥîṭû · H2338
they repair, join · v12
'They are repairing (or joining up)'. The root may be related to the word for sewing or thread, hence KJV 'joined'. The picture is of mending and closing gaps in old footings. The ongoing form ends the letter on work still under way.
-
כְּעַ֗ן
kĕʿan · H3705
now · v13, v21
A standard marker in Aramaic letters meaning 'and now', which moves from the opening into the point of the letter. It shows up the same way in the Elephantine papyri (Aramaic letters from 5th-century BC Egypt). Here it brings in the financial argument that backs up the accusation in v. 12.
-
הֵ֣ן
hēn · H2006A
if · v13, v16
In Aramaic this is the ordinary word for 'if', not the Hebrew 'look!'. It frames the whole verse as a prediction: if this happens, that will follow.
-
דָךְ֙
dāk · H1791
this, that · v13, v15, v16, v19, v21
A demonstrative ('that/this'). It points at the city from a distance with a little disdain: 'that city', the one just denounced.
-
מִנְדָּֽה־
mindāh · H4061
tribute · v13, v20
The regular tribute owed to the crown, borrowed from Akkadian mandattu ('what is given'). It is the first of three standard Persian-era tax terms.
-
בְל֤וֹ
bĕlô · H1093
tax, duty · v13, v20
A second kind of royal levy. It is probably from Akkadian biltu (a 'load', so a rent or tax paid in produce or goods). The exact difference from mindah is not certain.
-
וַהֲלָךְ֙
wahălāk · H1983
toll; service-due · v13, v20
Traditionally linked to the verb 'to go', which gave the reading 'road toll'. Most specialists now trace it to Akkadian ilku, the service owed by holders of crown land, which by Persian times was usually paid in silver as a land tax.
-
לָ֣א
lāʾ · H3809
not · v13, v16, v21
Plain negation. The three taxes are put first for emphasis: 'tribute, duty and service-due: these they will not give.'
-
יִנְתְּנ֔וּן
yintĕnûn · H5415I
to give, pay · v13
'They will give', meaning pay. 'They' are the Jews of Jerusalem. The charge is that they will stop paying, which amounts to revolt.
-
וְאַפְּתֹ֥ם
wĕʾappĕtōm · H0674
revenue; or finally · v13
A Persian loanword whose meaning is disputed. Read as a noun it is 'the revenue/treasury (of kings)'. Read as an adverb it is 'and in the end' or 'surely'. Either way the clause ends the letter's financial threat.
-
תְּהַנְזִֽק׃
tĕhanzīq · H5142
to cause damage · v13, v15
'It will damage' or 'you will damage' (same spelling). The verb is about real financial loss to the crown. The same root comes back in vv. 15 and 22 ('harmful to kings', 'damage grow').
-
יְבַקַּר֩
yəvaqqar · H1240
to search, inquire, investigate · v15, v19
"Let one search" — a third-person form with no named subject, so effectively "let a search be made". It is a polite way of asking the king to order an investigation, not telling him to do it himself.
-
בִּֽסְפַר־
bisfar · H5609
document, scroll, book · v15
"In the scroll / document of" — a written record, a scroll or archive, not a bound book.
-
דָּכְרָ֨נַיָּ֜א
dokhranayyā · H1799
record, memorandum · v15
"The records" — official entries kept to preserve what happened (from the root "to remember"). Together with the previous word: the royal chronicle or archive.
-
אֲבָהָתָ֗ךְ
ʾavāhātākh · H2
father, forefather · v15
"Your fathers" — in royal speech, the kings who held the throne before you, not only blood ancestors. The Persian king is treated as heir of the Babylonian (and Assyrian) kings whose records would mention Jerusalem.
-
וּ֠תְהַשְׁכַּח
ūtəhashkaḥ · H7912
to find · v15, v19
"And you will find" — the writers are confident the evidence is there. (In Aramaic this root means "find"; the similar-looking Hebrew word means "forget".)
-
וּמְדִנָ֔ן
ūmədīnān · H4083
province, administrative district · v15
"And provinces" — the imperial administrative districts. The threat is not just to the king's honour but to the stability of the regional system of government.
-
וְאֶשְׁתַּדּוּר֙
wəʾeshtaddūr · H849
revolt, sedition · v15, v19
"And sedition" — organised stirring-up against authority. Placed first in its clause for emphasis.
-
עָבְדִ֣ין
ʿāvədīn · H5648
to do, make · v15, v19
"They make / have been making" — an ongoing participle with an unnamed "they": the inhabitants habitually produce revolt. Pictures sedition as a standing activity of the city.
-
בְּגַוַּ֔הּ
bəgawwah · H1459
midst, inside · v15
"In its midst" — revolt is brewed inside the city itself, which is why walls (vv. 12–13, 16) are so alarming.
-
יוֹמָ֖ת
yōmāt · H3118
day · v15, v19
"The days of" — a period of time.
-
עָלְמָ֑א
ʿāləmā · H5957
long duration, antiquity, perpetuity · v15, v19
"The long ago": "from days of old". The word means a remote or unbounded stretch of time; here it points backward, to centuries of history.
-
דְּנָ֔ה
dənāh · H1836
this · v15, v16
"This": "because of this", that is, "that is why".
-
הָֽחָרְבַֽת׃
hoḥorvat · H2718
to be laid waste, devastated · v15
"Was laid waste" — a passive form: someone did this to it. The unspoken agent is the earlier kings (Nebuchadnezzar in 587/586 BC), so the past ruin is offered as precedent for how a king should treat this city.
-
אֲנַ֙חְנָה֙
ʾănaḥnâ · H0586
we · v16
The senders, Rehum, Shimshai and their associates (vv. 8–9), speaking as one body of local officials. Spelling the pronoun out stresses that loyal servants are the ones giving the warning.
-
לָקֳבֵ֣ל
lāqŏbēl · H6903G
before, in front of; corresponding to · v16
Literally "in front of." With "this" it means "as a result of this, consequently." KJV's "by this means" catches it.
-
חֲלָק֙
ḥălāq · H2508
portion, share · v16
"A portion, a share." It means the king's share in the province: his holding, and especially the revenue v. 13 says will stop. The word comes first in its clause for emphasis: "a share … you will have none."
-
אִיתַ֖י
ʾîtay · H0383
there is, exists · v16
"There is." With "not" and "to you" it is the normal Aramaic way to say "you will have no …". The tone is blunt and complete.
-
לָֽךְ׃
lāk · H9031
to you · v16
"To you," singular, meaning the king himself. After the formal third person ("to the king"), the letter ends on a direct personal threat: you, Artaxerxes, will lose the province.
-
פִּתְגָמָ֞א
pitgāmāʾ · H6600
word, reply, decree · v17
'The reply' or 'the written answer.' A Persian loanword for an official message. It is placed first for emphasis: what follows is the king's answer to the complaint in vv. 11–16.
-
שְׁלַ֣ח
šəlaḥ · H7972
to send · v17
'Sent.' The ordinary verb for sending a letter or messenger. In the perfect form it reports a finished act: the reply was written and sent off.
-
שְׁלָ֖ם
šəlām · H8001
peace, welfare, well-being · v17
'Peace' or 'greetings.' This is the standard opening greeting of an Aramaic letter, a wish for the readers' well-being, much like 'Greetings' or 'Dear sirs.' It is not a statement about peace between peoples.
-
שִׂים
śîm · H7761
was set / was made · v19, v21
Literally "was placed." Together with ṭəʿēm it forms the fixed office phrase for issuing an official order, the same as Akkadian ṭēma šakānu, "to set an order."
-
מִתְנַשְּׂאָה
mitnaśśəʾāh · H5376
lifting itself up, rising up · v19
A reflexive form, "raising itself up," in the feminine to match "city." It is a participle, which makes the uprising a habit of the city's character ("is always rising up") and not a single past event.
-
וּמְרַד
ûmərad · H4776
and rebellion · v19
A vassal throwing off its overlord. In Hebrew, the matching verb describes Hezekiah, Jehoiakim and Zedekiah revolting against Assyria and Babylon.
-
בַּהּ
bah · H9034
in it · v19
"In her," meaning in the city. Jerusalem is pictured as the place where revolt breeds, not only as the one doing it.
-
תַּקִּיפִ֗ין
taqqīfīn · H8624
-
וְשַׁ֨לִּיטִ֔ין
wə-šallīṭīn · H7990
having mastery, ruling · v20
"Holding authority": the power to give orders and collect what is owed. The same word comes back in Ezra 7:24, where no one is "authorized" to take these same three taxes from the temple staff.
-
בְּכֹ֖ל
bə-kōl · H3606
in all, over the whole · v20
"Over the whole of": the claim is about the whole province, not a corner of it. That makes the threat larger.
-
מִתְיְהֵ֥ב
mityəhēb · H3052
being given, paid · v20
A passive participle, "being given." Set in a past context it describes ongoing, regular payment: the money used to flow to Jerusalem's kings, and it could again.
-
לְהֽוֹן׃
ləhōn · H9038
to them · v20
"To them," meaning the Jerusalem kings. The sting is that revenue going to them is revenue not going to Persia.
-
לְבַטָּלָ֖א
lĕbaṭṭālāʾ · H989
to cease; (in this form) to make cease · v21, v23, v24
'To make … stop', an infinitive in the form that means causing an action. The same root comes back in vv. 23–24 ('they made them cease'; 'the work ceased'), and the narrator uses that repetition to tie the episode together.
-
גֻּבְרַיָּ֣א
gubrayyāʾ · H1400
man · v21
'The men', meaning the Jewish builders the complaint described (v. 12). It is ordinary Aramaic for men or persons and carries no special nuance of 'warrior' here.
-
אִלֵּ֑ךְ
ʾillēk · H479
these, those · v21
Points back to the group named in the complaint: 'those men' you wrote about.
-
עַד־
ʿad · H5705
until · v21, v24
This word makes the ban temporary. It sets a time limit: the halt lasts until the king decides otherwise.
-
פַּרְשֶׁ֤גֶן
paršegen · H6573
copy · v23
A Persian loanword for a copy or duplicate of a document. The officials got an official copy; the original order stayed in the royal chancery.
-
נִשְׁתְּוָנָא֙
ništəwānāʾ · H5407
letter, written order · v23
Another Persian administrative word: an official written communication, here the king's reply and order of 4:17–22. It is a government document, not a personal letter.
-
קֱרִ֧י
qĕrî · H7123
to read, call out · v23
A passive form: 'was read'. In the ancient world reading usually meant reading aloud. A secretary read the order out in front of the assembled officials, which made it public and binding.
-
קֳדָם־
qŏdām · H6925
before, in front of · v23
'Before' or 'in the presence of'. The usual phrase for something read or presented to officials.
-
אֲזַ֨לוּ
ʾăzalû · H0236
to go · v23
'They went'. A plain verb of motion; the urgency comes from the next word.
-
בִבְהִיל֤וּ
bibhîlû · H0924
haste · v23
'In haste'. The word comes from a root linked with alarm and hurry. They lost no time using the authority they had just been given.
-
בְּאֶדְרָ֥ע
bəʾedrāʿ · H0153
arm; force · v23
'With arm'. This is the Aramaic form of the Hebrew zərôaʿ, 'arm'. The arm is the ancient picture of physical and military power. The word occurs only here in the Bible.
-
וְחָֽיִל׃
wəḥāyil · H2429
strength, force, army · v23
'And force'. The word often means an armed force or army (as in Daniel 3:20 in Aramaic). Paired with 'arm', it means armed force, not just 'with determination'.
-
עֲבִידַ֣ת
ʿăbîdat · H5673
-
בֵּית־
bêt- · H1005
house, temple · v24
'House of'. Used of a god, this is the normal way to say 'temple': the god's home and palace.
-
אֱלָהָ֔א
'ĕlāhā' · H0426
god, God · v24
'The God'. The -ā' ending works like English 'the'. Persian-period Aramaic used this ordinary phrase for Israel's God, and Jewish documents of the time used it too.
-
שְׁנַ֣ת
šənat · H8140
year · v24
'The year of', the first word of a date given by the king's year on the throne.
-
תַּרְתֵּ֔ין
tartên · H8648
two · v24
'Two'. It is in the feminine form to match 'year'. 'Year two' is the same date given in Haggai 1:1 and Zechariah 1:1.
-
לְמַלְכ֖וּת
ləmalkût · H4437
kingdom, reign, royal rule · v24
'Of the reign of'. Here it means a king's years on the throne, the standard way of dating events in the ancient Near East, not a territory.
-
דָּרְיָ֥וֶשׁ
dārəyāweš · H1868G
Darius · v24
Darius I (522–486 BC). The name comes from Old Persian Dārayavauš. His second year began in spring 520 BC.
-
פָּרָֽס׃
pārās · H6540
Persia · v24
'Persia'. Darius's own inscriptions also call him 'king in Persia', and this title ties the date to the empire that was both permitting the work and policing it. A paragraph break (פ) follows.
The world behind it
Where this verse sits. Ezra 4:6–23 interrupts the story's timeline. Verse 5 brings events to the reign of Darius I (522–486 BC), when the temple was rebuilt (finished 515 BC, Ezra 6:15). Verse 24 picks up the story again under Darius. In between, the narrator gathers later examples of opposition, under Xerxes I (v. 6, 486–465 BC) and Artaxerxes I (vv. 7–23, 465–424 BC). Those later examples concern Jerusalem's walls and city, not the temple. The arrangement goes by theme, not by date: this is what the community faced, reign after reign.
Accusations at the start of a reign. In the Persian empire, provinces and local leaders dealt with the king by letter, usually in Aramaic, the empire's language of government (see v. 7). A new king was a moment of opportunity and danger. Old privileges might be confirmed or cancelled, and rivals tried to shape the new ruler's impressions early. Xerxes came to the throne in late 486 BC with Egypt in revolt. He put it down around 485–484 BC, and then faced revolts in Babylonia (around 484 and 482 BC). Judah lay on the main route to Egypt, so a charge that its people were disloyal would have been dangerous. Many scholars think the accusation was framed that way, but the text does not say what the letter contained.
Same king as Esther. Ahasuerus is the king of the book of Esther. Jewish readers would recognise a reign in which Jewish communities faced hostile intrigue at court.
From the study of Ezra 4:6.
Where scholars differ
in v6
Which king is 'Ahasuerus' here?
-
Xerxes I (486–465 BC). This is the majority view.
The Hebrew name corresponds to Old Persian Xšayāršā, Babylonian Aḫšiaršu and Aramaic ḥšyʾrš, all used for Xerxes. The list Cyrus → Darius (v. 5) → Ahasuerus (v. 6) → Artaxerxes (v. 7) follows the real Persian succession. And 4:24 explicitly returns to Darius, which shows that vv. 6–23 are a deliberate look ahead.
-
An earlier king, usually Cambyses (530–522 BC).
An older attempt to fit the story together, partly following Josephus, who moves the hostile correspondence into Cambyses' reign so that it all falls before the temple was finished in 515 BC. Few scholars hold it today, because the name does not fit Cambyses (Kambūjiya) and nothing in the text needs it.
in v6
Why does the narrator jump from Darius to Xerxes and Artaxerxes and then back?
-
A deliberate arrangement by theme.
Verse 5 already looks ahead ('down to the reign of Darius'), and 4:24 clearly resumes with 'until the second year of Darius'. Collecting later hostile letters together shows a pattern of opposition, and the narrator is open about the shift in subject from the temple to the city walls (vv. 12–16).
-
The compiler misunderstood the order of the Persian kings or the date of his sources.
Some critical scholars have argued that placing the Artaxerxes letter, which concerns the walls, inside a temple story suggests confusion. Most current commentators prefer the thematic explanation, because the narrator marks the return to Darius so carefully.
in v6
What prompted the accusation under Xerxes?
-
Charges of disloyalty at a time of imperial revolt.
Egypt was in revolt when Xerxes came to the throne, and Babylonia rose against him soon after. Judah lay on the road to Egypt. The later letter in vv. 12–16 accuses Jerusalem of a history of rebellion, which suggests what kind of charge was typical.
-
The content cannot be known.
The narrator neither quotes nor summarises the letter and records no result. Linking it to the revolts is a plausible guess, not something the text states.
in v7
Is 'Bishlam' a person's name or a phrase meaning 'with the agreement of'?
-
A personal name: three named leaders (Bishlam, Mithredath, Tabeel) and their colleagues wrote.
The Masoretic accents treat it as a separate item in the list. 1 Esdras 2:16 and the Vulgate read it as a name, and all major English versions follow. Hebrew often uses a singular verb before a compound subject.
-
A phrase, bi-šəlām, 'in peace / with the approval of': Mithredath wrote with the agreement of Tabeel and the others.
The Septuagint reads 'in peace'. The singular verb 'he wrote' and the singular 'his colleagues' fit one main author. šəlām is common in Aramaic letter formulas. Several commentators find this attractive, though some prefer to emend to 'concerning Jerusalem', which is more speculative.
in v7
What does 'written in Aramaic and translated Aramaic' mean?
-
Script and language: the document was in Aramaic script and the Aramaic language.
kəṯāḇ can mean 'script' (Esther 1:22; 8:9), and Persian decrees could differ in script and language. Followed by the NIV.
-
Written in Aramaic, then translated (into Persian or orally for the king).
The natural sense of the verb 'translated'. Persian practice of reading documents aloud before the king (Ezra 4:18). Followed in various forms by the BSB, ESV and NASB.
-
The second 'Aramaic' is a heading marking that the following text is in Aramaic.
The text does switch to Aramaic at 4:8. Daniel 2:4 uses the single word 'Aramaic' in the same way. This explains the redundancy without requiring a strange translation process. Widely held in critical commentaries (Williamson, Blenkinsopp).
in v7
Is the letter of v. 7 the same as the letter of Rehum and Shimshai in vv. 8–16?
-
Different letters: v. 7 notes a separate complaint whose content is not preserved, and v. 8 begins another.
Different senders are named, and v. 8 begins with its own introduction ('wrote a letter… as follows').
-
Closely related or the same campaign: v. 7 introduces the group, and vv. 8–11 give the formal letter heading.
The language note in v. 7 seems to introduce the Aramaic letter that follows. The 'colleagues' in v. 9 may overlap with v. 7's group, and 1 Esdras merges the two lists.
in v8
What exactly was a bəʿēl ṭəʿēm?
-
A senior provincial official in charge of reports and official correspondence: a 'chief of staff' or 'chancellor' type of post.
Ṭəʿēm regularly means 'report/account' and 'decree' in Biblical Aramaic (Ezra 5:5; 6:14; Dan 6:2). The Akkadian equivalent bēl ṭēmi is an administrative title in Babylonian texts. Rehum works alongside a secretary and writes formal reports.
-
A higher governing officer, roughly 'commander' or 'governor' of the region around Samaria.
Rehum heads a long list of officials and peoples (4:9–10), and the king addresses him first (4:17). After the reply, Rehum and his associates enforce the halt 'by force and power' (4:23).
in v8
Is the Rehum letter the same as the letter of Bishlam, Mithredath and Tabeel in 4:7?
-
Two distinct letters: 4:7 records one complaint (not quoted), and 4:8–16 quotes a second.
Different named authors. Verse 7 is in Hebrew and ends with a section break before the Aramaic of 4:8.
-
Closely connected, or part of the same campaign; some even read 'bishlam' as 'with the approval of' (Shelam) rather than as a name.
Both letters go to Artaxerxes and concern the same issue. The note in 4:7 about Aramaic leads straight into the Aramaic of 4:8. The Greek renders bishlam as 'in peace', showing early uncertainty about whether it is a name.
in v8
Are the Aramaic letters in Ezra 4–6 authentic Persian documents?
-
Substantially authentic archive documents, perhaps lightly edited.
Their Aramaic, address formulas and terminology (e.g. ʾiggərāh, bəʿēl ṭəʿēm, the officials' titles) match Persian-period papyri such as the Elephantine and Arsames letters.
-
Literary compositions or heavily reworked documents written in a Persian style.
Some spellings and phrases look later. The letters serve the narrative's themes neatly. The lists of peoples in 4:9–10 are unusual for genuine letters.
in v9
Are dînāyēʾ, ʾăpharsatkāyēʾ, ṭarpĕlāyēʾ and ʾăphārsāyēʾ ethnic groups or official titles?
-
Ethnic or place names, as the vowel marks indicate (Dinaites, Apharsathchites, Tarpelites, Apharsites).
They share the gentilic ending -āyēʾ with the undoubted city-names that follow (Erech, Babylon, Susa). This is how the Masoretes, the Greek versions, the Vulgate and the KJV tradition read them.
-
Mostly or entirely official titles (judges, envoys, officials, Persians or inspectors), followed by the communities descended from deportees.
dînāyēʾ fits the common Aramaic dîn, 'judgment', and no 'Dinaite' people is known. ʾăpharsatkāyēʾ and its relative ʾăpharsĕkāyēʾ (5:6; 6:6) look like Old Persian administrative terms. Opening with officials and then naming communities matches how Persian-era letters list senders. This is the majority view in modern lexicons and commentaries (e.g., HALOT, Williamson, Blenkinsopp), but the exact meaning of each title remains uncertain.
in v9
What does ṭarpĕlāyēʾ mean?
-
'Men of Tripolis', the Phoenician city.
The consonants resemble the Greek place-name, and a Phoenician coastal group would suit a coalition from 'Beyond the River'. This is BSB's choice. Against it: the city name is Greek, and its existence as early as the 5th century BC is debated.
-
An official title of uncertain origin ('officials').
It stands between two other probable titles, and no deportation from Tripolis is known. The supplied gloss follows this view. No proposed derivation has won general agreement.
in v9
Does ʾăphārsāyēʾ mean 'Persians', a title, or 'Sipparites'?
-
'Persians'
The simplest reading of the Masoretic text, followed by several modern versions.
-
An Old Persian title (e.g., 'inspectors' or 'secretaries')
Its similarity to ʾăpharsĕkāyēʾ (5:6; 6:6), and ethnic Persians are unlikely among people deported by Assyria. NASB follows a version of this.
-
'Sipparites', by emendation
It would match the Assyrian resettlement from Sepharvaim/Sippar (2 Kings 17:24). It has no support in manuscripts.
in v10
Who is 'Osnappar'?
-
Ashurbanipal, king of Assyria (668–c. 631 BC). This is the majority view.
The name can plausibly be traced to Aššur-bāni-apli. His campaigns against Babylon and Susa/Elam match the peoples listed in v. 9. Ancient versions support a form 'snpr.
-
Another Assyrian king (e.g. Esarhaddon, named in Ezra 4:2) or an Assyrian official acting for the king.
Esarhaddon is the king the opponents themselves cite in 4:2. Rab can be a title for an official. However, the sound correspondence is poor, and the pair of epithets reads like royal praise.
in v10
How should the closing u-khe'enet be understood?
-
The letter-formula 'and now', marking where the body of a quoted letter began.
There are close parallels in Elephantine and other Persian-period Aramaic letters, and in Ezra 4:11, 4:17 and 7:12.
-
An editorial 'etc.', meaning the narrator abbreviated the list of senders or the heading.
It stands awkwardly at the end of a list, and v. 11 restarts the address. These two views can be combined: the formula is left in as a marker where the narrator cut the text.
in v12
Which group of Judeans 'came up from you to us'?
-
The group that came with Ezra under Artaxerxes I (Ezra 7–8, traditionally dated 458 BCE).
'From you' implies the king himself sent or permitted them. Ezra's caravan came under an Artaxerxes decree, and renewed wall-building would fit the growing confidence after its arrival.
-
An unrecorded wave of returnees, or the returnee community in general.
The letter names no leader or decree. Officials may simply mean 'those exiles who came from your eastern territories', and the dating of Ezra's mission (458 vs. 398 BCE) is itself disputed.
in v12
Were the walls actually finished?
-
No. The officials exaggerate to provoke the king.
v. 13 and v. 16 speak conditionally ('if… the walls are completed'). The king's order to stop the work (vv. 21–23) presupposes it was unfinished.
-
The completed form means substantial progress or 'set about completing', not literal completion.
Aramaic completed forms can describe an action seen as decisively under way. The ongoing verbs on either side ('building', 'repairing') show the work was still continuing.
in v12
Is the letter an authentic Persian-period document?
-
Substantially authentic, abridged by the narrator.
Matching formulas in the Elephantine and Arshama letters, Akkadian loanwords typical of imperial Aramaic, and realistic administrative procedure (archive search, official titles).
-
Largely a literary composition in documentary style.
Some spellings and grammatical features look later than the 5th century BCE. The letters serve the book's theological storyline closely.
in v13
Does אַפְּתֹם (appetom) mean 'revenue/treasury' or 'in the end/finally'?
-
A noun, 'revenue' or 'treasury', so 'the revenue of kings you/it will damage'.
It fits the financial argument of the verse, and 'appetom malkin' reads naturally as 'X of kings'. It is the reading of BDB, Strong's, KJV, and the NIV/ESV/NASB/BSB family.
-
An adverb, from Old Persian *apatama 'last, furthest', so 'in the end' (or 'surely'), with 'kings' as the object: 'it will finally harm kings'.
There is a plausible Persian origin, and v. 15 uses parallel wording ('hurtful to kings') with no word for revenue. Many Aramaic grammars and HALOT favour or allow it. It is followed by YLT and WEB, and the Vulgate's rendering is compatible with it.
in v13
What exactly are the three taxes (mindah, belo, halakh)?
-
They are Akkadian-derived technical terms: mindah = mandattu (regular tribute), belo = biltu (tax or rent in produce), halakh = ilku (land-service due, paid in silver).
The words line up in sound and use with Babylonian and Persian tax documents, especially the Murašû archive from Artaxerxes' time. This is the majority view in modern lexicons and commentaries.
-
The terms can't be precisely separated. They act as a set phrase meaning 'all royal taxes', and halakh may still be a travel or road toll.
The words appear only in this fixed triplet (Ezra 4:13, 20; 7:24), so we have no other context to define them one by one. The link between belo and biltu has sound-change problems. Traditional Jewish interpretation derived halakh from 'to go'.
in v15
Are the Aramaic letters in Ezra 4 copies of genuine Persian-period documents, or literary compositions?
-
Substantially authentic documents (or close copies) drawn from archives.
The letter formulas, titles, official vocabulary and Persian loanwords closely match fifth-century BC Aramaic correspondence from Elephantine and elsewhere. The letter's emphasis on revenue fits known Persian concerns (argued by e.g. Williamson, Fensham, Porten).
-
Literary compositions or edited versions shaped by the author of Ezra.
The letters fit the book's themes neatly, include features some date later, and are arranged out of chronological order for rhetorical effect (argued in varying degrees by e.g. Grabbe and others). Even so, many on this side accept that a documentary core lies behind them.
in v15
Who is the subject of "let [him/one] search" (yəvaqqar)?
-
Impersonal: "let a search be made".
The third-person form without a stated subject is a common Aramaic way of expressing a passive. Most modern translations (BSB, NASB, NIV) take it this way, and v. 19 reports that "search was made" by the court.
-
Courtly third-person address to the king: "that he [the king] may search".
Petitions often address the monarch in the third person. YLT renders "he doth seek". The verse then shifts to direct "you will find … you will know", which fits either reading.
in v16
Is the Rehum–Shimshai letter an authentic Persian-period document?
-
Substantially authentic, possibly abridged or excerpted from an archive.
Its formulas ("let it be known to the king," "and now"), titles such as *bəʿēl ṭəʿēm*, Akkadian loanwords like *šaklel*, and its bureaucratic style match imperial Aramaic letters from Elephantine and the Arshama correspondence. This is the view of commentators such as H. G. M. Williamson and, with nuances, Joseph Blenkinsopp.
-
A literary composition, or heavily reworked by the author of Ezra–Nehemiah.
The letters fit the book's theme of opposition very neatly. Some features of spelling and language may be later than the 5th century. Some scholars (e.g. Dirk Schwiderski, in studies of Aramaic letter formulas) argue that the formulas match Hellenistic-period letters better and question the case for authenticity.
in v16
When and why was the wall-building halted?
-
Under Artaxerxes I in the 450s–440s BCE, against the background of the Egyptian (Inaros) revolt and possibly the Megabyzus affair.
A king worried about the route to Egypt would react sharply to a fortified Jerusalem. Nehemiah 1:3 (c. 445) reports broken walls and burned gates, which may reflect the forced stop in 4:23.
-
The halted project is linked to Ezra's own mission (458 BCE, if Artaxerxes I) or is left undated by the text.
Ezra 4:12 speaks of Jews who "came up from you to us," which may point to a recent group of returnees. But the chapter's themed arrangement makes exact dating uncertain.
in v17
What office did Rehum hold as bəʿēl-ṭəʿēm?
-
A senior administrator responsible for official reports and orders: commissioner, chancellor, or chief of correspondence.
The parallel Akkadian title bēl ṭēmi is an administrative office. ṭəʿēm often means 'report' in Ezra (5:5) and Daniel (6:2). 1 Esdras 2:16 describes Rehum as the one 'who writes what happens.' His role in vv. 8–16 is to send a report to the king.
-
A governing or commanding officer with executive authority in the province.
ṭəʿēm also means 'decree, command' (Ezra 4:19, 21). Rehum is named first and acts with authority, stopping the work by force (v. 23). Many modern versions translate 'commander' or 'commanding officer.'
in v17
Are the Aramaic letters of Ezra 4 authentic archival documents?
-
Substantially authentic copies of Persian-period letters, perhaps lightly edited.
Persian loanwords (pitgām), Babylonian-Persian titles, the colleagues formula, and the greeting and 'and now' formulas match 5th-century papyri closely. Details such as translating and reading the letter aloud (v. 18) and searching the archives (v. 19) fit known practice.
-
Reworked or literary compositions modelled on chancery style.
The letters serve the book's theology closely. Some forms of address show signs of later editing, such as the overloaded list of senders in vv. 9–10 and the shift between 'their' and 'your.' The episode is placed out of chronological order for thematic effect.
in v19
Is Artaxerxes' letter (4:17–22) a genuine Persian-period document or a later literary composition?
-
Substantially authentic Achaemenid correspondence, preserved and perhaps lightly edited.
Its office terms (śîm ṭəʿēm, bəʿēl-ṭəʿēm), its letter structure and its Imperial Aramaic features match fifth-century papyri from Elephantine and the Arsames letters. Its content (archive search, worry about tribute) fits the revolts early in Artaxerxes' reign. Argued by e.g. Williamson and Fried.
-
Composed or heavily reworked later, possibly in the Hellenistic era, to resemble official letters.
Some spelling and formal features (greetings, word forms) look later than fifth-century originals, and the letters serve the book's theological arrangement neatly. Argued by e.g. Grabbe and Schwiderski.
in v19
Which revolts would the royal archives have recorded?
-
The Assyrian and Babylonian-era revolts of Judah's last kings.
Hezekiah against Sennacherib (2 Kgs 18:7; Sennacherib's annals), and Jehoiakim and Zedekiah against Nebuchadnezzar (2 Kgs 24:1, 20; the Babylonian Chronicle). Persian kings inherited and drew on Babylonian records.
-
A general, partly rhetorical claim, perhaps also echoing more recent unrest.
"Kings" has no article and "from time immemorial" is sweeping, which suits an exaggerated official finding. Some suggest the instability of Artaxerxes' own reign (Inaros, Megabyzus) coloured how the records were read, though no Judean involvement is documented.
in v20
Who are the "mighty kings" who ruled over all Beyond-the-River?
-
David and Solomon (and the idealised united monarchy).
1 Kgs 5:1, 4 (Eng. 4:21, 24) describes Solomon ruling "over all Beyond-the-River" with near-identical wording and receiving tribute from the kingdoms. 2 Sam 8 records David's conquests in Syria and the tribute he took. This is the majority view in commentaries (e.g. Williamson, Fensham).
-
A rhetorical overstatement built on archive records of later Judean kings.
Assyrian and Babylonian records would mainly document rebellions by Hezekiah, Jehoiakim and Zedekiah (fitting v. 19), not a Davidic empire. Some interpreters therefore read v. 20 as exaggeration meant to justify the halt order, or as shaped by Jewish tradition about Solomon rather than drawn from Persian files.
-
Foreign kings who ruled over Jerusalem (Assyrians, Babylonians).
"Kings were over Jerusalem" could in principle mean overlords of the city. But the sentence's purpose (showing that Jerusalem is dangerous) and the parallel with v. 19 make this unlikely, and few scholars hold it.
in v20
Are the letters in Ezra 4 authentic Persian documents or literary compositions?
-
Substantially authentic chancery documents, possibly abridged.
Their Imperial Aramaic vocabulary, the Akkadian tax loanwords, address formulas and archive-search motif match 5th-century documents (Elephantine papyri, Arshama letters, the Murashu archive). Held by e.g. Williamson, Fensham, and Porten's comparative work.
-
Edited or composed by the Jewish narrator using authentic forms.
The letters serve the book's themes neatly: the echo of Solomon, and the reversal in 7:24. Some scholars (e.g. Grabbe) argue that the narrator shaped or wrote them, while granting that the author knew Persian administrative style well.
in v20
How do the three tax terms differ?
-
Distinct imperial categories: general tribute (*mandattu*), a levy in kind (*biltu*), and a land-tied service duty (*ilku*).
The Akkadian origins and the documented use of *ilku* in Achaemenid Babylonia (the Murashu archive). This is the position of HALOT and most modern commentaries.
-
A conventional set phrase meaning "all forms of tax," with no precise distinctions intended.
The three always appear together (4:13, 20; 7:24). Ancient translators (the Septuagint, Vulgate, 1 Esdras) did not carefully distinguish them.
in v21
Is the Artaxerxes correspondence an authentic Persian document?
-
Substantially authentic, adapted from archival copies.
The letter uses Imperial Aramaic forms, Persian loanwords, chancery formulas ('set a decree', bĕʿēl ṭĕʿēm) and an archive search, and its structure matches Elephantine and other Achaemenid letters (Williamson, Fensham, Porten).
-
Edited or composed by the author of Ezra in imitation of chancery style.
The letters suit the book's themes very well, the spelling has been modernized in places, and later writers could imitate official style (some arguments in Grabbe and Blenkinsopp).
in v21
Why does a ban on the walls under Artaxerxes sit in a chapter about the temple under Darius?
-
Arranged by theme: vv. 6–23 are a deliberate flash-forward listing later opposition, and v. 24 resumes the earlier story.
Kings are named out of chronological order (Xerxes and Artaxerxes before Darius in 4:24–5:1), and the repeated verb 'cease' (vv. 21, 23, 24) acts as a hinge. This is the majority view (Williamson, Blenkinsopp).
-
The editor confused or merged the episodes and thought they stopped the temple work.
Verse 24 says 'then the work on the house of God ceased', which can be read as the result of vv. 21–23. Some older critics took this as a historical mistake.
in v21
Is this verse the background to Nehemiah 1:3 and 2:1–8?
-
Yes. The forced stoppage (v. 23) explains the broken walls reported to Nehemiah, and Artaxerxes' later permission is the 'decree from me' this verse anticipates.
Same king, same project (walls), and the timing works (the late 450s or 440s BCE before Nehemiah's mission in 445 BCE).
-
Possibly, but the link cannot be proven.
Neither text cites the other, and the walls had lain in ruins since 586 BCE, so Nehemiah 1:3 could describe long-standing devastation.
in v23
Is the 'forcible stop' of 4:23 the destruction reported in Nehemiah 1:3 (walls broken down, gates burned)?
-
Yes, or probably: the armed halt under Artaxerxes involved tearing down the newly rebuilt walls, and this is the fresh news that shattered Nehemiah around 445 BC.
Nehemiah's grief (fasting, weeping for days) suits recent news, not a disaster 140 years old. The same king, Artaxerxes, is involved in both. His order in Ezra 4:21 explicitly expects a later decree, which Nehemiah 2 supplies. 'With arm and force' implies troops able to demolish. Held by many commentators (e.g. Williamson, Blenkinsopp, Fensham).
-
Not necessarily: Nehemiah 1:3 may describe the long-standing ruin from the Babylonian destruction of 587 BC.
Ezra 4:23 says only that the work was stopped, not that walls were demolished. The burning of gates matches 2 Kings 25:9–10. Nehemiah's question may be about the community's general condition.
in v23
How does 4:23 relate to 4:24 ('Thus the work on the house of God… ceased')?
-
4:6–23 is a thematic digression about later opposition to the walls. 4:24 is a 'resumptive' verse that returns to the temple story left off at 4:5, so the halt in 4:23 is not the cause of the temple stoppage.
The letters concern the city and walls (4:12–16), not the temple. Artaxerxes reigned after Darius I. 4:24 repeats the chronology of 4:5 ('until the reign of Darius'). The temple was completed in 515 BC (6:15), decades before Artaxerxes. This is the majority view among modern scholars.
-
4:24 follows directly from 4:23: the stoppage in 4:23 is the temple stoppage, either because 'Artaxerxes' refers to an earlier king or because the editor (or a source) understood the events that way.
The Aramaic 'then' (bēʾdayin) and the repeated verb 'ceased' tie 4:23 and 4:24 together on the surface. 1 Esdras 2 and Josephus both read the episode as a halt to temple work before Darius. Some older interpreters identified this Artaxerxes with Cambyses or Smerdis (Bardiya). Few now hold this, since there is no evidence that those kings bore the name Artaxerxes.
in v24
Does verse 24 follow on from Artaxerxes' order in 4:23, or does it return to the story of 4:1–5?
-
It picks the story back up (majority view): verses 6–23 are a side-section arranged by theme, about later opposition, and verse 24 returns to the temple story halted 'until the reign of Darius' (4:5).
The matching phrases 'until the reign of Darius king of Persia' in 4:5 and 4:24 frame the section. Verses 12–16 concern the walls and city, not the temple. Artaxerxes I (465–424 BC) reigned after the temple's completion in 515 BC (6:15).
-
It follows straight on, with the 'Artaxerxes' of 4:7–23 identified as an earlier king (Cambyses or the usurper Bardiya/Gaumata) who reigned before Darius I.
Josephus puts the letter under Cambyses, and 1 Esdras places the episode before Darius. 'Then' most naturally reads as sequence. But no Persian king before Darius I is known to have carried the name Artaxerxes, and most scholars reject this identification.
-
It follows straight on because the compiler arranged his sources in the wrong order or misread them.
Some critical scholars hold this view, but it has to assume the editor missed the bracketing 'until Darius' phrases, which look deliberate.
in v24
Did work stop completely for about sixteen years, or was it intermittent?
-
It was a real, near-total halt from about 536 to 520 BC.
The emphatic 'it was standing stopped' here. Haggai 1:2–4 has the people saying 'the time has not yet come', and Haggai 2:18 speaks of the foundation day in 520 as a new beginning.
-
Some small-scale or intermittent activity continued, and the narrative telescopes events.
In 5:16 the elders tell Tattenai that 'from then [Sheshbazzar's foundation] until now it has been under construction and is not finished.' This may be diplomatic phrasing, or it may reflect sporadic work.
Sources
- BDB s.v. שִׂטְנָה, שָׂטַן
- HALOT s.v. שִׂטְנָה
- HALOT s.v. אֲחַשְׁוֵרוֹשׁ
- HALOT s.v. מַלְכוּת
- H.G.M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary 16) on Ezra 4:6–24
- J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra–Nehemiah (OTL), on Ezra 4
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Ezra 4
- Josephus, Antiquities 11.21–30
- 1 Esdras 2:16–30
- Septuagint, 2 Esdras 4:6 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate, Ezra 4:6
- P. Briant, From Cyrus to Alexander: A History of the Persian Empire (on Xerxes' accession and revolts)
- HALOT s.v. אֲרָמִית, כְּנָת, נִשְׁתְּוָן, תִּרְגֵּם, בִּשְׁלָם
- BDB s.v. אֲרָמִית, תִּרְגֵּם, נִשְׁתְּוָן
- H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary 16, 1985), on Ezra 4:6–24
- J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra–Nehemiah (Old Testament Library, 1988), on Ezra 4:7
- F. C. Fensham, The Books of Ezra and Nehemiah (NICOT, 1982)
- B. Porten & A. Yardeni, Textbook of Aramaic Documents from Ancient Egypt (TAD), esp. A4.7
- Septuagint, 2 Esdras 4:7 (Rahlfs); 1 Esdras 2:16
- Vulgate, Ezra 4:7
- Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, Masoretic notes at Ezra 4:7
- BDB (Aramaic section) s.v. טְעֵם, בְּעֵל, סָפַר, אִגְּרָא
- HALOT (Biblical Aramaic) s.v. טְעֵם, בְּעֵל טְעֵם
- H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary 16)
- J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra–Nehemiah (Old Testament Library)
- F. C. Fensham, The Books of Ezra and Nehemiah (NICOT)
- B. Porten & A. Yardeni, Textbook of Aramaic Documents from Ancient Egypt
- G. R. Driver, Aramaic Documents of the Fifth Century B.C. (Arsames correspondence)
- 1 Esdras 2:16–30 (Greek parallel)
- Vulgate, Ezra 4:8
- HALOT (Koehler–Baumgartner), Aramaic section, s.v. בְּעֵל, טְעֵם, כְּנָת, דִּינַי, אֲפַרְסַתְכָי, טַרְפְּלָי, אֲפָרְסָי, דְּהוּא
- BDB, Biblical Aramaic section, s.v. טְעֵם and כְּנָת
- H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary 16, 1985), on Ezra 4:7–11
- J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra–Nehemiah (Old Testament Library, 1988), on Ezra 4:8–10
- L. S. Fried, Ezra: A Commentary (2015), on the Aramaic correspondence and Persian titles
- B. Porten & A. Yardeni, Textbook of Aramaic Documents from Ancient Egypt (TAD A4.7 = Cowley 30, 'Jedaniah and his colleagues')
- F. Rosenthal, A Grammar of Biblical Aramaic, on Persian loanwords
- 1 Esdras 2:16 (Greek) and Septuagint 2 Esdras 4:9, for early reception
- 2 Kings 17:24; Ezra 4:2, 10 (resettlement of Samaria)
- BDB (Aramaic section) s.v. גְּלָה, יְתִב, כְּעֶנֶת, עֲבַר
- HALOT (Biblical Aramaic) s.v. אָסְנַפַּר, יַקִּיר, קִרְיָה
- H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary)
- J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra-Nehemiah (Old Testament Library)
- J. A. Fitzmyer, 'Some Notes on Aramaic Epistolography', JBL 93 (1974)
- B. Porten & A. Yardeni, Textbook of Aramaic Documents from Ancient Egypt, A4.7 (Elephantine petition naming the governor of Samaria)
- Septuagint 2 Esdras 4:10; Vulgate Ezra 4:10; 1 Esdras 2:16
- 2 Kings 17:24; Ezra 4:2; 5:12
- BDB, Aramaic section, s.v. מָרָד, בְּאִישׁ, כְּלַל (šaphel), אֹשׁ, חוּט
- HALOT (Aramaic), s.v. מָרָד, בִּאישׁ, כלל, אֻשׁ, חיט
- F. Rosenthal, A Grammar of Biblical Aramaic (l-prefixed forms of הוה; šaphel; Akkadian loanwords)
- B. Porten & A. Yardeni, Textbook of Aramaic Documents from Ancient Egypt (TAD), letter formulas
- L. L. Grabbe, Ezra-Nehemiah (Old Testament Readings)
- S. Mason, 'Jews, Judaeans, Judaizing, Judaism', Journal for the Study of Judaism 38 (2007)
- Septuagint 2 Esdras 4:12; 1 Esdras 2:17–18
- HALOT (Koehler–Baumgartner), Aramaic section, s.v. אַפְּתֹם, בְּלוֹ, הֲלָךְ, מִנְדָּה, נזק
- BDB, Aramaic section, s.v. אַפְּתֹם, בְּלוֹ, הֲלָךְ, מִנְדָּה
- F. Rosenthal, A Grammar of Biblical Aramaic (Persian and Akkadian loanwords)
- Chicago Assyrian Dictionary (CAD) s.v. ilku, mandattu, biltu
- Herodotus, Histories 3.89–97 (Persian tribute districts)
- M. W. Stolper, Entrepreneurs and Empire: The Murašû Archive (ilku payments under Artaxerxes I)
- B. Porten & A. Yardeni, Textbook of Aramaic Documents from Ancient Egypt (Imperial Aramaic letter formulas)
- Septuagint 2 Esdras 4:13; 1 Esdras 2:18; Vulgate Ezra 4:13
- BDB (Aramaic section) s.v. בְּקַר, דָּכְרָן, מְרָד/מָרָד, נְזַק, אֶשְׁתַּדּוּר, חֲרַב
- HALOT (Biblical Aramaic) s.v. אֶשְׁתַּדּוּר, נזק, דִּכְרוֹן/דָּכְרָן
- F. Rosenthal, A Grammar of Biblical Aramaic
- A. K. Grayson, Assyrian and Babylonian Chronicles (ABC 5)
- B. Porten, The Elephantine Papyri in English
- Josephus, Antiquities 11.2.1 (§§21–30)
- HALOT (Aramaic section) s.v. חֲלָק, כְּלַל, עֲבַר, אִיתַי, הֵן, דֵּךְ
- BDB (Aramaic) s.v. ידע (Haphel), קֳבֵל
- Porten & Yardeni, Textbook of Aramaic Documents from Ancient Egypt (Elephantine letter formulas)
- 1 Esdras 2:16–30 (LXX) parallel account
- HALOT (Aramaic section) s.v. פִּתְגָם, בְּעֵל, טְעֵם, כְּנָת, כְּעֶנֶת
- BDB (Biblical Aramaic) s.v. טְעֵם, שְׁלָם
- F. Rosenthal, A Grammar of Biblical Aramaic (epistolary formulas)
- B. Porten & A. Yardeni, Textbook of Aramaic Documents from Ancient Egypt (Elephantine letters, e.g. TAD A4.7)
- 1 Esdras 2:16–30 (Septuagint)
- BDB (Brown-Driver-Briggs), Aramaic section, s.v. טְעֵם, בְּקַר, מְרַד, אֶשְׁתַּדּוּר, עָלַם
- HALOT, Aramaic section, s.v. טְעֵם, אֶשְׁתַּדּוּר
- H.G.M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary)
- L.S. Fried, Ezra: A Commentary
- B. Porten & A. Yardeni, Textbook of Aramaic Documents from Ancient Egypt (Elephantine)
- G.R. Driver, Aramaic Documents of the Fifth Century B.C. (Arsames letters)
- A.K. Grayson, Assyrian and Babylonian Chronicles (Chronicle 5)
- E. Jenni, 'ʿôlām', Theological Lexicon of the Old Testament
- L.L. Grabbe, 'The Authenticity of the Persian "Documents" in Ezra'
- D. Schwiderski, Handbuch des nordwestsemitischen Briefformulars
- Septuagint (2 Esdras 4:19); 1 Esdras 2:16–30; Vulgate Ezra 4:19
- HALOT (Aramaic section) s.v. מִנְדָּה, בְּלוֹ, הֲלָךְ, שַׁלִּיט, תַּקִּיף, עֲבַר
- BDB (Biblical Aramaic section) s.v. מִנְדָּה, בְּלוֹ, הֲלָךְ
- Chicago Assyrian Dictionary (CAD) s.v. mandattu, biltu, ilku
- L. L. Grabbe, Ezra–Nehemiah (Old Testament Readings)
- M. W. Stolper, Entrepreneurs and Empire: The Murašû Archive
- 1 Kings 5:1–4 (Eng. 4:21–24); 1 Esdras 2; Septuagint 2 Esdras 4
- BDB (Aramaic section) s.v. טְעֵם, בְּטֵל, שׂוּם
- HALOT (Biblical Aramaic) s.v. טְעֵם, בטל
- Septuagint 2 Esdras 4; 1 Esdras 2:16–30
- HALOT (Aramaic section) s.v. אֶדְרַע, בְּטֵל, נִשְׁתְּוָן, פַּרְשֶׁגֶן
- BDB (Biblical Aramaic section) s.v. בְּטֵל, חַיִל, בְּהִילוּ
- F. Rosenthal, A Grammar of Biblical Aramaic (Persian loanwords; independent pronoun as object)
- B. Porten & A. Yardeni, Textbook of Aramaic Documents from Ancient Egypt (Elephantine 'Judeans', administrative vocabulary)
- Josephus, Antiquities 11.2.1–2
- 1 Esdras 2:16–30 (LXX)
- BDB / HALOT (Aramaic section) s.v. בְּטֵל, עֲבִידָה, אֱדַיִן, מַלְכוּ
- H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra–Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary), on Ezra 4:6–24
- J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra–Nehemiah (OTL)
- Haggai 1:1–15; 2:18; Zechariah 1:1 (dating of Darius's second year)
- 1 Esdras 2:16–30 (parallel account)
- Behistun Inscription of Darius I
- Elephantine papyri (TAD A4.7, petition concerning the temple of YHW)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
4 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.