Jeremiah Chapter 23 Read as one passage
Jeremiah 23:16–40
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
16This is what the LORD of Hosts says: “Do not listen to the words of the prophets who prophesy to you. They are filling you with false hopes. They speak visions from their own minds, not from the mouth of the LORD. 17They keep saying to those who despise Me, ‘The LORD says that you will have peace,’ and to everyone who walks in the stubbornness of his own heart, ‘No harm will come to you.’ 18But which of them has stood in the council of the LORD to see and hear His word? Who has given heed to His word and obeyed it? 19Behold, the storm of the LORD has gone out with fury, a whirlwind swirling down upon the heads of the wicked. 20The anger of the LORD will not turn back until He has fully accomplished the purposes of His heart. In the days to come you will understand this clearly. 21I did not send these prophets, yet they have run with their message; I did not speak to them, yet they have prophesied. 22But if they had stood in My council, they would have proclaimed My words to My people and turned them back from their evil ways and deeds.” 23“Am I only a God nearby,” declares the LORD, “and not a God far away?” 24“Can a man hide in secret places where I cannot see him?” declares the LORD. “Do I not fill the heavens and the earth?” declares the LORD. 25“I have heard the sayings of the prophets who prophesy lies in My name: ‘I had a dream! I had a dream!’ 26How long will this continue in the hearts of these prophets who prophesy falsehood, these prophets of the delusion of their own minds? 27They suppose the dreams that they tell one another will make My people forget My name, just as their fathers forgot My name through the worship of Baal. 28Let the prophet who has a dream retell it, but let him who has My word speak it truthfully. For what is straw compared to grain?” declares the LORD. 29“Is not My word like fire,” declares the LORD, “and like a hammer that smashes a rock?” 30“Therefore behold,” declares the LORD, “I am against the prophets who steal from one another words they attribute to Me.” 31“Yes,” declares the LORD, “I am against the prophets who wag their own tongues and proclaim, ‘The LORD declares it.’” 32“Indeed,” declares the LORD, “I am against those who prophesy false dreams and retell them to lead My people astray with their reckless lies. It was not I who sent them or commanded them, and they are of no benefit at all to these people,” declares the LORD. 33“Now when this people or a prophet or priest asks you, ‘What is the burden of the LORD?’ you are to say to them, ‘What burden? I will forsake you, declares the LORD.’ 34As for the prophet or priest or anyone who claims, ‘This is the burden of the LORD,’ I will punish that man and his household. 35This is what each man is to say to his friend and to his brother: ‘What has the LORD answered?’ or ‘What has the LORD spoken?’ 36But refer no more to the burden of the LORD, for each man’s word becomes the burden, so that you pervert the words of the living God, the LORD of Hosts, our God. 37Thus you are to say to the prophet: ‘What has the LORD answered you?’ and ‘What has the LORD spoken?’ 38But if you claim, ‘This is the burden of the LORD,’ then this is what the LORD says: Because you have said, ‘This is the burden of the LORD,’ and I specifically told you not to make this claim, 39therefore I will surely forget you and will cast you out of My presence, both you and the city that I gave to you and your fathers. 40And I will bring upon you everlasting shame and perpetual humiliation that will never be forgotten.”
What the first hearers heard
For people in Jerusalem in Jeremiah's day, this was a disturbing instruction: stop listening to your own prophets. These men spoke in the temple, used the same "thus says the LORD" formula, and drew on respected beliefs about Zion and David. Jeremiah was a lone voice, often treated as a traitor (Jer 26; 37–38).
The verse gave them a way to tell the two kinds of message apart. It did not depend on how confident or pious a prophet sounded. It depended on source: did the word come from the LORD's mouth, or from the speaker's own mind? The surrounding verses add content: a message promising peace to people who ignore the covenant (v. 17) shows its origin, because it tells a stubborn heart exactly what it wants to hear. The chapter also says the true word acts on people. It is "like fire" and "like a hammer that shatters rock" (v. 29), and it turns people from evil ways (v. 22). Reassuring talk that leaves people unchanged is mere breath.
The hevel wordplay also implied that clinging to these promises was a kind of idolatry. It meant trusting a breath, and that would leave the nation as empty as what it trusted. Judah's fall in 587 seemed, to those who kept Jeremiah's words, to confirm which word had come from the LORD's mouth.
From the study of Jeremiah 23:16.
Verse by verse
-
16This is what the LORD of Hosts says: “Do not listen to the words of the prophets who prophesy to you. They are filling you with false hopes. They speak visions from their own minds, not from the mouth of the LORD.
Full study →Thus says the LORD, commander of heaven's armies: "Don't listen to the words of the prophets, the ones who keep on prophesying to you. They are pumping you full of breath. They are making you as empty as the vapour you're hoping in. What they call a revelation came out of their own minds. It did not come out of the LORD's mouth."
The verse is a formal message from the divine king. It opens with the same "thus says" formula the other prophets also used, and then turns that formula against them. Its targets are not fringe cranks. They are the recognised prophets of Jerusalem, who keep producing messages (the Hebrew stresses that this is constant, ongoing activity). Their effect is put in a word built on hevel, "breath, vapour", the word Ecclesiastes uses for life's "vanity" and the prophets use for idols. They are not only telling falsehoods. They are making their hearers hevel: as insubstantial as the hopes they are given, just as Israel once "went after emptiness and became empty" (Jer 2:5).
The last line names the two possible sources of a prophetic word. One is "their heart", meaning in Hebrew the mind, imagination and will, not mainly the emotions. The other is "the mouth of the LORD". Their message has the outward form of a vision, but it starts inside the speaker. A true prophet repeats what came from God's mouth. These prophets repeat what came from their own heads, and v. 17 shows what that was: "You will have peace… no harm will come to you," spoken to people who walk in the stubbornness of their own hearts.
-
17They keep saying to those who despise Me, ‘The LORD says that you will have peace,’ and to everyone who walks in the stubbornness of his own heart, ‘No harm will come to you.’
Full study →The prophets keep saying it, over and over, like a slogan. They say it to people who treat YHWH with open contempt, and they stamp it with God's own authority: "YHWH has spoken: all will be well with you." Here "well" (shalom) means safety and prosperity for the nation. No enemy army will take the city, and life will go on as normal. To every person who lives by their own hardened will, refusing God's way, they have pronounced: "No disaster will come upon you." "Disaster" here means the catastrophe of judgment: sword, famine, siege and exile.
The verse is built as a matched pair: shalom in the first half, its opposite ra'ah (calamity) in the second. Each half is aimed at people who, by the covenant's own terms, should expect the curse. The wording deliberately echoes Deuteronomy 29:19, where the rebel tells himself, "I will have shalom, though I walk in the stubbornness of my heart." Deuteronomy says that God will not forgive such a person and that every curse will settle on him. Jeremiah's point is that the prophets have taken the self-deceiving words of Deuteronomy's rebel and turned them into an official oracle from God.
-
18But which of them has stood in the council of the LORD to see and hear His word? Who has given heed to His word and obeyed it?
Full study →"After all, which of them has ever stood among the attendants in YHWH's inner council, the assembly around his throne where his decisions are made, and actually seen and heard the word decided there? Which of them has ever strained to catch his word and really heard it?"
The questions expect the answer none of them. In verse 17 the prophets assure people who scorn God, "YHWH has said: you will have peace." Jeremiah's reply is a matter of credentials. A real prophet is like a royal herald who has stood in the king's council chamber, watched the deliberation, and been sent out with the decree. These men were never in the room. Their "peace" is a vision of their own hearts (v. 16). The word that really goes out from the council is the one announced in the next breath: a storm of YHWH's fury bursting on the heads of the wicked (v. 19).
The Hebrew word for "council" (sod) also means "secret" or "confidential counsel". To stand in YHWH's sod is to be in on his private decisions, as Amos says: "YHWH does nothing without revealing his sod to his servants the prophets" (Amos 3:7).
-
19Behold, the storm of the LORD has gone out with fury, a whirlwind swirling down upon the heads of the wicked.
Full study →Look! Yahweh's own storm, his burning rage, has already been let loose. A tempest twisting and spinning in on itself, and it will come whirling down, right onto the heads of those who are in the wrong.
The verse is built as a picture of the God of the storm coming out to battle. "Storm" and "rage" stand side by side as two names for one thing: the storm is Yahweh's anger in visible form. "Has gone out" is stated as done. The storm has left his presence and is on its way, even though it has not yet struck. The second line repeats the storm word ("yes, a tempest!") and uses the same verb twice, "whirling... it will whirl down," so the sound of the line imitates its motion. That verb can also mean writhing in pain, so the twisting of the wind and the agony it brings are heard together.
The target matters. "Upon the head of the guilty" answers, word for word, what the prophets of peace had been telling Jerusalem in verse 17: "No harm will come upon you." Jeremiah's reply is that harm is coming upon them, onto their own heads. The "guilty" are not distant pagans. They are the religious insiders who promised safety, and the people who wanted to hear it. The next verse completes the thought: this anger will not turn back until it has done everything God intends, and only afterward will they understand.
-
20The anger of the LORD will not turn back until He has fully accomplished the purposes of His heart. In the days to come you will understand this clearly.
Full study →The LORD's anger, pictured in the previous verse as a storm already sent out, will not turn around and come home with its work unfinished. It will keep going until God has done what he decided to do, until he has made his plans stand, the way he makes a promise stand. Those plans are the settled purposes of his heart: not passing moods or feelings, but what he has deliberately made up his mind to do (in Hebrew the "heart" is mainly the seat of thinking and will). Then the tone changes from warning to prediction: later on, once all this has happened, you (the whole people, and the prophets who promised you peace) will look back into it and understand it fully and clearly. The repeated wording ("understand it with understanding") stresses that the insight will be complete and undeniable. It will also be insight gained only by looking back, after events have shown whose word was true. "The latter days" here means "the days after this," the time after the judgment has fallen, not the end of the world.
-
21I did not send these prophets, yet they have run with their message; I did not speak to them, yet they have prophesied.
Full study →"I never commissioned those prophets as my envoys, and yet off they ran, like royal couriers racing out with a dispatch. I never spoke a word to them, and yet they stood up and delivered oracles in my name."
The line is built as two matched halves, and each half sets God's denial against the prophets' own action. God's side: he did not send them (no commission, no authority) and did not speak to them (no message, no content). Their side: they ran (they took the messenger's role with energy and urgency) and they prophesied (they performed the full public act of speaking for God). The repeated emphatic "they" ("but they ran… but they prophesied") marks the whole operation as their own initiative.
The picture comes from the royal court. A king's runners carried his letters through the realm, and a messenger's words counted only because he had been sent and handed the message. These prophets are couriers who never stood before the king (v. 18, 22, "stood in my council") and never received a dispatch, yet they are on the road shouting "Thus says the king!" Their haste and confidence prove nothing. What they "prophesied" was not chiefly prediction. It was the reassuring message of v. 17, "You will have peace," given to a people God was calling to turn from evil (v. 22).
-
22But if they had stood in My council, they would have proclaimed My words to My people and turned them back from their evil ways and deeds.”
Full study →"But if they really had stood among my attendants in my private council, the inner court where I make my decisions known, they would have made my people hear my words, not their own dreams. And those words would have turned my people around and led them off the evil road they keep walking, away from the corrupt practices that make up their lives."
The verse is a counterfactual: it describes what would have happened. Verse 21 has just said God never sent these prophets, so verse 22 is an accusation dressed as a hypothesis. It also sets out the test by which they fail. Two things mark a true prophet. The first is about where they have been: they have stood in God's council the way a royal servant stands before the throne, and so have heard the king's actual decision. The second is about what their words produce: they turn people back. The verse uses the causative forms of two verbs, so the prophet makes the people hear and makes them turn. Hearing in God's council should lead to repentance among God's people.
The last phrase is deliberately heavy: "from their evil way, and from the evil of their deeds." Hebrew repeats the same root, evil way and evil of their doings. It echoes Jeremiah's earlier sermons ("amend your ways and your deeds," 7:3). It also contrasts with the false prophets, who "strengthen the hands of evildoers so that no one turns from his evil" (23:14) and tell people "no disaster will come upon you" (23:17). Their message made people comfortable on the wrong road. A word from God's council would have turned them off it.
-
23“Am I only a God nearby,” declares the LORD, “and not a God far away?”
Full study →"Do you take me for a God who is only close by: a local god of easy reach, at home in your temple, whose words you can hand out as you like? That is the declaration of Yahweh. Am I not also a God of far off, whose sight and power stretch across every distance, from whom no one can hide?"
The verse is a sharp question with a built-in answer. The prophets Jeremiah opposes act as if God were small enough to be familiar: near enough to assume, too near to notice what they are doing. Yahweh answers that he is not only near. He is also the God "from afar", and in Hebrew that means the one who sees and knows from any distance (compare Psalm 139:2). The next verse spells it out: "Can a man hide in secret places where I cannot see him? Do I not fill the heavens and the earth?" Distance here is not coldness or absence. It is limitless reach, and to anyone faking a word from God it is a threat. The formula "declaration of Yahweh", set in the middle of the question, stamps it as God's own speech in a chapter about men who forge that very formula (v. 31).
-
24“Can a man hide in secret places where I cannot see him?” declares the LORD. “Do I not fill the heavens and the earth?” declares the LORD.
Full study →"Or does anyone really think he can go to ground, slip into some hiding place, some lair, and that I, of all beings, will not see him? That is the sealed word of Yahweh. Is it not the heavens and the earth, the whole of creation, top to bottom, that I myself fill? That is the sealed word of Yahweh."
The verse is two rhetorical questions, each stamped with God's formal oracle seal. The first is mocking. The Hebrew uses one root twice ("hide himself in hiding places"), and the word for those places is used elsewhere for a lion's lair or an ambusher's lurking spot. The picture is of someone guilty or scheming who believes his cover will hold. The emphatic "I" sets him against the God who sees. In this chapter "see" is pointed. The false prophets never "saw" God's word in his council (v. 18), but God sees them, and in the next breath he says he has "heard" them too (v. 25).
The second question explains why hiding is impossible. God does not live in one shrine or one land, so there is no place out of his sight. The language is temple language: just as the glory-cloud once filled the sanctuary, God himself now fills the entire cosmos. Every corner of heaven and earth is effectively his house. The tone is not abstract philosophy and not, in the first place, reassurance. It is a warning to people who use God's name while assuming he is not watching closely: there is nowhere outside his presence to do it.
-
25“I have heard the sayings of the prophets who prophesy lies in My name: ‘I had a dream! I had a dream!’
Full study →"I myself have heard it, and I have the record. I know exactly what the prophets have been saying, the ones who keep prophesying, who put my name on what they say while what they say is falsehood, a hollow promise that will give way under anyone who leans on it. Their catchphrase is: 'I've had a dream! I've had a dream!'"
The verse comes right after God's question in v. 24: can anyone hide from the One who fills heaven and earth? So the opening "I have heard" is a quiet threat. There is also an irony in it. These prophets claim to have heard from God, but what has actually happened is that God has heard them. In the Hebrew, "in my name" and "falsehood" stand next to each other, so God's name is bound to a lie. The repeated "I dreamed, I dreamed!" catches their excited insistence. Dreams were an accepted way for God to speak, so the claim sounded like real revelation. Jeremiah repeats it almost as a parody. The following verses explain the problem. These dreams come from "the deceit of their own heart" (v. 26) and not from standing in God's council (vv. 18, 22). They are straw passed off as wheat (v. 28).
-
26How long will this continue in the hearts of these prophets who prophesy falsehood, these prophets of the delusion of their own minds?
Full study →"How long? Is there anything — will this go on — in the minds of the prophets? Prophets who prophesy what is false and empty, prophets whose message springs from the deceit their own minds have bred!"
The LORD speaks with worn-out exasperation. "How long?" is a complaint more than a question. Just before this (v. 25) he has quoted the prophets' boast, "I had a dream! I had a dream!" Now he asks what is actually in these men. The Hebrew sentence breaks off ("Is there… in the heart of the prophets?"), and that broken phrasing may itself carry the sense: God is asking whether anything real is in there at all, and how long this will keep going. They are given the title "prophets" three times in a row, and each time it is undercut. What they prophesy is sheqer: not only conscious lies but messages with no backing from God, promises that will fail everyone who leans on them. Where their message comes from is tarmit libbam, "the deceit of their own heart". In Hebrew the "heart" is mainly where a person thinks, plans and wills. The phrase can mean that they deceive themselves, that they deceive others, or both. In any case the source is their own minds and not the LORD's council. Their sincerity is not in question. They may truly have had their dreams. The problem is that the dreams came from them and not from God.
-
27They suppose the dreams that they tell one another will make My people forget My name, just as their fathers forgot My name through the worship of Baal.
Full study →YHWH is still speaking about the prophets of v. 26, whose prophecies are "lies" and "the deceit of their own heart." In Hebrew, verses 26–27 run as one long accusation: How long? Is there anything in the hearts of these prophets…
…these men who are scheming to make My people forget My name, by means of their dreams, the dreams they keep retelling, one man to the next, just as their fathers forgot My name by means of Baal.
The prophets are pictured as planners, not harmless dreamers. The verb is the one Jeremiah uses for plots. Their aim, or at least the result of their work, is to make people forget, and in covenant language forgetting means turning away in disloyalty, not just a lapse of memory. What gets forgotten is God's name: his known character, his reputation and his claim on his people. The irony is sharp. These prophets use the name all the time ("I had a dream, I had a dream!" v. 25, "in my name"), yet what they say takes the real God out of the people's minds. The tool is "their dreams," which they invented, swapped and passed around until everyone was repeating them. The verse ends with a pointed comparison. "By their dreams" is matched by "by Baal": the dreams of Jerusalem's YHWH-prophets now do what the Baal cult did to earlier generations. No foreign god is needed. A comfortable message spoken under God's own name can erase him just as well. The next verse gives the alternative: a dream is straw, but YHWH's word is grain.
-
28Let the prophet who has a dream retell it, but let him who has My word speak it truthfully. For what is straw compared to grain?” declares the LORD.
Full study →"The prophet who has a dream in hand: let him tell it as a dream. But the one who has my word with him: let him speak my word, faithfully and accurately, adding nothing and keeping nothing back. What does straw have to do with grain?" This is Yahweh's own declaration.
The verse is built as a matched pair. Each man "has" something "with him," and each is told to pass it on. The first has a dream, with no article and no owner. It is his, and he is to "recount" it, using the same storytelling verb v. 27 uses for the dreams these prophets swap with one another. The second has my word, and he is to "speak" it, using the verb for delivering a message, "in truth." That means reliably and loyally, as a messenger who changes nothing.
God is not banning dreams as such. He is refusing to let a dream be passed off as his word. Then comes the picture from the threshing floor. Straw and grain grow on the same stalk, and straw has its uses: fodder for animals, binder for bricks. But no one can make bread from it. The prophets' dreams of "peace" (v. 17) may look like part of the harvest, but they cannot feed a people facing judgment. Only God's word can. The next verse says what that word is like: fire, and a hammer that shatters rock. The closing formula, "declares Yahweh," puts God's own authority behind the line that separates his speech from theirs.
-
29“Is not My word like fire,” declares the LORD, “and like a hammer that smashes a rock?”
Full study →“Isn't my word exactly this: like fire?” This is Yahweh's own oracle. “And like a heavy hammer that splits solid rock to pieces?”
The question expects one answer: of course it is. It sits in the middle of Jeremiah's long attack on the prophets of Jerusalem who were telling a doomed city that all would be well (23:16–17). In the line just before, Yahweh says: let the man with a dream tell his dream, but let the man with my word speak it faithfully, because what does straw have to do with grain? This verse finishes the thought. The other prophets' dreams are straw. The real word is the fire that burns straw up.
Then the image gets harder. Fire deals with what is flimsy. A smith's or quarryman's hammer deals with what is solid, and the word for rock here means a crag or cliff face, the most immovable thing in the landscape. The verb is violent: shatters, smashes into pieces. The real word from Yahweh is not soothing, and it is not one more opinion beside other prophets' opinions. It is an active force that destroys whatever stands against it. In context that means the false prophets' comforting messages and a nation set on its course.
“Word” here means the message God actually gives a prophet, as opposed to dreams and borrowed oracles (v. 30). The small word “thus” (kōh) adds a note of insistence: this is what my word is like. The formula “oracle of Yahweh” in the middle of the line seals the claim with his authority.
-
30“Therefore behold,” declares the LORD, “I am against the prophets who steal from one another words they attribute to Me.”
Full study →"So now, look: I myself am taking the field against these prophets — this is Yahweh's own sworn word — the men who keep stealing my words, each one lifting them off his colleague."
The verse opens with a verdict. "Therefore" follows the charges of verses 25–29: these prophets spread dreams of their own invention, while God's true word is a fire and a hammer that smashes rock. "Here I am against" is a challenge to combat, and the same formula is repeated three times (vv. 30, 31, 32), each time with a new charge. God is not just withholding approval. He has become their opponent.
The charge is put vividly. They are habitual "stealers" (the Hebrew form points to a repeated practice, and the same form is used of Absalom secretly "stealing the hearts" of Israel). What they steal is "my words": messages carrying the claim of divine origin. Where they steal from is the giveaway: "each from his fellow." A true prophet in Jeremiah's world received the word by standing in Yahweh's council and hearing it directly (23:18, 22). These men pass oracles among themselves, so each one's message is second-hand at best. They then present it to the public with the seal "utterance of Yahweh," a seal the next verse mocks. The theft is twofold. They take material that is not theirs, and they deceive the hearers about where it came from.
-
31“Yes,” declares the LORD, “I am against the prophets who wag their own tongues and proclaim, ‘The LORD declares it.’”
Full study →"Look — here I am, standing against the prophets," runs Yahweh's own oracle, "the ones who take up their own tongue and then oracle an oracle."
The verse is built on a bitter wordplay. Every true prophetic message in Israel carried a seal: nəʾum YHWH, "oracle of Yahweh," a fixed tag that meant this word is God's, not mine. Here God uses that genuine seal in the middle of his sentence, then shows the prophets imitating it. They "take their tongue." The word comes from their own mouth and their own resources, not from God's mouth (compare v.16, "a vision of their own heart"). Then they perform the formula. Jeremiah turns the noun into a verb found nowhere else in the Bible: "they oracle an oracle." Their "oracle" has no "of Yahweh" attached. It has the outward form of prophecy, the official stamp, pressed onto words God never gave.
"Here I am against" is the language of a challenger stepping out to face an opponent. It is the second of three such blows in vv.30–32: against prophets who steal words from one another, against prophets who speak from their own tongue, and against prophets who peddle invented dreams. The charge is not bad delivery. It is forgery: claiming God's signature for one's own speech.
-
32“Indeed,” declares the LORD, “I am against those who prophesy false dreams and retell them to lead My people astray with their reckless lies. It was not I who sent them or commanded them, and they are of no benefit at all to these people,” declares the LORD.
Full study →"Look, I am standing against those who prophesy dreams that are lies. This is Yahweh's own word. They tell and retell those dreams, and by their lies and their reckless, boiling-over insolence they set my people wandering off the path like a flock with no shepherd, or men staggering drunk. But I, I never sent them. I never gave them their orders. And as for helping this people? They will be no help to them at all. This is Yahweh's word."
Several things are packed into the Hebrew:
- "I am against" is a declaration of hostility. It is repeated three times in vv. 30–32, so Yahweh is the prophets' opponent, not just someone who disagrees with them.
- "Dreams of falsehood" condemns what the dreams say, not dreaming itself. Their message deceives.
- "Retold" shows the lie spreading from person to person.
- Two separate charges: their lies (what they say) and their recklessness (a rare word for unrestrained, arrogant rashness, describing what they are like).
- The emphatic "But I" is the verdict: no sending, no commission. Their claimed "utterance of Yahweh" is forged.
- "No help at all" uses the same wording Jeremiah uses for idols. These prophets are as useless as Baal when disaster comes.
- Framing. The verse opens and closes with Yahweh's real oracle formula, and it sits around the counterfeit oracles it condemns.
-
33“Now when this people or a prophet or priest asks you, ‘What is the burden of the LORD?’ you are to say to them, ‘What burden? I will forsake you, declares the LORD.’
Full study →"And whenever this people (ordinary folk, or one of the prophets, or a priest) comes up to you with the taunt, 'So, what's the LORD's heavy word today?', you are to fire it back at them: 'Heavy word? You are the heavy load! And I am going to drop you and walk away.' That is the LORD's own declaration."
The Hebrew word at the centre, massaʾ, means two things at once: a formal prophetic pronouncement and a load carried on the back. The questioners mean the first, and they say it mockingly, as people who have grown tired of Jeremiah's gloomy announcements. God's answer turns to the second meaning. The real burden is not Jeremiah's message but the people, a load God has carried for generations and will now put down ("cast off, let fall, abandon", natash). That picture points to the coming loss of land, temple and king in the Babylonian exile.
The standard Hebrew text has Jeremiah reply "What burden?!", which turns their question back on them. The ancient Greek and Latin translations read the same consonants as "You are the burden", which says the punchline outright. On either reading the point is the same: those who sneer at God's word are about to find out that they are what God is setting down.
-
34As for the prophet or priest or anyone who claims, ‘This is the burden of the LORD,’ I will punish that man and his household.
Full study →"Whether it is a prophet, a priest or an ordinary person, whoever goes on saying, 'A maśśāʾ of the LORD!', I will deal with that man myself, him and his whole family."
The forbidden phrase has two meanings in Hebrew. Maśśāʾ was the formal heading for a prophetic announcement, roughly "the pronouncement of the LORD." It is also the everyday word for a load, something heavy you lift and carry. Prophets in Jerusalem used it as a label of authority on their messages, and people had started using it too, sometimes to mock Jeremiah's grim oracles ("So what's the LORD's burden now?"). God answers the joke with one of his own in verse 33: "What burden? You are the burden, and I am going to throw you down." Verse 34 then bans the label entirely. Anyone who keeps claiming to carry "the LORD's load" will find a different load put on him: God will "visit" him in judgment. The verb means God paying close, personal attention, and here that attention brings ruin. It reaches beyond the speaker to his household, his family name and his future. The verses that follow give the humble wording to use instead: "What has the LORD answered? What has the LORD spoken?" (v. 35). The reason comes in verse 36: "every man's own word becomes his burden." So the verse is not banning a word for its own sake. It condemns stamping God's name on a message of your own.
-
35This is what each man is to say to his friend and to his brother: ‘What has the LORD answered?’ or ‘What has the LORD spoken?’
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
36But refer no more to the burden of the LORD, for each man’s word becomes the burden, so that you pervert the words of the living God, the LORD of Hosts, our God.
Full study →"As for the phrase 'the burden-oracle of YHWH': you are not to say it anymore. Whatever passes for 'the oracle' is now nothing more than each man's own word, and it will become a load that he himself has to carry. In this way you turn upside down the words of the living God, YHWH, commander of the armies of heaven, our God."
The verse plays on the Hebrew word massa. It was the standard label for a prophetic pronouncement, but it also means a load carried on the back. In Jeremiah's day people asked the prophets, "What is the massa of YHWH?", and some prophets presented their own ideas under that heading. God's response is to withdraw the term: it has become a stamp anyone can put on his own opinions. The second line works both ways. Each man's private "word" has become the "oracle", and that "oracle" will be a weight on its speaker (v. 33 has already said, "you are the burden, and I will cast you off"). The last line uses the verb for flipping something over, the verb used for the overthrow of Sodom. Calling human talk God's word turns his real words upside down, so that a message of judgment becomes a message of peace. The verse ends by stacking up God's titles (living God, as opposed to mute idols; commander of armies; our God, bound to this people by covenant) to show how serious this is. Verses 35 and 37 give the honest replacement: simply ask, "What has YHWH answered? What has YHWH spoken?"
-
37Thus you are to say to the prophet: ‘What has the LORD answered you?’ and ‘What has the LORD spoken?’
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
38But if you claim, ‘This is the burden of the LORD,’ then this is what the LORD says: Because you have said, ‘This is the burden of the LORD,’ and I specifically told you not to make this claim,
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
39therefore I will surely forget you and will cast you out of My presence, both you and the city that I gave to you and your fathers.
Full study →"So that is why — look, it is I myself who act — I will put you out of my mind completely. Or, to hear the pun, I will pick you up like the 'burden' you keep talking about, and I will fling you away and leave you lying. I will do the same to the city I granted to you and to your ancestors, sweeping you both off from in front of my face."
The verse turns on a sound-play the first hearers would have caught. People kept asking Jeremiah, perhaps mockingly, "What's the massa' of the LORD?" The word means both "burden, load" and "prophetic pronouncement." God's reply is that they are the burden. Here he says he will nasa' them, "lift" them like a load, and then drop them. The standard Hebrew text points the first verb as "forget" (nashiti), which sounds almost the same. So the verse means both things at once: God stops caring for them and heaves them off. The double verb ("forget… forgetting" / "lift… lifting") makes it emphatic: utterly, without reserve. "From my face" means God's presence at the temple in Jerusalem, so the penalty is exile and the loss of the city itself. That city was a gift to the ancestors, never a possession that could not be taken back.
-
40And I will bring upon you everlasting shame and perpetual humiliation that will never be forgotten.”
Full study →"And I myself will lay on you a disgrace with no end in sight: the taunts of everyone who looks at you, and a humiliation that strips you of all standing, lasting on and on. It will never be forgotten."
This is the last line of a bitter oracle about the word massa, which can mean both an "oracle" and a "burden" (vv. 33–40). People, prophets and priests had been asking, "What is the burden of the LORD?", using Jeremiah's own prophetic language against him or to dress up their own messages. God's answer turns their words back on them. They wanted a burden, and now he will lay one on them. They forgot him, so he will "forget" them (v. 39). But the disgrace he lays on them will be the one thing nobody forgets.
The two nouns work as a pair. The first, ḥerpah, is the scorn and mockery other people pour out. The second, kelimmut, is the humiliated, lowered position of the one who receives it. "Perpetual" (ʿolam) is repeated with each, like two hammer blows. It means a disgrace lasting beyond any horizon the hearers could see: it will outlive them and stay attached to their name and their city in the memory of the nations. The "you" is plural. It is aimed at the community and its religious leaders who treated the prophetic word lightly, together with the city named in v. 39.
Where the English drifted
-
in v16
they make you vain (KJV)
mahbilim (from hevel)
- What we hear
- They make you conceited or proud of yourselves.
- What they heard
- They make you empty and futile. They fill you with breath, hopes that have nothing in them.
-
in v16
a vision of their own heart (KJV, WEB)
chazon libbam
- What we hear
- A sincere, heartfelt, emotional conviction, which modern culture tends to treat as something good.
- What they heard
- A 'revelation' that their own minds produced: human imagination and wishes passed off as divine speech.
-
in v16, v36
LORD of hosts
YHWH tseva'ot
- What we hear
- 'Hosts' heard as people who entertain guests, or as a vague religious title.
- What they heard
- The LORD of armies: commander of the heavenly forces and head of the divine council where true prophets receive their word (v. 18).
-
in v17
imagination of his own heart (KJV)
sherirut libbo
- What we hear
- Daydreaming, fantasy, or creativity: something harmless or even admirable.
- What they heard
- A hardened, obstinate will set against God's instruction. The word is about rigidity and refusal, not fancy.
-
in v17
No evil shall come upon you (KJV, WEB)
ra'ah
- What we hear
- Moral wickedness or sinister spiritual forces will not touch you.
- What they heard
- No disaster, calamity or harm will befall you. It refers to the concrete catastrophe of military defeat and exile.
-
in v17
you will have peace
shalom yihyeh lakhem
- What we hear
- You will feel calm inside, or be at peace with God.
- What they heard
- All will be well for you: national safety, prosperity, no invasion. It is a political and public reassurance.
-
in v18
counsel (KJV: "stood in the counsel of the LORD")
sod
- What we hear
- Advice or a plan, as in 'God's counsel' meaning his wisdom or guidance.
- What they heard
- An assembly or inner circle a person can stand in: the heavenly council around YHWH's throne, along with the confidential decisions made there.
-
in v18
his word
devaro
- What we hear
- The Bible, or God's word as written Scripture in general.
- What they heard
- A particular decree spoken in the council and carried out orally by a prophet. In context it is the coming judgment (v. 19), not 'peace'.
-
in v19
the wicked
resha'im
- What we hear
- Obviously evil people, villains, usually outsiders to the community of faith.
- What they heard
- The guilty party, those in the wrong before the divine judge. Here that means Judah's own prophets and the people who trusted their promises of peace.
-
in v19
whirlwind (KJV)
sa'ar / se'arah
- What we hear
- A tornado or narrow funnel of wind.
- What they heard
- A violent tempest or gale, the storm of the divine warrior. The spinning motion comes from the verb mitcholel beside it, not from the noun itself.
-
in v20
in the latter days (KJV, WEB, ESV); in the last days (NASB)
be'acharit hayyamim
- What we hear
- The end times: the final period of world history before Christ's return.
- What they heard
- 'In the after-part of the days,' meaning later on, in days to come. Here it means once the judgment now being announced has actually happened.
-
in v20
the thoughts of his heart (KJV)
mezimmot libbo
- What we hear
- God's inner feelings or musings.
- What they heard
- The deliberate plans and decisions of God's mind and will. The Hebrew 'heart' is mainly the organ of thinking and deciding.
-
in v20
ye shall consider it perfectly (KJV)
titbonenu vah binah
- What we hear
- You will think about it flawlessly, or just reflect on it.
- What they heard
- You will see into it and understand it thoroughly. The doubled wording adds emphasis; it does not claim perfect knowledge.
-
in v21
prophesied
nibba'u (naba')
- What we hear
- Predicted the future.
- What they heard
- Delivered oracles as God's spokesman: public speech claiming divine authority. Here the content was mostly reassurance about the present ('you will have peace,' v. 17), not forecasts.
-
in v21
they ran
ratsu (ruts)
- What we hear
- They ran off, or simply moved quickly or were eager.
- What they heard
- They ran as messengers do: took up the courier's role and rushed out with a 'message' to deliver.
-
in v22
stood in my counsel (KJV)
sod
- What we hear
- Received advice or guidance from God; was open to his counsel.
- What they heard
- Was present in God's council, the inner assembly at his throne, and so heard the confidential decisions made there. The word is about access and presence before it is about advice.
-
in v23
a God nearby / a God at hand
elohei miqqarov
- What we hear
- A warm assurance that God is close, available and intimate with us.
- What they heard
- The incomplete, shrunken picture of God that Yahweh is questioning: a local, close-range deity whom the false prophets assume they can speak for. Nearness here is not the comfort. The question challenges it.
-
in v23
a God far away / afar off
elohei merachoq
- What we hear
- A remote, aloof or absent God, the opposite of a caring one.
-
in v24
the LORD
YHWH
- What we hear
- A title, "Lord" or "master", a generic way of referring to God.
- What they heard
- The personal, covenant name of Israel's God. The verse is signed with that name twice, at the very point where false prophets are claiming to speak "in my name" (v. 25).
-
in v24
Do I not fill heaven and earth?
mālēʾ (et-hasshāmayim wəʾet-hāʾāreṣ)
- What we hear
- Usually taken as a general statement of the abstract attribute "omnipresence", often as a comfort that God is everywhere and so near to me.
- What they heard
- God's presence and sight leave no place outside his reach. In context this is the reason no one, especially a lying prophet, can escape his scrutiny. The doctrinal summary is not wrong, but the verse's own emphasis is exposure and accountability, in temple-filling language.
-
in v25
lies
sheqer
- What we hear
- Deliberate, conscious untruths told by people who know they are lying.
- What they heard
- Falsehood or deception in a broad sense: a message that is untrue and will fail anyone who trusts it. The word does not settle whether the speaker knowingly invented it. Verse 26 traces it to 'the deceit of their own heart,' which allows for self-deception as well as fraud.
-
in v25
I had a dream
ḥalamti
- What we hear
- Mere fancy or a psychological event. Or, in some modern religious circles, a casual personal 'word' from God.
- What they heard
- A claim to revelation through a widely accepted channel of divine communication, a claim that carried public authority in Judah and across the ancient Near East.
-
in v26
heart ("deceit of their own heart")
lēb
- What we hear
- Feelings and emotions, or heartfelt sincerity; 'following your heart' sounds warm and positive.
- What they heard
- The mind and will: where a person reasons, imagines, plans and decides. 'Prophets of the deceit of their own heart' means prophets whose messages are made up in their own minds.
-
in v27
forget My name
lehashkîaḥ … shəmî
- What we hear
- To stop remembering or using the word for God, his label.
- What they heard
- To lose hold of YHWH himself: his revealed character, reputation and covenant claim, and to stop living loyally toward him. These prophets used the name constantly. What disappeared was the God it stood for.
-
in v27
dreams
ḥălômôt
- What we hear
- Private, psychological experiences, or personal hopes and ambitions.
- What they heard
- Claimed messages from God received in sleep, a widely accepted and authoritative channel of revelation. Here they are condemned as invented ('the deceit of their own heart', v. 26).
-
in v28
dream
chalom
- What we hear
- A private product of the sleeping mind, or a wish or fantasy; something obviously unreliable.
- What they heard
- A recognized, respected means of receiving a message from God, claimed publicly by professional prophets as their credential. The contrast is between two claimed revelations, not between imagination and fact.
-
in v28
chaff (KJV)
teven
- What we hear
- Weightless, worthless husks that blow away.
- What they heard
- Straw: the stalks left after threshing, chopped for fodder and used in bricks. It was useful in its place, but it was not food for people. Hebrew has a different word (mots) for wind-blown chaff.
-
in v29
my word
dəbārî
- What we hear
- The Bible, God's written Scripture as a whole.
- What they heard
- The specific message Yahweh gives a true prophet. It is set against the dreams and recycled oracles of rival prophets (vv. 28, 30), and it is a spoken word that brings about what it announces.
-
in v29
like fire
kāʾēš
- What we hear
- Warmth, zeal, passion, or a refining “fire of revival.”
- What they heard
- Fire that consumes. Following v. 28, it burns up straw, meaning the false prophets' messages. Compare 5:14, where the people are the wood the word-fire consumes.
-
in v30
prophets
nəviʾîm
- What we hear
- Lone visionaries who predict the future. 'False prophets' sounds like obvious charlatans or outsiders.
- What they heard
- Recognised spokesmen for Yahweh, often working in groups and connected to temple and court, whose job was to bring the divine word on current affairs. These were respected insiders, and the public could not easily tell them apart from Jeremiah.
-
in v30
his neighbour
rēʿēhû
- What we hear
- The person living next door, or the 'neighbour' one is told to love.
- What they heard
- His fellow, his colleague: here another prophet. 'Each from his fellow' is simply Hebrew for 'from one another'.
-
in v31
declares the LORD / saith the LORD / He saith
nəʾum YHWH / nəʾum
- What we hear
- An ordinary verb of speaking, as if the verse were simply reporting what someone said.
- What they heard
- A fixed noun formula, "(an) oracle of Yahweh." It was an authentication seal claiming divine authorship. The prophets' offence is attaching this seal to their own words, and the verse mocks it by turning the noun into a verb: "they oracle an oracle."
-
in v31
use their tongues
lōqəḥîm ləšônām
- What we hear
- Readers in charismatic or Pentecostal settings may hear "tongues" as speaking in tongues, ecstatic or unknown languages.
- What they heard
- "Taking their own tongue": speaking out of their own mouth and imagination, as opposed to speaking words God put in their mouth (Jer 1:9). Nothing in the verse concerns ecstatic speech or unknown languages.
-
in v32
lightness (KJV)
paḥăzût
- What we hear
- Light-heartedness, cheerfulness, not being too serious.
-
in v32
they shall not profit this people (KJV)
hôʿêl lōʾ-yôʿîlû
- What we hear
- They will bring no financial gain.
- What they heard
- They will be of no use or help whatever, above all no rescue in the coming crisis. This is the wording used of idols, the "things that do not profit".
-
in v33
burden (of the LORD)
massaʾ
- What we hear
- An inward weight of concern or calling, as in 'God has given me a burden for this city'.
- What they heard
- Either a formal prophetic pronouncement or a literal load carried on the back. Here the two are played against each other. It does not describe a feeling in the prophet.
-
in v34
the burden of the LORD
maśśāʾ YHWH
- What we hear
- An inner weight of concern that God puts on someone's heart, as in 'I have a burden for this ministry.'
- What they heard
- A recognised heading for a formal prophetic pronouncement, playing on maśśāʾ as a physical load. It said nothing about the speaker's feelings. In this passage the phrase is actually banned because it was being misused to claim divine authority.
-
in v36
burden (of the LORD)
massa
- What we hear
- A heavy emotional concern or sense of calling ('I have a burden for this'), or a hardship someone bears.
- What they heard
- A formal prophetic pronouncement, with a pun on 'load carried on the back'. The weight lay in the content (often judgment) and in the wordplay, not in the speaker's feelings.
-
in v36
pervert
hafakh
- What we hear
- Sexual deviance, or a sexually deviant person.
- What they heard
- To overturn, flip upside down, reverse into the opposite; the verb used for the overthrow of Sodom.
-
in v39
forget ("I will surely forget you")
nāshāh
- What we hear
- God's memory lapses, or he absent-mindedly loses track of them.
- What they heard
- A deliberate covenant act: God stops attending to and acting for these people, as a fitting reply to their refusal to listen. The sound also puns on nasa', 'lift' (as a burden), so the hearers would also have heard 'I will heave you up and off.'
-
in v40
everlasting / perpetual
ʿolam
- What we hear
- Literally without end, eternal, often heard as eternal punishment in the afterlife.
-
in v40
shame (BSB, for ḥerpah)
ḥerpah
- What we hear
- An inner feeling of guilt or embarrassment.
- What they heard
- Public reproach: the taunts, scorn and insults other people direct at someone who has fallen. It is a social condition, not mainly an emotion.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v21
'They ran before I sent them' isn't about bad timing
- What's often taught
- The verse is often preached as a warning against 'running ahead of God': people who begin a ministry or step into a role before God's appointed time, or without proper preparation or recognition.
- What the text supports
The Hebrew does not say they ran before they were sent, as if a commission was coming later. It says flatly that God never sent them (lo' shalachti) and never spoke to them (lo' dibbarti). Their 'running' is the courier's dash with a message (ruts), and that message was false: 'You will have peace' (v. 17), given to a people steeped in injustice and idolatry (vv. 10–14). Verse 22 gives the test: a prophet who had stood in God's council would have carried God's words and turned the people from their evil ways.
What the popular reading gets right is that zeal and activity do not prove a divine commission. But the verse's concern is the source and content of a message claimed as God's word, not timing, readiness or formal credentials. These men held the recognized office of prophet. What they lacked was a word from God.
- Where the English feeds it
- Translations that add 'these prophets… have run' with no context, or NLT's 'run around', can make 'running' sound like restless haste or overeagerness, which invites a lesson about patience rather than about false messages.
in v23
This verse doesn't promise God is near. It questions a God who is only near
- What's often taught
- Jeremiah 23:23 is often quoted as a reassurance that God is always close at hand and never distant from his people.
- What the text supports
The Hebrew is a pointed question: "Am I a God of near, and not a God of far?" It expects the hearer to admit that God is not merely near. In context (v. 16-32) Yahweh is confronting prophets who treat him as a familiar, local God they can speak for without being sent. Verse 24 explains the "far" side: no one can hide from him, and he fills heaven and earth. The verse stresses God's unlimited reach and all-seeing knowledge, and it is aimed as a warning at those faking his word.
The comforting reading is not wholly wrong. The Bible does affirm God's nearness elsewhere (e.g. Ps 145:18), and this verse does not deny that God is near. But nearness is not this verse's message, and here God's reach brings exposure, not reassurance.
- Where the English feeds it
- Literal renderings such as "Am I a God at hand…?" leave out the implied "only", so a reader can catch the phrase "a God at hand" and miss the challenge. The Greek Septuagint's statement "I am a God who draws near" also encouraged the nearness reading in some later tradition.
Every word
-
כֹּֽה־
koh · H3541
thus, so · v16, v29
Opens the standard messenger formula: what follows is quoted speech carried from a superior. It sets up the whole verse's contrast: Jeremiah claims to carry a real 'thus says', and the other prophets do not.
-
אָמַ֞ר
'amar · H559
to say · v16, v17, v25, v33, v34
'Has said' / 'says'. In the messenger formula the perfect tense presents the word as already spoken by the sender and now being delivered by the messenger.
-
יְהוָ֣ה
YHWH · H3068
the LORD (the divine name) · v16, v17, v18, v19, v20, v23, v24, v28, v29, v30, v31, v32, v33, v34, v36
Israel's God by his personal name, rendered 'the LORD' in most English Bibles. The verse begins and ends with this name: the true source of speech brackets the false speakers.
-
צְבָא֗וֹת
tseva'ot · H6635
armies, hosts · v16, v36
'Of armies': the God who commands the heavenly forces and the divine council. It prepares for v. 18, which asks which of these prophets has actually stood in the LORD's council.
-
אַֽל־
'al · H408
do not · v16
The negative used with a direct, immediate command: 'Don't!' It is an urgent warning for right now, not a general rule set out for the future.
-
תִּשְׁמְע֞וּ
tishme'u · H8085
hear, listen, heed, obey · v16, v18, v22, v25
Plural, addressed to the people. Shama' means more than hearing sounds: it means paying attention, taking to heart and acting on. The people are told not to give these prophets a hearing or obey them.
-
עַל־
'al · H5921
upon, to, concerning · v16, v17, v19, v30, v31, v32, v34, v39, v40
Here it simply marks what is listened to ('to'). Jeremiah's Hebrew often uses 'al where other books would use 'el ('to').
-
דִּבְרֵ֤י
divrei · H1697
words, matters · v16, v18, v22, v28, v29, v30, v36
'The words of'. The question running through the chapter is whose davar (word) is really the LORD's; v. 28–29 set the true word, which is like fire and a hammer, against their dreams.
-
הַנְּבִאִים֙
ha-nevi'im · H5030
prophet · v16, v21, v25, v26, v28, v30, v31, v33, v34
'The prophets': here the recognised, professional prophets of Jerusalem (v. 15). Jeremiah does not call them 'false prophets'; the Hebrew uses the ordinary word. They hold the office but do not have the commission.
-
הַנִּבְּאִ֣ים
ha-nibbe'im · H5012
to prophesy · v16, v21, v25, v26, v32
'The ones prophesying': a participle for ongoing activity. They keep on prophesying. The repetition of the same root ('the prophets, the prophesying ones') stresses the busy, constant output.
-
לָכֶ֔ם
lakhem
to you · v16
'To you' (plural): their message is aimed at the people, telling them what they want to hear (v. 17).
-
מַהְבִּלִ֥ים
mahbilim · H1891
to act emptily; (causative) make empty, fill with vain hopes, delude · v16
Built on hevel, 'breath, vapour', the word behind Ecclesiastes' 'vanity'. This is the only place in the Bible where the verb takes its causative form: 'they are making you hevel', filling you with breath, hopes that have nothing in them. The participle shows it is happening now and continuing.
-
הֵ֖מָּה
hemmah · H1992
they · v16, v21
An emphatic 'they', not strictly needed in Hebrew. It points the finger: it is these men who are emptying you.
-
אֶתְכֶ֑ם
'etkhem · H853
(object marker) + you · v16, v18, v21, v22, v24, v25, v27, v32, v33, v36, v39
'You' as the object. The people are the ones being made empty. The harm is done to the hearers, not only to the truth.
-
חֲז֤וֹן
chazon · H2377
vision, revelation, prophetic oracle · v16
The technical word for a prophet's revelation, whether something seen or a revelatory message (compare Isaiah 1:1, 'The vision of Isaiah'). They present their message as revelation.
-
לִבָּם֙
libbam · H3820
heart, mind, will · v16, v17, v20, v26
'Their heart', meaning their mind, imagination and intentions, not mainly their feelings. 'A vision of their heart' is a revelation they made up themselves. It echoes v. 17, where the audience walks 'in the stubbornness of his heart'.
-
יְדַבֵּ֔רוּ
yedabberu · H1696
to speak · v16, v17, v21, v28
'They speak', in the imperfect tense of habitual action: this is what they keep producing. Placing the object first ('a vision of their heart they speak') stresses where the message comes from.
-
לֹ֖א
lo' · H3808
not · v16, v17, v20, v21, v23, v24, v29, v32, v36, v40
A flat denial: 'not'. The clause has no verb, so it lands as a curt verdict.
-
מִפִּ֥י
mippi · H6310
-
לִֽמְנַאֲצַ֔י
limna'atsay · H5006
to spurn, treat with contempt · v17
'To those who spurn me.' God speaks: the prophets' audience is people who openly treat YHWH with contempt. The irony is sharp: the very people who despise God are promised his blessing.
-
שָׁל֖וֹם
shalom · H7965
well-being, safety, peace · v17
Here this means national safety and prosperity: no invading army, no siege, life going on as normal. It is not a promise of inner calm.
-
יִֽהְיֶ֣ה
yihyeh · H1961
will be · v17, v36
'Will be.' A confident prediction about the future: things will turn out well.
-
לָכֶ֑ם
lakhem · H9036
to/for you (plural) · v17, v39
'For you all.' Addressed to the people as a whole, which makes it a promise to the nation.
-
וְ֠כֹל
vekhol · H3605
and every, all · v17
'And every one.' The second line moves from the group to each individual. No one who goes their own way is left out of the false reassurance.
-
הֹלֵ֞ךְ
holekh · H1980
walking · v17
'Walking.' In Hebrew, to 'walk' means to live, to follow a way of life. The participle describes a settled pattern of conduct.
-
בִּשְׁרִר֤וּת
bishrirut · H8307
stubbornness, hardness · v17
'In the stubbornness of.' The word suggests something hard and fixed. It describes a will that has set itself against God's instruction. This is one of Jeremiah's signature words, and it echoes Deuteronomy 29:19.
-
תָב֥וֹא
tavo · H0935
will come · v17
'It will come.' The feminine verb agrees with 'disaster.' In prophetic speech, disaster 'coming upon' people is standard language for judgment arriving.
-
רָעָֽה׃
ra'ah · H7451
harm, calamity, disaster · v17, v22
Here this means disaster: invasion, siege, exile. It is not 'evil' in the sense of moral wickedness. It is the exact counterpart of shalom in the first half of the verse.
-
כִּי
ki · H3588A
for, because, indeed · v18, v33, v36
Ties this question to verse 17. The prophets are promising 'peace' in YHWH's name, and the reason that claim is empty follows here. It can also simply add emphasis: 'Why, who has stood…?'
-
מִי
mi · H4310
who? · v18
A question that expects a negative answer, the kind that means 'nobody'. Here it means none of the peace-prophets. Whether it also means 'no human at all' is debated (see debates).
-
עָמַד
ʿamad · H5975G
to stand · v18, v22
To stand as an attendant stands before a king: present, on duty, waiting for orders. The perfect tense asks whether any of them has ever actually been there.
-
בְּסוֹד
be-sod · H5475
in the council / confidential circle of · v18, v22
'In the council of', meaning the inner assembly around YHWH's throne where decisions are talked over and decrees are issued. It is a place a person attends, and the private deliberation that happens there.
-
וְיֵרֶא
ve-yere · H7200G
and see / perceive · v18, v24
The short (jussive) form after 'and' marks purpose or result: 'so that he saw / might see'. Prophets 'saw' as well as heard. Compare Micaiah: 'I saw YHWH sitting on his throne' (1 Kgs 22:19).
-
הִקְשִׁיב
hiqshiv · H7181
to pay close attention, give ear · v18
An intensive word for listening: pricking up the ears and attending closely. It suggests the alert courtier who catches every word of the king.
-
הִנֵּה
hinneh · H2009
look, behold · v19
A word that grabs attention, like pointing and shouting 'Look!' It puts the storm in front of the hearers as if it were already in sight on the horizon.
-
סַעֲרַת
sa'arat · H5591B
-
חֵמָה
chemah · H2534
heat, rage, wrath · v19
Literally 'heat', from a root meaning 'to be hot'. It is the burning anger of a wronged judge. It stands next to 'storm' as a second name for the same thing: the storm is the wrath. Translations that say 'with fury' or 'in wrath' smooth this into an adverb.
-
יָצְאָה
yatse'ah · H3318G
go out, go forth · v19
'Has gone out', a completed action. The storm has already been let loose from Yahweh's presence. The judgment is spoken of as settled fact even though it has not yet struck.
-
מִתְחוֹלֵל
mitcholel · H2342J
whirling, twisting itself · v19
A form of the verb chul meaning 'whirl, spin, writhe' (the same root is used of dancing and of labor pains). The form describes the wind turning in on itself, a swirling, twisting storm.
-
רֹאשׁ
rosh · H7218A
head · v19
'Head', singular, applied to a group. It pictures the blow landing directly on each person, and in Hebrew idiom something 'on the head' of a person is the consequence that is theirs to bear (compare 'his blood be on his head').
-
רְשָׁעִים
resha'im · H7563
-
יָשׁוּב
yashuv · H7725
-
אַף־
af · H639
nose, nostril; anger · v20
Literally 'nose.' Hebrew speaks of anger through the image of flaring, snorting nostrils. Here it means God's judicial anger against covenant-breaking Judah, the force behind the storm of v.19.
-
עַד־
ad · H5704
until · v20, v26
Sets the limit of the anger: it runs until a goal is reached. The anger has a purpose and an end point; it is not endless.
-
עֲשֹׂתוֹ
asoto · H6213
to do, make, carry out · v20
'His doing,' a verbal noun with 'his': until he has done or carried out. It is the first of a pair of verbs that together stress complete execution.
-
הֲקִימוֹ
haqimo · H6965
-
מְזִמּוֹת
mezimmot · H4209
-
בְּאַחֲרִית
be'acharit · H319
end, latter part, outcome, sequel · v20
'In the after-part of.' The word means the later part or outcome of something, what comes afterward. It does not mean the end of the world.
-
הַיָּמִים
hayyamim · H3117
days · v20
With the previous word: 'in the after-part of the days,' meaning 'later on, in days to come.' In context this means once the judgment has actually fallen.
-
תִּתְבּוֹנְנוּ
titbonenu · H995
consider, discern, gain insight · v20
A reflexive form of the verb 'understand': to look into something closely until it becomes clear. The 'you' is plural: the people (and their prophets) who will see the truth only after events prove it.
-
בָהּ
vah · H9034
in/into it · v20
'Into it.' The feminine 'it' most naturally means 'the matter' in general (Hebrew often uses the feminine for that). It may also point back to the storm (se'arah, a feminine noun) of v.19.
-
בִּינָה
binah · H998
understanding, insight · v20
A noun from the same root as the verb before it: literally 'you will understand it with understanding.' Hebrew uses this kind of echo for emphasis, so it means 'you will understand it clearly, fully.'
-
שָׁלַ֥חְתִּי
shalachti · H7971
-
רָ֑צוּ
ratsu · H7323
they ran · v21
To run, and in particular to run as a courier carrying a message (2 Sam 18:19–27). The picture is messengers dashing out with a dispatch that was never handed to them.
-
אֲלֵיהֶ֖ם
'aleihem · H0413
to them · v21, v33
'To them', meaning addressed to them directly. A prophet is first someone who has been spoken to, and only then someone who speaks.
-
וְאִֽם־
ve'im · H0518A
and if · v22, v24
Opens a condition. Verse 21 has just said God did not send these prophets, so the 'if' describes something that did not happen: 'but if they had…'. The 'and' works here as 'but'.
-
עַמִּ֔י
ʿammi · H5971A
people, kin-group · v22, v27, v32, v33, v34
'My people' is the language of the covenant. Even while judgment is coming, God still calls them his own. The prophets have failed people who belong to him.
-
מִדַּרְכָּ֣ם
midarkam · H1870G
way, road, conduct · v22
'From their way.' A road you walk on, standing for a settled pattern of living. Hebrew has the singular 'way' here, which BSB turns into the plural 'ways'.
-
וּמֵרֹ֖עַ
umeroaʿ · H7455
badness, evil quality · v22
'And from the badness of…' An abstract noun from the same root as 'evil' just before it. Repeating the sound drives the point home: evil way, evil of their deeds.
-
מַֽעַלְלֵיהֶֽם׃
maʿaleleihem · H4611
-
הַאֱלֹהֵ֧י
ha'elohei · H0430
(is it) a God of …? · v23, v36
The prefixed ha- marks a question here. It is not the word "the", which does not normally attach to this linked (construct) form. Elohei means "God of" and is tied to the phrase that follows: "a God of from-near". The question is about what kind of God Yahweh is.
-
מִקָּרֹ֛ב
miqqarov · H7138
from near · v23
Literally "from near": a God who belongs to, sees from, and acts within close range. In context this means a local, close-at-hand deity whom the prophets assume they can speak for at will. Elsewhere the same phrase can also mean "recently" (Deut 32:17).
-
אָ֖נִי
ani · H0589
I · v23, v24
An emphatic "I" placed after the predicate. Yahweh himself is the subject being questioned: "is that what I am?"
-
נְאֻם־
ne'um · H5002
utterance, oracle · v23, v24, v28, v29, v30, v31, v32, v33
A fixed prophetic formula, "oracle of", that marks words as a direct divine declaration. Here it is dropped into the middle of the question. In a chapter about prophets who fake oracles (v. 31), it underlines who is actually speaking.
-
מֵרָחֹֽק׃
merachoq · H7350
from far, from afar · v23
"From far off": a God whose reach and sight stretch across all distance. Verse 24 explains it: no one can hide from him, and he fills heaven and earth. In the Psalms, seeing "from afar" is a mark of complete knowledge (Ps 139:2). The word can also mean "from long ago" (2 Kgs 19:25).
-
יִסָּתֵר
yissātēr · H5641
to hide; (Niphal) hide oneself, be hidden · v24
"Hide himself": a deliberate act of going under cover, the way a fugitive or someone lying in ambush does. The verb form looks to the future: "will anyone (manage to) hide?"
-
אִישׁ
ʾîsh · H0376I
man; anyone, each · v24, v27, v30, v34, v36
Used broadly here to mean "anyone" or "a person", not a male in particular. In context it points first at the false prophets, but the claim covers everyone.
-
בַּמִּסְתָּרִים
bammistārîm · H4565
hiding place, secret place · v24
"In the hiding places". It comes from the same root as the verb just before it, so the line sounds like "hide himself in the hidey-holes". The word is used elsewhere for a lion's lair and for an ambusher's lurking spot.
-
הַשָּׁמַיִם
hasshāmayim · H8064
heavens, sky · v24
The sky and everything above it, including the realm of God's throne and council. It is the first half of the pairing "heavens and earth".
-
הָאָרֶץ
hāʾāreṣ · H0776G
earth, land · v24
"The earth". Paired with "the heavens", it means the whole created world. It also reaches beyond the "land" of Judah where the prophets assume God lives.
-
מָלֵא
mālēʾ · H4390
to fill, be full · v24
"Filling" or "fill": an ongoing state, not a one-time act. It is the language used of the glory-cloud filling the temple. Here the "house" being filled is the entire cosmos, so there is no room left over to hide in.
-
אֲשֶׁר־
ʾasher · H0834
that which, what · v25, v27, v28, v34, v39, v40
Together with the object marker it means 'what' or 'that which.' What God heard is the content of their speech.
-
בִּשְׁמִ֛י
bishmi · H8034
in my name · v25, v27
Speaking under my authority, as my authorised agent, with formulas like 'thus says the LORD.' This is the core of the offence. Compare Deut 18:20, where a prophet who speaks in God's name what God did not command is to die.
-
שֶׁ֖קֶר
sheqer · H8267
falsehood, deception · v25, v26, v32
What they prophesy is sheqer: false, deceptive, something that will let down whoever trusts it. In Hebrew the word stands right after 'in my name,' so God's name and falsehood sit side by side.
-
חָלַ֖מְתִּי
ḥalamti · H2492
I have dreamed · v25
'I have dreamed!' or 'I had a dream!' Their claim rests on a dream experience, which Israel and its neighbours accepted as a real channel of divine communication.
-
מָתַ֗י
mātay · H4970
-
הֲיֵ֛שׁ
hăyēš · H3426
there is / is there? · v26
'Is there…?' The little question marker ha- sits on the word for 'there is'. The sentence never says what 'is there', which is why translations differ: 'this', 'lies', 'anything'. This is the verse's main difficulty (see debates).
-
תַּרְמִ֥ת
tarmit · H8649B
deceit, treachery, delusion · v26
'The deceit of'. It comes from the root meaning 'to deceive, betray'. This deceit grows inside them and then misleads others, so it may be self-deception, deliberate trickery, or both.
-
הַחֹשְׁבִ֗ים
ha-ḥōshəvîm · H2803J
-
לְהַשְׁכִּ֤יחַ
ləhashkîaḥ · H7911
to cause to forget · v27, v40
The causative form of 'forget': to make someone forget. The prophets do not just forget God themselves. They bring about forgetting in others. This is the goal or effect of their planning.
-
בַּחֲל֣וֹמֹתָ֔ם
ba-ḥălômōtām · H2472
-
יְסַפְּר֖וּ
yəsappərû · H5608A
they recount · v27, v28, v32
'They keep telling.' This form of the verb means to recount or narrate and is the normal verb for telling a dream (Gen 37:9–10; 40:8–9; Judg 7:13). The verb form suggests ongoing, repeated telling.
-
לְרֵעֵ֑הוּ
lərēʿēhû · H7453
to his neighbor/fellow · v27, v30
'To his fellow.' The dreams pass from person to person, from mouth to mouth. The same idiom comes back in v. 30, where the prophets 'steal my words each from his fellow', which suggests a circle of prophets recycling one another's material.
-
אֲבוֹתָ֛ם
ʾăvôtām · H0001G
their fathers · v27, v39
The ancestors, the earlier generations of Israel and Judah who served Baal, especially under the northern kings and under Manasseh in Judah.
-
בַּבָּֽעַל׃
ba-bbāʿal · H1168A
Baal · v27
'By/for the Baal.' The preposition can mean 'by means of', 'because of' or 'in exchange for'. It mirrors 'by their dreams' earlier in the verse, so the dreams are set in the same slot Baal once filled.
-
אִתּ֤וֹ
itto · H0854
with him · v28, v30
"With him": the dream is pictured as something the prophet carries around and holds. It is his.
-
אֱמֶ֑ת
emet · H0571G
truth, faithfulness · v28
Used here as an adverb: "in truth, faithfully, reliably." He is to pass the word on intact and loyal to its source, adding nothing and softening nothing.
-
מַה־
mah · H4100
what? · v28, v33
Opens a question that expects no answer and makes a point: "what is there between…?"
-
לַתֶּ֥בֶן
latteven · H8401
to the straw · v28
Straw: the stalks left after threshing. Farmers chopped it for animal fodder and builders mixed it into mud bricks. It had uses, but people could not live on it.
-
הַבָּ֖ר
habbar · H1250A
the grain · v28
Threshed and winnowed grain, the cleaned kernels people actually eat. It is the product the whole harvest is for.
-
כָּאֵ֖שׁ
kāʾēš · H784
-
וּכְפַטִּ֖ישׁ
ûkəpaṭṭîš · H6360
-
יְפֹ֥צֵֽץ
yəpōṣēṣ · H6327
-
סָֽלַע׃
sālaʿ · H5553
crag, rock · v29
A cliff, crag or rock face. It means bedrock and boulders, not a pebble. It stands for the hardest, most immovable thing there is, and even that splits under this word.
-
לָכֵ֛ן
lākhēn · H3651
therefore · v30, v39
Literally 'to so', 'for that reason'. In prophetic speech it is the hinge between the charge and the sentence: after the case against the prophets (vv. 25–29), the verdict now follows.
-
הִנְנִ֥י
hinnî · H2005
behold, here I am · v30, v31, v32, v39
'Look, here I am' — God points to himself as the one now stepping in. Paired with 'against', it begins a fixed formula of hostile confrontation.
-
מְגַנְּבֵ֣י
məgannəvê · H1589
to steal · v30
An intensified participle, 'stealers of', describing an ongoing practice rather than a single act. The same stem describes Absalom 'stealing the hearts' of Israel (2 Sam 15:6), so stealthy deception is part of the picture.
-
הַלֹּקְחִ֣ים
hallōqəḥîm · H3947G
to take · v31
"The ones who take": an ongoing habit. They "take," or take up, something to speak with, and the next word says what: their own tongue, not a word received from God.
-
לְשׁוֹנָ֔ם
ləšônām · H3956G
tongue, speech, language · v31
"Their tongue": their own organ of speech and so their own speech. The possessive "their" is the point. The source of the message is the prophet, not God (compare 23:16, "a vision of their own heart").
-
וַֽיִּנְאֲמ֖וּ
wayyinʾămû · H5001
to utter an oracle · v31
"And they oracle": a verb made from the noun nəʾum, found as a finite verb only here in the Hebrew Bible. It mocks them: they produce the oracle formula as an act of their own, they "do" oracles.
-
וַיַּתְע֣וּ
wayyatʿû · H8582
to wander, go astray · v32
"And they made [my people] wander": a causative form. The picture is a flock led off the path, or a drunk man staggering. The same verb is used of Samaria's Baal-prophets in v. 13.
-
וּבְפַחֲזוּתָ֑ם
ûḇəpaḥăzûtām · H6350
recklessness, wantonness · v32
"And by their recklessness": a word found only here in the Bible, from a root meaning to boil over or be reckless and insolent. It describes how they behave: careless, arrogant, unrestrained.
-
וְאָנֹכִ֨י
wəʾānōḵî · H0595
I · v32
An emphatic "I" that Hebrew does not need grammatically: "But I, for my part…". It sets Yahweh against their claim to speak for him.
-
צִוִּיתִ֗ים
ṣiwwîtîm · H6680
to command, charge · v32
"I commanded / charged them": giving a messenger his orders and content. This echoes Deut 18:20, where a prophet who speaks what Yahweh "did not command" is condemned.
-
וְהוֹעֵ֛יל
wəhôʿêl · H3276
to profit, help · v32
A verb form placed before the main verb for emphasis (an "infinitive absolute"): "as for helping…". It sets up the strong denial that follows.
-
הַזֶּ֖ה
hazzeh · H2088
this · v32, v33
"This people": the generation actually standing in front of Jeremiah, facing Babylon.
-
יִשְׁאָלְךָ֩
yishʾalekha · H7592
-
אֽוֹ־
ʾo · H176
or · v33
"Or": the list widens to cover everyone who might ask.
-
כֹהֵן֙
khohen · H3548
-
מַשָּׂ֖א
massaʾ · H4853
burden; oracle · v33, v34, v36
"Burden/oracle of": a formal word for a prophetic pronouncement, which also means a load carried on the back. The questioners use it as the set term for 'the latest word from God', with a sneer: "So what's today's heavy word from the LORD?"
-
וְנָטַשְׁתִּ֥י
wenatashti · H5203
to leave, abandon, cast off, let fall · v33, v39
"And I will cast off / let go of." With 'burden' still in the air, it suggests a porter dropping a load from his shoulders: God will put Judah down and leave it.
-
וּפָקַדְתִּ֛י
ûp̄āqaḏtî · H6485H
and I will visit / punish · v34
With 'upon' (ʿal), pāqad means God stepping in to deal with someone and bring the consequences of what they did down on them. Here it means punishment. The 'and' marks the start of the main clause: 'then I will…'
-
הַה֖וּא
hahûʾ · H1931
that · v34
'That man' points back to the speaker of the forbidden phrase and singles him out.
-
בֵּיתֽוֹ׃
bêṯô · H1004M
his house(hold) · v34
Not the building. It means his family line and dependents, the household he heads. In that world the household was treated as one unit with its head.
-
תִזְכְּרוּ־
tizkeru · H2142
you will remember / mention · v36
In Hebrew 'remembering' is calling something to mind and, very often, to the lips. Here it means bringing up or using the phrase in speech: 'you shall not mention it'.
-
ע֑וֹד
od · H5750
again, any longer · v36
'Anymore': the phrase had been in common use and is now withdrawn.
-
וַהֲפַכְתֶּ֗ם
wa-hafakhtem · H2015
and you overturn · v36
To turn over, flip, overthrow. It is the verb used for the overthrow of Sodom. Grammatically it can state the result ('and so you overturn') or describe what they have already been doing ('you have overturned'). Either way, labelling human words as God's turns God's words upside down.
-
חַיִּ֔ים
chayyim · H2416A
living · v36
'Living' is plural here to match the plural-looking word Elohim, which happens only in a few old fixed phrases (Deut 5:26; 1 Sam 17:26, 36; Jer 10:10). The living God, who acts and speaks, is set against human talk that only borrows his name.
-
וְנָשִׁ֥יתִי
wənāshîtî · H5382
forget · v39
As the Masoretes pointed it, 'and I will forget.' The consonants (נשיתי) can also be read as a spelling of nasa'tî, 'I will lift up', which would continue the pun on massa', 'burden'. See textual notes.
-
נָשֹׁ֑א
nāshōʾ · H5375G
lift, carry (infinitive) · v39
An infinitive placed beside a finite verb for emphasis, giving 'surely' or 'utterly'. It is spelled with aleph, like nasa' ('lift'), even though the verb before it is pointed as 'forget'. So the word carries both sounds and keeps the burden pun audible.
-
הָעִיר֙
hāʿîr · H5892B
city · v39
Jerusalem, the city of the temple and of David's line, which people believed God would never give up.
-
נָתַ֧תִּי
nātattî · H5414G
I gave · v39, v40
Language for granting land. The city was never theirs by right. It was God's grant, and the giver can take it back.
-
פָּנָֽי׃
pānāy · H6440H
my face · v39
'My face', meaning God's presence. In Judah that presence was linked to the temple and the land, so being sent 'from my face' means exile.
-
חֶרְפַּ֣ת
ḥerpat · H2781
reproach, taunt, scorn · v40
Public scorn: the taunts and mockery other people throw at someone who has fallen. It names how outsiders treat you, not a private feeling. It is bound to the next word, "reproach of perpetuity".
-
עוֹלָ֑ם
ʿolam · H5769
long duration, perpetuity · v40
Used here as an adjective, "lasting, perpetual". It describes a disgrace with no end in sight, one that will outlast the generation that earned it.
-
וּכְלִמּ֣וּת
ukhlimmut · H3640
and humiliation, disgrace · v40
Humiliation: being shamed, insulted and lowered in standing. This exact form appears only here in the Hebrew Bible. It is a variant of the common word kelimmah, and the rare form may have been chosen for sound and emphasis.
The world behind it
The last years of Judah (roughly 609–587 BC). Babylon had crushed Egypt at Carchemish (605). Jerusalem was taken in 597, the king and leading citizens were deported, and Zedekiah reigned as a vassal until the final destruction in 587/586. Throughout this period Jeremiah predicted disaster, while other prophets announced shalom, "peace, well-being" (Jer 6:14; 8:11; 14:13). The best-known clash is with Hananiah, who publicly promised the exiles would return within two years (Jer 28).
Why their message was believable. The comforting prophets could rely on a strong tradition: the LORD had chosen Zion, his temple was in Jerusalem, and he had promised David a lasting dynasty (compare the slogan "the temple of the LORD" in Jer 7:4). Isaiah had once announced that Jerusalem would be spared from Assyria (Isa 37), and it was. Promising safety therefore looked orthodox.
Prophets in the wider ancient world. Kings across the Near East kept prophets who delivered favourable oracles. The Mari letters and the Assyrian oracles to Esarhaddon ("Fear not, O king") show that reassuring the throne was a normal part of the job. Israel's tradition had already seen the danger: the 400 prophets who promised Ahab victory (1 Kgs 22), and the law's test of a prophet whose word does not come true (Deut 18:21–22).
The divine council. The next verses ask, "Who has stood in the council (sod) of the LORD?" (v. 18) and say "If they had stood in my council, they would have proclaimed my words" (v. 22). In Israel's picture of heaven, a true prophet was let into the throne room of "the LORD of armies" and overheard the decisions made there (1 Kgs 22:19–23; Isa 6). That is why "from the mouth of the LORD" matters here. A word was authentic because of where it came from: the speaker had been in the court and heard it.
From the study of Jeremiah 23:16.
Where scholars differ
in v16
What exactly does mahbilim ('making-hevel') mean here?
-
They fill the people with empty, false hopes (BSB, NIV, ESV).
The context is the promise of 'peace' in v. 17. The hope is hevel because it will vanish. Many lexicons give 'fill with vain hopes' for this form.
-
They make the people themselves empty and futile, like idol-worshippers.
Jer 2:5 and 2 Kgs 17:15, 'went after hevel and became hevel (wayyehbalu)', use the same root. The Hebrew object is 'you' (the people), not 'hopes'.
-
It simply means 'they deceive you'.
The Vulgate's decipiunt vos, and the parallel with 'deceit of their heart' in 14:14 and 23:26.
in v16
Were these prophets lying on purpose or sincerely self-deceived?
-
Conscious fraud.
V. 26 calls them 'prophets of the deceit (tarmit) of their heart'. Vv. 30–31 accuse them of stealing words from one another and saying 'he declares' on their own initiative.
-
Sincere but self-generated: they took their own convictions and orthodox Zion theology for revelation.
'Vision of their heart' and the dreams of vv. 25–28 suggest real experiences with an inner origin. Zion's inviolability had precedent in Isa 37. Scholars such as Crenshaw and Overholser stress how hard it was, at the time, to tell true prophecy from false.
in v17
Should the opening be read 'to those who despise me, "YHWH has spoken"' or 'to those who despise the word of YHWH'?
-
Keep the standard Hebrew reading: 'despise me' plus the quotation formula 'YHWH has spoken.'
It is the received Hebrew vocalisation and is supported by the Vulgate. It fits the context, where false prophets claim divine speech (23:16, 'not from the mouth of YHWH'; 23:31, 'they say, "He declares"'). The first-person 'me' matches God speaking throughout 23:16–40. It is also arguably the harder reading, which copyists would be less likely to invent.
-
Follow the Septuagint: 'those who despise the word of YHWH.'
The Greek translators read the same consonants as a single phrase. That gives a smoother sentence without the abrupt switch from 'me' to 'YHWH' in the third person. 'Despising YHWH's word' also fits Jeremiah's theme of rejecting the prophetic word. NRSV and ESV adopt it.
in v18
Is 'who?' aimed only at the false prophets, or does it mean no human being can stand in YHWH's council?
-
It targets the peace-prophets: none of *them* has stood there, though a true prophet like Jeremiah has.
Verse 22 assumes the council is open to true prophets ('if they had stood in my council, they would have proclaimed my words'). Jeremiah is promised he will 'stand before' YHWH (15:19), and Amos 3:7 and 1 Kgs 22 show prophets with access. BSB, NIV and ESV build this reading in with 'of them / among them'.
-
It is a wisdom-style question meaning no mortal at all has access to God's council, perhaps a later scribal comment.
Similar questions expect a universal 'no one': Job 15:8 ('Have you listened in the council of God?'), Isa 40:13–14, Prov 30:4. On this reading v. 18 is in tension with v. 22, which is why some commentators (e.g., McKane, Carroll) treat it as a secondary insertion.
in v18
Does the final shamaʿ mean 'heard' or 'obeyed'?
-
'Heard', meaning actually received the message.
It parallels 'see and hear his word' in the first half, and the whole verse is about access to the council and receiving its message (vv. 16, 21–22).
-
'Obeyed', meaning heeded and acted on it.
Shamaʿ often means obey, and v. 22 links true prophecy with turning people from evil. BSB takes this line.
in v19
Do verses 19–20 belong here, or were they copied in from 30:23–24?
-
They are secondary here, inserted from ch. 30 (or both are drawn from a common stock of sayings).
Verses 19–20 interrupt the flow from v.18 to v.21, which reads smoothly ('Who has stood in the council?... I did not send these prophets'). An identical doublet elsewhere suggests an editor placed them. This view is held by several critical commentators (e.g. McKane, Holladay, with variations).
-
They are in place, as the actual content of the council word.
Verse 18 asks who has heard Yahweh's word in the council. Verses 19–20 then give that word: a storm, not peace. This answers the false prophets' 'no harm will come upon you' (v.17) by reusing their own preposition 'upon'. Reuse of oracles is typical of Jeremiah (e.g. Lundbom).
in v19
What does the final verb yachul mean?
-
'Whirl / swirl down'.
It is the same root as mitcholel earlier in the line, so it continues the storm's motion and creates deliberate sound-play (BSB, NASB, NIV).
-
'Burst / fall heavily'.
A looser contextual rendering of the storm's impact (ESV, WEB, Vulgate erumpens).
-
'Writhe / cause pain' or 'endure, remain'.
The root has a well-attested sense of writhing in pain (KJV 'grievously'), and a separate sense 'be firm, last' (Job 20:21; Ps 10:5), followed by YLT's 'stayeth'.
in v19
Who are 'the guilty' (resha'im)?
-
Mainly the false prophets.
The whole section 23:9–40 is directed against the prophets, and v.11 calls prophet and priest godless.
-
The prophets together with the people who followed them.
Verse 17 has the prophets speaking to 'everyone who walks in the stubbornness of his heart', and the parallel in 30:23–24 has a wider horizon of judgment on the nation.
in v20
Does 'acharit hayyamim' here point to the end of history or simply to 'afterwards'?
-
Relative sense: 'later on, after these events,' i.e. after the judgment on Judah.
The immediate context is the dispute with the false prophets (vv.17–22). Gen 49:1, Num 24:14 and Deut 31:29 use the phrase for the future of a nation within history. Deut 32:29 links understanding to one's 'latter end.' Most critical commentaries (e.g. Holladay, Lundbom, McKane) and the lexicons (HALOT, TDOT) take this view.
-
A future turning point with a wider, end-of-the-age horizon.
In the doublet at 30:24 the same lines lead into promises of restoration (30:18–31:40). Isa 2:2, Mic 4:1 and Hos 3:5 use the phrase for a decisive future turning. Later Jewish readers, as at Qumran, heard it as end-time language. Some interpreters therefore see the line opening toward a more distant fulfilment, especially in its ch. 30 setting.
in v20
Which setting of the doublet is original, 23:19–20 or 30:23–24?
-
Original in ch. 23, and reused in ch. 30.
It fits tightly between v.18 (the council of the LORD) and vv.21–22 (prophets not sent). Many read it as the very message the false prophets failed to hear.
-
Original in ch. 30, or an independent saying placed in both.
Some scholars see vv.19–20 as interrupting the flow from v.18 to v.21. On this view it was inserted into ch. 23 from a collection of oracles, and the shorter 30:24 (without binah) supports the idea that the ch. 23 form was expanded.
in v21
Were these prophets conscious frauds, or sincere but self-deceived?
-
Sincere but self-deceived: they mistook their own hopes and the nation's assumptions for revelation.
Jeremiah says they speak 'a vision of their own heart' (v. 16) and 'the deceit of their own heart' (v. 26). Their message drew on genuine earlier traditions of Zion's inviolability (compare Isaiah's assurances in 701 BCE, Isa 37:33–35).
-
Knowingly deceptive or at least culpably careless.
'They steal my words from one another' (v. 30); they 'use their tongues' to say 'declares the LORD' (v. 31); they 'strengthen the hands of evildoers' (v. 14); Micah 3:5, 11 links prophetic oracles to payment.
-
The text does not decide motive; its criterion is commission and content, not inner sincerity.
Verse 21 judges by what God did or did not do (send, speak), and v. 22 by the fruit (turning people from evil). Scholars such as J. L. Crenshaw (*Prophetic Conflict*) stress that listeners at the time had no reliable outside test for motive.
in v21
How could hearers tell a sent prophet from an unsent one?
-
By fulfillment.
Deut 18:21–22; Jeremiah himself applies it in 28:9 ('when the word of that prophet comes to pass').
-
By moral content and its effect: a true word confronts sin and calls for repentance.
Jer 23:14, 17, 22; Jer 28:8 (true prophets have historically prophesied war and disaster); Mic 3:5–8.
-
By access to the divine council, which only God can confirm, so the matter is finally left to God.
Jer 23:18, 22; 1 Kgs 22:19–23. Some scholars note that this criterion could not be checked at the time, which is why Jeremiah's conflict with Hananiah ends in a standoff until God acts (Jer 28:10–17).
in v22
Does *sod* here mean God's heavenly assembly or a more personal 'confidence' with God?
-
The heavenly council: the prophet is pictured as standing among God's attendants at the throne.
'Stand' is the posture of courtiers (1 Kgs 22:19). There are close parallels in 1 Kgs 22, Isa 6, Job 15:8 and Ps 89:7, and the council language of 23:18 ('see and hear his word'). This is the majority view in modern commentaries (e.g. Holladay, Lundbom) and in divine-council studies (e.g. E. T. Mullen).
-
Intimate confidence: *sod* stresses private, trusted friendship with God rather than an assembly scene.
*Sod* often means a confidential circle or secret (Ps 25:14; Prov 11:13; Amos 3:7). The Septuagint did not render it as 'assembly'. The two views overlap, because in the ancient world the king's council *was* the circle of his confidants.
in v22
Is the condition contrary to fact ('if they had…') or a present challenge ('if they have…, let them…')?
-
Contrary to fact: they did not stand in the council, and the absence of repentance proves it.
It follows directly on v. 21 ('I did not send… I did not speak to them'). Nearly all modern translations read it this way.
-
A present test or challenge: if they truly have stood there, let them prove it by making the people hear and turn.
The verb forms are not marked as unreal, and the YLT renders them in the present. In this reading the verse works as an open criterion, much like Deut 18:21–22 and Jer 28:8–9.
in v22
Is 'turning people from evil' the test of a true prophet, or one sign among others?
-
The decisive test in this passage: the fruit of the message shows where it came from.
It contrasts directly with 23:14 ('so that no one turns from his evil') and 23:17 (the message of peace). Jer 28:8–9 also treats warning prophecy as the normal pattern.
-
One test among several: Deuteronomy also uses fulfilment (18:22) and loyalty to YHWH alone (13:1–5).
Jeremiah himself uses fulfilment as a test for prophecies of peace (28:9). Within 23:9–40, the issues of source (dreams, stolen words) and effect (encouraging evildoers) work together.
in v23
What is the thrust of the contrast between "near" and "far"?
-
Transcendence over a domesticated deity (majority reading). God is not just a local, manageable god but the far-reaching one who sees all.
The question form of the Hebrew; the immediate explanation in v. 24 (no hiding, God fills heaven and earth); the context of prophets who presume on God's presence (v. 17-18, 22); ancient Near Eastern ideas of gods with local domains (1 Kgs 20:23, 28).
-
God is both near and far. The verse affirms nearness and distance together rather than downgrading nearness.
The "only" that many translations infer allows nearness to stand; elsewhere the Bible affirms God's nearness (Ps 145:18). Some versions (e.g. NLT) render it as both at once.
-
Nearness itself is the point (the Septuagint's reading). God draws near and is not remote.
The Septuagint's statement form. But it fits v. 24 less well and does not represent the Hebrew text.
in v23
Is "near / far" about space or about time?
-
Spatial: a God of close range against a God of far range.
V. 24 is spatial (hiding places, heaven and earth); "from afar" in the sense of seeing or knowing from a distance (Ps 139:2; 138:6).
-
Possibly temporal as well: "a God of recent date" against "a God of long ago", i.e. not a newcomer god but the ancient one.
Mi-qqarov means "recently" in Deut 32:17 ("new gods who came lately"), and me-rachoq means "long ago" in 2 Kgs 19:25 / Isa 37:26. Some commentators note this as a secondary resonance, but the spatial sense of v. 24 makes it at most a minor overtone.
in v24
How does verse 23 ("Am I a God near at hand and not a God far off?") set up verse 24?
-
Hebrew text, read as a rhetorical question expecting "No": God is not only near but also far, beyond Zion and beyond control. The false prophets assumed a cosy local deity who would not look closely. Verse 24 follows from this: from "far off" he still sees every hiding place.
The Hebrew question marker in v. 23; the parallel in Ps 139:2 ("you discern my thoughts from afar"); 1 Kgs 8:27; the chapter's attack on Zion-centred assurances of peace (23:17). Most modern commentators (e.g. Holladay, Lundbom) take a version of this view.
-
Septuagint, read as a statement: "I am a God near at hand, not a God far off." God is close by, so he overhears the prophets, which leads into "I have heard" (v. 25).
The Greek translation of v. 23. Some scholars think it reflects a different Hebrew text or an interpretive smoothing. Its "nearness" also fits Deut 4:7 ("a god so near").
-
Either way, the conclusion is the same: whether God is stressed as near or as far, verse 24 says no one escapes his sight. The real difference is only which misconception of God is being attacked.
Verse 24's two questions work under both readings, because filling heaven and earth includes both near and far.
in v24
Is "I fill heaven and earth" mainly about God's presence or about his knowledge and rule?
-
Presence: the verse asserts that God is not spatially limited, in temple-filling language extended to the cosmos.
The verb *mālēʾ* is used for the glory or cloud filling the tabernacle and temple (Exod 40:34; 1 Kgs 8:10–11). Compare Ps 139:7–10 ("Where can I flee from your presence?").
-
Knowledge and jurisdiction: the point is that no place lies outside God's sight and authority as judge, rather than a claim about how God's being relates to space.
The first question is about *seeing*. Verse 25 continues with *hearing*. The parallels (Amos 9:2–4; Job 34:21–22; Isa 29:15) are all about escaping judgment. Ancient Near Eastern ideas of the all-seeing judge point the same way.
-
Both together: in Hebrew thought, being present and seeing or judging were not separate categories. Where God fills, God sees and rules.
Isa 66:1–2 (heaven my throne, earth my footstool, and "to this one I will look") joins cosmic presence and attentive sight.
in v25
Does Jeremiah reject dreams as a way of receiving revelation, or only these prophets' dreams?
-
Jeremiah ranks dreams below the direct word and treats them with suspicion as such.
V. 28 contrasts 'the prophet who has a dream' with 'the one who has my word,' adding 'what has straw to do with wheat?' Jeremiah never claims dreams for himself; his own calling comes through the word and through standing in God's council (vv. 18, 22). He groups dreamers with diviners and sorcerers in 27:9 and 29:8.
-
The problem is where these dreams come from and what they say, not dreams in themselves.
V. 26 traces the dreams to 'the deceit of their own heart.' V. 28 still allows the dreamer to 'tell the dream.' Elsewhere scripture affirms dreams as revelation (Num 12:6; Joel 2:28; Joseph; Daniel), and Deut 13 tests dreamers by what they lead people to. The content here, peace to the unrepentant, is what shows them to be false.
in v25
Is the doubled 'I dreamed, I dreamed!' the prophets' own words or Jeremiah's caricature?
-
It faithfully reports their emphatic way of announcing a revelation.
Hebrew often repeats a word for emphasis or urgency, and the quotation is introduced as what they actually 'said.'
-
It is a deliberately mocking imitation of a stock catchphrase.
The surrounding oracle is full of sarcasm and wordplay (for example the pun on massaʾ, 'burden/oracle,' in vv. 33–40), and the bare repetition with no content reported sounds like a parody of empty claims.
in v26
What is the subject of 'Is there…?' (hăyēš), and how should the sentence be built?
-
Supply a demonstrative or noun: 'How long will this / lies be in the heart of the prophets?'
Jerome's Vulgate supplies 'this' (istud), followed by KJV, WEB and BSB. The ESV supplies 'lies', drawing on sheqer in the same line. The Septuagint also supplies an indefinite subject ('it will be'). This gives a smooth sense that fits the context.
-
Keep the broken question: 'How long? Is there [anything] in the heart of the prophets…?', a rhetorical question suggesting there is nothing real in them, or nothing from God.
This takes the Masoretic punctuation seriously: the major pause marks set 'Until when?' apart. NASB follows this. Yēš can stand alone meaning 'there is [something]'. It fits Jeremiah's habit of short, broken outbursts.
-
The question continues into v. 27: 'Is it in the heart of the prophets… who plan to make my people forget my name?', meaning 'Do they really intend this?'
The participle with the article at the start of v. 27 (haḥōšəbîm, 'those who plan / think') can be read as describing the prophets of v. 26, so that v. 27 completes the thought. YLT's punctuation points this way. It explains the missing subject without changing the text.
-
Emend the consonants, for example to a verb meaning 'turn' or 'continue'.
Some critical commentators propose this because the Masoretic syntax is so hard. No manuscript or ancient version supports it, so most recent translations do not adopt it.
in v26
Is 'the tarmit of their heart' self-deception or deliberate deceit?
-
Self-deception or delusion: they sincerely believe their dreams.
BSB and NIV say 'delusion(s)'. In v. 25 they report dreams they appear to believe they had. The Septuagint's 'wishes of their heart' suggests wishful thinking.
-
Deliberate deceit of others.
The root רמה means 'to deceive, betray' (e.g. Gen 29:25; Josh 9:22). Zeph 3:13 uses 'a tongue of tarmit' for speech that misleads others. Verse 30 charges these prophets with 'stealing my words' from one another, which implies conscious fraud. The Vulgate says seductiones.
-
Both: a deceit that starts inside them and is then passed on.
'Of their heart' names where the deceit comes from, not who its victim is. Jeremiah 17:9 calls the lēb itself deceitful (using a different root), so self-deception and misleading others are not exclusive in Jeremiah's thought.
in v27
Did the prophets deliberately aim to make Israel forget YHWH, or is God describing the effect of what they did?
-
Deliberate intent: they are actively scheming.
The verb ḥāshav with 'to' plus a verb normally means 'plan/intend to', and in Jeremiah it describes hostile plots (11:19; 18:18). YLT, WEB, NASB and the Vulgate ('volunt') read it this way.
-
God's sharp description of the result, not their conscious goal.
These prophets claimed to speak for YHWH (23:25) and would hardly have said they wanted his name forgotten. The verb can also mean 'reckon, think'. Commentators such as Holladay and Thompson note that the language exposes the real direction of their work. KJV/ESV 'think' and BSB 'suppose' lean this way.
in v27
What does the preposition in 'ba-bbāʿal' mean: 'by means of Baal', 'because of Baal', or 'in exchange for Baal'?
-
By means of, or through: the Baal cult was the means of forgetting.
It matches 'by their dreams' (ba-ḥălômōtām) earlier in the verse, which is plainly the means. Compare 23:13, 'they prophesied by Baal.' BSB and NIV take this view.
-
In exchange for: they traded YHWH's name for Baal.
The Hebrew preposition can express price or exchange. Jer 2:11 ('my people have exchanged their glory for what does not profit') supports the idea of a swap. KJV/ESV 'for Baal' leaves this open.
-
Because of.
A common use of the preposition. NASB, WEB and the Vulgate ('propter') take it this way.
in v27
Who is 'his neighbor' to whom the dreams are told?
-
Fellow prophets swapping dreams among themselves.
In v. 30 the prophets 'steal my words each from his neighbor', which suggests a closed circle sharing and recycling material.
-
Anyone the dream is told to, so the message spreads through the population.
'Each to his neighbor' is a general idiom, and the verse is about the effect on 'my people' as a whole.
in v28
Is the verse rejecting dreams as a way God speaks, or only dreams passed off as God's word?
-
Dreams themselves are being set below the word, or ruled out as a basis for prophecy.
Jeremiah never reports a dream of his own. The surrounding verses mock the cry "I have dreamed!" (23:25) and link dreams to "the deceit of their own hearts" (23:26). Jer 27:9 and 29:8 group dreamers with diviners and sorcerers. Some scholars (e.g., Holladay, McKane) see Jeremiah as distrusting the dream as a medium altogether.
-
The issue is the source and the labeling, not the medium.
Elsewhere the Hebrew Bible accepts dreams from God (Num 12:6; Gen 37, 40–41; 1 Kgs 3; Dan 2). The verse lets the dreamer tell his dream, only as "a dream." The charge throughout the chapter is that these prophets were not sent and had not stood in God's council (23:18, 21–22). That points to who sent the message, not how it arrived.
-
"Let him tell a dream" is sarcastic.
Some read the permission ironically ("go ahead, tell your little dream"), given the scornful tone of vv. 25–27. Others take it as a sincere concession. The Hebrew allows both, and the tone has to be judged from context.
in v29
What does the small word kōh (“thus”) do in the verse?
-
Emphasis: “Is not my word just so, like fire?”
kōh can strengthen a comparison. The Masoretic Text is stable, and most translations treat it as adding force without a separate word.
-
A separate question: “Is it not thus?”
YLT and a few commentators read it as its own clause that sums up v. 28.
-
A scribal error to be deleted or changed
The Septuagint and Vulgate have nothing for it, and it is unusual in this position.
in v29
What is the “rock” that the word shatters?
-
The hardened resistance of the people
Jeremiah repeatedly describes Judah as stubborn and hard (5:3: “their faces harder than rock”). In 5:14 the word-fire consumes the people.
-
The false prophets and their message
The immediate context (vv. 28, 30–32) is the contest with the false prophets, and v. 30 turns straight to “I am against the prophets.”
-
Any opposition at all; the image is general
The verb describes what a hammer typically does, which suggests a general statement of the word's irresistible power rather than one specific target.
in v30
Whose words are being stolen: real oracles of God or the false prophets' own material?
-
They plagiarise each other's invented oracles and dreams and then label them as God's words. 'My words' is ironic or means 'what they present as my words'.
The immediate context is about dreams the prophets 'tell each to his fellow' (v. 27) and the 'deceit of their own heart' (v. 26). Verse 31 accuses them of using their own tongues and attaching God's formula. BSB, NIV and NLT translate this way.
-
They take genuine words of God spoken by true prophets (Jeremiah, or earlier prophets such as Isaiah on Zion's safety) and reuse them out of context as if they had received them.
The Hebrew says plainly 'my words', and Yahweh's words elsewhere are his real messages. Older prophecies of Zion's protection (Isa 37:33–35) may have been recycled as timeless guarantees. Some commentators (e.g. those following Calvin and later Holladay's discussion) allow for this.
-
The point is the second-hand character itself: whatever the original source, a word received from a colleague is not a word received from God.
Jeremiah's test of a prophet is direct access to Yahweh's council (23:18, 22). The Hebrew leaves the ambiguity open, which suggests that the source matters less than the method.
in v31
What does "taking their tongue" mean?
-
They speak from their own resources: their own tongue instead of God's word.
This is the ordinary meaning of lāqaḥ ("take") with a possessive. It fits the immediate context: v.16 "a vision of their own heart, not from the mouth of Yahweh," v.30 stealing words, v.32 invented dreams. Most modern commentators (e.g. Holladay, Lundbom) take this view.
-
They make their tongue smooth or persuasive.
Based on the related noun leqaḥ, "persuasive speech" (Prov 7:21), and the parallel idea in Ps 5:9. This view is reflected in YLT and NLT. Some scholars have suggested emending the text to a form of ḥālaq, "make smooth," but no Hebrew manuscript reads that.
-
They "take up" speech the way one takes up an oracle, presuming to speak with authority.
This reads lāqaḥ as roughly parallel to nāśāʾ, "lift up" a saying or burden (cf. the "burden" wordplay in 23:33–40). It is less widely held and has no direct parallel.
in v31
Do vv.30–32 describe three different groups of prophets or one group seen three ways?
-
Three types: plagiarists, self-inspired speakers, dream-mongers.
Each verse has its own "here I am against" and its own distinct charge.
-
One group, with three overlapping descriptions of the same practice.
The whole unit 23:9–40 targets the same "prophets of Jerusalem" (23:14–15), and the three charges belong together: stolen words, self-made words and invented dreams are all ways of speaking without being sent (v.32).
in v32
Does Jeremiah reject dreams as a way of receiving revelation, or only these particular dreams?
-
Dreams as such are ranked below the word: Jeremiah sets "dream" against "my word" as straw against wheat.
Jer 23:25–28 repeatedly contrasts dream with word; 27:9 and 29:8 group dreamers with diviners. Jeremiah himself never reports receiving revelation by dream (31:26 is debated). Some commentators (e.g. Carroll, McKane) read the chapter as moving away from dream-revelation.
-
Only these dreams are condemned, because they are deceptive and uncommissioned. Dreams remain a legitimate channel.
Num 12:6 and Joel 2:28 affirm dreams. Jer 23:28 lets the dreamer "tell the dream" as long as it is not passed off as the word. Here the qualifier is "dreams of šeqer", and the stated fault is that Yahweh "did not send them". The test in Deut 13 and 18 is about source and content, not medium.
in v32
Were the false prophets sincere dreamers or deliberate frauds?
-
They genuinely dreamed and believed what they said, but their dreams came from their own hopes, not from Yahweh.
v. 16 "a vision of their own heart"; v. 26 "the deceit (tarmît) of their own heart". This describes self-deception as much as calculated lying. Ancient dream practice was widespread and taken sincerely.
-
They knowingly invented or embroidered oracles for popularity or royal favour.
v. 30 "steal my words from one another"; v. 31 "take their tongues and declare 'utterance'"; the charge of šeqer and paḥăzût (insolent recklessness); Jer 29:23 accuses Ahab and Zedekiah of adultery and lies. Many interpreters see a mix: borrowed formulas, real wishes, careless speech.
in v33
Does the reply read "What burden?" (standard Hebrew) or "You are the burden" (Greek/Latin)?
-
Original text was "You are the burden" (ʾattem hammassaʾ).
Supported by the Septuagint and Vulgate. It removes the odd object marker before 'what', and it states the pun directly, which fits the logic of 'and I will cast you off'. Many commentators (e.g. Bright, Holladay, Lundbom) and the ESV/NRSV adopt it.
-
The standard Hebrew "What burden?!" should be kept.
It is the harder reading, and scribes tend to smooth hard readings rather than create them. Its tone of scornful repetition is plausible, and the object marker can be explained as marking the quoted phrase. Followed by KJV, BSB, NIV, NASB.
in v33
Is massaʾ 'oracle' a separate word from massaʾ 'load', or one word with two senses?
-
Two separate words (homonyms).
BDB and HALOT list them separately; 'oracle' is derived from 'lifting up' the voice (nasaʾ qol).
-
One word: the oracle is a 'load' laid on the prophet or on the nation addressed.
Many oracle headings introduce threats; this passage treats the two senses as one for the sake of the pun. Some genre studies (e.g. R. Weis) argue massaʾ names a type of prophecy that explains how God is acting in events. On any view, Jeremiah 23:33 depends on hearers sensing both meanings.
in v34
Is maśśāʾ 'oracle' the same word as maśśāʾ 'load,' or two separate words that happen to sound alike?
-
Two separate words. 'Oracle' comes from 'lifting up the voice' (nāśāʾ qôl), so it means a raised, solemn utterance with no built-in sense of weight.
BDB and HALOT list them separately. Maśśāʾ headings include oracles of hope as well as doom (e.g. Zech 12:1 begins an oracle that turns to rescue). The idiom nāśāʾ qôl is well attested.
-
One word. A prophetic maśśāʾ is a 'load' or 'imposition,' either the word God lays on the prophet or the heavy judgment laid on its target.
Both senses share the same root and form. P.A.H. de Boer argued for 'burden imposed.' Jeremiah 23:33–40 treats the two senses as interchangeable, which suggests hearers felt them as one word.
-
Either way, Jeremiah 23 plays on the sound and both senses.
Whatever the history of the word, vv. 33 and 36 only work if hearers could hear 'load' in the prophetic formula.
in v34
Why is the phrase banned, and are vv. 34–40 Jeremiah's own words?
-
An authentic saying of Jeremiah aimed at the Jerusalem prophets and people who used the formula to claim authority or to mock him.
It fits the section's charges against prophets who 'steal my words' and speak unsent (23:30–32). Jeremiah clashes with named prophets in chs. 28–29. Holladay and Lundbom take a basically Jeremian core.
-
Verse 33 is the original saying (an oracle on the pun). Verses 34–40 are a later expansion written in the style of an interpretive commentary, perhaps reflecting a later distrust of anyone claiming new prophetic oracles.
The repetitive, legal style differs from v. 33. McKane and Carroll see layers of later commentary. Zechariah 13:2–6 shows a later period hostile to prophetic claims.
in v36
What does 'the massa will be to each man his word' mean?
-
Each man's own word becomes his 'oracle': people pass off their own ideas as divine pronouncements.
This fits the context of prophets 'speaking a vision of their own heart' (23:16) and 'stealing my words from one another' (23:30). ESV and WEB read it this way.
-
Each man's word will become a 'burden' on him, a weight of judgment he must carry.
This fits the load pun in v. 33 ('you are the burden') and v. 39 (God will lift and cast them off). KJV ('his burden') and the Vulgate read it this way.
-
The phrase is deliberately ambiguous and means both.
The whole unit, vv. 33–40, is built on the double meaning of massa, and the Hebrew does not force a choice.
in v36
Is massa 'oracle' the same word as massa 'load'?
-
Two different words that happen to look alike (homonyms).
Standard lexicons (HALOT, BDB) list two entries. The oracle sense may come from 'lifting up' the voice (nasa qol).
-
One word: an oracle is a 'load' the prophet is given to carry or deliver.
Older interpreters and the Vulgate took it this way (onus), and judgment oracles are often 'heavy'.
-
Whatever the origin, Jeremiah 23 exploits both senses.
The pun only works if hearers knew both meanings, whether or not they were historically one word.
in v36
Do verses 34–40 come from Jeremiah himself or from later expansion?
-
Later prose expansion reflecting on the term massa.
The style is repetitive prose. The Greek text is shorter. Commentators such as McKane and Carroll point to these features.
-
At least the core (v. 33 and the pun) goes back to Jeremiah, with later elaboration.
Holladay and others argue that the wordplay fits Jeremiah's known style and his conflict with prophets of peace.
in v36
Does the final clause state a result ('so that you pervert') or a past fact ('you have perverted')?
-
Result or consequence: using the phrase this way ends up overturning God's words.
This is the usual force of this Hebrew verb construction (perfect with 'and'). BSB has 'so that'.
-
A statement of what they have done.
KJV and WEB ('ye have perverted'), reading the clause as an accusation that supports the ban.
in v39
Should the first verb be read 'forget' (MT) or 'lift up' (ancient versions)?
-
Read 'lift up' (nasa').
The infinitive is spelled with aleph like nasa'. The Vulgate, the Syriac and some Hebrew manuscripts support it. It completes the massa' ('burden') pun of vv.33–38, in which God treats the people as the load he throws off. RSV, NRSV and ESV follow it.
-
Keep 'forget' (nashah), as in the MT.
It is the received pointing. Retributive 'forgetting' fits Jeremiah's charge that the people forgot God (2:32; 13:25) and parallels Hos 4:6. It also sets up the irony of v.40, where their shame 'will not be forgotten'. KJV, NIV, NASB and BSB follow it.
-
Both sounds are meant at once.
The text mixes the two roots (finite verb pointed 'forget', infinitive spelled 'lift'). In unpointed writing the forms are nearly identical, and Hebrew prophets often exploit near-homophones (e.g. Jer 1:11–12, shaqed/shoqed).
in v39
Why was the phrase 'the burden of the LORD' banned?
-
It was used mockingly against Jeremiah.
v.33 pictures people asking 'What is the burden of the LORD?' Jeremiah's opponents mocked his words elsewhere (Jer 17:15; 20:7–8).
-
Rival prophets used it to claim authority for their own messages.
v.36 says 'every man's own word becomes his burden', and the wider chapter (23:16, 21, 25–32) attacks prophets who speak their own visions.
in v40
Is the prose section 23:34–40, which ends with this verse, Jeremiah's own oracle or a later expansion?
-
A later scribal expansion that comments on v. 33 and in effect bans the expression "burden of the LORD".
The shift from the punchy wordplay of v. 33 to repetitive prose, the legal-sounding ban on a phrase (vv. 34–38), and the stock language of the conclusion (cf. 20:11; 24:9). Argued in different forms by commentators such as McKane and Carroll.
-
Substantially Jeremianic, or a faithful development of his own wordplay.
Continuity with Jeremiah's clash with the prophets in 23:9–32, the deliberate reuse of 20:11 in v. 40, and the tight massa/nasa' wordplay throughout. Holladay and Lundbom, among others, give more weight to Jeremiah's own voice, though with differing reconstructions.
in v40
In v. 39, does God say he will "forget" the people or "lift" them, and how does this shape v. 40?
-
"Forget" (MT root nashah).
The consonantal Hebrew text as transmitted. It sets up a deliberate contrast with v. 40's "will not be forgotten" and with Jeremiah's theme of Israel forgetting God.
-
"Lift" (nasa'), as in some Hebrew manuscripts and the ancient versions.
The infinitive nasho' is spelled like nasa'. The Septuagint, Syriac and Vulgate support "lift". It continues the massa ("burden") pun that runs through vv. 33–39.
Sources
- BDB s.v. הָבַל, הֶבֶל
- HALOT s.v. הבל (Hiphil 'to fill with vain hopes')
- HALOT s.v. לֵב / לֵבָב
- HALOT s.v. חָזוֹן
- W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia)
- J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 21–36 (Anchor Bible)
- W. McKane, Jeremiah 1–25 (ICC)
- J. A. Thompson, The Book of Jeremiah (NICOT)
- M. Nissinen, Prophets and Prophecy in the Ancient Near East (SBL Writings from the Ancient World)
- J. L. Crenshaw, Prophetic Conflict
- Rahlfs/Ziegler, Septuagint Jeremias 23:16
- Biblia Sacra Vulgata, Jeremias 23:16
- BDB s.v. נָאַץ, שְׁרִירוּת, רָעָה, שָׁלוֹם
- HALOT s.v. שְׁרִירוּת; נאץ
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Jeremiah 23:17
- Vulgate Jeremiah 23:17
- William L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia), on 23:16–22
- J. A. Thompson, The Book of Jeremiah (NICOT), on 23:17
- Jack R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 21–36 (Anchor Bible), on 23:17
- David Kimhi (Radak) on Jeremiah 3:17 / 23:17 (etymology of sherirut)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, Jeremiah 23
- HALOT s.v. סוֹד
- BDB s.v. סוֹד, קָשַׁב, עָמַד
- W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia), on 23:16–22
- R. P. Carroll, Jeremiah (OTL)
- H. W. Robinson, 'The Council of Yahweh', JTS 45 (1944)
- F. M. Cross, 'The Council of Yahweh in Second Isaiah', JNES 12 (1953)
- E. C. Kingsbury, 'The Prophets and the Council of Yahweh', JBL 83 (1964)
- E. T. Mullen, The Divine Council in Canaanite and Early Hebrew Literature (1980)
- Masoretic Ketiv/Qere note at Jer 23:18 (BHS apparatus)
- BDB s.v. חוּל, סַעַר, חֵמָה, רָשָׁע
- HALOT s.v. סְעָרָה, חֵמָה, חוּל I
- W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia), on 23:9–40
- W. McKane, Jeremiah 1–25 (ICC), on 23:19–20
- J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 21–36 (Anchor Bible), on 23:19–20 and 30:23–24
- Rahlfs-Hanhart, Septuaginta, Ieremias 23:19
- Biblia Sacra Vulgata (Weber-Gryson), Hieremias 23:19
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jer 23 (divine council; storm-god imagery)
- BDB s.v. אַף, מְזִמָּה, אַחֲרִית, בִּין
- HALOT s.v. מְזִמָּה; s.v. אַחֲרִית
- TDOT s.v. 'acharit' (H. Seebass)
- W. McKane, Jeremiah (ICC), vol. 1
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Jeremiah 23:20
- Vulgate, Jeremiah 23:20
- HALOT s.v. שׁלח, רוץ, נבא, נָבִיא
- BDB s.v. רוּץ (ptc. 'runners, couriers'), שָׁלַח, נָבָא
- J. L. Crenshaw, Prophetic Conflict: Its Effect upon Israelite Religion (1971)
- Lachish Ostracon 3 (c. 589 BCE)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jer 23
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Jer 23:21; Vulgate Jer 23:21
- BDB s.v. סוֹד, עָמַד, שׁוּב (Hiphil), שָׁמַע (Hiphil), רֹעַ, מַעֲלָל
- J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 21–36 (Anchor Bible), on 23:18–22
- E. T. Mullen, The Divine Council in Canaanite and Early Hebrew Literature
- Septuagint Jeremiah 23:18, 22 (ὑπόστημα / ὑπόστασις)
- Vulgate Jeremiah 23:22 (consilium)
- Supplied OSHB-style morphology and BSB/KJV/WEB/YLT texts
- BDB s.v. קָרוֹב, רָחוֹק, נְאֻם
- HALOT s.v. קָרוֹב, רָחוֹק, נְאֻם
- Septuagint, Jeremiah 23:23 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate, Jeremiah 23:23
- BDB s.v. סָתַר, מִסְתָּר, מָלֵא, נְאֻם
- HALOT s.v. סתר, מִסְתָּר, מלא, נְאֻם
- W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia), on 23:23–24
- J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 21–36 (Anchor Bible), on 23:23–24
- W. McKane, Jeremiah 1–25 (ICC), on 23:23–24
- Septuagint Jeremiah 23:23–24 (Göttingen ed., J. Ziegler)
- Vulgate Jeremiah 23:24
- Wisdom of Solomon 1:7–9
- BDB s.v. שֶׁקֶר, חָלַם, נָבָא
- HALOT s.v. שֶׁקֶר, חֲלוֹם/חָלַם
- Thomas W. Overholt, The Threat of Falsehood: A Study in the Theology of the Book of Jeremiah (1970)
- William L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia)
- Jack R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 21–36 (Anchor Bible)
- A. Leo Oppenheim, The Interpretation of Dreams in the Ancient Near East (1956)
- Martti Nissinen, Prophets and Prophecy in the Ancient Near East (Mari dream reports)
- Jean-Marie Husser, Dreams and Dream Narratives in the Biblical World
- BDB s.v. שֶׁקֶר; תַּרְמִית; לֵב
- HALOT s.v. שֶׁקֶר; תַּרְמִית; יֵשׁ
- Masoretic Text (Leningrad Codex) with supplied morphology
- Septuagint, Jeremiah 23:26 and 14:14
- Vulgate, Jeremiah 23:26
- Deuteronomy 13:1–5; 18:20–22 (laws on prophets and dreamers)
- Mari prophetic and dream letters (as background on ancient Near Eastern court prophecy)
- Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia); Lundbom, Jeremiah 21–36 (Anchor Bible): discussions of the syntax of 23:26–27
- BDB and HALOT s.v. חָשַׁב, שָׁכַח, שֵׁם, חֲלוֹם, סָפַר, בַּעַל
- W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia), on 23:23–32
- A. L. Oppenheim, The Interpretation of Dreams in the Ancient Near East (1956)
- Mari prophetic letters (ARM 26) on dreams as divine messages
- Vulgate, Jeremiah 23:27
- BDB s.v. חֲלוֹם, תֶּבֶן, בַּר, אֱמֶת
- HALOT s.v. תֶּבֶן; בַּר I; אֱמֶת
- W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia), on 23:25–32
- Vulgate, Jer 23:28
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Jer 23:28
- BDB s.v. דָּבָר, אֵשׁ, פַּטִּישׁ, פָּצַץ, סֶלַע, נְאֻם
- HALOT s.v. פַּטִּישׁ; פָּצַץ
- Septuagint, Jeremiah 23:29
- Vulgate, Jeremiah 23:29
- Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 34a; Shabbat 88b
- Lachish Ostraca (letters 3, 16)
- BDB and HALOT s.v. גנב (Piel)
- HALOT s.v. נְאֻם
- HALOT s.v. רֵעַ
- William L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia), on 23:25–32
- Martti Nissinen, Prophets and Prophecy in the Ancient Near East (on group prophecy at Mari and in Assyria)
- BDB s.v. נְאֻם, נָאַם
- HALOT s.v. נאם, נְאֻם
- BDB s.v. לָקַח; לֶקַח
- W. McKane, Jeremiah I–XXV (ICC)
- P. Humbert, "Die Herausforderungsformel 'hinnenî êlêkâ'" (ZAW 1933)
- Rahlfs, Septuaginta, Jeremiah 23:31
- Vulgate, Jeremiah 23:31
- BDB s.v. פחז, פַּחֲזוּת; תָּעָה; יָעַל
- HALOT s.v. פַּחֲזוּת, פחז; שֶׁקֶר; תעה hiphil
- BDB s.v. מַשָּׂא I, II
- HALOT s.v. מַשָּׂא
- HALOT s.v. נטשׁ
- BDB s.v. נְאֻם
- Septuagint, Jeremiah 23:33 (ὑμεῖς ἐστε τὸ λῆμμα)
- Vulgate, Jeremiah 23:33 (vos estis onus)
- J. Bright, Jeremiah (Anchor Bible)
- R. D. Weis, 'Oracle', Anchor Bible Dictionary
- HALOT s.v. מַשָּׂא I, II
- HALOT s.v. פקד
- W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia), on 23:33–40
- W. McKane, Jeremiah 1–25 (ICC), on 23:33–40
- P. A. H. de Boer, 'An Inquiry into the Meaning of the Term Maśśāʾ,' OTS 5 (1948)
- M. H. Floyd, 'The Maśśāʾ as a Type of Prophetic Book,' JBL 121 (2002)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Jer 23:33–34
- Vulgate, Jer 23:33–34
- BDB s.v. מַשָּׂא
- HALOT s.v. הָפַךְ
- BDB s.v. זָכַר
- R. D. Weis, 'A Definition of the Genre Maśśā' in the Hebrew Bible' (diss., Claremont, 1986)
- E. Tov, The Text-Critical Use of the Septuagint / studies on the two editions of Jeremiah
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Jeremiah 23:36
- Vulgate, Jeremiah 23:36
- BDB s.v. נָשָׁה, נָשָׂא, מַשָּׂא, נָטַשׁ
- HALOT s.v. נשׁה I; נשׂא; נטשׁ
- STEPBible TAHOT morphological tagging (supplied source text)
- Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia apparatus at Jer 23:39
- Vulgate, Jer 23:39 ('tollam vos portans')
- BDB s.v. חֶרְפָּה, כְּלִמּוּת, עוֹלָם, שָׁכַח
- HALOT s.v. חֶרְפָּה; כְּלִמּוּת; עוֹלָם
- E. Jenni, "ʿōlām", in Theological Lexicon of the Old Testament (TLOT)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Jeremiah 23:39–40
- Vulgate, Jeremiah 23:39–40
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
3 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.