Luke Chapter 19 Read as one passage
Luke 19:39–44
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
39But some of the Pharisees in the crowd said to Him, “Teacher, rebuke Your disciples!” 40“I tell you,” He answered, “if they remain silent, the very stones will cry out.” 41As Jesus approached Jerusalem and saw the city, He wept over it 42and said, “If only you had known on this day what would bring you peace! But now it is hidden from your eyes. 43For the days will come upon you when your enemies will barricade you and surround you and hem you in on every side. 44They will level you to the ground—you and the children within your walls. They will not leave one stone on another, because you did not recognize the time of your visitation from God.”
What the first hearers heard
For Luke's readers the moment was full of meaning. Throughout the Gospel the Pharisees have been the main voice questioning Jesus. Here, in their last appearance in Luke, they try one final time to correct him, and they do it by asking him to silence the confession that he is king. They call him "Teacher" and treat his followers' praise as a discipline problem. The disciples, though, are giving the verdict the angels gave at his birth ("glory in the highest... peace," 2:14).
Readers would also notice the pattern from the healing of the blind beggar near Jericho (18:38–39). Others rebuked a man for crying out "Son of David," and Jesus honoured the cry. Now the same kind of rebuke is aimed at the whole procession, and Jesus again sides with the shouting. For a community that would itself be told to keep quiet about Jesus (Acts 4:17–20; 5:28–29), the scene showed that confessing him as king is not something an authority can shut down by appealing to order and respectability.
Readers who knew Jerusalem's history would also feel the danger. A crowd hailing a king at Passover could bring Roman swords. Luke leaves room for the Pharisees' worry to be political caution as well as religious objection. The immediate sequel is Jesus weeping because the city "did not know the things that make for peace" (19:42).
From the study of Luke 19:39.
Verse by verse
-
39But some of the Pharisees in the crowd said to Him, “Teacher, rebuke Your disciples!”
Full study →As Jesus rides down the Mount of Olives toward Jerusalem, the whole crowd of his followers is shouting a Passover pilgrim psalm (Psalm 118), with a pointed change: "Blessed is the King who comes in the name of the Lord!" At that point a few Pharisees who are there in the throng, not the whole party, speak up from the crowd. They address Jesus respectfully but carefully as "Teacher": the title for a rabbi, not the "King" the crowd has just proclaimed. Then they give him an order: "Rebuke your disciples!" That means tell them off sharply and make them stop.
Their request assumes that a teacher answers for his followers. These are your disciples, so their shouting is your responsibility, and you are able to silence them. Behind it may lie offence at a royal claim they do not accept, or alarm at what Rome's soldiers might do to a crowd crowning a king at Passover, or both. Luke does not say which. In a sense the request is a test: if Jesus silences them, he disowns the title. His reply in the next verse ("if these are silent, the stones will cry out") refuses. The praise is not a crowd getting carried away. It is the right response to what is happening, and creation itself would take it up.
-
40“I tell you,” He answered, “if they remain silent, the very stones will cry out.”
Full study →Jesus answers the Pharisees who have just demanded, “Teacher, rebuke your disciples!” He puts his own authority behind the reply: “I tell you — if these people here are hushed, the stones themselves will shout it out.”
The disciples have been shouting, at full voice, a royal welcome from Psalm 118: “Blessed is the King who comes in the name of the Lord!” (v. 38). Jesus refuses to stop them. The acclamation fits what is actually happening, and if every human mouth were shut, the most lifeless and voiceless things in the landscape, the rocks of the road down the Mount of Olives and the stones of the city ahead, would take up the cry. The verb for “cry out” means a loud, urgent shout that cannot be held back. It is the same verb Luke used for the blind beggar who was told to be quiet and “cried out all the more” (18:39).
Jewish hearers would also catch an older echo. In Habakkuk 2:11, “the stone will cry out from the wall” as a witness against a house built by injustice. Luke follows the saying at once with Jesus weeping over Jerusalem and predicting that not one of its stones will be left on another (19:41–44). So the stones that would “shout” are both a sign that the truth cannot be suppressed and a hint that, if Jerusalem will not acknowledge its king, its own stones will one day testify to that refusal.
-
41As Jesus approached Jerusalem and saw the city, He wept over it
Full study →And just as he was drawing near, the moment the city came into view, he broke down and wept aloud over it.
Luke places this right after the crowd's shouting: "Blessed is the King who comes in the name of the Lord! Peace in heaven and glory in the highest!" (v. 38). The disciples are celebrating. Jesus comes over the shoulder of the Mount of Olives, sees Jerusalem and its gleaming temple spread out below, and begins to wail.
The Greek word is not the quiet "shed tears" of John 11:35. It is the audible weeping of mourners at a funeral, the lament sung over a city that has fallen. "Over it" names the cause: he weeps for the city, on its account, as if mourning someone already dead. The next lines say why. Jerusalem has not recognized "the things that make for peace" on the very day they were offered to it, and so siege, ruin and the death of its children are coming (vv. 42–44).
His weeping puts him among Israel's prophets. Jeremiah wished his head were a spring of tears for "the slain of the daughter of my people". Elisha wept when he foresaw what an enemy would do to Israel's children. Jesus does the same. He is not a cold judge announcing doom. He is a king arriving at his capital who grieves openly for the people who will not receive him.
-
42and said, “If only you had known on this day what would bring you peace! But now it is hidden from your eyes.
Full study →As the road came over the Mount of Olives and the city came into view, Jesus broke into loud weeping (v.41) and spoke to Jerusalem as if it were a person, the way the prophets spoke to "Daughter Zion":
"If only you had recognized, on this very day, you too, you of all places, the things that lead to peace…"
The sentence breaks off. In the Greek there is no "then" clause, only the grieving wish, the way speech stops when grief takes over. The verb means recognize more than have information: the signs were there, and the crowd of disciples had just praised God for the mighty works they had seen. "Peace" here is the Hebrew shalom: the safety and wholeness of the city, its people's welfare, and its right standing with God, all at once. The phrase "the things toward peace" is the same one Luke uses for envoys asking a stronger king for terms of peace (14:32). The king has come to his city, and the terms are on the table. The irony is sharp. The disciples have just sung "peace in heaven" (v.38), and Jerusalem, whose very name Jews heard as linked to shalom, misses the things of peace.
"But as things stand, they have been hidden from your eyes."
"But now" here mainly means "but as it is", turning from the wished-for situation to the real one. The hiding is described as already done, and the verb does not say who did it. In Luke that kind of unnamed actor often points to God confirming a blindness people chose (compare Isaiah 6). The next verses spell out what the missed peace costs: siege ramparts, encirclement and ruin, "because you did not recognize the time of your visitation" (v.44).
-
43For the days will come upon you when your enemies will barricade you and surround you and hem you in on every side.
Full study →Because days are coming that will land on you, Jerusalem. Your enemies will arrive, set up camp and drive a ring of sharpened stakes and earthworks around you. They will close the circle completely, then squeeze you tighter and tighter from every direction, until there is no way out.
Jesus speaks to the city as if it were one person, as the prophets did. He has just come over the Mount of Olives and wept at the sight of it (v. 41). This verse explains the tears. Because the city did not recognize "on this day" what would bring it peace (v. 42), other "days" are coming: days of siege. The steps follow the real order of an ancient siege. First the army camps and builds a palisade (charax, a fence of pointed stakes on an earth bank, not a dug "trench"). Then the ring is closed. Then the city is slowly squeezed (synechō, the word for a crowd crushing in or a fever gripping someone). The chain of "and… and… and…" makes the noose feel like it is tightening.
The wording echoes Israel's prophets on the Babylonian siege of Jerusalem: Isaiah 29:3, "I will cast a palisade around you", and Ezekiel 4:2, where the prophet acts out the siege with a palisade around a model city. Luke's Gospel opened with a promise of "salvation from our enemies" (1:71). Now the enemies are the ones closing in. Verse 44 completes the picture: the city levelled, its children killed, not one stone left on another.
-
44They will level you to the ground—you and the children within your walls. They will not leave one stone on another, because you did not recognize the time of your visitation from God.”
Full study →Jesus has just come over the Mount of Olives, seen Jerusalem spread out below him, and burst into tears (v.41). Still speaking to the city as if it were one person, a mother, he finishes his lament:
"…and they will throw you down flat to the ground: you, and the children inside your walls with you. They will not leave one stone resting on another stone anywhere in you. And this is the reason: you did not recognize the moment when God came to visit you."
The verb Jesus uses means to bring something down to floor level. It fits a city razed to its foundations and it fits little ones dashed to the ground, and he applies it to both at once. Any listener who knew the Greek Psalms and prophets would hear echoes of the first fall of Jerusalem to Babylon (Ps 137:9; Hos 10:14; Nah 3:10). "Not a stone on a stone" means total demolition: no wall left even two courses high.
The last clause gives the reason, with a solemn formula ("in return for which") that the old prophets used to state the grounds of judgment. Jerusalem's fault was not missing information. It failed to recognize a decisive, closing moment (kairos): God's "visitation". In Israel's scriptures that word means God coming in person to look into his people's condition and act. In Luke the act was meant to save: "he has visited and redeemed his people" (1:68), "God has visited his people" (7:16). The visit was in Jesus himself, riding into the city. "Know" closes the lament where it opened: "if only you had known… the things that make for peace" (v.42). Missing peace and missing the visit are the same failure, and the ruin comes from it. The verse is spoken as grief, not as gloating.
Where the English drifted
-
in v39
Master (KJV)
didaskale
- What we hear
- Lord, owner, someone with authority over servants.
- What they heard
- Teacher (Greek equivalent of "Rabbi"). It was polite, but it names a teacher, not a lord or king.
-
in v39
Pharisees
Pharisaioi
- What we hear
- Hypocrites, self-righteous legalists. "Pharisee" used as an insult.
- What they heard
- Members of a respected, influential lay movement devoted to exact observance of the Law. In Luke they sometimes host and even warn Jesus. Only "some" of them object here.
-
in v40
hold their peace (KJV)
siōpēsōsin / siōpēsousin
- What we hear
- Keep the peace, avoid conflict, stay calm.
- What they heard
- Simply to be silent, stop speaking. Here it means silenced at the Pharisees' demand.
-
in v40
cry out
krazō
- What we hear
- Weep or wail in distress; an emotional outburst of sorrow.
- What they heard
- To shout aloud with urgency and volume. In context the shout stands in for the disciples' loud royal acclamation, possibly with an undertone of witness against Jerusalem.
-
in v41
wept
eklausen (klaiō)
- What we hear
- Quiet, private tears: a moved, silent sorrow, often pictured like 'Jesus wept' at Lazarus's tomb.
- What they heard
- Audible weeping and wailing, the sound of funeral mourning and lament over a fallen city, done openly before the crowd.
-
in v42
what would bring you peace / the things that make for peace
ta pros eirēnēn
- What we hear
- Personal inner calm or tranquillity, or an individual's private peace with God.
- What they heard
- The safety, wholeness and survival of the city and its people, together with their right standing with God, and the terms on which that peace was being offered by the arriving king (compare Luke 14:32). The opposite in context is war and siege, not anxiety.
-
in v42
But now it is hidden
nyn de ekrybē
- What we hear
- "From this moment on it is too late, permanently", as though a door has just shut forever. Some paraphrases make this explicit.
- What they heard
- *Nyn de* is a common Greek turn meaning "but as things actually are", contrasting reality with the unfinished "if only". It does carry a sense of the present situation, but by itself it does not say the hiddenness is permanent. Luke's parallels show hidden things later opened (18:34 with 24:31), and Acts has Jerusalem offered repentance again (Acts 3:17–20).
-
in v43
cast a trench about thee (KJV)
charax
- What we hear
- A ditch dug around the city, like a World War I trench.
- What they heard
- A palisade of sharpened stakes, usually on an earth bank: a raised barrier built to seal the city in, not a hole in the ground.
-
in v44
visitation
episkopē
- What we hear
- A social call, a custody visit, a funeral viewing, or (in some church settings) a special spiritual experience or outbreak of revival.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v40
The stones aren't a threat to quiet worshippers
- What's often taught
- If we fail to praise God, he will replace us with rocks, so praise him or a stone will take your place.
- What the text supports
Jesus is answering the Pharisees, who had just demanded that he “rebuke” his disciples to make them stop (v. 39). “These” are the disciples who were already shouting praise at the top of their voices. The “if” describes the situation the Pharisees wanted, the disciples being silenced, not disciples who are slack in worship.
The point is that the acclamation of the king cannot be suppressed: even the most lifeless things would proclaim it. With the echo of Habakkuk 2:11 and the prophecy of Jerusalem's stones being thrown down in 19:44, it may also warn that creation would testify against those who reject him.
The popular reading is right that the verse affirms praise of Jesus as fitting and that God's purposes do not depend on human cooperation. It is not a warning to believers that rocks will replace them.
- Where the English feeds it
- Renderings like “if they keep quiet” or “if they remain silent” can make the silence sound like the disciples' own choice. In the Greek, prompted by the Pharisees' demand for a rebuke, it reads as silence forced on them.
Every word
-
καί
kai · G2532
and · v39, v40, v41, v42, v43, v44
Links this objection straight onto the disciples' shout in v. 38. It works as a mild contrast here ("but"): the praise is interrupted by a protest.
-
τινες
tines · G5100
some, certain ones · v39
"Some" of the Pharisees. Luke does not say the Pharisees as a group objected, only a particular few who were there.
-
τῶν
tōn · G3588
the · v39, v40, v41, v42, v43, v44
Article marking the group the "some" are taken from: "some of the Pharisees."
-
Φαρισαίων
Pharisaiōn · G5330
Pharisee · v39
Members of a respected lay movement devoted to careful keeping of the Law and the traditions of the elders. In Luke they have argued with Jesus all through the Gospel. This is the last time they appear in Luke's Gospel.
-
ἀπὸ
apo · G0575
from · v39, v42
"From the crowd": they spoke from within the throng, or stepped out of it. Either way they are physically among the people but not part of the praising disciples.
-
ὄχλου
ochlou · G3793
crowd, multitude · v39
The large crowd of the procession. Verse 37 calls it "the whole multitude of the disciples," so this crowd is mostly Jesus' followers, and the Pharisees stand out from it.
-
εἶπαν
eipan · G2036
said · v39, v40
Simple past, "they said": a single spoken protest, not a long dispute.
-
πρὸς
pros · G4314
to, toward · v39, v42
They speak "to him" directly. They go to the teacher, not to the disciples.
-
αὐτόν·
auton · G0846
him · v39, v40, v41
Jesus, who is riding the colt at the center of the procession.
-
διδάσκαλε,
didaskale · G1320
teacher · v39
A polite, respectful title, the Greek counterpart of "Rabbi." It ranks him as a teacher. Coming just after the crowd hailed him as "the King," it quietly declines that bigger title.
-
ἐπιτίμησον
epitimēson · G2008
rebuke, sternly order · v39
A command: "rebuke them," meaning tell them off sharply and make them stop. It assumes a teacher has authority over his followers' behaviour.
-
μαθηταῖς
mathētais · G3101
disciple, student · v39
Followers who learn from a teacher. Here it means the whole crowd of followers (v. 37), not only the Twelve.
-
σου.
sou · G4771
your · v39, v40, v42, v43, v44
"Your" disciples: they are his, so he answers for them. The Pharisees hold Jesus responsible for what his followers are shouting.
-
ἀποκριθεὶς
apokritheis · G0611
to answer · v40
“Answering.” This is a set biblical phrase for replying (“answering, he said”). It marks what follows as a direct answer to the Pharisees' demand.
-
λέγω
legō · G3004
I say · v40, v42
“I tell (you).” With “to you” this is one of Jesus' solemn formulas. It puts his own authority behind the statement that follows.
-
ὅτι
hoti · G3754
that · v40, v42, v43
“That.” Found only in some editions. It introduces what Jesus says, much like opening quotation marks.
-
ἐὰν
ean · G1437
if · v40
“If.” It sets up a supposed situation: the disciples are silenced, as the Pharisees want. Unusually, it is followed by a future indicative verb (see the studies).
-
οὗτοι
houtoi · G3778
these · v40, v42
“These.” It points to the crowd of disciples who were shouting praise down the slope of the Mount of Olives (v. 37). It almost sounds like Jesus gesturing toward them.
-
σιωπήσουσιν
siōpēsousin · G4623
to be silent · v40
“Will be silent / fall silent.” This answers the Pharisees' “rebuke” directly: suppose the disciples are hushed, as the Pharisees demand.
-
λίθοι
lithoi · G3037
-
κράξουσιν
kraxousin · G2896
to cry out, shout · v40
“Will cry out / shout aloud.” A loud, urgent cry that cannot be held back. It takes the place of the disciples' loud acclamation (v. 37, “with a loud voice”).
-
ὡς
hōs · G5613
as, when · v41
Marks time: 'as' or 'when'. The weeping happens during the approach itself, not after he arrives.
-
ἤγγισεν
ēngisen · G1448
-
ἰδὼν
idōn · G1492
to see, perceive · v41
'Having seen.' This participle describes an action completed before the main verb: it was the sight of the city, laid out below the Mount of Olives, that set off the weeping.
-
πόλιν
polin · G4172
-
ἔκλαυσεν
eklausen · G2799
to weep, wail, lament · v41
'He wept.' Klaiō is audible crying, the word for mourning over the dead and for public lament. Here it is a single, definite outburst of grief, voiced openly in front of the crowd.
-
ἐπ᾽
ep' · G1909
upon, over, on account of · v41, v43, v44
With 'weep', ἐπί names what the grief is about: 'over' or 'for' the city. Luke uses the same pairing in 23:28: 'do not weep over (ἐπί) me, but weep over yourselves.'
-
Εἰ
ei · G1487
if · v42
Starts an 'if' sentence that never finishes. With a past-tense verb it states something contrary to fact ("if you had known, but you did not"), and since no 'then' clause follows, it works as a grieving wish: "If only…!"
-
ἔγνως
egnōs · G1097
you knew / had known · v42, v44
Aorist (simple past) of 'know', in the sense of recognizing or grasping. The point is that the city did not recognize what was in front of it. It is not about lacking information. The same verb comes back in v.44: "you did not know the time of your visitation."
-
γε
ge · G1065
indeed / at least · v42
Byzantine text only. With καί it gives the KJV's "at least in this thy day", which adds the note that even this late, the last day would have been enough.
-
ἐν
en · G1722
in / on · v42, v44
Marks the time: on this day.
-
ἡμέρᾳ
hēmera · G2250
day · v42, v43
The day the king arrives at his city. It matches "the time of your visitation" in v.44, the decisive moment when God comes to his people. In v.43 it stands against the coming "days" of siege.
-
εἰρήνην
eirēnēn · G1515
peace · v42
This carries the Hebrew sense of shalom: the city's safety, wholeness and well-being, and its right standing with God. It is set against the war and destruction described in vv.43–44.
-
νῦν
nyn · G3568
now · v42
Together with δέ, a stock phrase that turns from the wished-for situation to the real one: "but as it is". There is still some sense of time ("now, at this point").
-
δὲ
de · G1161
but · v42
Sets what is actually the case against the unfinished "if only".
-
ἐκρύβη
ekrybē · G2928
it was hidden · v42
Aorist passive: "it was hidden", or "it has been hidden". The hiding has already happened. The passive does not name who hid it, and in Luke that kind of passive often hints that God is behind it (compare 18:34).
-
ὀφθαλμῶν
ophthalmōn · G3788
eyes · v42
The city's eyes, standing for its perception. This draws on the prophets' picture of people with eyes who do not see (Isa 6:9–10; Jer 5:21), and on Luke's own theme of eyes being closed and later opened (24:16, 31).
-
ἥξουσιν
hēxousin · G2240
to come, to have arrived · v43
Future: 'they will come'. ἥκω stresses arriving and being there. The days do not just approach; they land on the city.
-
παρεμβαλοῦσιν
parembalousin · G6070
to throw up, to set up (a siege-work); to encamp · v43
'They will throw up'. The verb is related to παρεμβολή, 'army camp', and in the Greek Old Testament it often means 'to encamp' against a city. It pictures an army settling in and building.
-
ἐχθροί
echthroi · G2190
-
χάρακά
charaka · G5482
pointed stake; palisade; siege-rampart · v43
A barrier of sharpened stakes, usually set in an earthen bank, built around a city both to attack it and to stop anyone getting out. This is the word KJV renders 'trench'.
-
περικυκλώσουσίν
perikyklōsousin · G4033
to encircle completely · v43
'They will ring you round'. The word combines 'around' and 'circle'. It appears only here in the New Testament and means a full encirclement with no gap.
-
συνέξουσίν
synexousin · G4912
-
πάντοθεν
pantothen · G3840
from all sides · v43
'From every direction'. It closes the verse by shutting the last way out.
-
ἐδαφιοῦσίν
edaphiousin · G1474
to raze; dash to the ground · v44
'They will bring you down to the floor (edaphos).' The verb works both for a city flattened to its foundations and for people thrown down on the ground. Here it covers both the city and her children.
-
τέκνα
tekna · G5043
child, children · v44
The city's inhabitants, pictured as children born to a mother-city (compare Luke 13:34, 'how often I wanted to gather your children'). Real children are not excluded. The verb's echo of Psalm 137:9 and Hosea makes the picture painfully literal.
-
οὐκ
ouk · G3756
not · v44
Flat negation of fact: this will not happen.
-
ἀφήσουσιν
aphēsousin · G0863
to let go, leave, release, forgive · v44
'They will not leave.' The usual sense here is to let something remain where it stands. This is the same verb Luke uses for forgiving, but here it has its plain physical meaning.
-
ἀνθ᾽
anth' · G0473
in place of, in return for · v44
With 'which' it forms the idiom 'in return for which', meaning 'because'. It is a solemn phrase from the Greek Old Testament, used in announcements of judgment that give the reason for what is coming.
-
ὧν
hōn · G3739
which · v44
Part of the idiom 'because'. It points ahead to the reason: failing to recognize.
-
καιρὸν
kairon · G2540
time, decisive moment, season · v44
Not clock time but the right or appointed moment, an opportunity with a deadline. Compare Luke 12:56, 'why do you not know how to interpret this present time (kairos)?'
-
ἐπισκοπῆς
episkopēs · G1984
oversight; visitation · v44
In the Greek Bible, God's 'visitation' is when he comes in person to look into his people's condition and act, to rescue or to judge. Here it means God's coming to Jerusalem in Jesus.
The world behind it
Passover in Jerusalem. Jesus arrives just before Passover, the feast that remembered Israel's freedom from a foreign king. Pilgrims swelled the city's population many times over. The Roman governor came up from Caesarea with extra troops, and soldiers watched the Temple courts from the Antonia fortress. Josephus records riots and massacres at festival time (e.g. Jewish War 2.224–227, under Cumanus, and the Passover disturbances after Herod's death, Antiquities 17.213–218). A crowd publicly calling someone "the King" as it entered the city was exactly the kind of event Rome put down by force. Luke's account of the trial later turns on this charge: "saying that he himself is Christ, a king" (23:2).
Teachers and their disciples. In Jewish (and Greek) teaching circles a master was held responsible for his pupils' conduct. Pupils reflected on their teacher, and the teacher was expected to correct them. This is why questions about the disciples' behaviour are repeatedly put to Jesus (Luke 5:30, 33; 6:2), and why the Pharisees here take their complaint to him and not to the crowd.
Only in Luke. Luke alone records this exchange. Matthew 21:15–16 has chief priests and scribes objecting to children shouting "Hosanna" in the Temple. John 12:19 has Pharisees grumbling to one another that "the world has gone after him." Luke's version puts the objection on the road itself, just before Jesus weeps over the city (19:41–44).
From the study of Luke 19:39.
Where scholars differ
in v39
Why did these Pharisees want the disciples silenced?
-
Religious objection: they rejected the messianic and royal claim being made for Jesus.
The crowd has just added "the King" to Psalm 118:26. The Pharisees answer by calling Jesus only "Teacher." Luke has portrayed them as consistently opposed to Jesus (e.g. 11:53–54; 15:2; 16:14). Jesus' reply treats the praise as fitting, which implies the objection was to its content.
-
Political caution: they feared a Roman crackdown on a crowd hailing a king at Passover.
Festival riots and Roman massacres are recorded by Josephus. Some Pharisees in Luke had warned Jesus of danger before (13:31). Compare the similar worry voiced by the Jerusalem leaders in John 11:48. The request is addressed to Jesus politely, as "Teacher."
-
A mixture of both. Luke does not settle it.
Luke gives no motive. Many commentators (e.g. Marshall, Bock, Green) think theological disapproval was primary, but they allow that fear of disorder probably played a part.
in v39
Does "from the crowd" mean they were part of the procession or separate from it?
-
They were within the throng ("in the crowd").
*Apo* can mean simply "from among"; most modern versions read it this way.
-
They stepped out of or stood apart from the crowd.
The basic sense of *apo* is "away from." Verse 37 calls the crowd "the multitude of the disciples," which marks the Pharisees off from it.
in v40
Would the stones' cry be praise or accusation?
-
Praise: if people are silenced, creation itself would join in acclaiming the king.
The stones' cry takes the place of the disciples' joyful praise (v. 37). Elsewhere in scripture creation praises God (Ps 96:11–12; 98:7–8; Isa 55:12). The immediate context is celebration.
-
Accusation or judgment: the stones would testify against those who reject the king.
Habakkuk 2:11 has stones crying out against a guilty house. Joshua 24:27 has a stone as witness against Israel. Luke follows the saying at once with the prophecy that Jerusalem's stones will be thrown down (19:41–44). Brent Kinman (Biblica 75, 1994) argues this case.
-
A proverbial impossibility, stressing that the truth cannot be suppressed, with both overtones possible.
Many commentators (e.g. Fitzmyer, Marshall, Nolland) see a proverb-like hyperbole. Luke's placement lets the joyful and ominous senses stand side by side.
in v40
Why did the Pharisees want the disciples rebuked?
-
Political caution: a public royal acclamation at Passover could bring Roman reprisal.
Rome treated unsanctioned kings as rebels. Some Pharisees in Luke show concern for Jesus' safety (13:31).
-
Theological objection: they rejected the messianic claim implied by “King.”
Luke's ongoing conflict between Jesus and the Pharisees, and the parallel indignation of the Temple authorities in Matthew 21:15.
in v41
Is Jesus' weeping mainly personal grief or a formal prophetic act?
-
A prophetic sign-act and lament: the weeping itself announces judgment, in the line of Jeremiah and Elisha.
Close verbal parallels to 2 Kings 8:11–12 LXX and Jeremiah's laments. The oracle that follows (vv. 42–44) is in the form of a prophetic lament, and Luke presents Jesus as a prophet who must die in Jerusalem (13:33).
-
Genuine personal anguish over people he loves, which the prophetic form expresses rather than replaces.
Klaiō is the word for real mourning, and the lament in 13:34 ('how often I wanted to gather your children') is openly personal. Most commentators (e.g., Green, Bock) treat the two as inseparable rather than as alternatives.
in v41
Was the oracle that follows (vv. 43–44) shaped by knowledge of the AD 70 destruction?
-
Luke wrote or reshaped it after the event, so its detail reflects the Roman siege.
The mention of siege works and total destruction matches Josephus's account of Titus's siege. Many date Luke after AD 70 on other grounds too.
-
The language is the stock imagery of siege from the Old Testament and fits a genuine pre-70 prediction.
C. H. Dodd (1947) argued that every detail in vv. 43–44 comes from Septuagint descriptions of the Babylonian siege of 587 BC (e.g., Isa 29:3; Ezek 4:2; Ps 137:9; 2 Kgs 8:12), with nothing specific to AD 70, such as the burning of the temple.
in v42
Is "the things that make for peace" mainly about political survival (avoiding war with Rome) or about peace with God (salvation)?
-
Primarily national and political: Jesus' kingdom way (love of enemies, refusing violent revolt) was Jerusalem's path to survival, and rejecting it led to the war of AD 66–70.
The immediate result is a military siege (vv.43–44). The phrase matches the diplomatic "terms of peace" in 14:32. Josephus' account shows revolutionary nationalism driving the city to ruin. This line is argued, for example, by N. T. Wright (*Jesus and the Victory of God*) and M. Borg.
-
Primarily religious and salvific: "peace" is Luke's word for the salvation Jesus brings, and the failure is failing to recognize God's visit in Jesus.
Luke's peace language elsewhere is about salvation (1:79; 2:14; 10:5–6; Acts 10:36). Verse 44 names the failure as not recognizing "the time of your visitation", which is God's coming, not a policy choice. Commentators such as I. H. Marshall and D. Bock stress this.
-
Both together: for a first-century Jew, covenant faithfulness and the city's safety were one question.
The Hebrew *shalom* behind *eirēnē* holds the material and the religious together. The prophetic model (Jeremiah) ties the city's military fate to its response to God's word. Many recent commentators (e.g., J. B. Green, NICNT) take this combined view.
in v42
Who hid the things of peace, and is the hiddenness final?
-
God has hidden them as a judgment, confirming the city's refusal, and the outcome is now fixed.
The passive fits Luke's usage where God is the unnamed actor (10:21 has God hiding things explicitly). Isaiah 6:9–10 lies behind it, and Luke quotes it as a closing verdict in Acts 28:26–27. The siege oracle that follows is stated as certain.
-
The hiddenness is real but not necessarily permanent or total: it describes the present situation, and Luke–Acts expects further opportunity.
*Nyn de* mainly contrasts reality with the wish. In Luke, things hidden from the disciples (18:34) are later revealed (24:31, 45). In Acts, Peter tells Jerusalem they acted "in ignorance" and calls them to repent (Acts 3:17–20), and thousands respond (Acts 2:41). Luke 13:35 looks ahead to a time when the city will say "Blessed is he who comes".
in v42
What does "even you" (kai sy) emphasize?
-
"You too": Jerusalem, like the disciples who just proclaimed peace.
The nearby contrast with v.38 ("peace in heaven") shows that others did recognize what was happening.
-
"You, of all places": the holy city, whose name and calling were tied to peace and to God's presence.
Pss 122 and 48 present Zion as God's chosen city. The prophets addressed it in just this tone of wounded intimacy, and Luke 13:34 laments that the prophets die in Jerusalem.
in v43
Does this wording show that Luke wrote after the fall of Jerusalem in AD 70, or is it stock prophetic siege language?
-
The details reflect knowledge of Titus's siege, so Luke shaped the saying after the event.
The palisade and total encirclement match Josephus's account of Titus's wall around the city (Jewish War 5.491–511). Luke's version is more specific than Mark's (compare Luke 21:20 with Mark 13:14). Most scholars date Luke after 70.
-
The language comes from the Greek Old Testament's accounts of the Babylonian siege and fits any ancient siege. It does not need knowledge of 70.
C. H. Dodd (1947) argued that every element (palisade, encirclement, children dashed, no stone on stone) has a close parallel in Isa 29:3, Ezek 4:2, Jer 52, Ps 137:9 and similar texts. Encirclement was standard Roman practice, and anyone who knew Rome could foresee it. Nothing in the verse names features unique to 70, such as the burning of the Temple.
in v43
What are 'the things that make for peace' (v. 42) that the city missed, which lead to this siege?
-
Mainly religious recognition: accepting Jesus as God's visitation.
Verse 44 gives the reason directly: 'you did not recognize the time of your visitation'. In Luke, 'visitation' language means God coming to save (1:68, 78; 7:16).
-
It also includes a political path: Jesus' way rather than armed revolt against Rome, which led to the siege.
The siege came as the result of the Jewish revolt of 66–70. Jesus' teaching on loving enemies (6:27–36) and his peaceful royal entry contrast with nationalist hopes. Scholars such as N. T. Wright read the lament this way. Others think it reads modern political categories into the text.
in v44
Is this prophecy written after the events of AD 70, or a genuine prediction in traditional prophetic language?
-
After the fact: Luke shaped the oracle in light of Titus's siege.
The siege rampart (v.43) and total razing (v.44) match Josephus's account of AD 70 (War 5.491–511; 7.1–3), and many scholars date Luke after 70.
-
A prediction in the language of the prophets, not a description of 70.
C. H. Dodd (1947) showed that every detail of vv.43–44 can be found in LXX descriptions of the 587 BC fall (Isa 29:3; Jer 6:6; Ezek 4:2; Ps 137:9; Hos 10:14). The oracle also lacks distinctive features of 70 such as the burning of the Temple, the famine and the internal factions. So it need not reflect the actual events, whatever date Luke is given.
in v44
Is the 'visitation' a saving visit or a visit of judgment?
-
Saving: God's gracious coming in Jesus, unrecognized.
Luke consistently uses the cognate verb for God's saving visits (1:68, 78; 7:16; Acts 15:14). The clause gives the reason for the judgment, so the visitation is what came before the judgment and was refused.
-
A visit of reckoning in which God inspects the city, with judgment as the result.
In the LXX, 'day' or 'time of visitation' often means judgment (Isa 10:3; Jer 6:15; 10:15). Jesus' arrival in the city and Temple (19:45) works as an inspection.
-
Both: one visit that saves those who recognize it and judges those who do not.
The Hebrew background word *pequddah* covers both senses, and Luke 2:34 presents Jesus as set for 'the fall and rising of many in Israel'.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. ἐπιτιμάω
- BDAG s.v. διδάσκαλος
- BDAG s.v. Φαρισαῖος
- BDAG s.v. μαθητής
- Josephus, Antiquities 13.171–173, 13.297–298, 17.213–218, 18.12–15
- Josephus, Jewish War 2.162–166, 2.224–227
- J. A. Fitzmyer, The Gospel According to Luke X–XXIV (Anchor Bible)
- I. H. Marshall, The Gospel of Luke (NIGTC)
- D. L. Bock, Luke 9:51–24:53 (BECNT)
- J. B. Green, The Gospel of Luke (NICNT)
- J. Nolland, Luke 18:35–24:53 (WBC)
- BDAG (Bauer–Danker–Arndt–Gingrich), s.v. σιωπάω, κράζω, λίθος
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon, s.v. κράζω
- Blass–Debrunner–Funk, A Greek Grammar of the New Testament §373.2 (ἐάν with future indicative)
- Nestle–Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Luke 19:40
- Habakkuk 2:11 (Hebrew text and Septuagint); Joshua 24:27
- Babylonian Talmud, Ta'anit 11a (Hab 2:11 applied to stones witnessing)
- B. Kinman, “‘The Stones Will Cry Out’ (Luke 19,40) — Joy or Judgment?” Biblica 75 (1994)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Luke 19:28–44
- NA28 Greek New Testament
- BDAG s.v. κλαίω
- BDAG s.v. δακρύω
- BDAG s.v. ἐπί
- Septuagint: 2 Kingdoms (2 Kings) 8:11–12; Jeremiah 8:23 (9:1); 13:17
- Josephus, Jewish War 5.222–223; book 6 (fall of Jerusalem)
- C. H. Dodd, 'The Fall of Jerusalem and the "Abomination of Desolation"', Journal of Roman Studies 37 (1947)
- Vulgate, Luke 19:41
- BDAG s.v. εἰρήνη, γινώσκω, κρύπτω, νῦν
- Blass–Debrunner–Funk, Greek Grammar of the NT §360 (contrary-to-fact conditions), §482 (sentences that break off)
- TDNT s.v. εἰρήνη (W. Foerster / G. von Rad)
- NA28 / UBS5 apparatus at Luke 19:42
- Septuagint: Ps 121(122):6–8; Jer 6:14; 8:11; 9:1; Isa 6:9–10; 29:3; Ezek 4:2; Isa 10:3
- Josephus, Jewish War 5.491–511; book 6
- N. T. Wright, Jesus and the Victory of God
- Vulgate, Luke 19:42
- BDAG s.v. χάραξ, παρεμβάλλω, συνέχω, περικυκλόω
- LSJ s.v. χάραξ
- Septuagint: Isa 29:3; Ezek 4:2; 2 Kgs (4 Kgdms) 25:1; Deut 28:52
- Josephus, Jewish War 5.491–572
- NA28 critical apparatus at Luke 19:43
- Vulgate, Luke 19:43
- BDAG s.v. ἐπισκοπή, ἐδαφίζω, καιρός, ἀντί
- LSJ s.v. ἐδαφίζω, ἔδαφος
- HALOT s.v. פְּקֻדָּה
- Septuagint: Gen 50:24–25; Exod 3:16; Ps 136:9; Hos 10:14; 14:1; Nah 3:10; Isa 3:26; 10:3; 29:3; Jer 6:6, 15; 10:15; Wis 3:7
- Josephus, Jewish War 5.491–511; 6.249–266; 7.1–4
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).