Luke Chapter 5 Read as one passage

Luke 5:7–11

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

7So they signaled to their partners in the other boat to come and help them, and they came and filled both boats so full that they began to sink. 8When Simon Peter saw this, he fell at Jesus’ knees. “Go away from me, Lord,” he said, “for I am a sinful man.” 9For he and his companions were astonished at the catch of fish they had taken, 10and so were his partners James and John, the sons of Zebedee. “Do not be afraid,” Jesus said to Simon. “From now on you will catch men.” 11And when they had brought their boats ashore, they left everything and followed Him.

What the first hearers heard

For Luke's readers this verse does three things.

  1. It shows how big the miracle was. The fishermen are experts who worked all night and caught nothing. Now one boat cannot hold the catch, two crews are needed, and even both boats are on the point of sinking. The overflow is a sign that God is at work through Jesus. A reader steeped in the Old Testament might recall God's provision that fills every vessel available, such as Elisha and the widow's oil in 2 Kings 4. That echo is possible but not certain.

  2. It brings in the partners. By involving the second boat, Luke prepares for v. 10, where James and John are named as Simon's partners and all of them are called to 'catch people'. The call comes to a working group, not to one man alone.

  3. It builds tension for Peter's reaction. The boats are going down under a weight of blessing. That frightening abundance is what Peter 'sees' in v. 8. It moves him to fall at Jesus' knees and confess that he is a sinful man, the reaction of someone who senses God is close.

From the study of Luke 5:7.

Verse by verse

  1. 7So they signaled to their partners in the other boat to come and help them, and they came and filled both boats so full that they began to sink.

    With the nets already starting to rip, Simon's crew could not spare a hand or a shout. They waved across the water to their partners, the other half of their shared fishing operation, whom Luke soon names as James and John. The signal meant: come over and grab hold with us. The partners came at once. Together they hauled the fish aboard and filled both boats, the whole working fleet of the partnership, until the boats sat so low in the water that they were starting to go under. They did not sink, but they were on the edge of it.

    The picture is of skilled men overwhelmed in their own trade. After a night of catching nothing (v. 5), one word from Jesus produces more than two crews and two boats can safely carry. The danger in the scene comes from too much, not too little, and that sets up Peter's fall to his knees in the next verse.

    Full study →
  2. 8When Simon Peter saw this, he fell at Jesus’ knees. “Go away from me, Lord,” he said, “for I am a sinful man.”

    The moment Simon (Luke uses for once the name he will be known by, Simon Peter) took in what had happened, he threw himself down at Jesus' knees. He did it right there in a boat so loaded with fish it was starting to go under. Out came the words: "Get away from me, because I am a sinful man, Lord!"

    Peter is not rejecting Jesus. He has recoiled before holiness. He had fished all night in his own waters and caught nothing. Then, at a word from Jesus, there was more fish than two boats could hold. He understands that he is in the presence of power that belongs to God. The old instinct of Israel's scriptures takes over: an impure person cannot stand near the holy and stay safe. Isaiah cried out the same way when he saw the Lord ("Woe is me… I am a man of unclean lips"), and so did the widow when Elijah's miracle made her afraid her sin would be remembered.

    He calls himself hamartōlos, "a sinner". In Luke this is the label for the people the religious elite keep at a distance, and the people Jesus says he came to call (5:32). Peter does not list wrongdoings. He states what he is in the light of what he has just seen. A few moments earlier he called Jesus "Master" (epistata), a respectful word for a boss or teacher. Now he says "Lord" (kyrie). The word can mean "sir", but Luke's readers knew it as the Greek Bible's word for God. Peter's language has gone beyond what he could yet explain. The surprise of the story comes in the next verse: Jesus does not leave. He says "Do not be afraid" and gives the frightened sinner a new job.

    Full study →
  3. 9For he and his companions were astonished at the catch of fish they had taken,

    For a stunned, fearful awe came over him and gripped him, and everyone in the boat with him, at the haul of fish they had just pulled in together.

    The verse explains verse 8. Peter has fallen at Jesus' knees saying, "Go away from me, Lord, for I am a sinful man." Luke says why: the men did not just feel amazed in the modern, delighted sense. They were seized by the kind of awe that makes people afraid, the reaction to holy power suddenly showing itself in the middle of their own trade. The Greek puts "awe" first and makes it the actor. It "surrounded" or "gripped" Peter, as something that came over him from outside.

    Everyone in the boat felt it, so it was not one man's emotional moment. The cause was the catch. The word picks up Jesus' command in verse 4 to "let down your nets for a catch". The command had been obeyed after a night of catching nothing, and the result tore the nets and nearly sank two boats. The verb "they had caught" means "seized together" and echoes the partners being called to "help" in verse 7: it took both crews to land it.

    In Greek, "catch" also sets up Jesus' answer in verse 10. Simon will now be "catching people alive", using a verb built from "alive" and "catch".

    Full study →
  4. 10and so were his partners James and John, the sons of Zebedee. “Do not be afraid,” Jesus said to Simon. “From now on you will catch men.”

    James and John, Zebedee's sons, who were Simon's established business partners in the fishing trade, were seized by the same stunned amazement at the huge haul of fish. Simon was still on his knees in the boat. He had just begged Jesus to go away because he was a sinful man and could not bear to be near such holiness. Jesus said to him: “Stop being afraid. From this moment on, it is human beings you will be taking — and you will take them alive.”

    The fear is the terror a sinner feels before divine power, the same fear Isaiah and Gideon felt. Jesus does not deny that Simon is a sinner, and he does not withdraw. He removes the fear and gives Simon a task. The final word plays on the “catch” of the previous verse. The fish in the nets were hauled out to die. Simon's new work will be hauling people out alive, rescuing them the way Rahab's household was kept alive when Jericho fell. Grammatically it is a continuing occupation (“you will be catching”), not a one-time event. It is spoken to Simon personally, though his partners leave everything and follow too (v. 11).

    Full study →
  5. 11And when they had brought their boats ashore, they left everything and followed Him.

    When they had brought the boats in from the lake and run them up onto the shore, they let go of everything (boats, nets, the record catch still in them, the family trade) and went with him as his followers.

    The sentence is built so that everything leads to one point. Two actions come first, "having brought the boats in" and "having let go of everything," and only then the main verb: they followed him. Bringing in the boats uses an ordinary sailor's word for coming to land. It closes the scene that began when Jesus said "put out into the deep" (5:4). On the shore, fishing ends.

    The word for "left" pictures opening the hand and releasing what it holds. It is the same verb Luke uses a few verses later for God's releasing of sins (5:20–24). "Everything" is Luke's own emphasis. Mark mentions only the nets and their father. Luke says all, and he says it on the day the two boats were so full they began to sink. These men did not leave because fishing had failed. They left at the height of success.

    "Followed" is meant literally. They went on the road behind a traveling teacher, as his companions and apprentices. The moment echoes the prophet Elisha, who left his oxen and "went after" Elijah (1 Kings 19:19–21). The verb's tense presents it as one decisive step. It came right after Jesus' promise, "do not be afraid; from now on you will be catching people."

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v7

    ship (KJV)

    ploion

    What we hear
    A large sea-going vessel with decks and a big crew.
    What they heard
    A small, open fishing boat on a lake, about 8 m long and worked by a handful of men. That size is exactly why a big catch could swamp it.
  • in v8

    Lord

    kyrie

    What we hear
    A full, considered confession that Jesus is God, said with the meaning later creeds give it.
    What they heard
    A word that could run from respectful 'sir/master' to the Greek Bible's title for God. On Peter's lips at this point it shows a sudden step up from 'Master' (v.5): he recognises God-like power in Jesus. He does not yet have a worked-out belief about who Jesus is, though Luke's readers would hear the divine overtone.
  • in v8

    a sinful man

    anēr hamartōlos

    What we hear
    A general statement that all people are sinners, or a private feeling of guilt.
    What they heard
    Peter puts himself in the category of 'sinners'. In Luke and other Jewish writings of the time these are the ones set against 'the righteous', and the ones Jesus is criticised for welcoming (5:30–32; 19:7, same phrase of Zacchaeus). The word has moral weight, but it also places Peter among the people Jesus came to call.
  • in v9

    astonished / amazed

    thambos

    What we hear
    Pleasantly surprised or impressed: 'that's amazing!'
    What they heard
    Stunned awe with fear in it: the shaken reaction to something supernatural. This is why Jesus has to say 'Do not be afraid' in the next verse.
  • in v9

    draught (KJV)

    agra

    What we hear
    A current of air, a drink, or beer on tap. Most readers simply don't recognise the word.
    What they heard
    A catch or haul of fish taken with a net.
  • in v10

    catch (men)

    zōgreō

    What we hear
    Simply to land or acquire something, like a fisherman catching a fish (which then dies), or to bring someone in with the right bait.
    What they heard
    To take *alive*, a word from warfare for sparing a captive's life instead of killing him. It is the opposite of what happens to the fish.
  • in v10

    men

    anthrōpoi

    What we hear
    Males.
    What they heard
    Human beings, people. The contrast is with fish, not with women.
  • in v10

    Do not be afraid / Fear not

    mē phobou

    What we hear
    General reassurance against worry or nervousness, for instance about leaving a livelihood.
    What they heard
    The formula God speaks to someone terrified by an encounter with the holy. Here it answers Simon's “Depart from me, I am a sinful man.”
  • in v11

    followed him

    ēkolouthēsan autō

    What we hear
    Came to believe in him, agreed with his teaching, or became committed to him inwardly, without necessarily changing where or how they lived.
    What they heard
    Physically went with him as members of a traveling teacher's company: they left the lake and went on the road behind Jesus as companions, learners and helpers. Inner commitment was included, but the word first describes a change of location and way of life.
Every word
  1. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v7, v9, v10, v11

    Carries the story straight on from v. 6, where the nets began to tear. Luke links one quick action to the next.

  2. κατένευσαν

    kateneusan · G2656

    to nod, signal · v7

    They signaled with a gesture, a nod or a wave, not a shout. Their hands were full of a net that was tearing, and the other boat may have been some distance off.

  3. τοῖς

    tois · G3588

    the · v7, v8, v9, v10, v11

    The article marks out a known group: the partners the fishermen already worked with.

  4. μετόχοις

    metochois · G3353

    partner, sharer · v7

    People who share in something. Here they are working partners in the same fishing operation. Verse 10 names them as James and John, sons of Zebedee.

  5. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in · v7

    Places the partners: they are in the second boat.

  6. ἑτέρῳ

    heterō · G2087

    other · v7

    'The other' of the two. Luke said in v. 2 that there were exactly two boats on the shore.

  7. πλοίῳ

    ploiō · G4143

    boat · v7, v11

    A working fishing boat on the lake, small and open. It was rowed and sailed by a crew of a few men.

  8. ἐλθόντας

    elthontas · G2064

    having come · v7

    'Coming over.' The partners' movement across the water is the first step before they can help.

  9. συλλαβέσθαι

    syllabesthai · G4815

    to help, take hold together · v7, v9

    In this middle form it means to lend a hand or take hold together with someone. It fits men grabbing the same overloaded net.

  10. αὐτοῖς

    autois · G846

    them · v7, v9, v11

    Simon and those with him in the first boat, the ones who called for help.

  11. ἔπλησαν

    eplēsan · G4130

    they filled · v7

    They loaded fish into the boats until both were full. It is a single completed action: the boats ended up full.

  12. ἀμφότερα

    amphotera · G297

    both · v7

    Not one boat but both. The whole fleet of this small partnership could not hold the catch.

  13. ὥστε

    hōste · G5620

    so that · v7

    Introduces the result: how full the boats got.

  14. βυθίζεσθαι

    buthizesthai · G1036

    to sink · v7

    The present tense pictures something under way: the boats were starting to go down and riding dangerously low. The text does not say they sank.

  15. Ἰδὼν

    Idōn · G1492

    having seen · v8

    Peter reacts to what he has just seen: two boats so full of fish they are starting to sink (v.7). The tense shows a completed act of seeing that comes before and sets off his reaction. This is sight that turns into understanding.

  16. δὲ

    de · G1161

    now, and, but · v8, v10

    A light connective that moves the scene from the overflowing boats to Peter's response.

  17. Σίμων

    Simōn · G4613

    Simon · v8, v10

    His ordinary name. In this episode Luke otherwise calls him simply 'Simon' (vv. 3, 4, 5, 10).

  18. Πέτρος

    Petros · G4074

    Peter ('rock') · v8

    This is the only place in his Gospel where Luke uses the double name 'Simon Peter'. Jesus does not give him the name until 6:14. Using it here, at the moment he collapses before Jesus, points ahead to who this fisherman will become.

  19. προσέπεσεν

    prosepesen · G4363

    fell down before, fell toward · v8

    He throws himself down in front of someone. Luke uses the same verb for the possessed man (8:28) and the bleeding woman (8:47) falling before Jesus. It is the posture of someone overwhelmed by superior power, either begging or bowing in submission.

  20. γόνασιν

    gonasin · G1119

    knees · v8

    Jesus is presumably sitting in the boat, as he did to teach (v.3). Peter goes down at his knees, in the tight space of a boat full of fish. Grasping or falling at someone's knees was a familiar ancient gesture of a suppliant, someone begging a greater person for mercy.

  21. Ἰησοῦ

    Iēsou · G2424

    of Jesus · v8, v10

    Whose knees they are. This is the Greek form of Yeshua/Joshua, 'YHWH saves'.

  22. λέγων

    legōn · G3004

    saying · v8

    Peter speaks while he is falling down. The words and the gesture belong together.

  23. ἔξελθε

    exelthe · G1831

    go out, go away, depart · v8

    A blunt command, 'go out' or 'get away'. On a small boat in deep water it cannot be done literally. It is the instinct of someone who suddenly feels the holy too close and wants distance. It is recoil, not rudeness.

  24. ἀπ᾽

    ap' · G575

    from, away from · v8, v10

    Separation. Peter wants space between himself and Jesus.

  25. ἐμοῦ

    emou · G1473

    me · v8

    Peter asks Jesus to withdraw from him personally. He does not say 'from us' or 'from the boat'.

  26. ὅτι

    hoti · G3754

    because, for · v8

    Gives the reason for 'go away'. Peter's request rests on who he is.

  27. ἀνὴρ

    anēr · G435

    man (adult male) · v8

    'A man, a sinful one'. Greek often pairs anēr with a description like this ('a sinful man', as with Zacchaeus in 19:7). The point is the label, not maleness.

  28. ἁμαρτωλός

    hamartōlos · G268

    sinful; a sinner · v8

    Peter calls himself by the word Luke uses for the 'sinners' Jesus will eat with and call (5:30, 32). It is placed early in the clause for weight. It is a statement about himself, not a list of particular wrongs.

  29. εἰμι

    eimi · G1510

    I am · v8, v10

    Present tense: this is what he is now, standing (kneeling) where he is.

  30. κύριε

    kyrie · G2962

    Lord, master, sir · v8

    Peter calls out to him with this title, the last word of the sentence. In v.5 he had called Jesus epistata, 'Master' (a boss or teacher). Now, after the catch, he says kyrie, a word that runs from polite 'sir' to the Greek Bible's word for God's own name.

  31. θάμβος

    thambos · G2285

    amazement, astonishment · v9

    The subject of the sentence, placed first for emphasis. It means being stunned, with a strong note of awe and fear, the kind of reaction people have to something beyond the human. It is not pleasant surprise.

  32. γὰρ

    gar · G1063

    for, because · v9

    Links this verse back to verse 8 and explains it. Peter fell at Jesus' knees and cried 'Go away from me' because this awe had taken hold of him.

  33. περιέσχεν

    perieschen · G4023

    to surround, encompass; to seize · v9

    Literally 'held around', so 'gripped' or 'came over'. Peter is not the one acting here. The awe is pictured as something that wraps around him and takes hold. The tense describes a single event: it came over him at once.

  34. πάντας

    pantas · G3956

    all · v9, v11

    'All' stresses that everyone in the boat felt it, which makes it a shared experience rather than one man's emotional outburst.

  35. σὺν

    syn · G4862

    with · v9

    'With him': the men working alongside Simon in his boat. James and John, in the second boat, are added in verse 10.

  36. ἐπὶ

    epi · G1909

    upon, at, because of · v9, v11

    Gives the cause of the awe: 'at' or 'over' the catch.

  37. ἄγρᾳ

    agra · G61

    catch, haul; hunting · v9

    A word from hunting and fishing that means both the act of catching and what is caught. It picks up Jesus' command in verse 4, 'let down your nets for a catch' (eis agran). The command has now come true, and in a way that overwhelmed them.

  38. ἰχθύων

    ichthyōn · G2486

    fish · v9

    The ordinary word for fish. Verse 6 has already called it 'a great multitude of fish'.

  39. ὧν

    hōn · G3739

    which · v9, v10

    'Which', referring to the fish. Some manuscripts have a form referring to 'the catch' instead. The meaning is the same.

  40. ὁμοίως

    homoiōs · G3668

    likewise, in the same way · v10

    Links James and John to verse 9: the same astonishment that gripped Simon gripped them too.

  41. Ἰάκωβον

    Iakōbon · G2385

    James (Jacob) · v10

    The Greek form of the Hebrew name Ya'aqov (Jacob), the patriarch's name. It is in the object case because the verb it depends on is in verse 9: amazement “seized” him and his companions, and likewise James and John.

  42. Ἰωάννην

    Iōannēn · G2491

    John · v10

    From the Hebrew Yochanan, “YHWH has been gracious.” This is John son of Zebedee, not John the Baptist.

  43. υἱοὺς

    huious · G5207

    sons · v10

    Identifies the brothers by their father, as was normal. It also signals a family business: Zebedee's household owned boats and, according to Mark 1:20, employed hired men.

  44. Ζεβεδαίου

    Zebedaiou · G2199

    Zebedee · v10

    Greek form of a Hebrew name probably related to Zabdi/Zebadiah, “gift (of YHWH).” He is the father and head of the fishing household.

  45. κοινωνοὶ

    koinōnoi · G2844

    partners, sharers · v10

    Business associates who shared in a common enterprise and its profits. Here it means a fishing partnership or cooperative with Simon's crew.

  46. εἶπεν

    eipen · G2036

    said · v10

    A simple past tense that reports a single, decisive saying.

  47. πρὸς

    pros · G4314

    to, toward · v10

    Shows who is addressed. The saying is aimed at Simon personally.

  48. μὴ

    mē · G3361

    not · v10

    The negative used with commands: “do not.”

  49. φοβοῦ

    phobou · G5399

    fear, be afraid · v10

    A present-tense command, so it has the force of “stop being afraid / do not go on fearing.” The fear is Simon's terror at being a sinner close to divine power. It is not anxiety about money or the future.

  50. νῦν

    nun · G3568

    now · v10

    “From now on.” Luke uses this phrase at turning points (1:48; 12:52; 22:69). Simon's life is being split into before and after.

  51. ἀνθρώπους

    anthrōpous · G444

    human beings, people · v10

    The generic word for human beings, not specifically males. It is placed first for emphasis and contrasts with the fish of verses 6–9: “people, not fish, is what you will be taking.”

  52. ζωγρῶν

    zōgrōn · G2221

    take alive, capture alive · v10

    Literally “to take alive.” The word was used for taking prisoners in war instead of killing them, and so for sparing a life. The fish in the nets were caught to die. The people Simon catches will be caught for life.

  53. καταγαγόντες

    katagagontes · G2609

    to bring down; (nautical) to bring a boat in to land · v11

    A sailor's word: to bring a vessel in from open water to the shore (the opposite is anagō, 'put out to sea'). The participle comes first: the boats, nearly sinking with the catch (5:7), are brought in before anything else happens.

  54. γῆν,

    gēn · G1093H

    earth, land, ground · v11

    Here simply 'land/shore', the dry ground beside the lake, not 'the earth' in a cosmic sense.

  55. ἀφέντες

    aphentes · G0863G

    to let go, release, leave behind; to forgive · v11

    'Having let go of / left behind.' The word pictures opening one's hand and releasing what one holds. Here what they release is their boats, nets, catch and trade.

  56. ἠκολούθησαν

    ēkolouthēsan · G0190

    to follow, accompany, go along behind · v11

    The main verb, and the only finite one in the sentence. Everything else leads up to it. In the Gospels it means literally going with a traveling teacher as his companions and learners. The aorist tense presents it as one decisive step taken.

The world behind it

Fishing on the Sea of Galilee. Fishing on the lake was a regulated, taxed trade under Herod Antipas. It was usually run by family groups who pooled boats, nets and hired hands, and who sometimes leased fishing rights together. Luke's word μέτοχοι ('partners') here, and κοινωνοί in v. 10, match the language of such partnerships in papyrus documents. Mark 1:20 also mentions that Zebedee had 'hired men'. Simon's family and Zebedee's family appear to have worked as one group with two boats.

The boats. A first-century fishing boat found in the mud near Ginosar in 1986 (often called the 'Jesus boat') is about 8.2 m long and 2.3 m wide (about 27 by 7.5 ft). It was open, shallow, rowed and sailed by a small crew. A boat like that has little height above the waterline when loaded, so a heavy catch of fish could quickly push it down to a dangerous level.

Nets and timing. Most fishing was done at night (v. 5) with large nets. Fishing in daylight in deeper water, as Jesus tells them to do, ran against the fishermen's own experience. That is why the size of the catch is so striking.

From the study of Luke 5:7.

Where scholars differ

in v7

Is Luke's miraculous catch the same event as the catch after the resurrection in John 21:1–11?

  • They are two tellings of one tradition, which Luke moved to the beginning of Jesus' ministry.

    Both stories share a night of catching nothing, Jesus telling them where to let down the nets, a huge catch, strained nets, and a strong reaction from Peter. Scholars such as Fitzmyer and Bovon discuss the possibility that one tradition was reshaped.

  • They are two separate events, the second deliberately recalling the first.

    The details differ. In Luke the nets tear and there are two boats; in John 21 the net does not tear, there is one boat, and the fish are counted at 153. The settings and purposes differ too: a first call in Luke, restoration after Peter's denial in John. Some commentators (e.g. Marshall, Bock) prefer this reading.

in v8

What does Peter mean by calling himself 'a sinful man'?

  • Awe before the holy: a reflex of unworthiness in the presence of God-like power, following prophetic call scenes.

    Close parallels with Isa 6:5 and with Judg 6:22 and 13:22. The 'astonishment' (thambos) explanation in v.9. Jesus' 'Do not be afraid' in v.10, the standard reassurance in Luke's divine appearances (1:13, 30; 2:10). Peter names no specific sin. Held by many commentators (e.g. Fitzmyer, Green).

  • Real moral self-awareness: Peter recognises his own guilt and need of mercy, foreshadowing Luke's theme of sinners being called to repentance.

    Hamartōlos is a morally loaded word in Luke (5:32; 15:7; 18:13). The parallel with the widow's fear that her sin will be remembered (1 Kgs 17:18). The scene sits right before 'I came to call sinners to repentance' (5:32).

  • Both together, and not exclusive: biblical holiness exposes moral impurity, so awe and confession of guilt are one reaction.

    In Isa 6:5 seeing the King and confessing 'unclean lips' happen at the same moment. Luke's narrative moves straight from this scene into Jesus' mission to 'sinners'.

in v8

Is Luke 5:1–11 related to the post-resurrection catch in John 21?

  • One underlying tradition, originally a resurrection appearance, which Luke moved to the start of Jesus' ministry. 'I am a sinful man' would then first have fitted Peter after his denial.

    Shared features: a night of catching nothing, Jesus' instruction, a huge catch, net or boat strain, Peter's dramatic reaction, Peter's commission. Raised by a number of critical scholars (discussed by R. E. Brown and Fitzmyer).

  • Two distinct events or traditions, each in its proper place.

    Significant differences: the nets break in Luke (5:6) but not in John (21:11); the settings and the response of Jesus differ; Peter's reaction is opposite (asking Jesus to leave versus rushing to him). Argued by e.g. Bock and Marshall.

in v8

How much does 'Lord' (kyrie) mean on Peter's lips here?

  • An honorific stronger than 'Master' but not yet a confession of divinity.

    Kyrie is widely used as respectful address in the Gospels. Peter's fuller confession comes later (9:20, 'the Christ of God').

  • A recognition, however inarticulate, that God is present in Jesus.

    The deliberate change from epistata (v.5) to kyrie. The theophany pattern of the scene. LXX use of kyrios for YHWH. Luke's own narrative habit of calling Jesus 'the Lord'.

in v9

How does this miraculous catch relate to the catch after the resurrection in John 21:1–11?

  • Two separate events: one at the start of Peter's discipleship, one after the resurrection that deliberately recalls it.

    The settings differ (early in Jesus' ministry vs. after Easter) and so do the details (nets begin to tear in Luke but do not tear in John; two boats vs. one boat with 153 fish). A repeat of the miracle would make sense as part of Peter's restoration in John 21.

  • One tradition, which Luke and John placed at different points in the story.

    Both share a night of catching nothing, a command to let down the nets, a huge catch, Peter as the central figure with a strong personal reaction, and a commission that follows. Mark and Matthew tell Peter's call without any miraculous catch (Mark 1:16–20; Matt 4:18–22), which suggests Luke has combined the call with a catch story that also existed separately.

in v10

Does ζωγρέω here stress rescue (“catching people to save their lives”) or simply capture/gathering?

  • Rescue and preservation of life is the point.

    The word's root meaning is “take alive.” The Septuagint uses it for sparing lives (Josh 2:13; 6:25). The contrast with fish that die once caught is deliberate, given the *agra/zōgreō* wordplay with verse 9. Luke's wider emphasis on salvation for sinners points the same way (Fitzmyer, Green, and others).

  • It mainly means capture or gathering, with “alive” as a lighter nuance.

    Its only other New Testament use (2 Tim 2:26) is hostile capture by the devil. In ordinary Koine Greek the word could mean “capture” without stressing rescue, and Luke may have picked it simply to vary Mark's “fishers.” Commentators such as Marshall note the overtone but are cautious about building much on it.

in v10

Does the fishing image carry the Old Testament sense of judgment (Jeremiah 16:16)?

  • Yes. Jesus' saying (especially in Mark's form) echoes the prophetic image of gathering people for God's reckoning.

    Jeremiah 16:16, Amos 4:2 and Habakkuk 1:14–17 use fishing for judgment, and Wuellner's study traces a wide ancient use of “fishing for people” imagery.

  • Luke at least reshapes it toward rescue.

    His choice of “take alive” in place of “fishers,” together with the setting of a forgiven sinner, turns the image toward saving life. Even scholars who see a judgment echo in Mark tend to accept this point.

in v10

How does Luke 5:1–11 relate to the post-resurrection catch in John 21?

  • They reflect one original tradition, placed in different settings.

    Both have Peter, a night of catching nothing, a command to let down the nets, a huge catch, strained nets, and Peter's dramatic reaction. Fitzmyer, R. E. Brown and others argue for a common source.

  • They are two separate events, the second deliberately echoing the first.

    There are differences in timing, details (the nets break in Luke but not in John), and outcome. John 21 may be meant to recall the original call as Peter is restored (e.g., Bock).

in v11

How literally should 'they left everything' be taken?

  • Literal and total: a complete break with property and livelihood, which Luke sets as the standard for discipleship.

    Luke alone adds 'everything' here and at 5:28, and he makes it a rule in 14:33 ('renounce all that he has') and 18:22. Peter says 'we have left everything' (18:28; Mark 10:28). The early Jerusalem community's sharing of goods (Acts 2:44–45; 4:32–37) fits this emphasis.

  • Decisive but not absolute: they gave up their trade and their claim on what they owned, but did not destroy every tie or sell every asset.

    Simon's house and mother-in-law in Capernaum are still in the background (Luke 4:38; Mark 1:29). The boats seem to remain available (Mark 3:9; 4:1, 36), and John 21:3 has Peter go fishing again. Luke 8:3 shows women supporting Jesus 'from their possessions'. Luke uses 'all' in a way typical of narrative speech: everything that would have kept them at the lake.

in v11

Is Luke's call scene the same event as Mark 1:16–20, or a separate one?

  • Luke's own retelling of the same call, enlarged with a catch-miracle tradition.

    The same three men (Luke omits Andrew here), the same lake, the same 'fishers/catchers of people' saying and the same response of leaving and following. Luke is known to rearrange and expand material from Mark.

  • A separate, later occasion, or the decisive call after an earlier first meeting.

    In Luke, Jesus already knows Simon and has healed his mother-in-law (4:38–39) before this scene. John 1:35–42 describes an earlier first meeting in Judea. So Luke 5 could be a later, final summons. Harmonizers since Augustine have proposed versions of this.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. κατανεύω, μέτοχος, συλλαμβάνω, βυθίζω
  • LSJ s.v. κατανεύω
  • Mendel Nun, The Sea of Galilee and Its Fishermen in the New Testament (1989)
  • K. C. Hanson, 'The Galilean Fishing Economy and the Jesus Tradition', Biblical Theology Bulletin 27 (1997)
  • Shelley Wachsmann, The Sea of Galilee Boat (1995)
  • J. A. Fitzmyer, The Gospel According to Luke I–IX (Anchor Bible)
  • F. Bovon, Luke 1 (Hermeneia)
  • I. H. Marshall, The Gospel of Luke (NIGTC)
  • Joel B. Green, The Gospel of Luke (NICNT)
  • BDAG s.v. ἁμαρτωλός, κύριος, προσπίπτω, ἐξέρχομαι, ἐπιστάτης
  • Septuagint: Isaiah 6:1–5; 3 Kingdoms (1 Kings) 17:18; Judges 6:22; 13:22
  • Psalms of Solomon and 1 Enoch on 'sinners' vs 'the righteous'
  • D. L. Bock, Luke 1:1–9:50 (BECNT)
  • J. B. Green, The Gospel of Luke (NICNT)
  • R. E. Brown, The Gospel According to John XIII–XXI (Anchor Bible), on John 21 and Luke 5
  • J. D. G. Dunn, 'Pharisees, Sinners and Jesus'; E. P. Sanders, Jesus and Judaism, on the 'sinners' category
  • BDAG s.v. θάμβος, περιέχω, ἄγρα, συλλαμβάνω, ζωγρέω
  • LSJ s.v. ἄγρα, ζωγρέω
  • Septuagint: 1 Kingdoms (1 Samuel) 26:12; Song of Songs 6:4, 10; Psalm 17(18):5–6
  • Vulgate, Luke 5:9
  • K. C. Hanson, 'The Galilean Fishing Economy and the Jesus Tradition,' Biblical Theology Bulletin 27 (1997)
  • I. Howard Marshall, The Gospel of Luke (NIGTC)
  • Craig S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Luke 5:1–11
  • BDAG s.v. ζωγρέω, κοινωνός, φοβέω
  • LSJ s.v. ζωγρέω
  • Septuagint: Num 31:15, 18; Deut 20:16; Josh 2:13; 6:25; 2 Chr 25:12
  • Homer, Iliad 6.46; 10.378
  • W. Wuellner, The Meaning of “Fishers of Men” (1967)
  • K. C. Hanson, “The Galilean Fishing Economy and the Jesus Tradition,” Biblical Theology Bulletin 27 (1997)
  • B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (on Codex Bezae at Luke 5:10)
  • Nestle-Aland 28th edition
  • BDAG s.v. κατάγω, ἀφίημι, ἀκολουθέω, πᾶς
  • LSJ s.v. κατάγω (nautical sense, paired with ἀνάγω)
  • Septuagint, 3 Kingdoms (1 Kings) 19:19–21
  • Mishnah Avot 1:6
  • Martin Hengel, The Charismatic Leader and His Followers (1968; ET 1981)
  • W. Wuellner, The Meaning of 'Fishers of Men' (1967)
  • Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Luke 5:10–11 (Codex Bezae)
  • Joseph A. Fitzmyer, The Gospel According to Luke I–IX (Anchor Bible)
  • Vulgate, Luke 5:11

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).