John Chapter 6 Read as one passage

John 6:61–64

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

61Aware that His disciples were grumbling about this teaching, Jesus asked them, “Does this offend you? 62Then what will happen if you see the Son of Man ascend to where He was before? 63The Spirit gives life; the flesh profits nothing. The words I have spoken to you are spirit and they are life. 64However, there are some of you who do not believe.” (For Jesus had known from the beginning which of them did not believe and who would betray Him.)

What the first hearers heard

To a first-century Jewish or Jewish-influenced hearer, the scene would have sounded like a replay of Israel's oldest story of failure. God gave bread from heaven, and the people who received it murmured. Now someone stands in a synagogue claiming to be the bread from heaven, and his own followers murmur against him in the same words.

The verse makes three points:

  1. Jesus knows the heart. He answers what has not been said to him. For John's readers this fits the Gospel's picture of Jesus as one who knows people the way God does, and it leads into v. 64: he knew from the start who would not believe and who would betray him.
  2. Following Jesus can break here. "Skandalizō" names a moment of falling away. Jesus does not soften the hard saying to keep the crowd. He states the risk openly: this may be what makes you fall. Many do leave (v. 66).
  3. There is worse to come. The unfinished question in v. 62 ("What if you see the Son of Man going up where he was before?") pushes further. If the claim that he came down from heaven trips them up, his going back up (in John, through the cross, resurrection and return to the Father) will test them even more. Verse 63 then gives the key: "It is the Spirit who gives life; the flesh is of no help. The words I have spoken to you are spirit and life."

For a community that may itself have seen members leave, the scene explained defection without pretending it was surprising. Some who had followed Jesus did stumble over who he claimed to be, and Jesus had seen it coming.

From the study of John 6:61.

Verse by verse

  1. 61Aware that His disciples were grumbling about this teaching, Jesus asked them, “Does this offend you?

    But Jesus, knowing within himself without anyone telling him that his own followers were muttering in complaint about this, said to them: "Is this what is tripping you up? Is this the thing that will make you fall away?"

    Several things are packed into the Greek:

    • "Knowing within himself": Jesus does not overhear the complaint or have it reported. He already knows it inwardly, as he knows what is in people's hearts throughout John's Gospel (2:24–25; 6:64).
    • "Muttering": the word is the one the Greek Old Testament uses for Israel grumbling in the wilderness, above all over the manna. Jesus has just called himself the true bread from heaven. Now his own followers react the way the wilderness generation did: they are given bread from heaven and they complain about it. The tense is ongoing: they are muttering, right then.
    • "His disciples": not only the Twelve, but the wider body of people who had been following him as their teacher.
    • "This" is the "hard saying" of verse 60, the claim that he came down from heaven and that people must eat his flesh and drink his blood (vv. 51–58). It comes first in his question for emphasis.
    • "Trip you up": the verb comes from the word for a trap or stumbling block. Jesus is not asking whether they feel insulted. He is asking whether this teaching has become the obstacle their loyalty will fall over. Verse 66 gives the answer: many of them turned back and no longer walked with him.

    The question then leads into an unfinished one in verse 62: "Then what if you see the Son of Man going up to where he was before?" In effect: if this trips you up, what will you make of what is still to come?

    Full study →
  2. 62Then what will happen if you see the Son of Man ascend to where He was before?

    Jesus has just asked his offended followers, "Does this scandalize you?" Now he adds a question he deliberately leaves unfinished: "So if you are watching the Son of Man going back up to the place he was before…?" The Greek has an "if" but no "then." The listener has to finish the thought, something like "…what will you say then?"

    The picture is a reversal. The whole synagogue discourse has repeated one claim: the true bread came down from heaven. The crowd choked on it ("Isn't this Joseph's son? How can he say 'I came down from heaven'?"). Jesus now names the other half of the journey. The same Son of Man will go up again, back to the place he occupied before he came. "Son of Man" here is not simply "a human being." It recalls Daniel's figure who comes on the clouds to the throne of God. "Where he was before" quietly claims that he existed in heaven before he ever walked in Galilee.

    Readers have finished the broken sentence in two ways, and the open grammar may be deliberate. (1) Then you will be even more offended. His return to the Father runs through the cross, his being "lifted up," which is a far greater scandal than talk of eating flesh. (2) Then the offense will dissolve. Once he has gone up, it will be clear that he is no mere man from Nazareth, and that "eating his flesh" was never meant crudely, as the next verse explains: "the Spirit gives life; the flesh profits nothing." Either way, the "seeing" he describes is the kind John cares about. Will they look on as outsiders, or see and believe?

    Full study →
  3. 63The Spirit gives life; the flesh profits nothing. The words I have spoken to you are spirit and they are life.

    It is the Spirit, God's own life-breath, and nothing else that makes the dead alive and keeps giving life. This is the same breath that turned dust into Adam and raised Ezekiel's valley of bones. "Flesh", meaning human nature on its own terms (mortal, earthbound, judging by what it can see and taste), is of no use at all for producing that life. This is not a judgment that bodies are bad: this Gospel says the Word himself became flesh. It is a judgment about what merely human resources and merely human understanding can achieve. If you hear "eat my flesh" as butcher-shop meat, you have heard it "according to the flesh", and on that level it profits nothing.

    Then Jesus turns to his own teaching. "The words that I myself have spoken to you" points back to the hard saying that has just offended his followers, and the perfect tense means the words stand spoken, still in force. Those words are spirit: they come from God's realm and carry God's breath. And they are life: they do not just tell you about life, they give it. A Jewish hearer would catch the echoes. "Man does not live by bread alone, but by every word that comes from the mouth of God" was said about the manna, and this whole chapter is about manna. "All flesh is grass… but the word of our God stands forever." Moses' word was "not an empty word, it is your life." Jesus claims all of this for his own speech. The life is not in the flesh as flesh. It is in the Spirit, and Jesus' words are where that Spirit meets the hearer.

    Full study →
  4. 64However, there are some of you who do not believe.” (For Jesus had known from the beginning which of them did not believe and who would betray Him.)

    "But there are some among you, here in my own company, who are not actually trusting me." That is where Jesus' words end. The gospel writer then turns to the reader: Jesus had known all along, from the time these followers first came to him, exactly who among them were not really relying on him, and which one of them would be the man to hand him over into the power of his enemies.

    The verse moves from many to one. Jesus speaks to a crowd of disciples who are offended by his teaching about eating his flesh and drinking his blood (6:53-61). He has just said his words are "spirit and life" (6:63). Now he says that some of them hear those words but do not lean their weight on him. "Believe" here means trust and loyalty, not agreeing to an idea: these people have been following him, and within a few lines many of them will walk away (6:66). The narrator then narrows the focus from "some" to "the one." The verb is "hand over," the word used of delivering someone to captors and judges, the same word Isaiah uses for the Servant who was "handed over" to death. Judas is not yet named, but the reader is told that his act did not catch Jesus unaware. It was known "from the beginning."

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v61

    offend / take offense

    skandalizō

    What we hear
    To upset someone, hurt their feelings, insult or annoy them.
    What they heard
    To trip someone up, to be the obstacle that makes them fall, especially to make someone give up their faith or loyalty and turn away. Moral shock is part of it, but the result in view is falling away.
  • in v61

    grumbling

    gongyzō

    What we hear
    Minor complaining, a grumpy mood.
    What they heard
    Discontented muttering against a leader. In Israel's scriptures it is the word for the wilderness generation's resistance to God over the manna, which counted as rebellion.
  • in v61

    his disciples

    mathētai

    What we hear
    The Twelve apostles.
    What they heard
    The wider circle of people following Jesus as a teacher. Verse 67 separates 'the Twelve' from these many disciples who are leaving.
  • in v62

    Son of Man

    ho huios tou anthrōpou

    What we hear
    A title that stresses Jesus' ordinary humanity, the counterpart to 'Son of God' for his divinity.
    What they heard
    A title tied to Daniel 7's heavenly figure who comes to God's throne. In John it marks the one who came down from heaven and returns there. In this verse it is the title of a being who existed in heaven before coming to earth.
  • in v62

    ascend

    anabainō

    What we hear
    Only the Ascension event of Acts 1, forty days after Easter, separate from the cross.
    What they heard
    The return journey of the one who came down. In John it is one movement that includes being 'lifted up' on the cross, the resurrection and the going to the Father.
  • in v63

    quickeneth (KJV)

    zōopoieō

    What we hear
    Speeds up, accelerates.
    What they heard
    Makes alive, gives life, raises from death. It is God's own creative act.
  • in v63

    the flesh

    sarx

    What we hear
    Either the physical body (with the idea that material things are inferior to spiritual ones) or "the sinful nature".
    What they heard
    Human nature as merely human: mortal, limited, unable by itself to produce or grasp divine life. In John it is not a word for moral evil; the Word himself became flesh (1:14).
  • in v63

    are spirit

    pneuma

    What we hear
    Are "spiritual", i.e. to be taken figuratively or symbolically, or concerned only with inner feelings.
    What they heard
    They come from God's realm and carry God's life-giving breath and power. The word describes their source and effect, not a rule for interpreting them.
  • in v64

    believe

    pisteuō

    What we hear
    To agree that something is true, or to hold an opinion. A person who 'doesn't believe' is a sceptic who rejects the claims.
    What they heard
    To trust, rely on, entrust yourself to someone. The people described here are followers who have been with Jesus, but who do not truly put their weight on him or his words, and who are about to stop following (6:66).
  • in v64

    betray

    paradidōmi

    What we hear
    An act defined entirely by treachery against a friend. The word sounds like a special term for Judas alone.
    What they heard
    To hand someone over into another's custody or power. Here the treachery is real because the one doing it is one of the Twelve (6:71), but the same verb is used for the priests handing Jesus to Pilate, for Pilate handing him to be crucified, and in Isaiah 53 for the Servant being 'handed over'. 'Betray' is a fair contextual rendering that hides those links.
Every word
  1. Εἰδὼς

    Eidōs · G6063

    knowing · v61

    A perfect-tense form that works like a present: Jesus already knows, as settled knowledge, without being told or overhearing. It opens the sentence and puts the stress on what Jesus knows before anything is said.

  2. δὲ

    de · G1161

    but, and · v61

    A light connective moving from the disciples' private complaint (v. 60) to Jesus' answer. 'But' or 'now' rather than a strong contrast.

  3. ὁ

    ho · G3588

    the · v61, v62, v63, v64

    Greek often puts the article before personal names. Not translated in English.

  4. Ἰησοῦς

    Iēsous · G2424

    Jesus · v61, v64

    The Greek form of Yeshua/Joshua. He is the subject of the whole sentence.

  5. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in · v61

    With 'himself' it means 'inwardly', 'within himself'.

  6. ἑαυτῷ

    heautō · G1438

    himself · v61

    'In himself': the knowledge came from inside Jesus, not from anyone reporting the complaint. This matches John's repeated point that Jesus 'knew what was in a person' (2:24–25; 6:64).

  7. ὅτι

    hoti · G3754

    that · v61

    Introduces what Jesus knew.

  8. γογγύζουσιν

    gongyzousin · G1111

    murmur, grumble, mutter · v61

    Present tense: 'they are murmuring', going on right then. The word sounds like low, discontented muttering, and in Israel's scriptures it is the word for the wilderness generation complaining against God, especially over the manna. Here Jesus' own followers take up the murmuring that 'the Jews' started in 6:41.

  9. περὶ

    peri · G4012

    about, concerning · v61

    What the murmuring is about.

  10. τούτου

    toutou · G3778

    this · v61

    'This' points back to the 'hard word' of v. 60: the teaching just given in the Capernaum synagogue, above all the call to eat his flesh and drink his blood (vv. 51–58). BSB supplies the word 'teaching' to make that clear.

  11. μαθηταὶ

    mathētai · G3101

    disciples, students, followers · v61

    People who had attached themselves to Jesus as a teacher. Here it is the wider crowd of followers, not only the Twelve. Verse 66 says 'many' of them left, and verse 67 then turns to 'the Twelve' as a separate group.

  12. αὐτοῦ

    autou · G846

    his · v61, v64

    'His' disciples: these are his own followers, not outsiders or opponents, which is what makes their murmuring sharp.

  13. εἶπεν

    eipen · G2036

    said · v61

    A simple past 'he said'. Jesus speaks to the complaint out loud even though no one put it to him.

  14. ὑμᾶς

    hymas · G4771

    you (plural) · v61, v63, v64

    Plural, addressed to the whole group of complaining followers.

  15. σκανδαλίζει

    skandalizei · G4624

    cause to stumble, trip up, make fall away · v61

    Present tense: 'is this tripping you up?' It does not mean 'hurt your feelings'. It means 'is this becoming the obstacle that makes your faith fall over?' Verse 66 shows the answer: many stopped following him.

  16. ἐὰν

    ean · G1437

    if · v62

    Opens a condition about something that may happen. Jesus never finishes the sentence. There is an 'if' with no 'then', and the listeners have to fill in the rest themselves.

  17. οὖν

    oun · G3767

    then, so · v62

    Ties the question to verse 61 ('Does this offend you?'). The sense is: so, if this offends you, what about the following?

  18. θεωρῆτε

    theōrēte · G2334

    to watch, look at, behold · v62

    Present tense with 'if': 'if you are watching'. The verb suggests looking on at something as it happens, the way a spectator does. John often uses it for seeing that can lead to understanding, or that fails to.

  19. υἱὸν

    huion · G5207

    son · v62

    First part of the title 'Son of Man', the name Jesus most often uses for himself.

  20. ἀνθρώπου

    anthrōpou · G0444

    human being, man · v62

    Finishes the title. In John the Son of Man is the figure who links heaven and earth (1:51), who came down from heaven and goes back up (3:13).

  21. ἀναβαίνοντα

    anabainonta · G0305

    to go up, ascend · v62

    A present participle: 'going up', shown as something in progress. It is the counterpart to the 'coming down' (katabainō) repeated all through John 6 about the bread from heaven (6:33, 38, 41, 42, 50, 51, 58).

  22. ὅπου

    hopou · G3699

    where · v62

    Points to a place: the one he came from. Heaven is not named, but the whole chapter's talk of 'from heaven' makes it clear.

  23. ἦν

    ēn · G1510

    was · v62, v63, v64

    The imperfect 'was' describes an existing state. It echoes John's opening ('In the beginning was the Word', 1:1): he did not start existing in Galilee.

  24. πρότερον

    proteron · G4387

    before, earlier, formerly · v62

    'Where he was before' means before he came down. It quietly but clearly claims that he existed in heaven first. The crowd thought they knew his origins ('Is this not Jesus, the son of Joseph?', 6:42), and this contradicts them.

  25. πνεῦμά

    pneuma · G4151

    spirit, breath, wind · v63

    God's life-giving breath and power, in contrast to "flesh". It echoes Genesis 2:7 and Ezekiel 37, and Jesus' words to Nicodemus in John 3:5–8.

  26. ζῳοποιοῦν

    zōopoioun · G2227

    making alive · v63

    Present participle, so an ongoing activity: "the one that keeps giving life". The verb belongs to God's own work of creating life and raising the dead (John 5:21).

  27. σὰρξ

    sarx · G4561

    flesh · v63

    Human nature as merely human: mortal, creaturely, limited to earthly ways of seeing. In John it is not a word for moral corruption (compare 1:14, "the Word became flesh").

  28. οὐκ

    ouk · G3756

    not · v63, v64

    A plain negative. Paired with "nothing" it forms an emphatic double negative.

  29. ὠφελεῖ

    ōphelei · G5623

    benefits, helps, is of use · v63

    Means to be of use or benefit. Flesh on its own produces no gain toward the life Jesus is talking about.

  30. οὐδέν

    ouden · G3762

    nothing · v63

    "Not… nothing" is normal emphatic Greek, meaning "is of no use at all".

  31. ῥήματα

    rhēmata · G4487

    words, sayings · v63

    The things Jesus has said, above all the hard teaching about the bread from heaven and eating his flesh (6:60). John uses it interchangeably with logos (6:60, "this logos is hard").

  32. ἃ

    ha · G3739

    which · v63, v64

    A relative pronoun that ties the words to the specific act of speaking that follows.

  33. ἐγὼ

    egō · G1473

    I · v63

    Emphatic, because Greek does not need the pronoun: "the words that I myself have spoken". The speaker is the one who came down from heaven (6:38).

  34. λελάληκα

    lelalēka · G2980

    have spoken · v63

    Perfect tense: the words were spoken and still stand with their effect. It looks back at the discourse that has just offended the disciples.

  35. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v63, v64

    It joins two claims: the words are spirit, and they are life.

  36. ζωή

    zōē · G2222

    life · v63

    In John this is the life of God himself, the life of the age to come, already given now to the one who trusts (6:47). Peter echoes it a few verses later: "You have words of eternal life" (6:68).

  37. ἀλλ᾽

    all᾽ · G0235

    but · v64

    A strong contrast. Jesus has just said his words are 'spirit and life' (6:63); 'but' turns to the fact that some of his hearers are not receiving those words.

  38. ἐξ

    ex · G1537

    out of, from · v64

    'Out of' or 'among' you. The unbelievers are part of the group, not outsiders.

  39. τινες

    tines · G5100

    some, certain ones · v64

    'Some.' Jesus does not name anyone, but the narrator will soon point to one of them (6:70-71).

  40. πιστεύουσιν

    pisteuousin · G4100

    to trust, believe · v64

    Present tense: 'are not trusting.' These people follow Jesus around but do not truly rely on him or on his words. Their offence at his teaching (6:61) shows it, and their leaving (6:66) will prove it.

  41. ᾔδει

    ēdei · G1492

    to know · v64

    'He knew.' The word is past-perfect in form, but because οἶδα already works as a present ('I know'), this form simply means 'knew' or 'had been knowing.' It signals settled knowledge, not a sudden discovery.

  42. γὰρ

    gar · G1063

    for · v64

    Brings in the narrator's explanation. It is the gospel writer, not Jesus, speaking to the reader at this point.

  43. ἀρχῆς

    archēs · G0746

    beginning · v64

    'From the beginning.' Most likely the beginning of his ministry, when these followers first joined him (compare 15:27; 16:4). Some readers also hear an echo of 'In the beginning' (1:1).

  44. τίνες

    tines · G5101

    who? which? · v64

    'Who' (plural), opening an indirect question: he knew who they were.

  45. μὴ

    mē · G3361

    not · v64

    The ordinary Greek 'not' used with participles. It means the same as οὐ earlier in the verse.

  46. παραδώσων

    paradōsōn · G3860

    to hand over, deliver · v64

    Future participle: 'the one who will hand [him] over.' At this point in the story the act is still in the future. The word itself means handing someone over into another's power. The treachery comes from who does it: one of the Twelve (6:71).

The world behind it

Where and when. John places the scene in the synagogue at Capernaum (6:59), the day after Jesus fed the five thousand, with Passover near (6:4). Passover recalled the Exodus, and the feeding miracle and the talk of "bread from heaven" would have brought the manna straight to mind (Exod 16; Ps 78:24, quoted in John 6:31). Many Jews of the period expected the Messiah to bring a new gift of manna. One later Jewish text says "the treasury of manna will again descend from on high" (2 Baruch 29:8).

Why the saying was so hard. Jesus had moved from "I am the bread of life" to "unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you have no life in you" (6:53). For Jews, drinking blood was strictly forbidden. Blood carried life and belonged to God alone (Gen 9:4; Lev 17:10–14). Taken literally, the words sounded repulsive. Taken at any level, they claimed that life with God depended on taking in Jesus himself. Add the claim to have "come down from heaven" (6:38, 41–42) by a man whose father and mother they knew, and the "hard word" of v. 60 meant both hard to stomach and hard to accept.

The murmuring tradition. Every synagogue-goer knew the wilderness story: Israel was fed by God and grumbled anyway, and that generation died in the desert (Num 14:27–35; Ps 95:8–11). By using the same verb for the disciples, John's account casts them in that role.

John's first readers. John was probably written late in the first century. Many scholars think the community behind it had known painful defections; compare 1 John 2:19, "they went out from us, but they were not of us". If so, this scene of followers stumbling and leaving would have been familiar to them.

From the study of John 6:61.

Where scholars differ

in v61

What exactly is the 'this' that trips the disciples up?

  • Specifically the command to eat his flesh and drink his blood (vv. 53–58).

    It comes right before v. 60. It cuts against the blood prohibition (Lev 17), and the crowd already argued over it in v. 52 ('How can this man give us his flesh to eat?').

  • The whole discourse, especially the claim to have come down from heaven and to be the source of eternal life.

    The murmuring began over the descent claim (vv. 41–42), and v. 62 answers with ascent 'to where he was before', which points to his heavenly origin as the core problem. Verse 63 then speaks of all 'the words I have spoken'.

in v61

Does the unfinished question of v. 62 make the stumbling block smaller or bigger?

  • Bigger: if this offends you, seeing the Son of Man go up (through the cross, which John calls being 'lifted up', and his return to the Father) will offend you even more.

    In John, 'lifting up' and glorification include the cross (3:14; 12:32–33), the most scandalous event of all (cf. 1 Cor 1:23, 'Christ crucified, a skandalon to Jews').

  • Smaller: seeing him return to heaven would confirm his claim to have come from there and show that 'eating his flesh' was never meant in a crudely physical way.

    Verse 63 ('the flesh is of no help; the words … are spirit and life') immediately points away from a literal-physical reading, and the ascension would prove where he came from.

  • Both: the ascent is at once the greater offence and the vindication, depending on whether one has faith.

    John often uses double meanings, and the open-ended sentence may be meant to leave both senses in play (so, e.g., R. E. Brown, C. K. Barrett).

in v61

How did Jesus know about the murmuring?

  • By supernatural insight: John means that Jesus knows hearts in a way that belongs to God.

    'In himself' together with John's repeated stress on this kind of knowledge (2:24–25; 4:17–18; 6:64; 13:11).

  • By ordinary perception: the muttering may have been audible or visible, and the phrase means only that he realised it.

    γογγύζω can describe audible group muttering, and 'in himself' can simply mean 'inwardly'. However, v. 64 suggests John means more than ordinary perception.

in v62

How should the unfinished question be completed: would seeing the ascent increase the offense or remove it?

  • It would increase the offense: 'then you will be even more scandalized.'

    In John, going up to the Father runs through the cross, being 'lifted up' (3:14; 12:32–33). A crucified Messiah is a worse scandal than the bread discourse. Supporters include many modern commentators (e.g. Barrett, Carson), who often see 'going up' as including the Passion.

  • It would remove or reframe the offense: 'then you will understand.'

    Once he has returned to heaven, his physical flesh is no longer present to be eaten crudely, so his words must mean something by the Spirit (v. 63). This is Augustine's line (Tractates on John 27.3–5), and it is common in older interpretation. It also explains why 'where he was before' is stressed: the ascent confirms that he came from heaven.

  • Both, deliberately.

    The open grammar leaves the choice to the hearer. For unbelievers the 'lifting up' is a deeper scandal. For believers it is a glorification that confirms everything he said. R. E. Brown and others treat the ambiguity as intended, in keeping with John's double meanings.

in v62

What does 'ascending' refer to: the Acts 1 Ascension only, or the cross–resurrection–return as a whole?

  • The ascent to heaven proper.

    The wording 'going up where he was before' points to a place, heaven, and matches 3:13 and 20:17.

  • The whole 'hour' of return, including the cross.

    John uses 'lifted up' and 'glorified' for the crucifixion (12:23, 32–33). He presents Jesus' departure as a single movement back to the Father (13:1; 16:28) and has no separate Ascension narrative.

in v63

What does "the flesh profits nothing" refer to, and does it cancel the "eat my flesh" language of 6:51–58?

  • It refers to Jesus' own flesh: the earlier language was symbolic, and a physical eating or presence in the Lord's Supper is of no benefit. (This was argued in the sixteenth century by Huldrych Zwingli against Martin Luther, e.g. at Marburg, 1529.)

    The verse follows directly on the eating-flesh discourse and uses the same word, sarx. Verse 62 (the ascension) seems to rule out a physical, crude reading.

  • It refers to human nature and fleshly understanding, not to Jesus' flesh. The disciples' crude, literal hearing profits nothing. (Augustine, Tractates on John 27; Chrysostom, Homily 47 on John; later Luther and Catholic interpreters.)

    There is no "my" here, unlike 6:51–56. Jesus has just said his flesh gives life (6:51, 54), so he can hardly be calling it useless. In John, "flesh" commonly means the merely human (3:6; 8:15, "you judge according to the flesh"). Augustine: the flesh profits nothing as they understood it, like meat sold in the market; join the Spirit to the flesh and it profits much.

  • A middle reading held by many modern commentators: even Jesus' flesh, taken on its own and apart from the Spirit and his ascension, would not give life. His flesh gives life only as the Spirit works through it and through his words.

    The verse sets up a contrast of realms (spirit vs. flesh, as in 3:6) rather than a comment on 6:51–56 specifically. It follows the ascension remark (6:62) and anticipates the Spirit given after Jesus is glorified (7:39).

in v63

Is the first "pneuma" the Holy Spirit as a person, or spirit as God's realm and life-power?

  • The Holy Spirit (capitalised in ESV, NIV, NASB, BSB).

    John links the Spirit to new birth (3:5–8), to living water given after Jesus' glorification (7:37–39), and to the breath Jesus breathes on the disciples (20:22). The verb "gives life" is used of a divine agent.

  • Spirit as the divine sphere or principle, God's life-power, set against flesh as the human sphere. The second "spirit" ("my words are spirit") is then clearly descriptive.

    The neat spirit/flesh opposition matches 3:6 and 4:24 ("God is spirit"). The same word in the second half cannot be a person ("the words are spirit"). Lowercase in KJV, WEB and YLT.

  • Both at once: in Jewish usage, God's Spirit is his life-power, so the distinction is sharper in later theology than in John.

    The Old Testament ruach of God (Gen 1:2; Ezek 37) is both God's own presence and his life-giving power, and the two are not separated.

in v64

Which 'beginning' is meant by 'from the beginning'?

  • The beginning of Jesus' ministry, or of the disciples' time with him (including when he chose the Twelve).

    John uses ἐξ/ἀπ᾽ ἀρχῆς this way in 15:27 ('you have been with me from the beginning') and 16:4. Verse 6:70 ('Did I not choose you, the Twelve?') points to the moment of choosing. Brown, Barrett and Carson take this view in their commentaries.

  • An absolute beginning: Jesus' knowledge reaches back before time, as with the Word 'in the beginning' (1:1).

    John stresses Jesus' divine knowledge (2:24-25), and the word ἀρχή recalls the prologue. Critics point out that John uses a different phrase (ἐν ἀρχῇ, 'in the beginning') for that absolute sense.

in v64

How does Jesus' knowing relate to the unbelief and the handing over?

  • His knowledge goes with the Father's sovereign 'giving' (6:37, 44, 65), so that unbelief shows who has not been 'given' to him.

    Verse 65 directly links 6:64 to 'no one can come to me unless it is granted by the Father.' Readers in the Augustinian and Reformed traditions stress this.

  • It is foreknowledge, not cause. The unbelievers and Judas are fully responsible for their choices.

    John treats unbelief as blameworthy (3:19; 12:37-43). Jesus still offers Judas the morsel and the chance to turn back (13:26). The text says what Jesus *knew* and never says he caused it. Readers in the Arminian and Eastern Orthodox traditions stress this.

  • John holds both together without explaining how they fit.

    The same passage has divine giving (6:37, 44, 65) alongside a human call to 'come' and 'believe' (6:29, 35, 40). Many commentators (e.g. Carson, Keener) describe this as tension the text does not resolve.

in v64

Does paradidōmi present Judas as a traitor, or only as the one who 'handed over'?

  • Treachery is clearly in view. 'Betray' is a faithful contextual translation.

    In John's own framing Judas is 'a devil' (6:70), a thief (12:6), and moved by Satan (13:2, 27). Psalm 41:9 is applied to him: 'he who ate my bread has lifted his heel against me' (13:18).

  • The verb is neutral ('hand over'), and the English 'betray' has added more moral colour than the word itself carries.

    W. Klassen (Judas: Betrayer or Friend of Jesus?, 1996) argued this from the verb's ordinary use. Most scholars agree that the verb is neutral but hold that John's context clearly makes the act treacherous.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. σκανδαλίζω, σκάνδαλον
  • BDAG s.v. γογγύζω
  • BDAG s.v. οἶδα
  • LSJ s.v. σκάνδαλον
  • G. Stählin, TDNT s.v. σκάνδαλον, σκανδαλίζω
  • K. H. Rengstorf, TDNT s.v. γογγύζω
  • Septuagint: Exod 16:2–8; Num 11:1; 14:27–29; Lev 19:14; Ps 105(106):25
  • 2 Baruch 29:8 (manna expectation)
  • R. E. Brown, The Gospel according to John I–XII (Anchor Bible)
  • C. K. Barrett, The Gospel according to St John
  • C. S. Keener, The Gospel of John: A Commentary
  • D. A. Carson, The Gospel according to John
  • Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed.
  • Vulgate (Stuttgart edition), John 6:61
  • BDAG s.v. ἀναβαίνω, θεωρέω, πρότερος
  • Blass–Debrunner–Funk, Greek Grammar of the NT §482 (aposiopesis)
  • D. A. Carson, The Gospel according to John (PNTC)
  • Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John 27
  • Philo, Life of Moses 1.158
  • 1 Enoch 37–71 (Parables of Enoch); Daniel 7:13–14 LXX/Theodotion
  • Vulgate (Stuttgart edition), John 6:62
  • NA28 apparatus
  • BDAG s.v. πνεῦμα, σάρξ, ζῳοποιέω, ῥῆμα, ὠφελέω
  • Septuagint: Gen 2:7; Deut 8:3; 32:47; Isa 31:3; 40:6–8; Ezek 37:14; Ps 103:30 LXX
  • NA28 critical apparatus at John 6:63
  • Raymond E. Brown, The Gospel According to John I–XII (Anchor Bible)
  • Craig S. Keener, The Gospel of John: A Commentary
  • D. A. Carson, The Gospel According to John (Pillar)
  • John Chrysostom, Homilies on John 47
  • Vulgate, John 6:63
  • BDAG s.v. πιστεύω
  • BDAG s.v. παραδίδωμι
  • BDAG s.v. ἀρχή
  • Louw-Nida 37.111 (παραδίδωμι, 'hand over into custody')
  • Septuagint: Isaiah 53:6, 12; Genesis 15:6; Isaiah 7:9
  • R. E. Brown, The Gospel According to John I–XII (Anchor Bible)
  • C. K. Barrett, The Gospel According to St John
  • D. A. Carson, The Gospel According to John (Pillar NT Commentary)
  • W. Klassen, Judas: Betrayer or Friend of Jesus? (1996)
  • Vulgate, John 6:64

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).