Mark Chapter 12 Read as one passage
Mark 12:13–17
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
13Later, they sent some of the Pharisees and Herodians to catch Jesus in His words. 14“Teacher,” they said, “we know that You are honest and seek favor from no one. Indeed, You are impartial and teach the way of God in accordance with the truth. Is it lawful to pay taxes to Caesar or not? Should we pay them or not?” 15But Jesus saw through their hypocrisy and said, “Why are you testing Me? Bring Me a denarius to inspect.” 16So they brought it, and He asked them, “Whose image is this? And whose inscription?” “Caesar’s,” they answered. 17Then Jesus told them, “Give to Caesar what is Caesar’s, and to God what is God’s.” And they marveled at Him.
What the first hearers heard
Mark's readers learn the delegation's real aim before the delegates open their mouths. That shapes everything that follows: the praise in verse 14 reads as bait, and Jesus' reply in verse 17 reads as an escape from a hunter's net as well as a piece of teaching.
The verse also confirms the storyline that runs through Mark. The leaders' hostility has moved from a plot in Galilee (3:6) to a coordinated effort in Jerusalem. Listeners who had just heard the parable of the tenants would see the tenants' scheme against the son beginning to play out in real life.
Mark's first readers, wherever exactly they lived (Rome and Syria are the main suggestions), knew what it meant to live under Caesar and to have words reported to the authorities. For them, a scene in which hostile questioners try to draw out a politically fatal statement would have felt close to home. How directly Mark intended that connection cannot be proved, but the setting makes it natural.
From the study of Mark 12:13.
Verse by verse
-
13Later, they sent some of the Pharisees and Herodians to catch Jesus in His words.
Full study →The men who have just realized that Jesus' parable was aimed at them cannot lay hands on him, because the crowd is watching. So they do the next thing: they send people to him. Mark tells it in the present tense, as if it were unfolding before us. The delegates are hand-picked from two groups who would not normally stand together: Pharisees, whose reputation for devotion to the law carried weight with ordinary people, and Herodians, backers of the Herod family, whose power depended on Rome.
Then Mark states the purpose before anyone speaks: they have come to catch him. The word is a hunter's and fisherman's word, used of taking prey, and it appears nowhere else in the New Testament. Jesus is the quarry. And the net is a word, in the singular: one statement drawn out of him in public, one line that could be used against him. What force could not do safely, speech might. The reader therefore knows, before hearing the flattering "Teacher, we know that you are honest" in the next verse, that it is bait.
-
14“Teacher,” they said, “we know that You are honest and seek favor from no one. Indeed, You are impartial and teach the way of God in accordance with the truth. Is it lawful to pay taxes to Caesar or not? Should we pay them or not?”
Full study →They came up to him and said: "Teacher, Rabbi, you who rule on what God's law requires: we know for a fact that you are a man of truth. You say what is so. No one's standing weighs with you at all. You do not look at a person's 'face', their rank, wealth or power, to decide what you will say. You are like the impartial judge the Torah demands, like God himself, who 'does not lift faces'. Instead you teach the way of God, the life God requires, truly, without bending it for anyone.
So rule for us: does God's law permit us to hand over the census tax, the Roman head-tax that marks us as Caesar's subjects, to Caesar, or not?" (And, pressing for a plain yes or no: "Do we pay, or don't we?")
The compliments are a trap. Each one is true of Jesus, but they are offered to box him in. A man who fears no one and teaches God's way without compromise cannot hedge, they imply, so he must say either 'yes' and seem to bless pagan rule, or 'no' and declare Rome's tax against God's law, which was treason in Roman eyes. Even the wording is loaded: they ask whether it is permitted to give Caesar his tax, and they set 'the way of God' right beside 'Caesar', as though the two could not both be honoured.
-
15But Jesus saw through their hypocrisy and said, “Why are you testing Me? Bring Me a denarius to inspect.”
Full study →“Do we pay it, or don't we?” they pressed. But Jesus already saw what they were doing. Their admiring words about his honesty were a performance, an act put on to bait a trap. He said to them, “Why are you putting me to the test? Bring me a denarius,” meaning the Roman silver coin worth about a day's wage and stamped with the emperor's head, “so I can have a look at it.”
A few details carry more weight than English shows:
- “Give”: they ask whether they should give the tribute. In v.17 Jesus will answer “give back” to Caesar, recasting the payment as returning what is already his.
- “Hypocrisy” here is play-acting in the stage sense. The flattery of v.14 was a mask, and Jesus names it.
- “Test” means a hostile test meant to catch him out, a question built so that both answers are fatal, rather than enticement to sin.
- He has them bring the coin. He does not take one out himself, so it is his questioners who hold Caesar's coin. The verse opens with him knowing and closes with him asking to see, two words from the same Greek root.
-
16So they brought it, and He asked them, “Whose image is this? And whose inscription?” “Caesar’s,” they answered.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
17Then Jesus told them, “Give to Caesar what is Caesar’s, and to God what is God’s.” And they marveled at Him.
Full study →Jesus answered them: “Caesar's things, pay them back to Caesar, and God's things, pay them back to God.” And they just stood there, utterly astonished at him.
The questioners had asked whether the Law allows Jews to give the Roman census tax to Caesar. Jesus answers with a different verb, one that means pay back what you owe or return to its owner. The silver denarius they had just produced bore Caesar's portrait and a stamp calling him “son of the divine Augustus.” By their own admission it is Caesar's, so handing it back to him is no act of worship and no betrayal of God. It is returning a man's property to him.
The same verb carries into the second half. There is a debt owed to God too, and to a Jewish listener in the temple courts, God's share was not one half of life. “The earth is the LORD's and everything in it.” Caesar's claim stops at his stamped silver. God's claim covers everything that bears his image, including the people holding the coin. The answer tells them to pay the tax, and it refuses Caesar's claim to be divine. For leaders who had just heard the parable of tenants refusing to give the vineyard's owner his share (12:1–12), it was also a demand. Neither the Pharisees nor the Herodians could use it against him, and they were left amazed.
Where the English drifted
-
in v13
catch ... in his words
agreuō ... logō
- What we hear
- Catching someone out: exposing a slip or an inconsistency, as in a debate or an interview, with embarrassment as the likely cost.
- What they heard
- Taking prey. The verb comes from hunting and fishing, and the aim here is capture, in a setting where the right statement could lead to arrest and execution.
-
in v13
Pharisees
Pharisaioi
- What we hear
- Self-righteous hypocrites, with the group's name serving as a byword for religious fakery.
- What they heard
- Members of a respected movement known for its careful practice of the law and its influence with the people. Mark's "some of" points to a selected delegation, not the whole group. Jesus does accuse these particular men of hypocrisy in verse 15.
-
in v14
carest for no man (KJV)
ou melei soi peri oudenos
- What we hear
- You don't care about anybody, you are cold or indifferent to people.
- What they heard
- No one's opinion or status influences you. You are not beholden to anyone and do not shape your teaching to win favour.
-
in v14
Master (KJV)
didaskale
- What we hear
- Lord, owner, someone in command.
- What they heard
- Teacher, the Greek counterpart of 'Rabbi'. In 1611 'master' could still mean schoolmaster.
-
in v14
lawful
exestin
- What we hear
- Legal under the government's laws.
- What they heard
- Permitted under God's law, the Torah. It asks for a religious-legal ruling of the kind Jewish teachers gave.
-
in v15
tempt (KJV: "Why tempt ye me?")
peirazō
- What we hear
- Trying to lure Jesus into doing something sinful or giving in to a desire.
- What they heard
- Putting him to the test with a hostile question, trying to trap him into an answer they could use against him.
-
in v15
penny (KJV)
dēnarion
- What we hear
- A coin of almost no value.
- What they heard
- A Roman silver coin worth about a day's wage, stamped with the emperor's portrait and titles. It was a visible sign of Roman rule.
-
in v15
hypocrisy
hypokrisis
- What we hear
- Failing to live up to what you preach; general inconsistency.
- What they heard
- A deliberate performance: acting the part of sincere admirers in order to set a trap.
-
in v17
Give (to Caesar)
apodote
- What we hear
- A voluntary handing over, like a donation or present.
- What they heard
- Pay back what is owed, or return something to its owner. Jesus deliberately replaces the questioners' plain “give” (dounai) with this word for settling a debt.
-
in v17
Render (to Caesar)
apodote
- What we hear
- To depict, process or produce something (as in rendering an image or rendering fat), or a vague formal word for “give.”
- What they heard
- Give back or pay what is due. Through the Latin reddite of the Vulgate, the English word “render” originally meant exactly this.
-
in v17
Caesar
Kaisar
- What we hear
- “The government” or “the state” in general, or Julius Caesar personally.
- What they heard
- The reigning emperor, Tiberius: a particular pagan ruler whose coins called him son of a god and chief priest, and who ruled Judea through a governor.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v17
“Give to Caesar” is not a fifty-fifty split
- What's often taught
- In this verse Jesus divides life into two separate and equal domains, a secular one ruled by the state and a sacred one ruled by God, each with its own independent authority. This is often treated as the biblical basis for the separation of church and state.
- What the text supports
Part of this is right. Jesus really does tell his hearers to pay the tax (apodote, “pay back what is owed”), and he rejects the revolutionary view that paying it betrays God. The two halves are not equal, though:
- Caesar's share is defined by the coin. It carries his image and name, so it goes back to him. His claim reaches as far as his stamped silver.
- God's share has no such limit. To a Jew in the temple courts, “the things of God” meant everything (Ps 24:1; Lev 25:23), Caesar included. The coin's claim that Caesar was son of a god is quietly refused.
- The context points the same way. The parable just before (12:1–12) is about withholding what is owed to God, and the same phrase “the things of God” in Mark 8:33 means God's ultimate purposes.
So the verse sets civil duty inside the far larger duty owed to God. It is not a charter for two independent kingdoms. How Christians should relate church to state today is a real question, but it is a later one, and this saying does not answer it in modern terms.
- Where the English feeds it
- Smooth renderings like “Give to Caesar what is Caesar's, and to God what is God's” sound perfectly balanced, and when “Caesar” is heard as “the government” the saying becomes an abstract political principle. “Give” also hides the debt language (“pay back”) that ties both halves to the coin's ownership marks.
Every word
-
Καὶ
Kai · G2532
and · v13, v14, v17
Mark's usual plain link between scenes. It ties this move directly to verse 12, where the leaders wanted to arrest Jesus and backed off, but it does not say how much time passed.
-
ἀποστέλλουσιν
apostellousin · G0649
to send · v13
"They send": a past event told in the present tense, as Mark often does, so the reader watches it happen. The unnamed "they" are the chief priests, scribes and elders of 11:27, who now act through agents instead of coming themselves.
-
πρὸς
pros · G4314
to/with · v13
Direction toward a person: the delegation is aimed at Jesus. The word is neutral on its own, and the hostility arrives at the end of the sentence.
-
αὐτόν
auton · G0846
-
τινας
tinas · G5100
one, a certain, some · v13
"Some" or "certain ones": a selected group, not the whole of either party. Mark is describing a particular delegation, not every Pharisee or every Herodian.
-
τῶν
tōn · G3588
the/this/who · v13, v14, v15, v17
"Of the": marks the Pharisees as a known group from which the delegates are drawn.
-
Φαρισαίων
Pharisaiōn · G5330
Pharisee · v13
Members of the respected, largely lay movement devoted to careful keeping of the law and ancestral tradition. Their presence gives the coming question credibility with ordinary Jewish listeners.
-
Ἡρῳδιανῶν
Hērōdianōn · G2265
Herodians · v13
"Herod's people": most likely supporters of the Herod family, whose power rested on Rome. They are the people who would notice, and could report, anything said against Roman rule.
-
ἵνα
hina · G2443
in order that/to · v13, v15
States the purpose outright. Before the delegates have said a word, Mark tells the reader that the coming compliments and question are bait.
-
ἀγρεύσωσιν
agreusōsin · G0064
to catch · v13
A hunter's and fisherman's word, used nowhere else in the New Testament: to take as prey. It casts Jesus as quarry and the delegation as hunters, and the form looks to one successful capture.
-
λόγῳ
logō · G3056
word · v13
Singular: "by a word", a single statement or the exchange that draws it out. The net is speech, because the leaders cannot safely seize him by force. This is ordinary speech, not the title "the Word" of John 1:1.
-
ἐλθόντες
elthontes · G2064
having come · v14
The delegation of Pharisees and Herodians that was 'sent' (v.13) arrives. The scene is the temple courts in Jerusalem during Passover week (11:27).
-
λέγουσιν
legousin · G3004
they say · v14
Present tense used for past action, which makes the scene vivid ('they say'). This is typical of Mark.
-
διδάσκαλε
didaskale · G1320
teacher · v14
A respectful address, the Greek equivalent of 'Rabbi' (compare John 1:38). It treats Jesus as a recognised authority on God's law, and so as someone expected to give a legal ruling.
-
οἴδαμεν
oidamen · G6063
we know · v14, v15
'We know (for a fact)'. It is a confident claim. In context it is flattery meant to bind Jesus to a straight answer, because Mark has already said their aim is to trap him.
-
ὅτι
hoti · G3754
that · v14
Introduces what they claim to know.
-
ἀληθὴς
alēthēs · G227
true, truthful · v14
Said of a person, it means honest, sincere, someone whose words match reality and who does not shade the truth. Placed first in its clause for emphasis.
-
εἶ
ei · G1510
you are · v14
Simple present: this is what you characteristically are.
-
οὐ
ou · G3756
not · v14
Negates 'it is a concern'.
-
μέλει
melei · G3199
it is a concern · v14
An impersonal idiom: 'it matters to someone'. Here: no one's standing or opinion weighs on you or makes you adjust your teaching. It is not a claim that he is unfeeling.
-
σοι
soi · G4771
to you · v14
The person to whom something does or does not matter.
-
περὶ
peri · G4012
about · v14
'Concerning'. It marks what the concern would be about.
-
οὐδενός
oudenos · G3762
no one · v14
'About no one at all'. Greek stacks negatives for emphasis: you are not beholden to anybody, high or low.
-
γὰρ
gar · G1063
for · v14
Explains the previous phrase: the reason no one sways you is that you do not judge by a person's 'face'.
-
βλέπεις
blepeis · G991
you look · v14
With 'into the face' it forms a Semitic idiom for showing partiality: letting someone's rank or influence decide how you rule.
-
εἰς
eis · G1519
into, at · v14
'Look at, have regard to'.
-
πρόσωπον
prosōpon · G4383
face · v14
The 'face' stands for a person's outward standing: status, wealth, power, reputation. It echoes the Torah's ban on 'regarding faces' in judgment.
-
ἀνθρώπων
anthrōpōn · G444
of people · v14
'Of human beings', in general and including the powerful. It quietly sets up the contrast with 'God' later in the verse, and with Caesar.
-
ἀλλ᾽
all' · G235
but · v14
A strong contrast: not human faces, but truth.
-
ἐπ᾽
ep' · G1909
upon, on the basis of · v14, v17
With 'truth' it forms an idiom, 'in truth, truly', meaning in accordance with what is really so.
-
ἀληθείας
alētheias · G225
truth · v14
Reality as it actually is, as opposed to pretence or slanted presentation. Your teaching about God's way is not bent to please anyone.
-
ὁδὸν
hodon · G3598
way, road · v14
The path of life God requires, the conduct his law lays out. In this setting it means the teaching of how to live before God.
-
θεοῦ
theou · G2316
God · v14, v17
The God of Israel. 'The way of God' sets up the coming clash with the claims of Caesar.
-
διδάσκεις
didaskeis · G1321
you teach · v14
Picks up 'Teacher'. Your habit is to teach God's way straight, so (they imply) you must rule on this question straight.
-
ἔξεστιν
exestin · G1832
-
δοῦναι
dounai · G1325
to give · v14, v15
'To give, pay'. Their verb frames the tax as a gift handed over. Jesus' reply in v.17 switches to 'give back' (apodote), meaning return what is owed.
-
κῆνσον
kēnson · G2778
census, poll-tax · v14
A Latin loanword (census): the Roman head-tax assessed by census on the inhabitants of Judea. It was the most visible sign of subjection to Rome.
-
Καίσαρι
Kaisari · G2541
Caesar · v14, v17
The Roman emperor, at this date Tiberius. 'Caesar' had become the ruler's title.
-
ἢ
ē · G2228
or · v14, v15
Offers only two options. That is the trap.
-
μὴ
mē · G3361
not · v15
The negative used with the subjunctive: 'or should we not give?'
-
δὲ
de · G1161
but, and · v15
Marks the turn. They have finished their act, and now he answers it.
-
ὑπόκρισιν
hypokrisin · G5272
hypocrisy, play-acting, pretence · v15
The role they are performing: sincere seekers who admire an honest teacher. Underneath it is a plan to trap him. The word looks back to the flattery in v.14.
-
εἶπεν
eipen · G2036
said · v15, v17
Simple past tense ('he said'). He answers at once and directly.
-
τί
ti · G5101
why? what? · v15
'Why?' This question is not looking for information. It tells them he can see what they are doing.
-
με
me · G3165
me · v15
'Me' comes before the verb in Greek, which gives it emphasis. It is Jesus they are trying to trip up.
-
πειράζετε;
peirazete · G3985
to test, put to the proof, try to trap · v15
'Are you testing me?' The present tense shows the testing is going on right now. Here the word means a hostile test meant to catch him out, not an attempt to lure him into sin.
-
φέρετέ
pherete · G5342
bring, carry · v15
'Bring.' A command addressed to all of them. Jesus takes control of the exchange and makes them produce the evidence.
-
δηνάριον
dēnarion · G1220
denarius · v15
The Roman silver coin, roughly a day's pay for a labourer (Matt 20:2). It carried the emperor's portrait and titles, so it stood for Roman rule and was the kind of coin linked with the tribute.
-
ἴδω.
idō · G1492
see, look at · v15
'That I may see/look at it.' He wants to examine the coin closely, which sets up the question in v.16, 'Whose image and inscription?' The verb comes from the same root as 'knowing' (eidōs) earlier in the verse: he sees through them, and now he will look at their coin.
-
Ἰησοῦς
Iēsous · G2424
Jesus · v17
The Greek form of Yeshua/Joshua, “YHWH saves.” Here Jesus is the one being tested in the temple courts, and now he answers.
-
ἀπόδοτε
apodote · G591
give back, pay (what is owed) · v17
A plural command meaning “give back” or “pay what you owe.” The questioners asked whether one may “give” (dounai, 12:14). Jesus answers with the compound verb for repaying a debt, which makes the tax something owed, not a gift.
-
ἐξεθαύμαζον
exethaumazon · G6028
were greatly amazed · v17
A strengthened form of “marvel” (ek- means “out,” so “utterly”), in a tense that describes an ongoing state: they stood there astonished. It appears nowhere else in the New Testament.
The world behind it
Where and when. This takes place in the Jerusalem temple courts in the days before Passover (Mark 11:27; 14:1), when the city was crowded with pilgrims and national hopes ran high. The people sending the delegation are the chief priests, scribes and elders who challenged Jesus' authority in 11:27-33. Verse 12 explains their problem: they want to arrest him, but they fear the crowd.
Why a single word could be fatal. Judea had been under direct Roman rule since AD 6, when a Roman census and tax prompted Judas the Galilean to lead a revolt, arguing that God alone was Israel's master (Josephus, War 2.118; Antiquities 18.1-10). So the next verse's question, whether to pay the tax to Caesar, was explosive. Saying "pay" could cost Jesus the crowd that was protecting him. Saying "don't pay" could be reported as sedition, a matter for the Roman governor, who could impose death. Luke says this outright: they wanted to hand him over to the governor (Luke 20:20).
Why this odd pairing. Pharisees and Herod's supporters had different loyalties. Josephus reports many Pharisees refusing a loyalty oath to Caesar and Herod (Antiquities 17.41-45). Mark has already shown these two groups joining forces against Jesus, plotting his death back in Galilee (3:6), so this verse picks up that thread. Together they cover both sides of the trap: one has standing with the people, the other has an interest in Rome's order.
Public challenge. In this culture, public debate was also a contest for honor. A teacher questioned before a crowd had to answer, and a poor answer could damage his standing at once. This verse opens a series of such tests in the temple courts (12:13-34), which ends with no one daring to question him further.
From the study of Mark 12:13.
Where scholars differ
in v13
Who exactly were the Herodians?
-
Political supporters of the Herod family, without being a formal party or sect. This is the most widely held view.
The word's ending marks attachment to a person (compare *Caesariani*). Josephus uses similar labels for Herod the Great's partisans (*War* 1.319; *Antiquities* 14.450). Herod Antipas ruled Galilee at this time, which fits the first plot there in Mark 3:6.
-
Officials, courtiers or household members of Herod Antipas, a more specific group.
Antipas had a court and staff, and Luke 23:7 places him in Jerusalem at Passover, which could explain the presence of his people there. However, no source clearly uses the term this way.
-
A religious sect, perhaps one that attached religious hopes to Herod.
Later Christian writers such as Epiphanius describe them this way, but they wrote centuries later, and no first-century source supports it. Most scholars give it little weight.
in v13
Whose "word" is the net: something Jesus would say, or the delegation's question?
-
Jesus' own statement: they aim to catch him in something he says. Most English versions take it this way.
Luke 20:20 explicitly says "his word", and Matthew 22:15 has "in a word". The story turns on what Jesus will answer.
-
The means they use: they aim to catch him by a word, meaning their loaded question.
The Greek dative without a preposition commonly expresses means, and the next verse presents the trap as a question. WEB's "with words" leans this way.
-
The two cannot be sharply separated.
The question is the bait, and the answer would be the catch. The bare Greek phrase can cover the whole verbal exchange, and the meaning of the scene is much the same on either reading.
in v14
What exactly made paying the tax religiously objectionable?
-
Sovereignty: paying the census acknowledged a human lord in God's place over God's land and people.
Josephus' account of Judas the Galilean's teaching (Antiquities 18.4–10, 23; War 2.118), and the Jewish belief that the land belonged to God (Lev 25:23).
-
Idolatry: the coin itself carried the emperor's image and divine titles, a problem under the commandment against images.
Jesus asks for a denarius and asks 'whose image and inscription?' (vv.15–16). The Tiberius denarius read 'son of the divine Augustus'. Jewish sensitivity to images is recorded in Josephus (e.g., the protests over Pilate's standards, Antiquities 18.55–59).
-
Both together, along with the economic burden of Roman taxation.
The question as asked concerns legality under Torah, and Jesus' answer addresses both the coin's image and what belongs to God.
in v14
Is the questioners' praise purely insincere?
-
It is calculated flattery meant to remove any possibility of evasion.
Mark frames it with 'to catch him in a word' (v.13) and 'knowing their hypocrisy' (v.15).
-
It is insincere in motive but accurate in content, a deliberate irony by Mark.
Mark repeatedly lets opponents state truths about Jesus unwittingly (15:2, 18, 26, 32). Jesus' answer does prove them right: he answers without fear of Caesar or the crowd.
in v15
Is it significant that the questioners, not Jesus, produce the denarius, and that they do it in the Temple courts?
-
Yes. It exposes them. They carry and use a coin bearing a human image and claims of divinity, even within the Temple precincts, which undercuts any show of religious scruple about paying the tax.
The scene is set in the Temple (11:27). Jesus asks them to 'bring' one, so he apparently has none at hand. Jewish coinage of the time avoided human portraits, and some groups strongly objected to images.
-
The detail is mainly practical and should not be over-read. It simply sets up the 'whose image?' question in v.16.
Mark makes no comment on the questioners' possession of the coin. Roman coins circulated in Judea and handling one was not obviously scandalous to most Jews. The emphasis falls on the image and the reply in v.17.
in v15
What exactly was the coin, and was the tribute paid in denarii?
-
A denarius of Tiberius (the 'tribute penny'), with his portrait and the title 'son of the divine Augustus'. It was the expected currency of the tax.
Tiberius reigned c. 14–37 AD and his denarii were mass-produced. Mark's parallel accounts also call it a denarius (Matt 22:19 even says 'the coin for the tax').
-
Any imperial denarius would fit. Denarii were relatively uncommon in Judea, and the tax may have been paid in other silver, so the request highlights the Roman coin as a symbol more than as the only way to pay.
Hoard evidence from Judea is dominated by Tyrian silver and local bronze. Mark does not name the emperor on the coin.
in v15
What shade of 'hypocrisy' does Mark mean?
-
Play-acting: an insincere performance, here the flattery of v.14 masking a trap.
The word's classical stage meaning, and the close link to the staged praise in v.14.
-
A heavier Jewish-Greek sense of malicious, even godless falsehood.
The Greek Old Testament uses hypokritēs for Hebrew ḥānēp ('godless') in Job, and Matthew's parallel substitutes ponēria ('wickedness'). Both senses can be present here.
in v17
What is the relationship between the two clauses: two legitimate spheres, or God's claim swallowing Caesar's?
-
Two real obligations. Jesus affirms that paying the tax is legitimate and also commands loyalty to God, so civil duty has its own, though limited, place.
The real command “pay back” is applied to Caesar. Jewish practice of paying foreign rulers (Jer 29:7; Josephus on the sacrifices for the emperor). Early Christian application in Rom 13:7 and 1 Pet 2:13–17. Jesus clearly rejects the revolutionary position of Judas the Galilean.
-
Unequal claims. The second clause relativises the first: Caesar gets his coin, but God owns everything, including Caesar.
For a Jewish listener “the things of God” takes in all of creation (Ps 24:1; 1 Chr 29:11–14; Lev 25:23). The inscription's divine claims are implicitly rejected. Mark 8:33 uses “the things of God” for ultimate priorities. The vineyard parable just before (12:1–12) is about withholding God's due.
-
A subversive or ironic answer. “Give Caesar back his idolatrous coin” means be rid of it, implying distance from Rome or even resistance.
The coin's image and divine titles, Jesus' not carrying one, and the 1 Macc 2:68 echo (“pay back the Gentiles”) all point this way. Against it: the questioners and the Gospels' own later framing treat the answer as permitting payment (cf. Luke 23:2, where the opposite accusation is presented as false).
in v17
Does the saying deliberately allude to humans as bearing God's image (Genesis 1:26–27)?
-
Yes, or at least strongly implied: the coin bears Caesar's image, so give it to him; people bear God's image, so give yourselves to God.
The word eikōn (“image”) in v.16 is the same word as Genesis 1:26–27 in the LXX. “The things of God” needs some content, and this supplies it. The reading appears early (Tertullian, On Idolatry 15; Against Marcion 4.38) and is widely held by commentators.
-
Possible but not demonstrable. Mark does not spell out a Genesis link, and the main point is ownership marked by a stamp.
Neither Mark nor Matthew nor Luke draws the connection. Eikōn was the ordinary word for a portrait on a coin. The structure of the saying works without the allusion.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. ἀγρεύω
- BDAG s.v. λόγος
- BDAG s.v. Ἡρῳδιανοί
- BDAG s.v. Φαρισαῖος
- Liddell-Scott-Jones s.v. ἀγρεύω
- Septuagint: Job 10:16; Proverbs 5:22; 6:25-26; Hosea 5:2
- Josephus, Jewish War 1.319; 2.118; 2.162
- Josephus, Antiquities 13.297-298; 14.450; 17.41-45; 18.1-15
- H. H. Rowley, "The Herodians in the Gospels", Journal of Theological Studies 41 (1940)
- E. Bickerman, "Les Hérodiens", Revue Biblique 47 (1938)
- H. Hoehner, Herod Antipas (1972)
- J. P. Meier, "The Historical Jesus and the Historical Herodians", Journal of Biblical Literature 119 (2000)
- A. Saldarini, Pharisees, Scribes and Sadducees in Palestinian Society (1988)
- J. Marcus, Mark 8-16, Anchor Yale Bible (2009)
- R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark, NIGTC (2002)
- BDAG s.v. κῆνσος, μέλω, πρόσωπον, ἔξεστι, ἀληθής
- Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. κῆνσος, πρόσωπον
- Josephus, Antiquities 18.1–10, 18.55–59; Jewish War 2.117–118
- LXX Leviticus 19:15; Deuteronomy 1:17; 10:17; 16:19
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Mark 12:13–17
- Nestle-Aland 28 apparatus, Mark 12:14
- BDAG s.v. ὑπόκρισις, πειράζω, δηνάριον, δίδωμι
- LSJ s.v. ὑπόκρισις
- TDNT (U. Wilckens) s.v. ὑποκρίνομαι
- Josephus, Jewish War 2.117–118; Antiquities 18.1–10
- 2 Maccabees 6:24–25; 4 Maccabees 6:15–17
- Nestle-Aland 28 apparatus, Mark 12:14–15
- J. Marcus, Mark 8–16 (Anchor Yale Bible)
- R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark (NIGTC)
- Roman Imperial Coinage I, Tiberius denarius (TI CAESAR DIVI AVG F AVGVSTVS)
- Matthew 22:15–22; Luke 20:20–26 (Synoptic parallels)
- BDAG s.v. ἀποδίδωμι
- BDAG s.v. ἐκθαυμάζω
- BDAG s.v. Καῖσαρ
- Josephus, Antiquities 18.1–10; Jewish War 2.117–118, 2.197; Against Apion 2.77
- Tertullian, On Idolatry 15; Against Marcion 4.38
- LXX Genesis 1:26–27; Psalm 49:14 (MT 50:14); 1 Maccabees 2:68; Sirach 27:23; 43:18
- Gospel of Thomas 100
- Joel Marcus, Mark 8–16 (Anchor Yale Bible)
- Craig A. Evans, Mark 8:27–16:20 (WBC)
- B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.