Mark Chapter 2 Read as one passage
Mark 2:17–22
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
17On hearing this, Jesus told them, “It is not the healthy who need a doctor, but the sick. I have not come to call the righteous, but sinners.” 18Now John’s disciples and the Pharisees were often fasting. So people came to Jesus and asked, “Why don’t Your disciples fast like John’s disciples and those of the Pharisees?” 19Jesus replied, “How can the guests of the bridegroom fast while He is with them? As long as He is with them, they cannot fast. 20But the time will come when the bridegroom will be taken from them; then they will fast. 21No one sews a patch of unshrunk cloth on an old garment. If he does, the new piece will pull away from the old, and a worse tear will result. 22And no one pours new wine into old wineskins. If he does, the wine will burst the skins, and both the wine and the wineskins will be ruined. Instead, new wine is poured into new wineskins.”
What the first hearers heard
For those at the table and those watching. The critics heard their objection turned back on them with a proverb they could not easily dispute. Nobody blames a physician for being near disease. The insult was in the frame: if Jesus is the physician, then they have cast themselves as the "healthy" with no need of him. The toll collectors and "sinners" heard something unusual from a teacher with a holy reputation. They were not tolerated guests. They were the people his mission was aimed at, invited and called the way Levi had just been.
For Mark's readers (often placed in Rome around AD 65–70, in communities that mixed Jews and Gentiles), the story spoke to a live question: who may share the community's table? Paul's clash with Peter over eating with Gentiles (Galatians 2:11–14) shows how heated this issue was. Mark's account roots the community's open table in Jesus' own practice and his own words about why he came.
In Israel's story, the physician image reminded hearers that God had promised to be Israel's healer (Exodus 15:26) and to heal its waywardness (Jeremiah 3:22; Hosea 14:4). By describing his table fellowship in those terms, Jesus presented it as that promised restoration beginning. He was gathering the strays rather than guarding the boundary against them.
From the study of Mark 2:17.
Verse by verse
-
17On hearing this, Jesus told them, “It is not the healthy who need a doctor, but the sick. I have not come to call the righteous, but sinners.”
Full study →The religious experts had asked his disciples, not Jesus, why their teacher would share a table with toll-collectors and people everyone knew to be "sinners." Jesus overhears and answers them directly, and Mark tells it in the present tense as if it were happening now:
"People who are strong and well don't need a physician. People who are in a bad way do. And I didn't come to invite the righteous, the people already in good standing with God's covenant. I came to invite sinners, the very people you've written off."
The first sentence is a proverb his hearers would have known. A physician who stays away from the sick is not being careful; he is failing at his job. His place is at the bedside. The second sentence explains it. Jesus uses his critics' own word, "sinners," and does not argue with the label. He reverses its consequence: their condition is the reason he is at this table, not a reason to leave it.
The word "call" also means "invite," the word for asking someone to dinner, and it is the word for calling a disciple. Jesus has just called Levi away from his toll booth, and now he is reclining at Levi's banquet with Levi's friends. The meal is the invitation.
Whether "the righteous" is meant ironically ("those who think they're healthy") or straightforwardly ("the faithful aren't my urgent case") is left open. Either way, the critics are cast as people who see themselves as having no need.
In Mark's original wording the sentence ends on the word "sinners." The phrase "to repentance" in some Bibles was added later from Luke's version.
-
18Now John’s disciples and the Pharisees were often fasting. So people came to Jesus and asked, “Why don’t Your disciples fast like John’s disciples and those of the Pharisees?”
Full study →At that time John the Baptizer's followers and the Pharisees were keeping a fast. Fasting was a regular, visible part of their devotion: going without food from dawn to dusk to mourn, to humble themselves before God over Israel's sins, and to plead for God's redemption. So people come to Jesus (Mark tells it in the present tense, as if it were happening before us) and challenge him directly: "Why is it that John's students fast, and the Pharisees' students fast, but your own students don't fast?"
The question is aimed at the teacher, because a teacher was answerable for how his followers lived. It sets three schools of devotion side by side and makes Jesus' group the odd one out. And it comes straight after Jesus has been seen eating and drinking with tax collectors and sinners (2:15–17), so it really asks: What kind of holy man lets his followers feast when serious people are mourning? Jesus' answer in the next verse (no one fasts at a wedding while the bridegroom is present) assumes this meaning of fasting. The question is not about willpower or diet. It is about whether this is a time to mourn or a time to celebrate.
-
19Jesus replied, “How can the guests of the bridegroom fast while He is with them? As long as He is with them, they cannot fast.
Full study →Jesus answered the people who asked why his disciples did not fast, as John's disciples and the Pharisees did. He replied with a question that expected the answer 'Of course not!':
"Surely the bridegroom's own wedding party can't fast while the bridegroom is right here with them, can they? For as long as they have the bridegroom among them, fasting is simply impossible for them."
The people he describes are not children and not just any guests. They are the groom's own company of attendants and close friends, whose role during the week-long wedding feast was to celebrate with him. Jewish custom even excused them from some ordinary religious duties during those days. Fasting in that culture was the outward sign of mourning, repentance or anxious waiting for God to act. To fast at a wedding would be to grieve at a party: absurd, and an insult to the groom.
The word 'cannot' therefore does not mean a rule forbids it. It means fasting contradicts the moment. Jesus places himself at the centre of the picture as the bridegroom, a role Israel's prophets gave to God himself when they spoke of the coming day of restoration as a wedding. The moment the prophets waited for is here, and the fitting response is joy.
There is also a quiet hint of an ending. 'As long as they have the bridegroom' implies that this time is limited. The next verse says it plainly: the bridegroom will be taken away, and then they will fast.
-
20But the time will come when the bridegroom will be taken from them; then they will fast.
Full study →"But days are coming" (said the way the prophets announced a turning point in God's dealings with Israel) "when the bridegroom will have been taken away from them, removed from their company by others. And then, and only then, they will fast: on that day."
Jesus has just said that his disciples are like the groom's companions at a wedding (v. 19). You do not put on mourning and refuse food at a wedding feast while the groom is there; it would be absurd, even insulting. This verse turns that joke dark. The groom will not simply leave when the party ends. He will be taken. The verb is passive and says "away from them" twice, once inside the verb and once in the following phrase. When that happens, the companions' joy will give way to grief, and fasting, the ordinary sign of grief, will become right.
So the verse does two things. It defends the disciples: they are not lax, they are celebrating at the right time. And it quietly predicts a violent loss, the first hint in Mark that Jesus' story ends in his removal. The move from "days" to "that day" narrows from a coming period to the moment itself. Fasting is not abolished. It is tied to the bridegroom's absence.
-
21No one sews a patch of unshrunk cloth on an old garment. If he does, the new piece will pull away from the old, and a worse tear will result.
Full study →"Nobody takes a scrap of raw, never-washed wool, cloth that has not yet been through the fuller's shrinking process, and stitches it over a hole in an old cloak that years of washing have already shrunk. If someone does, the patch, the very piece meant to fill the hole, will shrink the first time it gets wet and drag at the worn cloth around it. The new pulls away from the old, and you end up with a worse rip than the one you started with."
The saying is a piece of household common sense that every listener would recognise, and it is spoken in the middle of a dispute about why Jesus' disciples do not fast (2:18–20). The weight falls on three things: the patch is unfulled, so it still has a pull in it; it is the filler, so it fails at the one job it had; and the result is worse, so mismatched mending does more harm than leaving the hole alone. Together with the wine-and-wineskins saying that follows (2:22), it pictures what Jesus brings as something that cannot simply be stitched onto existing patterns of practice as a minor repair. Forcing the two together damages the old as well as wasting the new.
-
22And no one pours new wine into old wineskins. If he does, the wine will burst the skins, and both the wine and the wineskins will be ruined. Instead, new wine is poured into new wineskins.”
Full study →"And nobody pours young wine, wine still fermenting and giving off gas, into old leather skins that have already been stretched once and have dried stiff. If anyone tries it, the working wine will split the skins open, and then the wine runs out onto the ground and the skins are ruined too. Both are lost. No: young wine goes into fresh, unused skins."
Jesus is speaking common sense that every household in Galilee knew. The image has three parts:
- The wine is alive. "New wine" here does not mean a new brand or flavour. It means this season's wine, still fermenting and expanding.
- The old skin has no give left. A goatskin stretches the first time it is filled. Once dried and aged, it cannot stretch again, and it will burst under pressure.
- Mixing them wastes both. Mark's Greek is clipped and vivid: "the wine is lost, and the skins." It is a double loss. The verse ends without a verb, like a proverb: young wine — fresh skins!
The saying is Jesus' answer to the question of 2:18: why don't your disciples fast? He has just said that wedding guests do not fast while the bridegroom is with them (2:19–20). Wine is the drink of weddings, and abundant wine was a familiar picture of the age God had promised. What has arrived with Jesus is like that young wine: festive, powerful and still working. It cannot simply be poured into the existing customs of fasting and mourning without tearing them apart and losing itself in the process. It needs forms suited to it.
Where the English drifted
-
in v17
sinners
hamartōloi
- What we hear
- Everyone, since all people sin, or a humble way of describing oneself as a believer.
- What they heard
- A label for a recognisable group of people seen as living outside God's Law: the openly lawless and disreputable, the people respectable observant Jews would not eat with. Here they are the critics' own category, paired with toll collectors.
-
in v17
the righteous
dikaioi
- What we hear
- Either the morally flawless (so nobody), or the self-righteous and hypocritical.
- What they heard
- People in good standing within God's covenant who faithfully keep his commands. Scripture can use the word with full approval (Luke 1:6). Whether Jesus is being ironic here is debated, not settled by the word.
-
in v17
call
kalesai
- What we hear
- A religious vocation or an evangelistic appeal (“the call of God,” “an altar call”).
- What they heard
- To invite, including to a meal, and to summon into discipleship. At a dinner table, right after Jesus has called Levi, both senses are active.
-
in v17
whole (KJV)
ischyontes
- What we hear
- Complete or undivided.
- What they heard
- Strong or fit, meaning healthy. “Whole” meant “healthy, sound” in 1611 English (as in “hale”).
-
in v18
Pharisees
Pharisaioi
- What we hear
- Hypocrites, self-righteous legalists, the bad guys of the story.
- What they heard
- A respected, popular movement of lay Jews devoted to exact keeping of the Law and ancestral traditions. Their fasting was seen as genuine and admirable piety, and the question puts them alongside John's disciples as models of devotion.
-
in v18
disciples
mathētai
- What we hear
- A Christian word for followers of Jesus (or the Twelve specifically).
- What they heard
- Students or apprentices of any teacher. Here it is used just as naturally for John's followers and the Pharisees' followers as for Jesus' followers.
-
in v18, v20
fast
nēsteuō
- What we hear
- A diet or health practice, or a personal spiritual discipline for self-improvement, sometimes giving up something other than food.
- What they heard
- Going without food as an act of mourning, repentance and urgent petition before God. It was often communal and public, and it did not fit with celebration. That is why Jesus can answer with a wedding image.
-
in v19
children of the bridechamber (KJV)
huioi tou numphōnos
- What we hear
- Young children at a wedding, or literal offspring.
- What they heard
- The groom's adult attendants and the wedding party closest to him. 'Sons of X' is a Hebrew-style way of saying 'people who belong to X'.
-
in v19
fast
nēsteuein
- What we hear
- A private spiritual discipline or self-improvement practice, sometimes a way to gain spiritual power.
- What they heard
- A public act of mourning, repentance or humbling oneself while waiting for God to act. Matthew's parallel uses 'mourn' instead of 'fast'.
-
in v20
the time will come (BSB, NIV)
eleusontai hēmerai
- What we hear
- Just 'sometime later', an ordinary note about the future.
- What they heard
- 'Days will come.' The wording echoes the prophets' 'behold, days are coming', which announced a decisive turn in God's dealings with his people.
-
in v21
a piece of new cloth (KJV)
rhakos agnaphos
- What we hear
- Just a newer, stronger piece of fabric, as if the trouble were that the new is stronger than the old or simply doesn't match it.
- What they heard
- Raw, unfulled cloth that has never been through the fuller's washing and shrinking process, so it will shrink as soon as it gets wet and rip the old fabric around it.
-
in v22
bottles (KJV)
askoi
- What we hear
- Rigid glass bottles, which do not expand. That makes 'burst the bottles' sound like glass shattering, and the logic of old versus new containers becomes puzzling.
- What they heard
- Sewn animal-skin bags that stretch when new and become stiff and brittle with age. The danger is that old leather has no stretch left.
-
in v22
new wine
oinos neos
- What we hear
- Either (a) unfermented grape juice, or (b) loosely, any exciting new experience or idea.
- What they heard
- Young wine still actively fermenting. The fermentation is what produces the pressure that bursts an old skin. Unfermented juice would not make the picture work.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v22
'New wine, new wineskins' starts as an answer about fasting
- What's often taught
- The verse is often taught as a principle for church renewal. God is pouring out 'new wine' (a fresh move of the Spirit or revival), and churches must replace their 'old wineskins' (traditional structures, styles and denominations) or they will burst.
- What the text supports
In Mark the saying closes a specific exchange. People ask why Jesus' disciples do not fast like the Pharisees and John's disciples (2:18). Jesus answers that wedding guests do not fast while the bridegroom is present (2:19–20), and then gives the patch and wine pictures. The 'young wine' is the festive reality arriving with Jesus himself. The 'old skins' are, first of all, the inherited fasting customs that cannot contain it. The verse never names the Holy Spirit or church structures.
The popular reading gets something right: the principle that a living new reality needs forms suited to it is really in the saying. But two features of the text are often missed:
- Both are lost. Mark stresses the double waste, wine and skins. Matthew adds 'both are preserved' and Luke adds 'the old is good'. The saying is not a slogan for discarding older things.
- The newness is Jesus' presence. The wedding context ties the new wine to the bridegroom himself, not to a later wave of experience or method.
Applying the principle more widely is a choice made by later readers. It is not what the verse itself was answering.
- Where the English feeds it
- Reading 2:22 alone, as it is often quoted, cuts it off from the fasting question and the bridegroom saying of 2:18–20. Modern English 'new wine' also suggests novelty in general, more than young, still-fermenting wine. 'New … new' in most versions hides the fact that the skins are simply 'unused', so it is easy to read a programme of reinventing structures into the second 'new'.
καινός kainos νέος neos οἶνος oinos παλαιός palaios ἀσκός askos
Every word
-
Καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v17, v18, v19, v20, v21, v22
Mark's usual linking word. It ties Jesus' answer straight to the critics' question in verse 16.
-
ἀκούσας
akousas · G0191
to hear · v17
“Having heard.” The scribes had put their question to the disciples, not to Jesus. He overhears it and answers it himself.
-
ὁ
ho · G3588
the · v17, v18, v19, v20, v21, v22
Greek puts an article before the name. English leaves it untranslated.
-
Ἰησοῦς
Iēsous · G2424G
Jesus / Joshua · v17, v19
This is the Greek form of the Hebrew Yeshua/Joshua, “YHWH saves.” It was a common Jewish name.
-
λέγει
legei · G3004G
to say · v17, v18
Literally “says,” not “said.” Mark often tells past events in the present tense to make the scene vivid, as if it were happening in front of you.
-
αὐτοῖς·
autois · G0846
to them · v17, v18, v19, v20, v21
“To them” means the scribes of the Pharisees from verse 16, the people who objected. Jesus answers the critics directly.
-
ὅτι
hoti · G3754G
that · v17
This word appears only in some manuscripts. Where it appears, it simply opens the quotation, like a quotation mark, and is left untranslated.
-
οὐ
ou · G3756
not · v17, v18, v19
A flat negative placed first for emphasis: “*No* need do they have…”
-
χρείαν
chreian · G5532
need · v17
A need or necessity. The healthy simply have no use for a physician.
-
ἔχουσιν
echousin · G2192
to have · v17, v19
“They have.” This is the first of two uses of the verb “have” in the proverb. The second turns up in the idiom for being sick (word 17).
-
ἰσχύοντες
ischyontes · G2480
be strong · v17
Literally “those being strong.” In a medical setting it means the healthy and fit. The KJV's “whole” and the YLT's “strong” both reflect this.
-
ἰατροῦ
iatrou · G2395
-
ἀλλ᾽
all' · G0235
but · v17, v22
A strong contrast: “not this one, but that one.” It sets up the first half of a matched pair.
-
κακῶς
kakōs · G2560
badly · v17
“Badly.” Together with the next word it forms an everyday Greek idiom for being ill.
-
ἦλθον
ēlthon · G2064
-
καλέσαι
kalesai · G2564G
-
δικαίους
dikaious · G1342
righteous / just · v17
There is no article: “righteous people.” It means people in good standing who keep God's covenant and are recognised as faithful to the Law. Commentators debate whether the word is meant straight or ironically.
-
ἁμαρτωλούς
hamartōlous · G0268
sinners · v17
This picks up the critics' own word from verse 16. It was a label for people publicly regarded as living outside God's Law and therefore unfit company for the devout. These are the very people reclining at Levi's table.
-
εἰς
eis · G1519
into / to · v17, v22
This word is only in later manuscripts (the Byzantine tradition behind the KJV), as part of the phrase “to repentance.” It is not original to Mark.
-
μετάνοιαν
metanoian · G3341
-
ἦσαν
ēsan · G1510
were · v18, v19
Joined to the participle 'fasting' further on, it makes a past tense that describes an ongoing state: they 'were fasting'. This could mean a fast going on at that moment or a regular habit.
-
μαθηταὶ
mathētai · G3101
disciples, students · v18
Followers who attach themselves to a teacher to learn his teaching and way of life. Here the word is used of John's followers, so it is not a special Christian term.
-
Ἰωάννου
Iōannou · G2491
-
Φαρισαῖοι
Pharisaioi · G5330
Pharisees · v18
A respected lay movement known for careful keeping of the Law and of ancestral traditions. Their fasting would have counted as admirable piety.
-
νηστεύοντες
nēsteuontes · G3522
fasting · v18, v19, v20
Going without food (usually from morning to evening) as a religious act of mourning, repentance or earnest petition. The present participle stresses the activity as ongoing.
-
διὰ
dia · G1223
on account of · v18
With 'what' it forms the ordinary 'why?' It asks for a reason or justification.
-
τί
ti · G5101
what? · v18
'On account of what?', meaning 'why?' The tone is a challenge, not mild curiosity.
-
δὲ
de · G1161
but · v18, v20, v21, v22
Marks the contrast: the other groups fast, but yours…
-
σοὶ
soi · G4771
your (own) · v18
The possessive adjective 'your', not the pronoun 'to you'. Placed between the article and the noun ('the your disciples'), it points at Jesus: your own followers, the ones you are responsible for.
-
εἶπεν
eipen · G2036
said · v19
A simple past tense, 'he said'. It brings in Jesus' reply to the people who asked why his disciples do not fast.
-
μὴ
mē · G3361
not · v19, v21, v22
This word opens a question that expects the answer 'No'. It works like 'Surely the wedding party can't fast…, can they?'
-
δύνανται
dunantai · G1410
are able · v19
'Can'. The point is not that they lack the physical ability. Fasting in that setting would be absurd and out of place, so it is socially impossible.
-
υἱοὶ
huioi · G5207
sons · v19
Used here in a Hebrew-style idiom: 'sons of X' means people who belong to X. They are adult members of the wedding party, not children.
-
νυμφῶνος
numphōnos · G3567
bridal chamber / wedding hall · v19
The bridal room or wedding hall. 'Sons of the bridal chamber' are the groom's companions and wedding guests, the people at the centre of the celebration.
-
ἐν
en · G1722
in · v19, v20
Together with the next word it forms the expression 'in which [time]', meaning 'while'.
-
ᾧ
hō · G3739
which · v19
'In which' refers to the time the bridegroom is present, so it means 'while'.
-
νυμφίος
numphios · G3566
bridegroom · v19, v20
The man being married, the centre of the wedding feast. Jesus is clearly speaking of himself, though he does it through a picture.
-
μετ᾽
met' · G3326
with · v19
'With' in the sense of being present among them.
-
ὅσον
hoson · G3745
as much as · v19
With 'time' it means 'for as long as'.
-
χρόνον
chronon · G5550
time · v19
A stretch of time. Saying it this way hints that the period has a limit, which v.20 then states outright.
-
ἡμέραι
hēmerai · G2250
days · v20
Plural and without 'the': 'days', an open-ended stretch of time still to come. It matches the singular 'that day' at the end of the verse.
-
ὅταν
hotan · G3752
when, whenever · v20
'When.' With the verb that follows, it marks an event that happens first, with the fasting coming after. It expresses no doubt that the event will happen.
-
ἀπαρθῇ
aparthē · G0522
be taken away, be removed · v20
'He has been taken away.' The verb is passive: someone else removes him, he does not just leave. In the New Testament this verb appears only here and in the two parallel Gospel passages. Readers who knew how Mark's story ends heard a hint of his arrest and death.
-
ἀπ᾽
ap' · G0575
from, away from · v20
'From' them. It repeats the 'away' already built into the verb (ap-airō), which stresses that he is separated from his companions.
-
τότε
tote · G5119
then · v20
'Then, and not before.' It ties the fasting to the time after the groom is gone. That is the point Jesus is making against the question in verse 18.
-
ἐκείνῃ
ekeinē · G1565
that · v20
'That' day: it points back to the moment of removal. 'That day' is also a common prophetic phrase.
-
οὐδεὶς
oudeis · G3762
no one · v21, v22
A flat 'nobody does this'. The saying appeals to common sense: every household that mended its own clothes knew it.
-
ἐπίβλημα
epiblēma · G1915
patch · v21
Literally 'something put on top', the ordinary word for a patch laid over a hole. It comes first in its clause in Greek, so the patch is in focus.
-
ῥάκους
rhakous · G4470
piece of cloth, rag · v21
A scrap or piece of cloth. Here it is not a worn rag: it is a fresh scrap cut from cloth that has never been processed.
-
ἀγνάφου
agnaphou · G0046
unfulled, unshrunk · v21
'Not yet fulled'. The cloth has not been through the fuller, who washed, beat and shrank new woollen cloth. The word explains the whole problem: this cloth will still shrink.
-
ἐπιράπτει
epiraptei · G1976
sew on · v21
'Stitches on'. This is the only place the verb appears in the New Testament; Matthew and Luke both use the plainer 'puts on'. The present tense describes what people normally do, or here, never do.
-
ἐπὶ
epi · G1909
on, upon · v21
The patch goes onto the garment's surface over the hole.
-
ἱμάτιον
himation · G2440
cloak, outer garment, clothing · v21
Usually the outer mantle, a large woollen wrap worn over the tunic, though it can mean clothing in general. It was costly, kept for years and mended again and again.
-
παλαιόν·
palaion · G3820
old, worn · v21, v22
Old in the sense of long used and already shrunk by years of washing. Here it describes an aged object, not a bad one.
-
εἰ
ei · G1487
if · v21, v22
Begins the fixed phrase 'if not', meaning 'otherwise'.
-
αἴρει
airei · G0142
lift, take away · v21
'Pulls away, tears off'. When the patch shrinks, it drags at the old fabric round the hole and rips it. The verb picks up 'taken away' (apairō, same root) in v. 20, where it is used of the bridegroom.
-
πλήρωμα
plērōma · G4138
that which fills; fullness · v21
Here it simply means 'the filler', the piece that fills the hole, so 'the patch'. The KJV's 'the new piece that filled it up' keeps this. The later theological sense of 'fullness' has nothing to do with it here.
-
καινὸν
kainon · G2537
new, fresh, unused · v21, v22
'The new [piece]'. It clarifies the subject: the new cloth against the old cloth. The same adjective describes Jesus' 'new teaching' in Mark 1:27.
-
χεῖρον
cheiron · G5501
worse · v21
A comparative placed first for emphasis: a worse tear than the hole you were trying to fix.
-
σχίσμα
schisma · G4978
tear, split, rip · v21
A literal rip in the cloth. The later sense of 'schism', a split in a community, is not in view here.
-
γίνεται.
ginetai · G1096
become, happen · v21
'Results, comes about'. The present tense states a general rule: this is what always happens.
-
βάλλει
ballei · G0906H
to throw; put · v22
In everyday Greek of the time 'throw' had softened to plain 'put' or 'pour in' (compare putting money into the treasury, Mark 12:41). Nothing violent is implied here. The present tense states a general habit: this is never done.
-
οἶνον
oinon · G3631
wine · v22
Ordinary grape wine, the drink of every meal and above all of weddings. It ties back to the wedding picture of 2:19–20.
-
νέον
neon · G3501
new, young · v22
'Young' wine: recently pressed and still fermenting, so it is still giving off gas and expanding. The whole picture depends on that.
-
ἀσκοὺς
askous · G0779
wineskin · v22
A container made from the whole hide of a goat (sometimes a sheep), sewn shut, with a leg or the neck used as the spout. It was a flexible leather bag, not a bottle.
-
ῥήξει
rhēxei · G4486
to burst, tear apart · v22
'Will split, will burst open.' The future tense states what is certain to happen. The wine is the one acting: the fermenting wine itself tears the old leather apart.
-
ἀπόλλυται
apollytai · G0622
to destroy; be lost, ruined · v22
'Is lost, goes to waste.' The present tense gives a vivid snapshot of the result. Here the verb means wasted or spoiled. The 'perish' sense the same verb carries elsewhere does not apply.
The world behind it
The meal (2:13–17). Jesus calls Levi son of Alphaeus away from his toll booth at Capernaum. Capernaum was a lakeside town on a trade route in Herod Antipas' territory. Levi then holds a dinner where "many tax collectors and sinners" recline with Jesus and his disciples.
- Toll collectors in Galilee were local men who bought the right to collect duties on goods. They were widely seen as extortionate, as collaborators with the ruling powers, and as constantly in contact with Gentiles. Jewish sources group them with robbers and other people of ill repute.
- Table fellowship was not casual. Reclining at a meal together meant mutual acceptance, shared honour and a degree of social bonding. Some Pharisaic circles took particular care over the purity of their meals and who sat at them. To eat with "sinners" publicly looked like approving of them, or being contaminated by them.
- "Scribes of the Pharisees" were experts in the Law attached to the Pharisee movement. The Pharisees were a popular lay movement devoted to careful observance. Their objection was a serious one about holiness and loyalty to the covenant, not mere snobbery.
Where the verse sits in Mark. It is the third of five controversy stories (2:1–3:6) that build toward the plot against Jesus in 3:6. Just before it, Jesus has healed a paralysed man to show that "the Son of Man has authority on earth to forgive sins" (2:10). So healing and forgiveness are already linked when he calls himself a physician. In Mark 1:40–45 he touched a man with a skin disease, and instead of becoming unclean he made the man clean. The physician image follows the same reversal: his wholeness passes to them, not their uncleanness to him.
From the study of Mark 2:17.
Where scholars differ
in v17
Who are “the righteous” Jesus did not come to call?
-
Irony: “those who consider themselves righteous.” The critics are as needy as anyone but do not see it.
The scene is a confrontation with critics. Mark elsewhere shows the Pharisees' resistance as spiritual blindness (3:5). The NLT translates this way, and many preachers read it this way.
-
Taken straight: genuinely faithful people exist, and Jesus' urgent mission is to those outside the fold.
Scripture calls people dikaios with approval (Luke 1:6; Matthew 1:19). Luke 15:7 speaks of “ninety-nine righteous persons who need no repentance.” The physician proverb itself treats the healthy as really healthy.
-
A Semitic “not… but” contrast meaning “not so much X as Y.” The emphasis falls on whom he goes after, not on dividing humanity into two kinds.
The same idiom appears in Hosea 6:6 (“mercy and not sacrifice”), which Matthew inserts at exactly this point. In it, the “not” sharpens priority rather than denying something outright.
in v17
Who were “sinners” in this period?
-
The wicked: Jews who deliberately and persistently broke the Law (E. P. Sanders).
This fits the Septuagint and Second Temple usage of hamartōloi for the lawless and apostate (Psalm 1; 1 Maccabees 2:44). Sanders argues it does not mean the ordinary unobservant population.
-
It also included ordinary people and those in despised trades whom strict groups looked down on (J. Jeremias).
It is paired with toll collectors. Later rabbinic lists of suspect occupations and contempt for the “people of the land” (ʿam ha-areṣ) point the same way, though these sources are later than the Gospels.
-
A term each faction used for outsiders, people judged unfaithful by another group's standards (J. D. G. Dunn).
In the Dead Sea Scrolls and the Psalms of Solomon, rival groups call other Jews “sinners” for not keeping the Law their way.
in v17
Does “I came” imply that Jesus came from heaven?
-
It is a prophetic mission formula meaning “my purpose in appearing is…,” with no claim to have existed before.
Messengers and prophets speak of coming or being sent for a purpose. Mark 1:38 (“that is why I came out”) can mean simply leaving Capernaum.
-
The “I came” sayings, taken together, suggest coming from God's presence (S. Gathercole).
This argument rests on comparison with angelic “I have come” statements in Jewish texts (e.g. Daniel 9:22–23; 10:14, Greek versions) and on the sayings' sweeping, life-summarising scope.
in v18
Does 'were fasting' describe a particular fast going on at that moment, or a regular habit?
-
A particular occasion: a fast was under way when the question was asked.
Mark uses 'were' + participle to set a scene. A weekly fast day (Monday or Thursday) or John's disciples mourning his arrest (1:14) would explain why Jesus' disciples stood out. NLT and others take it this way.
-
A habitual practice: these groups regularly fasted.
The question itself uses the habitual present ('fast'), and Luke 5:33 adds 'often'. Twice-weekly fasting is attested for the devout (Luke 18:12; Didache 8:1). KJV ('used to fast') and BSB ('often') take it this way.
in v18
Who are the unnamed 'they' who come and ask?
-
People in general ('people came').
Mark often uses an unspecified 'they' for 'people' (e.g. 1:30, 32; 2:3). BSB and ESV render it so.
-
The fasting groups themselves, or some of them.
Matthew 9:14 names John's disciples as the questioners. Luke 5:33 continues with the Pharisees and scribes. Mark's sentence begins by naming both groups.
in v18
Why were John's disciples fasting?
-
As part of John's call to repentance before the coming judgment.
John's austere lifestyle (Mark 1:6; Matt 11:18) and his message of repentance (Mark 1:4).
-
In mourning for John, who had been arrested.
Mark has already reported John's arrest (1:14). Fasting was a standard mourning practice, and Jesus' reply about the bridegroom 'taken away' suggests a fast tied to a lost leader. This is plausible but not stated in the text.
in v19
Is Jesus' 'bridegroom' language an implicit claim to a divine role, or just an everyday picture?
-
It deliberately echoes the prophets' picture of God as Israel's husband, so Jesus is quietly taking up a role belonging to God.
Isaiah 54:5–6; 62:5; Hosea 2:16–20 use the image of God as Israel's bridegroom or husband. Elsewhere Mark often shows Jesus doing what belongs to God (e.g. forgiving sins in 2:5–10, just before this passage).
-
It is mainly a common-sense comparison from village life (no one fasts at a wedding), with no technical title in view.
No pre-Christian Jewish text clearly calls the Messiah 'the bridegroom' (Jeremias, TDNT). The argument works on ordinary social logic, and the term may only have become a title in later Christian reflection (cf. Ephesians 5; Revelation 19).
in v19
Does the second half of v.19 (and v.20) go back to Jesus, or did the early church expand the saying?
-
The core question (v.19a) goes back to Jesus. Verses 19b–20 were added later to explain why the church fasted again after Easter.
Form-critical scholars (e.g. Bultmann) point out that v.20 seems to presuppose Jesus' death and later Christian fasting practice (Didache 8:1). Several manuscripts and Matthew/Luke lack v.19b.
-
The whole unit fits Jesus' ministry. Jesus could foresee his violent end, and the 'taken away' language is veiled rather than detailed.
Rejected prophets commonly met a violent end (cf. John the Baptist's arrest). The wording is allusive, not a detailed account of the passion. Most manuscripts include v.19b.
in v20
Does 'the bridegroom will be taken away' refer to Jesus' violent death?
-
Yes: a veiled prediction of his death, the first in Mark.
The passive ('be taken', i.e. by others), the stress on 'away from them', the possible echo of Isaiah 53:8 LXX ('his life is taken away'), and Mark's placement within conflict stories that end in a plot to kill Jesus (3:6). The shift to mourning-fasting implies a loss that calls for grief.
-
Only an absence, not necessarily a violent one.
The verb itself does not mean violence, and in the Greek Old Testament it often means simply departing. The parable's logic needs only that the groom is no longer present. A violent sense depends on reading it alongside the Passion.
in v20
Do verses 19b–20 go back to Jesus, or were they shaped by the early church?
-
An expansion by the early church to justify Christian fasting.
Form critics (e.g. Bultmann) argued that 19a stands alone as a complete saying and that 19b–20 read like a later explanation reconciling Jesus' non-fasting with the church's practice (cf. Didache 8:1).
-
Substantially from Jesus.
Other commentators (e.g. Jeremias, France, Guelich in part) note that Jesus elsewhere expects rejection and death. They argue the riddling bridegroom image fits him and is not explicitly Christian. All three Synoptic Gospels have the saying, and Thomas 104 also preserves a form of it.
in v20
What is 'that day'?
-
A specific day: the day of removal, perhaps marked by a regular Friday fast.
The shift from plural 'days' to singular 'that day' is unique to Mark. Early Christians fasted on Friday (Didache 8:1), and some scholars think Mark's wording reflects that.
-
A general prophetic idiom for the coming period.
'On that day' is a common Old Testament phrase for a coming time. Here it may simply pick up 'days will come' with no reference to a weekly practice.
in v20
Is the 'bridegroom' a claim to be Messiah or to act in God's role?
-
It draws on the Old Testament picture of God as Israel's husband and so carries a high claim.
Isa 54:5; 62:5; Hos 2:16–20 picture God as Israel's groom at the time of restoration.
-
It is mainly a parable image without a fixed title behind it.
No clear pre-Christian Jewish source calls the Messiah 'the bridegroom' (Jeremias). The image may work simply as 'you don't fast at a wedding', with the Christ-as-groom title developing later in Christian writing.
in v21
How should the clause 'airei to plērōma autou to kainon tou palaiou' be parsed?
-
'The patch pulls away from it, the new from the old.' Plērōma is the subject, and 'the new… the old' restates it to make it clear.
This is the most natural reading of the word order, especially with the critical text's ἀπ᾽ αὐτοῦ. Matthew 9:16 reads it this way ('its filler pulls away from the garment'), and ESV and NASB follow it.
-
'The new [patch] pulls the filling away from the old [garment].' Plērōma is the object and τὸ καινόν the subject (as in the supplied tagging).
The neuter forms allow it, and without ἀπ᾽ (the Textus Receptus reading) the clause can be taken this way. The KJV's 'the new piece that filled it up taketh away from the old' blends the two.
-
The ambiguity does not affect the meaning.
On either parsing the shrinking new patch tears the old cloth and the hole gets bigger. Commentators such as Marcus and France note the awkward Greek but give the same sense.
in v21
What do the 'old garment' and 'new patch' stand for?
-
The old order of Israel's religion (or 'Judaism' as a system) versus the new age brought by Jesus. The two cannot be combined, and the new replaces the old.
Mark places the saying in a run of conflicts over religious practice (2:1–3:6), uses kainos for Jesus' 'new teaching' (1:27), and in v. 22 says the new wine needs new skins. This reading is common in older and patristic interpretation.
-
More narrowly, particular forms of piety (such as the voluntary fasting customs of John's disciples and the Pharisees) do not fit the joyful situation of the bridegroom's presence. The saying is not a verdict on Israel's Scriptures or covenant.
The immediate trigger is fasting (2:18–20). Jesus himself expects his disciples to fast later (2:20). Elsewhere in Mark he affirms the commandments (10:19; 12:28–34).
-
The saying stresses incompatibility and concern for both sides, not contempt for the old.
In the picture, what gets ruined is the old garment, which no one wants. Matthew adds 'both are preserved' (9:17), and Luke adds 'the old is good' (5:39). Each Gospel writer handles the old/new tension in his own way.
in v22
What do the young wine and the old skins stand for?
-
The skins are the specific practices under discussion, namely the customary fasts of the Pharisees and John's disciples, and the wine is the wedding joy of Jesus' presence.
The immediate context is the fasting question (2:18–20) and the wedding and bridegroom image. The saying closes that scene.
-
More broadly, the wine is the kingdom of God or Jesus' whole new teaching, and the skins are the inherited religious framework, or at least its legal customs, which cannot simply contain it.
'A new teaching' in Mark 1:27. The cluster of controversy stories in 2:1–3:6. The 'new covenant' language of Jeremiah 31:31 (which uses kainos in the Greek Old Testament).
-
It is a proverb about fitting things together that should not be decoded item by item. Its point is simply that the new needs appropriate forms.
It is introduced with 'no one does…' common-sense wording, paired with the patch saying, and the Gospels handle it differently (Matthew: both preserved; Luke: old wine preferred), which suggests a flexible proverb.
in v22
Does the saying reject the old?
-
Yes. The old forms are outworn and must give way.
The old skins burst and the new needs new containers. Hebrews 8:13 treats what is 'growing old' as ready to vanish.
-
No. The concern is to avoid wrecking both. The old is not called bad, only unsuitable for this new wine.
Mark stresses that both wine and skins are lost. Matthew 9:17 adds 'both are preserved'. Luke 5:39 says 'the old is good'. In 2:20 Jesus says his followers will fast later.
in v22
Is the switch from neos (wine) to kainos (skins) significant?
-
Yes. Kainos means 'new in kind', hinting that what Jesus brings requires a qualitatively new framework.
Kainos is used for new teaching (1:27), the new covenant and the new creation. The writer deliberately varies the word.
-
Mostly not. The words fit their objects naturally (young wine, unused skins), and in Greek of this period the two often overlap.
Matthew and Luke use the same pairing, which suggests ordinary idiom. Colossians 3:10 (neos) and Ephesians 4:24 (kainos) use them interchangeably for the 'new self'.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. ἁμαρτωλός, δίκαιος, καλέω, ἰσχύω, ἰατρός
- Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. κακῶς
- Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (2nd ed.), on Mark 2:17 and Matthew 9:13
- Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Mark 2:17
- E. P. Sanders, Jesus and Judaism (1985), ch. 6, “The Sinners”
- J. D. G. Dunn, “Pharisees, Sinners and Jesus,” in Jesus, Paul and the Law (1990)
- Joachim Jeremias, New Testament Theology: The Proclamation of Jesus (1971)
- Joel Marcus, Mark 1–8 (Anchor Yale Bible)
- R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark (NICNT)
- Simon Gathercole, The Preexistent Son (2006)
- Plutarch, Apophthegmata Laconica 230F
- Diogenes Laertius, Lives of the Philosophers 6.6
- Septuagint: Psalm 1:1–5; 1 Maccabees 1:34; 2:44–48; Sirach 38:1–15; Psalms of Solomon
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Mark 2:13–17
- BDAG s.v. νηστεύω
- BDAG s.v. μαθητής
- BDAG s.v. Φαρισαῖος
- Josephus, Antiquities 13.297–298; 18.12–15; Jewish War 2.162–163
- Didache 8:1
- Mishnah Ta'anit
- Psalms of Solomon 3:8
- Septuagint: Lev 16:29–31; 2 Sam 12:16–23; Isa 58:3–6; Zech 7:3–5; 8:19
- R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark (NIGTC)
- Craig S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament
- Daniel B. Wallace, Greek Grammar Beyond the Basics (periphrastic participles; historical present)
- BDAG s.v. νυμφών, νυμφίος, νηστεύω, δύναμαι
- J. Jeremias, TDNT IV s.v. νύμφη, νυμφίος
- Tosefta Berakhot 2:10; Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 25b (bnei ha-ḥuppah)
- Megillat Ta'anit
- B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (2nd ed.)
- NA28 critical apparatus at Mark 2:19
- J. Marcus, Mark 1–8 (Anchor Bible)
- A. Y. Collins, Mark (Hermeneia)
- R. Bultmann, History of the Synoptic Tradition
- BDAG s.v. ἀπαίρω, νυμφίος, νηστεύω, ἡμέρα
- LSJ s.v. ἀπαίρω
- J. Jeremias, TDNT s.v. νύμφη, νυμφίος
- J. Behm, TDNT s.v. νῆστις, νηστεύω, νηστεία
- J. Marcus, Mark 1–8 (Anchor Yale Bible)
- R. A. Guelich, Mark 1–8:26 (Word Biblical Commentary)
- B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament
- Septuagint: Isaiah 53:8; Jeremiah 38:31 LXX; Amos 8:11
- Gospel of Thomas 104
- Tobit 8:19–20; Judges 14:12
- Babylonian Talmud, Sukkah 25b
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Mark 2:18–22
- BDAG s.v. ἄγναφος, ἐπίβλημα, ἐπιρράπτω, πλήρωμα, σχίσμα, καινός
- LSJ s.v. γναφεύς / κναφεύς, ἄγναφος
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. πλήρωμα
- R. C. Trench, Synonyms of the New Testament, §60 (καινός and νέος)
- Adela Yarbro Collins, Mark (Hermeneia)
- Robert Guelich, Mark 1–8:26 (WBC)
- Septuagint: Ps 23:1 LXX; Jer 38:31 LXX; Isa 43:19
- Didache 8:1; Luke 18:12 (fasting customs)
- Gospel of Thomas 47
- Vulgate, Mark 2:21
- Nestle-Aland 28 / Textus Receptus (edition comparison)
- BDAG s.v. ἀσκός, νέος, καινός, παλαιός, ῥήγνυμι, ἀπόλλυμι
- Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. ἀσκός
- J. Behm, TDNT s.v. καινός, νέος
- R. C. Trench, Synonyms of the New Testament, §60 (νέος, καινός)
- B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Mark 2:22
- Nestle-Aland 28 / SBL Greek New Testament
- Septuagint: Joshua 9:4, 13; Job 32:19; Psalm 118(119):83; Sirach 9:10
- Mishnah Avot 4:20
- 2 Baruch 29:5
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).