Mark Chapter 9 Read as one passage
Mark 9:31–34
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
31because He was teaching His disciples. He told them, “The Son of Man will be delivered into the hands of men. They will kill Him, and after three days He will rise.” 32But they did not understand this statement, and they were afraid to ask Him about it. 33Then they came to Capernaum. While Jesus was in the house, He asked them, “What were you discussing on the way?” 34But they were silent, for on the way they had been arguing about which of them was the greatest.
What the first hearers heard
For the Twelve on the road through Galilee, this was a riddle they could not solve. The words were plain, but the idea did not fit anything they expected: the triumphant Son of Man of Daniel, the one they had begun to see as Messiah, handed over and killed by ordinary people, and then standing up out of death on his own, ahead of the general resurrection. Mark says straight away that they did not understand and were afraid to ask (9:32).
For Mark's first readers, likely Christians who knew persecution, perhaps in Rome in the 60s, the saying meant something else. It showed that the arrest and execution of Jesus were neither an accident nor a defeat. The death had been foreseen, spoken of as already under way and part of a purpose, and its reversal had been promised in advance. Because the prediction is repeated three times, the reader cannot miss that the road to Jerusalem is a road to death and vindication. The surrounding teaching (9:33–37; 8:34–38) presses the point that following this Son of Man means walking the same road. The generality of "the hands of men" also tells readers that the guilt of his death is not one group's alone: humanity as such rejects the Human One.
From the study of Mark 9:31.
Verse by verse
-
31because He was teaching His disciples. He told them, “The Son of Man will be delivered into the hands of men. They will kill Him, and after three days He will rise.”
Full study →Mark explains why Jesus kept his journey through Galilee secret: he was busy teaching his inner circle, and he kept telling them the same thing again and again. "The Son of Man", meaning the human figure whom Daniel saw receiving everlasting rule from God, "is already being handed over into the power of human beings." The tense is present. The handing-over is spoken of as already in motion and as certain. The verb leaves open who does the handing over; in biblical language, "delivering someone into the hands of" others is often what God does. There is also a pointed play on words: the Man is handed to men. No elders, priests or Gentiles are named this time. Humanity as such receives him, "and they will kill him." Then, repeating the verb for emphasis: "and once he has been killed," really and fully dead, "after three days he will stand up again." In Jewish counting, "after three days" means a short, set interval, the same as "on the third day," not a precise 72 hours. "He will rise" is the concrete image of a dead body getting up. The disciples associated this with the end of history, not with something that would happen to one man within the week.
-
32But they did not understand this statement, and they were afraid to ask Him about it.
Full study →"But they kept on not grasping what he had told them, and they kept shrinking from asking him about it."
Both verbs describe a continuing state, not a single moment. The disciples heard every word of Jesus' plain statement in verse 31: the Son of Man would be handed over into human hands, killed, and would rise after three days. They could not make it fit anything they knew or hoped for, so it stayed unabsorbed. Asking was the normal way they learned from their teacher, and they had done it twice already in this chapter (9:11, 9:28). This time they held back. Mark does not say what they were afraid of. It may have been another sharp rebuke like the one Peter received when he objected to the first prediction (8:33). It may have been hearing the dreadful thing confirmed. Throughout the Gospel, the disciples also feel a kind of awe at what God is doing that they cannot yet take in. The verse leaves that unease hanging. In the next breath Jesus asks them a question (9:33), and it turns out that on the road they had been arguing about which of them was greatest.
-
33Then they came to Capernaum. While Jesus was in the house, He asked them, “What were you discussing on the way?”
Full study →They arrived back in Capernaum, Jesus' home base by the lake. Once they were inside the house, the familiar one where he taught his followers in private, Jesus put a question to them, and kept pressing it: "What were you talking through out there on the road?"
The word for their talk means going over something with one another, weighing and debating it, not just chatting. In Mark the same word has already described thinking that misses the point or serves oneself. The next verse names the subject they would not admit to: which of them was the greatest.
The question is pointed in two ways. First, just before this, the disciples had been afraid to ask him what he meant about being handed over and killed (v. 32). Now he is the one asking them, using the same verb, and again they say nothing. Second, the argument happened "on the way". That is the road Mark keeps returning to, where Jesus talks about his suffering as they head toward Jerusalem. He was walking toward the cross, and behind him they were deciding who ranked highest.
-
34But they were silent, for on the way they had been arguing about which of them was the greatest.
Full study →But they said nothing. They kept quiet, an uncomfortable silence that went on. Jesus had asked what they were talking about on the road, and they could not bring themselves to tell him. The reason: walking along that same road, they had been talking it out among themselves, debating back and forth, over one question: Who is greater? Which of us ranks highest?
The verse turns on its setting. "The way" is the road on which Jesus has just told them, for the second time, that he will be handed over and killed (9:31). They did not understand that and were afraid to ask (9:32). Meanwhile they were working out their own order of precedence. Their silence shows they knew it. The conversation that felt natural on the road could not be repeated in front of their teacher. Jesus answers in the next verse by turning their ranking upside down: the one who wants to be first must be last of all and servant of all.
Where the English drifted
-
in v31
Son of Man
ho huios tou anthrōpou
- What we hear
- A name for Jesus' human nature, as opposed to 'Son of God' for his divinity.
- What they heard
- An Aramaic or Hebrew idiom for 'a human being', used as a title that recalls the glorious figure of Daniel 7:13 who receives everlasting dominion. In Mark it often carries heavenly authority (8:38; 13:26; 14:62). Here that figure is handed over and killed.
-
in v31
after three days
meta treis hēmeras
- What we hear
- A measured period of at least 72 hours.
- What they heard
- An idiom for a short, set interval, counted inclusively (part of a day counts as a day). It is used interchangeably with 'on the third day'.
-
in v31
betrayed (NLT)
paradidotai
- What we hear
- Judas's treachery specifically.
- What they heard
- 'Is being handed over', a broad word for delivering someone into another's custody. No agent is named, and in biblical idiom God can be the one who hands over.
-
in v32
that saying / the saying (KJV, WEB, ESV)
rhēma
- What we hear
- A proverb or set phrase, something cryptic or riddling ('as the saying goes').
- What they heard
- A specific spoken statement: the prediction Jesus had just made, plainly, that he would be handed over, killed and raised.
-
in v34
disputed (KJV, WEB)
dielechthēsan (dialegomai)
- What we hear
- A quarrel or formal conflict, as in "a legal dispute" or "a disputed claim".
- What they heard
- A back-and-forth discussion or debate. The competitive edge comes from the topic (ranking), not from the verb itself.
-
in v34
held their peace (KJV)
esiōpōn (siōpaō)
- What we hear
- They stayed calm or untroubled.
- What they heard
- They kept silent. The tense describes an ongoing, uncomfortable silence, the opposite of peace of mind.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v31
'After three days' was never a 72-hour stopwatch
- What's often taught
- Some teach that because Jesus said he would rise 'after three days', he must have been in the tomb a full 72 hours. On that view the crucifixion was on a Wednesday or Thursday, not on Friday.
- What the text supports
Mark's meta treis hēmeras is a Jewish time idiom, counted inclusively. Any part of a day counts as a day. The Old Testament treats 'three days' and 'on the third day' as the same span: Esther fasts 'three days, night or day' and goes in 'on the third day' (Esth 4:16; 5:1), and Joseph's 'three days' ends 'on the third day' (Gen 42:17–18). Matthew and Luke rewrite this very saying as 'on the third day' without any sense of changing it. In Matthew 27:63–64 the priests quote 'after three days' and ask for a guard only 'until the third day'. Mark himself places the death on the day before the Sabbath (15:42) and the empty tomb early on the first day (16:2). He saw no conflict with 'after three days'. The verse supports a short, divinely fixed interval. It does not support an exact count of hours.
- Where the English feeds it
- Renderings like 'after three days' or 'three days later' sound to modern ears like measured elapsed time. The later manuscript reading 'the third day' (KJV) is closer to how the idiom was understood, though it is probably not Mark's original wording.
Every word
-
ἐδίδασκεν
edidasken · G1321
to teach · v31
The imperfect tense shows ongoing or repeated action: 'he kept teaching'. This was teaching he was giving them over the length of the journey, not one remark.
-
γὰρ
gar · G1063
for, because · v31, v34
Gives the reason for verse 30. Jesus wanted no one to know where they were because he was busy with private instruction for the Twelve.
-
τοὺς
tous · G3588
the · v31, v32, v33, v34
The article that goes with 'disciples'.
-
μαθητὰς
mathētas · G3101
disciple, student, apprentice · v31
His inner circle of followers, here taught apart from the crowds. In that world a disciple was an apprentice who lived with his teacher, not just someone who agreed with him.
-
αὐτοῦ
autou · G0846
his · v31, v32, v33
'His' disciples. They are attached to him personally.
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v31, v32, v33
Links 'teaching' with 'saying'. The second verb gives the content of the first.
-
ἔλεγεν
elegen · G3004
to say · v31
Another imperfect: 'he was saying, he kept telling them'. Mark suggests this message was repeated, not mentioned once.
-
ὅτι
hoti · G3754
that · v31
Here it works as a speech marker, like opening quotation marks. Jesus' words follow directly.
-
υἱὸς
huios · G5207
son · v31
In the Semitic phrase 'son of X', 'son' marks membership in a class. 'Son of man' is idiom for 'a human being', not a statement about who his father was.
-
ἀνθρώπου
anthrōpou · G0444
human being, man · v31
'Of the man / of humanity'. It sets up the wordplay with 'men' a few words later: the Son of Man is handed over to men.
-
παραδίδοται
paradidotai · G3860
to hand over, deliver up · v31
Present passive: 'is being handed over'. The event is spoken of as already underway. The passive leaves the agent unnamed, and in biblical idiom that may point to God (see studies).
-
εἰς
eis · G1519
into · v31, v33
Movement into someone's possession or control.
-
χεῖρας
cheiras · G5495
hands · v31
'Hands' means power and control, as in the Old Testament phrase 'give into the hand of' an enemy.
-
ἀποκτενοῦσιν
apoktenousin · G0615
to kill · v31
Future active: 'they will kill'. A blunt word for violent killing. 'They' is the same 'men' who receive him.
-
μετὰ
meta · G3326
after · v31
With the accusative it means 'after'. The supplied in-context gloss 'on [the]' blends in the parallel wording. Mark's Greek here means 'after'.
-
τρεῖς
treis · G5140
three · v31
'Three' (cardinal), not 'third' (ordinal). It is part of a fixed phrase for a short, set interval (see studies).
-
ἡμέρας
hēmeras · G2250
days · v31
'Days'. In Jewish reckoning, part of a day counted as a day.
-
ἀναστήσεται
anastēsetai · G0450
to stand up, rise · v31
Future middle with an active meaning: 'he will stand up, rise'. Here the Son of Man is the subject, the one who rises. Matthew's parallel uses a passive, 'he will be raised'.
-
δὲ
de · G1161
but, and · v32, v34
A light contrast. Jesus taught plainly, 'but they' did not take it in. The gap between what he said and what they grasped is the point of the sentence.
-
ἠγνόουν
ēgnooun · G0050
not know, not understand · v32
Imperfect tense, so the not-understanding went on: 'they kept failing to grasp it.' It is not that they missed the words. They could not make sense of them or fit them into what they expected. It is not a charge of stupidity.
-
ῥῆμα
rhēma · G4487
spoken word, statement, matter · v32
The specific thing Jesus had just said: the Son of Man handed over, killed, and rising after three days. It means a particular spoken statement, not a proverb or a general teaching.
-
ἐφοβοῦντο
ephobounto · G5399
be afraid, fear · v32
Also imperfect: 'they kept being afraid'. This was a lasting reluctance, not a moment's hesitation. Mark does not say what they feared. The text leaves it open whether it was a rebuke, the answer itself, or both.
-
ἐπερωτῆσαι
eperōtēsai · G1905
-
ἦλθον
ēlthon · G2064
they came · v33
A plain past-tense 'they came'. The plural covers Jesus and the Twelve arriving together after the journey through Galilee (9:30).
-
Καφαρναούμ
Kapharnaoum · G2584
-
ἐν
en · G1722
in · v33, v34
Places the action inside the house.
-
οἰκίᾳ
oikia · G3614
-
γενόμενος
genomenos · G1096
having come to be · v33
Literally 'having come to be in the house', meaning 'once he was inside'. It is singular and refers to Jesus: the question comes after they have settled indoors.
-
τί
ti · G5101
what? · v33, v34
A direct question asking for the subject of their talk. Verse 34 gives the answer they would not say: 'who is greater'.
-
ὁδῷ
hodō · G3598
-
πρὸς
pros · G4314
to, with · v33, v34
Found only in later manuscripts (followed by the KJV). With the next word it means 'among yourselves'.
-
ἑαυτούς
heautous · G1438
yourselves · v33
Found only in later manuscripts. It spells out that the talk was among the disciples, which the plural verb already implies.
-
διελογίζεσθε
dielogizesthe · G1260
to reason, discuss, debate · v33
'Were you talking it through / debating?' The past tense here (the imperfect) shows talk that went on for some time on the road. On its own the verb can be neutral, but v. 34 shows it was a status argument.
-
ἐσιώπων
esiōpōn · G4623
be silent, keep quiet · v34
The tense pictures an ongoing state: "they kept silent" or "they stayed quiet". This is not a short pause but an awkward, held silence. People who have been caught out go quiet like this.
-
ἀλλήλους
allēlous · G0240
one another · v34
The discussion was internal, disciple against disciple. Mark puts it first in its clause for emphasis: it was *with each other* that they had been talking.
-
διελέχθησαν
dielechthēsan · G1256
discuss, converse, argue · v34
"They had discussed / debated." The word covers anything from talking a matter through to arguing it out. Here the topic, ranking against each other, gives it a competitive edge. Mark uses a simple past tense; English needs "had" because the talk came before the silence.
-
μείζων
meizōn · G3173
greater (comparative of 'great') · v34
Literally "greater". Everyday Greek of the time often used the comparative where English uses the superlative, so "greatest" is a fair rendering. Their question was about ranking: who stands above whom in the group.
The world behind it
Where this sits. This is the second of three formal predictions of Jesus' death in Mark (8:31; 9:31; 10:33–34). Together they shape the journey section of the Gospel, from Caesarea Philippi to Jerusalem. Each is followed by the disciples misunderstanding, and then by teaching on what it means to follow. Here, right after this verse, they argue about who is greatest (9:33–37).
Why secrecy. Galilee was Herod Antipas's territory, and crowds followed Jesus wherever he was recognised. Mark presents this journey as a deliberate withdrawal for private teaching of the Twelve. In that culture a teacher's most important instruction was given to his close students away from the public.
Why the disciples could not take it in. The Jewish hopes of the period about a coming anointed king (e.g., Psalms of Solomon 17) imagined him defeating Israel's oppressors, not being killed by them. And resurrection was expected as a single event at the end of the age, for all the righteous (Dan 12:2; 2 Macc 7). A Messiah-figure killed, and then rising alone within days, broke both expectations. Peter has already been rebuked for resisting the first prediction (8:32–33). That helps explain why they are now "afraid to ask him" (9:32).
Scriptural background. Daniel 7 already joins suffering and vindication: the "holy ones of the Most High" are "given into the hand" of a hostile power for a time before the kingdom is given to them (Dan 7:21–27). The "one like a son of man" in Daniel 7:13 is closely linked to them. Isaiah 53 (in Greek) uses the same verb, "hand over", for the servant: "the Lord handed him over for our sins." Many interpreters hear both texts behind the wording here, though Mark does not quote either.
From the study of Mark 9:31.
Where scholars differ
in v31
Who is the implied agent of 'is being handed over'?
-
God is the ultimate actor (a 'divine passive', where the passive voice leaves God unnamed out of reverence).
The LXX idiom 'deliver into the hands of' usually has God as subject. Isaiah 53:6, 12 LXX uses the same verb with the Lord as agent. Mark 8:31 says the suffering 'must' happen. Paul in Romans 8:32 says God 'handed over' his Son.
-
The human betrayer (Judas) and the authorities are in view.
Mark uses the same verb of Judas (3:19; 14:10–11, 44), of the Sanhedrin handing Jesus to Pilate (15:1), and of Pilate handing him to be crucified (15:15).
-
The ambiguity is deliberate and covers both.
The verse names no agent. Mark's narrative goes on to show several layers of 'handing over', both human and divine.
in v31
What does 'Son of Man' mean on Jesus' lips?
-
A title drawn from Daniel 7:13, the heavenly figure who receives the kingdom.
Mark 13:26 and 14:62 explicitly echo Daniel's 'coming with the clouds'. Mark uses the article ('the Son of Man') consistently. Jewish works such as 1 Enoch 37–71 also developed the figure.
-
Basically an Aramaic way of saying 'a man' or 'I', which only later became a title.
*Bar nasha* is an ordinary idiom in Aramaic. Vermes and others point to texts where it is used to refer to oneself indirectly.
-
Both: an ordinary-sounding phrase that carried a Danielic echo for those with ears to hear.
This explains why the phrase could be used publicly without sounding like a plain messianic claim, yet still carry exalted claims in Mark.
in v31
Do the passion predictions go back to Jesus in this form?
-
They are largely composed after the events by the early church.
The predictions grow more detailed as the Gospel goes on. 10:33–34 reads almost like a summary of the passion narrative.
-
A short, original core goes back to Jesus. This verse may be the closest to it.
Jeremias argued that the brief, riddle-like 'the Man is handed over to men' looks like an Aramaic wordplay and lacks the narrative detail of the other predictions. Jesus would also have known the fate of prophets and of John the Baptist (Mark 6; 9:13).
in v32
Why were the disciples afraid to ask Jesus?
-
Fear of rebuke
After the first prediction, Peter objected and Jesus called him 'Satan' in front of the others (8:32–33). Raising the subject again could invite the same response.
-
Fear of the answer
They may have understood enough to dread confirmation. Matthew's parallel says they were 'greatly grieved' (Matt 17:23), which implies some grasp of the content. Not asking let them keep it vague.
-
Awe at a divine purpose beyond them
Mark repeatedly links fear with moments where God's action is revealed but not understood (4:41; 6:50; 9:6; 16:8). Luke's 'it was concealed from them' (9:45) reads the incomprehension as part of God's purpose.
in v32
Is the disciples' incomprehension a historical memory or mainly a literary theme of Mark?
-
Mainly a literary and theological device
Following William Wrede's 'messianic secret' thesis (1901), many scholars see the repeated misunderstanding as Mark's way of teaching that Jesus' identity can only be understood in light of the cross and resurrection.
-
Rooted in real memory, shaped by Mark
It is unlikely that the early church would invent so unflattering a picture of its leaders. The lack of any Jewish expectation of a dying Messiah makes real confusion historically plausible. Mark heightens and arranges it within the three-prediction pattern.
in v33
Is Jesus asking for information, or exposing something he already knows?
-
A probing, rhetorical question: Jesus already knows.
Mark elsewhere has Jesus perceive people's inner reasoning (2:8, with the same verb), and Luke's parallel says outright that he knew 'the reasoning of their heart' (Luke 9:47). The disciples' guilty silence (v. 34) suits a question meant to bring things into the open.
-
A real question; Mark does not say Jesus knew.
Mark's text says nothing about supernatural knowledge here. Jesus could have noticed the dispute on the road (he may have walked ahead, compare 10:32) without hearing what it was about. Reading in Luke's detail goes beyond what Mark says.
in v33
How much weight does 'on the way' carry?
-
It is a deliberate theme: 'the way' is the way of the Lord and of the cross.
Mark opens with Isa 40:3, 'Prepare the way of the Lord' (1:2–3), and repeats 'on the way' at key points of the Jerusalem journey (8:27; 9:33–34; 10:32, 52). Scholars such as Joel Marcus and Rikki Watts read this against Isaiah's new-exodus 'way'.
-
It is mainly ordinary scene-setting.
ὁδός is a very common word for a road or journey. In v. 34 the phrase simply explains where and when the argument took place. Others accept the irony but warn against loading every use with symbolism.
in v33
Whose house is 'the house'?
-
Simon Peter's (and Andrew's) house.
Mark 1:29 names their house in Capernaum, and 2:1 has Jesus 'at home' there. The definite article suggests a known house. Early Christian tradition honoured a particular Capernaum house as Peter's.
-
Not specified; 'the house' is Mark's stock setting for private teaching.
Mark uses 'the house' for private teaching in different places (7:17; 9:28; 10:10) without always naming the owner, so the article may only mark the move indoors.
in v34
Were the disciples debating rank among themselves now, or positions in the coming kingdom?
-
Present standing within the Twelve.
Mark's wording is just "who is greater?" with no mention of the kingdom. The possible triggers are recent events: three disciples chosen for the mountain (9:2), the others failing at an exorcism (9:18). Jesus' reply (v. 35) addresses being "first" in the community.
-
Precedence in the messianic kingdom they expected.
Matthew 18:1 explicitly says "in the kingdom of heaven". Mark 10:37 shows James and John seeking seats "in your glory". Jewish expectation (e.g., 1QSa 2:11–22) imagined a ranked messianic community. The two need not be separate: rank now was assumed to carry over into the kingdom.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. παραδίδωμι
- BDAG s.v. ἀνίστημι
- BDAG s.v. μετά
- Nestle–Aland, Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed. (apparatus at Mark 9:31)
- J. Jeremias, New Testament Theology: The Proclamation of Jesus (on the 'mashal' form of the passion sayings)
- G. Vermes, Jesus the Jew (on bar nasha)
- J. Marcus, Mark 8–16 (Anchor Yale Bible)
- A. Yarbro Collins, Mark (Hermeneia)
- R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark (NIGTC)
- M. D. Hooker, The Son of Man in Mark
- Septuagint: Isaiah 53:6, 12; Daniel 7:13, 25; Hosea 6:2; Esther 4:16–5:1
- 1 Enoch 37–71 (Similitudes)
- BDAG s.v. ἀγνοέω
- BDAG s.v. ῥῆμα
- BDAG s.v. φοβέω
- BDAG s.v. ἐπερωτάω
- Joel Marcus, Mark 8–16 (Anchor Yale Bible)
- Adela Yarbro Collins, Mark (Hermeneia)
- William Wrede, The Messianic Secret (1901)
- Psalms of Solomon 17
- Daniel 7:13–14; 12:2
- Synoptic parallels: Matthew 17:22–23; Luke 9:43–45
- BDAG s.v. διαλογίζομαι, διαλέγομαι, ὁδός, ἐπερωτάω, οἰκία
- Moulton & Milligan, Vocabulary of the Greek Testament, s.v. διαλογίζομαι / διαλογισμός
- Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Mark 9:33
- Josephus, Jewish War 3.519–521; Life 403
- Dead Sea Scrolls, Community Rule (1QS) 2:19–23; 6:8–10; 8:13–14; 9:17–18
- Joel Marcus, The Way of the Lord
- Rikki E. Watts, Isaiah's New Exodus in Mark
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Mark 9:33–37
- BDAG s.v. σιωπάω, διαλέγομαι, ὁδός, μέγας
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. διαλέγομαι
- Blass–Debrunner–Funk, Greek Grammar §60, §244 (comparative used for superlative)
- Dead Sea Scrolls: Community Rule (1QS) 6:8–10; 8:13–16; Rule of the Congregation (1QSa) 2:11–22
- Parallels: Matthew 18:1; Luke 9:46–47; Mark 8:27–10:52 passion-prediction pattern
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).