Luke Chapter 17 Read as one passage

Luke 17:20–37

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

20When asked by the Pharisees when the kingdom of God would come, Jesus replied, “The kingdom of God will not come with observable signs. 21Nor will people say, ‘Look, here it is,’ or ‘There it is.’ For you see, the kingdom of God is in your midst.” 22Then He said to the disciples, “The time is coming when you will long to see one of the days of the Son of Man, but you will not see it. 23People will tell you, ‘Look, there He is!’ or ‘Look, here He is!’ Do not go out or chase after them. 24For just as the lightning flashes and lights up the sky from one end to the other, so will be the Son of Man in His day. 25But first He must suffer many things and be rejected by this generation. 26Just as it was in the days of Noah, so also will it be in the days of the Son of Man: 27People were eating and drinking, marrying and being given in marriage, up to the day Noah entered the ark. Then the flood came and destroyed them all. 28It was the same in the days of Lot: People were eating and drinking, buying and selling, planting and building. 29But on the day Lot left Sodom, fire and sulfur rained down from heaven and destroyed them all. 30It will be just like that on the day the Son of Man is revealed. 31On that day, let no one on the housetop come down to retrieve his possessions. Likewise, let no one in the field return for anything he has left behind. 32Remember Lot’s wife! 33Whoever tries to save his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life will preserve it. 34I tell you, on that night two people will be in one bed: one will be taken and the other left. 35Two women will be grinding grain together: one will be taken and the other left.” 36 37“Where, Lord?” they asked. Jesus answered, “Wherever there is a carcass, there the vultures will gather.”

What the first hearers heard

To the Pharisees in the scene, the answer would have been unsettling. They had asked a reasonable timing question, of the kind serious people asked when reading Daniel. Jesus did not give them a schedule. He told them their whole method was wrong: God's reign is not something you can see coming by watching for omens. The next sentence (v. 21) sharpens the point: it is already among them, and they are looking past it.

To Luke's first readers, a generation or more later, the verse dealt with a real pressure. There was expectation and disappointment about the timing of the end, and some, Jesus warns, would say "Look, here!" or "Look, there!" (17:21, 23). The verse taught them to stop calculating dates and stop following people who claimed to read the signs. They were to recognise that God's reign had already broken in through Jesus (compare 11:20, "the kingdom of God has come upon you"), and to live ready for a final arrival that will be sudden and unmistakable, not announced in advance.

From the study of Luke 17:20.

Verse by verse

  1. 20When asked by the Pharisees when the kingdom of God would come, Jesus replied, “The kingdom of God will not come with observable signs.

    The Pharisees put a direct question to Jesus: When is God's reign coming? They wanted a date, or at least a timetable, for the day when God would openly take up his rule as king, set Israel free and put the world right. Jesus answers, but not on their terms. Repeating their own words, he says: God's reign does not come in a way you can track by close watching.

    The word behind "observation" or "observable signs" means the careful, studied watching of an astronomer following the stars or a physician reading symptoms to predict what will happen next. In Luke the same root is used for people watching Jesus closely, hoping to catch him out. Jesus is not saying God's reign is invisible or only inward. A few lines later he says the Son of Man's day will flash across the sky like lightning (17:24). What he rejects is the idea that its arrival can be calculated by reading signs. As the next verse explains, the people scanning the horizon for signs are missing the reign of God that is already at work in front of them.

    Full study →
  2. 21Nor will people say, ‘Look, here it is,’ or ‘There it is.’ For you see, the kingdom of God is in your midst.”

    Jesus has just told the Pharisees that God's kingdom does not arrive in a way you can track by watching for signs (v. 20). Now he adds: nobody will be shouting "Look, it's over here!" or "No, over there!", the way excited crowds chase rumours of a deliverer appearing in this village or that wilderness. Then he turns their own "Look!" back on them: "Look, God's reign is already right here among you," present now, within your reach, standing in front of you in the one you are questioning.

    The "you" is plural, and he is speaking to Pharisees who doubt him. That makes it unlikely he means a private spiritual reality inside each of their hearts. The point is about where and when God's kingship can be found. It is not a far-off event to be dated or a place to be located. It is already at work in Jesus' words, healings and deliverances (compare Luke 11:20, "the kingdom of God has come upon you"). The Greek word entos basically means "inside", and that is why older translations say "within you." Given who is listening and what was asked, though, the sense is best captured as "in your midst" or "within your grasp, if you will see it."

    Full study →
  3. 22Then He said to the disciples, “The time is coming when you will long to see one of the days of the Son of Man, but you will not see it.

    Jesus turns from the Pharisees, who had asked when God's kingdom would arrive, to his own followers, and tells them something harder. In the prophets' ominous phrase, "Days are coming": a whole stretch of time lies ahead. In those days you will ache with longing (a strong, legitimate yearning, not a sinful craving) to live through even a single one of the days of the Son of Man, meaning the days of his open presence and reign as Daniel's heavenly figure who comes to receive God's kingdom. And you will not get it. You will not "see" that day in the biblical sense of experiencing it. The verse sets two kinds of days against each other: the coming days of absence and hardship, and the longed-for days that belong to the Son of Man. The same verb used twice ("to see … you will not see") makes the disappointment felt. The warning prepares what follows: because the longing will be so intense, people will be tempted to chase anyone who cries, "Look, there he is!" (v. 23). But when the real day comes it will be as unmistakable as lightning (v. 24), and before any of it, the Son of Man must suffer and be rejected (v. 25).

    Full study →
  4. 23People will tell you, ‘Look, there He is!’ or ‘Look, here He is!’ Do not go out or chase after them.

    "And people will say to you, 'Look, over there!' or 'Look, right here!' Don't set out, and don't go chasing after it."

    The verse comes right after Jesus tells his disciples that a time will come when they will ache to see even one of the days of the Son of Man and will not see it (v. 22). In that time of waiting, rumours will spread. Someone will cry 'Look!' and point one way, someone else will point the other way, and each will insist that the long-awaited figure has turned up at a particular spot. Jesus gives two flat prohibitions. Greek uses this verb form for "don't even start." First, don't leave where you are and set off. Second, don't run in pursuit. The second verb, diōkō, is a strong word for chasing, the same word used for an army pursuing an enemy. The picture is people hurrying out of their towns after a report.

    The Greek gives neither "there" nor "chase" an object. It does not say "there he is" or "chase after them." English translations supply these words, reasonably, but the bare Greek is sharper. Whatever is being pointed at, do not go after it. The reason comes in the next verse. When the Son of Man truly comes, he will be like lightning that lights up the whole sky (v. 24). Everyone will see it at once, and no one will need a guide to find it. A coming that has to be tracked down at a particular address is, for that very reason, not his coming.

    Full study →
  5. 24For just as the lightning flashes and lights up the sky from one end to the other, so will be the Son of Man in His day.

    "Don't go running after people who say, 'Look, he's over there!' or 'Look, he's here!' Because the way lightning flashes out from one side of the sky and lights up everything under heaven all the way to the other side, that is how the Son of Man will be on his Day."

    The picture is a lightning storm over the hills. One flash, and the whole horizon is lit at once. No one has to be told it happened, and no one has to travel to see it. Jesus sets this against rumours that place the Messiah in a particular desert or a particular back room. His arrival will not be found by tracking down reports. It will be impossible to miss, visible everywhere at the same moment.

    The lightning also carries a glow from Israel's scriptures, where lightning goes with God's own appearing: at Sinai, in the Psalms ("his lightnings light up the world"), and in Daniel's dazzling heavenly figure. "The Son of Man" is Jesus' way of speaking of himself, and it echoes Daniel 7, where "one like a son of man" comes with the clouds and receives everlasting rule. "His Day" takes up the prophets' "Day of the LORD", the appointed day when God steps in to judge and set things right, and makes it the Son of Man's day.

    The next verse adds a twist: before that blazing day, "he must suffer many things and be rejected by this generation." The one who will light up the sky from end to end is first the rejected one.

    Full study →
  6. 25But first He must suffer many things and be rejected by this generation.

    "But before any of that — before the Son of Man's day bursts across the sky like lightning — something else has to happen first, and it is not optional. It is part of what God has determined must take place: he has to go through a great deal of suffering, and he has to be examined and thrown out, judged unfit, by the very people of this present age, the same unresponsive generation that keeps asking for signs."

    The verse is a deliberate interruption. Verse 24 has just described the Son of Man's coming as sudden, unmistakable and universal, like lightning flashing from one end of the sky to the other. Verse 25 cuts in with "first," and the disciples hear that glory comes after suffering, not instead of it. "Must" is Luke's word for God's plan (the same "must" as in "Was it not necessary for the Christ to suffer these things and enter into his glory?" Luke 24:26). "Suffer many things" is the stock phrase of Jesus' earlier predictions of his death. "Be rejected" is the verb of Psalm 118:22, where builders inspect a stone, discard it, and find it becomes the cornerstone. So the rejection itself points toward reversal. "This generation" names the culprits as Jesus' own contemporaries, the people Luke has repeatedly described as faithless and sign-seeking, and it prepares for the warnings about Noah's and Lot's generations that follow.

    Full study →
  7. 26Just as it was in the days of Noah, so also will it be in the days of the Son of Man:

    "And in just the way things went in Noah's time, that is exactly how it will go in the time of the Son of Man."

    Jesus sets two periods side by side and says they will match. The first is the generation before the flood, which every Jewish hearer knew from Genesis and from many retellings as the world God judged. The second is "the days of the Son of Man": the time leading up to and including the moment when the figure from Daniel 7, who receives God's everlasting kingdom, is revealed (v. 30). Jesus uses this title for himself, and v. 25 has just said he must first be rejected by "this generation".

    The next verse says what the two periods share. In Noah's day people were eating, drinking and marrying "until the day Noah went into the ark", and then the flood came and swept them all away. The comparison is not mainly about how wicked they were. It is about normal life going on with no attention paid, and then an end that came all at once and could not be reversed. The verbs make the claim confident: it did happen that way, and it will happen that way again.

    Full study →
  8. 27People were eating and drinking, marrying and being given in marriage, up to the day Noah entered the ark. Then the flood came and destroyed them all.

    They kept on eating, they kept on drinking, men kept taking wives and fathers kept marrying off their daughters. Life went on as normal, right up to the very day Noah went into the ark. Then the Flood came and wiped out every one of them.

    The Greek paints two contrasting pictures. The first four verbs come with no "and" between them, in a tense that describes ongoing, repeated action: a busy, unbroken scene of meals and weddings, ordinary people building ordinary futures. Then the tense changes to three single, decisive events: Noah went in, the Flood came, it destroyed. In Greek "went in" and "came" are almost the same word, so the sentence turns on that echo: one man goes inside the shelter, and the water comes for everyone outside it. The last word, "all", closes the sentence with no exceptions.

    Nothing in the list is wicked in itself. Eating, drinking and marriage are good gifts in the Hebrew Scriptures. The warning is that people were so absorbed in normal life that the decisive day caught them unprepared. Jesus says the day of the Son of Man will come the same way (v. 26, 30).

    Full study →
  9. 28It was the same in the days of Lot: People were eating and drinking, buying and selling, planting and building.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  10. 29But on the day Lot left Sodom, fire and sulfur rained down from heaven and destroyed them all.

    "But on the very day Lot walked out of Sodom, God rained fire and burning sulfur down out of the sky, and it killed every one of them."

    The verse finishes a contrast that begins in v.28. There Jesus strings together continuous-action verbs: people kept on eating, drinking, buying, selling, planting, building. That was the ordinary, endless rhythm of a working city. Verse 29 switches to verbs for single, finished acts: Lot went out, God rained, the fire destroyed. In one day, everything that had looked permanent was over.

    The wording copies Genesis 19:24 almost word for word ("the LORD rained sulfur and fire… out of heaven"). Any listener who knew the Scriptures would understand that the fire came from God, even though the Greek does not name him. "From heaven" means both out of the sky and from God's own presence. The phrase "destroyed them all" is identical to what Jesus has just said about the flood (v.27), so Noah's world and Lot's city become matching examples. The same verb comes back in v.33 ("whoever tries to keep his life will lose it"), which turns the warning onto the listener.

    The detail that matters most for Jesus' point is timing. The fire fell only once Lot was out, and it fell without warning on people busy with everyday life. Verse 30 draws the conclusion: "It will be just like that on the day the Son of Man is revealed."

    Full study →
  11. 30It will be just like that on the day the Son of Man is revealed.

    "It will happen in exactly the same way on the day the Son of Man is unveiled."

    "The same way" points back to what Jesus has just described. In Lot's time, people ate and drank, bought and sold, planted and built, and gave no thought to what was coming. Then, on the very day Lot walked out of Sodom, fire and sulfur fell from the sky and destroyed them all (vv. 28–29). Jesus lines up his sentence with that one almost word for word: on the day Lot went out becomes on the day the Son of Man is revealed.

    The verb is "unveiled" or "uncovered." It means a figure who already exists but is now hidden from sight will suddenly be shown to everyone, and the grammar suggests God is the one who uncovers him. "The Son of Man" is not just a modest way of saying "a human being" here. It calls up Daniel's vision of the human-like figure who comes before God's throne and is given everlasting rule and authority to judge.

    The tense is present ("is unveiled"), but after "on the day" it points to the future. It names a single day that will cut off a long run of ordinary days. The warning is not that the world will first become recognisably like Sodom. It is that life will look completely normal right up to the moment the hidden judge appears, and on that day there will be no time to go back for anything (vv. 31–32).

    Full study →
  12. 31On that day, let no one on the housetop come down to retrieve his possessions. Likewise, let no one in the field return for anything he has left behind.

    On that day, the day the Son of Man is suddenly revealed, whoever happens to be up on the flat roof of his house, with his household things down inside, must not go down to grab them and carry them off. In the same way, the man out working in the field must not turn around and head back toward what he has left behind.

    Jesus has just compared his coming day to the flood in Noah's time and the fire on Sodom (vv.26–30). Both caught people in ordinary routine: eating, buying, planting, building. This verse gives two snapshots of that routine interrupted. One man is on the roof, which in Palestine was a flat terrace used for daily work, with stairs down the outside. The other is out in the farmland beyond the village. Both are told the same thing: don't go back. Not for your pots and tools, not for anything.

    The commands are short, one-time prohibitions ("let him not go down," "let him not turn back"). The closing words, literally "to the things behind," are the very words the Greek Old Testament used when Lot's wife "looked back" while fleeing Sodom and became a pillar of salt. So the next line, "Remember Lot's wife!" (v.32), lands as the punchline. In Mark and Matthew a similar saying is practical advice for escaping a war in Judea. Here, at the arrival of the Son of Man, running cannot save anyone, so the stress falls on the turning itself. The danger is a heart pulled back toward possessions and the old life. Verse 33 states it outright: whoever tries to keep his life will lose it, and whoever loses it will preserve it.

    Full study →
  13. 32Remember Lot’s wife!

    "Keep Lot's wife in mind, and let what happened to her warn you."

    Jesus has just described the day the Son of Man is revealed. It will come as suddenly as the Flood came on Noah's generation and as the fire came on Sodom. People will be eating, buying, planting and building right up to the moment (vv. 26–30). Then he gives a blunt order: on that day, if you are on the roof, do not go down for your things; if you are in the field, do not turn back (v. 31). This three-word sentence is the example that makes the order stick.

    Every hearer knew the story. Angels dragged Lot's family out of Sodom with one instruction: do not look behind you (Genesis 19:17). His wife, already outside the city and already among the rescued, "looked back" and became a pillar of salt (Genesis 19:26). Luke's wording in v. 31, "turn back to the things behind" (eis ta opisō), uses the exact phrase the Greek Genesis uses for her looking back. Jesus is quoting her story before he even names her.

    "Remember" here is not "recall a fact". It is the biblical kind of remembering that is meant to change what you do, like "Remember what the LORD did to Miriam" or "Remember Amalek". The verb's form says: keep remembering. Carry her with you, because you do not know when the day will come.

    The next verse spells out the lesson. Whoever tries to keep their life safe will lose it, and whoever lets it go will keep it alive (v. 33). Lot's wife is the picture of that saying. She had been brought out. Her heart turned back toward the house, the goods and the life being destroyed, and the turning cost her the life she had just been given.

    Full study →
  14. 33Whoever tries to save his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life will preserve it.

    Anyone who makes it his aim to keep his own life safe for himself, holding on to it and to what he owns, will lose that life. He goes down to destruction like the people of Noah's day and of Sodom. But anyone who lets his life go, who gives it up rather than clutch it, will have that same life kept alive.

    A few details carry the force of the line:

    • One life, two ways of holding it. The word for "life" is the whole living self, not an inner "soul" kept apart from the body. The same life is sought, lost, and kept alive.
    • Self-protection versus being kept. The first verb means "to secure for oneself." It is the instinct to run back into the house for one's goods (v. 31) or to look back as Lot's wife did (v. 32). The last verb means "to keep alive" or even "to give life". In the Greek Old Testament this is what the Hebrew midwives did for the babies, and what the Lord does ("the Lord kills and keeps alive"). The person who stops grasping has his life kept alive by Another.
    • "Lose" carries "destroy." Luke has just used the same verb twice: the flood "destroyed them all," the fire "destroyed them all" (vv. 27, 29). So the first half is a warning of doom, not a mild loss. In the second half the word is turned around, and "losing" one's life on purpose becomes the way out of that destruction.
    • Certainty. Both results are in the future tense and stated flatly. They are not possibilities but what will happen.

    Put together: On the day the Son of Man is revealed, the grip that tries to rescue your own life and possessions is the very thing that ruins you. Let go of it, and that life will be kept alive.

    Full study →
  15. 34I tell you, on that night two people will be in one bed: one will be taken and the other left.

    Jesus speaks with full authority to his own disciples: "I am telling you: on this night, the night the Son of Man is revealed, two people will be lying on one sleeping mat, as close as family. One of them will be taken along, and the other will be let go and left."

    The picture is deliberately ordinary. Two people share a bed, just as two women in the next verse grind grain together at one hand-mill. Nothing about them looks different. Life is going on as it did in the days of Noah and of Lot (17:26–30). Then, in a moment, God (the unnamed one doing the taking and the leaving) separates them. Closeness, family ties and shared routine do not decide who belongs to whom.

    "Taken" (paralambanō) means taken alongside, taken to be with someone. Jesus uses the same word when he promises to "take you to myself" (John 14:3). "Left" (aphiēmi) means let go, left where one is, even abandoned. Read with the stories just told, Noah taken into the ark and Lot led out of Sodom while the rest were left to the flood and the fire, the most natural sense is that one is gathered to safety and the other is abandoned to the judgment. But the verse itself does not say where anyone goes. When the disciples ask "Where, Lord?" (17:37), Jesus answers only with a grim proverb about vultures gathering over a corpse. The emphasis falls on the sudden, final division between people who looked exactly alike a moment before. That is why the saying comes right after the warning to hold life loosely (17:33) and to "remember Lot's wife" (17:32).

    Full study →
  16. 35Two women will be grinding grain together: one will be taken and the other left.”

    On the coming day of the Son of Man, two women will be sitting at the same hand mill, turning the same stone, doing the most ordinary chore of the household day. Then, without warning, one of them will be taken: removed and taken along by someone, with God (or his agents) the unnamed actor. The other will be let go: left where she is, with nobody taking her. The verse does not say where the taken woman goes, or whether being left means being spared or being abandoned to ruin. The surrounding verses suggest the pattern of Lot, who was brought out while Sodom was left to destruction. What the verse does make unmistakable is the split. Two people who share the same place, the same work and the same morning are divided in a moment, by a judgment that does not follow shared circumstances. Together with the previous verse, where two people are in one bed at night, the scene says the day will catch everyone in the middle of normal life, at any hour.

    Full study →
  17. 36

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  18. 37“Where, Lord?” they asked. Jesus answered, “Wherever there is a carcass, there the vultures will gather.”

    The disciples have just heard Jesus say that on the day of the Son of Man, of two people side by side, one will be taken and the other left. They respond: "Where, Lord?" They want a place: where will this happen, and where are the ones who are taken taken to?

    Jesus answers with a saying from the countryside, not a map: "Where the carcass lies, there the carrion birds will gather too." Anyone in Galilee or Judea knew the sight. Griffon vultures and other great birds of prey circle high above the hills, then drop from every direction onto a dead animal. You never have to ask where the carcass is. The birds show you, and they never fail to find it.

    Three things are held together in the saying:

    • Certainty. The future "will be gathered" states something as sure as nature.
    • Visibility. Like the lightning of v. 24, the event will need no one to announce "here it is".
    • Grimness. The image is death, exposure and judgment. In Israel's Scriptures, bodies left for the birds were a sign of God's curse.

    So the answer amounts to: Don't look for a location. Wherever there is something ripe for judgment, judgment will find it, unmissably and without fail.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v20

    observation (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    paratērēsis

    What we hear
    Being seen at all. "The kingdom cometh not with observation" is heard as "the kingdom is invisible" or "purely spiritual".
    What they heard
    Close, studied watching aimed at predicting or detecting something, such as reading signs or scrutinising events to fix a date. The point is that the kingdom's coming cannot be calculated, not that it cannot be seen.
  • in v20

    kingdom of God

    basileia tou theou

    What we hear
    A place: heaven, where believers go after death, or a spiritual realm.
    What they heard
    God's reign in action, his kingly rule breaking into the world to judge, rescue and restore, as Daniel and the prophets promised.
  • in v21

    within you

    entos hymōn

    What we hear
    The kingdom of God is an inner spiritual state, a divine presence inside each individual's heart or soul.
    What they heard
    Said to Pharisees (plural 'you') answering 'when will the kingdom come?'. Most likely it means the kingdom is already present among them, or within their reach, in Jesus' ministry, not that it dwells inside each of them.
  • in v21

    kingdom

    basileia

    What we hear
    A place, or heaven as the destination after death.
    What they heard
    God's active royal rule breaking into history: his reign, not mainly a territory.
  • in v22, v24, v26, v30

    Son of Man

    ho huios tou anthrōpou

    What we hear
    Jesus emphasising that he is human or humble, the counterpart to 'Son of God'.
    What they heard
    Here mainly the figure of Daniel 7:13–14, 'one like a son of man' who comes with the clouds and receives everlasting dominion from God. The next verse's lightning image confirms that sense. The title also covers the one who must first suffer (v. 25).
  • in v22

    to see … you will not see it

    idein … ouk opsesthe

    What we hear
    To watch an event or catch sight of Jesus.
    What they heard
    In biblical idiom, to 'see' a day is to live through it and share in it (Ps 34:12, 'see good days'; Luke 2:26, 'see death'). The longing is to experience even one day of the Son of Man's era.
  • in v23

    follow (KJV, WEB: 'nor follow [them]')

    diōkō

    What we hear
    Become a follower or supporter of someone, or agree with what they say.
    What they heard
    To chase or run after something, hurrying in pursuit. Here it means rushing out after a report that the expected figure has appeared somewhere.
  • in v24

    like lightning

    astrapē

    What we hear
    Mainly "very fast" (as in "lightning-fast").
    What they heard
    Mainly visible everywhere at once and impossible to miss, answering the "Look, there! Look, here!" rumours of verse 23. Lightning was also a familiar sign of God appearing. Suddenness is part of the passage too, but it is developed in the following verses.
  • in v24

    in his day

    en tē hēmera autou

    What we hear
    "In his prime" or "in his era", as in "in his day he was famous".
    What they heard
    On his appointed Day, the day of his appearing, echoing the prophets' "Day of the LORD". Verse 30 calls it "the day the Son of Man is revealed".
  • in v25

    this generation

    hē genea hautē

    What we hear
    A demographic age group or a fixed span of roughly 30–40 years, which invites calculating dates.
    What they heard
    Jesus' contemporaries viewed as a people with a shared character: in Luke, the faithless, sign-demanding people of his day who will not respond (echoing Deuteronomy 32:5, 20).
  • in v26

    the days of the Son of Man

    hai hēmerai tou huiou tou anthrōpou

    What we hear
    A long "end-times" period in which visible world trends show that the end is near.
    What they heard
    The time leading up to and including the Son of Man's revealing (v. 24, 30), which Luke stresses will come without warning, like lightning or the flood.
  • in v27

    ark

    kibōtos

    What we hear
    A large ship or boat, the kind with a pointed bow shown in children's Bible pictures.
    What they heard
    A box or chest. The same Greek word is used for the Ark of the Covenant. The picture is an enclosed shelter that one goes *into*, separating those inside from those outside.
  • in v27

    being given in marriage

    egamizonto

    What we hear
    A traditional wedding formality, like a father "giving away" the bride at the altar.
    What they heard
    The actual arrangement of a marriage, in which a father or guardian married off his daughter through an agreement between families. With "marrying" it covers both sides of how marriages were made.
  • in v29

    brimstone (KJV, NASB)

    theion

    What we hear
    An old-fashioned word heard almost only in 'fire and brimstone', which suggests hell, eternal torment and harsh revival preaching.
    What they heard
    Sulfur, an ordinary burning mineral. Here it is the fuel of a historical catastrophe that fell on a real city in this world. The first hearers would picture the Dead Sea landscape, not the afterlife.
  • in v30

    revealed

    apokalyptetai

    What we hear
    Information being disclosed, or, through the word "apocalypse", a world-ending catastrophe.
    What they heard
    A person who already exists but is hidden being uncovered in public, visible to all at once.
  • in v31

    housetop

    dōma

    What we hear
    A sloping roof of a house that nobody normally stands on. Being up there sounds odd or dangerous, and coming down would mean going inside.
    What they heard
    A flat roof terrace that was part of daily living and working space, usually reached by stairs on the outside. Someone up there could get down to the street without entering the house; the forbidden act is going in to collect belongings.
  • in v31

    return for anything he has left behind (BSB)

    epistrephō eis ta opisō

    What we hear
    The field worker is told not to go back to fetch forgotten items. The verse reads only as a rule about possessions.
    What they heard
    'Let him not turn back' (literally 'to the things behind'), the same wording the Greek Genesis uses for Lot's wife looking back. The stress is on the act of turning back itself, which v.32 makes explicit.
  • in v32

    Remember

    mnēmoneuete

    What we hear
    Recall this story; don't forget the fact that it happened.
    What they heard
    Keep this in front of you as a warning and let it decide what you do when the moment comes. The command is ongoing: keep remembering.
  • in v33

    save his life (BSB, KJV)

    peripoiēsasthai

    What we hear
    Many readers hear the word "save" in its church sense: to secure one's salvation. Or they hear a noble rescue.
    What they heard
    "To keep safe for oneself, to hold on to." It is the instinct of self-preservation: rescuing one's own life and goods in the crisis. The KJV's "save" translates a different Greek reading (σῶσαι), probably borrowed from Luke 9:24.
  • in v33

    lose

    apolesei / apolesē

    What we hear
    To misplace something or give it up. A loss, but not a disaster.
    What they heard
    The verb also means "destroy, ruin, perish". Luke has just used it for the flood and the fire on Sodom, which "destroyed them all" (vv. 27, 29). The first "lose" carries that doom. The second is a deliberate letting go that escapes it.
  • in v34

    taken

    paralambanō

    What we hear
    Lifted up into heaven in a secret, invisible rapture, leaving clothes and cars behind.
    What they heard
    Taken along, taken to be with someone. The word has no built-in upward direction and no idea of secrecy. The context (Noah, Lot, the lightning-like public appearance of 17:24) makes it a visible act of God dividing people at the Son of Man's coming.
  • in v34

    left (behind)

    aphiēmi

    What we hear
    Remaining on earth through a later tribulation period, with a chance to repent.
    What they heard
    Let go, left where one is, abandoned. In the Noah and Lot pattern, those left outside the ark or left in Sodom faced the judgment at once. The text describes no waiting period after the separation.
  • in v35

    taken

    paralēmphthēsetai (paralambanō)

    What we hear
    Caught up secretly to heaven in a rapture before a period of tribulation.
    What they heard
    Taken along or removed by someone. The verb names neither where she goes nor when this happens, and Luke places it at the visible, lightning-sudden day of the Son of Man (v. 24).
  • in v35

    left

    aphethēsetai (aphiēmi)

    What we hear
    'Left behind' as a survivor who now has a second chance during a tribulation.
    What they heard
    Let go or left where she is. In context this most likely means abandoned to the judgment that falls (as Sodom was 'left' when Lot went out). Some read it instead as 'spared', like Noah. Neither reading includes a later period of tribulation.
  • in v37

    eagles (KJV, YLT)

    aetoi

    What we hear
    Majestic, soaring birds that stand for strength, renewal and spiritual height (as in Isaiah 40:31). Readers sometimes take them as faithful believers.
    What they heard
    Large birds of prey seen as carrion feeders, in practice mostly vultures, coming down on a carcass. In this setting it is an image of death and judgment.
  • in v37

    body (KJV, YLT, WEB, NASB)

    sōma

    What we hear
    A living body, or in church language "the body of Christ" (the church or the Lord's Supper).
    What they heard
    A dead body, a carcass lying in the open, as Matthew's parallel word πτῶμα ("carcass") makes explicit.
Every word
  1. Ἐπερωτηθεὶς

    Eperōtētheis · G1905

    to question, ask · v20

    "Having been asked." The verb often means putting a pointed or probing question to someone. The form is passive: Jesus is on the receiving end, and the Pharisees set the topic.

  2. δὲ

    de · G1161

    now, and, but · v20, v22, v25, v29, v37

    A light connective that opens a new scene after the healing of the ten lepers (17:11–19). It marks a shift and does not contrast anything.

  3. ὑπὸ

    hypo · G5259

    by, under · v20, v24

    Names who asked: "by" the Pharisees.

  4. τῶν

    tōn · G3588

    the · v20, v21, v22, v24, v25, v26, v27, v30, v31, v32, v33, v34, v35, v37

    The definite article. It points to the Pharisees as a known group already active in Luke's story.

  5. Φαρισαίων

    Pharisaiōn · G5330

    Pharisee · v20

    Members of a respected Jewish lay movement known for exact interpretation of the Law. Many of them hoped God would soon restore Israel. Their question was natural for people who hoped this.

  6. πότε

    pote · G4219

    when? · v20

    An interrogative of time. The question is about timing and dates, not about what the kingdom is. Jesus will refuse to answer on those terms.

  7. ἔρχεται

    erchetai · G2064

    to come · v20, v22, v27

    "Is coming." Greek reported questions keep the speaker's original tense, so this is what the Pharisees literally asked: "When is the kingdom coming?" A present tense used of a future event pictures it as already on its way.

  8. βασιλεία

    basileia · G932

    kingdom, reign, kingship · v20, v21

    God's royal rule in action: God openly acting as king, putting things right and setting Israel free. It does not mean a territory, and it does not mean heaven after death.

  9. θεοῦ

    theou · G2316

    God · v20, v21

    "Of God." God is the one who reigns. The kingdom is God's own act and is not built by people.

  10. ἀπεκρίθη

    apekrithē · G611

    to answer · v20, v37

    "He answered." Jesus does answer, but he changes the question.

  11. αὐτοῖς

    autois · G846

    them · v20, v24, v25, v30, v31, v33, v35, v37

    The Pharisees who asked. The reply in verses 20–21 is spoken to them, and only after that (17:22) does Jesus turn to his disciples.

  12. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v20, v22, v23, v25, v26, v27, v29, v31, v34, v37

    Joins "answered" and "said". This is a common Semitic-style double verb that introduces speech.

  13. εἶπεν

    eipen · G2036

    to say · v20, v22, v37

    "Said." It introduces the words of the reply.

  14. Οὐκ

    Ouk · G3756

    not · v20, v22

    A flat negative placed first for emphasis: "Not". Jesus rejects the method the question takes for granted.

  15. μετὰ

    meta · G3326

    with, accompanied by · v20

    "With" in the sense of "accompanied by" or "in a way that goes along with". The kingdom does not arrive alongside the kind of watching the question assumes.

  16. παρατηρήσεως

    paratērēseōs · G3907

    close observation, watching · v20

    Close, deliberate watching. In Greek it was used for tracking the stars or symptoms in order to predict what comes next. Here it most likely means watching for signs that would let you calculate when God's reign will arrive. This is the only time the word appears in the New Testament.

  17. οὐδὲ

    oude · G3761

    and not, nor · v21

    Continues the denial of v. 20 ('not with observable signs'). It adds a second thing the kingdom's coming will not involve: people pointing to a spot.

  18. ἐροῦσιν

    erousin · G4483

    they will say · v21, v23

    Future tense with no stated subject: 'people will not say.' It describes how people react when the kingdom comes, and denies that they will react by announcing its location.

  19. ἰδοὺ

    idou · G2400

    look! behold! · v21, v23

    The call of someone pointing: 'Look!' Here it quotes the excited cry of people announcing they have found the kingdom (or its leader).

  20. ὧδε

    hōde · G5602

    here · v21, v23

    A specific place you could go to. It is the language of someone claiming to have located the kingdom or a messiah.

  21. ἢ

    ē · G2228

    or · v21, v23

    Offers a second place. Together the two make the stock phrase 'here or there', meaning one rumoured place after another.

  22. ἐκεῖ

    ekei · G1563

    there · v21, v23, v37

    The other place. Pairing it with 'here' pictures crowds chasing reports.

  23. γὰρ

    gar · G1063

    for, because · v21, v24

    Gives the reason no one will need to point 'here' or 'there': the kingdom is already present in a way that makes that kind of pointing beside the point.

  24. ἐντὸς

    entos · G1787

    inside, within; (disputed) among, within reach of · v21

    The key word. Its basic meaning is 'inside'. With a plural 'you', said to Pharisees about the kingdom's arrival, most scholars take it as 'in your midst' or 'within your reach' rather than 'inside each of your hearts'. See the study below.

  25. ὑμῶν

    hymōn · G4771

    you (plural) · v21, v23, v34

    'You all'. Jesus is speaking to the Pharisees who asked the question (v. 20), not to his disciples. That weighs against reading it as a private inner experience.

  26. ἐστιν

    estin · G1510

    is · v21, v24, v26, v30, v31, v34, v35

    Present tense: the kingdom 'is' there, not 'will be'. Jesus answers a 'when?' question with 'it is already here', though a few read it as a vivid present meaning 'will suddenly be'.

  27. πρὸς

    pros · G4314

    to, toward · v22

    Marks who is being spoken to. Luke often uses 'said to' (eipen pros) to signal a speech aimed at one particular group.

  28. μαθητάς·

    mathētas · G3101

    disciples, learners · v22

    Apprentices attached to a teacher. Outsiders (the Pharisees) were told that the kingdom is already among them. Insiders are now told how hard the time ahead will be.

  29. ἡμέραι

    hēmerai · G2250

    days · v22, v24, v26, v27, v29, v30, v31

    Plural and without 'the': a whole stretch of time is meant, not one date. These are days of waiting and hardship, set against the longed-for 'days of the Son of Man'.

  30. ὅτε

    hote · G3753

    when · v22

    A conjunction (the supplied tag 'PREP' is a tagging slip). It introduces what will mark those days: unfulfilled longing.

  31. ἐπιθυμήσετε

    epithumēsete · G1937

    long for, desire strongly · v22

    A strong, aching desire. In this verse it carries no moral fault. It is the same longing Jesus has for the Passover meal (Luke 22:15) and that hungry Lazarus has for scraps (16:21).

  32. μίαν

    mian · G1520

    one · v22, v34, v35

    'One' (feminine, agreeing with 'day'), most naturally meaning 'even a single one'. Some scholars read it as 'the first' (on the Semitic pattern of Luke 24:1, 'on day one of the week'). See debates.

  33. υἱοῦ

    huiou · G5207

    son · v22, v24, v26, v30

    Part of the fixed title. 'Son of' in Semitic idiom marks the class someone belongs to, so 'son of man' at root means 'a human being'.

  34. ἀνθρώπου

    anthrōpou · G0444

    human being, man · v22, v24, v26, v30

    Completes the title. Here the setting is Daniel 7's human-like figure, who comes to receive God's kingdom, as the lightning image in v. 24 confirms.

  35. ἰδεῖν

    idein · G1492

    to see · v22

    This infinitive tells us what they long to do. In biblical idiom, to 'see' a day means to live through it, to experience it (Ps 34:12, 'see good days'), not only to look at it.

  36. ὄψεσθε.

    opsesthe · G3700

    you will see · v22

    Future of 'see', echoing 'to see' just before: you will long to see it, and you will not see it. The repeated verb makes the frustration sharper.

  37. μὴ

    mē · G3361

    not · v23, v31

    The negative used in commands and prohibitions. With the verb form that follows it makes a firm 'Don't.'

  38. ἀπέλθητε

    apelthēte · G0565

    go away, go off · v23

    To leave where you are and head off somewhere. Greek uses this verb form (an aorist subjunctive after mē) for a flat 'don't even start': do not set out at all.

  39. μηδὲ

    mēde · G3366

    nor, and not · v23

    Adds a second prohibition that goes further than the first: don't leave, and don't chase either.

  40. διώξητε

    diōxēte · G1377

    pursue, chase, run after · v23

    To hurry after something and try to catch it. Here it means running after the rumour, or after the people spreading it. The Greek gives the verb no object; 'them' is supplied by English translators. The same form is used as a firm 'don't even start.'

  41. ὥσπερ

    hōsper · G5618

    just as · v24

    Opens a careful comparison ("just as... so...") that the paired word οὕτως ("thus") will finish. The weight falls on the likeness between the lightning and the Son of Man.

  42. ἀστραπὴ

    astrapē · G0796

    lightning · v24

    A flash of lightning. In Israel's scriptures lightning often goes with God's own appearing (Sinai, the Psalms, Daniel's heavenly visitor), so the image has a glow of divine glory as well as brightness.

  43. ἀστράπτουσα

    astraptousa · G0797

    flashing · v24

    "Flashing", from the same root as the noun ("the lightning lightening"). The repetition makes the picture vivid. The present tense pictures the flash as it happens.

  44. ἐκ

    ek · G1537

    out of, from · v24

    Marks where the flash starts: out of one part of the sky.

  45. οὐρανὸν

    ouranon · G3772

    heaven, sky · v24, v29

    Here the visible sky, the dome overhead, not God's dwelling place or the afterlife.

  46. εἰς

    eis · G1519

    into, to · v24, v27, v31

    Marks where the flash ends: all the way across to the far side.

  47. λάμπει

    lampei · G2989

    shines · v24

    "Shines, gives light": the main verb of the lightning clause. Its present tense states a general truth: this is what lightning always does. It lights everything up at once.

  48. οὕτως

    houtōs · G3779

    thus, so · v24, v26

    "So, in the same way": turns from the picture to what it describes.

  49. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in, on · v24, v26, v31

    "In" or "on": the time when this will happen. (This word and the next three are missing from some early manuscripts.)

  50. Πρῶτον

    Prōton · G4413

    first · v25

    Used as an adverb ("first, beforehand"). It sets up a sequence: before the lightning-like 'day' of the Son of Man described in verse 24, something else has to happen. Placed first in the sentence for emphasis.

  51. δεῖ

    dei · G1163

    it is necessary, must · v25

    Impersonal 'it is necessary.' In Luke this word regularly marks what God's plan requires (Luke 9:22; 24:7, 26, 44). The suffering is not an accident or a detour; it is part of what has to happen.

  52. πολλὰ

    polla · G4183

    many, much · v25

    'Many things.' A deliberately general summary of the coming passion, the same phrase used in the first prediction of his suffering (Luke 9:22; Mark 8:31).

  53. παθεῖν

    pathein · G3958

    to suffer, to undergo · v25

    'To suffer.' The aorist form views the suffering as a single completed whole. In Luke-Acts, 'the Christ must suffer' becomes a fixed way of referring to the cross (Luke 24:26, 46; Acts 3:18; 17:3).

  54. ἀποδοκιμασθῆναι

    apodokimasthēnai · G0593

    to reject (after examining) · v25

    'To be rejected,' with the sense of being looked over, judged, and declared unfit. It echoes Psalm 118:22, the stone the builders examined and threw out, which Jesus quotes about himself in Luke 20:17.

  55. ἀπὸ

    apo · G0575

    from, by · v25, v29

    Here it marks who does the rejecting: 'by.' Luke uses the same construction in 9:22 ('rejected by the elders…').

  56. γενεᾶς

    geneas · G1074

    generation · v25

    The people living at that time, viewed as a group with a shared character. In Luke 'this generation' is the unresponsive, sign-demanding people of Jesus' day (Luke 7:31; 11:29–32, 50–51).

  57. ταύτης

    tautēs · G3778

    this · v25, v34

    'This.' It pins the rejection to Jesus' own contemporaries, the people standing in front of him, rather than to some later age.

  58. καθὼς

    kathōs · G2531

    just as · v26

    Opens the first half of a matched pair, "just as … so …". It sets up a close comparison: the pattern of Noah's time will repeat.

  59. ἐγένετο

    egeneto · G1096

    to happen, come about · v26

    Past tense, "it happened" or "it came about". It points to Noah's time as a finished event that everyone knew from Genesis. The subject is left vague: "how things went".

  60. Νῶε

    Nōe · G3575

    Noah · v26, v27

    The Greek form of the Hebrew name Noach (the KJV's "Noe"). It calls up the whole story of Genesis 6–9 and the large Jewish tradition built on it.

  61. ἤσθιον,

    ēsthion · G2068

    to eat · v27

    "They were eating." The tense describes something ongoing, like a film running, not a single act. Its subject is simply "they", the people of Noah's day, so the verse opens straight onto a picture of daily life.

  62. ἔπινον,

    epinon · G4095

    to drink · v27

    "They were drinking." Also ongoing. Paired with eating, it is the stock biblical phrase for ordinary life and its meals, sometimes festive ones. On its own it does not mean drunkenness.

  63. ἐγάμουν,

    egamoun · G1060

    to marry · v27

    "They were marrying." In normal usage the active verb describes the man taking a wife, which is why the KJV supplies "married wives". Weddings kept happening: people were planning families and futures.

  64. ἐγαμίζοντο,

    egamizonto · G1061

    to give in marriage · v27

    "They were being given in marriage." This is the other side of the arrangement: daughters being married off by their fathers or families. Together with the verb before it, it means marriage went on in the usual way on both sides.

  65. ἄχρι

    achri · G0891

    until · v27

    "Until, right up to." It marks the point where the ongoing picture is cut off. Normal life ran right up to the edge.

  66. ἧς

    hēs · G3739

    which · v27, v29, v30, v31, v33

    "Which" or "that". It ties "until" to "day": "until the day on which...".

  67. εἰσῆλθεν

    eisēlthen · G1525

    to enter · v27

    "Entered." A shift to the tense for a single completed event: one decisive act. It echoes Genesis 7:13 in the Greek Old Testament, "on that very day Noah entered the ark".

  68. κιβωτόν,

    kibōton · G2787H

    ark, chest, box · v27

    "Ark." The basic sense is a wooden box or chest. It is the Septuagint's word for Noah's vessel and also for the Ark of the Covenant. The picture is a closed, sheltering container, not a sailing ship.

  69. κατακλυσμὸς

    kataklysmos · G2627

    flood, deluge · v27

    "The deluge": literally a washing-down or overwhelming by water. It is the Septuagint's technical word for Noah's Flood, so it names that event, not just any flood.

  70. ἀπώλεσεν

    apōlesen · G0622

    to destroy, ruin; to lose · v27, v29, v33

    "Destroyed": made them perish. Here it means physical death in the waters, a single completed act. Luke uses the same verb for being "lost" (15:4, 24) and for losing one's life (17:33).

  71. πάντας.

    pantas · G3956

    all · v27, v29

    "All" (masculine plural): all those people who had been eating, drinking and marrying. It is the last word of the sentence, and it is final: nobody outside the ark was spared.

  72. ἐξῆλθεν

    exēlthen · G1831

    to go out · v29

    'Went out', a single completed act. Lot's leaving is the trigger: once the one righteous household is out, nothing holds the judgment back (compare Gen 19:22, 'I cannot do anything until you arrive there').

  73. Λὼτ

    Lōt · G3091

    Lot · v29, v32

    Abraham's nephew, who settled in Sodom (Gen 13:12; 19). In Jewish tradition he is the one who was rescued out of a doomed city.

  74. Σοδόμων,

    Sodomōn · G4670

    Sodom · v29

    In Greek the city name is a neuter plural (Sodoma), the same way 'Athens' is plural. By Jesus' day Sodom was Israel's stock example of a city wiped out by God (Isa 1:9; Lam 4:6; Luke 10:12).

  75. ἔβρεξεν

    ebrexen · G1026

    to rain, send rain · v29

    'Rained', a single decisive act. 'Fire and sulfur' is the grammatical object, so someone rains it down. The unnamed subject is almost certainly God, as in Gen 19:24 ('the LORD rained… from the LORD out of heaven'). YLT's 'He rained' makes this explicit.

  76. πῦρ

    pyr · G4442

    fire · v29

    Literal fire falling from above. In Scripture this is a standard image of God's judgment (Ps 11:6; Ezek 38:22).

  77. θεῖον

    theion · G2303

    sulfur · v29

    Sulfur, the yellow mineral that burns with a choking, foul-smelling blue flame. The Dead Sea region where Sodom stood has natural sulfur and bitumen (asphalt) deposits. Here it is the fuel of a physical catastrophe.

  78. κατὰ

    kata · G2596

    according to, in line with · v30

    With an accusative it means "in accordance with". It sets up a comparison: the coming day will follow the same pattern as the story just told.

  79. ἀποκαλύπτεται

    apokaluptetai · G0601

    uncover, reveal · v30

    A present passive, "is unveiled". After "on the day" the present tense points to the future. It means the one who is now hidden is suddenly made visible to everyone, and the passive suggests God is the one who unveils him.

  80. ἐκείνῃ

    ekeinē · G1565

    that · v31

    Points to the specific day just named in v.30, 'the day the Son of Man is revealed'. 'That day' also echoes the prophets' set phrase for the day of the LORD's intervention.

  81. ἐπὶ

    epi · G1909

    upon, on · v31, v34, v35

    Physically up on the roof surface.

  82. δώματος

    dōmatos · G1430

    housetop, flat roof · v31

    The flat roof of a Palestinian house. It was a working and living space reached by an outside stair, used for drying produce, sleeping, prayer and talk. Someone up there could get down to the street without passing through the house.

  83. σκεύη

    skeuē · G4632

    vessels, implements, goods · v31

    Household equipment: jars, pots, tools, bedding, the movable property of a modest home. It is everything you would grab if you had to run.

  84. οἰκίᾳ

    oikia · G3614

    house · v31

    The dwelling itself. The roof is above it and the goods are in it.

  85. καταβάτω

    katabatō · G2597

    let him come down · v31

    A third-person command, 'let him not go down'. It is a single decisive 'don't': do not make even the trip downstairs.

  86. ἆραι

    arai · G0142

    to take up, carry off · v31

    States the purpose of the forbidden trip: to pick the things up and carry them away. What is forbidden is going down to save belongings.

  87. ἀγρῷ

    agrō · G0068

    field, countryside · v31

    Farmland outside the village where a man works by day, away from his house and its contents.

  88. ὁμοίως

    homoiōs · G3668

    likewise · v31

    The same rule applies: the field worker is under the same command as the man on the roof.

  89. ἐπιστρεψάτω

    epistrepsatō · G1994

    let him turn (back) · v31

    'Let him not turn around.' It is the physical act of turning back toward home. Elsewhere the same verb can mean turning in repentance, but here it is literal turning, and it carries the weight of looking back.

  90. ὀπίσω

    opisō · G3694

    behind, back · v31

    'Eis ta opisō' means 'backward'. It is the exact phrase the Greek Old Testament uses for Lot's wife looking back (Gen 19:26), which is why v.32 follows with 'Remember Lot's wife!'

  91. μνημονεύετε

    mnēmoneuete · G3421

    remember, keep in mind · v32

    A command in the plural, spoken to all the disciples, in a form that points to ongoing action: 'keep her in mind'. It is not a request to recall a fact. It means holding the story in front of you as a warning that shapes what you do when 'that day' arrives (v. 31).

  92. γυναικὸς

    gynaikos · G1135

    woman, wife · v32

    The same word means 'woman' and 'wife'. Paired with a man's name it means 'wife'. She has no name in Genesis or in Luke. She is known only through her husband and through what she did.

  93. ἐὰν

    ean · G1437

    if, -ever · v33

    Makes the relative word open-ended: "whoever". It sets up a general case that may or may not happen.

  94. ζητήσῃ

    zētēsē · G2212

    to seek, try, strive for · v33

    To aim at something and work toward it. Here it is the deliberate effort to hold on to one's life when the crisis comes. It describes a will and a priority, not one passing reflex.

  95. ψυχὴν

    psychēn · G5590

    life, soul, self · v33

    One's living self, one's very life. It is the whole person who is alive, not an inner part kept separate from the body. The next words make the meaning concrete: the man on the roof and the man in the field (v. 31) are trying to stay alive and keep what is theirs.

  96. περιποιήσασθαι

    peripoiēsasthai · G4046

    to keep safe, preserve; acquire for oneself · v33

    The middle voice (the subject acting for his own benefit) means "to secure for oneself, keep safe for oneself". In the Greek Old Testament it is the ordinary word for keeping someone alive (Gen 12:12; Exod 1:16). Here it pictures self-protection: holding on to life and property for oneself.

  97. ἂν

    an · G0302

    (-ever) · v33

    With ὅς it means "whoever". It does the same job as ἐάν in the first half.

  98. ζῳογονήσει

    zōogonēsei · G2225

    to keep alive, preserve alive; give life · v33

    "Will keep it alive." The word is built from "life" and "to bring into being". In the Greek Old Testament it is the word for sparing someone or keeping them alive, as the Hebrew midwives did for the boys in Exodus 1. It is stronger than "keep": the life is kept alive, perhaps even given back.

  99. Λέγω

    Legō · G3004

    I say, I tell · v34, v37

    Jesus' solemn formula for a weighty statement. It marks what follows as his own authoritative warning, not general wisdom.

  100. νυκτὶ

    nykti · G3571

    night · v34

    Moves from "on that day" (17:31) to night-time, when people are in bed. Next to the grinding women (work done at dawn), it suggests the moment will catch people in whatever they are doing, at any hour.

  101. δύο

    dyo · G1417

    two · v34, v35

    Two people as close as people can be, sharing one bed.

  102. κλίνης

    klinēs · G2825

    bed, couch, mat · v34

    A bed, sleeping mat or couch. In a one-room village house it is the shared sleeping place of a household (compare Luke 11:7, "my children are with me in bed").

  103. παραλημφθήσεται

    paralēmphthēsetai · G3880

    will be taken (along) · v34, v35

    Future passive of "take alongside, take to oneself." No one is named as the taker, which implies God or his agents. The verse does not say where the person is taken.

  104. ἕτερος

    heteros · G2087

    other · v34, v35

    The second of the pair. Their outcome is different.

  105. ἀφεθήσεται

    aphethēsetai · G863

    will be left, let go · v34, v35

    Future passive of "let go, send away, leave, abandon" (the same verb also means "forgive" elsewhere, but not here). It means left where they are or abandoned, with God again as the implied agent.

  106. ἀλήθουσαι

    alēthousai · G0229

    grinding (grain) · v35

    A present participle, meaning they are in the middle of the job. The ending is feminine, so the two are women, though the Greek never uses the word 'women'. Grinding flour by hand was a daily chore for women and slaves, and it was usually done before dawn.

  107. ποῦ

    pou · G4226

    where? · v37

    A question about place. It probably means "Where will they be taken?" or "Where will this happen?" The disciples want a location, as the people in v. 21 and v. 23 did ("Look, here! Look, there!").

  108. κύριε

    kyrie · G2962

    lord, master, sir · v37

    A respectful way of addressing someone. The word ranges from a polite "sir" (YLT) to "Lord". From disciples in Luke it carries real deference to Jesus as master.

  109. ὅπου

    hopou · G3699

    where, wherever · v37

    "Where(ver)". It pairs with "there" (ἐκεῖ) to make a general rule rather than name one spot: wherever X is, there Y will be.

  110. σῶμα

    sōma · G4983

    body; corpse · v37

    In this picture it is a dead body, a carcass lying in the open. Luke uses the same word for Jesus' corpse in 23:52, 55 and 24:3, 23. Matthew's version of the saying has the plainer word πτῶμα, "carcass".

  111. ἀετοὶ

    aetoi · G0105

    eagles; large birds of prey, including vultures · v37

    Large raptors. Next to a carcass the word means carrion birds circling and dropping onto a corpse, which in Palestine would mostly have been griffon vultures. It is not the noble "soaring eagle" image.

  112. ἐπισυναχθήσονται

    episynachthēsontai · G1996

    will be gathered together · v37

    Future passive: "will be gathered together" (onto it). The word pictures birds converging from all sides onto one spot. The same verb is used elsewhere for God gathering his people, so its use for vultures is grim.

The world behind it

Calculating the end. By the first century, many Jews were trying to work out when God would act. Daniel's "seventy weeks" (Daniel 9:24–27) invited counting. 1 Enoch's "Apocalypse of Weeks" (1 Enoch 93; 91) divided history into fixed periods. Psalms of Solomon 17 longed for God's king to cleanse Jerusalem. Josephus says that a prophecy in the scriptures about a world ruler coming from Judea fuelled the revolt against Rome (Jewish War 6.312). He also describes "sign prophets" such as Theudas and "the Egyptian", who promised miraculous signs that would trigger deliverance (Antiquities 20.97–99, 167–172; compare Acts 5:36; 21:38). In that climate, "When is the kingdom coming?" was a pressing practical and political question, not an abstract one.

Luke's framing. The exchange comes in Luke's long account of Jesus' journey to Jerusalem. Luke is aware of this expectation and comes back to it: just before Jesus enters Jerusalem, people "supposed the kingdom of God was going to appear immediately" (19:11). In Acts 1:6–7 the disciples ask, "Will you at this time restore the kingdom to Israel?" and are told, "It is not for you to know times or dates." Luke 17:20 belongs to the same line of teaching: do not try to set the timetable.

The flow of the passage. Verses 20–21 are addressed to the Pharisees. Verses 22–37 then speak to the disciples about the future "day of the Son of Man". That day will be sudden, visible to all, and will arrive while life goes on as usual, as in the days of Noah and Lot. Verse 20 has to be read together with both parts: the kingdom is already present in Jesus (v. 21), and its final arrival will be unmistakable but impossible to predict (vv. 24–30).

From the study of Luke 17:20.

Where scholars differ

in v20

What kind of "watching" does paratērēsis mean here?

  • Watching for signs in order to calculate the time of the end. This is the majority view.

    Greek usage of the word for observation that aims to predict, as with stars or symptoms. It fits the "when?" question, and it fits the rejection of "Look, here! Look, there!" in vv. 21 and 23. Luke shows the same concern in 19:11 and Acts 1:6–7.

  • Hostile scrutiny: the kingdom does not come by watching Jesus (or others) closely to catch them out.

    Every other use of the root in Luke (the verb in 6:7; 14:1; 20:20) means suspicious watching of Jesus by religious opponents. Most scholars think this sense is too narrow for a saying about *how the kingdom comes*.

  • Religious observance: the kingdom does not arrive through keeping the Law or a rite. A specific form of this view (A. Strobel) links it to the Passover-night vigil, when some expected the Messiah to appear.

    The root can mean observing days or rites (Galatians 4:10). Aquila's Greek translation of Exodus 12:42 is often cited as using paratērēsis for the Passover "night of watching". Critics reply that this sense is rare, that it fits the "when?" question less naturally, and that the Passover link is speculative.

in v20

Was the Pharisees' question sincere or hostile?

  • A sincere question that reflects common Jewish hope.

    Luke does not call it a test (contrast 10:25; 11:16). Some Pharisees in Luke are friendly (13:31; 7:36), and waiting for God's reign was mainstream Jewish piety.

  • A challenge to Jesus' claims about the kingdom.

    Jesus has been announcing the kingdom as near (10:9, 11). Luke's Pharisees often test or oppose him (11:53–54; 16:14). The question could be a challenge to show where this kingdom is.

in v20

Is Jesus denying that the kingdom will come with any visible signs at all?

  • No. He denies that it can be calculated or predicted, not that it will be visible.

    17:24 compares the Son of Man's day to lightning seen across the sky. Luke 21:25–28 describes signs in the sun, moon and stars that come *with* the end, not as a timetable.

  • Yes, at least for the kingdom's present form: it works hiddenly, like yeast or a mustard seed.

    Luke 13:18–21 (mustard seed, yeast) and 17:21 (already "in your midst") stress a presence that is easy to overlook. Supporters of this view usually still allow for a visible final coming.

in v21

What does ἐντὸς ὑμῶν mean here?

  • 'Within you': an inward, spiritual presence.

    This is entos's most common meaning in Greek generally and in the LXX (Ps 38:4; 102:1), and in its only other NT use (Matt 23:26, the 'inside' of the cup). Taken this way by the Vulgate, the KJV, some church fathers and Gospel of Thomas 3. Against it: the addressees are Pharisees, the 'you' is plural, and Luke never presents the kingdom as an inner state.

  • 'In your midst / among you': present in Jesus' person and ministry.

    Fits the reply to Pharisees and the 'here/there' contrast, and matches Luke 11:20 ('has come upon you'). This is the majority view of modern commentators (e.g. Fitzmyer, Marshall, Bock) and of most recent translations. Against it: Greek usually says ἐν μέσῳ for 'among', and examples of entos meaning 'among' are debated.

  • 'Within your reach / grasp': available to you if you respond.

    Papyri use entos for what lies within someone's reach or control (argued by C. H. Roberts, 1948; developed by others, e.g. A. Rüstow, 'in your realm of experience'). Fits a challenge to respond rather than to calculate. Against it: the papyrus parallels are few, and the sense comes close to the 'among you' view.

in v21

Is 'is' (ἐστιν) a real present or a vivid future?

  • Real present: the kingdom is already active in Jesus' ministry.

    A present tense answering a future 'when?' question (v. 20). Luke's 'already' kingdom sayings (10:9; 11:20; 16:16).

  • Vivid future: when it comes it will suddenly be among you, without warning signs.

    Vv. 22–37 go on to the sudden, lightning-like day of the Son of Man. Greek can use the present for a certain future. A minority view.

in v22

What are 'the days of the Son of Man' that the disciples will long to see?

  • Future: the days of the Son of Man's coming and reign. In a time of hardship, disciples will long for even one day of that age, or for its dawning, and it will not come yet.

    The surrounding verses are all forward-looking: lightning (v. 24), 'in the days of the Son of Man' alongside Noah's flood (v. 26), 'the day the Son of Man is revealed' (v. 30). Jewish hope for 'the days of the Messiah' (Ps. Song of Songs 17:44; m. Ber. 1:5) fits. Held in various forms by many commentators (e.g., Fitzmyer, Marshall, Nolland, Bock).

  • Backward-looking: the days of Jesus' earthly ministry. In later trouble the disciples will long for one more day of having him with them.

    Luke 5:35 (the bridegroom taken away, then fasting) and 10:23–24 (blessed are the eyes that see what you see) value the time of Jesus' presence. The plural 'days' fits a period already lived. Critics reply that v. 26 uses the same phrase for a future period.

  • 'One' means 'the first': a longing for the first day, the very start, of the Son of Man's coming age.

    Semitic-style use of 'one' for 'first' (Luke 24:1; Acts 20:7). A minority view. The Greek reads naturally as 'one of', and nothing in the context signals an ordinal.

in v22

Does 'you' mean the original disciples only, or the later church Luke wrote for?

  • Addressed to the historical disciples, predicting the hardship after Jesus' departure.

    The narrative frame: 'he said to the disciples'. The parallel with 5:35 (the bridegroom taken away).

  • Luke shapes the saying for his own community, living through delay and persecution and exposed to false claims.

    Luke alone has this verse. It leads straight into warnings against chasing reports (v. 23) and into the parable about persistent prayer and losing heart (18:1–8), which addresses a waiting church.

in v23

Who or what is being pointed to with 'Look, there!' / 'Look, here!'?

  • The Son of Man himself, meaning claims that he has already come or appeared in secret.

    Verse 22 is about longing to see the Son of Man's days, and v. 24 gives his coming as the reason not to go. This is why BSB and NIV supply 'He is.'

  • Messianic pretenders or sign prophets more broadly.

    The parallels Mark 13:21–22 and Matt 24:23–26 explicitly mention false messiahs and false prophets. Josephus records first-century figures who drew crowds to specific places.

  • The arrival of the kingdom or 'the day' in general.

    The wording closely echoes 17:21, where the kingdom of God is the subject of 'Look, here or there.'

in v23

What period does the warning have in view?

  • The time before Jesus' final, visible return.

    The lightning image (v. 24) and the comparisons with Noah and Lot (vv. 26–30) describe a sudden, universal event. Luke treats Jerusalem's fall separately in ch. 21. This is the majority view (e.g. Fitzmyer, Bock, Nolland).

  • Mainly the crisis leading up to Jerusalem's destruction in AD 70, as a judgment-coming of the Son of Man.

    The warning matches the sign prophets and the false prophet in the Temple whom Josephus describes during the war years. Some interpreters (e.g. N. T. Wright) read the Son-of-Man language as vindication within history.

in v24

What is the main point of the lightning comparison: visibility, suddenness, or divine glory?

  • Universal, unmistakable visibility

    The verse is given as the reason (γάρ, "for") for verse 23's "don't go chasing 'Look, there! Look, here!'". The doubled "under heaven" phrase stresses reach across the whole horizon, not speed. Ancient writers noted that lightning is "easily seen" (Letter of Jeremiah / Baruch 6:61). Most commentators (e.g. Marshall, Bock, Fitzmyer) put this first.

  • Suddenness and unpredictability

    The following verses (vv. 26–30) stress that people were eating, drinking, marrying and building when Noah's flood and Sodom's fire struck without warning. Lightning gives no notice.

  • Glory of a divine appearing

    In the Old Testament lightning goes with God appearing (Exod 19:16; Ps 97:4; Zech 9:14; Dan 10:6). Applying it to the Son of Man suggests a heavenly, glorious arrival. Most interpreters see this as an overtone alongside the first two points, not a rival to them.

in v24

What event does "his day" refer to?

  • The final, public return of Jesus at the end of the age

    Verse 30 speaks of "the day the Son of Man is revealed". Luke 21:27 describes the Son of Man "coming in a cloud with power and great glory", and Acts 1:11 says he will come back "in the same way". This is the majority reading.

  • Divine judgment within history, especially the fall of Jerusalem in AD 70, understood as the Son of Man being shown to be in the right

    Some interpreters read the Gospels' "coming of the Son of Man" language, drawn from Daniel 7 (where the figure comes *to* the Ancient of Days), as language of vindication and judgment within history. They point to the urgent, local details in vv. 31–37 (rooftops, fields, vultures). Critics reply that v. 24's universal horizon-to-horizon image fits a local event poorly.

in v24

Did Luke write "in his day"?

  • Original; dropped accidentally

    Most manuscripts have it. A copyist's eye could easily skip between ἀνθρώπου and αὐτοῦ, which share the same ending. Luke's own context speaks of "the day(s) of the Son of Man".

  • An early addition

    P75 and Codex Vaticanus, two of the earliest and most reliable witnesses, together with Codex Bezae, lack it. A scribe could have added it to clarify, in line with v. 30. Hence the brackets in NA28.

in v25

Who exactly is 'this generation' here?

  • Jesus' contemporaries in a time sense: the people living then, especially in Jerusalem, who would carry out or agree to his rejection.

    'This' (ταύτης) points to the present; Luke 9:22 names the Jerusalem authorities as the rejecters; Luke 11:50–51 holds 'this generation' accountable for events in its own lifetime.

  • Mainly a moral type: people characterised by unbelief, in line with Deuteronomy 32's 'crooked generation,' with the time reference secondary.

    Luke's uses of 'this generation' carry moral descriptions (7:31; 9:41 'faithless and twisted'; 11:29 'evil'); Lövestam argues the phrase is drawn from the Deuteronomy/flood-generation tradition, which fits the Noah reference in v. 26.

  • Both together (the majority view in commentaries such as Marshall, Bock, Nolland): Jesus' actual contemporaries, described by their response.

    In this verse the rejection is a historical event (the passion), yet the phrase carries Luke's consistent moral colouring.

in v25

Why does Luke place the passion here, inside teaching about the end?

  • To correct expectations of immediate glory: the Son of Man's day cannot come before the cross.

    'First' (πρῶτον) after v. 24; Luke 19:11 says that people 'supposed the kingdom of God was to appear immediately'; 24:26 sets out the order suffering, then glory.

  • To show a parallel between his rejection and the judgment on those who reject him, leading into the Noah and Lot warnings.

    'This generation' links to the earlier generations of vv. 26–30; Luke 11:50–51 and 13:34–35 connect rejecting the prophets with judgment.

in v26

What exactly are "the days of the Son of Man"?

  • The period just before his appearing, matching "the days of Noah" before the flood.

    The exact parallel with "the days of Noah", which in v. 27 means the time *up to* the day Noah entered the ark. The same holds for Lot (v. 28–29).

  • The time of his revelation itself, the day of judgment.

    V. 24 ("in his day") and v. 30 ("on the day the Son of Man is revealed") use the singular for the event. Matthew 24:37 calls it his "coming".

  • Both: the run-up to and the arrival of his day, taken as one unit.

    Many commentators (e.g. Marshall, Bock) note that the comparison only works if "days" covers ordinary life before the event and the sudden event that ends it.

in v26

What is the point of comparison with Noah's generation?

  • Unpreparedness and suddenness.

    V. 27 lists only ordinary activities (eating, drinking, marrying), and v. 28 does the same for Lot. Matthew 24:39 adds "they did not know". The surrounding sayings stress lightning-like suddenness (v. 24) and not turning back (v. 31–32).

  • Moral corruption as well.

    Genesis 6:5, 11–13 and Jewish tradition treated the flood generation as notoriously wicked, and Sodom (v. 29) was a byword for sin. Hearers would have heard judgment on sin in the background, though Jesus does not mention it.

in v26

Is "Son of Man" a title or a way of saying "I"?

  • A title drawn from Daniel 7 (and similar to 1 Enoch).

    Sayings about his future coming, like this one, closely echo Daniel 7:13–14: coming in glory and bringing judgment.

  • Basically an Aramaic idiom ("a man", "someone like me") that later took on a titular sense.

    Aramaic *bar enash* is used as a general term for a person, and some scholars (e.g. Vermes, Casey) argue for a self-referring idiom. In this verse the future, judgment setting favours the Daniel background.

in v27

Do the listed activities imply moral fault, or only obliviousness?

  • The activities are morally neutral. The fault is unpreparedness: ignoring the warning and assuming normal life would go on.

    Eating, drinking and marriage are good gifts throughout Scripture. The Lot list in v. 28 (buying, selling, planting, building) is equally ordinary. Jesus leaves out the wickedness Genesis emphasises (Gen 6:5, 11). The surrounding sayings focus on suddenness (v. 24) and not looking back (vv. 31–32). Commentators such as Marshall (NIGTC) and Bock (BECNT) stress the normality.

  • The list hints at a self-absorbed, worldly life that pushes God out, so the ordinary activities carry a note of complacency.

    Elsewhere Luke uses eating and drinking for careless self-indulgence before judgment: the rich fool (12:19), the servant who "eats and drinks and gets drunk" (12:45), and the warning against hearts "weighed down with dissipation, drunkenness and the cares of this life" so that "that day" catches you like a trap (21:34). Isaiah 22:13 has the same overtone.

in v29

Was the Lot comparison (Luke 17:28–29) part of the sayings source Matthew and Luke shared, or did Luke add it?

  • It stood in the shared source (Q) next to the Noah saying. Matthew dropped it.

    Noah and Sodom were a standard pair in Jewish tradition (Sirach 16; Wisdom 10; 3 Macc 2; T. Naphtali 3). The Lot saying is built exactly like the Noah saying: a list of verbs, then 'destroyed them all'. That suggests the two were composed together.

  • Luke (or his own special tradition) added it.

    Matthew 24:37–39 has only Noah. Luke shows a special interest in the Lot material (v.32, 'Remember Lot's wife', is also unique to Luke). Reconstructions of Q such as the Critical Edition of Q treat these verses as uncertain.

in v29

What exactly is being compared: Sodom's wickedness, or its unpreparedness?

  • Mainly the suddenness and unpreparedness of people absorbed in ordinary life.

    Verse 28 lists only neutral activities. The parallel Noah saying (v.27) does the same. The surrounding verses stress the lack of warning signs (vv.20–24) and the need to leave decisively (vv.31–33). Most major commentaries (e.g. Fitzmyer, Marshall, Green, Bock) put the main emphasis here.

  • The wickedness of Sodom is assumed in the background.

    Any Jewish listener knew Genesis 18–19 and the prophets' charges against Sodom (Isa 1:10; Ezek 16:49–50). So judgment on a guilty city is implied. Even so, Jesus does not name any particular sin as the point of the comparison.

in v29

Does the 'day' in vv.29–30 refer to the final coming of the Son of Man, to the fall of Jerusalem in AD 70, or both?

  • The final revealing of the Son of Man.

    Verse 30 says 'revealed' (apokalyptetai). The lightning image (v.24) is universal. Luke deals with Jerusalem's siege separately in 21:20–24.

  • It includes, or is prefigured by, Jerusalem's destruction.

    Verse 31 ('on the housetop… do not go down') matches Mark 13:15, which is set in the context of Jerusalem. Luke elsewhere describes Jerusalem's fall as a 'day' of visitation (19:41–44).

in v30

What event is "the day the Son of Man is revealed"?

  • The future, worldwide appearing of Jesus at the end of the age (the majority view among commentators).

    The lightning image covers the whole sky (17:24). The comparison is with universal judgments (the Flood, Sodom). Elsewhere in the New Testament, apokalypsis is used for Christ's final appearing (1 Cor 1:7; 2 Thess 1:7; 1 Pet 1:7, 13). Luke also keeps the fall of Jerusalem (21:20–24) separate from the Son of Man's coming on the clouds (21:25–28).

  • Mainly or partly the judgment on Jerusalem in AD 70, understood as the Son of Man being vindicated within history.

    The commands in verse 31 (flee from the housetop and field) closely match the flight instructions about Judea in Mark 13:14–16 and Luke 21:21. "This generation" (17:25) points to Jesus' own contemporaries. Some scholars read Daniel 7's coming with the clouds as a figure ascending to God to be vindicated, not descending to earth.

in v30

Does "revealed" imply that the Son of Man is already present but hidden?

  • Yes. The verb assumes he is hidden now, in heaven or in some veiled way, and will be uncovered later.

    The basic meaning of apokalyptō is to uncover something that exists. 1 Enoch 48:6; 62:7 describe a hidden Son of Man who is later revealed. Luke 17:22 says the disciples will long to see one of his days and will not see it.

  • The verb is just an alternative to "come" or "appear", with no specific claim about hiddenness.

    Luke often varies his wording. Matthew's parallel says "coming". The disclosure idea may simply mean being made visible and public, without any detailed view of where he is now.

in v31

Is Luke 17:31 a literal instruction to flee, or a picture of inner detachment from possessions and the old life?

  • Mainly a call to detachment. In Luke's setting, flight is pointless because the Son of Man's day is universal and sudden like lightning. The saying becomes a warning against clinging to property and the past.

    The setting is the revealing of the Son of Man (v.30), not a regional war. It is framed by Lot's wife (v.32) and the paradox of losing and keeping one's life (v.33). Luke elsewhere stresses not looking back (9:62) and holding possessions loosely (12:15–34; 14:33). Commentators such as Fitzmyer, Marshall and Nolland take this line in various forms.

  • Still an urgent call to flee immediately, in the pattern of Lot's escape from Sodom.

    The Sodom story itself is about physically fleeing a doomed place without delay (Gen 19:15–17). The wording is the same as the flight instructions in Mark 13:15–16. Lot's wife is an example of fatal delay during an actual escape. Some interpreters therefore keep a literal flight sense alongside the moral one.

in v31

Does 'that day' in Luke 17 refer to the final coming of the Son of Man or to the destruction of Jerusalem in AD 70?

  • The final, worldwide appearing of the Son of Man.

    Luke keeps the Jerusalem-siege material for 21:20–24 and uses this saying in a different context here. Chapter 17 compares the day to the universal flood and lightning across the whole sky (vv.24, 26–27). The day is 'revealed' (apokalyptetai, v.30), language of a final unveiling. This is the majority view.

  • The judgment on Jerusalem in AD 70, described in the language of prophecy.

    The roof-and-field saying is tied to the Judean war in Mark 13 and Matthew 24. Prophetic 'day of the LORD' language was regularly used of historical judgments. Preterist interpreters (those who see most of these prophecies as fulfilled in the first century) read Luke 17:22–37 in this light.

in v32

What exactly was Lot's wife's fault, the thing Jesus warns against?

  • Attachment to possessions and the old life

    Luke's immediate context: do not go down for 'his goods in the house' (v. 31), Sodom's buying, selling and building (v. 28), and the saying about trying to keep one's life (v. 33). Most modern commentators on Luke (e.g., Marshall, Fitzmyer, Nolland) read the example this way within Luke's framing.

  • Disobedience and unbelief: she did not trust the warning

    Genesis 19:17 gives a direct command, which she broke. Wisdom 10:7 calls the pillar 'a monument of an unbelieving soul'. 1 Clement 11 treats her as a sign against the double-minded who doubt God's power.

  • Divided loyalty or longing: her heart was still in the city, possibly with family left behind

    The Hebrew 'behind him' suggests she lagged behind. Later rabbinic tradition (Pirqe de Rabbi Eliezer 25) says she looked back out of pity for married daughters still in Sodom. This is a later tradition, not in Genesis or Luke. These views overlap rather than exclude each other, and Luke's context stresses the first.

in v32

Which 'day' is in view: the fall of Jerusalem (AD 70) or the final coming of the Son of Man?

  • The final, worldwide revelation of the Son of Man

    Luke 17:24 and 30 speak of the day 'the Son of Man is revealed', sudden like lightning across the sky, with universal examples (the Flood, Sodom). Luke saves the Jerusalem-specific siege material for chapter 21.

  • At least partly the Roman war and the destruction of Jerusalem

    The rooftop/field sayings appear in Mark 13 and Matthew 24 in the Jerusalem-crisis setting, and Luke 21:21 tells people to flee Judea. Some interpreters read the urgent flight language of Luke 17:31 in that light, or see the two events as pattern and fulfilment.

in v33

What does it mean for the life to be "kept alive" (ζωογονήσει)?

  • Life in the age to come, or resurrection: the person who gives up life now receives it from God at the judgment.

    In the parallel in John 12:25 the life is kept "for eternal life". In the Greek Old Testament ζωογονέω is God's act (1 Sam 2:6), and in 1 Tim 6:13 it describes God "who gives life to all things". The setting is the final day of the Son of Man (vv. 24, 30).

  • Survival in the crisis itself: those who flee at once without going back for goods escape with their lives.

    The immediate imagery (rooftop, field, Lot's escape from Sodom) is about physical rescue. Elsewhere in the Greek Old Testament ζωογονέω usually means sparing someone's physical life (Exod 1; 1 Kings 20:31).

  • Both: physical rescue is the picture, and final life from God is what it stands for.

    Luke tells the Noah and Lot stories as illustrations of the final judgment. The life-and-death language works on both levels, as it does in Luke 9:24–25.

in v33

Which "day" is in view: the fall of Jerusalem or the final coming of the Son of Man?

  • The final coming (parousia) of the Son of Man.

    Lightning visible "from one end of heaven to the other" (v. 24), the universal comparisons with the flood and Sodom, and "the day the Son of Man is revealed" (v. 30) all point to a worldwide, final event.

  • Mainly the Roman destruction of Jerusalem (AD 70), or the crisis leading up to it.

    Instructions about fleeing from roofs and fields match Luke 21:20–24 and Mark 13:14–16, which are tied to Jerusalem's siege.

  • Luke deliberately keeps the two apart.

    Luke puts the Jerusalem material in ch. 21 and this "day of the Son of Man" teaching in ch. 17. Many scholars think he is separating the historical judgment on Jerusalem from the final day, with the same call to readiness for both.

in v34

Is the one "taken" rescued, or taken away in judgment?

  • Taken to safety. The one taken is gathered to the Son of Man, like Noah into the ark or Lot out of Sodom. The one left is abandoned to judgment.

    Paralambanō usually means taking someone to be with you, often positively (John 14:3; Matt 1:20; 17:1). Luke's examples are rescues of the righteous out of judgment (17:27–29). The parallel tradition speaks of the elect being gathered (Mark 13:27). Held by e.g. Marshall (NIGTC), Bock (BECNT) and Fitzmyer (Anchor Bible).

  • Taken in judgment. The one taken is swept away like the flood victims. The one left survives, like Noah left on the earth.

    In Matt 24:39 the flood "took" the wicked. In Luke 17:37 the disciples ask "Where?" and Jesus answers with corpses and vultures, which suggests the taken end up dead. Paralambanō can be hostile (Matt 27:27; John 19:16). Held by a number of commentators and popular preachers.

  • Deliberately unspecified. The saying stresses sudden separation, not where anyone goes.

    The verse names no destination. The answer in 17:37 is a proverb that sidesteps the question of where. The surrounding warnings (17:31–33) are about readiness, not about where people end up.

in v34

What does the reply in 17:37 ("Where the body is, there the vultures/eagles will gather") refer to?

  • It describes where the judgment happens, which is everywhere it is deserved. The point is that judgment is as visible and unavoidable as vultures over a carcass.

    It is a proverbial saying (compare Job 39:30). It answers "where" by saying it will be obvious, just as the lightning saying in 17:24 does.

  • It describes the fate of those taken: they become carrion.

    The question "Where, Lord?" directly follows "one taken." The image is of dead bodies.

in v35

Is the one 'taken' rescued or seized for judgment?

  • Taken = gathered to the Son of Man for salvation; left = abandoned to judgment.

    The usual sense of paralambanō is 'take to oneself' (compare John 14:3). Luke's analogy is Lot being brought out of Sodom before destruction (17:28–29). Aphiēmi is used for being abandoned to ruin in Luke 13:35. Matthew 24:31 has the elect 'gathered' by angels. The Vulgate's adsumetur reads it the same way.

  • Taken = taken away in judgment; left = spared.

    In the flood, those 'taken away' were the ones destroyed (Matt 24:39), while Noah remained. In Luke the disciples ask 'Where?' straight after this saying and are told 'where the corpse is, there the vultures will gather' (17:37), which some read as the place where the taken end up. Paralambanō can mean arrest (John 19:16).

  • The saying is about the sudden separation itself, not where anyone goes.

    Neither verb names a destination, and the answer in v. 37 is a proverb rather than a location. The saying's force lies in the contrast between two people who were physically together. Many commentators therefore decline to press the details.

in v35

Does the verse describe a rapture distinct from the visible return of Christ?

  • Yes: it describes believers removed before a tribulation.

    Supporters read 'taken' as removal to heaven and link it with 1 Thessalonians 4:17.

  • No: Luke places it at the single, visible day of the Son of Man.

    The day is like lightning lighting up the whole sky (17:24). Luke's text has no hint of secrecy or of a later tribulation period. Even many interpreters who believe in a pre-tribulation rapture assign the Gospel 'taken/left' sayings to Christ's visible return rather than to the rapture.

in v37

What does "Where?" ask about, and so what does the proverb answer?

  • "Where are those who are taken taken to?" The answer is to death and judgment: they end up as the carcass the vultures find.

    The question follows straight on from "one will be taken" (vv. 34–35). The surrounding examples (the flood, Sodom) are about people destroyed. Carcass and vultures is a standard Old Testament image of the judged.

  • "Where will this happen?" The answer is: everywhere it needs to, unmistakably. The proverb is about how certain and universal the event is, not where the taken go.

    The passage's recurring theme is the false search for "here" or "there" (vv. 21–23) and the lightning that lights up the whole sky (v. 24). The "wherever… there" form states a general rule. Matthew uses the same saying in a context about the visibility of the coming.

in v37

In vv. 34–35, is the one "taken" rescued or judged?

  • Taken in judgment. The one "left" is spared, as Noah and Lot were left alive.

    In vv. 27 and 29 the flood and fire "destroyed them all". On this reading, v. 37's carcass-and-vultures answer describes what happens to those taken. Many commentators argue for this, for example on the basis of Luke's flow of thought.

  • Taken to salvation. The verb παραλαμβάνω ("take along") usually has a positive sense (compare John 14:3). The one "left" is abandoned to judgment.

    This fits Mark 13:27 and Matthew 24:31 (angels gathering the elect). On this view v. 37 does not describe where the taken go. It states more generally that judgment will strike wherever the dead (the unready) are.

  • Deliberately unresolved. The point is the sudden, decisive separation, not the destination.

    Jesus never says where either party goes. Major commentaries (e.g. Marshall, Fitzmyer, Bock) note how open the wording is.

in v37

Do the "eagles" allude to Roman legions?

  • Yes, at least as a secondary echo: the aquila standards of the legions that would surround and destroy Jerusalem.

    Josephus calls the eagle the standard at the head of every legion (*Jewish War* 3.123). Luke 19:43–44 and 21:20 foresee armies surrounding Jerusalem. Readers after AD 70 could hardly miss the image.

  • No. The saying is a nature proverb about carrion birds, and Luke 17 concerns the worldwide day of the Son of Man, not Jerusalem's siege.

    Job 39:30 gives a ready-made proverb. Luke's context (Noah, Lot, people all over the world going about daily life) is universal. Matthew's πτῶμα ("carcass") points to scavenging, not military standards.

in v37

Can the body be Christ and the eagles the faithful gathering to him?

  • Allegorical reading: the body is Christ (or the Eucharist) and the eagles are the saints or the righteous gathering to him.

    Found in some church fathers, e.g. John Chrysostom (*Homilies on Matthew* 76) and Ambrose (*Exposition of Luke*). It draws on the positive sense of "gather" and the noble symbolism of the eagle.

  • Literal proverb: a carcass and carrion birds, as an image of judgment.

    Matthew's word πτῶμα ("carcass"), the Job 39:30 background, the Old Testament "food for the birds" curse texts, and the judgment context (Noah, Lot) all point this way. Most modern critical commentators read it so.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

2 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.